Preparing your works for Paper 2

How to prepare works for Paper 2: choosing three works, building a work file, key passages, a quotation bank and precise references, organizing by concept and feature, and practicing ready comparisons.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

21 min readLast reviewed

Paper 2 is written without the books, so everything in the essay has to be carried into the room in memory. What you remember, and how it is organized, decides what you can write. A student who remembers the plot of Macbeth can retell it. A student who remembers how the play is built, five or six moments in close detail and a dozen short lines tagged by what they prove, can answer almost any question with it. A single half-line shows how much a remembered quotation can carry:

What’s done cannot be undone.

William Shakespeare, Macbeth, 5.1

Lady Macbeth says this in her sleep, in the scene where she walks at night trying to wash imagined blood from her hands. Earlier in the play, after the murder of Duncan, she told her husband that “what’s done is done” (3.2), as a reason to stop thinking about it. The same thought, in new words, now means the opposite: what was a way of forgetting has become what she cannot forget. Those five words can support an essay on guilt, on time, on transformation, on a character who breaks, or on how a play uses repetition. That is the kind of knowledge preparation builds.

Which works to prepare

You may write on any two works studied in class. Whether a work used for the individual oral or the HL essay may be used again in Paper 2 depends on the rules of the course and the school, so check with your teacher, early in the second year, which works you may use where. From the works that are free, most students prepare three works for Paper 2. Two would be enough if every question suited them, but questions vary, and a third work means that at least one strong pair is available for almost any question.

Three works also give three possible pairs, and that is their real value. The works are best chosen to combine well rather than for being individually the easiest. A good set usually covers at least two forms, since a difference of form is itself a rich point of comparison. It also includes works that share some concerns but treat them in different ways, so that each pair has both common ground and a difference to argue.

One set that works well is Macbeth (William Shakespeare, about 1606), a tragedy; The Handmaid’s Tale (Margaret Atwood, 1985), a dystopian novel narrated by its heroine; and Requiem (Anna Akhmatova, written 1935 to 1940), a cycle of poems read in English translation. All three are about life under a ruler or a regime that kills. Each sees it from a different place: inside the tyrant’s mind, in the testimony of a woman the state controls, and in the queue of women waiting outside a prison.

What knowing a work means

Knowing a work for Paper 2 is not knowing what happens in it, although that comes first. It means being able to say, without the book, how the work is built and what its writer chose to do. For any one work, that knowledge has seven parts. Its structure, as an outline of acts, chapters or sections, with the turning points marked. Its method, meaning who narrates or how the stage is used, and how time moves. Its key passages, a handful of moments known in detail. Its characters, and how each changes. Its images and motifs, and where they recur. Its context, in a sentence or two. And one or two critical readings, each in a sentence.

The difference between this and plot knowledge shows clearly in writing. Two sentences about the same moment in Macbeth, written from memory, show the difference.

Plot: After killing Duncan, Macbeth is upset and has blood on his hands, and Lady Macbeth tells him to wash it off.note 1

Method: Shakespeare keeps Duncan’s murder offstage and shows only its aftermath, so the audience meets the killing through Macbeth’s horror at his own bloody hands, and the blood that Lady Macbeth says “a little water” will clear returns in her sleepwalking, where no water can.note 2

  1. Accurate, and only events. True to the play, but it could come from a summary. It gives an essay nothing to analyze.

  2. Staging, structure and a motif. The offstage murder, the link between two scenes and the blood motif are all remembered, so the sentence can analyze the play from memory.

The second sentence needs more knowledge, but of a different kind. It knows where the murder happens (offstage), what the play shows instead, and how an image returns later. None of it requires a long quotation; “a little water” is three words. Preparation for Paper 2 is mostly the collection of exactly this kind of knowledge, organized so that it can be found under pressure.

Context and criticism belong in this knowledge, but in small amounts. A sentence on the play’s first audience, such as King James’s interest in witchcraft and his descent from Banquo, can sharpen a point about how the witches are presented. A critic’s view, given in a sentence with the critic’s name, can give an argument something to push against. Neither should take more than a line of a work file.

Summaries have one honest use: checking, after reading, that the sequence of events is right. A work file starts where the summary stops.

A work file for Macbeth

A work file is a single page, or a single screen, that holds what you need to write about one work from memory. It is built over months and revised often, and its shape matters more than its length. The diagram shows the four parts of a file for Macbeth: a structure strip, the key passages, a quotation bank and a grid of concepts and features.

