The individual oral

What the individual oral asks, how its two works and two extracts fit together, what each of its four criteria rewards, and the practical rules for preparing and recording it.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • SL and HL

24 min readLast reviewed

The individual oral is the one assessment that you speak rather than write. It asks you to take an issue that matters beyond the classroom, find it in two literary works you have studied, and explain in ten minutes how each writer presents it. The examples that follow use one pairing throughout: Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale (1985), a novel written in English, and Han Kang’s The Vegetarian (2007), a Korean novel read in Deborah Smith’s English translation (2015).

What the oral asks

The individual oral is a prepared talk of 10 minutes, followed by 5 minutes of questions from your teacher. In the talk you examine how one global issue of your choice is presented in two works. One work was originally written in English. The other was written in another language and is one you have studied in translation. You ground the talk in one extract from each work, and you connect each extract to the work it comes from.

The oral is marked out of 40, on four criteria of 10 marks each. It counts for 30% of the final grade at SL and 20% at HL. The task itself is the same at both levels: the same length, the same criteria and the same choice of works. Your teacher marks it, and the IB checks a sample of each school’s marks against its own standard.

The diagram sets out the shape of the task. The issue sits above both works, and each work holds one extract. The green arrows show the move that every strong oral makes, from the extract out to the rest of its work, and the orange arrow is the comparison between the two. The bar beneath shows how the fifteen minutes divide.

Diagram of the individual oral: one global issue at the top, with arrows to Work A (originally written in English) and Work B (studied in translation).Diagram of the individual oral: one global issue at the top, with arrows to Work A (originally written in English) and Work B (studied in translation).
The individual oral at a glance: one issue, two works, one extract from each, then 10 minutes of talk and 5 of questions.

Nothing in the oral is set by anyone else. There is no question paper and no list of issues. You choose the issue, the two works from those you have studied, and the extracts, usually with your teacher’s advice. That freedom is the oral’s main difficulty. A badly chosen issue or extract can hold a talk down before it starts, which is why choosing them has a page of its own.

Why the oral is built around a global issue

Literature has always dealt with matters larger than any one reader: who holds power, who belongs, what a society teaches its children, what people do to the land. The oral asks you to show that literary works take part in those arguments, and that they do so through their own methods. A novel about a regime does not present control in the way a newspaper report does. It presents control through a narrator’s voice, a pattern of images, a structure that withholds or repeats.

For this reason the oral analyzes the presentation of an issue, not the issue itself. Your opinion of how women are treated, however well informed, is not what is assessed. What is assessed is how Atwood and Han make their readers see that treatment: whose eyes the reader looks through, what is described and what is left out, which words carry the weight. A talk that becomes a speech about the issue has stopped doing the task, even when every sentence in it is true.

Weak: Today many women around the world still do not have control over their own bodies, and governments and families often make decisions for them. This is a very serious problem that needs to be solved.note 1

Strong: Both novels present the control of a woman’s body as something carried out in ordinary rooms by people who think they are doing right. Atwood shows it from inside, through Offred’s flat present tense; Han shows it from outside, through a husband who reports his wife’s refusal as an embarrassment to himself.note 2

  1. About the world, not the works. Both sentences could open a debate on the topic. Neither names a writer, a work or a choice, so there is nothing for criterion B to reward.

  2. About presentation. The sentence states the issue through the works and names a method in each (narrative voice), so the talk is already analyzing how the issue is shown.

The strong opening still has a view of the issue. It suggests that control is most frightening when it is domestic and sincere. That view, though, comes out of the works, and each half of the sentence is something the talk can go on to prove from an extract.

How the extracts and the works fit together

The extracts are the ground of the talk. Each is a short passage you know so well that you can point to a line, read a phrase aloud and analyze it on the spot. Because the extracts are in front of you and your teacher, they are where your closest analysis happens: of diction, imagery, syntax, narrative voice, structure and, in a play, staging.

