6.19 Textbook
What textbooks are for and how they work: lessons built for learners, definitions and questions, scaffolding, the voice of authority and its values, a modern textbook page, and digital and open textbooks.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 6 Non-literary text types
- SL and HL
Notes on 6.19 Textbook
A textbook teaches a body of knowledge to learners in a course. It is written by teachers and subject experts, shaped by publishers, often approved by a ministry or a state board, and bought by schools in classroom sets. Its readers are unusual. They did not choose the book, they read it because they must, and they are expected to learn from it, remember it and be tested on it. A textbook therefore speaks with more authority than almost any other text a young person meets, and what it includes, and how it words it, can become what a whole generation takes to be simply true.
The McGuffey Readers were among the most widely used schoolbooks in the history of the United States. They were first published in 1836 under the name of William Holmes McGuffey, a teacher and minister. They were graded from a First Reader for beginners to a Sixth for older pupils, and taught reading through short lessons of prose and verse. This lesson is from the Fourth Reader in its revised edition of 1879.
A lesson built for recitation
The lesson’s parts are designed for a classroom in which pupils read aloud and answer questions. It has a number and a title in capitals, “LVI. Knowledge Is Power”, so a teacher can set it by number and a pupil can find it. Its six paragraphs are numbered too, a convention of the series, which lets a teacher say “begin at paragraph 4” or ask for the meaning of a word “in paragraph 3”. The numbers turn a short story into a text that can be divided among readers, practiced and checked.
In the printed book, a paragraph headed “Definitions” sits between the story and the questions. It glosses the harder words in order, each keyed to the number of the paragraph where it appears, so bustling is “very active, stirring” and meekly is “mildly, quietly, gently”. Each word is printed with an accent mark for stress and small marks over its letters for pronunciation. The definitions are those that fit this story, not every meaning in a dictionary, so the pupil learns the word as the lesson uses it. The series explains this help in its preface:
It can not be presumed that every pupil has at hand all the works of reference necessary for the proper preparation of each lesson; hence all the aids that seem requisite to this purpose have been given. Brief notices concerning the various authors represented have been inserted; the more difficult words have been defined, and their pronunciation has been indicated by diacritical marks; and short explanatory notes have been given wherever required for a full understanding of the text.
McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader, revised edition (1879), preface
The preface states the textbook’s situation exactly. The pupil may own no dictionary, so the book must contain everything needed to prepare the lesson at home. Definitions, pronunciation marks, notes on authors and explanations are all built into the page. A textbook is a self-sufficient text in this sense: it supplies its own context, its own reference works and its own questions, and assumes that the learner has nothing else.
Questions that check and questions that tell
The lesson ends with five questions under the heading “Exercises”:
What is the subject of this lesson? Is knowledge always a power? Is it always a blessing? Relate the several examples of power wrongly used. If we use the powers that God has given us for bad purposes, what will our knowledge prove to be?
McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader, Lesson LVI, Exercises (paragraph 7)
The questions move in a planned order. The first asks for the subject, a test of whether the pupil understood the whole. The next two can be answered from paragraph 2 and need only a yes or no. The fourth asks the pupil to relate, to retell the three examples of horse, pond and ship, which checks memory and gives practice in speaking. The last asks for the lesson’s moral, and its wording gives the answer away, since a pupil who has read paragraph 6 knows that the knowledge will “prove” to be a curse.
No question asks the pupil to disagree, to compare the analogies or to say whether knowledge works like a horse at all. The Exercises check that the lesson has been received, not that it has been weighed. This is typical of the schoolbooks of the period, which treated reading as the transmission of a settled meaning, and it is the clearest difference from the questions in a modern textbook.
From the familiar to the abstract
The lesson teaches an abstract idea, that knowledge is a power which can do harm, to children in the middle grades of school. It does so by building up to it. The old man does not begin with the rule; he begins with everyday things, a horse, a pond and a ship:
When the power of a horse is under restraint, the animal is useful in bearing burdens, drawing loads, and carrying his master; but when that power is unrestrained, the horse breaks his bridle, dashes to pieces the carriage that he draws, or throws his rider.
McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader, Lesson LVI, paragraph 3
The horse, the pond in paragraph 4 and the ship in paragraph 5 are three analogies with the same shape. Each sentence sets power used well against power out of control, joined by but. By the third, the pupil has heard the pattern twice and can predict it. Only then, in paragraph 6, does the old man state the general rule that “knowledge, to be a good thing, must be rightly applied”. The order is from the concrete to the abstract and from examples to a principle, so the pupil arrives at the rule already holding three cases of it.
This kind of support is called scaffolding: help built into teaching so that learners can reach what they could not reach alone, reduced as their skill grows. In the McGuffey lesson the scaffolding works inside one story. Across the series it works on a larger scale, since the Readers move from short words in large type in the First Reader to long passages from adult literature in the Sixth. Each book assumes the one before, and the reading demanded of the pupil grows with every volume.
A pupil inside the lesson
The story puts a learner on the page. The “bustling little man” (paragraph 1) asks the question a child might ask, “How can power be a bad thing?” (paragraph 2), and answers each analogy with “I see!”, more confidently each time, until “I see clearly!” (paragraph 5). He models the response the lesson wants from its readers: attention, recognition and agreement. Another page reads the lesson as didacticism, with this repeated “I see!” as the response the book expects. Read as textbook design, it is a ready-made dialogue for reading aloud in parts, with an old man as the teacher and a pupil who always understands.
LVI. Knowledge Is Powernote 1
1.note 2 “What an excellent thing is knowledge,” said a sharp-looking, bustling little man, to one who was much older than himself.
“That is what I can not understand,”note 3 said the bustling little man. “How can power be a bad thing?”
“When the power of a horse is under restraint, the animal is useful in bearing burdens, drawing loads, and carrying his master; but when that power is unrestrainednote 4, the horse breaks his bridle
“I see!” said the little man, “I see clearly!”note 5
knowledge, to be a good thing, must be rightly appliednote 6. God’s grace in the heart will render the knowledge of the head a blessingnote 7;
Exercises.—What is the subject of this lesson? Relate the several examples of power wrongly used.note 8 If we use the powers that God has given us for bad purposes, what will our knowledge prove to be?note 9
Numbered title. The lesson is set and found by number, as a unit in a graded course.
Numbered paragraphs. Units for reading aloud in turn, for reference in class and for the Definitions.
A learner’s question. The pupil-figure voices the difficulty the lesson will solve.
The pattern of the analogy. Use and misuse, joined by but, repeated three times so the pupil can predict it.
Learning made visible. The pupil-figure’s growing confidence models the response the book expects.
The rule after the cases. The abstract principle comes only when three examples have prepared it.
Values as knowledge. A religious claim is stated as the condition of good learning, with no hedge.
Recall as exercise. The pupil retells the examples, practicing memory and speech.
A question that answers itself. The moral is asked for in words that already contain it.
The notes show a textbook doing several jobs at once: teaching reading and pronunciation, teaching a way of reasoning by analogy, and teaching values. In 1879 the three were not separated. A reading lesson was expected to form character as well as skill, and the book’s structure serves all three aims together.
The voice of authority
The lesson is unsigned. Many McGuffey lessons name their authors, but this one speaks with the voice of the book itself, and that voice does not hedge. Its definitions are given as plain equivalents, and its moral is stated by a wise old man and confirmed by a pupil. Its religious claim, that “God’s grace in the heart will render the knowledge of the head a blessing” (paragraph 6), is presented as a fact about learning. Textbooks still use this voice. They define, generalize and state, with few of the hedges that an encyclopedia entry uses to measure uncertainty, because their task is to give learners a foundation before they are asked to question it.
