- Subjects
- English A Lit
- Structuring the ten minutes
Structuring the ten minutes
How to plan and deliver the ten minutes of the individual oral: a timed structure, moving from extract to whole work, signposting, referring to lines aloud and ending on the issue.
- IB English A: Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
Ten minutes is short for two works and long for a speaker without a plan. A strong oral is built like a short essay that is meant to be heard. It states where it is going and gives each work its share of time. It moves from close analysis to the work as a whole, and it ends by saying what the two works show together. The case at the center of the page plans a full oral on Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman (1949) and Anton Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard (1904), read in Julius West’s English translation of 1916.
The shape of a strong oral
Most strong orals follow one of two shapes. The first, and the safest, takes the works one at a time. It opens with the issue and the line of argument, analyzes the first extract closely and moves out to the rest of the first work. It does the same for the second, and then spends its last minutes on the comparison and on what the two works show about the issue. Each part has a clear job, and a listener can follow the order without effort.
The second shape is integrated. It moves between the two works throughout, organizing the talk by points of comparison rather than by work: first both writers’ use of a setting, then both narrators or central figures, then both endings. An integrated oral compares in every minute, which criterion B rewards, but it is harder to keep balanced and harder to follow. It suits a student who knows both works closely and whose extracts share several features. For most students the first shape, with comparison planted early and gathered at the end, gives the clearer talk.
Whichever shape you choose, the introduction states the plan. A listener cannot glance ahead, so a strong introduction does in speech what a thesis and a first paragraph do on paper. It names the issue, names both works and their extracts, and says in one sentence how the two works present the issue differently. That sentence is the line of argument, and the rest of the talk tests and develops it.
The ten minutes as a timeline
The timeline sets out the first shape minute by minute. Each work has about three and a half minutes, of which about two and a half go to its extract and one to the work beyond it. The comparison and synthesis have a minute and a half, and the introduction and conclusion take a minute and a half between them. The phrases above and below the bar mark where the talk turns, and each is a signpost to the listener.


Written as a student would keep it, the same timeline becomes a plan of seven steps. Its times are a guide. A talk whose first extract needs a little longer can take it from the second work’s minute beyond the extract, as long as the two works end up close to equal.
0:00–1:00. Introduction: the issue as a question, the two works and extracts, the line of argument in one sentence.
1:00–3:30. Extract A: two or three features, each quoted briefly with its line, each tied to the issue.
3:30–4:30. Work A beyond the extract: one or two moments that develop the same method or pattern.
4:30–7:00. Extract B: two or three features, with a first sentence that turns from the first work.
7:00–8:00. Work B beyond the extract.
8:00–9:30. Comparison and synthesis: the main difference in method, and what the two works show together.
9:30–10:00. Conclusion on the issue.
A plan for one oral
A student has studied Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman (1949), a play written in English, and Anton Chekhov’s The Cherry Orchard (1904), written in Russian and read in Julius West’s translation. Miller’s play follows the last day of Willy Loman, an aging traveling salesman from Brooklyn whose sales have dried up. Chekhov’s follows an aristocratic Russian family that loses its estate and its famous orchard to Lopakhin, a merchant whose father and grandfather were serfs on the land. The student’s issue, in the field of politics, power and justice, is put as a question: who pays when an economy changes, and are the people it leaves behind its victims, or partly to blame for not changing with it?
Both works present that question through a scene in which a decision about money is reported to the person it ruins. In Miller’s second act, Willy goes to his young boss, Howard Wagner, the son of the man Willy worked for, to ask for a job that would let him stop traveling. Howard is absorbed in a new wire recorder, plays Willy the recorded voices of his family, and then lets him go. In Chekhov’s third act, the family waits at a party for news of the auction, and Lopakhin returns to announce who has bought the estate. The student’s first extract is about 40 lines of the scene in Howard’s office. The second is the end of Act III, printed in West’s translation with its line numbers, as the student would bring it into the room:
The extract runs to 21 numbered lines, but several are long speeches, so its length is about the same as 40 lines of verse. That matters for the plan. Lopakhin’s speech in line 16 is long enough to hold most of the analysis, and the short exchange in lines 11–14 is the hinge on which the whole scene turns. A student who knows where those lines are can move through the extract in two and a half minutes without hurrying.
