- Subjects
- English A Lit
- Structuring the HL essay
Structuring the HL essay
How to shape an HL essay: an opening that gives its answer, sections in which each claim builds on the last, integrated quotation, consistent MLA citation, a counterargument and a conclusion that judges.
- IB English A: Literature
- Internal assessment
- HL only
An HL essay is an argument in a fixed space, and its structure is what lets the argument move. In 1,500 words there is room for an introduction, three or four sections and a conclusion, and no room for a paragraph that does not advance the answer. The plan that follows is for an essay on Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights (1847), a novel told almost entirely by two narrators who are not the people the story is about. It begins with the diary of the first:
1801—I have just returned from a visit to my landlord—the solitary neighbour that I shall be troubled with. This is certainly a beautiful country! In all England, I do not believe that I could have fixed on a situation so completely removed from the stir of society. A perfect misanthropist’s Heaven—and Mr. Heathcliff and I are such a suitable pair to divide the desolation between us. A capital fellow!
Emily Brontë, Wuthering Heights (1847), chapter 1
Lockwood, a gentleman from the south who has rented the house called Thrushcross Grange, decides within a paragraph that his landlord is “a capital fellow!” and his own kind of solitary. Heathcliff has hardly spoken, and he is not glad of the visit. The opening tells the reader that the first judge of Heathcliff is a poor one. A student who notices this has found the start of a line of inquiry: How does the nested narration of Lockwood and Nelly Dean shape the reader’s judgment of Heathcliff?
The work and its frames
Wuthering Heights is a frame narrative with frames inside frames. Lockwood writes the outer narrative as a diary of his winter in Yorkshire. Most of the story reaches him from Nelly Dean, the housekeeper, who served both families for most of her life and tells him their history over several evenings. Inside Nelly’s account are further voices: speeches she remembers, a letter she reads aloud. The diagram sets out the levels and shows where each voice sits.


The diagram already suggests the essay’s shape. Its sections can move inward through the frames, from Lockwood to Nelly to the words of Heathcliff himself. They can then test the answer on the one document that escapes Nelly: the diary Catherine wrote as a girl in the margins of her books, which Lockwood reads on his first night at the Heights. That order is not the order of the plot. It follows the argument, which grows more precise at each level and is ready to be tested by the time it reaches the diary.
The introduction
The introduction has four jobs, and in an essay of 1,500 words it does them in about 100 to 150 words. It states the line of inquiry, either as the essay’s title or in its opening sentences. It names the work and the edition the essay quotes from. It gives the answer in brief: the essay’s thesis, a claim someone could dispute. And it maps the argument, so that the examiner knows the order of the steps before taking them. A model introduction for the plan on Wuthering Heights follows.
How does the nested narration of Lockwood and Nelly Dean shape the reader’s judgment of Heathcliff?note 1
Nearly everything the reader learns about Heathcliff in Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights (1847) reaches them through two narrators, Lockwood and Nelly Dean, neither of whom is neutral.note 2 This essay argues that the frame does not make judging Heathcliff impossible but makes every judgment provisional:note 3 the novel first shows its outer narrator misreading him, then lets an inner narrator judge him as a participant, and delivers his own words only at two removes. A diary that escapes Nelly’s telling shows how much the frame withholds, and how much a reader must reconstruct.note 4
The line as title. The question is stated exactly, so every later paragraph can be measured against it.
The work, and the method in brief. One sentence names the novel, its date and the feature the essay analyzes. The edition goes in the works-cited list.
The answer. The thesis is a claim of degree (judgment is possible but provisional) that a reader could dispute.
The map. The last two sentences give the order of the sections, inward through the frames and then outward to a counterexample.
The introduction is 108 words with its title, which leaves the body almost all of the limit. It contains no biography of Emily Brontë, no history of the Yorkshire moors and no summary of the plot. An examiner reading it knows the question, the answer and the route, and can judge every later paragraph by whether it takes the next step on that route.
Context earns a place in the introduction only in the rare case where the line of inquiry depends on it, and even then a clause is usually enough. The introduction for Wuthering Heights needs none, because the frame it asks about is in the novel itself.
Sections that develop
The body of an HL essay is three or four sections, each one or two paragraphs long. What makes the essay developed rather than merely organized is the relation between them. A section that offers another example of the same point adds weight without adding thought. A section that takes a further step changes the answer: it narrows it, extends it, explains it or tests it, so that the essay knows more at the end of the section than at its start.
