Finding a line of inquiry

How to turn a topic into a line of inquiry for the HL essay, test it against the work, open new lines through the concepts and areas of exploration, and use primary and secondary sources.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

22 min readLast reviewed

Most of the marks an HL essay earns are decided before it is written, by the question it asks. A line of inquiry that asks how a work makes its meaning gives the essay something to analyze and an answer to develop. A topic gives it only a subject to describe. Finding a good line is slow work, and it usually begins with a sentence like the one that opens Toni Morrison’s Beloved (1987):

124 was spiteful. Full of a baby’s venom.

Toni Morrison, Beloved (1987), the first sentences of Part One

A reader who notices that the novel’s first word is a house number, and that the house is given a feeling, has noticed something an essay could ask about. That noticing is where a line of inquiry starts. Turning it into a question that can carry 1,500 words takes several further steps, and those steps are the subject of everything that follows.

What a line of inquiry is, and what it is not

A line of inquiry is a question about how one work makes its meaning. It is narrow enough to answer fully in the word limit and open enough that a thoughtful reader could answer it differently. The essay states it at the start and spends every paragraph answering it. Four kinds of question look like lines of inquiry and are not, and each leads to a recognizable kind of weak essay.

The first is a topic: Memory in Beloved. A topic names a subject the work deals with, and it asks nothing, so the essay that follows collects examples of memory and arranges them. The second is a theme word dressed as a question: How is memory presented in Beloved? The “how” is welcome, but the question is still as wide as the novel, and almost any paragraph about any chapter would fit it. An essay on it is usually a tour of the plot.

The third is a closed question, one answered with yes or no: Is Beloved the ghost of Sethe’s dead daughter? It sounds like an inquiry, but it asks about the story rather than about the writing, and the essay can only list evidence on each side and then choose. The fourth is a question about the writer: How did Morrison’s research into an 1856 case of an escaped mother shape Beloved? It is a real question, but its answer lies in biographies and interviews, not in the novel, so the essay ends up about Morrison rather than about her book.

The difference shows in the verbs an essay can use. An essay on a topic says what the work contains: memory appears here, and here, and here. An essay on a line of inquiry says what the work does: the house records, distorts, releases.

The three parts of a good line

A strong line of inquiry has three parts, and a weak one usually lacks at least one of them. It names the work. It names a feature or method: a pattern of images, a narrator, a way of ordering events, a kind of scene, the handling of one character. And it names a concern: the meaning the method serves, such as how a character is judged, how a loss is felt or how a community is shown. The line on Beloved names the novel, a method (the house and the sentences that describe it) and a concern (the state of Sethe’s memory).

A good line also passes two further tests. It can be answered “partly” as well as “yes” or “no”, so the essay has room to qualify its answer in its last section. And it can be answered without summarizing the whole work, because it points to particular moments. A question that needs the plot told from beginning to end before it can be answered is still a topic.

From topic to line, across several works

Every work studied in class can yield many lines of inquiry, and every topic can be turned into one. The table sets out five topics students often begin with, on five works of different forms, and a line of inquiry that each could become. In every case the line keeps the topic’s concern and adds a method that the essay can analyze.

Work

Topic

Line of inquiry

Macbeth (Shakespeare, about 1606), drama

Ambition

How does Shakespeare’s choice to keep some murders offstage and stage others shape the audience’s judgment of Macbeth as the play goes on?

Persepolis (Marjane Satrapi, 2000–2003, read in translation), graphic memoir

Religion

How do the panels in which the child Marji talks with God trace the narrator’s loss of faith, and what takes its place?

Ariel (Sylvia Plath, 1965), poetry

Death

How does Plath use the color red to turn images of injury into images of energy across the collection?

The God of Small Things (Arundhati Roy, 1997), prose fiction

Childhood

How does the twins’ wordplay, from capitalized phrases to words read backward, let the novel describe adult cruelty from a child’s height?

The Cherry Orchard (Anton Chekhov, 1904, read in translation), drama

Social change

How does Chekhov use small talk about money, from Lubov’s gift of gold to a passer-by to Pishchik’s borrowing, to show a family that cannot speak of its own ruin?

Each line in the table is longer than its topic, and the extra words do the work. Offstage and stage in the Macbeth line gives the essay a pattern to trace through the acts. As the play goes on asks for development over time, which criterion C rewards. In the Plath line, across the collection tells the examiner that the essay will read several poems, not one, and injury and energy name the tension it will explore.

