- Subjects
- Mandarin B
- Articles
Articles
How a Chinese magazine or school article draws in readers who owe it nothing: title, subtitle, byline, standfirst, an opening scene, subheaded sections and a conclusion that adds something, with a model from Vancouver.
- IB Mandarin B
- Text types
- SL and HL
An article, 文章 (in a school magazine 校刊文章, in a newspaper or magazine 报刊文章), explains or explores a subject for readers of a publication. Those readers did not ask for it. They turn the page or scroll past unless the title and the first lines give them a reason to stay. An article therefore has to catch interest, keep it with a clear structure and give readers something they did not know or had not thought about. Unlike a news report, it may include the writer’s view; unlike an opinion column, it often weighs several. The model comes from the Chinese pages of 《枫叶》, a bilingual magazine for Chinese-Canadian families in Vancouver. A sixteen-year-old student wrote it for the magazine’s youth section, about the weekend Chinese school she has attended for ten years.
How it works
Every convention of an article follows from its situation: a writer with something to explain and readers who owe her no attention. The model announces its subject in a title, a subtitle and a short question, opens on a scene, and then gives three groups of people their own section under a heading. Only at the end does the writer give her own answer. Each part makes the article easier to enter, to follow and to remember.
Title, subtitle and byline
The title, 周六早上的中文课 (the Saturday morning Chinese class), is a picture rather than a topic. A title such as 海外华人学中文的问题 (problems of overseas Chinese learning Chinese) would name the same subject, but it sounds like a school essay, and it promises a lecture. The model’s title promises a scene that many readers of 《枫叶》 know from their own family.
Under it, a subtitle with a long dash says what kind of piece follows: “——一个温哥华高中生的观察” (paragraph 1: observations by a Vancouver high school student). A subtitle like this sets readers’ expectations: this is one student’s view from the inside, not a survey or an official report. The byline, “文/林嘉欣(十一年级)” (paragraph 2: text by Lin Jiaxin, Grade 11), names the writer. 文 followed by a slash is the usual way to credit the writer of an article in Chinese magazines and school papers, and the grade in brackets tells readers she is one of the students she writes about.
A standfirst that asks the question
Before the article proper, one short paragraph sums up what it is about: “家长为什么坚持?孩子为什么想放弃?” (paragraph 3: why do parents insist? why do children want to give up?). This is a standfirst. It tells a reader who is deciding whether to read on what the article will weigh, and its two parallel questions set out the two sides before the writer says anything about them.
A standfirst is common in magazines and longer newspaper features. A short school magazine article can do without one, and a news report replaces it with a first paragraph that gives the main facts. In the model, the two questions also do a second job: they become the plan of the article, because the next two sections answer them in turn.
An opening that draws readers in
The first paragraph of the body is a scene, not a statement: “每个星期六早上九点,当很多同学还在睡觉的时候,我已经坐在中文学校的教室里了” (paragraph 4: every Saturday at nine in the morning, while many classmates are still asleep, I am already sitting in the Chinese school classroom). The structure 当……的时候 (while…, when…) sets two pictures side by side, and the contrast between sleeping classmates and the writer at her desk makes readers feel the cost of Chinese school before anyone has argued about it. The paragraph is the article’s hook: the opening detail that makes readers want to continue.
The paragraph then adds two facts that sharpen the scene. The first is “这样的周六,我过了十年” (paragraph 4: I have spent ten years of Saturdays like this). The second is a class of twelve students, all born in Canada, who speak English “一下课” (paragraph 4: as soon as class ends). The last detail shows the problem the article explores without naming it. A student who opened with 现在很多华人孩子不喜欢学中文 (nowadays many Chinese children do not like learning Chinese) would state the same idea and lose the reader’s interest in the same sentence.

The diagram sets out the model’s structure. The frame at the top leads readers in, three sections give three views, and the conclusion comes back to the question the standfirst asked.
Sections under subheadings
The body is divided into three sections, each with a subheading: “父母的坚持” (paragraph 5: the parents’ insistence), “孩子的疲惫” (paragraph 7: the children’s tiredness) and “学中文,为了什么?” (paragraph 9: learning Chinese, for what?). The first two are parallel, each five characters and each a noun phrase built with 的, so readers see at once that two sides are being compared. The third breaks the pattern with a question, which marks the turn to the writer’s own view.
Subheadings help readers who skim, but they also discipline the writer. Each section has to be about what its heading says. In the model, every sentence under 父母的坚持 gives a parent’s reason, and every sentence under 孩子的疲惫 gives a child’s, so the article never drifts between the two.