The staircase sets out the plan for the essay on Wuthering Heights, one step for each part, with the claim each step adds. Read from the bottom, it shows the argument rising: each claim depends on the one below it, and the counterargument (orange) is placed where the answer is strong enough to be tested.


The plan, section by section
Section 1 begins at the outer frame. Lockwood’s first judgment of Heathcliff is wrong, and so are his next ones. On his second visit he admires a cushion “full of something like cats”, and the narration corrects him at once: “Unluckily, it was a heap of dead rabbits” (ch. 2). He takes the young woman of the house for Heathcliff’s wife, then for the wife of Hareton. The section’s claim is that the novel teaches its reader, in three chapters, to treat its narrators’ verdicts as evidence about the narrators.
Section 2 moves inward to Nelly, who knows far more than Lockwood but judged Heathcliff as someone who took part in his story. Her first description of him as a child calls him “it”, and she admits to putting him “on the landing of the stairs, hoping it might be gone on the morrow” (ch. 4). The section argues that Nelly’s honesty about her early hostility makes her more credible and, for the same reason, harder to trust: her judgments come from inside the history she tells.
Section 3 reaches Heathcliff’s own words and finds that they arrive at two removes. His most violent speech, “I have no pity! I have no pity!” (ch. 14), and his most desperate, “I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!” (ch. 16), both reach Lockwood through Nelly’s memory of scenes years old. The frame gives the reader Heathcliff at his extremes. The section’s step is to ask what is missing between them, and to set his late, quiet admission that his revenge is “a poor conclusion” (ch. 33) against the speeches that made him monstrous.
Section 4 tests the answer on the one early voice that escapes Nelly. Catherine’s diary, scrawled in the margins of her books and read by Lockwood on his first night, calls Hindley “a detestable substitute” for their father and says his “conduct to Heathcliff is atrocious” (ch. 3). Here the boy is a fellow rebel and a victim, seen by someone who loved him. The section weighs this against the darkest reading of Heathcliff, and the conclusion can then state how far the frame shapes judgment.
A model section
The paragraph that follows is section 2 as a strong student might write it. Its notes say what each sentence does, and the paragraph is the right length for its share of the essay.
Nelly Dean knows far more than Lockwood, but she judged Heathcliff from inside the story she tells, and the novel lets her admit it.note 1 Her first description of him is of “a dirty, ragged, black-haired child”, and for a page she calls him “it” (ch. 4). The pronoun is hers as well as the family’s, since she confesses that she “put it on the landing of the stairs, hoping it might be gone on the morrow.”note 2 Brontë could have given the history to a narrator who stood outside it. Instead she chose a servant who “plagued” the boy alongside Hindley, and who calls her own behavior “cowardice and inhumanity” (ch. 4).note 3 The confession makes Nelly more credible, because she does not hide her bias, and at the same time less reliable, because a reader now knows that her judgments of the adult Heathcliff come from someone who wronged the child.note 4 Nelly’s account therefore cannot settle what Heathcliff is; it can only show what he became to the people around him, which is why his own words, when they reach the reader, carry such weight.note 5
A topic sentence that moves the argument. It builds on section 1 (Lockwood knows little) and states the new step (Nelly knows much, as a participant).
Integrated quotation, closely read. The quoted words run inside the student’s own sentence, and the analysis turns on one small word, “it”.
A choice the writer made. Naming the narrator Brontë did not choose makes the choice visible. The citation is by chapter, as in every section.
Development by qualification. The paragraph holds two effects together (credible and unreliable) instead of settling for one.
A link forward. The last sentence names the limit that section 3 will address, so the reader expects the next step.
The paragraph is 185 words, which suits a section of 250 to 300 words in an essay of 1,500. Its quotations are short and all from one chapter, and each is analyzed in the sentence that quotes it. It ends with a link, not a summary, so the section hands the essay on to the next.
A word budget
A plan with lengths attached keeps the essay inside the limit and stops one section swallowing the others. The budget in the table is a guide for an essay of five parts. An essay with three body sections gives each a little more.
