Opinion columns

How to write an opinion column in Spanish: a headline with a view, a thesis in the first paragraph, reasons with evidence, a counterargument answered, the right mood after opinion verbs and a close that moves on.

  • IB Spanish B
  • Text types
  • SL and HL

18 min readLast reviewed

An opinion column is an argument made in public by a named person. The writer chooses an issue the readers already know about, takes a side and tries to bring them round, or at least to make them think again. Its authority is personal: the columnist speaks as a student, a doctor or a neighbor, never as the publication. The readers did not ask for this view, so the column has to state it early and defend it well. In Spanish it is la columna de opinión or el artículo de opinión.

A student in Madrid answered a task of this kind, set on the theme Social organization: Tu región prohíbe el uso del móvil en los centros escolares. Escribe una columna de opinión para la revista de tu instituto. The ban is real. Since the 2020–2021 school year, public schools and publicly funded private schools (concertados) in the Community of Madrid have not allowed students to use phones during the school day, breaks included. Her column, written for the school magazine, is a strong response at SL length.

Sin móvil en el instituto: tenían razón (casi)El Altavoz, the student magazine of a public secondary school in Madrid (Retiro) (a student's opinion column)Written for Augment Education
El Altavoz · Opinión
Sin móvil en el instituto: tenían razón (casi)
Lucía Ferrer estudia 2.º de Bachillerato y escribe en El Altavoz desde 1.º de ESO.
Lo admito: cuando empecé 1.º de ESO, la norma que prohíbe el móvil en el instituto me parecía la más absurda del mundo. Cinco años después, he cambiado de opinión. Estoy convencida de que la prohibición ha hecho más bien que mal, aunque creo que se queda corta.
Desde el curso 2020-2021, en los colegios e institutos públicos y concertados de la Comunidad de Madrid no se puede usar el móvil durante toda la jornada escolar, ni siquiera en el recreo, salvo cuando un profesor lo pide para una actividad. ¿Qué ha cambiado? Para empezar, los recreos. En nuestro patio se juega al fútbol, se charla y a veces se discute, pero mirándose a la cara. Los profesores que llevan años en el centro cuentan que antes media clase pasaba el recreo en silencio, cada uno con su pantalla.
Además, en clase prestamos más atención. Cuando el móvil está apagado en la mochila, nadie espera una notificación. Y hay algo que se nota menos pero importa más: durante seis horas al día, nadie nos mide por los «me gusta». Las peleas de las redes no desaparecen, pero por lo menos se quedan en la puerta.
Es cierto que la norma tiene costes. Algunos profesores echan de menos el móvil para buscar información en clase, y muchas familias se preocupan porque no pueden localizar a sus hijos. Sin embargo, el instituto tiene ordenadores y un teléfono en conserjería, y en una emergencia eso basta. No creo que estos problemas sean motivo suficiente para volver atrás.
Lo que de verdad me preocupa es otra cosa: prohibir el móvil no nos enseña a usarlo. A las tres de la tarde salimos por la puerta y lo encendemos todos a la vez, con las mismas costumbres de siempre. ¿No sería mejor que el instituto, además de prohibir, nos enseñara a controlar el tiempo de pantalla, a detectar un bulo o a proteger nuestra privacidad?
Así que, compañeros, la próxima vez que os quejéis de la norma, pensad en los recreos de antes. Y a la dirección le pido una cosa: que el curso que viene haya un taller de hábitos digitales en cada clase de la ESO. La prohibición fue el primer paso; ahora falta el segundo.

How it works

The column takes a position on one question, whether the ban has been good for students, and every paragraph serves that position. Its readers are the writer’s schoolmates, most of whom dislike the rule, so the column cannot simply praise it. It has to win them over, step by step, with evidence they recognize from their own school. That situation explains each convention below.

Headline and columnist line

The headline states the view in a compressed form: “Sin móvil en el instituto: tenían razón (casi)” (no phone at school: they were right (almost)), paragraph 2. The phrase tenían razón concedes that the adults were right, and the bracketed casi warns that the writer will not agree completely. A reader who sees only the headline already knows the column’s position and its limit. A neutral headline such as El móvil en el instituto would announce a topic, which suits an article but not a column.