Other people’s voices
An article that explores a question lets people with different views speak. The model quotes a mother: “中文是根,丢了就找不回来了” (paragraph 6: Chinese is our roots; once lost, it cannot be found again). It also quotes a Grade 10 boy: “我能听懂奶奶说话就够了,为什么还要学写字?” (paragraph 8: it is enough that I can understand Grandma, so why learn to write too?). Each quotation gives a side its strongest, most human form. Neither speaker is a straw figure set up to be knocked down.
Between the quotations, the writer reports views in her own words and marks whose they are. “对他们来说” (paragraph 6: for them, from their point of view) frames the parents’ reasoning, and “在孩子们看来” (paragraph 8: in the children’s eyes) frames the children’s. Phrases like these keep the writer at a fair distance while she reports. They also add range: the article reports a practical view, “认为会说中文的人以后找工作更有优势” (paragraph 6: they think that people who speak Chinese will have an advantage in finding work later), in a different structure from the quoted one.
A conclusion that returns to the title
The writer gives her own view only at the end of the article, and she reaches it through a moment from her own life. On a visit to Guangzhou she read, for the first time on her own, “外婆写在旧照片背面的字” (paragraph 10: the words her grandmother had written on the back of old photographs). The realization that follows uses the pair 不只是……而是……, which sets a smaller idea aside for a larger one. Chinese is “不只是一门课,而是一条通向家人过去的路” (paragraph 10: more than a school subject, a road to the family’s past). The scene of a Saturday morning class at the start has become a question about family by the end.
The final paragraph does two things an article conclusion often does. It concedes with 当然 (of course): “不是每个人都会有这样的时刻” (paragraph 11: not everyone will have such a moment). It then suggests a way forward with 如果 and 也许: less recitation and more doing things in Chinese, such as interviewing older relatives, so that “也许会有更多同学愿意留下来” (paragraph 11: perhaps more students would be willing to stay). The suggestion is modest, 也许 rather than 一定, which suits an article that has just given both sides a fair hearing.
The model’s key lines are annotated here, from the subtitle to the last sentence.
——一个温哥华高中生的观察note 1
家长为什么坚持?孩子为什么想放弃?note 2
每个星期六早上九点,当很多同学还在睡觉的时候note 3,我已经坐在中文学校的教室里了。
王妈妈说:“中文是根,丢了就找不回来了。”note 4也有家长想得更实际……对他们来说note 5,每周三个小时并不算多。
可是在孩子们看来note 6,周六的中文课常常是一种负担。
那一刻我才明白,中文不只是一门课,而是一条通向家人过去的路note 7。
当然,不是每个人都会有这样的时刻。note 8我认为,中文学校如果能少一点背诵……也许会有更多同学愿意留下来note 9。
Subtitle. The dash and 观察 (observations) tell readers whose view this is and what kind of piece follows.
Standfirst. Two parallel questions set out the article’s subject and its two sides.
Hook. 当……的时候 sets the writer’s Saturday beside her classmates’, so readers feel the cost before any argument.
A voice for one side. A short quotation gives the parents’ view in its strongest form.
Reporting a view. 对他们来说 marks the view as the parents’, not the writer’s.
Turning to the other side. 可是 plus 在……看来 opens the second section with the contrast and its owner.
The writer’s realization. 不只是……而是…… replaces a small idea of Chinese with a larger one.
Concession. 当然 admits the limit of one personal story before the writer suggests anything.
A modest proposal. 如果……也许…… suggests a change and its likely result without claiming certainty.
The annotated lines carry the article’s whole movement: question, scene, two voices, a realization, a concession and a suggestion. The structures are those of a strong student response, chosen because each move needs one, and the writer never uses 首先 or 综上所述.
Register and audience
An article’s register comes from its publication. A youth section or school magazine allows 我, scenes from the writer’s life and the occasional question to readers. A city newspaper’s education page keeps more distance: it seldom uses 我, prefers facts and reported views, and uses more written-style words. The two openings that follow begin an article on the same subject for those two publications.
