The HL essay

What the HL essay asks, how it differs from Paper 2, what each of its four criteria rewards, and the rules and stages that take it from a line of inquiry to a final version.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

26 min readLast reviewed

The HL essay is the one assessed piece of the two years that you plan, research and revise over months rather than write in a single sitting. It asks for one argument about one work: a question about how the work makes its meaning, and an answer developed in 1,200 to 1,500 words. The examples that follow come from Virginia Woolf’s Mrs Dalloway (1925), a novel of a single June day in London. Clarissa Dalloway gives a party that evening, and Septimus Warren Smith, a young veteran of the First World War whom she never meets, takes his own life. Late in the party, after Lady Bradshaw has mentioned the young man’s death, Clarissa leaves her guests for a small empty room:

Clarissa at the windowMrs. Dalloway, 1925Virginia Woolf, Mrs. Dalloway (New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1925), the party, near the end of the novel
Somehow it was her disaster—her disgrace. It was her punishment to see sink and disappear here a man, there a woman, in this profound darkness, and she forced to stand here in her evening dress. She had schemed; she had pilfered. She was never wholly admirable. She had wanted success. Lady Bexborough and the rest of it. And once she had walked on the terrace at Bourton.
It was due to Richard; she had never been so happy. Nothing could be slow enough; nothing last too long. No pleasure could equal, she thought, straightening the chairs, pushing in one book on the shelf, this having done with the triumphs of youth, lost herself in the process of living, to find it, with a shock of delight, as the sun rose, as the day sank. Many a time had she gone, at Bourton when they were all talking, to look at the sky; or seen it between people’s shoulders at dinner; seen it in London when she could not sleep. She walked to the window.
It held, foolish as the idea was, something of her own in it, this country sky, this sky above Westminster. She parted the curtains; she looked. Oh, but how surprising!—in the room opposite the old lady stared straight at her! She was going to bed. And the sky. It will be a solemn sky, she had thought, it will be a dusky sky, turning away its cheek in beauty. But there it was—ashen pale, raced over quickly by tapering vast clouds. It was new to her. The wind must have risen. She was going to bed, in the room opposite. It was fascinating to watch her, moving about, that old lady, crossing the room, coming to the window. Could she see her? It was fascinating, with people still laughing and shouting in the drawing-room, to watch that old woman, quite quietly, going to bed. She pulled the blind now. The clock began striking. The young man had killed himself; but she did not pity him; with the clock striking the hour, one, two, three, she did not pity him, with all this going on. There! the old lady had put out her light! the whole house was dark now with this going on, she repeated, and the words came to her, Fear no more the heat of the sun. She must go back to them. But what an extraordinary night! She felt somehow very like him—the young man who had killed himself. She felt glad that he had done it; thrown it away. The clock was striking. The leaden circles dissolved in the air. He made her feel the beauty; made her feel the fun. But she must go back. She must assemble. She must find Sally and Peter. And she came in from the little room.

The three paragraphs hold most of what an HL essay on this novel could ask about. Clarissa turns a stranger’s death into “her disaster” (paragraph 1), watches an old woman in a window, hears the clock, recalls a line of Shakespeare, and decides to go back to her guests. An essay could ask how Woolf joins two characters who never meet, why Clarissa feels “glad” rather than sorry, or what the old woman opposite is doing in the scene. Each of those is a different essay, and choosing one of them is where the work begins.

What the essay asks

The HL essay is written by higher level students only. You choose one literary work studied in class, ask a question of your own about it, and answer that question in a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words. The essay is coursework: you write it over several months, with time to read, draft and revise. It is not marked by your teacher. It is sent to the IB and marked by an examiner, out of 20, and it counts for 20% of the final HL grade.

The question you ask is called a line of inquiry. It is a question about how the work makes meaning, narrow enough to answer fully in 1,500 words and open enough that someone could argue with your answer. The essay states it at the start, usually as its title or in the first paragraph, and every later paragraph helps to answer it. Without a line of inquiry an essay has nothing to develop, and the four criteria all depend on its having one.

Those numbers explain the essay’s character. Twenty percent of the grade is a large share for a single piece of writing: it carries the same weight as the HL individual oral and nearly as much as Paper 2. It is also the share over which you have the most control, because you choose the work, the question and the time you spend on each draft.

