- Subjects
- English A Lit
- An HL essay at each band
An HL essay at each band
Three complete HL essays on Pride and Prejudice, at the high, middle and low bands, with marks and comments on each criterion, and what separates them from the line of inquiry onward.
- IB English A: Literature
- Internal assessment
- HL only
Three HL essays on the same novel can earn widely different marks, and most of the difference is decided by the question each one asks. The three essays that follow are all on Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice (1813), and all quote the George Allen edition of 1894. The strongest of them is built around chapter 36, in which Elizabeth Bennet rereads the letter Mr. Darcy has given her the day after she refused his proposal, and finds that she has misjudged both him and Mr. Wickham:
The four paragraphs move from Elizabeth’s shame to her own exclamation and back into the narrator’s reporting of her thoughts. Her speech is in quotation marks, but the paragraphs around it are not, and they are still full of her. The question “How could she deny that credit to his assertions, in one instance, which she had been obliged to give in the other?” (paragraph 3) is her own question, asked in the narrator’s sentence. An essay that notices this has found a method to analyze, and the high-band essay does.
Three lines of inquiry
Before reading the essays, it helps to set their lines of inquiry side by side, because the rest follows from them. The diagram shows the three questions and what each makes possible. The high essay’s line names a method (free indirect discourse), a stretch of the novel (the chapters after the letter) and a concern (how the reader comes to share Elizabeth’s self-correction). The middle essay’s line names a method of a kind (three marriages) and a concern (Austen’s view), but it is wide enough to be answered by describing the marriages one at a time. The low essay’s title is a topic and asks nothing.


The arrows in the diagram are the point. A line that names a method and a concern gives an essay a sequence of steps, because the method can be traced through several moments and the concern can deepen as it goes. A line that names three examples gives an essay three sections, and they tend to stay separate. A topic gives an essay nothing to answer, so it fills its length with what it knows about the subject, which in Pride and Prejudice means the plot and the history of marriage in Austen’s England.
Each essay is shown in full, with margin comments that name the criterion and give a verdict, and with a mark and a reason for each criterion. Between the essays, short sections say what separates them, so that the comparison can be followed without reading every line.
The high-band essay
The first essay takes the line of inquiry built on chapter 36 and follows it across the novel, from the first ball in chapter 3 to Elizabeth’s joke about Pemberley in chapter 59. In it, every topic sentence makes a claim that depends on the one before it, and the quotations come from many chapters. The essay quotes the passage from chapter 36, but most of its evidence comes from other chapters, chosen because each one marks a stage in the reader’s relation to Elizabeth.
The essay earns 17 of 20. Its strongest criterion is B. It analyzes narrative method at the level of a single phrase (“handsomer than ever”), a sentence’s syntax (the clauses that build Elizabeth’s case against herself) and a shift of mode (from reported thought to speech). Then it evaluates the method by showing that it produces irony as well as sympathy. That last step is what lifts analysis into evaluation: the essay weighs what the method does well against what it also does, rather than praising it.
Under C the essay develops in the sense the criterion means. The first section establishes that the error was shared, the second that the correction is performed by the reader, the third that the recognition becomes a process, and the fourth that it remains incomplete. Each section needs the last. What keeps C at 4 is the essay’s edges: an opening sentence spent on a definition, and a conclusion that repeats the thesis before adding its final point.
Under A, one sentence overreaches. Calling Elizabeth’s outburst “the climax of the whole novel’s argument” may be true, but the essay never compares it with the ending, so the claim is asserted rather than shown. A mark of 4 rather than 5 reflects that one unsupported claim in an otherwise exact interpretation. Criterion D is strong throughout, with quotations integrated and every citation in one form, and loses a mark only for formulas such as the stock phrase that opens its last paragraph.
The middle-band essay
The second essay asks a sound question and answers it with accurate knowledge. Its line names a method of a kind, three marriages set side by side, and a concern, Austen’s view of marriage. The difficulty is that the line can be answered by describing each marriage in turn and then stating a view, and that is what the essay does. It analyzes well in places, and elsewhere it summarizes or adds another example.
The essay earns 11 of 20. Its two best moments are genuine analysis: the connotations of “preservative”, and the balanced syntax of “the advantage of both”, read as part of the sentence’s meaning. Those moments are what a middle-band essay usually has: real skill, used occasionally. Between them, features are named with general effects (“a list of adjectives which emphasizes”), and at the moment where the narrator’s irony would have helped the essay most, at Pemberley, the sentence is read straight.
The mark that most separates this essay from the high one is C. Its sections are a list. “The first marriage”, “Another marriage”, “The third marriage”: the words that open each section say that the sections are interchangeable, and they are. Mr. and Mrs. Bennet are added halfway through as a fourth example, which shows the essay collecting evidence instead of building a case. The conclusion then repeats the three sections in order, and the answer at the end is the answer given at the start.
Under A, the thesis is accurate but predictable, and much of the essay’s length goes on summary that a reader of the novel already knows. Under D the writing is clear, but citation changes form from paragraph to paragraph, the list at the end names no edition, and the conclusion slides into a generalization about today. Each of these faults is small, and together they hold A and D at 3.
The low-band essay
The third essay has a topic for a title, and everything that follows comes from that choice. With no question to answer, it fills its length with what its writer knows about the subject: the history of marriage in Regency England, the facts of Austen’s life and the plot of the novel. Where it touches the text, each moment turns back quickly into summary or context.
