- Subjects
- English A Lit
- The five minutes of questions
The five minutes of questions
Why the teacher asks questions after the individual oral, the six kinds of question, and how to answer each from the extracts and the works, with worked exchanges on Whitman and Chekhov.
- IB English A: Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
The individual oral does not end when the talk ends. Five minutes of questions from your teacher follow at once, and they are marked as part of the same performance. They are not a test of new knowledge. They are a chance to take the talk further: to look again at a line, to bring in more of a work, to sharpen the comparison or to defend a reading. Students who prepare only the ten minutes often give away marks in the last five.
The examples that follow come from one oral, which pairs a poem from Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass with a story by Anton Chekhov read in Constance Garnett’s English translation. Its global issue is the dignity a society grants or denies to manual work. The first extract is the whole of Whitman’s “Sparkles from the Wheel” (1871), in which the speaker stops on a busy street to watch a knife-grinder at work.
The second extract is the opening of Chekhov’s “Misery” (1886), in Garnett’s translation of 1920. Iona Potapov drives a horse-drawn sledge for hire through St Petersburg on a snowy evening. His son has died that week, and he wants to tell someone.
The talk the questions follow
Questions grow out of a talk, so the talk comes first. This student’s ten minutes argued that the two works present the dignity of manual work from opposite sides. Whitman grants it through attention. His speaker withdraws from the “ceaseless crowd” (line 1) to watch the grinder’s skill closely, and the poem turns the waste of the work, the sparks, into “tiny showers of gold” (line 15). Chekhov shows a society that denies it. The people who speak to Iona treat him as part of the vehicle, and the story’s narration, close to Iona and in the present tense, gives him the attention that nobody in the street will.
The talk spent about four minutes on each extract and ended with a short comparison. It said less about the rest of each work, and it did not decide which work treats its worker with more respect. Those gaps are typical of a good talk under time, and they are exactly where a teacher’s questions tend to go. The student’s outline for the last minutes of the talk read as follows.
8. Compare: W attention = dignity / C nobody listens → narration listensnote 1
9. Issue: who grants dignity? the watcher, not the streetnote 2
10. End: gold vs snownote 3
A comparison that could go further. The point names a difference in method, but only one sentence of the talk developed it. A teacher can ask the student to build on it.
A claim open to challenge. The point gives the watcher the power to grant dignity. A teacher may test it by asking whether watching is the same as respect.
An image pair, not yet explained. The contrast between Whitman’s gold and Chekhov’s snow closed the talk in a phrase. It is a natural place for a question asking the student to explain it.
Each point of the outline marks something the talk began and left open. Reading your own outline in this way, as a list of places where a listener would want more, is the best preparation for the questions.
What the questions are for
A follow-up question asks a speaker to extend, clarify or connect something they have said. In the oral, every question your teacher asks is of this kind. The teacher has just heard ten minutes and knows where the talk was strongest, where it was thin and where it made a claim it did not prove. The questions give you a chance to fill those places, so they are a second chance at the criteria, not a separate exam.
The three purposes produce different questions. A question that asks you to extend points to something the talk touched and left: a line you quoted but did not analyze, a part of a work you mentioned in passing. A question that asks you to clarify points to something said too quickly or too loosely: a term used vaguely, a claim whose evidence was unclear. A question that asks you to connect points to a link the talk did not make: between the extract and the rest of its work, between the two works, or between the works and the issue.
The questions are marked with the talk, on the same four criteria, as one performance. There is no separate mark for them. A strong answer can still lift a mark that the talk left on a boundary. It might supply the analysis of the second extract that the talk rushed (criterion B), or show knowledge of a part of a work that the talk never reached (criterion A). A weak answer cannot destroy a strong talk, but it can confirm a doubt the teacher already had.
What a teacher’s question looks like
Teachers often ask three to five questions in the five minutes, and most are short. They name a point in your talk or a place in a text and ask you to go further. A good question leaves you room to think aloud; it rarely has a single right answer. The question below came after the talk on Whitman and Chekhov, and the notes say what each part of it asks for.