A line of inquiry in brief

A line of inquiry starts from a subject that interests you, but it is not the subject itself. Mental illness in Mrs Dalloway names a subject: it could hold a history of shell shock, a summary of Septimus’s doctors, or a paragraph on Woolf’s own illness, and none of these would be an argument about the novel. A line of inquiry turns the subject into a question about the writing: How does Woolf use echoes between Clarissa’s day and Septimus’s to make his death part of her story? That question names a method (echoes between two strands of the narrative), a concern (how a death reaches a woman who never knew the man) and an answer that can only be found in the text.

The difference matters at every stage. A subject invites you to collect information and arrange it. A line of inquiry invites you to look for evidence and weigh it, because you are trying to answer something. The work of narrowing a subject into a line, testing it against the work and choosing among several candidates is a skill of its own, taught step by step with a worked case on Toni Morrison’s Beloved.

How the HL essay differs from Paper 2

Paper 2 and the HL essay are both formal essays about works studied in class, and students who have practiced one often write the other in the same way. The two tasks reward different things, and most of the differences follow from time. Paper 2 gives you 1 hour 45 minutes, no books and a question you have not seen. The HL essay gives you months, the book on your desk and a question you wrote yourself.

Paper 2

The HL essay

Works

Two works, compared

One work, studied in depth

The question

One of four general questions set by the paper

Your own line of inquiry

Time and conditions

1 hour 45 minutes, from memory, without the texts

Several months, with the text, drafts and revision

Evidence

Precise reference and a few remembered quotations

Exact quotation, cited by chapter, act and scene, or page

Sources

None

Optional secondary sources, acknowledged

Length and form

As long as the time allows

1,200 to 1,500 words, with citations and a works-cited list

Marking

25 marks on five criteria; 25% of the HL grade

20 marks on four criteria; 20% of the HL grade

The table shows what changes when the clock disappears. Because you have the text, every quotation must be exact and every reference must say where it comes from. Because you have time, an examiner expects an argument that has been thought through and revised, with no loose paragraphs and no summary written to fill space. Because you chose the question, nobody will forgive an essay that wanders away from it.

One habit carries over unchanged. In both tasks the essay argues a thesis, a claim someone could dispute, and each paragraph opens with a claim that advances it. What the HL essay adds is depth on a single work. A Paper 2 paragraph might use one moment from each of two works, while an HL essay paragraph can follow one feature through three or four moments of the same work.

Which work to choose

The essay is on one literary work studied in class, of any form, written in English or read in translation. The works for the individual oral, the HL essay and Paper 2 are widely reported to have to be different, so that a work used in one component cannot be used in another. Check with your teacher early which works you are using where, because the decision affects your preparation for all three.

Choose the work that gives you a question, not the work you like best. A favorite novel can be a poor choice if everything you want to say about it is admiration. A work that puzzles you, or that you read differently from your classmates, often leads to a stronger line, since an essay needs something to resolve. A class reading the party scene rarely agrees about why Clarissa feels “glad” at the news of a death, and a disagreement of that kind is already the start of an inquiry.

She felt glad that he had done it; thrown it away.

Mrs. Dalloway, paragraph 3

Read alone, the sentence can sound callous. Read with the rest of the paragraph, where she “did not pity him” and then feels “somehow very like him”, it becomes harder to judge. A line of inquiry could ask how Woolf’s narration keeps a reader from either condemning or excusing it.

What the four criteria reward

Each criterion judges one quality of the whole essay, and each is worth 5 marks. They are easier to understand side by side, on the same work and the same line of inquiry. The extracts that follow all come from essays on one line: How does Woolf use echoes between Clarissa’s day and Septimus’s to make his death part of her story? In each pair the first extract earns little on the criterion and the second earns a great deal, and the notes name the difference.

A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation

Criterion A asks whether you know the work well and whether you have turned that knowledge into an interpretation that answers your line of inquiry. Knowing the plot is the floor of the criterion, not its middle. The marks go to an essay that uses precise knowledge of the whole work, including moments far from the passage it is reading, to argue something about what the work means.