The works are the reach of the talk. An extract on its own can only show one moment, and the oral asks how the work presents the issue. So each part of the talk moves outward: from what the extract does, to where the extract sits in the work, to how the same method or pattern appears elsewhere. A talk that never leaves its extracts reads two passages well and says little about two works. A talk that leaves them too soon becomes a summary of two plots.

One pairing, from issue to extracts

A single pairing shows how the parts of the oral fit together better than a list of rules. The Handmaid’s Tale is set in Gilead, a religious dictatorship that has overthrown the government of the United States. Its narrator, Offred, is a Handmaid, a woman assigned to a high-ranking household to bear a child for the Commander and his wife. The Vegetarian is set in present-day Seoul. Yeong-hye, an ordinary married woman, stops eating meat after a violent dream, and her husband, her parents and later her doctors try to make her eat again.

An issue that both works present is the control of women’s bodies by family and state. Put as a question societies argue about, it becomes: who has the right to decide what is done to a woman’s body, and what happens when she refuses? The two works answer it from opposite ends. Gilead controls bodies through laws, rituals and uniforms, and the household carries out the state’s will. In The Vegetarian there is no regime at all; the family, and later the hospital, enforce a rule that nobody needs to write down.

Choosing an extract from each work

In The Handmaid’s Tale a strong extract comes from chapter 16, the monthly Ceremony, in which the Commander attempts to conceive a child with Offred while his wife holds her hands. The scene is the issue in its plainest form, but its value for the oral lies in how Offred tells it. She narrates in the present tense, in level, precise sentences, and she considers the words a reader might use for what is happening and sets each of them aside. The scene takes place in a bedroom, as part of a household routine, after a Bible reading. The control of her body is presented as something orderly and almost polite.

In The Vegetarian a strong extract comes from the family dinner in the first part of the novel. Yeong-hye’s father slaps her and, while her husband and her brother hold her arms, forces a piece of pork into her mouth. She spits it out and cuts her wrist with a fruit knife. This part of the novel is narrated by her husband, Mr Cheong, and his attention keeps returning to himself: to how her behavior looks, to what it costs him. Yeong-hye herself says almost nothing. The reader sees the control of her body only through a man who is helping to carry it out.

The Handmaid’s Tale (chapter 16)

The Vegetarian (part one, the family dinner)

Original language

English

Korean, read in Deborah Smith’s translation

Who controls the body

The state, through a household ritual

The family, with no law behind it

Who tells it

The woman herself, Offred, in the first person

Her husband, in the first person

Features to analyze

Present tense; level, exact diction; words weighed and refused; the ritual’s order

A narrator absorbed in himself; the father’s violence reported flatly; the woman’s near silence; one sudden act

Where the talk moves out

The Red Center and the Handmaids’ training; the “Historical Notes”, where scholars handle Offred’s story

The second and third parts, where her body becomes an artist’s material and then a patient forced to eat

The table shows why these two extracts make a pair and not just two scenes on the same subject. Each puts the controlled body at the center of a domestic ritual, a ceremony in a bedroom and a family meal. The narrative voice is where they divide. Offred speaks from inside the body being controlled, and in the dinner scene Yeong-hye is spoken about by someone outside it. That difference in method is what the comparison can explain, and it gives criterion B something to reward in every minute of the talk.

From each extract to its work

A strong talk does not stay in the bedroom or at the dinner table. For Atwood, the student might move from the Ceremony to the Red Center, where the Handmaids are trained to think of themselves in terms of their function, and to Offred’s own bitter summary of that training in chapter 23:

We are two-legged wombs, that’s all

The Handmaid’s Tale, chapter 23

The phrase lets the talk connect the flat voice of chapter 16 to an idea the whole novel develops: a body reduced to one use. The student might then end the Atwood section with the “Historical Notes” that close the book, in which scholars of a later century discuss Offred’s recorded story as a document and speculate about who she and the Commander were. Control of her body has become control of her account.

