3 Human ingenuity

What Human ingenuity covers: entertainment, art, the media, technology and science, how the five topics connect around the question of who benefits, and how the theme appears in Paper 1, Paper 2 and the oral.

  • IB Spanish B
  • SL and HL

7 min readLast reviewed

The subtopics of Human ingenuity

Each has its own page of notes.

  1. 3.1Entertainment
  2. 3.2Artistic expressions
  3. 3.3Communication and media
  4. 3.4Technology
  5. 3.5Scientific innovation

An overview of Human ingenuity

Human ingenuity is the theme of what people create, invent and share: entertainment, art, the media, technology and science. Its central question is what an invention is for, and who gets to use it. An editorial in El Altavoz, the magazine of a public secondary school in Madrid, asks the students who write it which invention changed their lives.

Inventos que nos cambiaron la vidaEl Altavoz, the student magazine of a public secondary school in Madrid (Retiro), editorialWritten for Augment Education
Para este número pedimos a cada persona de la redacción que eligiera un invento que le hubiera cambiado la vida. Esperábamos máquinas, pero las respuestas fueron mucho más variadas.
Omar eligió su móvil, «porque ahí están mi música, mis amigos y los deberes», aunque reconoce que a veces le roba horas de sueño. Lucía eligió una canción que toda la clase se sabe de memoria, «porque nos une más que cualquier aplicación». Otra compañera eligió las dos horas gratuitas que el Prado ofrece cada tarde, cuando cualquiera puede ver Las meninas sin pagar. Un compañero de segundo se quedó con el periódico de papel que su abuelo todavía compra en el quiosco, y otro con la vacuna que le pusieron de bebé y que ni siquiera recuerda.
Al leerlo todo, nos dimos cuenta de que la pregunta importante no era qué se ha inventado, sino para quién. Un invento solo cambia el mundo cuando llega a todos. ¿Y vosotros, qué habríais elegido?

Five inventions, one question

The editors “esperábamos máquinas” (expected machines), paragraph 1, and the answers in paragraph 2 show why they were wrong. Only one of the five is a machine in the usual sense: Omar’s phone, which holds his music, his friends and his homework. The others are a song, two free hours at a museum, a paper newspaper and a vaccine. Each belongs to a different topic of the theme, from entertainment to science.

Most of the choices come with a reason, and the reasons are about people rather than objects. Lucía keeps the song because “nos une más que cualquier aplicación” (it brings us together more than any app). A classmate values the Prado’s free evening hours because anyone can see Las meninas “sin pagar” (without paying). Omar’s reason has a limit built into it. The phone gives him a great deal, “aunque reconoce que a veces le roba horas de sueño” (although he admits it sometimes steals hours of his sleep).

Paragraph 3 draws the theme’s conclusion: “la pregunta importante no era qué se ha inventado, sino para quién” (the important question was not what has been invented, but for whom). The last sentence turns the question to the magazine’s readers with vosotros, the informal plural of Spain.

Para este número pedimos a cada persona de la redacción que eligiera un invento que le hubiera cambiado la vidanote 1. […] Omar eligió su móvil, […] aunque reconoce que a veces le roba horas de sueñonote 2. Lucía eligió una canción que toda la clase se sabe de memorianote 3 […]. Un invento solo cambia el mundo cuando llega a todosnote 4. ¿Y vosotros, qué habríais elegido?note 5

  1. A request in the past. Pedir que takes the subjunctive, and in the past the verb moves to the imperfect subjunctive: pedimos que eligiera. Hubiera cambiado looks further back, to a change that had already happened.

  2. A phone as a thief. Robar algo a alguien (to steal something from someone) takes an indirect object, le. The verb makes the phone responsible for the lost sleep.

  3. Saberse for “by heart”. Saberse algo de memoria stresses knowing something completely; saber la canción would be weaker.

  4. A condition in two words. Solo… cuando (only … when) sets a condition: an invention changes nothing until it reaches everyone.

