6.5 Cartoon
What cartoons are for and how they work: editorial cartoons, strips and gags; exaggeration, caricature, symbols and visual puns; labels and relay; panels and gutters; satire, context and offense; and how cartoons have changed.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 6 Non-literary text types
- SL and HL
Notes on 6.5 Cartoon
A cartoon is a drawing, usually simplified and often funny, that comments on people, events or ideas with few words or none. Its tools are exaggeration and symbols that a viewer recognizes at once, so a cartoon can make an argument in the time it takes to look at it. On 23 January 1889 the New York humor weekly Puck printed a full-color cartoon by its founder, the Austrian-born artist Joseph Keppler, about who controlled the United States Senate.

In words, the cartoon shows the Senate chamber from above, with rows of small desks curving across the floor. The senators at them are drawn small, hunched over papers, chatting or leaning back. Behind them, along a raised gallery rail, stands a row of enormous men in top hats, each with a body shaped like a bulging sack of money marked with a dollar sign and the name of a trust. They grow larger from left to right, and the largest, holding a cane, has just stepped through a wide doorway at the right. High on the back wall at the left, a much smaller door is shut. The cartoon’s words, as printed, are these:
PUCK.
PEOPLES’ ENTRANCE · CLOSED
THIS IS A SENATE / OF THE MONOPOLISTS / BY THE MONOPOLISTS AND / FOR THE MONOPOLISTS!
ENTRANCE FOR / MONOPOLISTS
SUGAR TRUST · STANDARD OIL TRUST · COPPER TRUST · STEEL BEAM TRUST · NAIL TRUST
THE BOSSES OF THE SENATE.Joseph Keppler, “The Bosses of the Senate”, Puck, 23 January 1889: the masthead, the two doors, the banner, five of the labels on the money bags, and the caption
Comment in a single image
Keppler’s cartoon is an editorial cartoon: a drawing published as opinion on a current political question. It does the work of an editorial or an opinion column, taking a position and trying to bring its audience round to it, but it argues with an image. Its caption states the claim:
THE BOSSES OF THE SENATE.
Joseph Keppler, “The Bosses of the Senate”, caption
Bosses is a pointed word. In American politics of the 1880s it meant the men who controlled a party machine from behind the scenes. Here it is given to the trusts, the great combinations of companies that dominated industries such as oil, sugar and steel. The senators, who should be the bosses of the nation’s laws, are shown as employees at their desks. In 1889 senators were still chosen by the legislatures of their states rather than by voters, and critics argued that wealthy interests could buy those choices. The cartoon pictures that argument as a room in which the people have no door.
Its situation explains its form. Puck was a weekly humor magazine sold to middle-class readers in New York and beyond, and its cartoons were printed in color by lithography, the largest often spread across two facing pages. A reader turned to the centerpiece expecting to be amused and to recognize the news of the week. The cartoon had to be understood in seconds and still reward a longer look, which is why it puts its argument in the scale of its figures and its details in the labels.
Three kinds of cartoon
Cartoons are not all editorial. A comic strip tells a short story or joke in a sequence of panels, usually with recurring characters, and is read for entertainment as much as comment. A gag cartoon is a single drawing with a joke, often with a caption beneath it, of the kind printed in magazines; it comments on manners and everyday life rather than on a political issue. The three share a toolkit of simplification and exaggeration, but they differ in purpose, and the purpose decides what a viewer must know to understand them.
Exaggeration, caricature and symbol
The cartoon’s first argument is its scale. The trusts are giants and the senators are small, and the giants grow larger toward the open door, as if the biggest fortunes had the most recent and easiest access. Nothing in the drawing needs a label to say who holds power in the room; the proportions say it. Exaggeration of size is the cartoonist’s most direct means, because a viewer reads relative size before anything else in an image, as the toolkit chapter on images explains through salience.
The bodies of the giants carry a second idea. Each is a money bag with a man’s head, a top hat and a cane:
SUGAR TRUST
STANDARD OIL TRUSTJoseph Keppler, “The Bosses of the Senate”, labels on two of the money bags
The money-bag body is a visual pun. Moneybags was already slang for a rich person, and the cartoon draws the word literally, so that each man is nothing but his wealth, swollen to bursting. A pun in words asks the reader to hear two meanings at once; a visual pun asks the viewer to see two things in one shape, here a man and a sack of coins. The top hats and frock coats belong to the costume of the wealthy in the 1880s, so the figures are recognizable as a class even before their labels are read.
