- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- 6 Non-literary text types
- 6.28 Opinion column
6.28 Opinion column
What an opinion column is for and how it works: a named space and its furniture, column, op-ed and editorial, the news peg, paragraphs for a narrow column, loaded language, the kicker, and how columns vary and change.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 6 Non-literary text types
- SL and HL
Notes on 6.28 Opinion column
An opinion column is a regular piece of argument that appears in the same place in a publication, under the same name, at the same interval, and is written in the voice of one person. Its audience returns to it by choice, which makes the column different from almost every other persuasive text: it argues with people who already know the voice and expect to disagree with it sometimes. The Port Ellery Tide, a weekly newspaper of a harbor town in Nova Scotia, runs its column under the standing name Off the Wharf. This is the column from the issue of Thursday, October 24, 2024, the opinion column on the Saturday ferry.
A space with a name
A column is defined first by where it sits. Off the Wharf has a fixed place in the Tide’s opinion pages, and it appears every Thursday. Its name is a standing head, a title that stays the same from week to week, while each week’s piece gets its own headline. The standing head says this is the place where an opinion lives, so the paper’s news reports can stay impersonal around it. Anyone who opens the paper to Off the Wharf knows before reading a word that the text will be first person, local and arguable.
The diagram sets the furniture of Off the Wharf beside that of a typical national column. Most columns carry a byline, often with a small photograph, and many end with a tagline saying who the writer is. Off the Wharf has neither. The Tide prints it in a box signed only with the column’s name, a practice the paper has always kept, so the space has a voice but no named writer.


Without a name, the column’s authority must come from inside the text. The first sentence supplies it:
I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters, most of them on the 8 a.m. sailing with a thermos and a list for the Co-op.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 1
The sentence gives everything a byline would and more. It does not say who the writer is, but it says where the writer stands: on the island, on the boat, on Saturdays, for more than a decade. The thermos and the shopping list make the habit specific enough to trust. A national columnist borrows authority from fame, a job title or a photograph; this one earns it from the same ferry the column defends, and the column’s first word is the I that the missing byline leaves unnamed.
The unnamed voice is a persona, and in a standing column the persona outlasts any single piece. Readers of the Tide meet the same I every Thursday, with the same habits and the same dry humor, and they read each column against the ones before. A few real publications have worked this way for generations. The British weekly The Economist has long run its columns under standing names, with no writer’s name attached, so that the column’s voice belongs to the publication rather than to a person.
Column, op-ed and editorial
The three types share a page and differ in who speaks. An editorial is the newspaper speaking as an institution: it says what the paper thinks, usually without a byline, often in the first person plural or with no person at all. An op-ed is a guest’s argument, published once by a writer with some claim to be heard, an expert, an official or a citizen with a story. A column sits between them. It is a regular writer’s voice, owned by the publication as a feature but spoken by an individual.
Off the Wharf complicates the scheme in an instructive way. Like an editorial it carries no byline, yet nothing in it sounds institutional. Its third paragraph shows the difference:
I will grant the council this much: $212,000 is real money in a district our size, and nobody at the Co-op thinks budgets grow on spruce trees.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 3
“I will grant” is a person conceding a point, and “nobody at the Co-op” places that person in a shop queue. An editorial on the same subject would more likely say that the Tide recognizes the pressure on the district’s budget, a sentence with no thermos and no spruce trees in it. The column is unsigned, but its grammar and its details make it personal. That is why it reads as a column, and why it can be fair to the council in a way that sounds like good manners rather than official balance.
The op-ed has its own history. The New York Times began printing its op-ed page on September 21, 1970, opposite its editorial page, to open the paper to writers with no connection to it. The name described the page’s position, not its attitude. In 2021 the same paper renamed such pieces “Guest Essays”, partly because online readers no longer see a printed page with anything opposite it. The type survived the loss of the place that named it.