For the youth section of a family magazine | For a city newspaper’s education page |
|---|---|
每个星期六早上九点,当很多同学还在睡觉的时候,我已经坐在中文学校的教室里了。这样的周六,我过了十年。 | 在温哥华,每逢周六,不少华人家庭的孩子都要到中文学校上课。然而,随着年龄增长,坚持下来的学生越来越少。家长与孩子之间的分歧,值得关注。 |
The second opening has no 我 and no scene from one life. It reports a pattern, with written-style words throughout: 每逢 (every time… comes round) for 每个, 然而 (however) for 可是, 与 (and, with) for 跟, 值得关注 (deserves attention) as a formal way of saying why the article matters. 随着 (as, along with) introduces a change over time. The first opening speaks as a student among students; the second speaks about students to adult readers. Both are articles, and each fits its publication.
The school or youth article still keeps to written Chinese. It may ask readers a question, as the standfirst does, and it uses 我 freely, but it avoids slang and spoken fillers. At HL, a well-chosen four-character expression can fit either register, as long as it says something precise.
Article, news report, opinion column
Three mass media types are easily confused, and the difference shows in their first lines. A news report states what happened, most important fact first, with no 我. It begins like this: 本报讯 上周六,本市一所中文学校举行了建校三十周年活动。 An opinion column argues one view under the writer’s name from the start. Its first line might be 我认为,周末中文学校应该彻底改变教学方式。 The model article explores before it judges: it opens on a scene, lets both sides speak, and gives the writer’s view only at the end.
An article can still argue. A school magazine article on whether students should have part-time jobs may end firmly on one side. What separates it from a column is the space it gives to other views on the way, and what separates it from a news report is that it explains and interprets rather than only reporting. The pages on news reports and opinion columns teach those types in full.
Improving a paragraph
A weak paragraph lists reasons with numbering words and develops none of them. The stronger version makes one point and supports it.
首先,学中文很重要。其次,中文可以帮助我们找工作。然后,我们可以跟家人说话。最后,学中文很有意思。note 1
对很多家长来说,中文首先是家里的语言。王妈妈担心,孩子如果不会说中文,以后就听不懂爷爷奶奶的故事了。她说:“中文是根,丢了就找不回来了。”note 2
Weak. Four reasons in four sentences, each one a bare claim. 首先, 其次, 然后 and 最后 number the sentences but do not link the ideas, and no reason is explained.
Stronger. One reason, framed as the parents’ view with 对……来说, explained with a consequence (如果……就……) and supported by a quotation. The paragraph says less and develops more.
Try it
The model’s third subheading is a question, 学中文,为了什么?, while the first two are phrases. Why might the writer have broken the pattern there?
The first two sections report other people’s views, so their headings are parallel labels for two sides. The third section is where the writer gives her own answer, and a question signals that turn: it repeats the article’s central question and promises a personal reply. A third phrase, such as 我的想法, would mark the turn too, but less strongly.
当然,不是每个人都会有这样的时刻。
周六早上的中文课, paragraph 11
This one sentence of concession, placed just before the suggestion, keeps the ending fair. Without it, the writer’s own experience would stand as a rule for everyone, and readers who never had such a moment would stop listening.
The same task, done badly and well
Both responses that follow answer one task, set in Chinese as a writing task would be:
越来越多的高中生在周末做兼职。请为你们学校的校刊写一篇文章,介绍同学们做兼职的情况,并谈谈你的看法。
More and more high school students take part-time jobs at weekends, and the student writes an article for the school magazine that describes the situation among classmates and gives a view. The readers are students at the same school, and the task has two parts: describe, then judge.
学生做兼职note 1
现在有很多学生做兼职。我觉得这个问题很重要。note 2
首先,做兼职可以赚钱。其次,做兼职可以学到很多东西。然后,做兼职也有坏处,比如没有时间学习。note 3
最后,我觉得学生可以做兼职,但是不要太多。综上所述,做兼职有好处也有坏处。note 4
A topic, not a title. It names the subject and gives readers no reason to read on. There is no subtitle, byline or standfirst.
An opening anyone could write. A general statement, then a claim that the subject matters, with nothing to show why.
The template frame. Three points numbered by 首先, 其次 and 然后, none developed with an example or a classmate’s experience. The first part of the task, the situation among classmates, is never described.
Two endings. 最后 introduces the view, and 综上所述 repeats it as a summary of nothing new.
The weak response is mostly correct and uses several connectives. It is still not an article for this school magazine: it would fit any publication equally well, it never shows a classmate at work, and its frame, learned for every type, replaces the links between ideas. The second response gives the same readers the same subject.