A worked narrowing: the house in Beloved

Beloved is set in 1873 in Cincinnati, Ohio, in a house at 124 Bluestone Road. Sethe, who escaped from slavery eighteen years earlier, lives there with her daughter Denver and with the ghost of the baby daughter she killed rather than let her be taken back. Students drawn to the novel often begin with the topic of memory, since almost every chapter returns to Sweet Home, the Kentucky farm where Sethe was enslaved. The topic is real, but an essay on it would have the whole novel to cover. The diagram shows the narrowing that turns it into a line of inquiry, in four steps, with two questions discarded on the way.

Funnel diagram: the topic memory in Beloved narrows to a focus on the house at 124 Bluestone Road, then to a method (the house’s description and the sentences opening each part), then to a line of inquiry about how the house registers Sethe’s memory. Two discarded questions branch off.Funnel diagram: the topic memory in Beloved narrows to a focus on the house at 124 Bluestone Road, then to a method (the house’s description and the sentences opening each part), then to a line of inquiry about how the house registers Sethe’s memory. Two discarded questions branch off.
Narrowing a topic into a line of inquiry on *Beloved*. Each step keeps the concern (memory) and adds something the essay can analyze; the two orange boxes are questions discarded on the way.

The first step is a focus: one place in the work where the topic can be seen. The house is an obvious choice, because the novel opens on its number and gives it moods. The second step is a method: the feature the essay will analyze. Here the method is the way the house is described, and especially the short sentences that open each of the novel’s three parts. The third step joins focus, method and concern in a question: How does Morrison use the house at 124 Bluestone Road, in its descriptions and in the sentences that open each part, to register the state of Sethe’s memory?

The opening of each part is the reason the line works. Each part begins by naming the house by its number and giving it a single quality, and the qualities change from spiteful to loud to quiet. Spiteful belongs to the ghost that breaks mirrors and leaves tiny handprints in a cake. Loud belongs to the voices around the house once Beloved has come to live in it, and quiet to the end, when the past has been faced. A line of inquiry built on this pattern has a structure to follow and a development to trace, from one part to the next.

Testing the line against the work

Before committing to a line, a student tests it on the work: can it be answered from several moments, and does each moment add something? The test takes an hour with the book, and it can save weeks of drafting a line that collapses. The worked example runs the test for the line on Beloved.

The test did more than confirm the line. It found the essay’s outline: three sections, one for each part of the novel, each a step further than the last, and a qualification at the end. A student who runs this test on two or three candidate lines will usually find that one of them produces an outline almost by itself, and that is the one to choose.

Two lines discarded, and why

The narrowing also threw up two questions that were rejected. Is Beloved the ghost of Sethe’s dead daughter? is a closed question about the story. The novel leaves it open on purpose, and an essay on it would set out the evidence on each side and then pick one, without analyzing how the openness is made. It could be rescued by turning it into a question about method: How does Morrison keep the identity of Beloved uncertain, and what does the uncertainty allow the novel to say?

The second rejected question asked how Morrison’s knowledge of Margaret Garner, an enslaved woman who killed her daughter in 1856 rather than see her returned to slavery, shaped the novel. That history matters, and one sentence of it might sharpen an introduction. As a line of inquiry it fails, because its evidence lies outside the novel. An examiner marks the essay on its knowledge of Beloved and its analysis of Morrison’s choices, and a comparison with a newspaper story of 1856 supplies neither.

Narrowing too far, and not far enough

A line can fail in two opposite directions. It can stay too wide, so that answering it needs the whole work summarized, or it can become so narrow that one scene answers it in a page. Both produce weak essays, for different reasons, and both can be repaired.

How does Morrison present slavery in Beloved? is too wide. Every chapter bears on it, so the essay would be forced to choose its evidence at random or to retell the plot, and either way the argument would not develop. What does the number 124 mean? is too narrow. It focuses on a single detail, and once the essay has offered an answer (or two), it has nowhere to go for the remaining thousand words. The line on the house sits between them: one method, several moments, a change to trace.

A useful check is to imagine the essay in sections. A line that is too wide gives you more sections than you can write; a line that is too narrow gives you one. A good line gives you three or four, each different, in an order that matters. If you cannot imagine at least three sections, widen the method a little (from one detail to a pattern of details); if you can imagine eight, narrow the focus.

Opening lines through the concepts

A student who has one candidate line often struggles to find a second, and comparing candidates is how a good line is chosen. The seven central concepts are a reliable way to open new lines on a work you know. Each concept asks a different kind of question, and applying all seven to one work usually produces two or three lines worth testing. The table applies them to Beloved.

Concept

A line of inquiry on Beloved

Identity

How does Morrison use names that are given, taken and chosen (Baby Suggs, Stamp Paid, Paul D) to show selves remade after slavery?

Culture

How does the novel present Baby Suggs’s preaching in the Clearing as a community’s own form of healing, and why does it fail after Sethe’s act?

