6.23 Essay
What an essay is for and how it works: thesis and topic sentences, personal, argumentative and expository essays, counterargument and rebuttal, evidence, the essayist’s voice, variations and change, and when an essay is literary.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 6 Non-literary text types
- SL and HL
Notes on 6.23 Essay
An essay is a short piece of prose in which a writer thinks a subject through for a reader, in a voice of their own. Its situation explains its conventions: a writer with no story to tell and no news to report, offering a reader the pleasure of following a mind at work. Essays are printed in magazines and newspapers, gathered in collections, broadcast, filmed and set in school. The opening of Virginia Woolf’s “Street Haunting: A London Adventure”, first printed in the American quarterly The Yale Review in October 1927, is an essay that hides its thinking inside an errand to buy a pencil.
What an essay is for
Anyone who opened The Yale Review in 1927 had chosen something with no practical use. The magazine printed criticism, politics and essays for people who read slowly, at home, for ideas and for style. The essay therefore owes its audience two things that a report or a leaflet does not. One is an idea worth the time. The other is a way of saying it that is a pleasure in itself, such as the “champagne brightness of the air” of a winter evening (paragraph 2). Its title promises the second before the first.
Street Haunting: A London Adventure
Virginia Woolf, title of the essay, The Yale Review, October 1927
The title and subtitle make two different offers. Street Haunting is an odd phrase, since haunting is what ghosts do in houses, not what people do in streets. A London Adventure sounds like a story, even a boys’ tale of danger. Neither says what the essay will argue, and paragraph 1 answers half of the puzzle when it calls the pleasure “rambling the streets of London”.
That is the essay’s usual bargain. A writer chooses a small occasion and promises that it will lead somewhere larger, as Woolf’s pencil is only “an excuse for walking half across London between tea and dinner” (paragraph 1). Readers trust the writer to keep the promise, so the opening can afford to be modest, even comic, as long as the voice is interesting. A school essay works in the opposite order, because a teacher has to assess a claim that is stated first.
Where the claims sit
Every essay makes claims, even one that seems only to wander. The main claim that an essay sets out to support is its thesis. In a school essay the thesis comes at the end of the first paragraph, stated plainly, so that everything after it can be tested against it. Woolf places her first claim in the same position, at the end of paragraph 1, but disguises it as a passing description.
“Really I must buy a pencil,” as if under cover of this excuse we could indulge safely in the greatest pleasure of town life in winter—rambling the streets of London.
Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 1
The phrase “the greatest pleasure of town life in winter” is a claim of value, and a large one. It ranks one pleasure above every other a city offers, yet it arrives in a subordinate clause, after a joke about a pencil and the words “as if”. The dash then holds back the pleasure itself until the last words of the paragraph. A strong opinion arrives as if it were an aside, which suits an essay that will argue by charm rather than by proof.
The deeper claim comes in paragraph 2, and this one is plain: “We are no longer quite ourselves.” The sentence is six words long in a paragraph of much longer ones, so its shortness marks it. It states the idea the essay will spend its remaining length exploring, that walking out at dusk changes who a person is. A thesis does not have to be one sentence in one place. In an exploratory essay the claim is often spread across several short statements, each a little more exact than the last.
Topic sentences and the essay’s movement
The first sentence of most paragraphs states that paragraph’s point, so the opening sentences of an essay, read in order, give its outline. Woolf’s three paragraphs open with three different kinds of topic sentence.
No one perhaps has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil.
The hour should be evening and the season winter, for in winter the champagne brightness of the air and the sociability of the streets are grateful.
But when the door shuts on us, all that vanishes.Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, the first sentences of paragraphs 1, 2 and 3
The first topic sentence is a hedged denial, “No one perhaps”, which lowers expectations so that the essay can raise them. The second is a rule, built on the verb should: the essayist lays down the conditions of the art of street walking the way a cook gives the oven temperature. The third opens on But, and “all that vanishes” announces a reversal before saying what is reversed. Together they give the essay’s movement in miniature, from an excuse to a set of conditions to a change of state.
Should is a strange word in a text with no instructions to give, since no reader needs telling when to walk. Its confidence is the confidence of taste. The essayist claims the right to judge, as a critic judges a play, and the claim holds if the details that follow (the “champagne brightness”, the “sociability of the streets”) make the judgment feel exact.