Why these two extracts make one argument
The scenes share a situation and divide on whose voice the audience hears. Miller keeps the man who is left behind at the center: Willy talks and pleads while Howard half listens, and the recorder’s cheerful family voices fill the space where attention should be. When Howard has left the room, Willy accidentally switches the machine on, and a child’s recorded voice fills the office while he struggles to stop it. Chekhov gives the scene to the winner. Lopakhin speaks the longest speech in the extract, while Lubov, who has lost everything, says nothing after the news: she nearly falls (line 15), and then she “sinks into a chair and weeps bitterly” (line 16).
That division is the line of argument. Miller presents economic change as something done to a man by a system that has stopped seeing him, so the audience’s sympathy runs one way. Chekhov presents the same kind of change as a gain and a loss in one room, and even the winner is “Confused, afraid to show his pleasure” (line 5). The comparison can then weigh the issue’s second half: Willy’s refusal to change his idea of success and the family’s failure to act on Lopakhin’s advice both make them partly responsible, yet neither play lets the audience simply blame them.
The outline the student brings in
The outline card shows the plan as the student would carry it: ten points, made of keywords, line numbers and arrows to the rest of each work. Points 2 to 4 hold work A, point 5 is the turn, points 6 to 9 hold work B, and point 10 is the synthesis. Nothing on the card is a sentence the student could read aloud, so the talk has to be spoken.


Three features make this outline useful. Every point names a place in a text, so the student can find the line in seconds. The arrows mark the moves outward, to the Requiem that ends Miller’s play and to the fourth act of Chekhov’s, which the plan needs and which are easy to forget under pressure. And the turn between the works has a point of its own, because the turn is where the comparison is first stated and where many talks lose their thread.
Weak: Death of a Salesman was written in 1949 by Arthur Miller, an American playwright who grew up during the Great Depression. The Cherry Orchard was written by Anton Chekhov in 1904, just before the Russian Revolution. Both plays are about money.note 1
Strong: My global issue is who pays when an economy changes, and whether the people it leaves behind are its victims or partly to blame.note 2 I will look at Willy Loman’s scene with Howard in Death of a Salesman and at the end of Act III of The Cherry Orchard, where Lopakhin announces that he has bought the estate.note 3 Miller keeps the loser at the center of his scene; Chekhov gives the stage to the winner. That difference is what I want to explain.note 4
Context instead of a plan. Three sentences of dates and background, and the issue arrives as “money”, a topic. The listener has no idea what the talk will argue.
The issue as a question. It is precise and could be answered either way, which sets the talk up to weigh, not to agree.
Both works and both extracts named. The listener knows where the talk will go and in what order.
The line of argument. One sentence states the difference in method that the talk will explain. It is the spoken equivalent of a thesis.
From the extract to the whole work
Each half of the talk spends most of its time in the extract and then moves outward. The move is made by a sentence that connects something in the extract to the shape of the work: its structure, a pattern that recurs, its ending. A connecting sentence does not tell the rest of the story. It says that a feature found in the lines is part of how the whole work presents the issue, and then gives one or two moments that prove it.
Come and look at Ermolai Lopakhin laying his axe to the cherry orchard, come and look at the trees falling!
The Cherry Orchard, tr. Julius West, line 16
Lopakhin’s boast in line 16 is spoken before a single tree has been cut. It points forward to the end of the play, where, after the family has left, the sound of the axe on the trees is heard from offstage. A student can use that link to show that Chekhov presents economic change as something the audience hears rather than sees: the auction happens offstage, and so does the felling. The losers are always in the room, and the change always happens somewhere else.