A one-page work file for Macbeth. A strip of five acts with their turning points; a box of five key passages (the dagger, after the murder, the banquet, sleepwalking, Tomorrow); a quotation bank of twelve tagged lines; and a grid of concepts and features.A one-page work file for Macbeth. A strip of five acts with their turning points; a box of five key passages (the dagger, after the murder, the banquet, sleepwalking, Tomorrow); a quotation bank of twelve tagged lines; and a grid of concepts and features.
A work file on one page: structure, key passages, quotation bank, and a grid of concepts and features.

The structure strip

The strip gives each act a line and marks where the play turns. In Macbeth the turns come early and fast. The witches’ prophecy and Lady Macbeth’s persuasion fill the first act, and Duncan is dead by the second. By the third Macbeth is arranging the murder of his friend Banquo without telling his wife. In the fourth he orders the killing of Macduff’s wife and children, a crime with no purpose but fear. The last act divides the two partners completely. Lady Macbeth breaks down and dies offstage, and Macbeth fights on alone.

A strip like this already holds analysis. It sets out a play built on acceleration, each murder easier and less necessary than the one before, and on a separation, the couple who planned together ending apart. Those two observations can answer questions on structure, on transformation and on relationships, and neither is a plot detail.

Key passages

A key passage is a moment you know in close detail, because it shows the work’s methods and concerns at once. For a play, it is usually a speech or a short scene; for a novel, a page; for poems, a whole short poem or a stanza. Five or six are enough. Knowing them closely lets you analyze language, form and staging from memory, which a general knowledge of the work cannot do.

For Macbeth the strongest choices are the dagger soliloquy (2.1), the scene after the murder (2.2), the banquet where Banquo’s ghost appears (3.4), the sleepwalking scene (5.1) and Macbeth’s speech on hearing of his wife’s death (5.5). Each is chosen because it does several jobs. The dagger soliloquy shows a mind making its own visions:

Is this a dagger which I see before me,
The handle toward my hand?

William Shakespeare, Macbeth, 2.1

The question form, the imagined object and the hand reaching for it carry guilt, imagination and the supernatural at the same moment, and they prepare the hands and blood of the next scene. The sleepwalking scene repeats those images in broken prose, far from the controlled verse Lady Macbeth spoke while planning the murder. The 5.5 speech turns the whole play’s rush of action into a vision of empty time. With these three passages a student can write about guilt, appearance and reality, time, the couple’s relationship, the play’s structure and its language.

The quotation bank

A quotation bank is your own list of short quotations from one work, learned by heart and tagged by what each can prove. It is the most portable part of a work file. Ten to fifteen quotations per work are enough, each a phrase or a line, never a speech. A quotation earns its place in the bank if it can serve several different questions. The table shows part of a bank for Macbeth.

Quotation

Where

What it can support

“Fair is foul, and foul is fair”

1.1, the witches

appearance and reality; a world turned upside down; the witches’ language

“look like the innocent flower, / But be the serpent under’t”

1.5, Lady Macbeth

deception; Lady Macbeth’s control; imagery of nature

“Vaulting ambition, which o’erleaps itself”

1.7, Macbeth

ambition; self-knowledge; the decision to kill

“Macbeth does murder sleep”

2.2, Macbeth

guilt; sleep as a motif; the cost of the act

“O, full of scorpions is my mind”

3.2, Macbeth

a mind tormented; the couple drifting apart

“I am in blood / Stepp’d in so far”

3.4, Macbeth

blood as a motif; the point of no return; transformation

“Out, damned spot!”

5.1, Lady Macbeth

guilt; reversal of her earlier control; blood

“Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow”

5.5, Macbeth

time; despair; the meaning of the action

“this dead butcher, and his fiend-like queen”

5.8, Malcolm

how others judge the couple; the ending; perspective

Every quotation in the table is short enough to remember exactly, and each carries a tag that points it at several kinds of question. “Fair is foul, and foul is fair” can support an essay on how a work opens, on deception, on a supernatural voice or on a world without stable values. Malcolm’s “dead butcher” is useful for a different reason. It is the play’s last judgment on Macbeth, and an essay that sets it against what the audience has seen of Macbeth’s mind can argue about perspective and sympathy.

Learning the bank

Quotations are learned the way any short facts are: by retrieval, spaced over time. Reading a list ten times teaches less than writing it from memory once, checking, and doing the same again a few days later. Cards with the tag on one side and the quotation on the other work well, because they train the step the exam needs: from an idea to the line that proves it. Writing a quotation into a practice paragraph is better still, since it fixes the quotation together with a use for it.