Under the headline, a one-line description introduces the writer: “Lucía Ferrer estudia 2.º de Bachillerato y escribe en El Altavoz desde 1.º de ESO” (paragraph 3). Newspapers print the same kind of line, often with a small photograph, because a column is read as one person’s view. The line tells the readers why this writer has a right to an opinion: she has lived through the ban for five years. The section label above it, “El Altavoz · Opinión” (paragraph 1), separates her view from the magazine’s news.

The thesis in the first paragraph

The thesis arrives in the third sentence of the body: “Estoy convencida de que la prohibición ha hecho más bien que mal, aunque creo que se queda corta” (I am convinced that the ban has done more good than harm, although I think it does not go far enough), paragraph 4. It has two parts, a judgment and a limit, and the rest of the column develops them in that order. Paragraphs 5 to 7 argue the judgment; paragraphs 8 and 9 argue the limit.

Before the thesis comes a short confession: “Lo admito: cuando empecé 1.º de ESO, la norma que prohíbe el móvil en el instituto me parecía la más absurda del mundo” (I admit it: when I started secondary school, the rule seemed the most absurd in the world). The writer begins on the side of her readers, then tells them she has changed her mind. A student who disliked the rule reads on, because the column starts from their own view. An opinion column is personal in exactly this way: the writer’s experience is part of the evidence.

Reasons, each with its evidence

Each argument paragraph opens with its reason and then proves it. Paragraph 5 begins with the law, stated as a fact with its date, and asks “¿Qué ha cambiado?” (what has changed?). The answer is the break time: “se juega al fútbol, se charla y a veces se discute, pero mirándose a la cara” (people play football, chat and sometimes argue, but looking each other in the face). The evidence that things were different before is reported, not invented: teachers who have worked at the school for years remember a silent playground, “cada uno con su pantalla” (each with their own screen).

Paragraph 6 opens with Además and gives a second reason, attention in class, then a third that the writer marks as the most important: “nadie nos mide por los «me gusta»” (nobody measures us by our likes). The phrase se nota menos pero importa más (is noticed less but matters more) tells the reader where the argument is heading. Every piece of evidence comes from the school or from the law. The column contains no statistics, because a student writing in a magazine has none to hand, and an invented figure would weaken the whole text.

The counterargument, conceded and answered

Paragraph 7 gives the other side its strongest form. “Es cierto que la norma tiene costes” (it is true that the rule has costs) opens a counterargument with two specific objections: teachers miss phones for research in class, and families cannot reach their children. The writer does not mock either objection. She grants them first, which is a concession, and only then answers with Sin embargo: the school has computers and a phone at the front desk, and in an emergency that is enough.

The paragraph ends on a judgment in the subjunctive: “No creo que estos problemas sean motivo suficiente para volver atrás” (I do not think these problems are reason enough to go back). The order of the three moves (grant, answer, judge) matters. A column that ignored the objections would look as if the writer had not heard them, and readers who hold them would stop reading. Answering them makes the thesis stronger than it was before the paragraph began.

Persuading without shouting

The column persuades with a few features, each used once. The rhetorical question in paragraph 8, “¿No sería mejor que el instituto, además de prohibir, nos enseñara a controlar el tiempo de pantalla…?” (wouldn’t it be better if the school, as well as banning, taught us to control screen time?), carries the writer’s proposal while letting the reader reach it. The conditional sería and the imperfect subjunctive enseñara make it a suggestion, not a demand. The inclusive nos puts the writer among the students who would benefit.

The image of the playground does more work than an adjective could. Instead of calling the old breaks tristes or aburridos, the writer shows them: half a class in silence, each with a screen. In paragraph 6, “Las peleas de las redes no desaparecen, pero por lo menos se quedan en la puerta” (the fights on social media do not disappear, but at least they stay at the door) turns an abstract benefit into a place. The register stays calm throughout. There are no insults, no exclamation marks and no claim that the writer’s opponents are foolish.

