- Subjects
- Mandarin B
- Characters that sound alike
Characters that sound alike
Why so many Chinese characters share a reading, how to tell apart 在 and 再, 做 and 作, 想 and 像 and other pairs, how radicals help, and how to check writing for miswritten characters.
- IB Mandarin B
- Grammar and usage
- SL and HL
Many Chinese characters are said in exactly the same way. A listener tells them apart by the words around them, so in speech they rarely cause trouble. In writing, the writer has to choose the character, and a student who writes from the sound alone will sometimes choose the wrong one and write a miswritten character. A student column in a Xiamen school paper tells how one such character cost its writer a mark, and what she learned from it.
Why so many characters share a reading
The writer’s complaint starts from a fact: “‘在’和‘再’读音一样” (paragraph 1: 在 and 再 have the same reading). Both are zài, with the same consonant, vowel and tone. Characters like these are homophones, and Chinese has a great many of them. Standard Mandarin uses only about 400 syllables without their tones, and about 1,300 with them, while a reader of a newspaper needs three to four thousand characters. Many characters must therefore share each syllable.
Speech copes with this easily because words in modern Chinese are mostly two syllables long. 再 alone is ambiguous when heard, but 再见 or 明天再来 is not. Writing takes the context away from the moment of choice, since the hand writes one character at a time. The column’s teacher puts the result in one sentence: “这样的错别字,她每次改作文都能找到好几个” (paragraph 2: she finds several such wrong characters every time she marks compositions).
The column also gives a modern cause. Typing Chinese with a pinyin input method means typing the sound and then picking a character from the list that appears, and “手指一快,就选错了” (paragraph 3: when the finger moves too fast, it picks the wrong one). People who type more than they write can lose the shape of a character while keeping its sound. Speakers of Chinese call this 提笔忘字 (paragraph 3: picking up a pen and forgetting how to write a character), and it is widely discussed among adults on the mainland and in Taiwan.
The Chinese term joins the two kinds the definition separates. A 错字 is a form that does not exist, with a stroke added or missed. A 别字 is a real character in the wrong place, such as 在 for 再. Most of the errors in this group of pages are 别字, and they are the more common kind in students’ writing, because a learner who knows the sound of a word can always find some character with that sound.
Homophones on purpose
The column’s fourth paragraph turns to homophones that people use deliberately, and here the same feature of the language becomes part of the culture. At the New Year dinner a fish is served, “因为‘鱼’和‘余’同音” (paragraph 4: because 鱼 fish and 余 surplus sound the same), so 年年有余 wishes the family more than enough every year. The character 福 (good fortune) is pasted upside down, because 倒 (upside down) sounds like 到 (to arrive): “福到了” means good fortune has come.
反过来,很多人不送朋友钟,因为“送钟”听起来像“送终”。
《一个“在”字,扣了我一分》, paragraph 4
The same mechanism works in reverse for gifts. 送钟, giving a clock, sounds the same as 送终, attending a dying parent at the end of life, so many people avoid giving clocks. The number four is avoided for a similar reason in many places: 四 sì is close to 死 sǐ, to die, and some buildings in Hong Kong, Taiwan and mainland cities skip floors numbered with a 4. These puns work because everyone knows both words. As the column says, “大家一看就懂” (paragraph 4: everyone understands at a glance), which is exactly what a miswritten character in a composition does not do.
在 and 再
The pair that cost the writer her mark is the commonest of all. Her sentence was “周末我们在来打球吧” (paragraph 1: come and play ball again at the weekend), and the teacher wrote 再 beside it. The teacher’s explanation divides the work of the two characters cleanly. 在 is about place, or an action going on: “在学校”, “在看书” (paragraph 2: at school; reading). 再 is about an action that will happen later or again: “明天再来”, “吃完饭再说” (paragraph 2: come again tomorrow; talk about it after eating).
A sentence in a Xi’an city newspaper report on families who spend the New Year in the city uses both characters a few words apart, each in its own job.