The news peg
A column is opinion, but it is printed in a newspaper, and it needs a reason to appear this week rather than any other. That reason is its news peg: the recent or coming event the argument hangs on. The ferry column’s peg is announced in its second paragraph:
The council would like to change that. A report tabled at last week’s meeting proposes cutting the Ellery Belle’s Saturday sailings from six to two.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 2
“Last week’s meeting” ties the column to the calendar of the paper itself. Readers of the Tide may have read about the meeting in the previous issue’s news pages, so the column does not repeat the news but answers it. The peg also decides the column’s order. Paragraph 1 is about the writer, but paragraph 2 must arrive quickly with the event, because a column that waited longer to say why it exists would lose anyone who came for the news.
The column’s time words fix it in one particular week. The writer went “down to the slip last Saturday” (paragraph 6), Wendell Corkum spoke “on the wharf on Tuesday” (paragraph 11), and the hearing is “Tuesday, Nov. 5” (paragraph 12). The diagram places those events on a line. Read from the date of the issue, the column reports a week of gathering evidence and points at a deadline twelve days away.


A column’s peg gives it urgency and also limits its life. After November 5 the call to “Come and fill it” (paragraph 12) can no longer be answered, and the column becomes a record of an argument rather than a part of one. Columns are written to a weekly or daily deadline for exactly that window. When a student meets a column out of its week, in a textbook or an anthology, part of the reading is to rebuild the calendar the first readers lived in.
A fixed space and a narrow column
The space a column fills is fixed, and its argument is cut to fit. Off the Wharf runs to 588 words in 13 paragraphs, so the average paragraph is about 45 words, two or three sentences. The shortest is the last, at 25 words; the longest is the seventh, at 89, the one that lists who rides the Saturday boat. Newspapers set columns in narrow strips of type, where a long paragraph becomes a gray block that the eye skips. Short paragraphs keep the page open and let each one carry a single step of the argument.
The one long paragraph breaks the pattern on purpose:
It looks like two hockey bags, a dog on its way to the vet, and Marjorie Langille, who is 91 and has had her hair done on Water Street every second Saturday since before the plant closed.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 7
In a column of short blocks, the longest paragraph is the one the eye notices on the page before reading it. Its length is the argument: the Saturday boat carries so many people and errands that the paragraph cannot hold them in two sentences. A columnist working in a fixed space has to choose where to spend words, and this column spends almost a sixth of them on the people the report counted as an average.
The same habits suit the screen. The Tide also publishes its stories on its website, where a paragraph of 45 words fills only a few lines of a phone screen. Columns written for print have moved online with little change, because the narrow newspaper column and the narrow phone screen ask for the same kind of paragraph.
Numbers set against people
The report’s case is a number, and a column that answers it has to decide what to do with the number. Off the Wharf concedes the figure first: “$212,000 is real money in a district our size” (paragraph 3). It never disputes it. It changes what a second figure means instead. The report counts an average of 58 passengers on each Saturday sailing and calls the boat under-used (paragraph 4). The column replies that an average hides who is on board, and paragraph 7 names them: four teenagers with Saturday jobs, the volunteers who open the food bank, two hockey bags, a dog, and a woman of 91.
The list works as a counter-statistic. Fifty-eight is a count of anonymous seats, and each item in the paragraph is a reason one of those seats is filled, so the column turns a count into a set of cases without adding a number. The only other figure it repeats is “from six to two” (paragraph 2), which it leaves unargued because readers of a weekly can see for themselves what losing four of six sailings does to a Saturday.
A column is free to choose its cases, which a report is not. Every person in paragraph 7 supports the writer, and no passenger who would happily travel on a Tuesday appears. A skeptical reader would test exactly that. Paragraph 8 answers part of it: most of these islanders already spend the week in town, so Saturday is the one day the trips cannot be moved.
The humor is spent twice. “So is the fire hall, most days” (paragraph 4) is an analogy with a laugh in it: if low use were a reason to close a building, the fire hall would be locked. When the public hearing turns out to be in the fire hall (paragraph 12), the joke becomes an instruction, “Come and fill it”, and the column ends its call to action on “nobody will call it under-used”. The joke therefore carries the call to action as well as the argument.