Weak: After this scene, in Act IV, the family leaves the estate. Lopakhin starts cutting down the trees, Anya and Trofimov go off to start a new life, and Fiers, the old servant, is left behind in the house.note 1
Strong: Lopakhin’s “axe” in line 16 is only a word, but Chekhov makes it a sound in the last act, when the trees are heard falling offstage after the family has gone.note 2 So the play never shows the change, only its noise reaching people who cannot stop it, and the last of those people is Fiers, the old servant, forgotten in the locked house.note 3
The plot continued. Every event is correct, but the sentences tell what happens next instead of connecting the extract to the work. The issue does not appear.
A feature of the extract linked to the structure. The speaker follows one word from the extract to its echo at the end of the play.
Back to the issue. The connection is turned into a claim about how the play presents those left behind, and the moment of Fiers is chosen because it proves it.
The strong version takes about the same time to say as the weak one. The difference is selection. The weak version follows the plot because that is the order in which the student remembers the play. The strong version follows a single feature, and the plot enters only where the feature leads. The same move works for Miller. Willy’s plea that a man is not to be thrown away like peel can be followed to the end of the play. There he dies so that his family will receive his life insurance, as if to prove his worth in the only terms Howard would recognize.
Signposting: telling the listener where you are
A listener cannot look back. In an essay, a paragraph break and a topic sentence show where a new point begins; in speech, the speaker has to say so. Signposting is the name for the words that do this: short statements of where the talk is and where it is going. Good signposting makes a talk easy to follow, and an easy talk sounds organized, which criterion C rewards.
Three kinds of signpost do almost all the work. An opening signpost states the plan once, in the introduction. A turning signpost marks each move: from the first extract to the rest of the first work, from the first work to the second, from the second work to the comparison. A closing signpost tells the listener that the talk is reaching its judgment. The best signposts do two jobs at once, because they mark the turn and state the point that the next part will develop.
Weak: OK, so that’s the first extract. Now I am going to move on to my second point, which is about the second play.note 1
Strong: Miller keeps the man who loses at the center of the scene. Chekhov does the opposite, and in my second extract the man who speaks most is the man who has won.note 2
A signpost with no content. It marks a change but says nothing about where the talk is going. A listener learns only that something else is coming.
A signpost that argues. The turn to the second work is made through the comparison, so the listener hears the line of argument at the moment the talk changes direction.
Signposts lose their value when there are too many of them. A talk that announces every sentence (my next point is, another thing I want to say is) sounds like a list being read, and the listener stops hearing the signals. Four or five planned turns in ten minutes, each one saying something, are enough. They should also be spoken naturally: a signpost read from the outline in a different voice from the rest of the talk sounds like a script.
Referring to lines while speaking
Your teacher has a clean copy of each extract, and a moderator may later listen to the recording with the same copy. Say the line number before or after each quotation, so that both can follow you. Quote briefly, a few words at a time, and spend your sentences on what the words do. Reading out a whole speech wastes time and analyzes nothing.
Weak: Then Lopakhin says, “I bought it! Wait, ladies and gentlemen, please, my head’s going round, I can’t talk.” And then he talks about the auction and how much he paid, and then he talks about his father and grandfather.note 1
Strong: In line 16 Lopakhin remembers the estate “where my grandfather and my father were slaves, where they weren’t even allowed into the kitchen”.note 2 That memory is why he cannot stop talking: for him the sale is a family’s history reversed, while for Lubov, who says nothing after line 13, it is the end of hers.note 3
Reading, then paraphrase. The quotation is longer than the point needs, and the rest is a summary in the order of the extract. No feature is analyzed.
A located, brief quotation. The line number comes first, and the quotation is chosen for the words that carry the meaning.
Analysis that returns to the issue. One sale means two opposite things to two people in the same room, which is the issue of who pays when an economy changes.
Try it
You are 30 seconds into your analysis of the Chekhov extract and want to show how Chekhov presents the change of ownership without anyone stating it. Which lines would you point to, and what would you say?
Lines 15 and 16. In line 15 Varya “takes her keys off her belt, throws them on the floor”, and in line 16 Lopakhin “Picks up the keys, nicely smiling”. You could say that ownership passes in a gesture: the keys of the house change hands through two stage directions while the speeches are about something else. The detail lets the audience see the change before anyone admits it, which is part of how the play presents economic change as something that happens around people faster than they can speak about it.