  5. Vosotros and the conditional perfect. Habríais elegido asks the readers about a choice they never had to make. In Latin America the question would be ¿Y ustedes, qué habrían elegido?

Try it

Two of the choices in paragraph 2 belong to a whole group rather than to one person. Which are they, and how do they support the editorial’s last paragraph?

The song that “toda la clase se sabe de memoria”, and the Prado’s free evening hours, when “cualquiera” (anyone) can see Las meninas. Both reach everyone, which is the condition paragraph 3 sets: “Un invento solo cambia el mundo cuando llega a todos”.

How the five topics connect

Each choice in the editorial belongs to one topic: the song to entertainment, the Prado to artistic expressions, the newspaper to communication and media, the phone to technology, the vaccine to scientific innovation. The diagram sets the five topics around ingenio humano and names in Spanish what links each pair of neighbors.

Five topics around the words ingenio humano: Entertainment, Technology, Scientific innovation, Communication and media, Artistic expressions.Five topics around the words ingenio humano: Entertainment, Technology, Scientific innovation, Communication and media, Artistic expressions.
The five topics of Human ingenuity and what links each pair of neighbors. Every link asks the editorial’s question: for whom?

Technology carries entertainment, the link the diagram calls difusión (spread). The topic of entertainment follows reggaeton from Panama and San Juan to the global charts, where streaming turned a local scene into a world market. It then turns to series and films in Spanish, such as Roma, on international platforms. A columnist in Miami shows the same spread from inside a family: the music that embarrassed her at fifteen in Hialeah now fills her niece’s playlist in Los Angeles.

Art and the media share memoria: both keep a record of what a society lived through. The topic of artistic expressions reads Mexican muralism, which put the country’s history on public walls in the 1920s, then Guernica and the arpilleras sewn by Chilean women as testimony under the dictatorship. Valparaíso’s open-air murals add the question of who pays when art draws tourists. The topic of communication and media starts from a hoax on a Madrid class chat, then turns to fact-checking, community radio in the Sierra Norte of Oaxaca and the risks journalists run.

Technology and science meet in acceso, access. The topic of technology moves from a grandmother’s video calls in Havana, where mobile data is costly, to phone classes for older people in Medellín. It names the digital divide that separates them from their grandchildren. Scientific innovation follows volunteers counting turtles at night in Costa Rica, the telescopes of Chile’s Atacama Desert, scientists who leave their countries, and desalination plants in the Canary Islands. A telescope built with foreign money in Chile and a data plan in Havana raise the same question about who benefits.

The theme also leads out of itself. Music is part of identity, phones change the working world, and every scientific advance raises questions about the environment, which the themes Identities, Social organization and Sharing the planet take further.

The theme in Paper 1, Paper 2 and the individual oral

Paper 1 tasks from Human ingenuity often ask for a judgment on something made: a series, an exhibition, a new app, a school’s rule on phones. The text types offered might be a review, an article for a school magazine or a blog post. A task might read: Las autoridades de su ciudad han decidido abrir gratis los museos públicos un día a la semana. Escriba un texto para la revista de su colegio en el que dé su opinión sobre la medida. A strong response takes a position and supports it with specific detail, as the editorial does with Las meninas and the free evening hours, rather than with general claims about culture.

In Paper 2, news reports, interviews and articles on technology and the media are common kinds of text for this theme. They often present a claim and a doubt about it in the same paragraph, as Omar’s choice of phone does with aunque reconoce que…. Items that ask for a writer’s attitude depend on catching such connectors of concession.

In the individual oral at SL, a visual stimulus on this theme might show a mural, a concert crowd or a family each looking at a different screen. The presentation interprets the image and links it to places where Spanish is spoken: a mural to Mexico City or Valparaíso, a screen to a video call between Havana and Miami. The general conversation then moves to at least one other theme.

The theme opens with entertainment, where songs and series give the language of reacting and recommending, and ends with scientific innovation, where the editorial’s question about who benefits is asked of research itself.

Carry on with Human ingenuity in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.