The essay earns 6 of 20, and its faults follow from its title. Without a line of inquiry, the introduction becomes a history lesson, the second paragraph becomes biography, and the body follows the plot from Netherfield to the weddings. At about 1,000 words, it also falls short of the 1,200 to 1,500 the task sets, and much of its length is context and summary. Its two worst errors are misreadings, and both come from not looking closely at the words. The novel’s ironic first sentence is taken as the narrator’s sincere statement, and Charlotte’s view of marriage is quoted as Austen’s own, when the novel goes on to test it.
Even here there is a moment worth building on. The essay notices the sentence about being “mistress of Pemberley”, which is exactly the sentence the high essay analyzes. It reads it as proof that Elizabeth is greedy, which the rest of the novel contradicts, but the instinct to stop at that sentence was sound. With a question about how the narration presents Elizabeth’s motives, the same student could have turned that instinct into analysis.
What separates the bands
The three essays can now be compared criterion by criterion. The chart sets out their marks side by side. The widest gaps are on B and C, the criteria that reward what an essay does with its knowledge; the narrowest are on A and D, where even the low essay earns something for knowing the plot and writing clearly. In these three essays, the shortfall lies in analysis and development more than in knowledge or language.


A: what the knowledge is used for
All three writers know the novel. The low essay knows its plot and its history; the middle essay knows which scenes concern marriage; the high essay knows which sentences show the narration at work, in chapters far apart. The difference under A is the use of that knowledge. The high essay’s interpretation, that the reader shares Elizabeth’s errors and then her correction, could only come from its line of inquiry. The middle essay’s view, that a good marriage needs love and sense, is true but could be reached without reading closely. The low essay offers two views that contradict each other and supports neither from the text.
B: features named, explained, evaluated
Under B the three essays sit on three steps. The low essay quotes and then paraphrases, so features are not even named. The middle essay names features and twice explains them well, with “preservative” and “the advantage of both”. The high essay explains features in every section and then evaluates the method as a whole: free indirect discourse creates sympathy and irony at once, and the essay shows both. The step from explaining to evaluating is the step from a 3 or 4 to a 5.
C: a list, a summary, or a sequence
Under C the line of inquiry shows most clearly. The high essay’s sections form a sequence in which each depends on the last, so they cannot be reordered. The middle essay’s sections form a list of three marriages, so they could be read in any order. The low essay’s paragraphs follow the plot, so their order is the novel’s, not the essay’s. The pair that follows rewrites one of the middle essay’s topic sentences so that it develops instead of listing.
Weak: Another marriage in the novel is between Lydia and Wickham.note 1
Strong: Charlotte’s marriage shows what happens when feeling is left out entirely; Lydia’s shows the opposite failure, a marriage made of nothing but impulse, and Austen lets the reader see that it is held together, in the end, by the money Charlotte at least understood.note 2
A second item. “Another” tells the examiner that the section adds an example. Nothing in the sentence depends on what the Charlotte section found.
A further step. The sentence carries forward the first section’s finding, sets Lydia against it, and makes a claim (money holds even this marriage together) that the section can now prove from Darcy’s payment.
The rewritten sentence does not need new evidence. It uses facts the middle essay already has, Darcy’s payment of Wickham’s debts among them, and puts them in a relation to what came before. Development is often a matter of rewriting topic sentences, not of finding more material.
D: clarity and convention
Under D the differences are smaller but easy to see. All three essays are clear enough to follow. The high essay cites every quotation in one form and lists its edition. The middle essay changes its form of citation within a paragraph and lists no edition, and the low essay cites in three forms and sometimes not at all, and its list names a website without details. Register follows the same pattern: the high essay’s few formulas cost it one mark, while the low essay’s closing remarks about how “funny” the novel is drift out of the essay’s register altogether.
Try it
Rewrite the low essay’s title, Marriage and money in Pride and Prejudice, as a line of inquiry that its writer could answer using the moments it already notices (the first sentence, Charlotte’s remark about chance, the sentence about Pemberley).
One possible line: How does Austen’s narrator use irony, from the first sentence to Elizabeth’s view of Pemberley, to show the pull of money on characters who claim to marry for other reasons? The line keeps the writer’s topic (marriage and money), adds a method (the narrator’s irony) and points to three moments the essay already found. It would also force the writer to read the first sentence as irony, which removes the essay’s worst misreading.
Using the exemplars on your own draft
The exemplars are most useful when you hold your own draft beside them. Begin with a reverse outline: write one sentence stating the point of each of your paragraphs, and read the sentences without the paragraphs. Compare the result with the three essays. If your sentences read like the high essay’s, as steps in which each needs the last, your structure is sound. If they read like the middle essay’s, joined by “another” and “also”, rewrite the topic sentences so that each takes something from the one before. If they follow the plot, return to your line of inquiry, because the problem begins there.
Then read your draft once for each criterion. For A, mark every sentence of summary and ask whether the line needs it. For B, find every quotation and check that the sentence after it explains what its words do. For C, check that the conclusion says something the introduction could not. For D, check every citation against one system and the list at the end. Four readings take an evening, and they find most of what separates a middle-band draft from a high-band essay.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain why three essays on the same novel earn 17, 11 and 6, starting from their lines of inquiry.
- To do:
I can say what distinguishes a high, a middle and a low essay on each of the four criteria.
- To do:
I can tell an essay whose sections develop from one whose sections list or summarize.
- To do:
I can rewrite a topic sentence that adds an example so that it takes a further step.
- To do:
I can turn a topic into a line of inquiry that uses evidence an essay already has.
- To do:
I can revise my own draft by reverse outlining and by reading it once for each criterion.
Internal assessment for English A Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutes
- 4The five minutes of questions
- 5An oral at each band
HL essay
- 6The HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiry
- 8Structuring the HL essay
- 9An HL essay at each bandThis page
Carry on with English A Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.