A close that moves the argument on

The last paragraph does not repeat the thesis. It speaks first to the readers, with vosotros, as students in Spain address each other: “la próxima vez que os quejéis de la norma, pensad en los recreos de antes” (next time the rule provokes a complaint, think of the breaks before), paragraph 9. Then it turns to the school’s management with one specific demand, introduced by le pido una cosa: a workshop on digital habits in every class. The final sentence, “La prohibición fue el primer paso; ahora falta el segundo” (the ban was the first step; now the second is missing), divides the argument into two steps the reader can remember.

A close of this kind gives the column a direction: the reader leaves with an action to take. Other strong closes ask a question the reader must answer for themselves or predict what will happen if nothing changes; a close that begins En conclusión and lists the reasons again only tells the reader what they have just read.

The annotated lines gather the conventions in the order a reader meets them.

Sin móvil en el instituto: tenían razón (casi)note 1

Lucía Ferrer estudia 2.º de Bachillerato y escribe en El Altavoz desde 1.º de ESO.note 2

Lo admito:note 3 cuando empecé 1.º de ESO, la norma que prohíbe el móvil en el instituto me parecía la más absurda del mundo. Cinco años después, he cambiado de opinión. Estoy convencida de que la prohibición ha hecho más bien que mal, aunque creo que se queda corta.note 4

Desde el curso 2020-2021, en los colegios e institutos públicos y concertados de la Comunidad de Madrid no se puede usar el móvil durante toda la jornada escolarnote 5, ni siquiera en el recreo […].

Es cierto que la norma tiene costes.note 6 […] Sin embargonote 7, el instituto tiene ordenadores y un teléfono en conserjería […]. No creo que estos problemas sean motivo suficientenote 8 para volver atrás.

¿No sería mejor que el instituto, además de prohibir, nos enseñaranote 9 a controlar el tiempo de pantalla […]?

Y a la dirección le pido una cosa: que el curso que viene haya un taller de hábitos digitalesnote 10 en cada clase de la ESO.

  1. Headline with a view. The position and its limit (casi) in six words.

  2. Columnist line. Who is speaking and why her view counts, in the third person.

  3. Personal opening. A confession puts the writer on her readers’ side before she argues against them.

  4. Thesis. A judgment and a limit; estoy convencida de que and creo que take the indicative.

  5. A fact with its date. The law stated accurately, with the impersonal se puede, before any argument about it.

  6. Concession. Es cierto que grants the other side its point.

  7. Rebuttal. Sin embargo turns from the objection to the answer.

  8. Mood after a negative opinion. No creo que + present subjunctive (sean).

  9. Proposal as a question. Conditional + imperfect subjunctive, with the inclusive nos.

  10. A specific demand. Pedir que + present subjunctive (haya), addressed to the people who can act.

Register and audience

Lucía writes for her schoolmates, so her register is personal and close. She opens with a confession (Lo admito) and addresses her readers as compañeros with vosotros. The same view sent to the regional education authority would be a formal letter with one reader who can act. The table sets the two openings side by side.

Column in the school magazine

Formal letter to the education authority

Sin móvil en el instituto: tenían razón (casi)

Asunto: la prohibición del móvil en los centros educativos

Lo admito: cuando empecé 1.º de ESO, la norma me parecía la más absurda del mundo.

Me dirijo a ustedes, como alumna de un instituto público de Madrid, para expresar mi opinión sobre la norma que prohíbe el uso del móvil durante la jornada escolar.

Estoy convencida de que la prohibición ha hecho más bien que mal.

Considero que la medida ha tenido efectos positivos en la convivencia y en la atención en clase.

¿No sería mejor que el instituto nos enseñara a usarlo?

Les agradecería que estudiaran la posibilidad de incluir talleres de hábitos digitales en la ESO.

compañeros, os quejéis, pensad (vosotros)

ustedes, les agradecería (formal plural)

The letter keeps the same thesis but changes everything around it. The confession disappears, because an official does not need to be won over from the students’ side. The rhetorical question becomes a request with Les agradecería que + imperfect subjunctive, and the vocabulary moves up a step: la medida for la norma, la convivencia (life together at school) for the scene of the playground. The column addresses many readers who may disagree, and the letter addresses one office that can decide.

