- Subjects
- English A Lit
- An oral at each band
An oral at each band
Three complete individual orals on Douglass’s Narrative and Sophocles’ Antigone, at the high, middle and low bands, with outlines, transcripts, comments and marks, and what separates them on each criterion.
- IB English A: Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
Three students give an individual oral on the same global issue, using the same two extracts. Their marks differ by more than twenty points. Because the works, the extracts and the issue are shared, every difference between the three orals lies in what the student does with them. The differences are in how precisely the issue is stated, how closely the extracts are read, how the time is divided and how the questions are answered.
The first work is the Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845), written in English by a man who had escaped from slavery in Maryland seven years before. The extract comes from chapter VII, in which Douglass describes how he learned to read in Baltimore after his mistress was forbidden to teach him.
The second work is Sophocles’ Antigone, first performed in Athens in about 441 BCE and read here in F. Storr’s verse translation of 1912. The extract is the opening scene. Antigone tells her sister Ismene that Creon, the new ruler of Thebes, has forbidden anyone to bury their brother Polyneices, and asks her to help do it.
The pair and the issue
The issue the three students share comes from the field of politics, power and justice. Stated precisely, it asks whether conscience can justify breaking a law, and who bears the cost when someone does. It is a question societies still argue about, whenever people refuse a law they believe unjust, and both works take part in the argument. Each extract shows a person deciding to break a law: Douglass learning to read, Antigone resolving to bury her brother. Each work then follows the decision to its cost.
The pairing meets the rule for the oral’s works in Literature. Douglass’s Narrative is a work originally written in English, read in the words Douglass chose. Antigone is a work in translation, read in Storr’s English, so any comment on a single word in it is a comment on a translator’s choice. The works also differ in nearly every other way, which gives a comparison plenty to find. One is prose non-fiction, a slave narrative written as testimony; the other is a tragedy written for performance. One is told in the first person, years after the events; the other is enacted in dialogue at the moment of choice.
The table sets out what each extract offers for the issue. A strong oral uses two or three features from each column, and connects each extract to a moment from elsewhere in its work.
Douglass, Narrative, chapter VII | Sophocles, Antigone, opening scene | |
|---|---|---|
Who breaks the law | Douglass, and the white boys who teach him (paragraph 3) | Antigone, who asks Ismene to join her (lines 41–48) |
How the law appears | Through its effect on the mistress, whose “tender heart became stone” (paragraph 1); as an “unpardonable” act (paragraph 3) | As a report, three times in brackets (lines 22, 26, 30); its author named with irony, “our most noble Creon” (line 31) |
Features to analyze | Metaphors of transformation (paragraph 1); “the inch” and “the ell” (paragraph 2); “bread of knowledge” (paragraph 3); the names withheld (paragraph 3) | The bracketed reports; the image of the unburied body (lines 28–29); the change to single-line exchanges (lines 39–48); the closing question (line 48) |
The cost, and who pays | Hidden and shared: the boys are protected by anonymity | Open and personal: the penalty is death by stoning (line 36) |
Where the talk moves out | Mr. Auld’s ban in chapter VI; the Sabbath school in chapter X; the escape withheld in chapter XI | Antigone before Creon; Ismene’s refusal; Creon’s ruin at the end |
Both extracts also turn on the same word. Douglass asks the boys, “Have not I as good a right to be free as you have?” (paragraph 3), and Antigone asks, “What right has he to keep me from my own?” (line 48). Each sets a claim of right against a law in the form of a question the law cannot answer. A student who notices that echo has the center of a comparison.
The extracts as students would bring them
The Antigone extract, at 48 lines, is close to the length usually expected for the oral. The Douglass extract is longer: its four paragraphs come to about 870 words, roughly twice the usual guide of about 40 lines of prose. It is printed whole here so that all three orals can be followed, since each uses different parts of it. A student bringing it to a real oral would usually cut it, for example to paragraphs 1 and 3, and should check the length with their teacher.
What separates the bands
The three orals differ before a word of analysis is spoken. The oral outline a student brings, and the first sentence of the talk, already show which band the oral is likely to reach. The three openings that follow are the first sentences of the three talks, and the notes say what each commits the talk to.
High: My global issue is whether conscience can justify breaking a law, and who pays the cost when someone does.note 1
Middle: Today I’m going to talk about the conflict between law and conscience in two works.note 2
Low: My global issue is freedom.note 3
A question with two parts. The issue can be answered differently by each work, and its second half (who pays) gives the talk somewhere to go that a topic would not.
A topic. Law and conscience are the right subject, but “the conflict” asks nothing. The talk can describe the conflict in each work, and that is what it does.
A theme word. Freedom is a subject both works touch, but it is not an issue, and it bends the reading of the second work to fit it.