Weak: Septimus is a soldier who fought in the First World War and now suffers from shell shock. He sees two doctors who do not help him, and in the end he jumps out of a window. At her party Clarissa hears about his death and goes into a small room to think about it.note 1 This shows that Woolf thinks war has terrible effects on people.note 2

Strong: Woolf gives the two characters the same scene at a window, with opposite endings. Before Septimus jumps, an old man on the stairs opposite “stopped and stared at him”; before Clarissa returns to her guests, “in the room opposite the old lady stared straight at her!”note 3 The echo suggests that Clarissa’s return to the party is the choice Septimus could not make, so her survival is presented as a decision, not as the natural ease of a hostess.note 4

  1. Accurate, but retold. Every sentence is true, and none of it is an interpretation. The extract tells the story of the two characters in order and answers no question about how the novel joins them.

  2. A claim the line did not ask. The closing sentence turns to the topic of war in general and to what Woolf “thinks”. It could end an essay on almost any war novel.

  3. Knowledge of the whole work. The detail of the old man on the stairs comes from Septimus’s chapter, many pages before the party. Setting it beside the passage shows knowledge used for a purpose.

  4. An interpretation that answers the line. The extract says what the echo means for Clarissa and states it as a claim someone could dispute.

The strong extract uses fewer facts than the weak one, and every fact is chosen because it bears on the question. Criterion A rewards this habit of selecting knowledge and putting it to work. An examiner can tell at once whether an essay knows the work or only the passage it quotes, because a strong essay reaches across the work for the moment that proves its point.

B: Analysis and evaluation

Criterion B asks how the writer’s choices make the meaning you found under A, and how well they work. Choices include diction, imagery, syntax, structure, narrative voice, the arrangement of chapters and scenes, and in drama the staging. Naming a feature earns almost nothing. Explaining what it does in this work earns the marks, and judging its effect, for example weighing one reading of it against another, earns the top of the scale.

Fear no more, says the heart in the body; fear no more.

Mrs. Dalloway, Septimus on the afternoon of his death

Clarissa first meets these words in a bookshop window on her morning walk, where a copy of Shakespeare’s Cymbeline lies open at the song from which the line in paragraph 3 of the passage comes. The words return to her through the day. Septimus, lying on his sofa on the afternoon of his death, hears them in his own body, in the sentence quoted. The two extracts that follow use this repetition.

Weak: Woolf uses stream of consciousness in this passage to create a sense of Clarissa’s emotions. There is also a lot of repetition, which emphasizes her feelings.note 1 The line “Fear no more the heat of the sun” is a quotation from Shakespeare.note 2

Strong: The words from Cymbeline reach Clarissa without quotation marks: “the words came to her, Fear no more the heat of the sun.” Set inside the narrator’s sentence, the line is no longer something she reads but something she thinks, and it is the same line that Septimus’s heart repeats before he dies.note 3 Woolf never tells the reader that the two characters share it. The echo is left for the reader to hear, which makes the connection feel discovered rather than imposed; the cost is that a hurried reader may miss the novel’s main bond between its two strands.note 4

  1. Labels without effects. Two features are named, and their effect is given as “a sense of” emotion. Nothing in the sentences belongs to this novel rather than any other.

  2. A fact, not an analysis. The source is identified, but the extract does not ask why the line matters or where else it appears.

  3. A choice explained. The missing quotation marks are a real choice, and the extract says what they do: they move the line from the page into Clarissa’s mind.

  4. Evaluation. The extract judges the method, naming what it gains and what it risks. Weighing an effect like this is what lifts criterion B to the top band.

C: Focus, organization and development

Criterion C is the one that most separates the HL essay from the exam essays. Its name adds one word to the criterion of Paper 1 and Paper 2: development. A focused, well-organized essay keeps to its line of inquiry and moves in a clear order. A developed essay does more. Each section takes the argument a step further than the last, so that the conclusion says something the introduction could not yet have said.

The difference shows most clearly in the topic sentences, read in sequence without the paragraphs around them. Two sequences follow, from two essays on the same line of inquiry. Both are focused, since every sentence is about the echoes between Clarissa and Septimus, but only the second develops.