不少年轻人说,假期长了,安排就灵活了:可以先陪父母在城里note 1过年,再带他们出去note 2玩几天,也可以错峰回老家,避开返程的高峰。
在 + place. 在城里 (in the city) says where the New Year is spent. The phrase comes before the verb 过年, as every place phrase with 在 does.
First, then. In 先……再…… one step follows another, and 再 marks the second step, which has not happened yet when the plan is made.
The extract is from 《今年过年,换爸妈“回家”》 (paragraph 5). The pair 先……再…… is one of 再’s most useful jobs: it orders the steps of a plan. The Singapore blog on learning Hokkien uses the same pattern twice in one paragraph: “我先用华语问,她再用福建话回答” (《星期天,跟阿嬷学福建话》, paragraph 4: I ask in Mandarin first, then she answers in Hokkien). In each case 再 could not be replaced by 在, because no place or ongoing action is meant.
再 also appears in negatives that mean “never again”. A Kuala Lumpur feature says of a great-grandfather who sent his earnings home, “他自己再也没有回去过” (《曾祖父的那张船票》, paragraph 4: he himself never went back again). A Shenzhen student sets a rule for watching short dramas, “不再充值” (《三分钟一集,我追了一百集》, paragraph 5: to stop paying for more episodes). A quick test settles almost every case: if the word can be replaced by “again” or “then”, it is 再; if it is followed by a place or describes something going on now, it is 在.
The alternative to 再 that a writer may pass over is 又, which also means “again”. The two divide the work by time: 又 is for a repetition that has already happened, 再 for one still to come. A writer reporting a second visit that happened yesterday writes 又去了; one planning a second visit for tomorrow writes 再去. The pages on 就 and 才 and on talking about the future set this pair out in full.
做 and 作
The column’s deskmate “把‘作业’写成‘做业’” (paragraph 3: writes 作业, homework, as 做业). Both characters are zuò, and both have to do with making and doing, so the confusion is natural. The difference is mostly one of use. 做 is the everyday verb for doing and making concrete things. 作 is found mainly inside fixed words, many of them about writing, work and art: 作业 (homework), 作文 (composition), 工作 (work), 作品 (a work of art), 作家 (writer).
A feature in a Taipei community newsletter about a girl who makes armor for cosplay shows both characters doing their own jobs in one text. Its title calls her “会做盔甲的女孩” (《巷口那个会做盔甲的女孩》: the girl who can make armor), with 做 as the verb of making a thing by hand. Later it reports that people online criticize others’ “作品” (paragraph 5: works) for being unlike the original, and here 作 is part of a noun that names what has been made. A Xi’an neighborhood worker in a city paper says “我们的工作不是替大家做决定” (《一部电梯,等了三年》, paragraph 4: our job is not to make decisions for everyone), with 工作 for the job and 做 for the action.
Two fixed words accept either character. 叫作 and 叫做 (to be called) are both in use, and the Taipei newsletter writes “她把这些叫作‘小确幸’” (《女儿说,这是她的小确幸》, paragraph 3: she calls these “small, certain happiness”). Many mainland dictionaries and style guides prefer 叫作, but 叫做 is common in print and is not treated as an error. These are exceptions. For 作业 and 作文, and for 做饭, 做事 and 做决定, only one character is right.
Characters that share a part
The column’s fifth paragraph moves from pairs that sound the same to a whole family of characters that look alike as well. “这几个字读音很像,偏旁却不一样” (paragraph 5: these characters sound alike, but their side parts differ), it says of 清, 晴, 睛, 请 and 情. All five contain 青, and all are read qīng, qíng, jīng or qǐng. The teacher’s method, “看偏旁” (paragraph 5: look at the side part), is the right one, because the other part of each character tells what area of meaning it belongs to.

Most Chinese characters are built this way, from two parts. One part, the phonetic component, hints at the sound: here 青 qīng. The other, the radical, hints at the meaning: water (氵), sun (日), eye (目), speech (讠) or heart (忄). The column gives each one an everyday word that makes its radical sensible, “有水的是‘清水’的‘清’” (paragraph 5: the one with water is 清 as in 清水, clear water), and so on through the family. The diagram sets the five characters around their shared sound part.
