6.29 Parody
What a parody is for and how it works: recognition of the original, what is kept and changed, incongruity and the mock-heroic, parody and satire, spoofs, culture jamming and fake news, change over time, and when a parody is literary.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 6 Non-literary text types
- SL and HL
Notes on 6.29 Parody
A parody imitates the recognizable style, form or conventions of another text and changes them, usually to mock, criticize or amuse. Its situation is unusual: it is written for an audience that already knows another text, and it means something only to them. Two short poems show the arrangement. The first is “Against Idleness and Mischief” by the English hymn writer Isaac Watts, from a book of moral songs for children first published in 1715.
Many Victorian children learned Watts’s songs by heart and could still recite them as adults. In 1865 Lewis Carroll put a version of this one into Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. Alice has grown and shrunk and no longer feels sure who she is. To test her memory she crosses her hands on her lap “as if she were saying lessons” and tries to recite the song, but “the words did not come the same as they used to do”. This is what comes out.
What a parody is for
Carroll’s poem is funny only to a reader who hears Watts’s poem under it. A reader who has never met “How doth the little busy Bee” sees a pleasant nonsense verse about a crocodile. A Victorian child who had recited the bee in school hears the familiar first line and then a crocodile where the bee should be. The joke is in the gap between the two, and only a reader holding both can see it.
How doth the little busy Bee
How doth the little crocodile“Against Idleness and Mischief”, line 1, and “How doth the little crocodile”, line 1
The first four words, “How doth the little”, are identical, and that is the point. A parody must keep enough of its original to be recognized at once, and the opening line is where recognition is fastest, since it is the line most people remember. Only the last word changes. The swap of busy Bee for crocodile turns a model of useful work into a predator, and the whole parody grows from that one substitution.
The parody’s audience is therefore narrower than the original’s. Watts wrote for any child who could read, and a line such as “I would be busy too” (line 10) needs nothing outside itself. Carroll wrote for readers who shared a schoolroom culture, which is why many readers today meet his poem first and learn of Watts’s only from a footnote. A parody of a forgotten text loses its edge, though it may survive as something else, as Carroll’s “gently smiling jaws” (line 8) have survived in a nonsense poem enjoyed for its own sake.
Recognition and the reader’s knowledge
Carroll makes recognition part of his story. Alice herself notices the change at once, saying in the next line that she is “sure those are not the right words”. Her distress is comic because a child’s whole education seems to have slipped, and the parody turns a lesson in obedience into evidence that she is no longer the same person. The setting tells the reader how to read the poem. It is a lesson recited wrongly, so it should be compared with the lesson.
Non-literary parodies signal their originals in the same way, through the features an audience recognizes fastest, as Carroll’s did with “How doth”. A mock advertisement keeps the layout, the slogan and the logo of the kind of advertisement it imitates. A parody of a news report keeps its headline style and its neutral voice. Each depends on an audience who has seen thousands of real examples, and each fails, or is mistaken for the real thing, when that knowledge is missing.
What a parody keeps and what it changes
A parody works by holding most things steady, such as the opening “How doth”, and changing a few. The diagram sets out Carroll’s choices line against line: what he kept so that Watts would be recognized, and what he changed so that the meaning would turn. The kept features are all formal, the opening words, the four-line stanzas and the rhyme. The changed features are all matters of content and attitude.


How skilfully she builds her Cell!
How neat she spreads the Wax;
How cheerfully he seems to grin,
How neatly spreads his claws,“Against Idleness and Mischief”, lines 5–6, and “How doth the little crocodile”, lines 5–6
Carroll’s second stanza copies the shape of Watts’s exactly: two exclamations beginning “How”, the second with the verb spreads. In Watts the bee “builds” and “spreads” in order to make honey, so each verb is a piece of work. In Carroll the crocodile grins and spreads his claws, and the reason is given in the last line: he “welcomes little fishes in / With gently smiling jaws” (lines 7–8). The verbs of industry have become the verbs of a host, and the host is about to eat his guests.
The adverbs carry the irony. Watts’s “skilfully” praises a craft; Carroll’s cheerfully and gently describe a manner. A crocodile that “seems to grin” only seems so, and gently smiling jaws joins the softest adverb in the poem to the most dangerous noun. The effect is a smile that cannot be trusted. Watts’s poem holds that nature is a teacher of virtue. Carroll’s keeps the teacher’s tone and lets nature teach something else.