Keppler draws types, not individuals: the giants have heavy jowls and smug faces, but none is a portrait of a particular businessman. Caricature in the strict sense exaggerates the features of a real person so that the viewer recognizes and judges them at once. Thomas Nast’s cartoon “The ‘Brains’” in Harper’s Weekly (21 October 1871) is a famous example. It shows William Tweed, the boss of New York’s Democratic party machine, as a heavy man in a suit whose head is a money bag marked with a dollar sign. Where Keppler’s money bags stand for a class, Nast’s stands for one man’s mind.
Labels, banners and relay
Keppler’s words are few, and each does a different job. The labels on the money bags (“SUGAR TRUST”, “COPPER TRUST”) name what the figures stand for, so a viewer cannot mistake them for ordinary rich men. The banner on the back wall does something else:
THIS IS A SENATE
OF THE MONOPOLISTS
BY THE MONOPOLISTS AND
FOR THE MONOPOLISTS!Joseph Keppler, “The Bosses of the Senate”, the banner on the wall
The banner rewrites the close of Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address (1863), which spoke of government of the people, by the people and for the people. Readers in 1889, a generation after the Civil War, would have heard the original under the new words at once. The allusion turns the cartoon’s complaint into a charge of betrayal: the Senate has replaced the people in Lincoln’s promise with monopolists, and the drawing shows the result. The picture alone could show rich men crowding a chamber; only the banner can say that this undoes the founding idea of the republic.
Words and image here divide the message between them. The toolkit chapter on images and the page on the photograph teach anchorage, the work words do when they fix one meaning of an image, as a caption does. Roland Barthes, in “Rhetoric of the Image” (1964), set beside it a second relation, relay, in which words and image each carry part of a message that neither carries alone. Barthes found relay above all in cartoons and comic strips. The labels on the money bags anchor; the banner relays, adding an argument the drawing could not make by itself, and the caption sums both up.
The diagram marks the six choices that carry the cartoon’s argument, with the words placed where they appear.


The doors read as a pair. The people’s door is small, high on the wall and marked “CLOSED”, while the monopolists’ door is wide, at floor level and open, with the largest giant just through it. The contrast needs both words and image: the signs say whose doors they are, and the drawing says which one is used. Read together, they turn the architecture of the chamber into the cartoon’s thesis.
Read once more, the cartoon’s words show how each one works with the drawing around it.
PUCK.note 1
PEOPLES’ ENTRANCEnote 2 · CLOSEDnote 3
THIS IS A SENATE / OF THE MONOPOLISTS / BY THE MONOPOLISTS AND / FOR THE MONOPOLISTS!note 4
ENTRANCE FOR / MONOPOLISTSnote 5
SUGAR TRUSTnote 6 · STANDARD OIL TRUSTnote 7 · COPPER TRUST · STEEL BEAM TRUST · NAIL TRUST
THE BOSSES OF THE SENATE.note 8
Masthead. The magazine’s name at the top tells its readers to expect satire, so the drawing is read as comment, not reportage.
A sign in the architecture. The words are placed on the building itself, so the exclusion of the people looks like a fact of the chamber, not an opinion.
One word against a door. The small notice settles what the small, high door already suggests.
Relay through allusion. The banner rewrites Lincoln’s words; the drawing cannot make this charge of betrayal without it.
The pair to the closed door. The open doorway, wide and at floor level, is the other half of the cartoon’s thesis.
Labels as anchorage. Each money bag is named, so the giants are trusts, not just rich men.
A real target. Naming the best-known trust of the day tied the cartoon to the news its readers followed.
Caption as claim. Bosses, the word for party machine leaders, is given to the trusts and taken from the senators.
Try it
The cartoon’s banner ends with an exclamation mark, and its caption with a full stop. What does each mark do?
The exclamation mark makes the banner sound like a proclamation or a slogan shouted in public, as if the monopolists themselves were boasting of their Senate; it adds mockery to the allusion. The caption’s full stop is calm and final: it states the cartoon’s claim as a plain fact, a title under the picture rather than a cry. Together they let the cartoon both mock and accuse.