For Han, the talk can follow Yeong-hye through the two later parts of the novel, each told from a different relative’s point of view. In the second, her sister’s husband, a video artist, paints flowers on her body and films it. In the third, she is in a psychiatric hospital, refusing food, and doctors try to feed her through a tube while her sister watches. The force at the dinner table returns in a medical form, so the family’s rule is taken over by an institution. The student can then show that the account of her body stays with others: Yeong-hye is heard directly only in brief italic passages of her dreams, and no part of the novel is hers to narrate.

Try it

Your talk has three minutes left for the comparison of these two works. Which single difference between the extracts would you build it on, and why that one?

The narrative voice is the strongest choice. Offred tells her own story, so The Handmaid’s Tale presents a woman who keeps a mind of her own while her body is controlled. Yeong-hye is told about by others, so The Vegetarian presents a woman whose refusal can only be misread. The difference also leads back to the issue: it asks whether control is complete when it reaches the body, or only when it reaches the person’s voice.

The practical arrangements

Some arrangements for the oral are fixed, and some vary in detail from school to school or are commonly stated without being confirmed for the current course. The fixed ones are the timing, the marks and the shape of the task: 10 minutes of talk, 5 minutes of questions and 40 marks, for one global issue in two works and two extracts. The arrangements for the extracts, the outline and the recording are what usually happens. Ask your teacher how it works at your school before you prepare.

The extracts

Each extract is usually about 40 lines long, or an equivalent length of prose, or a few pages of a graphic work. That length is chosen so that a whole extract can be analyzed in a few minutes of speech. A longer passage forces you to skim it, and a much shorter one gives too little to work with. You usually bring clean copies of both extracts into the room, one for you and one for your teacher, without your own notes or highlighting on them.

The extracts are the only text in front of you. You cannot bring the whole works, so everything you say about the rest of each work comes from memory: the order of events, the shape of the structure, a few key phrases. Preparing for the oral therefore includes learning each work well enough to refer to it precisely without the book, in the same way as for Paper 2.

The outline

You may usually bring a short oral outline into the oral: a list of brief notes, widely stated as no more than ten points. It is there to keep you on your plan, not to tell you what to say. A good outline is made of keywords, line numbers and the names of moments in each work. It is not a script, and a talk read aloud from full sentences sounds like reading, which costs marks under criteria C and D.

Too much: 3. In lines 12–20 Offred describes the Ceremony in a very calm and detached way, which shows that she has become used to the control of her body and that the regime has succeeded in making the abnormal seem normal to her.note 1

Enough: 3. Ext A 12–20: calm voice, words refused → numbed or resisting? → Red Centernote 2

  1. A sentence to read. This point is a finished paragraph. With it in front of you, the temptation is to read it out, and the talk loses the sound of thinking.

  2. A prompt to speak from. Line numbers, two features, the question the talk will weigh and the next move. Everything else comes from your preparation, in your own words, at the moment of speaking.

The second version holds more of the argument than the first, even though it has fewer words. It points to the lines, names the features, sets up an interpretation with two possible answers and marks the move to the rest of the work. Planning that outline, point by point, belongs to the work of structuring the ten minutes.

The recording

The oral is audio-recorded from start to finish, including the questions. The recording is not a formality. It is the only evidence of your performance that leaves the school, because the IB checks marks by listening to recordings. Speak clearly enough for a stranger to follow on a recording, and say line numbers aloud, since a listener cannot see where you are pointing.

How the oral is marked

Your teacher marks your oral against the four criteria, usually soon after it takes place. The IB then checks the school’s marking through moderation, which uses recordings of a sample of the school’s orals. Where the school’s marking differs from the IB’s standard, marks can be adjusted, so the mark a teacher gives is not always the final mark. Ask your teacher how moderation works at your school.

Because moderation compares teachers with an outside standard, a generous or severe teacher does not change what a strong oral is. What earns marks in your school is what earns marks everywhere. The descriptions that follow are written to that common standard.

Which works you may use

The oral needs one work originally written in English and one studied in translation. Beyond that, each work you use for assessment is normally used only once across the oral, Paper 2 and the HL essay. A work you choose for the oral is then not available as one of your works for the Paper 2 essay, and at HL your essay will be on a different work again. Check with your teacher which works you may use where, early in the second year, because the choice for the oral shapes your preparation for the other components.