Part | Words | What it does |
|---|---|---|
Introduction | 100–150 | States the line, the work and the answer; maps the route |
Section 1 | 250–300 | Lockwood’s misreadings: the frame’s verdicts are evidence about the teller |
Section 2 | 250–300 | Nelly’s partiality: a participant’s judgment, admitted |
Section 3 | 250–300 | Heathcliff at two removes: what the frame selects |
Section 4 | 250–300 | Catherine’s diary and the darkest reading: the answer tested |
Conclusion | 100–150 | A judgment of degree; what the inquiry has shown |
The budget totals between 1,200 and 1,500 words, which is the point of writing it down. A first draft will break it, usually in the first section, where students write the most because they are still finding their argument. The revision brings each part back to its share.
Integrating quotation
An HL essay quotes from the text in front of you, so its quotations can be exact and short. The usual form is the integrated quotation: a few words of the text worked into the grammar of your own sentence, so that the quotation and the analysis read as one. The model paragraph on Nelly quotes five times and never lets a quotation stand alone. Each one is a phrase inside a sentence that says what it shows.
Two sentences on the same late moment in Wuthering Heights show the difference. Near the end of the novel Heathcliff, who has spent many years taking revenge on two families, tells Nelly that he has lost the wish to finish it.
“It is a poor conclusion, is it not?” he observed, having brooded a while on the scene he had just witnessed: “an absurd termination to my violent exertions?”
Emily Brontë, Wuthering Heights, chapter 33
Weak: Heathcliff changes at the end of the novel. “It is a poor conclusion, is it not?” This shows he is different now.note 1
Strong: Heathcliff calls his own revenge “a poor conclusion” and “an absurd termination” (ch. 33), judging his life in the language of a story that has ended badly. Coming from the man the frame has shown at his most violent, the words ask the reader to revise a verdict the narrators had seemed to settle.note 2
A dropped quotation. The quotation stands alone between two sentences of summary, and “This shows he is different” explains nothing about its words.
Integrated and analyzed. Two short phrases run inside the student’s sentence, the citation follows, and the second sentence says what the words do to the essay’s line of inquiry.
The strong version quotes fewer words and gets more from them. It notices that conclusion and termination are words for the ending of a narrative, which connects Heathcliff’s speech to the essay’s concern with how the novel tells his story. A quotation chosen for one or two words that can be analyzed is almost always better than a whole sentence quoted for its general sense.
Block quotation
A block quotation is a long quotation set apart from the essay’s paragraph, indented, without quotation marks. In MLA style it is used for more than four lines of prose or more than three lines of verse, and the citation follows its last punctuation mark. In an essay of 1,500 words a block quotation is rarely justified, because it spends a large share of the limit on words that are not yours. Use one only when the essay analyzes the passage closely, phrase by phrase, in the paragraph that follows it.
Changing a quotation honestly
A quotation can be shortened or fitted to your sentence, provided every change is marked. An ellipsis (…) marks words left out: Heathcliff cries, “I have no pity! … The more the worms writhe, the more I yearn to crush out their entrails!” (ch. 14). Square brackets show words you have added or changed so that the sentence makes sense: Catherine writes that “[Hindley’s] conduct to Heathcliff is atrocious” (ch. 3), where the novel has his. Neither may change the meaning of the original. An ellipsis that drops a not, or brackets that put a word into a character’s mouth, misrepresent the text.
Citing the work and your sources
A citation tells the reader exactly where a quotation or a borrowed idea comes from, at the point where you use it. In an HL essay every quotation from the work is cited, and so is every quotation from or idea taken from a secondary source. Citations let the examiner check your evidence, and they are part of the academic conventions that criterion D rewards.
Several citation systems are in use, and your school may prefer one. MLA style, set out by the Modern Language Association, is the system most often used for essays on literature, and the examples here follow it. What matters more than the choice of system is using one system consistently, from the first citation to the last entry of the list.
In-text citation
MLA style puts a short reference in brackets after the quotation, before the full stop. For a novel it gives the author’s surname and the page of the edition you name: (Brontë 47). Because novels exist in many editions, adding the chapter helps any reader find the passage: (Brontë 47; ch. 4). When the author is already named in your sentence, or when the essay is about one work only, the page or chapter alone is enough. The plan for Wuthering Heights uses chapters alone, because its edition is an online text without page numbers.
Plays and poems are cited by their own divisions, not by pages. A verse play is cited by act, scene and line, separated by full stops: Macbeth 2.1.33 means Act 2, scene 1, line 33. A poem is cited by line numbers. A work read in translation is cited under its author, and the translator is named in the list at the end.