A misremembered word is a smaller fault than an invented line. If you are not sure of the exact words, a precise reference is the honest alternative.

References without quotation

A textual reference points precisely to a moment in a work without quoting it: an act and scene, a chapter, an image, a line of action. Paper 2 rewards precise knowledge, and quotation is only one form of it. A reference that names exactly where and what earns credit as evidence. A vague gesture at the end of the play does not.

Vague: Later in the play Lady Macbeth feels guilty and goes mad, which is ironic because she was strong at the start.note 1

Precise: In the sleepwalking scene (5.1), Lady Macbeth rubs at her hands for a quarter of an hour while a doctor and a gentlewoman watch. The taper she now keeps by her at all times marks how far the woman who called on darkness in Act 1 has fallen.note 2

  1. Vague reference. “Later” and “goes mad” point nowhere exact; the irony is claimed, not shown.

  2. Precise reference, no quotation. The scene, the action, the witnesses and an object (the taper) are named, and the contrast with Act 1 is made by reference alone.

The second sentence quotes nothing and is full of evidence. It names the scene, the action, who watches and a stage object, and it connects them to a moment four acts earlier. References of this kind are easier to remember than quotations, and in a comparative essay they can carry most of the evidence, with quotations kept for the moments where the exact words matter.

Try it

Without quoting, write one sentence that refers precisely to the banquet scene in Macbeth (3.4) to support a claim about how the play presents guilt.

One possible sentence: At the banquet (3.4), Macbeth alone sees Banquo’s ghost sitting in his own place at the table, so the guilt he has hidden from his guests takes a body that only he and the audience can see. His public role as host then breaks down in front of the court. It names the scene and the precise action (the ghost in Macbeth’s place, seen by him alone) and connects it to a claim about guilt.

Organizing by concept and feature

Paper 2 questions are general. They ask about a feature (an ending, a minor character, time), a kind of character or relationship, or an idea close to one of the central concepts. Knowledge organized by plot has to be searched through, in order, for each question. Knowledge organized by concept and feature can be found at once. The grid sets the three prepared works against four concepts and four features, with one moment in each cell.

Macbeth

The Handmaid’s Tale

Requiem

Identity

Macbeth becomes the “butcher” others call him; his wife breaks under what she made him

Offred’s real name is never given; she keeps a self in memory and in telling

the poet’s private grief becomes the voice of many mothers

Perspective

soliloquies take the audience inside the murderer’s mind

one narrator, in the present tense, who cannot see beyond her room

a speaker who stands in the crowd and speaks for it

Transformation

from loyal general to tyrant; Lady Macbeth from control to collapse

from a woman with a job and a family to a Handmaid

a mother turned to stone by waiting

Representation

the witches; how Malcolm’s final words represent the couple

how the “Historical Notes” represent Offred’s story

how a regime’s victims are to be remembered

Structure

five acts that accelerate; the couple separated by Act 5

present-day chapters and “Night” sections; a final academic frame

a cycle of short poems with prose and epilogues around them

Voice

verse and soliloquy; Lady Macbeth’s final prose

first person, fragmentary, correcting itself

the lyric “I” widening into “we”

Imagery

blood, sleep, darkness

red, the eye, the mirror

stone, the prison wall, the river

Ending

Macduff with the tyrant’s head; Malcolm crowned

Offred steps into the van, toward darkness or light

the speaker asks for a monument at the prison wall

A grid like this turns preparation into material for argument. A question about how works present a self that survives oppression points to the identity row; a question about endings points to the bottom row. Reading across a row gives three ready comparisons in a few seconds. Filling the grid also shows where a work is thin. If no moment comes to mind for Requiem under structure, that is the gap to fill before the exam.

The seven central concepts are identity, culture, creativity, communication, perspective, transformation and representation. They do not need to appear by name in a question to be useful. A question about characters who change is about transformation, and a question about whose story is told is about perspective. The grid is a way of having the answer already sorted when the question arrives.

Ready comparisons

Three prepared works make three pairs, and each pair can be prepared in advance on several points: setting, ending, narrator or speaker, a minor character, an image, how the reader is placed. The diagram shows the strongest point of comparison on each side of the triangle formed by the three works.