Panels, gutters and time
A single-panel cartoon shows one moment. A comic strip shows many, and its conventions are those of sequence. Winsor McCay’s Little Nemo in Slumberland, a full-page color strip in the Sunday New York Herald, began on 15 October 1905; this is its second page, printed a week later.

In words, the page is divided into a title band and eleven numbered comic panels, framed pictures separated by thin white gaps called gutters. The boy Nemo feels his bed shake and sink through the floor. A clown called the Pokoko leads him into a forest of giant mushrooms, and as Nemo walks on alone the panels grow taller, so the mushrooms tower over him and the frames themselves stretch to hold them. He stumbles against a stalk, the mushrooms topple like dominoes, and in the last panel, short again, he sits up in his own bed while his father speaks to him.
The words come in two kinds. Under each panel runs a narrator’s caption, and the captions of the last four panels run on as one passage of narration that crosses three gutters:
HIS FIRST THOUGHT WAS TO FLY FROM THE SCENE. IN FACT IT WAS HIS ONLY THOUGHT. WHEN HE BROKE THE FIRST
MUSHROOM, IT BUMPED AGAINST OTHERS WHICH IN TURN KNOCKED DOWN THEIR NEIGHBORS UNTIL THE WHOLE
FOREST WAS FALLING. THERE WAS ONLY ONE THING NEMO CARED TO DO AND THAT WAS TO YELL, WHICH
HE DID WITH ALL HIS STRENGTH UNTIL HIS PAPA CAME IN AND AWOKE HIM.Winsor McCay, Little Nemo in Slumberland, 22 October 1905, captions to panels 8–11
The narration runs on while the pictures change, so the fall of the forest, which takes one breath of narration, is spread over three images. Inside the panels, characters speak in speech balloons, outlined shapes with tails pointing to the speaker. In the last panel the father asks, “DIDN’T MAMA TELL YOU NOT TO EAT THAT RAISIN CAKE LAST NIGHT? NOW GO TO SLEEP SON.” The caption reports that Nemo woke, the picture shows him in bed, and the balloon explains the dream as indigestion. This is relay at its fullest: the narrator, the drawing and the father each supply a part of the ending.
What happens in the gutter
The gutter, the blank space between panels, is where a comic’s time passes. Scott McCloud, in Understanding Comics (1993), called the reader’s work of joining separate panels into one action closure: between a mushroom that tips and a forest that lies flat, the reader supplies the fall. McCay controls that work through the size of his frames. The tall panels slow the walk through the forest, and the sudden return to a small, wide panel in the bedroom makes the waking abrupt, as waking is. A single-panel cartoon like Keppler’s has no gutters, so it must put everything into one moment, which is why its argument depends on scale and on words placed inside the scene.
What the cartoon assumes
Every satirical cartoon has a target and an audience, and it depends on the audience knowing things about the target that the drawing does not explain. Keppler’s label for one of the money bags at the center of the row shows how much he could take for granted:
STANDARD OIL TRUST
Joseph Keppler, “The Bosses of the Senate”, label
A reader of Puck in 1889 knew that Standard Oil controlled most of the country’s oil refining, knew the arguments in the newspapers about the power of the trusts, and knew Lincoln’s words on the banner by heart. The cartoon names its targets and leaves the case against them to that knowledge. A viewer today has to bring the context the original audience already had, and the effort changes the experience. A joke that once landed in a second now has to be explained, and the cartoon becomes a historical document as well as an argument.
The target of the satire is not the senators alone. They are shown as small, distracted and comfortable, reading and chatting while the giants watch over them, so the cartoon mocks them for allowing the trusts in as much as it attacks the trusts for coming. Satire usually works this way, by making its targets ridiculous rather than simply wicked, because ridicule invites the viewer to share the cartoonist’s superiority. Its limit is simplification. The cartoon shows every senator as owned, a claim no one could prove, and a viewer who agrees with its spirit should still notice what it has flattened.
Cartoons and offense
The means that make cartoons persuasive also make them dangerous. A caricature reduces a person or group to a few features, and when the group is defined by race, religion or nationality the reduction becomes a stereotype. Puck, like other American humor magazines of its time, regularly printed caricatures of Irish, Chinese, Jewish and Black Americans built on such stereotypes. An analysis of such a cartoon names the stereotype and explains how the drawing builds it: which features are exaggerated, how the figure is placed, what it is made to say. It then considers whom the stereotype served, without repeating the insult as if it were neutral description.