Keeping the two works in balance
Criterion C asks for a talk that gives both works fair time. Fair time does not mean exactly equal seconds, but a talk of six minutes on one work and three on the other is unbalanced, and the imbalance is easy to hear on a recording. The cause is almost always the same. A student knows one work better, has more to say about it and keeps saying it, and the second work is reached late and in a hurry.
The remedy is to plan for running long. Before the oral, mark on your outline the one point in each half that you can drop without breaking the argument. In the plan for Miller and Chekhov, the Singleman story (point 3) can shrink to a sentence, and the table knocked over in line 18 (point 9) can go entirely. The issue, the extracts’ main features and the moves outward all stay. A student who reaches minute five still inside the first work drops point 3 and turns. Deciding what to cut at home is much easier than deciding it in the middle of a sentence.
Balance also means equal depth. Two halves of three and a half minutes each are not balanced if one analyzes three features and the other retells the scene. Plan the same number of features for each extract, and give each one a quotation, a line number and a sentence on its effect. The translated work needs that care most, because it is the half students most often prepare less thoroughly.
Comparing throughout or at the end
A talk that takes the works one at a time still has to compare. The weakest version leaves comparison to the last minute and joins the two halves with similarly. The strongest plants the comparison three times. It appears once in the introduction, as the line of argument, and once at the turn between the works, as a signpost that argues. It returns at the end, where it is developed into a judgment. Between those points, a sentence of comparison inside the second half is natural and earns its place (where Willy pleads, Lopakhin boasts), because by then the listener has the first work in mind.
Comparison also means weighing the writers’ choices, not only their subjects. Saying that both plays show people losing out to economic change compares content. Saying that Miller makes the audience share the loser’s point of view while Chekhov makes it watch the winner’s joy and the loser’s silence at once compares method. Criterion B rewards the second, because it explains how each work presents the issue.
Ending on the issue
The last minute of the oral is where many talks lose what they have built. Tired, and aware of the clock, the speaker summarizes, with a sentence such as So, to finish, both plays show the effects of economic change. The summary repeats what the listener has just heard and adds nothing. A strong ending does something different. It brings the two analyses together into a judgment about the issue that neither work, alone, would have produced.
That judgment is a synthesis. In the plan for this oral, it might be that neither play allows a simple villain. Howard is shallow but not cruel, and Lopakhin is the winner but weeps in the same speech as he boasts (line 16). Both plays place the cost of change on the old: Willy, who cannot sell any more, and Fiers, who is left in the locked house. Together the two works suggest that economic change is presented as something nobody controls and the weakest pay for, a claim about the issue that comes from setting the two methods side by side.
Weak: So, to finish, both Death of a Salesman and The Cherry Orchard show how economic change affects people, and they both show that it can have very negative effects on people’s lives.note 1 Thank you for listening.note 2
Strong: Miller asks the audience to feel what Willy loses; Chekhov asks it to hold Lopakhin’s joy and Lubov’s silence in one room.note 3 Set side by side, the two plays answer my issue in the same way from opposite ends. The people an economy leaves behind are partly responsible, Willy for his dream and the family for ignoring Lopakhin’s advice, but the cost still falls on the oldest and weakest, Willy and Fiers, who can least change.note 4
Summary. The sentence repeats the topic and adds an evaluation (“very negative”) that any work about economic change would support. Nothing in it needs these two plays.
A courtesy, not an ending. Thanking the listener is harmless, but it replaces the last sentence of argument with nothing.
The two methods compared. The first sentence states the difference in method in one line each.
A synthesis that answers the issue. The judgment takes both halves of the question (victims or to blame) and answers them with evidence from both works. It needed the comparison to exist.
The strong ending is about 75 words, roughly half a minute of speech. It names no new evidence and tells no more plot. Every element in it comes from the talk, but the combination is new, which is what makes the listener feel that the ten minutes have arrived somewhere.