The learner portfolio as preparation

Most of the work for the oral happens long before the recording, in your learner portfolio. Notes on how a work presents power, belonging or the body, written while you read it, become the material from which an issue is chosen. Connections between works noticed in class become the comparison. A portfolio that records, for each work, its methods and the issues it touches, gives you several possible pairings to test instead of one guess made in a hurry.

The portfolio is also where you practice speaking. Recorded discussions, short spoken commentaries on a passage and practice orals with a timer all belong there. A student who has spoken about each work for three minutes several times over the two years finds the oral itself much less strange.

What the four criteria reward

Each criterion judges one quality of the whole oral, talk and questions together, and each is worth 10 marks. A 10-mark scale is divided into bands of two marks, so a mark of 7 or 8 means the oral does what the fourth band describes, with the higher mark for doing it more consistently. The diagram sets out, for each criterion, what a low oral does, what a middle one does and what lifts an oral to the top.

Four columns for criteria A to D. Each rises from a low box (A retells the plots; B names features; C wanders, one work dominates; D unclear, read from a script) through a middle box (knows works; explains effects; clear parts; clear with loose terms) to a top box (interprets how each work…Four columns for criteria A to D. Each rises from a low box (A retells the plots; B names features; C wanders, one work dominates; D unclear, read from a script) through a middle box (knows works; explains effects; clear parts; clear with loose terms) to a top box (interprets how each work…
The four criteria of the individual oral, each read from the bottom up: what a low oral does, what a middle oral does, what the top band rewards.

The spoken extracts for each criterion all come from talks on the same pairing and the same issue. In each pair, the first would sit low on the criterion and the second high, and the notes say what makes the difference. They are written as speech, so they are less formal than an essay, and that is correct for the task.

A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation

Criterion A asks whether you know both works well and whether you understand how each presents the global issue, through its extract and as a whole. Accurate knowledge of the plot is the floor of this criterion. The marks rise when that knowledge is selected and turned into an interpretation: a claim about what the work shows the issue to be.

Weak: In The Vegetarian, Yeong-hye stops eating meat because of a dream. Her family is angry, and at a family dinner her father hits her and makes her eat pork. Later she goes to hospital.note 1 So the family controls her body.note 2

Strong: Han places the most violent scene of the first part at a family meal, the setting where a family shows itself at its most normal.note 3 The father does not see himself as cruel; he is correcting a daughter. That is why the scene matters to the issue: the novel suggests that control of a woman’s body is most complete when everyone around her believes it is care.note 4

  1. Accurate, but retold. Every detail is right and in order, and the talk is still telling the story. Nothing here interprets.

  2. The issue as a label. The conclusion repeats the issue in its own words without saying anything about how this work presents it.

  3. Knowledge selected. One fact about the setting is chosen because it carries meaning, and the speaker says what that meaning is.

  4. An interpretation of the issue. The speaker draws a claim about the issue out of the work, a claim a listener could argue with.

The strong extract uses less information than the weak one. Criterion A rewards knowledge put to work, and an oral that interprets one well-chosen detail shows more understanding than one that lists every event. Knowledge of the whole work counts too: the strong speaker would go on to the hospital in the novel’s third part, but to make a point about it, not to finish the story.

B: Analysis and evaluation

Criterion B asks how each writer’s choices present the issue, in the extracts above all, and how well those choices work. It is the criterion most orals lose marks on, because a talk can know the works and the issue thoroughly and still never say how either work is written. Choices include diction, imagery, syntax, narrative voice, structure and, in a play, staging.

Weak: Atwood uses a lot of literary techniques in this extract, like imagery and first-person narration, which create a sense of Offred’s feelings.note 1 This makes the reader feel sorry for her.note 2

Strong: Offred tells the Ceremony in the present tense and in short, level sentences, with almost no word of fear or anger in them.note 3 The flatness can be read in two ways: as numbness, a mind that has learned not to feel, or as a refusal to give the regime even her distress. I think the second reading is stronger, because she keeps choosing her words so carefully.note 4

  1. Labels without effects. Two features are named, and their effect is “a sense of” feelings that are never identified. The sentence would fit any first-person novel.