The question of offense is not only historical. In 2015 gunmen killed twelve people at the Paris offices of the satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo, which had published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad. In 2019 The New York Times announced that it would stop printing daily political cartoons in its international edition, soon after a cartoon it had published was widely condemned as antisemitic. The cartoonist Patrick Chappatte, who had drawn for the paper, argued in response that satire is necessary to free societies and that cartoonists face growing pressure from governments and from online outrage. Those who criticized the paper’s original cartoon argued that freedom to mock does not remove responsibility for what an image repeats. Both positions treat a cartoon as a public act with real consequences; they disagree about where its limits lie.
YouTubeFrom Punch to the feed
The word itself began as a joke. Before 1843 a cartoon was a full-size drawing made as the design for a painting or a fresco. That year the designs for frescoes in the new Houses of Parliament in London were on public show. The London humor magazine Punch responded by publishing its own satirical drawings as “cartoons”. The first was John Leech’s “Substance and Shadow” in July 1843, which showed hungry, ragged people among the designs on show and argued that the poor needed food more than art. The name stuck to the satirical drawing.
Pictures that argued are older than the word. Benjamin Franklin’s woodcut “Join, or Die”, printed in the Pennsylvania Gazette on 9 May 1754, shows a snake cut into eight pieces, each labeled with the initials of a British colony or region in North America. It needs almost no words: the snake that dies if it stays in pieces is an argument for the colonies to unite against the French, made with one symbol and a three-word caption. It was reprinted widely and revived during the American Revolution, which shows how easily a strong visual symbol can be moved from one argument to another.
JOIN, or DIE.
Benjamin Franklin (attributed), Pennsylvania Gazette, 9 May 1754, caption
The forms have multiplied since. Newspapers carried editorial cartoons and daily strips through the twentieth century, and many still do, though far fewer papers employ a cartoonist on staff than once did. Webcomics publish strips directly online, often in vertical formats designed to be scrolled on a phone. Animated cartoons and comic books grew from the same tools. The internet meme, an image with a caption remade and shared by thousands of people, works like a cartoon without a single author. It offers a picture everyone recognizes, words that change its meaning, and an audience expected to know the joke.
Writing about a cartoon
A paragraph about a cartoon describes its drawing precisely enough to be pictured, names the target, and explains how its exaggerations and words make the argument. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, is about the two doors and the banner in Keppler’s cartoon.
Keppler builds his attack on the Senate into the architecture of its chamber.note 1 High on the left wall, a small door labeled “PEOPLES’ ENTRANCE” is shut and marked “CLOSED”, while at floor level on the right a wide doorway marked “ENTRANCE FOR MONOPOLISTS” stands open, with the largest money-bag giant just through it.note 2 The banner between them rewrites Lincoln’s promise of government by the people as a Senate “OF THE MONOPOLISTS / BY THE MONOPOLISTS AND / FOR THE MONOPOLISTS!”, so the words supply the charge of betrayal that the drawing alone could not.note 3 For readers of 1889 who knew the Gettysburg Address, the cartoon turned a complaint about corruption into a claim that the republic itself had been taken over.note 4
A claim about method. The topic sentence names how the cartoon argues, not only what it argues.
Precise description. Position, size and labels are given exactly, so the evidence can be pictured.
Relay. The sentence explains what the banner adds that the image cannot, with a quotation from it.
Audience and context. The last sentence uses context to explain an effect on the original readers.
The same habit of describing before judging separates a weak and a strong sentence about the giants.
Weak: The cartoonist uses exaggeration to show that the businessmen are greedy and powerful.note 1
Strong: By drawing the trusts as giants whose bodies are money bags and the senators as small figures at their desks, Keppler makes the balance of power in the chamber visible at a glance.note 2
A formula. Exaggeration is named but not described, and the effect could follow from any cartoon about the rich.
Choice, contrast, effect. The sentence names two drawn choices, sets them against each other and says what the contrast does.
The strong sentence locates the exaggeration in particular figures and in a relation between them. A cartoon’s meaning usually lies in such contrasts of size, position and costume, and a sentence that names one is already analyzing.
