4.5 Perspective

Perspective as a way of reading: whose eyes a text uses, whose knowledge it trusts and whose silence matters, from narrators and speakers to a work’s angle on its world.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 4 Central concepts
  • SL and HL

28 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 4.5 Perspective

Every text is seen from somewhere. A reader shares the eyes and voice of a narrator, a speaker or a character, and also takes in the work’s own angle on its subject: what it treats as normal, what it mocks, what it never looks at. Reading for perspective asks three questions of a text. Through whose eyes is this seen? Whose knowledge does the text trust? Whose silence matters?

“White Nights” (1848) is a short novel by the Russian writer Fyodor Dostoevsky, read here in Constance Garnett’s translation of 1918. Its narrator is a young clerk in St Petersburg who calls himself a dreamer, and it opens in early summer, when the city empties.

White Nights (opening)White Nights and Other Stories, 1918Fyodor Dostoevsky, “White Nights”, translated by Constance Garnett, White Nights and Other Stories (New York: Macmillan, 1918)
It was a wonderful night, such a night as is only possible when we are young, dear reader. The sky was so starry, so bright that, looking at it, one could not help asking oneself whether ill-humoured and capricious people could live under such a sky. That is a youthful question too, dear reader, very youthful, but may the Lord put it more frequently into your heart!... Speaking of capricious and ill-humoured people, I cannot help recalling my moral condition all that day. From early morning I had been oppressed by a strange despondency. It suddenly seemed to me that I was lonely, that every one was forsaking me and going away from me. Of course, any one is entitled to ask who “every one” was. For though I had been living almost eight years in Petersburg I had hardly an acquaintance. But what did I want with acquaintances? I was acquainted with all Petersburg as it was; that was why I felt as though they were all deserting me when all Petersburg packed up and went to its summer villa. I felt afraid of being left alone, and for three whole days I wandered about the town in profound dejection, not knowing what to do with myself. Whether I walked in the Nevsky, went to the Gardens or sauntered on the embankment, there was not one face of those I had been accustomed to meet at the same time and place all the year. They, of course, do not know me, but I know them. I know them intimately, I have almost made a study of their faces, and am delighted when they are gay, and downcast when they are under a cloud. I have almost struck up a friendship with one old man whom I meet every blessed day, at the same hour in Fontanka. Such a grave, pensive countenance; he is always whispering to himself and brandishing his left arm, while in his right hand he holds a long gnarled stick with a gold knob. He even notices me and takes a warm interest in me. If I happen not to be at a certain time in the same spot in Fontanka, I am certain he feels disappointed. That is how it is that we almost bow to each other, especially when we are both in good humour. The other day, when we had not seen each other for two days and met on the third, we were actually touching our hats, but, realizing in time, dropped our hands and passed each other with a look of interest.
I know the houses too. As I walk along they seem to run forward in the streets to look out at me from every window, and almost to say: “Good-morning! How do you do? I am quite well, thank God, and I am to have a new storey in May,” or, “How are you? I am being redecorated to-morrow”; or, “I was almost burnt down and had such a fright,” and so on. I have my favourites among them, some are dear friends; one of them intends to be treated by the architect this summer. I shall go every day on purpose to see that the operation is not a failure. God forbid! But I shall never forget an incident with a very pretty little house of a light pink colour. It was such a charming little brick house, it looked so hospitably at me, and so proudly at its ungainly neighbours, that my heart rejoiced whenever I happened to pass it. Suddenly last week I walked along the street, and when I looked at my friend I heard a plaintive, “They are painting me yellow!” The villains! The barbarians! They had spared nothing, neither columns, nor cornices, and my poor little friend was as yellow as a canary. It almost made me bilious. And to this day I have not had the courage to visit my poor disfigured friend, painted the colour of the Celestial Empire.
So now you understand, reader, in what sense I am acquainted with all Petersburg.