Teacher: You said that Whitman’s speaker grants the grinder dignity by watching him.note 1 Could you look again at line 12, the line in brackets,note 2 and tell me what it adds to that idea?note 3
It starts from the talk. The teacher quotes your own claim back to you. You are being asked to build on it, not to defend a different one.
It points to the text. A line number tells you where the answer lies. The teacher has noticed a line the talk passed over.
It asks for more. “What it adds” is an invitation to extend the analysis. Repeating the claim would not answer it.
Most questions in the oral have this shape: a claim from your talk, a place in a text and a request. Hearing those three parts in a question tells you what kind of answer it wants, and the request at the end usually tells you which of six kinds of question it is.
Six kinds of question
Follow-up questions in the oral fall into six kinds. Each points to a different place in the talk or the texts, and each is answered best by a different move. Knowing the kinds does not tell you what your teacher will ask, but it lets you recognize a question quickly and start the right kind of answer while you are still thinking.
A closer look asks about a line or phrase in an extract, often one the talk quoted without analyzing or passed over. A question about the rest of a work asks how the extract connects to a moment, a pattern or the ending of its work. A question about the comparison asks you to set the two works against each other more precisely than the talk did. A question about the issue asks what the two works, together, suggest about it, and sometimes which presents it more convincingly. A challenge offers a different reading of something you claimed. A clarification asks what you meant by a word or a claim.
The diagram sets the six kinds around the question itself, each with the move that answers it well. All six moves return to a text: a line, a moment or a choice.


Applied to the oral on Whitman and Chekhov, each kind produces a question a teacher might well ask. The table gives one of each, with what a strong answer does. A teacher would not ask all six in five minutes, but any three or four of them are likely.
Kind | A question on this oral | What a strong answer does |
|---|---|---|
A closer look | “Could you look again at line 12, the line in brackets?” | Analyzes a feature the talk did not mention: the brackets and the sudden change of scale. |
The rest of a work | “What happens to Iona after the officer gets out?” | Names the later listeners in order and shows the same refusal repeated, until the mare at the end. |
The comparison | “Both extracts are set in a crowded street. How do the two crowds differ?” | Sets Whitman’s “loud, proud, restive base” against Chekhov’s “dark mass” of shouting voices and says what each crowd does to the worker. |
The issue | “Which work do you think comes closer to granting the worker dignity?” | Gives a judgment and weighs it, with a reason from each work. |
A challenge | “Isn’t Whitman’s speaker as uninterested in the grinder as the officer is in Iona? He never speaks to him.” | Concedes what is true in the reading, then defends the original claim with a line, adjusted where needed. |
A clarification | “You said Chekhov makes Iona look less than human. Who does that: the narrator or the people in the street?” | Separates the two and says which the talk meant, with a paragraph number. |
Answering well
A strong answer in the oral is short, specific and new. It usually lasts between thirty seconds and a minute, about as long as a paragraph of an essay. It goes to a place in a text within its first two sentences, and it says something the talk did not. Five moves produce answers of this kind, and most strong answers use three or four of them.
Take a moment
A pause of a few seconds before you answer is normal, and it sounds like thought, not like a lack of knowledge. Use it to find the line or moment the answer needs. Saying Let me look at that line again and turning to the extract is better than starting a sentence you have not planned. A pause of more than ten or fifteen seconds is long on a recording, so if you need longer, think aloud: name the line and say what you notice first.
Return to a line or a moment
The fastest way to make an answer specific is to quote. If the question is about an extract, read two to six words from it and give the line or paragraph number. If it is about the rest of a work, name the moment precisely: the chapter or part, who is present and what happens. An answer that never touches a text can only repeat what the talk said in general.
Extend rather than repeat
The teacher has heard the talk, so an answer that restates it adds nothing. Extending means adding something: a second feature in a line already discussed, a new line, a moment from elsewhere in the work, or a consequence of the talk’s claim that the talk did not draw. The test is simple. If the teacher could have heard the sentence during the talk, it is repetition.