That authority is what makes the textbook’s choices matter. A textbook selects, from everything that could be taught, what a course will cover, and it decides the words in which the past and the world are described. Those choices often carry the values of the nation or the community that produces the book. The McGuffey Readers carried the Protestant moral teaching that many American schools of the nineteenth century took for granted. Modern textbooks carry values too, usually less openly, in what they select and how they name it.
One word in a caption
In 2015 a mother in Texas posted online a photograph, sent to her by her son, of a caption in his high school geography textbook, published by McGraw-Hill and used in the state. On a map of migration into the United States, the caption said that the Atlantic slave trade brought “millions of workers from Africa” to the southern states to work on plantations. Her post about the word workers spread widely. A worker is paid and can leave, so the word presented enslaved people as if they had been labor migrants. The publisher apologized, said it would revise the caption to describe a forced migration, changed the digital edition at once and promised the change in future printings.
The case shows how a single noun in a textbook can represent a history. The caption was short, factual in form and placed in a section about migration, so the word workers fitted its frame and passed several rounds of review. Only a reader outside the process noticed what it did. Textbooks are reviewed by experts and boards, and still their word choices can carry a perspective that their makers do not see. That is one reason a textbook is worth reading as a text and not only as a source of facts.
Try it
Answer the last of the Exercises as a pupil in 1879 was expected to, and then say what the question assumes about the pupil and about knowledge.
The expected answer is that our knowledge will prove to be a curse, the answer paragraph 6 has just given. The question assumes that the pupil believes God has given human beings their powers. It also assumes that the purpose of reading is to receive and repeat the lesson’s moral, and that knowledge is good only when it is governed by religious faith. It leaves no room for a pupil who doubts the premise or who thinks knowledge valuable in itself.
A modern textbook page
Modern textbooks keep the McGuffey lesson’s aims (a self-sufficient page, help with hard words, questions at the end) but arrange them differently. The Sluicehead Heritage Trust, which looks after the ruins of a gold-mining settlement in New Zealand, publishes a resource for schools called Water and Gold. This section from its third unit is a page of the kind found in history and geography textbooks around the world.
The section opens with what learners will be able to do by its end: “find out who came to Sluicehead to mine, and why · use a primary source to learn about one miner’s life · explain why some people were left out of early histories of the goldfields” (paragraph 2). These are learning objectives. The McGuffey lesson left its purpose for the last question to reveal; the modern page states its purpose first, so the learner reads with a goal and can check at the end whether it was met. The three objectives also rise in difficulty, from finding out, to using a source, to explaining.
Key words, body text and the source
The “Key words” box (paragraph 3) defines three terms before the body text uses them, as the McGuffey Definitions did after the story. The definitions are written for this unit: sluice head points to “Figure 3”, the trust’s diagram of how sluicing worked, so the learner is sent from word to picture. The body text (paragraphs 4 and 5) explains in short, confident sentences with figures (“about 1,200 people”, “about 160”) and generalizes without hedging, “Life on the goldfield was hard for everyone”, which is the textbook’s voice of authority.
Unlike the McGuffey lesson, the page then hands the learner evidence to interpret. “Source 3B” (paragraph 6) is one entry from a storekeeper’s account book, and the lettering marks it as one of several sources in the unit, each to be read as evidence rather than as explanation. Many history textbooks now teach this way, setting primary sources beside the authors’ account so that learners practice the historian’s method as well as learning the history.
Questions that open
The questions are labeled by the kind of thinking they ask for:
Find it 1. Where did most of the Chinese miners at Sluicehead come from?
Explain it 2. What does Source 3B tell you about how Lee Hop worked and what he needed?
Think about it 3. Wong Sai Fook’s account book is the only document known to survive that was written inside the Chinese Camp. Why do you think the Chinese miners are missing from so many early histories, and what difference does a source like this make?Water and Gold, section 3.2, paragraphs 8–10
The sequence is scaffolding made visible. Find it asks for a fact from the text; Explain it asks the learner to infer from a source; Think about it asks for a judgment with no answer printed anywhere on the page. The McGuffey Exercises also moved from recall to the lesson’s point, but their last question had one correct answer. The third question here asks why do you think, which invites the learner to argue. It also turns the textbook’s attention to textbooks, asking learners to notice what earlier histories left out.