Creativity

How does Denver’s retelling of her own birth to Beloved turn the telling of a story into a way of making a relationship?

Communication

How do the three monologues of Part Two, and the voices that merge after them, show what the women of 124 cannot say to one another aloud?

Perspective

How does Morrison’s movement between Sethe’s and Paul D’s points of view lead the reader to judge Sethe’s act twice, and differently?

Transformation

How does the image of Paul D’s heart as a rusted tobacco tin chart the changes in what he can allow himself to feel?

Representation

How does the novel use schoolteacher’s notebook, in which Sethe’s “characteristics” are listed in columns, to show the power of being written about?

Some of these lines are stronger than others, and seeing why is part of the skill. The creativity line is the narrowest: Denver’s retelling is a single episode, and an essay might run out of moments. The perspective line is the widest, because the novel moves among many minds. The representation line is promising: it names one object, it connects to the novel’s concern with who tells the story of enslaved people, and it can be traced from the notebook to the end. A student might test the house line and the notebook line side by side and choose the one with the clearer development.

The concepts do not need to appear in the line itself. Transformation is a useful word for finding a question about Paul D, but the line names what changes and how the novel shows it, which is more precise than the concept. The concepts help to open a work, and the line that results is what the essay is judged on.

Opening lines through the areas of exploration

The guiding questions of the three areas of exploration open lines in the same way, and each area tends to produce a different kind of essay. Three examples show the range, one from each area, on three different works.

Structure and style

Asking how the structure or style of a work affects its meaning leads to lines about arrangement. Arundhati Roy’s The God of Small Things moves between 1969 and 1993. It tells the reader early that Velutha, the man the twins love, will be beaten and will die, and it keeps the love scene between Velutha and the twins’ mother for its final pages. A line could ask: How does Roy’s decision to announce Velutha’s death long before the love scene that leads to it change what the final chapter means? The essay would analyze order, not plot, which is what a structure line asks for.

Meaning over time

Asking how a work’s meaning changes over time can lead to strong lines, but it needs care, because the evidence for change lies outside the work. Sylvia Plath left a manuscript of Ariel in her own order when she died in 1963. The collection published in 1965 changed that order and some of its contents, and Plath’s own arrangement was published in 2004. A line could ask: How does the order of poems in Plath’s own arrangement of Ariel shape the collection’s movement, compared with the order readers met in 1965? The line is acceptable because its evidence is still the poems and their order. A line that asked only how critics’ views of Plath have changed would not be, since it could be answered without reading a poem.

Work with a reception history needs the same proportion as any other HL essay: the history explains why a question is worth asking, and the evidence comes from the text. The many receptions of Ibsen’s A Doll’s House show the balance: they explain why its final scene is worth a question, and the question is still answered from the play.

Conventions

Asking how works keep and break the conventions of their form leads to lines about expectation. Beloved draws on the slave narratives of the nineteenth century, whose writers, addressing mostly white readers, often drew back from describing the worst of what they had suffered. A line could ask: How does Beloved take up the silence of the slave narrative about what was too painful to tell, and where does it break that silence? An essay on it would need to know the convention well enough to see the departure, which is the kind of knowledge a convention line rewards.

Testing a line before you commit

A candidate line should pass a short test before any drafting begins. The test card sets out six checks, filled in for the line on the house in Beloved. Each check answers a different weakness: the first three catch a topic or a theme word, the fourth catches a closed question, and the last two catch a line too wide or too narrow.

A test card with six checks for a line of inquiry (names the work, names a method, names a concern, can be answered partly, needs no summary, five or six moments bear on it), each ticked with its evidence for the line on the house in Beloved.A test card with six checks for a line of inquiry (names the work, names a method, names a concern, can be answered partly, needs no summary, five or six moments bear on it), each ticked with its evidence for the line on the house in Beloved.
The test card for a line of inquiry, filled in for the line on the house in *Beloved*. A line that fails any check needs reworking before drafting starts.

Two further questions help when a line passes the card but still feels uncertain. Does it ask how rather than what? A line that begins with What is or Why does often asks for a meaning without a method, and rewording it to begin How does the writer use repairs it. Could a thoughtful classmate answer it differently? If every reader would give the same answer, the essay has nothing to argue, and the line needs a sharper concern.

Try it

A student proposes this line: How does Shakespeare present guilt in Macbeth? Test it on the card, then improve it.

It names the work and a concern, but no method, and guilt runs through the whole play, so the essay would need a summary to answer it. One improvement adds a method and narrows the focus. How does Shakespeare use the things Macbeth sees that no one else can, from the dagger to Banquo’s ghost, to make the audience share his guilt and then watch it from outside? The new line points to particular scenes (2.1 and 3.4 among them), it can be answered “partly”, and it gives the essay a development to trace.