The sound part is only a hint. 睛 is read jīng, not qing, because Chinese sounds have changed over the centuries since the character was made, while the written form stayed the same. The radical is the more reliable guide. A student who writes 晴楚 for 清楚 (clear), an error teachers of Chinese report often, has the right sound part and the wrong radical: sun instead of water. Asking what the word is about and matching the radical to the answer catches the mistake.
Three more pairs with a different part
Several common pairs share no part at all but differ only in tone or not at all in sound, and each has a meaning test. 想 xiǎng (to think, to want) has 心, the heart, at the bottom; 像 xiàng (to resemble, to be like) has 亻, a person, at the side. The Singapore blog uses both in one paragraph: the writer feels “像一个外人” (《星期天,跟阿嬷学福建话》, paragraph 3: like an outsider), and her grandmother says the young “不想学” (paragraph 5: do not want to learn). The heart radical suits wanting, and the person radical suits resembling someone.
以 and 已 are both yǐ and both appear in time words. 以 is in 以前 (before) and 以后 (after). 已 is in 已经 (already). A Guizhou village account has both in one sentence: “以前的旧球场因为球架不安全,已经不能用了” (《六月六,到台盘村看一场球》, paragraph 3: the old court from before can no longer be used because its hoops are unsafe). The test is the word, not the character: 已 most often comes as 已经.
记者在门口站了十分钟,发现大多数大人戴着头盔note 1,坐在后座的孩子戴头盔note 1的却不多。
上周末,女儿把她做的第一个面包带回家note 2给我吃。
戴: wearing on the body. Helmets, glasses, hats, watches and masks are 戴. The parts of the character give little help here, so the meaning is learned with the words it goes with.
带: carrying or bringing. Bread brought home, a phone taken to school, a child taken somewhere: 带. 带 also means a belt or band, which is easy to remember with the same idea of something that goes along.
The two sentences come from a Xi’an city paper’s report on helmets at a school gate (《校门口的头盔》, paragraph 1) and the Taipei newsletter column by a father (《女儿说,这是她的小确幸》, paragraph 6). 戴 and 带 are both dài. A student who writes 带眼镜 for 戴眼镜 (to wear glasses) says something different: to take one’s glasses along. The test is whether the thing is on the body or only with the person.
Try it
Each sentence has one miswritten character. Find it and give the right one, with the reason. (1) 我明天在来看你。 (2) 他的发音很晴楚。 (3) 我很像去中国旅游。 (4) 我已经准被好了。
(1) 在 should be 再: the visit is in the future (明天), so the meaning is “again”. (2) 晴 should be 清: clear speech has nothing to do with the sun; 清 has the water radical. (3) 像 should be 想: wanting is 想, with the heart radical; 像 means “to look like”. (4) 被 should be 备: 准备 means to prepare, and 被 is the passive marker. All four are errors teachers report often in the writing of students of Chinese.
One sound, three pronouns: 他, 她 and 它
The pronouns for “he”, “she” and “it” are a pair of homophones that speech never separates: all three are tā. Only writing shows the difference. 他 has the person radical 亻, 她 has 女 (woman), and 它 is used for animals and things. The column uses 她 for the teacher throughout, “她说……她还说” (paragraph 2: she said… she also said). It uses 它 for an idea that has become custom: “人们早就把它变成了一种文化” (paragraph 4: people long ago turned it into a part of the culture).
The written distinction is recent. Until the early twentieth century 他 served for everyone. The writer Liu Bannong proposed 她 for women in 1918, and it spread in the years of the New Culture Movement, around 1920. Students who speak Chinese well but write little sometimes fall back on 他 for everyone, which reads as careless today. The Guizhou village account writes “网友为什么把它叫作‘村BA’” (《六月六,到台盘村看一场球》, paragraph 1: why people online call it “Village BA”), with 它 for a sports event. A Chengdu school doctor, interviewed in a school magazine about short sight, warns students not to wait until they cannot see the board, “才想起来保护它” (paragraph 9: and only then think of protecting it), with 它 for eyesight.