The lesson left out
The largest change is a silence. Watts’s third and fourth stanzas turn from the bee to the child: “I would be busy too: / For Satan finds some Mischief still / For idle Hands to do” (lines 10–12). This is the purpose of the song, a moral drawn from the example, and the warning about idle hands passed into common speech. Carroll writes no third stanza. His crocodile is never made into a lesson, so the poem ends at the jaws, and the reader has to supply the moral, or notice that there is none.
Leaving out the moral is a comment on moral verse. Watts’s song assumes that every creature, even a “little busy Bee”, can be read as an example for children. Carroll’s parody demonstrates how easily the same form can describe an animal whose example no one would follow, which makes the assumption look less certain. Whether this mocks Watts or only plays with him is a question readers have answered differently, and the answer depends on how much weight is given to a schoolroom full of children reciting his verse.
The parodist’s methods
Every parody changes its original in one or more of a few ways, and Carroll’s eight lines, from “little crocodile” to “smiling jaws”, use three of them. The first is incongruity, the placing of something where it does not belong. A crocodile in a children’s hymn about industry is incongruous, and so is the Nile in a poem whose original stays with a hive and its flowers. The second is solemnity kept for a subject that does not deserve it. Carroll preserves Watts’s archaic doth and his tone of pious admiration, so the crocodile is praised in the voice of a Sunday school.
And pour the waters of the Nile
On every golden scale!“How doth the little crocodile”, lines 3–4
The lines are beautiful, and that is part of the joke. Watts’s bee gathers honey “From ev’ry op’ning Flow’r” (line 4), an act of useful labor. Carroll’s crocodile pours river water over his own scales, an act of grooming, and the poem admires it with the same closing exclamation. The third method is the most common of all, exaggeration, which pushes a feature of the original past the point where it can be taken seriously. Carroll exaggerates little, and his strength is the straight face.
The mock-heroic
One old form of parody turns solemnity into a whole method. The mock-heroic describes a small or silly subject in the grand language of epic poetry, with its invocations, battles and speeches. Alexander Pope’s The Rape of the Lock (1714) tells a quarrel between two families over a stolen lock of hair as if it were a war out of Homer. It has a battle of fans, and a pair of scissors is described like a hero’s weapon. The gap between style and subject mocks the triviality of fashionable society, and also, gently, the epic itself.
The same method works in non-literary texts: a sports report that describes a school football match as a clash of empires is mock-heroic, and it is a parody even though it imitates no single text.
Parody and satire
Parody and satire are often confused because they so often appear together. Satire exposes the faults of people, institutions or societies by making them ridiculous, in order to criticize them. Parody imitates a text or type. A satire can use many methods, and parody is one of its favorites, because imitating the way people speak or write is a quick way to expose how they think. The clearest example in English is a pamphlet of 1729 by the Irish writer Jonathan Swift.
The full title of A Modest Proposal continues “for Preventing the Children of Poor People from Being a Burthen to Their Parents, or the Country”. It copies the long, earnest titles of the economic pamphlets of its day, in which writers called projectors proposed schemes to cure Ireland’s poverty. It proposes that the children of the Irish poor be sold at a year old as food for the rich. Everything about it imitates a sensible proposal: the calculations, the concessions to objections, the polite tone. Two sentences from its seventh page show the method.
I have reckoned upon a Medium, that a Child just born will weigh 12 pounds, and in a solar Year if tollerably nursed encreaseth to 28 Pound.
I grant this food will be somewhat dear, and therefore very proper for Landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the Parents, seem to have the best Title to the Children.Jonathan Swift, A Modest Proposal (Dublin, 1729), page 7
The first sentence parodies the pamphlet’s habit of measurement. “Reckoned upon a Medium” means calculated on average, and the weights in pounds belong to cattle sold at market. The calm arithmetic is what makes the proposal monstrous, since it treats children exactly as the pamphlets treated grain and wool. The second sentence begins with a concession, “I grant”, as a careful arguer would. It then turns the concession into an accusation: landlords have “already devoured most of the Parents”, so eating the children only finishes what they began.
Here the parody and the satire separate. The parody’s target is a kind of text, the projector’s pamphlet, with its “12 pounds” and its reasonable voice. The satire’s target is a class of people and a policy: the landlords and the English rule that left the Irish poor to starve, and the readers who could discuss poverty as a problem of figures. The pamphlet form is the weapon, and the landlords are what it is aimed at.
The spoof
At the light end of parody is the spoof, made for fun more than for criticism, whose target is a familiar formula rather than one work. The American film Airplane! (1980) spoofs the disaster films of the 1970s, copying their crises in the cockpit, brave pilots and passengers in peril while its jokes take the dialogue literally. It has no quarrel with the films and no political target, unlike Swift’s “proper for Landlords”. It asks only that its audience know the formula well enough to enjoy seeing it pulled apart.