Place changes the form of address. A column from Spain may speak to its readers with vosotros (¿Os acordáis de los recreos de antes?), as Lucía does. In Latin America, where ustedes is the only plural form of address, the same line is ¿Se acuerdan de los recreos de antes?. A column in an Argentine or Uruguayan magazine might use vos inside a quoted voice. Columns everywhere use direct address sparingly: one or two lines that speak to the reader, usually near the end, give the argument a target without turning it into a speech.

The same task, done badly and well

Two students answered the same short task: Escribe una columna de opinión para la revista de tu colegio sobre si los deberes deberían eliminarse. Both write correct, understandable Spanish. The first response reads like a summary of a class discussion.

Los deberes

Hoy en día hay mucho debate sobre los deberes.note 1 Algunas personas piensan que los deberes son buenos porque ayudan a practicar. Otras personas piensan que son malos porque los alumnos están cansados.note 2 Los profesores dicen que son necesarios y los alumnos dicen que no. También hay padres que ayudan a sus hijos y otros que no pueden.

Los deberes tienen ventajas y desventajas.note 3 Por ejemplo, ayudan a estudiar, pero también quitan tiempo para hacer deporte o estar con la familia.

En conclusión, es un tema muy complicado y cada persona tiene su opinión.note 4

  1. No angle. A general opening that could start any text on any subject.

  2. Both sides, no writer. Algunas personas… otras personas… lists views without taking one; the writer never appears.

  3. Points without development. Each claim gets one clause and no example from the writer’s own school.

  4. No thesis at the end either. The close admits that the column has no position, which is the one thing a column must have.

The second response takes a side in its first lines, argues it with two developed reasons, answers the obvious objection and ends with a proposal.

Menos deberes, mejores deberes

No quiero que eliminen los deberes: quiero que tengan sentido.note 1 El año pasado, en 4.º, hacía tres horas de tareas cada noche, y casi todas eran ejercicios repetidos del libro.

Los deberes útiles son los que obligan a pensarnote 2, como preparar un debate o leer un capítulo para comentarlo en clase. Los que solo repiten lo que ya sabemos nos quitan tiempo para el deporte, la familia y el sueño.

Es cierto que sin práctica en casa algunos alumnos se quedarían atrás. Sin embargonote 3, una hora bien pensada sirve más que tres horas de copiar.

Propongo que cada departamento acuerde un máximo semanal.note 4 ¿No sería mejor hacer menos, pero hacerlo bien?

  1. Thesis first. The writer rejects both extremes in one sentence and backs it with her own experience of last year.

  2. A reason with an example. What makes homework useful is shown with two specific tasks.

  3. Counterargument answered. The concession is real (se quedarían atrás), and the answer compares one hour with three.

  4. A close that moves forward. A concrete proposal with propongo que + subjunctive, then a question that leaves the reader agreeing.

The two columns use the same ideas: practice, tiredness, family time. The difference is that the second one belongs to a writer. The first would fit a textbook on any subject, and a reader finishes it knowing nothing new. The second has a thesis in its first line, reasons drawn from the writer’s own year, an objection taken seriously and a proposal at the end. The Spanish in it is no harder; the whole text is organized around one position.

Try it

This sentence opens a student’s column: Hay personas que piensan que el uniforme es bueno y personas que piensan que es malo. Rewrite it as the first sentence of a column with a thesis.

One possible version: Estoy convencido de que el uniforme hace más justo el instituto, aunque no creo que deba ser obligatorio en Bachillerato. The rewrite takes a side, gives a reason in a few words and states a limit, so the reader knows what the rest of the column will argue. No creo que takes the subjunctive (deba).

The parts on the page

A printed column has a recognizable shape, and the diagram sets out its parts from top to bottom with the job of each. The section label (“El Altavoz · Opinión”) and the columnist’s line frame the text as one person’s view. The thesis paragraph is the one the reader must not miss, and the counterargument usually sits just before the close, where the writer answers the strongest objection before making a final demand. In Lucía’s column the parts follow exactly this order: label (paragraph 1), headline (2), columnist line (3), thesis (4), two paragraphs of reasons (5 and 6), counterargument (7), and a close in two steps (8 and 9).