Loaded language, used sparingly
Opinion writing depends on loaded language, and most columns use plenty of it. A columnist who calls a cut “savage” or a council “arrogant” has made the argument with one adjective. The ferry column is striking for how little of this it does in its own voice. Its sharpest word is applied to an imagined case, not to anyone real:
Deputy Mayor Ruth Mosher has been straight with us about the numbers. I would rather argue with a straight answer than nod along to a crooked one.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 3
Crooked is loaded, but it describes an answer the deputy mayor did not give. The column names a real official in its own town and praises her, because in a district of a few thousand people the columnist and the deputy mayor may meet at the Co-op the same afternoon. The column’s space, a weekly paper read by neighbors, sets limits on its vocabulary that a national columnist writing about distant politicians does not face.
The loaded words the column does use belong to its opponents. It reports the council’s word, “under-used” (paragraph 4), as the council’s, and puts the report’s phrase in quotation marks, “shift discretionary travel to weekdays” (paragraph 6), so that readers hear how it sounds beside the people it describes. Quotation marks make another writer’s words into evidence. The column’s own diction stays plain, so the official words stand out as the only cold ones on the page.
The kicker
Journalists call the last line of a column its kicker, the sentence a reader carries away. The ferry column’s kicker repeats its headline:
Keep the Saturday ferry, and we will keep filling it.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 13
On the page, the headline and the kicker frame the column like the two ends of its box. In many newspapers headlines are written by editors, not by columnists, so a kicker that echoes the headline word for word shows a column built as one object from top to bottom. The repetition also serves the skimmer, who may read only the headline and the last line: the two together give the whole position, and the second adds the promise that the island will use what it is given.
Try it
The column names three real people from Port Ellery: a deputy mayor (paragraph 3), a ferry captain (paragraph 10) and a man with forty years on the water (paragraph 11). Why might a local column name officials and neighbors so freely, when a national column on the same issue might not?
In a small town the people named are known to the readers, and naming them is part of the column’s credibility: anyone can check what Captain Thibodeau or Wendell Corkum said by asking them. Naming the deputy mayor with praise shows fairness to someone readers will meet in person. A national column addresses strangers, so named locals would mean nothing to its readers, and it would more often quote statistics or institutions instead.
The column as a column
The annotated lines gather the features that make the text a column rather than an argument in general: its furniture, its peg, its local space and its frame.
Keep the Saturday ferrynote 1 … I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven wintersnote 2 … A report tabled at last week’s meetingnote 3 proposes cutting the Ellery Belle’s Saturday sailings from six to two. … Deputy Mayor Ruth Mosher has been straight with us about the numbers.note 4 … The council’s report calls it under-used.note 5 … She asked me to print that it is not discretionary. I have.note 6 … “Cut a sailing and you don’t get it back,” Wendell Corkum said on the wharf on Tuesday.note 7 … The council will hear from the public at the fire hall on Tuesday, Nov. 5, at 7 p.m.note 8 … Keep the Saturday ferry, and we will keep filling it.note 9
Headline as position. An imperative that states the whole case, under the unchanging standing head Off the Wharf.
Authority without a byline. The unnamed I earns the right to speak from eleven winters of crossings.
The news peg. “Last week’s meeting” ties the column to the paper’s own news calendar.
A named neighbor. A local column can name an official and praise her, because its readers know her.
Loaded words kept in the opponent’s mouth. The report’s term is quoted, not adopted.
The columnist as printer. The text points to its own publication: a column is a space someone controls.
Evidence from this week. A quotation gathered on a dated day, as a reporter would gather it.
News-style detail. The house style of a public notice (“Nov. 5”, “7 p.m.”) turns the column’s ending into practical information.
The kicker. The headline’s words return with a promise, closing the box.
Read together, the notes show a column shaped by its space at every level. The weekly slot supplies the peg, the small readership permits named neighbors and forbids insults, the narrow box asks for short paragraphs, and the unsigned standing head throws all the authority onto the voice. Remove the newspaper around it and the same argument would have to be written differently.
Across publications and across time
Columns differ most between local and national publications. A national columnist writes for an audience that shares no streets, so the evidence is statistics, reports and public figures, and the persona is built over years of bylined pieces until the name itself is the authority. Some national columnists become public figures whose columns are read as much for the person as for the argument. Local columns, like Off the Wharf, can rely on shared places and people and must live with the fact that their subjects read them.