Personal, argumentative and expository essays
Essays differ in what they lean on. The novelist Aldous Huxley, in the preface to his Collected Essays (1960), described the essay as moving among three poles. One pole is personal and autobiographical. The second is objective and factual, turned toward the particulars of the world. The third is abstract and general, turned toward ideas. Huxley judged that the best essays move among all three, and the three poles give the three names most often used for kinds of essay.
A personal essay is built on the writer’s own experience, and the writer’s life is part of its evidence. An argumentative essay sets out to persuade a reader of a claim, with reasons. An expository essay explains a subject, such as how a law works or what a tea ceremony means, and its authority is knowledge rather than experience. Woolf’s essay is personal, though its “we” spreads the experience to every reader. The second example of the type is personal and argumentative at once. It comes from Crop Time and After (2023), a book of life writing by a retired Trinidadian nurse, who trained and worked in England for forty years and came home in 2011.
“On Keeping Letters” begins where Woolf’s second paragraph begins, with an object in a room: a tin trunk where Woolf has a china bowl. From there the two essays part. Woolf’s bowl releases memories and the essay follows them. The nurse’s trunk raises a question that needs an answer, whether to keep the letters on paper or let them go. Its thesis is stated plainly at the end of paragraph 2: “I still believe we should keep the letters themselves, on paper, where the next person can find them.”
Placing the thesis after the objections rather than before them is a choice. The essay lets the niece speak first, and only then says “I still believe”. The word still admits that the belief has survived a challenge, so the thesis sounds tested rather than stubborn.
Two shapes of essay
The diagram sets the two essays side by side. “On Keeping Letters” moves in a straight line and ends by returning to its object as a decision. The opening of “Street Haunting” turns as it goes: it lays down conditions, wanders into memories and then changes state when the door shuts. A reader needs to know which shape is in hand before deciding what counts as a digression and what counts as a weakness.


Counterargument, concession and rebuttal
An argument that never mentions the other side looks either naive or dishonest. Essays that argue therefore usually state a counterargument fairly before answering it, and the nurse gives her niece’s case real force. Anjali is “clever and kind and twenty-six”, and her case has three separate reasons: paper rots, the trunk takes space, and the letters were written for one reader who is dead.
She has a point, and more than one.
“On Keeping Letters”, paragraph 2
The short sentence is a courtesy and a tactic at once. Admitting that the other side has “more than one” point makes the writer seem fair, and a fair writer is easier to believe when she disagrees. The essay then makes a concession to the parts of the case that are true: “I will grant Anjali the termites. I will even grant her the gallery” (paragraph 3). The repeated grant, with even in the second sentence, gives ground twice and with good humor, so the turn that follows has more weight.
That turn is the rebuttal. It begins with But and states its claim in one sentence: “a photograph of a letter keeps the words and throws away the evidence” (paragraph 3). The evidence follows, the pencil sums on the backs of envelopes and the letters of 1979 worn soft from rereading. Paragraph 4 then answers the third reason, privacy, with a rebuttal of its own: “I do not think the dead need protecting from their own children.” The first two objections are granted and the third gets a rebuttal of its own, so the reply is easy to follow and hard to dismiss.
Counterargument in an exploring essay
Woolf’s essay has no opponent, but it has counterarguments, handled so lightly that they are easy to miss. Paragraph 2 has just claimed that winter is the right season for walking when it raises the obvious objection, that summer is better.
We are not then taunted as in summer by the longing for shade and solitude and sweet airs from the hayfields.
Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 2
The rival pleasure is given its due in a lovely phrase, “sweet airs from the hayfields”, and dismissed in one verb. To be taunted by a longing is to be teased by something out of reach, so summer’s pleasures become a torment and winter’s become a relief. The rebuttal is carried by connotation rather than by reasons. The opening’s last sentences then make a concession about its own method: “But, after all, we are only gliding smoothly on the surface” (paragraph 3). An exploratory essay concedes as an argued one does, but what it concedes is the limit of its own way of seeing.
Evidence in an essay
An essay has no laboratory and usually no footnotes, so its evidence is of a few kinds that a reader can check against experience. The commonest is the anecdote, a short story of one incident. Others are the example, the quotation, the number and the comparison drawn from the writer’s own work. “On Keeping Letters” uses all of them in five paragraphs, and each does a different job.
On the back of almost every envelope Mai wrote, in pencil, the day she answered it, and under the day a little sum in TT dollars (vegetables sold, I think, or money owed to the parlour), so that my news from Ward 9 sits on the same paper as her week at Chaguanas market.
