- Subjects
- Mandarin B
- Simplified and traditional characters
Simplified and traditional characters
Simplified and traditional characters: how simplification worked, the regular correspondences that let you read the other script, the characters where one simplified form stands for two, and keeping to one script.
- IB Mandarin B
- Grammar and usage
- SL and HL
Chinese is written in two standard sets of characters. Most characters exist in a single form, but a few thousand of the common ones have a simpler form used on the mainland, in Singapore and in Malaysia, and an older, fuller form used in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. A student who reads only one of them can learn to read the other in weeks, because the differences follow patterns. A blog by a Chengdu high school student on an exchange semester in Taipei describes what that is like.
Two scripts, one language
The writer arrives expecting to be “像一个不识字的人” (paragraph 1: like someone who cannot read), and finds instead that “我几乎每个站名都看得懂” (paragraph 1: I could understand almost every station name). Her explanation is the first thing to learn about the two scripts: “很多字只是笔画多了一些” (paragraph 1: many characters just have a few more strokes). 学 is 學, 书 is 書, 车 is 車. The words, the grammar and the pronunciation are the same; only the written form of some characters differs.
The book’s own texts are written in simplified characters, whatever place they come from, so the Taipei blog and the Hong Kong hiking blog read on other pages appear here in simplified form. In Taipei the writer’s surroundings are in traditional characters: the station names, the barber’s sign, the noodle shop’s order form. People in Taiwan usually call these 正体字, “standard characters”, while the mainland name is 繁体字, “complex characters”. The page on language and identity explains why that choice of name matters to many people.
Reading and writing are not equally hard. The writer’s Taiwanese classmates can read simplified characters, “因为常常在网上看大陆的影片和字幕” (paragraph 4: because they often watch mainland videos and subtitles online), but cannot write them. She can now read many traditional characters, yet writing 学习 in traditional form still takes her a long time. Her conclusion, “‘看得懂’和‘写得出’是两回事” (paragraph 4: being able to read and being able to write are two different things), sets a realistic goal for a student of either script: write one, read both.
How simplification happened
Simpler forms of many characters had existed for centuries, in handwriting, in cursive script and in the shorthand of merchants. The first official list of simplified forms, 324 characters, was published by the Ministry of Education of the Republic of China in 1935 and withdrawn the next year. After 1949 the government of the People’s Republic took the idea up as part of a campaign to spread literacy. Its Chinese Character Simplification Scheme of 1956 introduced 515 simplified characters and 54 simplified components, which could be used inside other characters.
A full list followed in 1964, and a revised version in 1986 that changed only a handful of forms. A second, more radical round, published in 1977, was little used and was formally withdrawn in 1986. The current standard is a list of 8,105 characters issued in 2013. Singapore adopted simplified characters in stages from 1969 and brought its forms fully into line with the mainland’s in 1976; Malaysia’s Chinese schools followed in 1981. Taiwan and Hong Kong kept the traditional forms, each with its own official standard for how they are written.
Reading the other script
The writer could guess 學, 書 and 車 because simplification was not random. Most simplified characters were made in one of a few ways, and a reader who knows the ways can work backward from one script to the other.
The first way kept the outline of a character as it was written quickly by hand. Cursive forms, used for centuries in letters and notes, became the printed standard: 書 became 书, 東 became 东, 長 became 长, 為 became 为. These are the hardest correspondences to guess, because the simplified form keeps the movement of the hand rather than the parts of the character. They have to be learned one by one, but there are not many of them.
The second way kept only part of a character. 聲 (sound) kept its top left corner and became 声; 習 (to practice) kept a piece of its top and became 习; 飛 (to fly) kept its outline and became 飞; 廠 (factory) kept its frame and became 厂. A reader of simplified characters meeting the traditional form can often recognize the part that was kept. That is why 学习 is easy to read as 學習, even for a writer who, like the student in Taipei, cannot yet write it.