Connect to the other work
Even a question about one work can end with a sentence about the other. That sentence turns an answer about a single text into comparison, which criterion B rewards and which most talks do too little of. One sentence is enough: and that is the opposite of the officer, who hears Iona and does not listen.
Admit uncertainty, then reason
Sometimes a question reaches a line you have not thought about, or asks for a judgment you have not made. Saying I hadn’t considered that, but I think… and then reasoning from the text is honest and earns credit. It shows the thinking the oral is designed to hear. Pretending to certainty usually produces a vague answer, while reasoning aloud from a line produces a specific one, even when it ends in a tentative judgment.
The five moves in one answer
The closer-look question on line 12 shows the moves at work. The student’s talk had said that Whitman’s speaker grants the grinder dignity by watching him. The teacher’s question asks what the bracketed line adds. The line in question reads:
The group, (an unminded point set in a vast surrounding,)
The attentive, quiet children, the loud, proud, restive base of the streets,Walt Whitman, “Sparkles from the Wheel”, lines 12–13
The first answer comes from a student who has prepared the talk and nothing more. The second comes from a student who uses the question as a chance to analyze. Both are what the student might say aloud.
Weak: Line 12 says the group is “an unminded point set in a vast surrounding”.note 1 This shows that the speaker is watching the grinder and giving him dignity, like I said in my talk, because he pays attention to him when nobody else does.note 2 So it shows that Whitman respects manual work.note 3
Strong: Let me look at that again. Line 12 is the only line in brackets, and it pulls the camera back:note 4 the grinder, the children and the speaker become one “unminded point” in “a vast surrounding”. So the attention the poem gives is small and local.note 5 The city as a whole doesn’t mind the grinder at all, and the “loud, proud, restive base of the streets” in line 13 goes on ignoring him. That is closer to Chekhov’s street than my talk suggested.note 6 I’d put it more carefully now: Whitman grants dignity inside a small circle of watchers, and the brackets admit how small it is.note 7
Quotes, then paraphrases. The answer reads the line out and stops. Nothing about it is analyzed: not the brackets, not the scale.
Repeats the talk. The answer returns to the claim the teacher quoted in the question and says it again.
A general close. “Respects manual work” could be said of a hundred poems. The answer ends further from the text than it began.
Takes a moment, finds a feature. The student turns to the line and names something the talk did not: it is the only bracketed line in the poem.
Analyzes the change of scale. The quotation is short and is followed at once by what it does.
Connects to the other work. One sentence brings Chekhov in, and the comparison is sharper than anything the talk said.
Qualifies the talk’s claim. The student adjusts the argument in the light of the line. A teacher hears thinking, not recital.
The strong answer is about 110 words, under a minute of speech. It adjusts the talk’s claim in the light of a closer reading. Admitting that the poem’s dignity is smaller than the talk claimed costs nothing, because the admission rests on a closer reading of line 12 than the talk contained.
Exchanges on the rest of a work and the comparison
The two exchanges that follow come from the same oral, after the question on line 12. Each gives the teacher’s question, then a weak and a strong answer, as the student might say them.
A question about the rest of a work
The talk analyzed the officer in the opening of “Misery” and said little about the rest of the story. The teacher asks the student to go beyond the extract. A question of this kind tests criterion A directly, because it asks how well the student knows the whole work and whether that knowledge can be put to use.
Teacher: You stayed with the officer in your talk. What happens to Iona after the officer gets out, and does it change how you read the opening?
Weak: After the officer, Iona picks up three young men. They argue about who has to stand, and the hunchback insults him and slaps him on the neck. Then Iona tries to talk to a man with a parcel, and then he goes back to the yard and tries to tell a young cabman, but he falls asleep. At the end he tells his horse.note 1 So it is a very sad story about loneliness.note 2
Strong: The opening becomes a pattern. Each listener after the officer turns Iona away in the same way, and each is smaller than the last: three young men, a house-porter, a cabman who falls asleep. Only the mare, at the end, listens.note 3 What changes my reading is how Iona treats the young men. He accepts a price the narrator says is not fair, and when the hunchback calls him “you old plague” he laughs and calls them “merry gentlemen”.note 4 So the story shows a worker who keeps offering courtesy to people who give him none, and that makes the officer’s “H’m!” in paragraph 15 look less like one rude man and more like how the whole city treats him.note 5
Accurate retelling. Every event is right and in order, and none of it is used. The answer proves only that the student has read the story, which is the lowest level of criterion A.