The name as the argument
A famous piece of opinion journalism shows the opposite extreme from an unsigned local box. On 13 January 1898 the Paris daily L’Aurore filled its front page with an open letter from the novelist Émile Zola to the president of France, Félix Faure. It accused senior army officers of covering up the wrongful conviction of Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish officer sentenced for treason in 1894. The front page reads, from the top:
L’AURORE
Littéraire, Artistique, Sociale
J’Accuse…!
LETTRE AU PRÉSIDENT DE LA RÉPUBLIQUE
Par ÉMILE ZOLAL’Aurore, front page, 13 January 1898
Everything about the page’s furniture is the reverse of Off the Wharf. The writer’s name is set almost as large as the headline, because Zola’s fame as a novelist was what would make a newspaper accusing generals believable. The headline, “J’Accuse…!” (“I accuse…!”), is the most loaded phrase possible, a first-person charge, and the letter goes on to name the officers it accuses. The text appears once, on the front page rather than the opinion page, as an event rather than a regular feature. Zola was prosecuted for libel and convicted, and he left France for England for about a year; Dreyfus was eventually cleared in 1906.
Set beside the ferry column, the front page shows how the place and the name of an opinion piece shape its language. A neighbor in a weekly box can be fair to a deputy mayor and leave her name unmarked by any loaded word. A famous writer on a national front page can use his name as evidence and the word accuse as a headline, and must accept the consequences that go with it.
Columns have also changed with their media. Newsletter columns sent by email to subscribers keep the regular slot and the personal voice but lose the surrounding newspaper, so the writer must supply the peg and the context that the paper used to provide. Blog columns and social media threads add a comment thread, so people who once argued with a column at the Co-op can now argue under it. The convention of the regular voice has survived every change of medium, because audiences keep returning to voices they know.
When a column becomes literature
A column is usually a non-literary text: it argues about a public issue for a particular week. It can count as literary when its design asks to be read for its own sake, beyond its occasion. Novelists, poets and essayists have often written regular newspaper columns, and when such columns are collected and published as a book, they are read for their voice, their style and their observation long after their pegs have passed. At that point they belong with the essay and with literary non-fiction. A famous author does not make every piece literary, however. Zola’s letter is the work of a novelist, but its purpose is to change a verdict, and it is read as an act of journalism.
The distinction matters for the individual oral, which pairs a literary work with a non-literary body of work. A columnist’s pieces over a season or a year make a strong non-literary body of work, since they share a voice, a space and an audience. A published collection of a literary author’s columns might be treated as a literary work instead. Teachers decide such questions for their courses, and a student who uses columns in the oral should be able to say on which side of the line they fall and why.
Writing about a column
A paragraph about a column links the writer’s choices to the column’s situation: its space, its readers and its week. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, is about the column’s missing byline.
Because Off the Wharf appears without a byline, the ferry column must build its authority inside its first sentence.note 1 “I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters” (paragraph 1) does the work of a name and a photograph, placing the unnamed writer on the boat, on the island and in the community for more than a decade.note 2 The domestic details that follow, “a thermos and a list for the Co-op”, make the habit concrete enough to trust, and they introduce the column’s method of arguing from what ordinary people carry and do.note 3 The persona therefore earns the right to speak for the island before the council’s figures appear in paragraph 2, which makes the report’s numbers look like the voice of people who have never made the crossing.note 4
Situation first. The claim begins from the column’s furniture, a fact about the space.
Quotation as evidence. The first sentence is quoted and its function named.
Detail and method. The paragraph shows how small details serve the whole argument.
Effect on the argument. It ends by explaining what the order of the opening does to the opposing case.
A weaker treatment of the same opening would name the feature and attach a general effect. The pair that follows shows the difference.
Weak: The writer uses first person and personal anecdote to connect with the reader and make the column more persuasive.note 1
Strong: With no byline to rely on, the column opens on “eleven winters” of Saturday crossings, so the writer’s claim to speak comes from the ferry itself rather than from a name.note 2
Features without a situation. First person and anecdote are in almost every column; the sentence does not say what they do here, or why this column needs them.
Choice explained by space. The rewrite connects the opening to the missing byline and names the source of authority.
The strong sentence explains the convention by the column’s situation, which is the habit this whole type rewards. A feature of a column usually makes sense once the writer’s position, the publication and the week are in view.