Try it
Swift’s pamphlet begins its argument with “I grant”, the language of concession that a careful arguer uses to admit an objection. Why might a satirist imitate the most reasonable features of a pamphlet rather than its most extreme?
The reasonable features are what make the proposal seem acceptable to its readers, and that is Swift’s target. If the pamphlet sounded mad, readers could dismiss it. Because it sounds like every sensible scheme they have read, with calculations and concessions, they are forced to see that the same calm voice was already being used to discuss real suffering as a matter of figures. The more reasonable the imitation, the sharper the accusation.
Parodies of non-literary texts
Any text type with strong conventions can be parodied, and the non-literary types are the easiest, because their conventions are seen every day. The advertisement is the commonest target. The book’s advertisement from The Port Ellery Tide, for Tidemark Hardware & Marine, shows the features a mock advertisement would keep. It has a large picture of the product, a punning headline, a list of stock and a slogan in italic above the shop’s name.
We know the ropes.
We’ve got it, or we’ll get it.Tidemark Hardware & Marine advertisement, The Port Ellery Tide: headline and slogan
A parody of this advertisement would keep the coil of rope, the bold headline and the confident slogan, and change what they promise. If the shop were raising its prices after the winter storm, a local wit might keep “We know the ropes” and add a smaller line under it about knowing the prices too. The parody would work only in Port Ellery, among readers who see the real advertisement every week, which is the same narrow audience that Carroll relied on. The confident second-person promises of advertising are what make it so easy to turn.
Culture jamming and the fake news story
Parody of advertising has become a movement of its own. Culture jamming alters or imitates real advertisements so that they criticize the companies or the consumer culture behind them. The Canadian magazine Adbusters, founded in Vancouver in 1989, printed “subvertisements”: pages that copied the photography, typefaces and slogans of famous brands and turned them into warnings about smoking, drinking or debt. Painted-over billboards and altered logos do the same work in the street. A culture jam needs the brand’s own style, because the borrowed style is what makes viewers stop and look.
The fake news story is the other common parody of a non-literary type. Satirical news sites such as The Onion, founded as a student paper in Madison, Wisconsin, in 1988, imitate the headline, the neutral voice and the quoted sources of a real report, and attach them to absurd or painfully true events. On social media, accounts that imitate a politician or a company are usually required to label themselves as parody, because without the label some readers take them for the real thing.
Parody across media and time
Parody is as old as the forms it imitates. Ancient Greek comedy parodied tragedy. In the early seventeenth century Miguel de Cervantes built Don Quixote (1605 and 1615) on a parody of the chivalric romances that Spanish readers loved. Its hero is a country gentleman who has read so many that he sets out to be a knight. The video from TED-Ed introduces the novel and its relation to those romances.
YouTubeCarroll’s other parodies
Carroll parodied several of the moral poems that children of his day had to learn. “You Are Old, Father William”, recited by Alice later in the book, answers Robert Southey’s “The Old Man’s Comforts, and How He Gained Them” (1799). In Southey’s poem a pious old man explains that he lived carefully when young; Carroll’s old man stands on his head and boasts. The fifth stanza is typical.
“You are old,” said the youth, “and your jaws are too weak
For anything tougher than suet;
Yet you finished the goose, with the bones and the beak—
Pray, how did you manage to do it?”Lewis Carroll, “You Are Old, Father William”, stanza 5, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (1865)
The youth’s question keeps the polite form of Southey’s, a young man asking an elder for the secret of a good old age, but the achievement he asks about is eating a goose “with the bones and the beak”. John Tenniel’s illustration of the stanza shows the old man as a stout, grinning figure in a flowered waistcoat, pipe in hand, at a table with an empty plate, while a thin young man leans over it holding up a dish cover.

The picture does visually what the parody does in words. Southey’s old man is a model of moderation. Tenniel draws a glutton, delighted with himself, beside the cleared plate. The young questioner is the earnest reader of moral verse, staring at an example he cannot learn from. In both of Carroll’s parodies the moral form survives and the moral disappears.
Sketches, memes and the parody video
Television made parody a staple form in sketch shows that imitate news programs, advertisements and other shows, and the internet has multiplied it. A parody music video copies a famous video shot by shot with new words, and a meme template is a parody form that anyone can fill. A parody of a video that everyone watched last month may be meaningless in a year, so online parody makes plain how much the type depends on shared, current knowledge.