A theme word for an ending. “Loneliness” is true of the story but is not the oral’s issue. The answer has drifted from dignity and work.
Selected knowledge, shaped. The later listeners are named in one sentence and turned into a pattern, which is a claim about the structure of the story.
A precise moment from beyond the extract. The unfair price and the insult are details only a student who knows the work well would have, and both are about work and respect.
Back to the extract and the issue. The answer ends by rereading the opening in the light of the whole story, a move from work to extract that the talk did not make.
Both answers know the same story. The difference is selection. The weak answer tells the events because the question named them. The strong answer picks one pattern and one detail, then returns to the extract the talk discussed. That return is what turns knowledge of the work into interpretation of it.
A question about the comparison
The student’s talk compared the two works in a minute at the end. The teacher points to a likeness the talk did not use, the crowded street in both extracts, and asks how the two crowds differ. This is a question for criterion B as well as A, because it asks for a comparison of how the writers present a setting, not only of what happens in it.
Where the city’s ceaseless crowd moves on the livelong day,
Withdrawn I join a group of children watching, I pause aside with them.Walt Whitman, “Sparkles from the Wheel”, lines 1–2
The second extract describes its crowd twice. In paragraph 2 it is the city of “monstrous lights, of unceasing uproar and hurrying people” into which Iona has been cast. In paragraph 8 it is the “dark mass shifting to and fro” that shouts at him once he moves. The two answers set these crowds side by side in different ways.
Teacher: Both extracts put the worker in a crowded city street. How do the two crowds differ?
Weak: Both crowds are busy and noisy and they don’t pay attention to the worker. In Whitman the crowd is “ceaseless” and in Chekhov it is “unceasing”, so they are similar.note 1 This shows that cities don’t respect manual workers.note 2
Strong: Whitman’s crowd ignores the grinder; Chekhov’s crowd runs into Iona and blames him for it.note 3 In paragraph 8 the shouts come out of a “dark mass”, and in paragraph 10 a pedestrian brushes the horse’s nose and then looks at Iona angrily, as if the collision were his fault.note 4 The bigger difference is where the speaker stands. Whitman’s speaker is “Withdrawn” in line 2: he can step out of the crowd and watch. Iona can’t, because driving into the crowd is his job.note 5 The words “ceaseless” and “unceasing” look like an echo, but the second is Garnett’s, so I wouldn’t build on the word. The idea of a city that never stops is in both, though.note 6
Similarity only. The answer finds what the crowds share and stops. A comparison question asks for the difference that matters.
A claim about cities, not works. The last sentence is about the world. It says nothing about how either writer presents the crowd.
The difference in one sentence. The answer opens with its whole claim, set out as a contrast, before any evidence.
Evidence located. Two paragraph numbers and a short quotation support the claim about Chekhov’s crowd.
From setting to the issue. The answer moves from the crowds to the position of the watcher and the worker, which is the oral’s issue seen through a choice in each text.
Translation handled with care. The student notices that a verbal echo across the works depends on a translator’s word and limits the claim to what both writers share.
The strong answer gives the teacher a new comparison, built on a feature of each text the talk did not use. Its last sentence also shows awareness of what reading in translation means: a single English word in “Misery” is Garnett’s choice, so a comparison resting on it would be a comparison with the translator. Treating the work in translation as if it were written in English is a fault that a question can expose, and this answer avoids it.
A question about the issue
Teachers often keep one question for the issue itself, near the end of the five minutes. It usually asks for a judgment: which work presents the issue more fully, more convincingly or more critically. On this oral, the question might be which of the two works comes closer to granting the worker dignity. A judgment needs reasons from both works, and it can be partial, since few pairs of works divide an issue so neatly that one does everything.