Primary and secondary sources

The work you write about is your primary source: the novel, play, memoir or collection of poems itself, in the edition you name. Everything written about the work is a secondary source: criticism, reviews, biographies, histories of the period, study guides and websites. A writer’s own essays, letters and interviews about the work sit between the two. They are evidence about the work, not part of it, so an HL essay treats them as secondary sources and cites them as such.

The HL essay does not need secondary sources, and many of the strongest essays use none. The marks go to your knowledge of the work and your analysis of its choices, and no amount of reading about the work replaces reading the work. A secondary source earns its place only when it does something for your argument that the primary source cannot.

When a critic helps

A critic is most useful as a position to test your argument against. If a well-known reading of the work disagrees with your answer, naming it and showing where the text supports you is a strong move, because it proves that your interpretation has been weighed. A critic can also supply a fact you cannot get from the work, such as the date a text was revised or what a word meant to its first readers. In both cases one or two sentences are enough at this length, cited precisely and followed by your own analysis.

Morrison’s own essay “The Site of Memory” (1987) shows the first use. In it she describes the slave narratives as often drawing back from what was most painful to tell, and her own task as imagining the inner lives those narratives left out. A student writing the convention line on Beloved might use that description once, as a claim about the narratives to set beside the novel. The two sentences that follow use the same source.

Weak: Morrison said in an essay that slave narratives left out the worst things, so in Beloved she shows everything.note 1

Strong: Morrison described the slave narratives as drawing back from what was most painful to tell (“The Site of Memory”, 1987).note 2 Beloved both repairs and repeats that silence: Sethe’s act is approached through hints and fragments for much of the novel before it is narrated in full, and the closing pages describe the whole story as one not to be passed on.note 3

  1. The source does the arguing. The essay borrows Morrison’s claim and draws a conclusion from it that the novel does not support, since much in Beloved is never shown directly. There is no citation.

  2. Cited and kept short. One clause reports the source, and the citation tells the examiner where it comes from.

  3. The student’s own step. The sentence goes further than the source, with evidence from the novel, and finds a complication (the silence is repaired and repeated) that the source did not state.

The strong version gives Morrison one clause and the novel the rest of the sentence. That proportion is the rule of thumb for any secondary source in an HL essay. It also guards against a quieter danger, which is that a confident critic makes your own reading look unnecessary. If a critic has already answered your question in full, look for a narrower or different one.

Every source you use, including the edition of the primary source, is cited where you use it and listed at the end. How to write those citations, and how to set out the list, belongs to the structure of the finished essay. What matters at this stage is to note the source, the page and your own comment on it every time you read, so that nothing in the final essay arrives without its origin.

Keeping lines in the learner portfolio

The best lines of inquiry rarely arrive when the essay is due. They come during the reading, as a sentence noticed in class or a disagreement in discussion, and they are lost unless someone writes them down. The learner portfolio is the natural place for them: a page for each work, with candidate lines, the moments each points to, and a note on why it might or might not work.

Kept over the two years, those pages give you a choice when the time comes. A student who has six candidate lines on three works can test them against each other in an afternoon, and choose the work as well as the line. A student who starts from nothing in the month the essay is due usually writes on the first topic that comes to mind, and the essay shows it.

A tested line is the beginning of the essay’s structure. The next step is to turn it into an introduction that states an answer and a sequence of sections in which each takes that answer further, with quotations integrated and the work cited consistently throughout.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what a line of inquiry is and tell it from a topic, a theme word, a closed question and a question about the writer.

  • To do:

    I can name the three parts of a good line (the work, a method, a concern) and check that a line can be answered “partly”.

  • To do:

    I can narrow a topic through a focus and a method into a line of inquiry, as in the case of the house in Beloved.

  • To do:

    I can test a line against five or six moments in the work and decide whether to keep it.

  • To do:

    I can use the central concepts and the areas of exploration to open several lines on one work and compare them.

  • To do:

    I can tell a primary source from a secondary one and use a critic in one cited sentence that my own analysis goes beyond.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Primary source HL only

The literary work itself, in a named edition, as the object an essay analyzes. Its words are the essay's main evidence.

Secondary source HL only

Writing about a literary work rather than the work itself, such as criticism, biography, history or a writer's comments on their own work. In an essay it is optional, acknowledged where it is used, and weighed against the work's own words.

Internal assessment for English A Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes
  4. 4The five minutes of questions
  5. 5An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 6The HL essay
  2. 7Finding a line of inquiryThis page
  3. 8Structuring the HL essay
  4. 9An HL essay at each band

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.