Two senses of perspective

The narrator says of the people he passes every day: “They, of course, do not know me, but I know them” (paragraph 1). Everything in the passage comes through this one man. The old man in Fontanka is described as he appears to the narrator, and his feelings are guessed: “I am certain he feels disappointed” (paragraph 1). The houses speak only because the narrator hears them speak. This is perspective in its narrow sense, the position from which events are seen and told. The toolkit’s account of narrative voice and point of view supplies the terms for its mechanics: here a first-person narration, in which the teller and the one who sees are the same person.

The passage has a perspective in a wider sense too. The story is not only told by the dreamer; it takes an attitude toward him. Paragraph 3 is a single sentence, “So now you understand, reader, in what sense I am acquainted with all Petersburg”, and it exposes what the narrator half admits. He knows the city as a lonely person knows it, through faces that never speak to him and buildings he treats as friends. The work’s angle on him is both comic and tender. It laughs at a man who is horrified that a pink house is painted yellow, and it shows how empty a life must be for that to matter.

Both senses belong to perspective: the position from which a text’s world is seen, and the text’s own angle on that world. The diagram sets out the two for “White Nights”. The narrow sense asks what this narrator can see and know. The wide sense asks what the work makes of what he sees, and it often shows something the narrator cannot.

Diagram of two nested frames. The inner frame, the narrow sense, is the dreamer’s eye and voice in paragraphs 1–2. The outer frame, the wide sense, is the work’s angle: an emptied summer city and a loner who calls himself acquainted with it, shown with comedy and pity.Diagram of two nested frames. The inner frame, the narrow sense, is the dreamer’s eye and voice in paragraphs 1–2. The outer frame, the wide sense, is the work’s angle: an emptied summer city and a loner who calls himself acquainted with it, shown with comedy and pity.
Perspective in two senses, applied to the opening of “White Nights”. The narrator’s view sits inside the work’s view of him.

A perspective that knows its own limits

The dreamer is not simply blind to his situation. In paragraph 1 he stops himself: “Of course, any one is entitled to ask who ‘every one’ was.” He anticipates an objection and answers it with a paradox, since he had “hardly an acquaintance” and yet was “acquainted with all Petersburg as it was”. A narrator who comments on the limits of his own view opens two positions at once: inside his feeling of desertion, and outside it, judging the logic that produces it.

The address to “dear reader”, used twice in the first three sentences, pulls the reader into the narrator’s position. It assumes agreement (“such a night as is only possible when we are young”) and asks for sympathy. The perspective of the whole story depends on this balance between closeness and distance. Too close, and the dreamer becomes a mere complainer; too distant, and he becomes a joke.

Case study: what Nick Carraway knows

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby (1925) is narrated by Nick Carraway, a young man from the Midwest who spends the summer of 1922 in a small house on Long Island, beside the mansion of the mysterious Jay Gatsby. His cousin Daisy lives across the bay with her husband, Tom Buchanan. The novel’s first pages, where Nick claims to be “inclined to reserve all judgements” (chapter 1), are the standard example of a narrator whose claims the story tests, and the account of fiction’s narrators treats them in that light. Perspective asks a different question of the same narrator: where he stands, how he comes to know what he tells, and what his position keeps out of view.

Nick describes his own position at a crowded party in a New York apartment in chapter 2. He imagines a stranger in the street looking up at the lit windows, and identifies with him as well as with the people in the room:

I was within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible variety of life.

F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (1925), chapter 2

The sentence defines the novel’s perspective. Nick is inside the world of wealth by family and education, since Daisy is his cousin and Tom was at college with him, and outside it by money and temperament. Being “within and without” lets him report the parties in loving detail and judge them at the same time. The pairing “enchanted and repelled” holds both responses in one breath, and the novel rarely lets one cancel the other.