“On Keeping Letters”, paragraph 3
This is physical evidence, described so exactly that a reader can almost hold the envelope. It is also the essay’s strongest example, because it proves the rebuttal’s claim that a photograph “throws away the evidence”. Nobody would scan the back of an envelope, and the back is where the mother’s life is. The bracketed guess, “vegetables sold, I think”, admits what the writer does not know, which makes the rest of the description easier to trust.
The number works differently. “Two hundred and eighty-six” appears in paragraph 1 as a fact and returns in the last sentence as a count of decisions: “Mai decided, two hundred and eighty-six times.” The figure changes meaning from the size of a collection to the size of a mother’s care. The comparison from nursing, “A nurse learns to read the body before she reads the chart” (paragraph 3), proves nothing about letters, but it shows that the writer’s way of reading comes from forty years of work, so her judgment carries professional weight.
An anecdote made into a general claim
Woolf’s evidence is almost all anecdote, and the chapter on prose non-fiction reads the Mantua memory as a digression that carries the essay’s claim about objects. As evidence, the anecdotes also show how an essayist turns one case into a rule. The melancholy Englishman in the hotel “revealed the secrets of his soul—as travellers do” (paragraph 2). The last three words turn one stranger into a law about all travelers, and they ask for no proof beyond the reader’s own memory of a confiding stranger.
The two anecdotes Woolf chooses are of different kinds. The bowl from Mantua releases a lyrical memory of “the vines laced about among the pillars and the stars white in the sky”. The brown ring on the carpet releases a comic one, a man so angry about a politician that he sets a kettle down on the carpet. Placed together, they show that every kind of memory, beautiful or absurd, is stored in the objects of a room, and the pairing widens the claim more than a third lyrical memory could have.
An anecdote can carry an argument much larger than itself. In George Orwell’s “Shooting an Elephant” (1936), the narrator is a young English police officer in colonial Burma who shoots an elephant because a crowd expects him to. The essay draws from that one incident a claim about empire, that a ruler who must perform power for the ruled loses his own freedom.
Try it
“On Keeping Letters” mentions Pa’s death in 1979 only once, inside a sentence about worn paper (paragraph 3). Why might the essay keep this grief so brief, and what does the detail do for its argument?
The essay is an argument about keeping letters, not a memoir of loss, so a long account of the death would turn it into a different kind of text. Placed inside the description of the paper, the grief becomes evidence: the 1979 letters are softer “because she read them more”, which proves that the physical letters record feeling that a photograph cannot. The restraint also fits the writer’s plain, unsentimental voice, so the detail moves a reader without the essay asking for sympathy.
The essayist’s voice
An essay is trusted or not trusted largely on its voice, because the reader has no story to follow and no news to check. The chapter on narrative voice describes how a writer builds a persona on the page. In an argued essay the voice has a further job: it must sound like someone worth agreeing with.
I have heard all of this and I have thought about it on many nights, and I still believe we should keep the letters themselves, on paper, where the next person can find them.
“On Keeping Letters”, paragraph 2
The nurse’s voice is patient. The long sentence, joined by and, moves at the speed of someone who has turned the question over “on many nights”, and its claim arrives only after that time has been shown. The humor elsewhere, the eleven spoons and the termites eating “the corner of 1977”, keeps the essay from self-pity, which matters in a piece about a dead mother. A reader is persuaded partly because the writer is fair to her niece, plain about her grief and funny about her mother’s kitchen drawer.
Woolf’s voice persuades by its range, witty in paragraph 1, precise in paragraph 2 and lyrical in paragraph 3, which makes a mind this alert to the city seem the right guide to it.
When an essay is literary
Many essays are non-literary texts: a newspaper’s weekend essay on housing, a museum’s essay on its collection, a student’s essay for a class. They are read for their argument and its effect on an audience. Others are read as literature. “Street Haunting” is one, for three reasons that usually decide the question. Its writer was a literary author, and its design (the walk, the images, the rhythm of its sentences) is shaped for its own sake as well as for its idea. It has also been collected and studied as a work long after its first readers, as the line “an enormous eye” (paragraph 3) still is.
“On Keeping Letters” sits nearer the line. It comes from a book of life writing published by a small press and read by people who share its history, and its prose is crafted, with a planned return to the trunk and the number at the end. Its purpose, though, is to settle a family question, and its craft serves that purpose. It could be read either way, and the reasons for each reading are part of the analysis.