The same problem, one sound and several characters chosen by grammar, is at its sharpest in 的, 得 and 地, all said de. Their choice depends on what follows them rather than on meaning, and they have a page of their own.
The mistake and its repair
These four errors are among the commonest that teachers of Chinese report in the writing of students at this level. Each is a real character in the wrong place, so none of them would be caught by a spelling check on a phone. The wrong characters are shown without readings, since their sound is the same as the right one.
我们一起做业note 1吧。
我很像去note 2中国旅游。
他的发音很晴楚note 3。
我已经准被好note 4了。
做 for 作. 作业 (homework) is a fixed word with 作. The verb before it is 做 or 写: 我们一起做作业吧. Students who write 做业 have merged the verb and the noun.
像 for 想. 想 (to want), with 心, the heart; 像 (to resemble), with 亻, a person. The two differ by one tone, xiǎng and xiàng, so this error appears in speech as well as writing. Repair: 我很想去中国旅游.
晴 for 清. Both contain 青. Clear speech is 清楚, with the water radical; 晴 (sunny) has the sun radical. Repair: 他的发音很清楚.
被 for 备. Both are bèi. 准备 (to prepare) takes 备; 被 is the passive marker. Repair: 我已经准备好了.
A quicker test than any rule is to ask what the word means and whether the character’s radical fits that meaning. Want, think, feel: heart. Clear, wash, river: water. Speak, ask, invite: speech. The test fails for a few characters, such as 再 and 在, whose parts give no hint, and for those pairs the only test is the meaning of the whole word.
Improving a notice
A notice is where a miswritten character does most harm, because readers act on it. The weak version is a class monitor’s message to the class group about a Saturday trip. It has the errors of the column and one more. The stronger version repairs them and makes the notice clearer.
大家好!明天早上八点,我们在学校门口集合note 1。请大家准被好note 2水和帽子,带好帽子note 3,不要迟到note 4。我们下午五点在回来note 5。
各位同学好!明天(星期六)早上八点在学校正门集合note 6,请准时到达。请准备好note 7水和午饭,天气很热,请戴上帽子note 8。活动下午四点结束,大约五点回到学校note 9。
Correct here. 在学校门口 is a place, so 在 is right; the same sound is wrong at the end of the notice.
Weak: 被 for 备. 准备好 (to have ready).
Weak: 带 for 戴. 带好帽子 means to bring a hat; the monitor means to wear one, 戴. The hat is also mentioned twice.
Weak: filler. 不要迟到 (don’t be late) after the time has been given adds nothing.
Weak: 在 for 再. 再回来 would mean “come back again”; the monitor means “return”, 回来, with no need for either character.
Stronger: the place made exact. 正门 (main gate) and the weekday in brackets prevent a different kind of misreading.
Stronger: 准备. The right character, and lunch added, which the trip needs.
Stronger: 戴上. 戴 for a hat that is worn, with 上 (on).
Stronger: the plan in order. 结束 and 回到学校 give two times, so parents know when to come.
The repair of the last error shows a habit worth learning. When a writer is unsure which zài to use, the sentence can often be rewritten without either: 我们下午五点回来 says everything the notice needs. Rewriting with words one can write is always safer than guessing.
Applying it in Paper 1
When Paper 1 is written by hand, no input method offers a list of characters, so every character comes from your own memory. Criterion A rewards accuracy alongside range, and characters written correctly belong to accuracy. One miswritten character rarely changes a mark. A pattern of them, the same 在 for 再 in four places, shows a reader that a basic distinction is not yet secure. A character that changes the meaning (带 for 戴, 买 for 卖) can blur your message as well.
The most useful habit is a final check aimed at your own errors. The column’s writer does exactly this: “现在我写完作文,都会再读一遍,专门找‘在’和‘再’” (paragraph 6: now when I finish a composition I read it once more, looking only for 在 and 再). A check that looks for everything at once finds little. A check that looks for the four or five pairs you know you confuse, one at a time, finds most of them in a few minutes.