Sequence 1:

  1. Woolf links Clarissa and Septimus through the line from Cymbeline.note 1

  2. Another link between the two characters is the window.

  3. Woolf also links them through the striking of the clock.

  4. Finally, the old people opposite them are a further connection.note 2

Sequence 2:

  1. The line from Cymbeline first joins the two characters as readers: Clarissa meets it in a shop window and Septimus hears it in his own heart, so the novel gives them a shared language before it gives them a shared event.note 3

  2. That shared language prepares the windows of the last hours, where one scene (a window, a stranger watching from opposite, a decision) is played twice with opposite endings.note 4

  3. Because the scene is doubled, Clarissa’s return to the party reads as a choice made in Septimus’s place, which is why she can feel glad without feeling pity.

  4. The connection has a limit, however: Clarissa never learns his name, so the bond is one-sided, and the novel leaves the reader holding the knowledge that she lacks.note 5

  1. A list of examples. The sentences could be read in any order. Each names another link, and none depends on the one before it.

  2. The giveaway words. “Another”, “also” and “finally” mark a collection. The essay will end where it began, having shown four times that the characters are linked.

  3. A first step that points forward. The sentence makes a claim (a shared language before a shared event) that the next section needs.

  4. Each claim built on the last. “That shared language prepares” and “Because the scene is doubled” are links of cause, so the argument moves forward.

  5. Development by qualification. The last step tests the argument’s limit. The conclusion can now judge how far the novel joins the two characters, which the first essay cannot do.

Both essays use the same evidence, and both are organized. The second earns more under C because its sections stand in a fixed order: change the order and the argument breaks. That is the practical test of development. If your sections could be shuffled without anyone noticing, the essay is listing.

D: Language

Criterion D asks whether the writing is clear, accurate and varied, in a formal register, with literary terms used precisely. In the HL essay it also covers the conventions of academic writing: quotations punctuated and integrated correctly, references in a consistent form. Second-language writers are not marked down for sounding like second-language writers. They are marked down when errors or vague words blur what they mean.

Weak: Woolf’s use of stream of conscious is really effectivenote 1 because it makes the reader feel what Clarissa is feeling and this is shown when she says she felt glad that he had done itnote 2 which is shocking. The author uses lots of techniques here to show her emotions.

Strong: The admission that Clarissa “felt glad that he had done it” is never spoken aloud. It reaches the reader in free indirect discourse, in the narrator’s past tense but in Clarissa’s own idiom, so the shock of the word “glad” belongs to her rather than to Woolf.note 3

  1. An error and a vague judgment. “Stream of conscious” misnames the term, and “really effective” says nothing an examiner can check.

  2. A misreading in the grammar. Clarissa does not say anything here; the narration reports her thought. The quotation is also unpunctuated, so the reader cannot tell where Woolf’s words begin.

  3. Precise and economical. Two sentences, one exact quotation with its marks, and a term used correctly to make a point about whose voice the reader hears.

The strong sentence is also shorter than the weak one. Clear academic English in an HL essay is rarely ornate. It uses the exact term once, quotes only the words the point needs, and puts the subject and verb early, which also makes a sentence easy to follow for a reader working in a second language.

Try it

Here is a sentence from an HL essay draft on Mrs Dalloway: “The old lady is a symbol for Clarissa which shows she is lonely.” Which criteria does it lose marks on, and how could it be rewritten?

It loses marks on B, because “symbol for” names a device without explaining how it works in the scene, and on A, because “lonely” is asserted with no evidence and does not answer any line of inquiry. One rewrite: “Clarissa watches the old lady ‘quite quietly, going to bed’ while ‘people still laughing and shouting’ fill the drawing-room. The woman opposite offers her an image of solitude that is calm rather than desperate, a way of being alone that Septimus never found.” The rewrite quotes, sets two details against each other, and connects the image to the essay’s question about the two characters.

The word limit

The essay must be between 1,200 and 1,500 words. The limit is part of the task, not a guideline. Examiners are widely reported to stop reading at 1,500 words, and the safe assumption is that anything after that point is not read. An essay whose conclusion falls past the limit may then be judged as if it had none, and criteria A and C suffer together: the interpretation is never completed, and the development stops short of its last step.