A triangle with Macbeth at the top, The Handmaid’s Tale at the bottom left and Requiem at the bottom right. Sides: Macbeth and Handmaid’s Tale, power seen from inside the tyrant and from a victim; Macbeth and Requiem, time under terror; Handmaid’s Tale and Requiem, two women’s testimony.A triangle with Macbeth at the top, The Handmaid’s Tale at the bottom left and Requiem at the bottom right. Sides: Macbeth and Handmaid’s Tale, power seen from inside the tyrant and from a victim; Macbeth and Requiem, time under terror; Handmaid’s Tale and Requiem, two women’s testimony.
Three works, three pairs. Each side holds the strongest point of comparison for that pair.

Each side is a different kind of comparison. Macbeth and The Handmaid’s Tale see a murderous regime from opposite ends: from inside the mind of the man who builds it, through soliloquy, and from inside the mind of a woman it controls, through her first-person account. Macbeth and Requiem both slow time to show what terror does to a person. Macbeth’s “Tomorrow” speech hears days creeping on without meaning, while Akhmatova’s poems record months of standing in a prison queue for news of her son.

The Handmaid’s Tale and Requiem are both testimony by a woman under a regime, and both are about how testimony survives. Offred’s story is recorded on tapes found long after Gilead has fallen, and Akhmatova’s poems were kept for years in the memories of a few trusted friends, because a written copy was too dangerous to keep.

Preparing these comparisons does not mean preparing essays. It means knowing, for each pair, two or three points on which the works can be measured against each other, with a moment from each. When a question arrives, one of those points will usually fit it, and the essay can be planned from there.

Testing a pair against questions

A useful exercise is to take one pair and test it against several invented questions. Macbeth and The Handmaid’s Tale answer a question on how a regime controls language (the witches’ and Macbeth’s double meanings against Gilead’s official phrases and greetings). They answer a question on a character who watches without acting (Banquo, who suspects and stays silent, against Offred). They answer a question on an ending that judges what came before (Malcolm’s verdict against the scholars of the “Historical Notes”). A pair that fits many questions is a pair worth preparing in depth.

Practicing with general questions

Practice for Paper 2 is mostly planning. A full essay takes 105 minutes; a plan takes 15, and planning six questions teaches more than writing one essay. Take a general question, choose the pair, write the comparative thesis and four points with evidence from both works, and check the plan against the work files. Then write one paragraph of it in full, under time, to see whether the knowledge survives without the books.

Full essays under timed conditions are still necessary, perhaps once a month in the final term, because only a full essay shows whether the second work fades or the conclusion is rushed. A practice essay becomes a better one when it is marked against the criteria, rewritten in its weakest paragraph, and its quotations checked against the text. Each of those steps also feeds the work file. A quotation misremembered in practice should be corrected in the bank at once.

The learner portfolio kept over the two years is the best source for all of this. Its annotations, notes on context and connections between works are the raw material of a work file, and comparisons noted while reading, such as two endings that seemed to answer each other, are ready comparisons waiting to be developed.

Before: Macbeth: Act 1 witches, Act 2 Duncan murdered, Act 3 Banquo murdered, Act 4 Macduff’s family killed, Act 5 Lady Macbeth dies, Macbeth killed. Themes: ambition, guilt, the supernatural.note 1

After: Macbeth: acceleration (each murder easier, less needed); the couple apart by Act 5. Key passages: 2.1, 2.2, 3.4, 5.1, 5.5. Blood and hands (2.2 → 5.1). Time: “Tomorrow” (5.5). Pairs with Handmaid’s on power seen from inside; with Requiem on time under terror.note 2

  1. A plot list with topics. Accurate and useless under a general question: nothing in it says how the play is built or what to compare it with.

  2. A revision note built for Paper 2. Structure as a claim, key passages by scene, a motif traced, and the comparisons already marked.

The second note is no longer than the first, but every item in it can become a sentence of analysis. Revising notes in this direction, from events toward methods and comparisons, is most of what preparation for Paper 2 involves.

A plan made from the work files

The test of preparation is what it produces in the first 15 minutes of the paper. The plan was made in that time, from memory, by a student who had prepared Macbeth, The Handmaid’s Tale and Requiem in the way described. The question is invented, in the style of the paper:

In what ways do two works you have studied use time (its speed, its gaps, its repetitions) to present a mind under pressure?