When you cannot remember a character, do not write pinyin in its place and do not guess between two characters you half remember. Rewrite the phrase with words you can write: 我们下午五点回来 instead of an uncertain 再回来, 我很想去 if 希望 will not come. A plainer sentence written correctly serves the message better than an ambitious one with a wrong character in it.
The pairs in brief
The table gathers the pairs taught here, each with a test and an example from the model texts read on this subject’s pages.
Characters | Reading | Test | Example from a model text |
|---|---|---|---|
在 / 再 | zài / zài | place or ongoing action / again, then (not yet done) | 先陪父母在城里过年,再带他们出去 (《今年过年,换爸妈“回家”》, 5) |
做 / 作 | zuò / zuò | the verb “do, make” / inside fixed words (作业, 作文, 工作, 作品) | 会做盔甲的女孩 and 作品 (《巷口那个会做盔甲的女孩》, title and 5) |
想 / 像 | xiǎng / xiàng | heart: want, think / person: resemble | 像一个外人 and 不想学 (《星期天,跟阿嬷学福建话》, 3 and 5) |
以 / 已 | yǐ / yǐ | 以前 and 以后 / 已经 | 以前的旧球场……已经不能用了 (《六月六,到台盘村看一场球》, 3) |
带 / 戴 | dài / dài | carry, bring / wear on the body | 戴着头盔 (《校门口的头盔》, 1); 带回家 (《女儿说,这是她的小确幸》, 6) |
备 / 被 | bèi / bèi | 准备, 设备 / the passive, 被子 | 准备好防晒霜和水杯 (《新生住校指南》, 11) |
清 / 晴 / 情 | qīng / qíng / qíng | water: clear / sun: sunny / heart: feeling | 清水 and 晴天 (《一个“在”字,扣了我一分》, 5) |
他 / 她 / 它 | tā | a man or anyone / a woman / an animal or thing | 把它叫作“村BA” (《六月六,到台盘村看一场球》, 1) |
Characters that sound alike are one reason Chinese keeps its writing system rather than writing in pinyin: on the page, 在 and 再 are never confused. The two forms of the characters themselves, simplified and traditional, are the subject of the page on the two scripts, where one simplified character sometimes stands for two traditional ones that are not homophones at all. The page on 的, 得 and 地 deals with the most frequent homophones of all.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain why many characters share a reading and why this causes errors in writing more than in speech.
- To do:
I can choose between 在 and 再, 做 and 作, 想 and 像, 以 and 已, 带 and 戴, 被 and 备 with a test for each.
- To do:
I can use the radical of a character to choose within a family such as 清, 晴, 睛, 请 and 情.
- To do:
I can explain homophones used on purpose, such as 年年有余 and 福到了, and tell them from miswritten characters.
- To do:
I can check my own writing for the pairs I confuse, and rewrite a phrase instead of guessing a character.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB Mandarin B glossary.
- Homophone
A character or word that sounds the same as another but has a different meaning and a different written form. Chinese has many, because it has far more characters than syllables.
- Miswritten character
A character written incorrectly: either a form with a wrong or missing stroke, or a real character used in place of the right one, usually because the two sound alike.
- Phonetic component
The part of a Chinese character that hints at how it is read. Characters that share one are often read alike, though sound changes over the centuries mean the hint is not always exact.
- Radical
The part of a Chinese character that usually hints at its meaning, and under which the character is listed in a dictionary. Characters about water, for example, share the water radical.
Grammar and usage for Mandarin B
Sentences
Characters and sounds
Sentences
Characters and sounds
- 4Simplified and traditional characters
- 5Characters that sound alikeThis page
Register
- 6Four-character expressions (成语)HL only
Words
Sentences
Words
Sentences
Words
Register
Time and aspect
Sentences
Time and aspect
Register
- 21Written-style ChineseHL only
More IB Mandarin B notes
Carry on with Mandarin B in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.