  2. The reader as a formula. A reader’s pity is asserted, not explained. Nothing ties it to a line.

  3. A choice, located. Tense, sentence length and the absence of emotional words are all things Atwood chose, and all can be found in the lines of the extract.

  4. Evaluation. The speaker weighs two readings of the same choice and judges between them on evidence. Weighing like this is what lifts criterion B to the top band.

C: Focus and organization

Criterion C asks whether the talk is planned and whether it stays on the global issue. A focused oral keeps the issue in view in every part, gives the two works roughly equal time, and moves in an order a listener can follow. An oral can be well organized and still lose focus, if its parts are clear but the issue drops out of them.

Weak: Now I have finished with The Handmaid’s Tale, so I will talk about The Vegetarian. It was written by Han Kang in 2007 and won the International Booker Prize.note 1

Strong: Offred keeps her own voice while Gilead controls her body. Yeong-hye is given almost none, and the second extract shows how.note 2 In the dinner scene, the person telling us what happens to her body is the husband who helps to hold her down.note 3

  1. A join, not a link. The transition marks the change of work but says nothing about the issue, and the next sentence turns to facts about the book’s publication that no part of the argument needs.

  2. A turn that argues. The transition carries the issue across from the first work to the second and sets up the comparison before the second extract begins.

  3. Straight to the extract. Within two sentences the speaker is analyzing the second extract’s narrative voice, so the talk stays on the issue.

The strong transition does the work of a topic sentence in an essay, said aloud. It tells the listener where the talk is going and why. Planning those turns in advance, and timing each part, is the subject of structuring the ten minutes.

D: Language

Criterion D asks whether you speak clearly, accurately and fluently, in a register that suits a formal academic task, and whether you use literary terms precisely. It does not reward a particular accent, or the ease of someone speaking their first language. It rewards speech that a listener can follow without effort, and terms used for what they mean.

Weak: So basically the husband is kind of telling the story, and it’s like, really creepy, because he doesn’t really care about her, which is a big theme in the book.note 1

Strong: The first part is narrated by the husband, and his narration is self-absorbed: he reports the violence at the dinner as an embarrassment to himself. That narrative choice keeps Yeong-hye silent even in the scene about her own body.note 2

  1. Casual register and vague words. “Basically”, “kind of” and “really creepy” belong to conversation. “A big theme” uses a term loosely, for an attitude rather than an idea the work develops.

  2. Precise and formal, still spoken. The sentences are short enough to say aloud, the terms “narrated” and “narrative choice” are used accurately, and the register suits an assessed talk.

Speaking an analysis

An oral is not an essay read aloud, and it is not a conversation. It sits between the two. The register is formal, the terms are precise and the argument is planned, but the sentences are shorter than written ones, and the talk is allowed to sound like someone thinking. I want to suggest, I think the stronger reading is and this is where the two works part are all natural in an oral and earn their place, because they show the listener a mind making judgments.

Spoken argument needs more help than written argument. A reader can glance back to the thesis, while a listener has only what they remember. That is why orals use signposting: short phrases that say where the talk is and where it is going. My first extract shows the control from inside is one; I want to turn now to the narrator of the second extract is another. Three or four planned signposts in ten minutes are usually enough. More than that, and the talk starts to describe itself instead of arguing.

Referring to the extracts aloud

In an essay you cite a line in brackets. In an oral you say it: in line 14, in the second paragraph of the extract, near the end of the extract, where she reaches for the knife. Saying the line number lets your teacher, and later a moderator listening to the recording, find exactly what you mean. Quote briefly, a few words at a time, and then comment on them. Reading out four lines and paraphrasing them uses a minute and analyzes nothing.