The diagram sets the three outlines side by side, each point colored by what it does. The high outline states the issue and the argument at its beginning and end, and between them every point names a located choice: a paragraph, a line or a chapter. The middle outline mixes located points with topics and plot, and its order is the order of the works. The low outline is almost all plot, in the order of events, with the theme word at the top.


The outline predicts the oral because a student speaks from it. A point that says Covey, escape produces a minute of plot, however well the student knows the book. A point that says ¶3 bread; names hidden produces analysis of two choices in a paragraph. Rewriting an outline so that each point names a choice and its location is the quickest way to move a practice oral up a band.
On each criterion
On criterion A, all three students know the works. The difference is what the knowledge is used for. The high oral selects details that carry the issue: the names Douglass withholds, the Sabbath school whose host he will not identify, the escape he refuses to describe. The middle oral knows as much but tells most of it as plot, and interprets the issue once, when it notices that the boys break the law. The low oral retells both works and, because its issue is a theme word, misreads Antigone as a play about freedom.
On criterion B, the bands separate most sharply. The high oral analyzes choices small enough to need a line number: slavery as the grammatical subject of a sentence, a law reported three times in brackets, the one-word sentence “Decide”. It also evaluates, weighing the two works’ use of the word “right”. The middle oral identifies features correctly (metaphor, irony, rhetorical question) and usually stops at a general effect, with one real analysis of the irony in line 31. The low oral quotes and then paraphrases.
On criterion C, the high oral states its issue and its line of argument in the first minute and returns to both in a synthesis at the end. Each work gets fair time. The middle oral follows the order of its outline, gives Douglass nearly two thirds of the time spent on the works, and spends stretches on background. The low oral has the simplest plan, one work after the other, runs short and ends by repeating its theme word.
On criterion D, the gap is smaller than on the others, because all three students speak clearly enough to follow. The high oral is fluent and precise, with terms such as stichomythia used accurately. The middle oral is clear but leans on vague evaluative words (“very powerful”, “terrible”). The low oral is conversational (“nice”, “mean”) and hesitates in the questions.
High (34) | Middle (21) | Low (12) | |
|---|---|---|---|
A Knowledge, understanding and interpretation (9, 6, 3) | Selected details from both works interpret the issue | Sound knowledge, mostly as plot; one interpretation | Retelling; the theme word causes a misreading |
B Analysis and evaluation (9, 5, 2) | Grammar, punctuation, imagery and form analyzed; the works weighed | Features named with general effects; one close analysis | Quotations paraphrased |
C Focus and organization (8, 4, 3) | Issue held from first sentence to synthesis; balanced | Topic order; Douglass nearly two thirds of the time; background | Plot order; short; no comparison |
D Language (8, 6, 4) | Fluent, precise terms; some framing words | Clear; vague evaluative words | Conversational; hesitates |
The questions | New evidence, a distinction, a defended reading | Partly extended when prompted; one answer drifts | Short answers; one idea found when prompted |
The high-band oral
The first student states a two-part issue in the first sentence and a line of argument in the third, and every later section tests that argument. Most of its evidence is in the two extracts, read closely by paragraph and line, but each half of the talk also reaches out to two or three precise moments elsewhere in its work. The answers to the questions add evidence the talk did not use.
The oral earns 34 of 40. Its strongest criteria are A and B. Its knowledge of the works is selected for the issue: the boys’ names, the Sabbath school and the withheld escape in Douglass, the speech about the unwritten laws in Antigone. Its analysis reaches choices small enough to be missed by most readers, including the grammatical subject of a sentence in paragraph 1 and the brackets in lines 22 to 30. What keeps B from the full mark is one inaccuracy under time, about where the single-line exchange begins.
Under C, the plan holds from the first sentence to the synthesis, and the time is fair to both works. Two things keep it at 8. The Antigone half ends with a minute of plot, and most of the comparison waits for the end of the talk instead of being planted at the turn between the works. Under D, the student speaks fluently and uses terms precisely, but the language loosens exactly where the argument about form needs it to be exact.
The answers to the teacher’s follow-up questions matter to the mark. In the first, the student finds evidence in lines 10 to 15, which the talk never used, and connects it to the boys in Douglass without being asked. In the third, the student concedes part of a challenge, defends the rest from the play’s ending and finishes with a sharper claim than the talk made. Both answers extend the talk, which is what the five minutes are for.
The middle-band oral
The second student knows both works well and quotes accurately. The difference from the first oral begins with the issue, stated as a topic, and the outline, which follows the order of the works rather than an argument. Analysis does happen in it, and so do stretches of background and plot.
The oral earns 21 of 40. Its knowledge is sound and its best moment, on the boys who break the law, is a real interpretation of the issue. Most of its analysis stops at naming: the metaphor “shows that slavery changed her”, the short lines show “the conflict between them”. Each sentence is accurate, and each could describe many texts. The one place it goes further is the irony of “our most noble Creon” in line 31, where the student explains what the words do to the authority of the law.