The diagram sets out the conventions of a modern textbook spread like this one, with what each does for the learner. Read across the spread, the conventions move from telling (objectives, key words, body text) to showing (figure) to asking (source and questions).


Textbooks in mathematics, the sciences and languages lean most on the worked example. A geography textbook might show, in four numbered steps, how to read a grid reference on a map before asking learners to read six themselves. The Water and Gold page has no worked example, since its skill is interpretation; a fuller unit might model an answer to a source question first, showing how one sentence from the account book supports one inference. The worked example is the textbook’s most direct form of scaffolding, because it lets the learner watch the skill before trying it.
Pictures, screens and open textbooks
Images in textbooks teach as much as their words, and their captions decide what an image means. The preface to the McGuffey Fourth Reader makes its pictures a selling point:
The book has been considerably enlarged, and has been liberally illustrated by the first artists of the country, as is shown in the Table of Contents.
McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader, revised edition (1879), preface
The first artists of the country claims national prestige for a schoolbook. The engravings of the Readers showed farms, schoolrooms and families that taught pupils what an American childhood looked like. The 2015 caption that called enslaved people “workers” sat beside a map, and it was the caption, not the map, that made the argument. A picture in a textbook arrives with the book’s authority, so its caption is read as fact.
The way textbooks are chosen shapes them too. In some countries a ministry writes or approves a single national textbook for each subject; in others, publishers compete for adoption by states, districts or schools. In the United States, a few large states that approve books for their whole school system have long had more influence on content than their size alone would suggest, because publishers write for the biggest buyers. A textbook is a commercial product as well as a teaching text, and both facts leave marks on its pages.
From the printed book to the screen
Digital textbooks keep the page’s conventions but change how they are used. Key words become links to a glossary, figures can be animated, questions can be marked at once, and a book can be corrected without a new print run, as the 2015 caption was in its digital edition. Some platforms adapt to each learner, offering easier or harder questions according to earlier answers, which makes scaffolding automatic. Open textbooks, written under licenses that let anyone read, copy and adapt them free of charge, have grown since the 2010s; projects such as OpenStax at Rice University publish whole college courses this way. Open licensing changes who can be an author and who must pay, but it does not change the textbook’s voice of authority.
Writing about a textbook
A paragraph about a textbook starts from its learner and its institutional voice, then shows how its structure teaches and what its choices assume. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, is about the McGuffey lesson.
Lesson LVI teaches its moral the way it teaches reading, by building from familiar cases to a rule the pupil cannot miss.note 1 Three analogies of the same shape, the horse, the pond and the ship, each set power “under restraint” against power that “bursts through its banks”, so the pupil can predict the pattern before the old man states it in paragraph 6.note 2 The pupil-figure’s rising “I see!” and “I see clearly!” model the response the book expects, and the Exercises confirm it, ending on a question whose wording supplies the answer.note 3 The lesson’s scaffolding is skillful, but it leads in one direction only: the pupil is taught to arrive at the book’s conclusion, not to test it.note 4
A claim about method. The topic sentence links the lesson’s structure to its purpose.
Structure as evidence. The three analogies are named and their shared pattern quoted.
The implied pupil. The dialogue and the questions are read as a model of the expected response.
Evaluation. The last sentence judges the design and states its limit.
The same habit of explaining a convention by its learner separates a weak and a strong sentence about the McGuffey Exercises.
Weak: The textbook asks questions at the end to check the reader’s understanding.note 1
Strong: The Exercises move from the lesson’s subject to a yes-or-no question and a retelling, and end by asking what knowledge used “for bad purposes” will “prove to be”, so even the last question checks that the moral was received rather than inviting the pupil to weigh it.note 2
True of any textbook. The sentence names a convention and its usual function, with no evidence from this lesson.