Must a parody mock?
Critics disagree about whether ridicule belongs in the definition of parody. Linda Hutcheon, in A Theory of Parody (1985), argued that modern parody is repetition with critical distance, imitation that marks its difference from the original, and that it need not ridicule at all. It can honor its original while commenting on it. Margaret Rose, in Parody: Ancient, Modern and Post-Modern (1993), insisted on the comic, holding that a definition without comedy loses what has made parody distinct since antiquity.
Carroll’s crocodile, with its “gently smiling jaws”, supports both positions. It is comic, as Rose’s definition requires, but its comedy hardly attacks Watts; it plays with him and comments on a kind of verse, which fits Hutcheon’s wider idea. The disagreement matters most for texts that imitate seriously. A protest that borrows the form of a national declaration to argue for new rights is a parody in Hutcheon’s sense but not in Rose’s, and calling it one is a choice that should be explained.
Reading the parody line by line
The annotated reading that follows returns to Carroll’s poem with Watts’s in mind. Each note names what is kept or changed and what the change does.
How doth the little crocodilenote 1
Improve his shining tail,note 2
And pour the waters of the Nilenote 3
On every golden scale!
How cheerfully he seems to grin,note 4
How neatly spreads his claws,note 5
And welcomes little fishes innote 6
With gently smiling jaws!note 7
The original recognized. Watts’s first four words are kept and only the animal changes, so the reader hears the hymn and meets a predator.
A verb of virtue turned to vanity. Watts’s bee improves “each shining Hour”; the crocodile improves his own tail, so time well used becomes self-admiration.
Incongruity of place. The Nile replaces an English garden, and pouring water over scales replaces gathering honey: grooming in place of work.
Manner in place of skill. Cheerfully replaces Watts’s “skilfully”, and seems warns that the grin may not mean what it shows.
The structure kept exactly. Two exclamations beginning “How”, with the same verb spreads, so the parallel with “How neat she spreads the Wax” is unmistakable.
The language of a host. Welcomes is polite, which makes the invitation sinister.
The turn, and the end. The softest adverb meets the most dangerous noun, and the poem stops where Watts’s moral would begin.
Read with the notes, the poem shows the classic proportions of parody: form almost entirely kept, content and attitude changed, and the missing moral doing the most work. Without Watts beside it, five of the seven notes could not be written.
When a parody is literary
And welcomes little fishes in
With gently smiling jaws!“How doth the little crocodile”, lines 7–8
Some parodies are literary works, and some are non-literary texts. Carroll’s crocodile is literary on every count, and these two lines show why: their sound and timing are shaped as carefully as any lyric’s. It is part of a novel by a literary author, it is designed with care for its sound and form, and it parodies a literary original. Don Quixote and The Rape of the Lock are major literary works built on parody. Swift’s pamphlet sits on both sides: it was published as a political pamphlet in Dublin and is now read as one of the most famous works of satire in English.
A mock advertisement, a culture jam, a satirical news story and a parody account are non-literary texts. They are made for an audience at a moment, they borrow the conventions of other non-literary types, and they are read for their purpose and effect. The distinction matters for the individual oral, which pairs one literary work with one non-literary body of work. A run of a satirical magazine’s covers, or one culture-jamming campaign, can form a non-literary body of work, while a novel built on parody, such as Don Quixote, serves as a literary work. A student should be ready to say which side a parody falls on, and why.
Writing about a parody
A paragraph about a parody names the original, shows what is kept so that it is recognized, and explains what the change does. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, takes Carroll’s second stanza.
Carroll’s parody keeps the shape of Watts’s praise of the bee so exactly that its change of subject becomes a change of moral.note 1 His second stanza copies Watts’s two exclamations beginning “How” and even his verb, so “How neatly spreads his claws” cannot be heard without “How neat she spreads the Wax”.note 2 But where the bee spreads wax to store food, the crocodile spreads claws to catch it, and the line that should complete the example, “With gently smiling jaws”, ends on the animal’s appetite instead.note 3 By stopping there and dropping Watts’s two moral stanzas, the parody leaves the form of a lesson with nothing to teach, which quietly questions the habit of reading every creature as an example for children.note 4
Claim about the parody’s method. The topic sentence links what is kept (the shape) to what the change does (the moral).
The original named and quoted. Both texts are quoted side by side, so the reader sees what makes the parody recognizable.
The change and its effect. The paragraph explains how the same verb serves a different purpose.
What is left out. The last sentence analyzes an absence, the missing moral, and states the parody’s comment on its original.