The distinction matters most for the individual oral, which pairs one literary work with one non-literary body of work. A set of essays by one literary writer can serve as a literary work, and a run of essays by one columnist or from one publication can form a non-literary body of work. Schools usually leave the decision on a particular collection to the teacher, and a student who brings an essay to the oral should be ready to say which side it falls on and why.
Essays across media and time
The essay took its name from Michel de Montaigne’s Essais (1580), attempts at a question, as the chapter on prose non-fiction explains. Its next home was the periodical. In 1711 and 1712 Joseph Addison and Richard Steele published The Spectator, a daily essay sold in London and argued over in coffee houses. It spoke through an invented observer, Mr. Spectator, so the short, witty essay with a recurring persona became a newspaper form.
Newspapers still print essays beside their close relative, the opinion column, which argues about this week’s news in a fixed slot under a regular name. The essay is tied less to the week and more to an idea, and it allows itself a digression and a slow ending. An opening as unhurried as “No one perhaps has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil” (paragraph 1) would be hard to fit in a column that must take a side by its second paragraph.
The photo essay and the video essay
The type has moved out of prose as well. A photo essay makes its case through a sequence of photographs with captions. In September 1948 the American magazine Life published W. Eugene Smith’s “Country Doctor”, which followed one doctor in a small Colorado town through his days and nights. Its order, from routine visits to emergencies and the doctor’s exhaustion after a night of work, made an argument about rural medicine that no single picture could, so sequence did the work that topic sentences do in prose. The video essay, which grew on video platforms in the 2010s, joins a spoken voice-over to edited footage, often clips from the films or games it discusses. Its evidence is shown rather than quoted, and it keeps the written essay’s personal voice of someone thinking aloud.
A nurse learns to read the body before she reads the chart, and a letter has a body too.
“On Keeping Letters”, paragraph 3
In every medium the essay turns a particular thing into a general idea through a voice. The nurse’s sentence does it in prose, moving from her training to a claim about letters; a photo essay does it by placing one picture after another, and a video essay by cutting from a clip to a face.
Where the thesis model stops
The thesis model explains “On Keeping Letters” almost completely: a claim, objections, concession, rebuttal and a return. It explains less of “Street Haunting”, whose pleasure lies in what the model would call digressions, the vines and stars of Mantua and the burnt ring on the carpet. A reading that tested only whether paragraph 3 proves paragraph 1 would miss most of the essay.
The philosopher Theodor Adorno, in “The Essay as Form” (1958), defended the essay because it does not proceed like a system: it starts from particular things, stops where it chooses and does not claim to cover its subject. School writing teaches the opposite habit, because a marker needs a claim to assess. Adorno’s view explains why an exploratory essay can be strong without a thesis stated at the start.
Writing about an essay
A paragraph about an essay names the essay’s claim and shows how one or two of its conventions serve it. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, takes the counterargument of “On Keeping Letters”.
“On Keeping Letters” persuades by giving the case against it real force before answering it.note 1 The niece Anjali is introduced as “clever and kind”, and the essayist concedes that “She has a point, and more than one” (paragraph 2), so the disagreement is presented as a family conversation rather than a quarrel.note 2 The concessions that follow, “I will grant Anjali the termites. I will even grant her the gallery”, give ground on everything practical, which makes the rebuttal’s single claim, that a photograph “throws away the evidence”, carry all the weight (paragraph 3).note 3 Because the writer is visibly fair to the other side, her final decision to keep the letters reads as a judgment rather than as sentiment.note 4
Claim about method. The topic sentence names how the essay persuades, not what it is about.
Evidence of fairness. Two short quotations show the counterargument presented generously, with the effect stated.
Concession and rebuttal together. The sentence explains how giving ground on small points focuses the reply.
Effect on the essay’s purpose. The last sentence links the structure to how the conclusion is received.
The same habit of linking a convention to its effect separates a weak sentence about Woolf’s essay from a strong one.
Weak: Woolf uses a lot of personal anecdotes in her essay to make it more interesting and relatable for the reader.note 1
Strong: When the melancholy Englishman reveals “the secrets of his soul—as travellers do” (paragraph 2), three words turn one remembered stranger into a rule, and the essay generalizes from anecdote without asking for any proof beyond the reader’s own memory.note 2
A description that fits any essay. “A lot of anecdotes” and “interesting and relatable” name no anecdote and no effect particular to this text.