An invented Paper 2 question

The student tests the three pairs against the question. Macbeth fits at once, because the play’s speed and Macbeth’s speech on time are both in the file. Requiem fits too, but the student knows its poems less closely than the novel. The Handmaid’s Tale has a present-tense narrator, memories that break into the present and a frame set two centuries later, all of them uses of time. The student chooses Macbeth and The Handmaid’s Tale.

Thesis: Both works show a mind under pressure through what happens to time, but Shakespeare speeds time up until it empties, while Atwood slows it down until memory is the only place left to live. The play’s mind is destroyed by its own actions, the novel’s survives by remembering.note 1

1. Speed. Macbeth: the five acts accelerate, Duncan dead in Act 2, each murder quicker and less needed (structure strip). Handmaid’s: the present moves slowly, days of waiting, the narrator’s present tense lingering on objects in her room.note 2

2. Gaps and memory. Macbeth: the murder of Duncan happens offstage, in the gap between scenes, and returns in 2.2 and in the sleepwalking (5.1). Handmaid’s: flashbacks to Luke, her daughter and Moira break into the present without warning; the “Night” sections are given over to her private thoughts and memories.note 3

3. Repetition. Macbeth: “Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow” (5.5), repetition as emptiness; Lady Macbeth’s “What’s done cannot be undone” (5.1) reversing “what’s done is done” (3.2). Handmaid’s: the monthly Ceremony and the daily shopping walk, repetition as control.note 4

4. The end of time. Macbeth: the play closes on Malcolm’s new reign and his verdict, “this dead butcher”. Handmaid’s: the “Historical Notes” jump to 2195, and scholars treat Offred’s mind as a document. In both, the mind under pressure is finally judged by others, but only the novel lets the reader see the judges’ blindness.note 5

  1. A comparative thesis from the grid. Speed against slowness, destruction against survival: both drawn from the structure and voice rows of the work files.

  2. Point 1 from the structure strip. The acceleration noted months earlier becomes the first point, set against the novel’s slow present.

  3. Point 2 from the key passages. Two linked scenes of the play (2.2 and 5.1) against the novel’s flashbacks: knowledge by scene, not by plot.

  4. Point 3 from the quotation bank. Three short lines, each tagged “time” in the bank, used exactly where they prove the point.

  5. Point 4 from the ending row. Both endings judge the mind from outside; the difference makes the conclusion.

A plan like this would support a high-band essay because almost every line of it came from preparation rather than from memory of the plot. The thesis is comparative and names methods. Each point sets the two works against each other on one use of time, the question’s own terms. The evidence is precise: scene numbers, three short quotations, named sections of the novel. The order builds from how fast time moves to how it ends, so the conclusion has somewhere to go.

The plan also shows the limits of preparation. Nothing in the work files was about time as such. The student had to see that the structure strip, the key passages, the quotation bank and the ending row could all be read as answers about time. Preparation supplies the material; the question decides how it is arranged. That is why work files organized by concept and feature are more useful than prepared essays, which can be arranged only one way.

The same is true of references to the novel. “The Night sections” is useful only to a student who remembers what happens in them, and why Atwood sets those sections apart.

The best use of practice during preparation is plans rather than essays: choose a general question, plan it in 15 minutes from memory, and then check the plan against the work files.

Preparation leads straight into the paper itself, where the work files become a comparative thesis and a point-by-point essay in 105 minutes. It also leads into comparison, where the points prepared for each pair become comparative paragraphs.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can choose three works for Paper 2 that combine well, and say which works I am not allowed to use.

  • To do:

    I can describe what knowing a work means for Paper 2: structure, methods, key passages, characters, images, context and criticism.

  • To do:

    I can build a work file with a structure strip, key passages, a quotation bank and a concept and feature grid.

  • To do:

    I can choose and learn ten to fifteen short quotations per work, each tagged by what it can support.

  • To do:

    I can support a claim with a precise reference to a moment when I do not remember the exact words.

  • To do:

    I can prepare points of comparison for each pair of my works and test them against invented questions.

  • To do:

    I can plan an answer to a general question in 15 minutes from my work files.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Key passage

A moment in a work that a student knows in close detail because it shows the work's methods and concerns at once, so that it can be analyzed from memory in answer to many different questions.

Quotation bank

A student's own short list of brief quotations from one work, each learned by heart and tagged with the ideas, features and kinds of question it can support.

Textual reference

A precise pointer to a particular moment in a work, such as an act and scene, a chapter, an image or a line of action, given without quoting its words. It lets an essay written from memory support a claim exactly when no quotation is remembered.

Exam skills for English A Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2This page

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.