Applying it in Paper 1
A cartoon in Paper 1 gives a student a compressed argument whose context may be unfamiliar. A guiding question on one is likely to direct attention to how the cartoon uses exaggeration and symbols to make its point. It may instead ask how image and words work together, or how the cartoon positions its viewer toward its target. A model sentence of analysis follows. Because the banner rewrites Lincoln’s promise while the drawing shows the people’s door closed, words and image together accuse the Senate of betraying the republic, a charge neither could make alone.
The commonest way to lose marks is to explain the issue instead of the cartoon, writing about trusts, elections or the history behind the drawing. Another is to name features (“caricature”, “symbolism”, “irony”) without describing the drawing that carries them. A response that describes the cartoon precisely, identifies its target and its audience, and analyzes two or three choices of scale, symbol and wording will usually reach further.
Its conventions in brief
Simplified drawing in a single panel or a sequence of panels.
Exaggeration of size, features and bodies, including caricature.
Symbols and visual puns that the audience recognizes at once.
Labels and captions that name and anchor what is drawn.
Words that add to the image (relay): banners, captions, speech balloons.
Panels and gutters that turn images into time, in comic strips.
A target, and an audience assumed to know the context.
Humor and ridicule used to argue, comment or entertain.
The cartoon leads to parody, which many cartoons use when they borrow a famous text or image. It leads too to the global issue of politics, power and justice, where editorial cartoons hold governments and the wealthy to account and sometimes face their anger.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what cartoons are for and distinguish the editorial cartoon, the comic strip and the gag cartoon.
- To do:
I can analyze exaggeration, caricature, symbols and visual puns in a single-panel cartoon.
- To do:
I can explain relay and anchorage and show how words and image share a cartoon’s message.
- To do:
I can analyze panels, gutters, captions and speech balloons in a comic strip.
- To do:
I can explain what a cartoon assumes its audience knows, and discuss cartoons built on stereotypes or that give offense.
- To do:
I can describe the history of the cartoon from Franklin and Punch to webcomics and memes.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph that describes a cartoon precisely and links its choices to its target and audience.
Key terms
Each is also in the Non-literary text types glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Caricature
A drawing that exaggerates the features, body or habits of a person or type so that they are recognized and judged at the same time. The exaggeration usually carries the cartoonist's opinion of the subject.
- Cartoon
A drawing, usually simplified and often humorous, that comments on people, events or ideas, with few or no words. Cartoons work through exaggeration and symbols that viewers recognize at once.
- Comic panel
One framed picture in a comic strip or graphic text, separated from the next by a narrow blank space called the gutter. The size and shape of panels, and the gaps between them, control how the reader experiences time.
- Comic strip
A sequence of drawn panels, read in order, that tells a short story or joke, usually with recurring characters. The order of the panels turns separate images into a sequence in time.
- Editorial cartoon
A cartoon published as opinion, usually in a newspaper or magazine, that comments on a current political or social issue. Like an opinion column, it argues a position, but through an image.
- Relay
A relation between words and image in which each carries part of a message that neither carries alone, so that the two must be read together. Roland Barthes named it as the complement of anchorage, in which words narrow what an image means.
- Speech balloon
An outlined space in a cartoon or comic that holds a character's words, with a tail pointing to the speaker. It turns a drawing into a scene with voices.
- Visual pun
A picture that plays on two meanings at once, often by drawing a figure of speech literally. It compresses two ideas into one image and rewards the viewer who sees both.
Practice questions on 6.5 Cartoon
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 6 questions on 6.5 Cartoon
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 6 Non-literary text types
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 6.1Advertisement
- 6.2Appeal
- 6.3Blog
- 6.4Brochure or leaflet
- 6.5CartoonThis page
- 6.6Diagram
- 6.7Electronic text
- 6.8Encyclopaedia entry
- 6.9Film and television
- 6.10Guide book
- 6.11Infographic
- 6.12Interview
- 6.13Music video
- 6.14Photograph
- 6.15Radio broadcast
- 6.16Report
- 6.17Screenplay for TV or film
- 6.18Set of instructions
- 6.19Textbook
- 6.20Work of art
- 6.21Autobiography or biography
- 6.22Diary entry
- 6.23Essay
- 6.24Letter
- 6.25Magazine article
- 6.26Manifesto
- 6.27Memoir
- 6.28Opinion column
- 6.29Parody
- 6.30Pastiche
- 6.31Speech
- 6.32Travelogue
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 6.5 Cartoon in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.