The works-cited list
The works cited list at the end of the essay gives the full details of every source the essay cites, in alphabetical order by surname, each entry with a hanging indent. It names the edition of the work you quote, so that page numbers mean something. The annotated list that follows shows three kinds of entry: a novel in an online edition, a translated play in a collection, and a secondary source.
Brontë, Charlotte. “Editor’s Preface to the New Edition of Wuthering Heights.” Wuthering Heights, by Emily Brontë, Smith, Elder, 1850.note 1
Brontë, Emily. Wuthering Heights. 1847. Project Gutenberg, 1996, www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/768.note 2
Sophocles. Antigone. Sophocles, translated by F. Storr, vol. 1, William Heinemann, 1912.note 3
A secondary source in a book. The preface’s title is in quotation marks, and the book that contains it is in italics, with its author after “by”. A print copy would end the entry with the preface’s page range (pp.), which the essay’s citation would use as well.
The primary source, online. The original year, then the site in italics, the year it was posted and the address. Entries are alphabetical, so the two Brontës are ordered by first name.
A translated work in a collection. The translator is named after the collection’s title, so the reader knows whose English is being quoted.
The list usually does not count toward the word limit, and neither do the citations in brackets; check with your teacher how your school applies the rule. The list must still be complete. A source that shaped your argument and is missing from the list is a breach of academic integrity, however small its part in the essay.
Try it
A draft quotes from chapters 4, 14 and 33 of the novel and cites them in three different ways: “(page 47)”, “(Brontë, chapter fourteen)” and “(WH, 33)”. Rewrite the three citations in one consistent MLA form, assuming the essay quotes the Gutenberg edition, which has no page numbers.
All three become chapter citations in the same form: (ch. 4), (ch. 14) and (ch. 33), since the essay is about one work by one author. If the essay also quoted Charlotte Brontë’s preface, the author’s name would be needed to tell the two apart: (E. Brontë, ch. 4). The point is consistency. The examiner should never have to work out which edition or which system a citation uses, and an abbreviation such as “WH” is never used unless the essay has said what it stands for.
Counterargument inside the essay
An answer is more convincing once it has been tested against the strongest reading that disagrees with it. A strong HL essay gives one section, usually the last before the conclusion, to the best case against its own answer, and shows how far the answer survives. The point is not to collapse the argument at the end. It is to find the limit of the answer, so that the conclusion can state it with the right degree of confidence.
For the essay on Wuthering Heights two kinds of challenge are available. One is a voice inside the novel that escapes the frame: Catherine’s childhood diary. The other is a reader who has judged Heathcliff without hesitation. Charlotte Brontë, writing a preface for a new edition of her sister’s novel in 1850, gave a verdict with no doubt in it:
Heathcliff, indeed, stands unredeemed; never once swerving in his arrow-straight course to perdition
Charlotte Brontë, “Editor’s Preface to the New Edition of Wuthering Heights” (1850)
A verdict as sure as this is a useful opponent, because the essay argues that the frame makes judgment provisional. Section 4 can set the preface against the diary and against Heathcliff’s late words, and decide which the novel supports. The model that follows does that in one paragraph.
The frame does not leave the reader without other evidence, and the one early voice that bypasses Nelly points away from her verdict.note 1 Catherine’s diary, read by Lockwood in her old room, records the boy as a fellow rebel: Hindley is “a detestable substitute” for their father, and his “conduct to Heathcliff is atrocious” (ch. 3).note 2 Charlotte Brontë’s preface of 1850 judged that Heathcliff “stands unredeemed; never once swerving in his arrow-straight course to perdition” (C. Brontë).note 3 The diary and the late chapters make that verdict hard to hold: a child described as wronged by someone who loved him, and a man who calls his own revenge “a poor conclusion” (ch. 33), have both swerved.note 4 Yet the preface shows what the frame makes possible. A reader who trusts Nelly’s darker scenes can reach Charlotte’s judgment honestly, which suggests that the narration does not decide the verdict; it decides how much of the evidence each reader is willing to weigh.note 5
A topic sentence that turns. The section opens by admitting the limit of the frame, which is the step after section 3.
Evidence from outside Nelly’s telling. The diary is quoted briefly and cited by chapter.
A secondary source, cited. The preface is quoted once, with a citation that tells it apart from the novel, and the essay takes its verdict seriously.
The answer tested. The student uses two pieces of evidence from the novel against the critic, and the word “swerved” turns the critic’s own image against her.