Seen, told and reconstructed

Much of Gatsby’s story happens where Nick cannot see it. The novel gets around this by letting other people tell him, and the diagram sets out where each part of the story comes from. In chapter 4, Jordan Baker tells how Daisy and Gatsby met in 1917. The novel prints her account in her own voice, framed by a parenthesis: “(said Jordan Baker that afternoon, sitting up very straight on a straight chair in the tea-garden at the Plaza Hotel)”. A story told inside the story by one of its characters is an embedded narrative, and it adds a second perspective, a cooler and more amused one, to Nick’s.

Table-like diagram of where Nick learns each part of the story in The Great Gatsby: seen by Nick (parties, the Plaza quarrel); told by Jordan (Daisy and Gatsby in 1917); told by Gatsby (his past as James Gatz); Michaelis at the inquest (the accident); told by Wolfsheim; never told (Myrtle’s and…Table-like diagram of where Nick learns each part of the story in The Great Gatsby: seen by Nick (parties, the Plaza quarrel); told by Jordan (Daisy and Gatsby in 1917); told by Gatsby (his past as James Gatz); Michaelis at the inquest (the accident); told by Wolfsheim; never told (Myrtle’s and…
How Nick knows what he tells in *The Great Gatsby*. Most of the story reaches him secondhand, and two minds are never entered at all.

Gatsby’s real past arrives in chapter 6, where Nick explains that the young James Gatz of North Dakota invented “Jay Gatsby” at seventeen. Nick adds that “He told me all this very much later”, and that he has placed it early “with the idea of exploding those first wild rumours about his antecedents”. The order of the telling is Nick’s decision. The correction comes before the novel’s events would allow it, and it protects Gatsby from the gossip repeated at his parties.

The car accident in chapter 7 is reconstructed from witnesses. Michaelis, who runs the coffee shop beside the garage, “was the principal witness at the inquest”, and the novel tells the scene through what he saw and heard. Only later in the chapter does Nick learn, from Gatsby, the fact that no witness knew. His question is short: “Was Daisy driving?” Daisy, not Gatsby, killed Myrtle Wilson. Nick, and the novel’s audience with him, now know more than the inquest, the police and Myrtle’s husband.

What Nick keeps to himself

Nick tells his story’s audience that Daisy was driving and tells no one inside the story. Tom Buchanan, meanwhile, has told George Wilson whose car it was, and Wilson shoots Gatsby and then himself. A narrator’s perspective includes his silences, and this one shapes the plot as well as the telling. Nick’s withholding protects the Buchanans, the people he goes on to condemn.

That condemnation comes in chapter 9, when Nick meets Tom on Fifth Avenue. He calls Tom and Daisy “careless people” who “smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money”. In the next paragraph he writes, “I shook hands with him; it seemed silly not to”. The judgment and the handshake sit side by side. At the moment the novel’s view of the rich is sharpest, its narrator’s behavior shows how hard that view is to act on from inside their world.

Whose eyes are never used

Two characters are never seen from inside. Myrtle Wilson, Tom’s mistress, gets one long speech in her own words in chapter 2, the story of meeting Tom on a train, which ends with what she kept thinking: “You can’t live forever; you can’t live forever.” Everything else about her is Nick’s view of her body, her clothes and her loud laughter. George Wilson, her husband, is seen by Michaelis in chapter 8, staring at an old advertising billboard of a pair of huge eyes. “God sees everything,” he says, and Michaelis replies, “That’s an advertisement.”

The exchange sets two perspectives against each other, and the novel gives Wilson’s no further room. Myrtle’s hope of escape and George’s grief are the strongest feelings in the book outside Gatsby’s, and both arrive secondhand. Whether this is Fitzgerald’s blind spot or Nick’s is the real question. Michaelis’s patient, sympathetic report suggests that the novel knows what its narrator does not see, and leaves the gap open to view. In either case the absence follows a class line: the people in the valley of ashes, beside the road between Long Island and New York, are seen from passing cars.