周末去奶茶店打工,值得吗?note 1
——听听两位同学的说法note 1
文/高二(5)班 周一鸣note 1
上个月,我在学校附近的奶茶店看见了同班的小雨。她穿着店里的围裙,一边做奶茶,一边跟我打招呼。note 2原来,她每个周末都在这里打工。
小雨说,第一次拿到工资的时候,她觉得自己“长大了”note 3。可是另一位同学阿杰只做了两个月就放弃了:“站一天腿都疼,周一上课根本没精神。”note 4
在我看来,周末兼职能让我们早一点了解工作的辛苦,但前提是不影响学习和休息。note 5每周只做几个小时,也许是最好的选择。
The frame of an article. A title that asks the article’s question, a subtitle that says how it will answer, and a byline.
A hook from school life. A classmate seen at work, in a scene readers can picture.
A detail that develops the point. The first wages make the benefit concrete.
The other side in a classmate’s words. 可是 turns to a second experience, and the quotation makes the cost real.
The writer’s view, with a condition. 在我看来 marks it as a view, and 前提是 (on condition that) qualifies it.
Under criterion C, the difference is the publication. The strong response has the frame of a magazine article (title, subtitle, byline) and is written for students at this school, who may know the shop and the classmates. Under criterion B, it answers both parts of the task: the situation, through two classmates, and a view with a reason and a condition. The weak response does neither part in detail. At about 200 characters the strong response is still short of a full SL response; a full one would add a third voice, perhaps a parent or a teacher, under its own subheading.
In Paper 1
An article is the right choice when a task asks you to inform readers of a publication about a subject, explain it, or explore a question and give a view: a school magazine, a youth page, a community newsletter. Tasks that name such a publication, or that ask you to describe a situation and comment on it, suit it well. If the task asks you to argue one side forcefully under your own name, an opinion column may fit better. If you are to address a live audience, write a speech. If the subject is your own experience for people who follow you, write a blog post.
A marker looks for the type first in its frame: a title that fits the publication, often a subtitle and a byline, and an opening that draws readers in. Inside the frame, the article must be organized for readers, with paragraphs or subheaded sections that each develop one point, and a conclusion that adds something. At 300 to 480 characters there is room for a frame, an opening, two or three developed points and a conclusion, but not for a long list.
The commonest way an article loses marks is the memorized frame. A response built on 首先……其次……然后……最后……综上所述 looks organized but rarely develops any point, and the same frame in a letter, a speech and an article shows a marker that the type and its readers were never considered.
Its conventions in brief
The model’s first two lines hold three of the type’s conventions: the subtitle with its dash, the byline with 文 and a slash, and the writer’s role in brackets.
——一个温哥华高中生的观察
文/林嘉欣(十一年级)周六早上的中文课, paragraphs 1–2
A title that gives a picture or a question, often with a subtitle after a long dash (破折号).
A byline: 文/ and the writer’s name, with a role or class where it matters.
A standfirst, in a longer magazine article, that sums up what the article explores.
An opening that draws readers in: a scene, a surprising fact or a quotation.
Sections under subheadings, or paragraphs, each developing one point with detail and voices.
Views marked as views (对……来说, 在……看来, 有人认为……也有人认为……) and linked in words.
A conclusion that returns to the title’s question and adds a judgment, a condition or a suggestion.
A register that fits the publication: 我 and an occasional question to readers in a school magazine, more distance in a newspaper.
The news report, the opinion column and the review are the article’s neighbors among the mass media types, and each has its own page; the speech is the type for a live audience. The theme pages on language and identity and on migration give material for articles like the model.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain how a publication and its readers shape an article’s title, opening, structure and register.
- To do:
I can write the frame of an article: title, subtitle, byline and, where it fits, a standfirst.
- To do:
I can open an article with a scene, a fact or a quotation instead of a general statement.
- To do:
I can organize sections under subheadings and develop each with detail and other people’s voices.
- To do:
I can write a conclusion that adds something instead of repeating the introduction.
- To do:
I can tell an article from a news report, an opinion column, a speech and a blog post.
- To do:
I can plan and write an article of 300 to 480 characters for a named publication.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB Mandarin B glossary.
- Standfirst
A short paragraph between the title and the body of an article that sums up what the article is about. It is written to make readers want to continue.
- Subheading
A short heading inside a text that names the topic of the section under it. It helps readers find their way through a longer text and keeps each section on one subject.
Text types for Mandarin B
Mass media
- 1ArticlesThis page
Personal
Mass media
Professional
- 7Formal letters and emails
- 8Reports
- 9Instructions and guidelines
- 10Surveys and questionnaires
- 11Proposals and appeals
Mass media
Carry on with Mandarin B in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.