The strongest answers to an issue question are a small synthesis. They do not choose a winner by praising one work. They find a distinction that only comparing the two could produce, such as a difference between honoring a kind of work and listening to a person who does it, and they support each half with a line. An answer like this can lift criterion A, because it shows how each work presents the issue, and criterion C, because it brings the whole oral back to the issue in its last minutes.
Questions that open a new angle
Some questions ask about something the talk never mentioned: another part of a work, another work by the same writer, a feature of the extract the talk ignored. These questions can feel like traps, because the student has prepared nothing on them. In fact they are usually generous. The teacher is giving you a chance to show knowledge of the works that the ten minutes had no room for.
The talk on Whitman and Chekhov used only one poem from Leaves of Grass, a book of several hundred poems. The teacher asks whether the knife-grinder is typical of Whitman’s workers. A student who has read the book will remember that it is crowded with workers, often named in long lists by their trades. “I Hear America Singing” is one such list:
The carpenter singing his as he measures his plank or beam,
The mason singing his as he makes ready for work, or leaves off work,
…
Each singing what belongs to him or her and to none else,Walt Whitman, “I Hear America Singing”, Leaves of Grass (1891–2)
A good answer to a new-angle question is brief, connects the new material to the talk at once, and returns to the extract. It does not try to deliver a second talk on the new poem. Thirty to forty-five seconds is enough, ending on the line from the extract that the new material makes clearer.
Teacher: You discussed only “Sparkles from the Wheel”. Is the knife-grinder typical of the workers in Leaves of Grass?
Weak: Yes, Whitman writes about workers in a lot of his poems, for example “I Hear America Singing”, where he lists different workers like the carpenter and the mason. He was very interested in ordinary people and democracy, and he worked as a printer and a journalist himself, so he knew about work.note 1 So the grinder is typical.note 2
Strong: In one way he is. Leaves of Grass is full of workers named by their trade, like the carpenter and the mason in “I Hear America Singing”, each “singing what belongs to him”.note 3 But those workers are usually in a list, one line each, and the grinder has a whole poem. That changes what dignity means. In the lists, dignity comes from belonging to the nation’s chorus. In “Sparkles from the Wheel” it comes from one old man’s skill watched closely, down to “the light-press’d blade” in line 14.note 4 So I’d say the grinder is typical in who he is and unusual in how closely the poem looks at him.note 5
Facts without a point. The answer names a poem and adds biography. None of it is connected to the grinder or to the issue.
A yes that closes the topic. “So the grinder is typical” answers the literal question and stops, when the question was an invitation to compare.
The new material named precisely. A poem, two trades and a short quotation show knowledge of the wider work in one sentence.
A difference of method. The answer compares how the two poems present workers, a list against a single portrait, and draws a consequence for the issue.
A balanced judgment. “Typical in who he is and unusual in how closely the poem looks” answers the question with a distinction and returns to the extract.
The strong answer uses the new poem to see the extract better. Biography, as in the weak answer, is relevant only when it explains something in a line.
Questions that challenge
A challenge offers a reading that differs from yours. The teacher may hold that view or simply want to see how you defend your own. Either way, a challenge is a request for evaluation, the second half of criterion B’s name. The strongest answers neither give in at once nor defend everything. They grant what is fair in the other reading, which is a concession, then defend the part of their own claim that the text still supports, and often end with a claim that is sharper than either.
The talk on Whitman had praised the poem’s gold imagery as a way of honoring work. The teacher puts the opposite view. The line it rests on is the longest in the poem:
Myself effusing and fluid, a phantom curiously floating, now here absorb’d and arrested,
Walt Whitman, “Sparkles from the Wheel”, line 11
The weak answer and the strong answer both keep the student’s view. Only one of them earns credit for doing so.
Teacher: Some readers would say the gold in this poem turns the grinder’s work into a show for an onlooker, and that the poem is really about the speaker. What do you think?