The count usually leaves out the works-cited list and the references in brackets, and usually includes the quotations in the body. Check with your teacher how the count is made in your session, and count the final version yourself before you submit. An essay under 1,200 words falls outside the range the task sets, and it rarely has room to develop an argument far enough to reach the top bands.

Most first drafts are too long, not too short. The usual cause is summary: a paragraph that tells the story of the work before analyzing it, or a quotation followed by a sentence that repeats what the quotation said. Cutting those is the quickest way under the limit, and it improves the essay at the same time, because the words that remain are the ones doing analysis.

Sources and academic integrity

The essay is about the work itself, and it can be written using nothing else. You may also use other writing about the work: criticism, a biography, a history of the period, the writer’s own letters or prefaces. Such sources are allowed but not needed, and many top-band essays use none. If you do use one, it must be acknowledged at the point where you use it and listed at the end, and it must serve an argument that remains your own.

Mrs Dalloway offers a clear case. In an introduction written for an American edition of 1928, Woolf said something about the novel’s first plan:

in the first version Septimus, who later is intended to be her double, had no existence; and that Mrs. Dalloway was originally to kill herself, or perhaps merely to die at the end of the party.

Virginia Woolf, introduction to Mrs. Dalloway (New York: Modern Library, 1928)

A student writing on the echoes between Clarissa and Septimus would find this useful, and the temptation is to make the essay a proof of it. That would hand the argument to Woolf. The introduction says what the writer intended; the essay must still show, from the novel’s words, how far the finished book makes Septimus a double and what kind of double he is. Woolf’s sentence is a piece of evidence to weigh, cited like any other, and the essay may even conclude that the novel does something her description leaves out.

Academic integrity means that every quotation and every borrowed idea in your work is acknowledged, and that the words and the argument presented as yours are yours. It covers more than copying. An idea taken from a study website and put into your own words is still borrowed, and it must be cited. So must a reading a classmate suggested, if it shapes your argument. Work that breaks these rules is treated as malpractice by the IB, and the consequences can include losing the grade for the subject.

The commonest breach is not deliberate copying but an idea absorbed from reading and then written as if it were one’s own. The worked example takes a sentence of that kind and repairs it.

The revised version is longer, and it is better on three criteria. Under A the interpretation has become the student’s, under B it names a structural choice, and under D the borrowing is acknowledged in the expected form. The way a citation is written, and how a works-cited list is set out, are part of structuring the essay and are taught with it.

Feedback and the process over time

The HL essay is written over several months, and the order of the work matters more than its speed. The diagram sets out the usual stages, from choosing the work to submitting the final version, with what to check before moving on from each. Schools set their own deadlines, so the stages matter more than any particular calendar.

Flow chart of seven stages of the HL essay, from choosing the work through exploring lines, reading and research, a full draft, the teacher’s comment and revision to final checks and submission, each with what to check beside it.Flow chart of seven stages of the HL essay, from choosing the work through exploring lines, reading and research, a full draft, the teacher’s comment and revision to final checks and submission, each with what to check beside it.
The HL essay over several months. The teacher’s comment (orange) usually comes once, on one draft; the final checks (green) cover the word count, citations and the works-cited list.

Two stages are easy to rush. Exploring lines takes time because the first question is rarely the best one, and a student who keeps three or four candidates in the learner portfolio can test each against the work before committing. Revising takes time because a draft written to find out what you think usually has its best idea in the last paragraph, and the revision moves it to the front.

What your teacher can and cannot do

Your teacher can talk through your choice of work and your line of inquiry, recommend reading, and usually comment once on a complete draft, in writing or in conversation. The comment is general: it can say that a section lists rather than develops, or that the conclusion does not answer the question. It cannot correct your sentences, rewrite paragraphs or tell you exactly what to change. Rules of this kind vary in detail, so check with your teacher what feedback you can expect, and when.

Because the comment usually comes once, it is worth more if the draft is complete. A draft that stops after two sections can only be told to keep going. A full draft, with its conclusion, lets your teacher see whether the argument develops and whether the answer at the end matches the question at the start.