Development by concession. The student does not simply defeat the critic, and the answer becomes more precise: the frame governs which evidence a reader weighs.
The counterargument section has done more than defend the thesis. It has refined it, from “the frame makes judgment provisional” to a claim about what the frame actually controls. That refinement is what the conclusion now states, and it is why the counterargument belongs near the end: earlier, the essay would not yet have had an answer worth testing.
The conclusion
The conclusion answers the line of inquiry with a judgment of degree. To a large extent, only partly, in one sense but not another: the answer says how far, because the essay has shown both the strength and the limit of its claim. It brings in no new evidence, since a new quotation in the last paragraph is a point the essay never made. And it says what the inquiry has shown about the work, which is more than a summary of what each section said.
The nested narration of Wuthering Heights shapes the reader’s judgment of Heathcliff to a large extent, but it does not fix it.note 1 By opening on a narrator who misreads everything and then handing the story to one who helped to wrong the boy, the novel makes its own tellers the first thing a reader must judge.note 2 What the frame controls is the evidence: Heathcliff is heard mostly at his extremes, and his gentler side arrives late, or at second hand from the margins of a child’s books.note 3 A reader can still reach a verdict, as Charlotte Brontë did; what the novel asks is that the verdict be built, piece by piece, from testimony that is never neutral.note 4
A judgment of degree. “To a large extent, but it does not fix it” answers the line exactly, with its limit.
The argument in one movement. The sections are not listed; their combined effect is stated.
The refinement from section 4. The conclusion states what the counterargument found: the frame controls the evidence.
What the inquiry has shown. The last sentence says something about how the novel works, which the introduction could not yet say.
Drafting and revising
The first full draft of an HL essay is a way of finding out what you think, and it is rarely the essay you submit. The most useful tool for revising it is the reverse outline: after drafting, write one sentence that states the point of each paragraph, then read the sentences in order without the paragraphs. The outline shows at once whether the argument develops, whether two paragraphs make the same point, and whether the conclusion answers the question the introduction asked.
Revision also means cutting. Most first drafts run long, and the words that go first are summary, repeated points and quotations longer than their analysis. A last pass then checks the mechanics: the word count, every quotation against the edition, every citation in one form, and every source in the list.
Four faults, corrected
Four faults of structure appear in HL essays more than any others, and each has been met in the plan above. A long introduction on context gives the argument less room; it is cut to the line, the work and the answer. Sections in plot order retell the work; they are reordered by the steps of the argument. Quotations dropped in without analysis earn nothing; they are shortened and worked into sentences that say what they do. Inconsistent citation looks careless; it is put into one system before submission.
The structure set out for Wuthering Heights can be seen at work, and at fault, in complete essays. Three HL essays on Pride and Prejudice, at the high, middle and low bands, show what separates a developed argument from a list of evidence and from a summary, with marks on each criterion.
Self-check
- To do:
I can write an introduction of 100 to 150 words that states the line of inquiry, names the work and gives a thesis and a route.
- To do:
I can plan sections in which each claim is a further step from the last, and order them by the argument rather than the plot.
- To do:
I can integrate short quotations into my sentences, and use ellipsis and square brackets without changing the meaning.
- To do:
I can cite the work and any sources in one consistent system, and set out a works-cited list in MLA style.
- To do:
I can write a section of counterargument that tests my answer and makes it more precise.
- To do:
I can write a conclusion that answers the line of inquiry with a judgment of degree and adds no new evidence.
- To do:
I can revise a draft by reverse outlining, merging, cutting and reordering paragraphs.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.
- Block quotation HL only
A long quotation set apart from the paragraph as an indented block, without quotation marks, with its citation after the final punctuation. It is kept for passages the essay goes on to analyze closely.
- Citation HL only
A short reference at the point where a quotation or borrowed idea is used, telling the reader exactly where it comes from, such as a page, chapter or line number. Each citation points to an entry in the works-cited list.
- MLA style HL only
A system for citing sources set out by the Modern Language Association and widely used for essays on literature. It places short references in brackets in the text and lists full details of the sources at the end.
- Works cited HL only
The list at the end of an essay that gives the full details of every source the essay cites, including the edition of the work it quotes, in alphabetical order by author.
Internal assessment for English A Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutes
- 4The five minutes of questions
- 5An oral at each band
HL essay
- 6The HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiry
- 8Structuring the HL essayThis page
- 9An HL essay at each band
More IB English A Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.