Layout of an opinion column: section label Opinión; a headline stating a view; the columnist’s name, photo and one-line description; a highlighted opening with the thesis; argument paragraphs, one reason each; a counterargument and rebuttal; a closing paragraph with a demand.Layout of an opinion column: section label Opinión; a headline stating a view; the columnist’s name, photo and one-line description; a highlighted opening with the thesis; argument paragraphs, one reason each; a counterargument and rebuttal; a closing paragraph with a demand.
An opinion column from the section label to the close. The thesis comes in the first paragraph, and the counterargument is answered before the final demand.

In a handwritten response, the parts are easy to show. The headline goes on its own line, followed by the columnist’s name and a short description such as “Lucía Ferrer estudia 2.º de Bachillerato” (paragraph 3). A photo is not needed, and neither is a long introduction. What matters is that the reader can find the thesis in the first paragraph and see where the other side is answered.

Applying it in Paper 1

Choose an opinion column when the task asks for your view on a public issue for the readers of a publication: a school magazine, a local newspaper, a website. Tasks that ask you to dar tu opinión, convencer a los lectores or reaccionar ante a new rule or event fit it well. Avoid it when the reader is one person (a letter or an email), when the purpose is to inform without taking sides (an article or a news report), or when the text will be heard rather than read (a speech). A formal letter to a newspaper also gives a view, but it answers something the paper printed and keeps a formal distance; a column speaks in its own space and its own voice.

A marker reads the first paragraph first. If it holds a thesis, the response is recognizably a column. Then the body is read for development: reasons with evidence, not a list of claims; a counterargument handled fairly; a close that does more than repeat. The weak response on homework would lose marks here, under both B and C, however correct its Spanish, because a reader finishes it without knowing what its writer thinks.

The commonest language slip in this type comes from the mood after verbs of opinion. Students who have learned that opinions take the subjunctive apply it to every opinion, including the affirmative ones.

Its conventions in brief

The conventions taught on the model, as a list to come back to:

  • A headline that states or hints the view: “tenían razón (casi)”.

  • The columnist’s name and a one-line description under it.

  • The thesis in the first paragraph, often after a short personal opening.

  • One reason per paragraph, each opened by its point and supported by evidence.

  • A counterargument stated fairly, then answered: Es cierto que…; sin embargo….

  • The indicative after creo que and estoy convencido de que; the subjunctive after no creo que.

  • A personal but calm register, with direct address to the readers used sparingly.

  • A close that moves the argument on: a demand, a question or a next step.

The opinion column leads to the speech, which argues in the same way for listeners rather than readers, and to the letter to the editor, which answers a publication in a formal register. The grammar it leans on is taught on the pages on the present subjunctive and on connectors of contrast and concession.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain how an opinion column differs from an article, an editorial and a letter to the editor.

  • To do:

    I can write a headline that states a view and a one-line description of the columnist.

  • To do:

    I can state a thesis in the first paragraph and support it with one reason per paragraph.

  • To do:

    I can present a counterargument fairly and answer it with Es cierto que…; sin embargo….

  • To do:

    I can use the indicative after creo que and the subjunctive after no creo que.

  • To do:

    I can keep a personal, calm register and address the readers with vosotros or ustedes sparingly.

  • To do:

    I can close a column with a demand, a question or a next step rather than a summary.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB Spanish B glossary.

Counterargument

A view against the writer's own, stated fairly in an argument and then answered, so that the writer's position holds up against its strongest objection.

Editorial

An unsigned text in which a newspaper or magazine states its own view on an issue, speaking for the publication rather than for one writer.

Opinion column

A signed mass media text in which a named writer argues a personal view on a current issue for a publication's readers, to persuade them or make them think.

Thesis

The main position a writer argues in a text, stated near the start and supported by every paragraph that follows.

Text types for Spanish B

Mass media

  1. 1Articles

Personal

  1. 2Diary entries
  2. 3Personal letters and emails
  3. 4Social media posts
  4. 5Blog posts

Mass media

  1. 6Brochures and leaflets

Professional

  1. 7Formal letters
  2. 8Reports
  3. 9Formal emails
  4. 10Proposals
  5. 11Instructions and guidelines

Mass media

  1. 12Interviews
  2. 13News reports
  3. 14Speeches
  4. 15Reviews
  5. 16Opinion columnsThis page
  6. 17Web pages

Carry on with Spanish B in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.