The lowest mark is on C. Douglass takes nearly two thirds of the time spent on the works, and the extra time goes to biography and to plot that the issue does not need. The ending joins two summaries with “Similarly” and “However”. In the questions, one answer comes close to the high oral’s central idea, that in Douglass the cost falls on others, and then stops. Another answers a question about the narrator by describing the book’s reception. With the same knowledge, a precise issue and a plan built around it would lift this oral by several marks on A, B and C at once.
The low-band oral
The third student also knows the outline of both works and quotes from both extracts. Almost every weakness of the oral follows from its first sentence. Because the issue is a theme word, the talk has nothing to argue, so it tells the story of each work as a story about freedom. In several places the word forces a reading the text does not support.
The oral earns 12 of 40. Its knowledge of the plots is mostly accurate, and its marks on A come from that. Its analysis is close to absent. Quotations are paraphrased (“which means she became mean”) or used to report what a character feels, and the terms from tragedy are attached to the play as labels. The talk runs about six minutes, and the last of them repeats the theme word.
The questions show what the oral could have been. Asked who breaks the law in Douglass, the student sees for the first time that the boys do, and that this may be why Douglass does not name them. That idea, developed, is the center of the high oral. The student knows the works well enough to have found the idea while preparing, but an issue that asked no question gave the preparation nothing to look for.
The three orals side by side
The chart sets out the marks on each criterion. The high oral is strong on all four. The middle oral is strongest on A and D, where knowledge and clear speech count, and weakest on C, where its plan lets it down. The low oral’s marks are low everywhere, but lowest on B, because analysis is the skill a theme word does least to support.


The widest gap is on B, and the reason can be seen in a single line. All three students quote the same image from paragraph 1 of the Douglass extract, the mistress whose “tender heart became stone”. What each does next is the difference between the bands.
High: Then Douglass makes slavery the subject of the sentence: slavery “proved its ability to divest her of these heavenly qualities”. And there are two images of change, “the tender heart became stone” and the “lamblike disposition” that turns into “tiger-like fierceness”. So obeying the law is presented as a kind of corruption.note 1
Middle: Douglass uses a metaphor, “the tender heart became stone”, which shows that slavery changed her.note 2
Low: In my extract it says “the tender heart became stone”, which means she became mean.note 3
Choice, pattern and issue. The student notices who does the changing (slavery, as a grammatical subject), sets two images together, and states what they mean for the issue: keeping the law corrupts.
Feature and general effect. The metaphor is named correctly. Its effect is a summary of what happens, which the quotation already said.
Paraphrase. The image is translated into plainer words, and the plainer words are weaker than the original.
The middle sentence is one step from the high one. It names the feature; it needs only to ask why Douglass chose stone, and what the change in a kind woman suggests about a law that requires cruelty. That question is the step from description to analysis, and it is the same at every point in an oral.
Using the exemplars to judge your own oral
The three orals are most useful set beside your own. Record a full practice oral with its questions, then transcribe two minutes of it: one from the middle of an extract and one answer to a question. Mark those minutes against the four criteria, using the comments on the three transcripts as a guide to what each band sounds like. Then compare your outline with the three in the diagram, point by point, and color each of your points by what it does.
Most practice orals will find themselves between the middle and the high bands on some criteria and lower on others, and the comparison shows which. A practice oral that sounds like the middle one on B needs its “shows that” sentences rewritten with line numbers and words. One that sounds like it on C needs its outline rebuilt around the issue. One whose answers to questions sound like the low one needs practice with a partner asking about lines the talk skipped.
Try it
A sentence from a practice oral on the same extracts reads: Antigone uses a lot of repetition of the word edict, which shows that she is angry about it. Which band is it closest to on criterion B, and how would you move it up?
It is close to the middle band: a feature is identified correctly (the word “edict” does recur, in lines 26, 30 and 35) but given a general effect. To move it up, locate the repetitions and say what they do. Twice Antigone sets the word inside a report she does not vouch for, “(So by report the royal edict runs)” in line 26, “(if report speak true)” in line 30. The repetition keeps the law in front of the audience while undermining its authority, so it presents the edict as a decree that rests on rumor and fear, which is exactly what the play goes on to test.
Self-check
- To do:
I can say what distinguishes a high, a middle and a low oral on each of the four criteria.
- To do:
I can explain how an issue stated as a question, a topic or a theme word shapes the whole oral.
- To do:
I can judge an outline by what each of its points does: state the issue, locate a choice, name a topic or tell the plot.
- To do:
I can show how three students treat the same line at three bands, and what turns description into analysis.
- To do:
I can explain how answers to the teacher’s questions can confirm or raise the marks of a talk.
- To do:
I can mark two minutes of my own practice oral against the criteria and say what would move it up a band.
Internal assessment for English A Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutes
- 4The five minutes of questions
- 5An oral at each bandThis page
HL essay
- 6The HL essayHL only
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
Carry on with English A Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.