Quotation, convention, effect. The sentence quotes the words, names the essayist’s move from case to rule, and says what that move asks of the reader.
Applying it in Paper 1
An essay in Paper 1 is usually an extract from a newspaper or magazine essay or from a published personal essay, often a page long. What it offers to analyze is the movement of thought. That means where the thesis sits and how it is reached, the topic sentences that mark the turns, the counterarguments answered, the evidence chosen, and the voice that makes the writer worth hearing. A guiding question on an essay is likely to ask how the writer develops an argument or reflection, how personal experience is used to persuade, or how the essay presents a place, an object or an idea.
A model sentence of analysis follows. By letting the niece speak first and conceding “the termites” and “the gallery”, the essay narrows the dispute to one claim, that a photograph “throws away the evidence”, so its defense of paper letters rests on the pencil sums no camera would record. The commonest way to lose marks is to argue with the essay instead of analyzing it: agreeing that letters should be kept, or retelling the writer’s reasons in order. Another is to treat an exploratory essay as a failed argument.
Its conventions in brief
A small occasion (an object, an errand, an incident) that leads to a larger idea.
A thesis, stated early in an argued essay or emerging in an exploratory one.
Topic sentences that state each paragraph’s claim or move.
Counterargument, concession and rebuttal, signaled by words such as grant and but.
Evidence from anecdote, example, quotation, number and the writer’s own work.
A distinctive first-person voice, singular or plural, that earns trust.
A title that frames the subject or poses a question.
An ending that returns to the occasion and turns the claim into a decision or an image.
The essay leads to the opinion column, a shorter argument in a fixed slot under a regular name, and to the HL essay, where students write the type themselves, with a line of inquiry in place of a pencil.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what an essay is for, where essays are published and read, and how that situation shapes the type.
- To do:
I can find an essay’s thesis and topic sentences and explain how the placement of a claim changes its effect.
- To do:
I can distinguish personal, argumentative and expository essays, and an exploratory essay from an argued one.
- To do:
I can analyze how an essay uses counterargument, concession and rebuttal.
- To do:
I can explain how an essay uses anecdote, example, quotation and number as evidence.
- To do:
I can describe how essays vary across print, photography and video and how the type has changed since Montaigne.
- To do:
I can explain what would make an essay literary and why it matters for the individual oral.
Key terms
Each is also in the Non-literary text types glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Concession
An admission that part of an opposing view is true, made before the writer explains why the main claim still stands. A concession narrows the claim to what can be defended.
- Counterargument
A view against the writer’s own that an argument states fairly before answering it. Raising it proves that the writer has weighed other positions, which makes the main claim more credible.
- Essay
A short piece of prose non-fiction in which a writer thinks a subject through for a reader, in a voice of their own. Essays range from arguments built around a thesis to explorations that follow the writer’s thoughts and memories.
- Personal essay
An essay built on the writer’s own experience, in which the writer’s voice and memories are part of the evidence. It moves from a particular occasion or object toward a general idea.
- Rebuttal
The part of an argument that answers a counterargument, showing why it is wrong, weaker than it looks or beside the point. A rebuttal usually follows the counterargument directly.
- Thesis
The main claim that an essay or argument sets out to support. It may be stated near the start, held back until the end, or left for the reader to put into words.
- Topic sentence
The sentence, usually the first in a paragraph, that states the paragraph’s point. Read in order, the topic sentences of an essay give the outline of its argument.
Practice questions on 6.23 Essay
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 6 questions on 6.23 Essay
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 6 Non-literary text types
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 6.1Advertisement
- 6.2Appeal
- 6.3Blog
- 6.4Brochure or leaflet
- 6.5Cartoon
- 6.6Diagram
- 6.7Electronic text
- 6.8Encyclopaedia entry
- 6.9Film and television
- 6.10Guide book
- 6.11Infographic
- 6.12Interview
- 6.13Music video
- 6.14Photograph
- 6.15Radio broadcast
- 6.16Report
- 6.17Screenplay for TV or film
- 6.18Set of instructions
- 6.19Textbook
- 6.20Work of art
- 6.21Autobiography or biography
- 6.22Diary entry
- 6.23EssayThis page
- 6.24Letter
- 6.25Magazine article
- 6.26Manifesto
- 6.27Memoir
- 6.28Opinion column
- 6.29Parody
- 6.30Pastiche
- 6.31Speech
- 6.32Travelogue
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 6.23 Essay in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.