Applying it in Paper 1
A column in Paper 1 offers an argument with a visible writer, a clear position and a particular audience, usually with its headline and sometimes with its byline and photograph. A guiding question on a column is likely to direct attention to how the writer persuades, how a persona or voice is built, or how the column addresses its readers. A model sentence of analysis follows. By quoting the report’s “discretionary travel” and then describing the people on the Saturday boat, the column keeps loaded language in its opponents’ mouths and lets its own plain words sound like common sense.
The commonest way to lose marks is to treat the column as a list of persuasive features detached from its situation, so that the essay never says who is writing. It also leaves out the publication, the readers and what the column answers. Another is to retell the argument instead of analyzing how it is made. A response that names the peg, the persona and the audience early, then follows two or three choices through the column, usually reaches further.
Its conventions in brief
A regular space under a standing head, at a fixed interval and length.
A headline that states the position, often as an imperative or a short claim.
A first-person voice whose authority comes from a name, a byline or experience.
A news peg: the recent or coming event that makes the column timely.
Short paragraphs that each carry one step of the argument.
Evidence chosen to persuade: anecdote, figures, quotation, named people.
Loaded language, used freely or sparingly according to the readership.
A kicker, often echoing the headline or calling readers to act.
The opinion column leads to the report, which presents the same kind of facts in an impersonal voice, and to the concept of perspective, since a column is the most openly positioned text a newspaper prints. The letter to the editor is its answer from the readers’ side of the page.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what an opinion column is and how its fixed place in a publication shapes its conventions.
- To do:
I can distinguish a column from an op-ed and an editorial, and say where the authority comes from in each.
- To do:
I can identify a column’s news peg and explain how it shapes the column’s order and life.
- To do:
I can analyze a column’s persona, paragraphing, loaded language and kicker on a complete example.
- To do:
I can compare a local column with a national opinion piece and explain how columns have changed.
- To do:
I can say what would make a column literary and why the distinction matters for the oral.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph that explains a column’s choices by its space, its readers and its week.
Key terms
Each is also in the Non-literary text types glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Editorial
An opinion piece that states a publication's own position on an issue, usually unsigned and written in the voice of the institution rather than of a person.
- Kicker
The last line of a column or feature, written to be remembered and repeated. A kicker often echoes the headline or the opening and may call readers to act.
- Loaded language
Words chosen because they carry strong approval or disapproval beyond their plain meaning, so that they push a reader toward a judgment while seeming only to describe.
- News peg
The recent or coming event that gives a column, feature or opinion piece its reason to appear at a particular time. The peg decides how timely the piece is and often what it must mention first.
- Op-ed
A single opinion piece by a writer from outside a publication, traditionally printed on the page opposite the editorial page. Its writer is usually chosen for expertise, office or a story worth telling.
- Opinion column
A regular piece of argument that appears in the same place in a publication, under the same name and at the same interval, written in the first-person voice of one writer. Its authority comes from that writer's name, experience or long-standing persona.
- Standing head
A title that stays the same from issue to issue over a regular feature or column, while each week's piece receives its own headline. It marks the space as one voice's or one feature's own.
Practice questions on 6.28 Opinion column
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 9 questions on 6.28 Opinion column
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 6 Non-literary text types
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 6.1Advertisement
- 6.2Appeal
- 6.3Blog
- 6.4Brochure or leaflet
- 6.5Cartoon
- 6.6Diagram
- 6.7Electronic text
- 6.8Encyclopaedia entry
- 6.9Film and television
- 6.10Guide book
- 6.11Infographic
- 6.12Interview
- 6.13Music video
- 6.14Photograph
- 6.15Radio broadcast
- 6.16Report
- 6.17Screenplay for TV or film
- 6.18Set of instructions
- 6.19Textbook
- 6.20Work of art
- 6.21Autobiography or biography
- 6.22Diary entry
- 6.23Essay
- 6.24Letter
- 6.25Magazine article
- 6.26Manifesto
- 6.27Memoir
- 6.28Opinion columnThis page
- 6.29Parody
- 6.30Pastiche
- 6.31Speech
- 6.32Travelogue
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 6.28 Opinion column in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.