For the rest of each work, where you have no text in front of you, refer by moment: the chapter, the part of the novel, the scene and what happens in it. A precise textual reference is often more useful than a remembered quotation, because it points to a structure as well as a sentence. The “Historical Notes” that end Atwood’s novel and the hospital in the third part of Han’s are both references of this kind.

Where marks are lost

Most orals that fall into the middle or low bands share one of a small number of faults. Several of them begin with the choice of issue or extracts, before a word of the talk is planned, and several come from preparing the talk as a written text. The table shows each fault in a sentence a student might say, and the same point said again in a form that earns marks.

Fault

As spoken

Revised

An issue too broad

“My global issue is power.”

“My issue is who decides what is done to a woman’s body, and what happens when she refuses.”

An issue that fits one work

“My issue is how religious states use scripture to control women.”

“My issue is how families and states control women’s bodies, a control Gilead writes into law and Yeong-hye’s family enforces without one.”

Unequal time

Six minutes on Atwood, then: “I’m running out of time, so briefly, The Vegetarian…”

A plan of about four minutes per work, timed in rehearsal, with the comparison kept for the last two.

Reading a script

Full sentences read at speed with the eyes down.

Speaking from an outline of keywords and line numbers, with pauses to think.

Extracts without works

Ten minutes on the two passages and nothing beyond them.

“This flat voice is the one Offred keeps through the whole novel, until the scholars of the ‘Historical Notes’ take her story from her.”

Content without analysis

“The father forces her to eat meat, which is very violent.”

“The husband reports the violence in one even sentence, and his flatness makes him part of it.”

No comparison

Two separate talks joined by “similarly”.

“Atwood lets the controlled woman narrate; Han leaves her almost silent. The difference asks whether control can reach a voice as well as a body.”

The faults in the table are connected. An issue that fits only one work produces unequal time, because one work has more to say. A talk prepared as a script loses its sound of thought and often its balance, because the writer of a script tends to keep adding to the part they know best. Fixing the choice of issue and extracts, and preparing to speak from an outline, removes several faults at once.

A last fault belongs to the questions. A student who has given a strong talk sometimes answers the teacher’s questions by repeating parts of it. The questions are a chance to go further: to look at a line you skipped, to bring in another moment of a work, to defend a reading. Answers count toward the same four criteria as the talk.

The oral is built in stages, each with a page of its own. The first is choosing a global issue, and two works and two extracts that present it differently. The second is structuring the ten minutes so that both works have fair time and the talk ends on the issue. The third is answering the five minutes of questions by returning to the texts, and three complete orals at different bands, on Frederick Douglass’s Narrative and Sophocles’ Antigone, show all of it at work.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what the individual oral asks: one global issue, two works (one originally in English, one in translation), one extract from each, 10 minutes of talk and 5 of questions.

  • To do:

    I can explain why the oral analyzes how works present an issue, not the issue itself.

  • To do:

    I can show how a talk moves from each extract to the rest of its work.

  • To do:

    I can say what each of the four criteria rewards and give a weak and a strong spoken sentence for each.

  • To do:

    I can describe the usual arrangements for the extracts, the outline and the recording, and know which details to check with my teacher.

  • To do:

    I can explain how moderation can change a teacher’s mark.

  • To do:

    I can recognize the commonest faults in an oral and correct them in my own sentences.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Individual oral

The spoken internal assessment of the course: a 10-minute talk on how one global issue is presented in two works, through one extract from each, followed by 5 minutes of the teacher's questions. It is marked by the teacher and checked by the IB.

Moderation

The IB's check on the marks a school gives, made from a sample of its recorded orals against the IB's standard. Marks can be adjusted where the school's marking differs from that standard.

Oral outline

The short list of notes a student may usually bring into the individual oral, made of keywords and line references rather than sentences. It reminds the speaker of the plan without becoming a script to read aloud.

Internal assessment for English A Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oralThis page
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes
  4. 4The five minutes of questions
  5. 5An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 6The HL essayHL only
  2. 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
  3. 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
  4. 9An HL essay at each bandHL only

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.