The third way replaced a complicated part with a simple symbol. In 對 (correct), 漢 (Chinese) and 難 (difficult), different complex parts were all replaced by 又, giving 对, 汉 and 难. The symbol carries no meaning or sound of its own; it simply marks where the old part stood. The fourth way gave a character a new, simpler sound part: 遠 (far) became 远, with 元 yuán for its sound, and 進 (to enter) became 进, with 井 jǐng. The fifth made a new character from meaningful parts: 體 (body) became 体, a person 亻 and a root 本, and 塵 (dust) became 尘, “small” 小 over “earth” 土.
Components that change everywhere
The most useful correspondences for a reader are the simplified components. When a part was simplified, it changed in every character that contains it, so learning one component makes dozens of characters readable. The speech radical 言 became 讠 in every character, so 語言 is 语言 and 說 is 说. The writer’s problem character 學 belongs to a family of its own: the top of 學 is simplified the same way in 覺 (觉) and 舉 (举).
Traditional component | Simplified | Meaning | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
言 | 讠 | speech | 語言 → 语言 and 說 → 说 |
金 | 钅 | metal | 銀行 → 银行 and 鐘 → 钟 |
食 | 饣 | food | 飯 → 饭, but 餐 stays 餐 |
糸 | 纟 | silk, thread | 紅 → 红 and 經 → 经 |
門 | 门 | door | 門 → 门 and 問 → 问 |
車 | 车 | vehicle | 車 → 车 and 輛 → 辆 |
馬 | 马 | horse | 馬 → 马 and 媽 → 妈 |
貝 | 贝 | shell, money | 買 → 买 and 賣 → 卖 |
見 | 见 | to see | 見面 → 见面 and 現 → 现 |
魚 | 鱼 | fish | 魚 → 鱼 and 鮮 → 鲜 |
頁 | 页 | head, page | 頁 → 页 and 題 → 题 |
The table also shows a limit. A simplified component replaces its traditional form only in some positions: 食 becomes 饣 as a side part in 饭, but stays 食 at the bottom of 餐 (meal) and as a word on its own. 言 in the same way stays whole at the bottom of 警 (to warn). A reader who expects every 言 to become 讠 will look for a character that does not exist.
没想到,第一天坐捷运note 1,我几乎每个站名note 2都看得懂。很多字只是笔画多了一些,比如“学”“书”“车”note 3,样子虽然不一样,但是一看就猜得出来。
捷运 → 捷運. 运 has a new sound part 云 for 軍; the radical 辶 (walking) is the same in both scripts.
站名. Neither character was simplified, so the station names the writer reads first look the same in both scripts.
学, 书, 车. Three ways of simplifying: 學 kept its lower part 子 and simplified the top; 書 took a cursive form; 車 simplified a component that also changes in 辆 and 转.
The writer’s station names show why she could read so much. In a typical sentence of Chinese, many characters are the same in both scripts, and most of the others differ in a component she already knows from its simplified form. The few characters she cannot guess are surrounded by ones she can, and the context does the rest.
One simplified character, several traditional ones
What stops the writer in Taipei is a smaller group of characters: “那些‘一个变两个’的字” (paragraph 2: the characters where one becomes two). In simplified writing, 头发 (hair) and 发展 (to develop) share one 发; in traditional writing they are “两个完全不同的字” (paragraph 2: two completely different characters), 頭髮 and 發展. The same is true of 面: noodles are 麵, with the wheat radical 麥 that the noodle shop owner describes as “多加一个‘麦’字旁” (paragraph 3: adding a wheat radical), while a face or a meeting, 见面, keeps 面.
The owner also explains why: “有些字是把读音相同的几个字合成了一个” (paragraph 3: some characters were made by merging several characters with the same reading into one). This was one of the methods of simplification. Where two or more characters sounded alike, and one of them was already simple, the simple one took over the jobs of the others. Merging saved strokes and reduced the number of characters to learn. The cost appears when a text is converted back to traditional characters.

The diagram shows the merged characters that cause the most trouble. For a reader of traditional characters, nothing is lost: 髮 and 發 are both read as 发. For a writer converting from simplified to traditional, each of these characters is a decision. The decision is always made by meaning, as with homophones, and the sound gives no help: 發 and 髮 differ only in tone, fā and fà, and 乾 and 幹 are gān and gàn.
The trap in the book’s own texts
Sentences from the model texts show how often the merged characters come up, and why a computer converter, which has to guess, can go wrong. Each marked character has two possible traditional forms.