Worldview, subjectivity and objectivity

Behind every perspective lies a set of beliefs that makes the world look a certain way. Nick Carraway names his on the first page of The Great Gatsby, when he explains why he tries not to criticize others:

I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that, as my father snobbishly suggested, and I snobbishly repeat, a sense of the fundamental decencies is parcelled out unequally at birth.

F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (1925), chapter 1

The belief is that decency is inherited, like money, and that those born with less of it deserve patience rather than blame. It is generous and condescending at once, and the double adverb “snobbishly … snobbishly” admits that Nick half knows this. A set of beliefs and assumptions through which a person makes sense of the world is a worldview. Nick’s worldview shapes his whole report: it explains his tolerance of Gatsby’s lies and his slowness to judge Tom.

A text can present a worldview from inside, so that it feels natural, or set it beside others so that it can be judged. The dreamer of “White Nights” mourns the pink house that has been “painted the colour of the Celestial Empire” (paragraph 2), the old name for China. Yellow, to him, is the color of a foreign and lesser place, and the joke depends on sharing the assumption without noticing it. Fitzgerald does the opposite at the end of his novel, when Nick calls the whole book “a story of the West” (chapter 9). Nick’s Midwestern worldview is named, placed on a map and set against the East’s, so it appears as one view among others.

Subjective and objective telling

The dreamer’s telling is openly personal. When the pink house is repainted he cries out “The villains! The barbarians!” (paragraph 2), and every building is described by the feelings it gives him. A view or a style shaped openly by one person’s feelings and position has strong subjectivity. Its effect is intimacy, since the passage tells as much about the narrator as about the city.

The French novelist Gustave Flaubert aimed at the opposite effect. In a letter to Louise Colet of 9 December 1852, he wrote that an author in a book must be like God in the universe, “present everywhere and visible nowhere”. Albert Camus’s The Stranger (1942) pushes the idea into a first-person voice. Its narrator, Meursault, reports his mother’s funeral, a swim, a love affair and the killing of a man on a beach in the same flat sentences, with almost no comment. The narration seems to have objectivity, and the work of judging passes to the reader. In the novel’s second half, at Meursault’s trial, the prosecutor supplies the feelings the narration left out and builds a story about a heartless man. The novel sets an objective telling against a subjective one and asks which is closer to the truth.

Seeing less than the reader

Some narrators understand less of their own story than the reader does. Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus (2003) is narrated by Kambili Achike, a fifteen-year-old girl in Enugu, Nigeria, whose father is a wealthy Catholic businessman, admired in public and violent at home. The novel opens:

Things started to fall apart at home when my brother, Jaja, did not go to communion

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, Purple Hibiscus (2003), opening sentence

The phrase “fall apart” echoes the title of Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart (1958), and Kambili applies it to a family where things have been broken for years. She does not yet see this. She reports her father’s punishments in the same careful voice she uses for his generosity, and she wants above all to please him. When he pours boiling water on her feet for sleeping in the same house as her grandfather, whom he calls a heathen, she tells it without condemning him. The reader judges what the narrator cannot.

A narrator who understands less than the reader, often because the narrator is a child, is a naive narrator. The effect is a double vision. The events are seen through innocent eyes and, at the same time, the novel shows what those eyes miss, which makes the cruelty clearer and the child more sympathetic. A naive narrator differs from an unreliable narrator who deceives himself or the reader: Kambili reports honestly, and the gap lies in her understanding, not in her honesty.

Two other children

Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird (1960) is narrated by an adult looking back, but most of its scenes keep to what Scout Finch understood as a child. In chapter 15 a crowd of men comes at night to the jail where her father guards a Black prisoner, Tom Robinson. Scout, who does not grasp that they mean to lynch him, chats politely to one of the men about his son and his debts until he is ashamed and leads the crowd away. Her innocence defeats the mob, and the irony is entirely the reader’s.