The weak sentence that follows makes the commonest fault in writing about parody: it treats the parody alone. The strong one brings in the original.
Weak: The poem uses humor and exaggeration to make fun of the crocodile and entertain the reader.note 1
Strong: Carroll’s crocodile is praised in Watts’s pious voice, with the hymn’s doth and its exclamation marks, so the joke falls on a kind of verse that could make any creature a lesson, more than on the crocodile.note 2
The target missed. “Make fun of the crocodile” misreads the parody’s target, and “humor and exaggeration” names no line.
Original, method, target. The sentence names what is borrowed from Watts, how it is used, and what the parody is about.
Applying it in Paper 1
A parody in Paper 1 is most likely to be a mock advertisement, a satirical news story, a spoof leaflet or an extract from a satirical column, since these are the non-literary parodies most often published. What it offers to analyze is its double nature: the conventions of the type it imitates, which a student must identify, and the changes that turn them. Its target, its audience’s knowledge and its tone matter as much as its features. A guiding question on a parody is likely to ask how the text uses the conventions of another type to criticize or amuse, or how it presents its target.
A model sentence of analysis follows. By borrowing the calm arithmetic of an economic pamphlet, “reckoned upon a Medium”, Swift’s proposal applies its readers’ own reasonable talk about poverty to children, so the parody of a form becomes a satire of the people who used it. The commonest way to lose marks is to analyze a parody as if it were a straightforward example of the type it imitates, taking its claims at face value. Another is to say that it is “satire” without naming what is imitated or what is attacked.
Its conventions in brief
A recognizable original: a particular text, a style or a whole type.
Form kept closely (opening words, layout, structure, voice), so the original is recognized at once.
Content, scale or attitude changed, so the meaning turns.
Methods of incongruity, exaggeration and mock solemnity.
An audience who must know the original for the parody to work.
A target, which may be the original itself or something in the world (in satire).
Signals, such as a label, an impossible detail or a setting, that mark it as parody.
Parody leads to its gentler relative, pastiche, which imitates a style without turning against it, and to intertextuality, the wider study of how texts depend on other texts for their meaning.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what a parody is for and why it depends on its audience knowing the original.
- To do:
I can identify what a parody keeps from its original and what it changes, and explain the effect of the difference.
- To do:
I can distinguish parody from satire and spoof, and explain how a satire such as Swift’s uses parody.
- To do:
I can recognize parodies of non-literary types, including the mock advertisement, the fake news story and culture jamming.
- To do:
I can explain the methods of incongruity, exaggeration and the mock-heroic.
- To do:
I can describe the debate over whether parody must mock, and how parody has changed across media.
- To do:
I can explain what would make a parody literary and why it matters for the individual oral.
Key terms
Each is also in the Non-literary text types glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Culture jamming
The practice of altering or imitating advertisements and other commercial messages so that they criticize the companies or the consumer culture that produced them. It turns a brand’s own style against it.
- Mock-heroic
A style that describes a small or trivial subject in the grand language and forms of epic and heroic writing. The gap between the style and the subject produces comedy and can mock either one.
- Parody
A text that imitates the recognizable style, form or conventions of another text or type and changes them, usually to mock, criticize or amuse. It depends on its audience knowing the original well enough to see the difference.
- Satire
Writing or art that exposes the faults of people, institutions or societies by making them ridiculous, in order to criticize them. It often uses irony, exaggeration and parody as its methods.
- Spoof
A light, playful parody, usually of a popular genre or kind of text, made more for fun than for criticism. Its target is a familiar formula rather than a particular work.
Practice questions on 6.29 Parody
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 3 questions on 6.29 Parody
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 6 Non-literary text types
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 6.1Advertisement
- 6.2Appeal
- 6.3Blog
- 6.4Brochure or leaflet
- 6.5Cartoon
- 6.6Diagram
- 6.7Electronic text
- 6.8Encyclopaedia entry
- 6.9Film and television
- 6.10Guide book
- 6.11Infographic
- 6.12Interview
- 6.13Music video
- 6.14Photograph
- 6.15Radio broadcast
- 6.16Report
- 6.17Screenplay for TV or film
- 6.18Set of instructions
- 6.19Textbook
- 6.20Work of art
- 6.21Autobiography or biography
- 6.22Diary entry
- 6.23Essay
- 6.24Letter
- 6.25Magazine article
- 6.26Manifesto
- 6.27Memoir
- 6.28Opinion column
- 6.29ParodyThis page
- 6.30Pastiche
- 6.31Speech
- 6.32Travelogue
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 6.29 Parody in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.