他告诉记者,夏天戴头盔太热,冬天又压头发note 1,而且孩子的头盔放在家里note 2总是忘了拿。
县里负责球场建设的一位干部note 3则认为,球场应该保持乡村的特点。
“那辆车我擦得比自己的脸还干净note 4。”
我们家附近的超市里,我也找到了中国的酱油和方便面note 5。
头发 → 頭髮. Hair takes 髮, never 發. (《校门口的头盔》, paragraph 2)
家里 → 家裡. Inside takes 裡 (in Hong Kong 裏); 里 stays only for distance and villages, as in 公里.
干部 → 幹部. An official, someone who does the work: 幹. (《六月六,到台盘村看一场球》, paragraph 5)
干净 → 乾淨. Clean, dry: 乾. A grandfather’s pride in his bicycle (《爷爷的第一辆自行车》, paragraph 3).
方便面 → 方便麵. Instant noodles: 麵, the wheat character. (《在汉堡,我遇见了“中国”》, paragraph 2)
The four sentences come from four places, Xi’an, Guizhou, Suzhou and Hamburg, and between them they use 干 in both of its meanings. A writer converting them by hand needs to know which meaning each 干 has, which is the same skill as choosing between 在 and 再 in simplified writing. Converters handle most cases, but they still make mistakes: tested on a short sentence, one widely used converter produced 頭髮裡有面條 for 头发里有面条, keeping 面 for noodles where 麵 was needed.
Try it
Each phrase has one character with two traditional forms. Give the right one, and the reason. (1) 我们出发吧 (2) 一只小狗 (《写给外孙女的回忆录》, paragraph 6) (3) 四十分钟 (《爷爷的第一辆自行车》, paragraph 3) (4) 干垃圾 (《关于本小区垃圾分类情况的观察报告》, paragraph 4)
(1) 出發: setting off is “sending out”, 發; 髮 is only hair. (2) 一隻小狗: 只 as a measure word for animals is 隻; 只 meaning “only” stays 只. (3) 四十分鐘: a clock or a period of time is 鐘, with the metal radical; 鍾 is mainly a surname. (4) 乾垃圾: dry waste is 乾; 幹 is “to do”.
Script and vocabulary are separate choices
Changing the script of a text changes its characters and leaves its words as they are. The Chengdu writer’s blog shows this from the other side. Writing in simplified characters, she still uses the words of the place she is in: she rides the “捷运” (paragraph 1: the Taipei metro, 地铁 on the mainland), and her classmates watch “影片” (paragraph 4: videos, often 视频 on the mainland). A text from Taipei is not mainland Chinese because it is printed in simplified characters, and a mainland text does not become Taiwanese by being converted to traditional ones.
Two consequences follow for a writer. First, a mainland text converted to traditional characters keeps its mainland words: 地铁 becomes 地鐵, not 捷運, and 出租车 becomes 出租車, not 計程車. Second, the traditional standards themselves differ slightly between places. Taiwan writes 裡 for “inside”, while Hong Kong usually writes 裏; the official written form of Taiwan’s name is 臺灣, though 台灣 is everywhere in daily use. These details matter to publishers. For a student, the rule is simpler: use one script, and use it consistently.
我们的中文老师提醒大家,写作文的时候,用简体还是繁体都可以,但是一篇文章里不要两种混在一起。
《在台北,我学会了“看”两种字》, paragraph 5
The teacher’s advice names the real risk. The usual problem is a slip, “写着写着,一个繁体字就跑进了简体的句子里” (paragraph 5: in the middle of writing, a traditional character runs into a simplified sentence). This happens most to students who learned one script at home or in primary school and another later, and to students who read a lot in one script and write in the other.
The mistake and its repair
Three sentences show the two errors students make with the scripts: mixing them, and choosing the wrong form of a merged character.
我的头發note 1很长。
我们學校note 2的图书馆很大,周末也开門note 2。
下課以後,我們一起去吃牛肉面note 3。
Mixed scripts, and the wrong traditional form. 头 is simplified and 發 traditional; and 發 is the wrong traditional character for hair in any case. Repair: 我的头发很长 in simplified, or 我的頭髮很長 in traditional.