Speaking from an outline, not a script
An oral read from a script is easy to recognize. The sentences are long and written, the speed is even, the eyes stay down, and the talk cannot adjust when time runs short. It also tends to lose marks on criterion D, which rewards fluent and natural speech, and on criterion C, because a script cannot respond to the clock. The oral outline exists to prevent this: it holds the plan, and the speaker supplies the sentences.
Speaking from an outline feels risky at first, because the words are not fixed. The risk shrinks with rehearsal. The aim of rehearsing is not to memorize a text but to have said each part of the talk several times, in slightly different words each time, so that the ideas come back in order when the keywords appear. A student who has given the talk five times from the outline speaks with the ease of someone explaining a reading they know well, which is exactly what the oral rewards.
A way to rehearse
Rehearse in stages. First, talk through each extract on its own with a timer, aiming for about two and a half minutes, and note where you run long. Next, give each half of the talk, extract and work, and check that both halves take about the same time. Then give the whole ten minutes from the outline alone, recording it on a phone. Listen to the recording once for the plan (can a listener tell where each part begins?) and once for the language (which filler words recur, which terms are used loosely?).
Two further rehearsals help most. One is in front of another student who has not read the works, who can say afterward what the issue was and how the two works differed; if they cannot, the signposting needs work. The other is a rehearsal in which you deliberately run long in the first half and then cut, so that the cut is practiced before it is needed. Your learner portfolio is a good place to keep the recordings and your notes on each, since they show how the talk developed.
Common faults in the ten minutes
The faults that cost most marks in the ten minutes are faults of planning, and each has a direct correction. The table gives each fault as it might sound in an oral on Miller and Chekhov, then the correction.
Fault | As it sounds | Corrected |
|---|---|---|
A long introduction on context | Two minutes on Miller’s life, the American economy after the war and the Russian emancipation of the serfs. | One sentence of context per work, inside an introduction that states the issue and the line of argument in under a minute. |
A first work that takes seven minutes | At minute seven, still on Willy: “I’ll go quickly through Chekhov now.” | A cut planned at home (point 3 shrinks to a sentence) and a check of the clock at 4:30. |
Extracts without works | Ten minutes inside the two scenes. | One minute per work beyond the extract, following one feature (Lopakhin’s axe, Willy’s worth) to the ending. |
Works without extracts | The whole plot of each play, with the extracts mentioned once. | About two thirds of each half spent in the extract, with line numbers. |
Signposts with no content | “Now I will move on to my second play.” | “Miller keeps the loser at the center; in my second extract the man who speaks most has won.” |
An ending that summarizes | “So both plays show that economic change affects people.” | A synthesis that answers both halves of the issue from both works. |
Most of these faults can be heard in a single recorded rehearsal, which is the best reason to make one early. A student who listens back and notices that the first work took six minutes can rebalance the plan in an evening. The same discovery made in the oral itself costs marks that cannot be recovered.
The ten minutes end with the teacher’s questions, which follow at once and count toward the same four criteria. They are a chance to extend the talk: to go back to a line, bring in another moment of a work, or defend the synthesis against another reading.
Self-check
- To do:
I can plan a ten-minute oral one work at a time, and say when an integrated structure would work better.
- To do:
I can write a timed plan that gives each work about three and a half minutes and keeps a minute and a half for the comparison.
- To do:
I can write an oral outline of about ten points made of keywords and line numbers, with a planned cut in each half.
- To do:
I can connect a feature of an extract to the structure or ending of its whole work.
- To do:
I can use opening, turning and closing signposts that state the argument as well as the order.
- To do:
I can refer to lines aloud with brief quotations and line numbers.
- To do:
I can end on the issue with a synthesis of both works rather than a summary.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.
- Signposting
Words that tell a listener or reader where an argument is and where it is going next, such as a statement of the plan or a phrase that marks a turn to the second work. In speech it does the work that headings and paragraph breaks do on the page.
- Synthesis
The bringing together of two separate analyses into one judgment that neither reaches alone. In a comparison it states what the two works, read side by side, show about an issue or a method.
Internal assessment for English A Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutesThis page
- 4The five minutes of questions
- 5An oral at each band
HL essay
- 6The HL essayHL only
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
More IB English A Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.