Weak: I don’t agree. I think Whitman really respects the grinder, because he describes him in detail and the sparks are gold, which is a positive image. Gold is valuable, so it shows that the work is valuable.note 1 So I still think the poem gives dignity to manual work.note 2
Strong: I think that reading is partly right.note 3 Line 11, the longest line in the poem, is about the speaker, “Myself effusing and fluid”, and he is “absorb’d and arrested” by a scene, not talking to a man. The grinder even becomes part of “The scene and all its belongings” in line 9.note 4 But I’d defend the first stanza. Lines 4 to 6 describe the work from the inside: how he “carefully holds” the knife “by foot and knee”, how he presses with a “light but firm hand”. You only notice those things if you respect the skill.note 5 So I’d now say the poem honors the craft and is less interested in the craftsman. That fits what I said about the gold. The sparks are the work made beautiful, but they are what the watchers see, not what the grinder feels.note 6
Disagreement without evidence. The answer refuses the challenge but repeats the talk’s claim. It quotes nothing from the poem.
Holding a position by repetition. Restating a view is not defending it. The teacher learns nothing new about the reading.
A concession, stated plainly. Granting part of the challenge at the start tells the teacher the student has heard it and is weighing it.
The other reading tested on the text. The student finds the lines that support the teacher’s view and says what they show.
The defense, with different lines. The student’s own reading rests on the first stanza, which the challenge did not consider.
A refined claim. The answer ends with a distinction, the craft against the craftsman, that is more exact than the talk’s claim and absorbs the challenge.
The strong answer ends with a better argument than the talk had. That is common when a challenge is answered well, and it is why teachers ask them. Giving up the talk’s reading entirely would abandon the argument, and refusing to move at all would ignore the lines the teacher pointed to.
When you do not understand a question
Questions in the oral are spoken once, quickly, and sometimes use a word you did not expect. If you are unsure what a question means, ask. Asking takes a few seconds and keeps your answer on the question that was meant. Teachers expect it, and rephrasing is part of their role in the oral.
A useful way to ask is to say back what you think the question means, so the teacher can confirm or correct it. A clarification question from the teacher works the same way in reverse: it asks you to say exactly what you meant by a word in the talk. The exchange that follows contains both.
Teacher: You said that Chekhov makes Iona seem less than human. Is that the narrator’s doing, or the people in the street?
Student: Do you mean whether the narrator agrees with the passengers, or whether the narration itself makes him seem less human?note 1
Teacher: The second. When the narrator says Iona is “all white like a ghost”, isn’t the story doing what the officer does?
Student: I see. I think the narrator and the passengers do different things.note 2 The ghost in paragraph 2 and the “halfpenny gingerbread horse” are the narrator’s images, but they show what the snow and the waiting do to Iona: he has been still so long that he looks like something else.note 3 The passengers in paragraphs 8 to 11 call him “you devil” and swear at him, which is a judgment. So the narrator shows Iona being made less human by his work, and the passengers treat him as if he already were.note 4
Checking the question. The student restates two possible meanings and lets the teacher choose. The answer that follows is then to the right question.
A plain start. The student signals the answer in one sentence before giving evidence.
The narrator’s images, located. Two images are quoted and explained as what the conditions of the work do to Iona, which keeps the answer on the issue.
A precise distinction. The answer separates showing from judging, which is exactly what the clarification asked for.
The student’s first sentence is not a weakness. It turned an ambiguous question into one with a single meaning, and the answer that followed is precise because the question was. Never guess at a question you have not understood.
Where marks are lost in the questions
Most weak answers in the five minutes fail in one of a few ways, and nearly all of them come from treating the questions as a chance to repeat the talk rather than extend it. The diagram sets the two paths side by side. Both begin with the same question. The weak path circles back to the talk and the issue in general, while the strong path goes to a text, adds something and ends on a claim the talk did not make.


The table gives the commonest faults as they sound in an oral on Whitman and Chekhov, each with a corrected version.