Marjane Satrapi’s graphic memoir Persepolis (first published in French, 2000–2003) draws the Iranian revolution of 1979 as a girl of ten saw it. The young Marji believes she will be a prophet and talks with God at night. When her beloved uncle Anoosh is executed by the new regime, she sends God out of her life. The adult Satrapi draws and narrates, but the panels keep the child’s scale and her partial grasp of politics, so the history arrives through what a child could see of it.

Try it

In paragraph 1 of “White Nights”, the narrator says of the old man in Fontanka, “I am certain he feels disappointed” when the narrator is absent. Is this narrator naive, and what does the sentence show about his perspective?

He is not naive in the way Kambili or Scout is: he is an adult and half aware of his situation. But the sentence shows him seeing less than the reader. He has no way of knowing what the old man feels, and certain claims a knowledge he cannot have. The sentence shows a lonely man projecting his own need for company onto a stranger, which is the comic and sad core of the passage.

Standpoint: where the knower stands

In “The Cutting of My Long Hair” (1900), Zitkála-Šá, a Yankton Dakota writer, remembers her first day at a missionary boarding school in Indiana, aged eight. She hides from the women who mean to cut her hair, and the room is described from where she lies:

From my hiding place I peered out, shuddering with fear whenever I heard footsteps near by. … What caused them to stoop and look under the bed I do not know.

Zitkála-Šá, “The Cutting of My Long Hair”, paragraph 5

The view from under the bed is a literal position: the girl sees feet, closet doors and trunks, and cannot see why she is found. It is also a social position. To the school, cutting a pupil’s hair is routine; to a Dakota child, as paragraph 1 explains, short hair marks a mourner and shingled hair a coward. When the scissors “gnaw off” a braid (paragraph 6), the girl sees herself as the school sees her, “only one of many little animals driven by a herder”. The same event means different things from different positions, and the text supplies the position the school’s own records would leave out.

The social position from which a person knows and speaks, shaped by gender, class, race and power, is a standpoint. The idea comes from feminist philosophy. Nancy Hartsock’s essay “The Feminist Standpoint: Developing the Ground for a Specifically Feminist Historical Materialism” (1983) argued that people at the bottom of a social order can see how it works more clearly than those at the top. Those at the top have reason not to look. Sandra Harding, in Whose Science? Whose Knowledge? (1991), called the method of starting from marginal lives “strong objectivity”. Their critics answer that no single position holds the whole truth, and that one group contains many standpoints. Zitkála-Šá’s text supports both sides: it shows what the school cannot see, and it admits what the hidden child could not see either.

Standpoint differs from an insider perspective, the view of a culture from someone who belongs to it. Zitkála-Šá writes as an insider to Dakota culture, but her standpoint is also that of a child, a girl and a member of a conquered people inside an institution. Reading for standpoint asks which of these positions shapes a particular sentence.

The perspective that is missing

Standpoint leads to a harder question: whose position is never used at all? In The Great Gatsby it is the Wilsons’; in many novels of empire it is the colonized. Albert Camus’s The Stranger never names the Arab man whom Meursault shoots. Works that answer such silences, by retelling a famous story from the position it ignored, are studied as writing back, and the page on multiple perspectives follows one of them. The question does not need a later rewriting. It is enough to list the people in a work who are spoken about and never speak, and to ask what the work would be if one of them told it.

Perspective in poetry and drama

A poem has a speaker, and the poem’s angle on its subject can differ from the speaker’s. In A. B. Paterson’s bush ballad “Clancy of the Overflow” (1889), a city clerk writes to a drover he once met and receives an answer from Clancy’s shearing mate. It is his only fact about Clancy:

’Twas his shearing mate who wrote it, and verbatim I will quote it:
‘Clancy’s gone to Queensland droving, and we don’t know where he are.’