Sequence, quotation and judgment. The sentence traces the order of the questions and evaluates what the last one asks of the pupil.
The strong sentence treats the questions as a designed sequence with an effect. A textbook’s questions are often the clearest evidence of what it believes learning is.
Applying it in Paper 1
A textbook page in Paper 1 is likely to be modern or historical, and often combines body text with a figure, a source box or questions. A guiding question on a textbook is likely to direct attention to how the text instructs or guides its readers, or to how it presents a subject or a group of people with authority. It may instead ask what the text assumes about its learner. A model sentence of analysis follows. By ending on a question that asks “Why do you think the Chinese miners are missing from so many early histories”, the page turns from giving its learners a history to asking them how histories are made.
The commonest way to lose marks is to retell the content being taught (the history of the gold field, the moral about knowledge) instead of analyzing how the textbook teaches it. Another is to praise a page as “informative” and stop. A response that analyzes the page’s order, one convention such as its questions or key words, and one choice of words or image will usually reach further.
Its conventions in brief
Numbered units, lessons and sections in a planned order.
Learning objectives that state what the learner should be able to do.
Key words or definitions that prepare the vocabulary of the lesson.
Body text in a confident voice of authority, with few hedges.
Figures, images and captions that teach and carry the book’s view.
Sources or extracts to interpret, and worked examples that model a skill.
Questions graded from recall to explanation to judgment.
Scaffolding across the page and the series of lessons, from simple to complex.
The textbook leads to the global issues of beliefs, values and education, which ask how societies pass on what they believe, and to the encyclopedia entry, which shares its voice of authority without its duty to teach.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what a textbook is for and how its readers and makers differ from those of other texts.
- To do:
I can analyze the parts of a textbook lesson, from objectives and key words to sources and questions.
- To do:
I can explain scaffolding and trace it through a lesson and its questions.
- To do:
I can analyze a textbook’s voice of authority and the values carried by its selection and word choice.
- To do:
I can compare an 1879 reader with a modern textbook page and describe how digital and open textbooks differ.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph that links a textbook’s conventions to its implied learner and its values.
Key terms
Each is also in the Non-literary text types glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Learning objective
A statement at the start of a lesson or unit of what learners should know or be able to do by its end. It tells learners what counts as success and frames everything that follows as a means to it.
- Scaffolding
Support built into teaching that helps learners do what they could not yet do alone, such as simpler steps first, examples and guiding questions, and that is reduced as they gain skill. In a textbook it shows in the order of explanations and tasks.
- Textbook
A book written to teach a subject to learners in a course, organized into lessons or units with explanations, examples and tasks. Its institutional voice presents what it includes as the knowledge a learner needs.
- Worked example
A task solved step by step in front of the learner, with the reasoning shown at each step, before the learner tries similar tasks alone. It models the process as well as the answer.
Practice questions on 6.19 Textbook
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 3 questions on 6.19 Textbook
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 6 Non-literary text types
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 6.1Advertisement
- 6.2Appeal
- 6.3Blog
- 6.4Brochure or leaflet
- 6.5Cartoon
- 6.6Diagram
- 6.7Electronic text
- 6.8Encyclopaedia entry
- 6.9Film and television
- 6.10Guide book
- 6.11Infographic
- 6.12Interview
- 6.13Music video
- 6.14Photograph
- 6.15Radio broadcast
- 6.16Report
- 6.17Screenplay for TV or film
- 6.18Set of instructions
- 6.19TextbookThis page
- 6.20Work of art
- 6.21Autobiography or biography
- 6.22Diary entry
- 6.23Essay
- 6.24Letter
- 6.25Magazine article
- 6.26Manifesto
- 6.27Memoir
- 6.28Opinion column
- 6.29Parody
- 6.30Pastiche
- 6.31Speech
- 6.32Travelogue
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 6.19 Textbook in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.