Mixed scripts. A student who learned traditional characters first lets 學 and 門 into a simplified sentence. Repair: 我们学校的图书馆很大,周末也开门.
A merged character left unchanged. The sentence is in traditional characters, but 面 for noodles should be 麵: 我們一起去吃牛肉麵.
A quick test catches most mixing. Common characters that differ between the scripts, such as 们, 这, 说, 学, 来, 时 and 会, appear in almost every sentence, so checking those few in a finished text shows at once which script it is in and whether anything has slipped. For merged characters, the test is the one used for homophones: what does the word mean, and which form carries that meaning?
Improving a paragraph
The weak version is the opening of a student’s blog post about a visit to Hong Kong. The student learned simplified characters at school and reads Hong Kong websites in traditional ones. The stronger version keeps to simplified characters and says more.
上個note 1周末我去了香港。那里的地鐵note 2很方便,東西note 3也很好吃。我觉得香港很漂亮note 4。
上个周末,我第一次去了香港。那里的地铁note 5很方便,我一天就去了三个区。街上的招牌都是繁体字,我一开始有点儿紧张,后来发现大部分都看得懂note 6。
Weak: mixed scripts. 個 is traditional; the rest of the paragraph is mostly simplified.
Weak: mixed scripts. 鐵 is traditional; the simplified form is 铁.
Weak: mixed scripts, and a vague point. 東 is traditional (东). 东西很好吃 says only that the food was good.
Weak: an opinion with no reason. 我觉得香港很漂亮 tells the reader nothing about the visit.
Stronger: one script. 地铁, 个 and 东 in simplified throughout.
Stronger: the scripts as content. The experience of reading traditional signs becomes part of the post, with a change over time (一开始……后来……).
The repair of the mixed characters takes a minute. The stronger version also replaces a list of vague judgments with one detail, a day spent in three districts, and one experience that only this writer had. Keeping to one script removes errors under criterion A; the detail is what develops the message.
Applying it in Paper 1 and Paper 2
Chinese B papers are printed in a simplified version and a traditional version, and candidates choose the one they work from; your teacher can confirm the arrangements at your school. A candidate writes in the script chosen, and what matters is consistency: a response in one script throughout, with the right traditional form where you write traditional characters. A response that drifts between scripts reads as careless, and a slipped character can count against the accuracy of your characters under criterion A.
In Paper 2, answers copied from a reading text take the script of the version you are using. Since the exactness rules ask for the text’s own words, copying 頭髮 from a traditional text and writing 头发 in your answer is a change you do not need to make. The practice questions on this site accept answers in either script, so practicing in your own script costs nothing.
The two scripts take further the ideas of the pages on tones and on characters that sound alike: merged characters are homophones that simplification put into one form. The page on language and identity discusses what each script means to the people who use it, and the text type pages show texts from Taipei, Hong Kong and Singapore in the book’s simplified characters with each place’s own words.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what simplified and traditional characters are and where each is used.
- To do:
I can describe how simplification was done: cursive forms, kept parts, simple symbols, new sound parts and merged characters.
- To do:
I can read the other script by its regular components, such as 言 and 讠 or 金 and 钅.
- To do:
I can choose the right traditional form for 发, 面, 后, 干, 里, 只 and 钟 by meaning.
- To do:
I can keep to one script in a piece of writing and repair a text that mixes them.
- To do:
I can write consistently in one script and copy answers in the script of the text I am reading.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB Mandarin B glossary.
- Simplified characters
The standard forms of Chinese characters in mainland China, Singapore and Malaysia, introduced from the 1950s, in which many common characters and components have fewer strokes than their older forms.
- Traditional characters
The forms of Chinese characters used before simplification, still the standard in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. In Taiwan they are usually called standard characters.
Grammar and usage for Mandarin B
Sentences
Characters and sounds
Sentences
Characters and sounds
- 4Simplified and traditional charactersThis page
- 5Characters that sound alike
Register
- 6Four-character expressions (成语)HL only
Words
Sentences
Words
Sentences
Words
Register
Time and aspect
Sentences
Time and aspect
Register
- 21Written-style ChineseHL only
Carry on with Mandarin B in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.