Fault | As it sounds | Corrected |
|---|---|---|
Repeating the talk | “As I said in my talk, Whitman shows respect for the grinder by describing him.” | “There’s something I didn’t mention: the grinder is described almost entirely through his hands and feet in lines 5 and 6.” |
The issue in general | “Even today manual workers are not respected, and they are often paid very little.” | “Iona accepts twenty kopecks, which the narrator says is not a fair price, and that detail puts the issue of pay into the story itself.” |
A one-sentence answer | “Yes, I think the grinder is typical.” | “Yes in who he is, no in how closely the poem looks at him, as the list in ‘I Hear America Singing’ shows.” |
A long answer that drifts | Two minutes moving from the mare to Chekhov’s life as a doctor to the history of Russian serfdom. | Forty-five seconds on the mare as the only listener, ending on what that says about dignity. |
A misremembered quotation | Words from the end of the story, quoted from memory and wrong. | The moment described without quotation marks: at the end Iona tells the whole story to his mare. |
Two of these faults deserve a word more. A long answer uses up the minutes in which the teacher could ask another question, and each question is a new chance at the criteria. A misremembered quotation costs more than a precise description of the moment would. The extracts are in front of you, so quote them exactly; for the rest of a work, describe the moment precisely and quote only what you are sure of.
Preparing for the questions
You cannot know the questions in advance, but you can predict most of their kinds. A teacher’s questions grow from the talk, so the talk you have planned already contains them. The gaps you know about (a line you will not have time to analyze, a part of a work you will barely mention, a claim you make quickly) are where questions are most likely to go.
Reading your outline for questions
The most useful preparation is to read your oral outline as a teacher would, point by point, and write beside each point the question it invites. Then prepare for each question the line or moment you would go to first. You do not script the answers. You find, in advance, the evidence each one needs.
A student who has done this for every point will meet few questions that are entirely new.
Practicing with someone else
The second form of preparation is practice with a listener. Give the talk to a classmate and ask them to put three questions to you, one from each of three kinds: a closer look, the rest of a work and a challenge. Record the answers and listen to them once. Check that each answer quotes or names a moment within two sentences, adds something the talk did not say, and stops within a minute. Practice recordings of this kind belong in your learner portfolio, together with the questions you were asked and your notes on the answers.
Practicing the challenge matters most, because it is the kind students find hardest. Ask your partner to argue against the claim in your talk that matters most to the oral’s issue. In the oral on Whitman and Chekhov, that claim concerns the poem, and a short line of it can carry the whole exchange:
The sad sharp-chinn’d old man with worn clothes and broad shoulder-band of leather,
Walt Whitman, “Sparkles from the Wheel”, line 10
Try it
A teacher asks: “The poem calls the grinder “sad” in line 10. How does the speaker know he is sad?” Plan an answer of three or four sentences.
A strong answer concedes that the speaker cannot know: the grinder never speaks, and “sad” is the speaker’s guess from what he sees. Every other detail in line 10 is visible, the “sharp-chinn’d” face, the “worn clothes”, the “shoulder-band of leather”, so the line moves from what is seen to what is imagined. That supports the challenge that the poem is partly about the watcher. It also connects to Chekhov: Iona’s grief is known because he says it himself in paragraph 14, so Chekhov gives the worker a voice that Whitman’s grinder never has.
A talk always leaves something out, and the five minutes are the only part of the oral in which a teacher can help you put it back. Three complete orals at different bands, on Frederick Douglass’s Narrative and Sophocles’ Antigone, show the questions at work alongside the talks they follow, and how answers move a mark.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what the teacher’s questions are for and how they are marked with the talk.
- To do:
I can name the six kinds of follow-up question and the move that answers each one well.
- To do:
I can answer a question by going to a line or moment within two sentences and adding something the talk did not say.
- To do:
I can connect an answer about one work to the other work in a sentence of comparison.
- To do:
I can answer a challenge by conceding what is fair and defending my reading with a line.
- To do:
I can ask for a question to be rephrased by saying back what I think it means.
- To do:
I can read my outline for the questions it invites and prepare evidence for each.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.
- Follow-up question
A question that grows out of what a speaker has just said and asks them to extend, clarify or connect it. In the individual oral, the teacher's questions after the talk are of this kind and are marked with the talk as one performance.
Internal assessment for English A Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutes
- 4The five minutes of questionsThis page
- 5An oral at each band
HL essay
- 6The HL essayHL only
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
Carry on with English A Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.