Where marks are lost

Many HL essays that sit in the middle or low bands share one of a small number of faults, and most of those faults begin before the first paragraph is written. An essay without a real line of inquiry has nothing to develop, so it fills its length with what it knows: the plot, the writer’s life, the history of the period, or the opinions of critics. The table sets out seven common faults, each in a sentence from a draft on Mrs Dalloway and in a revised version.

Fault

In a draft

Revised

A topic instead of a line

Title: The theme of time in Mrs Dalloway

Title: How does Woolf use the striking of clocks to set public time against private memory in Mrs Dalloway?

Biography replacing analysis

Woolf suffered from mental illness herself, which is why Septimus’s madness is so realistic.

In Regent’s Park the leaves seem to Septimus to be “connected by millions of fibres with his own body”, so the reader meets his illness from inside, as perception, before any doctor gives it a name.

Summary

In the next section Clarissa goes to a small room and thinks about the young man’s death.

Clarissa’s first response, that the death is “her disaster”, turns news about a stranger into a judgment of her own life.

Listing

Another example of the link between the characters is the window.

The window scene repeats the shared line in action: what Clarissa and Septimus first share as words, they now share as a choice.

A critic doing the thinking

As one critic says, Clarissa’s party is an act of courage.

The party could be read as courage, but the passage complicates that view: Clarissa returns to it only after admitting that she “had schemed” and “had wanted success”.

Over the limit

A conclusion at word 1,620, which an examiner may never read

A conclusion within the limit, after a paragraph of summary has been cut

Careless referencing

Clarissa feels “very like him” (near the end of the book).

Clarissa feels “very like him” (Woolf 283), with the edition named in the works cited.

Several faults in the table are one fault seen from different sides. Biography, history and criticism replace analysis when a student has nothing of their own to argue, and summary fills the space when the line of inquiry asks nothing that the plot does not already answer. That is why the time spent finding a line is never wasted, and why a weak line produces an essay with several faults at once rather than one.

Context in its place

Context is not a fault in itself. Mrs Dalloway is set five years after the end of the First World War, and an essay on Septimus may need a sentence on shell shock to explain what Sir William Bradshaw’s treatment means. The test is proportion and purpose. One or two sentences of context that sharpen a point about the text belong in the essay; a paragraph on the war that would fit any novel of the period does not.

The other faults are faults of care, and they cost marks under D and sometimes C. A page number with a question mark, a quotation changed without square brackets, or a citation style that changes halfway through tells an examiner that the essay was finished in a hurry. These are also the cheapest marks to keep, since a final read with the edition beside you corrects all of them.

An HL essay begins with its line of inquiry, and turning a broad interest into a question narrow enough for 1,500 words is the next step: from topic to focus to method, with each candidate tested against the work. After that come the essay’s shape, from an introduction that states the answer to sections that develop it, and three complete essays on Pride and Prejudice at the high, middle and low bands.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what the HL essay asks: a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words on a line of inquiry into one literary work, marked by the IB out of 20.

  • To do:

    I can say how the HL essay differs from a Paper 2 essay in its work, its question, its time and its use of evidence.

  • To do:

    I can explain what each of the four criteria rewards and tell a developed sequence of sections from a list.

  • To do:

    I can state the word limit and why writing past it is risky, and keep my essay within it.

  • To do:

    I can use a secondary source honestly, acknowledging it where I use it and keeping the argument my own.

  • To do:

    I can describe the stages of writing the essay and what my teacher can and cannot do to help.

  • To do:

    I can recognize the commonest faults in an HL essay sentence and revise it.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Academic integrity HL only

Honest, acknowledged use of other people's words and ideas in assessed work, so that everything presented as the writer's own is the writer's own. Quotations and borrowed ideas are cited where they are used.

HL essay HL only

The coursework essay written by higher level students: a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words that develops a line of inquiry into one literary work, written over several months and marked by the IB.

Line of inquiry HL only

A question about how one work makes its meaning, narrow enough to answer fully in the word limit and open enough that the answer can be argued. It names the work, a feature or method, and a concern, and the whole essay sets out to answer it.

Internal assessment for English A Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes
  4. 4The five minutes of questions
  5. 5An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 6The HL essayThis page
  2. 7Finding a line of inquiry
  3. 8Structuring the HL essay
  4. 9An HL essay at each band

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.