A. B. Paterson, “Clancy of the Overflow”, lines 7–8

The rest of Clancy’s life is the clerk’s invention, and the poem says so: “In my wild erratic fancy visions come to me of Clancy” (line 9). The speaker imagines the bush as all friends, breezes and “everlasting stars” (line 16), and the city as “pallid faces” and children fighting in the gutter (lines 25 and 23). His perspective is a city dweller’s dream of the country. The poem’s angle is gentler and more ironic. The ungrammatical letter, written “with a thumb-nail dipped in tar” (line 6), is all the speaker actually knows of the droving life. The last line turns the perspective round for a moment: “But I doubt he’d suit the office, Clancy, of ‘The Overflow’” (line 32).

The worldview behind the poem was argued in public. In 1892 Paterson and Henry Lawson wrote rival poems in The Bulletin, the Sydney weekly, about whether life in the bush was noble or brutal. Lawson’s bush sketches, such as “In a Dry Season”, show a hot, empty country that ruins the people who try to farm it. Read together, the two writers show that a landscape has no single meaning: it depends on where the writer stands, and Paterson’s clerk stands in an office.

A stage with no narrator

Drama has no narrator to tell the audience whose view to share, so its perspective is built by what the stage shows. Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman (1949) puts the audience inside the mind of its hero, Willy Loman, an aging salesman. Its opening stage directions explain that in scenes set in the present the actors keep to the imaginary walls of the house, while in scenes from the past they walk straight through them. Willy’s memories enter the present without warning, and the audience sees them as he does.

The stage can give the audience knowledge that characters lack. Late in the play a remembered scene in a Boston hotel shows what Willy’s son Biff discovered there years before: his father with another woman. Willy’s wife, Linda, does not know of it. This is dramatic irony, and it changes the audience’s perspective on everything in the family: Biff’s anger, which Willy explains as spite, has a cause the audience has now seen. Perspective in drama is controlled less by who speaks than by who is present when something is shown.

Perspective in the three areas

The last paragraph of the “White Nights” opening turns from the city to the reader:

So now you understand, reader, in what sense I am acquainted with all Petersburg.

Fyodor Dostoevsky, “White Nights”, translated by Constance Garnett, paragraph 3

The sentence assumes agreement with the narrator’s view and, in the same breath, invites a step back to see its oddness. Each area of exploration works with that movement between positions. In Readers, writers and texts, perspective explains how a text positions its reader: the dreamer’s “you understand” asks for agreement, and Kambili’s calm voice leaves the anger for others to supply. Readers also bring perspectives of their own, so a student who has lived under a strict parent may read Purple Hibiscus quite differently from one who has not.

In Time and space, perspective belongs to a period and a place. The dreamer’s “Celestial Empire” carries a nineteenth-century European view of China, and Nick’s “story of the West” carries an American map of moral geography in the 1920s. A reader a century later sees those views as views, which their first readers often did not. A work in translation adds another position: Constance Garnett’s English is itself a reading of the dreamer’s voice.

In Intertextuality, works answer one another’s perspectives. Paterson’s clerk and Lawson’s bush sketches give opposite views of one country, and later writers have retold famous works from the position of a character the original left silent. Perspective is often the clearest point of comparison between two works, because it can be named precisely: who sees, what they cannot see, and whose view is missing.

Perspective with other concepts

Perspective pairs most closely with two other concepts. With communication it asks what a teller chooses to pass on: Nick’s silence about who was driving is a fact about his perspective and about what he communicates. With representation it asks how a position shapes the way people are shown. Myrtle Wilson is represented almost entirely through Nick’s eyes, so the question of how she is portrayed cannot be separated from the question of who is looking.

Writing about perspective

A weak sentence about perspective names the narration and stops. A strong one says what the position lets the reader know and what it hides, and ties that to a moment in the text. The two sentences that follow are about the same chapter of The Great Gatsby.

Weak: The story is told from Nick’s point of view, so the reader only sees what Nick sees.note 1

Strong: Nick learns Gatsby’s real past “very much later” but places it in chapter 6,note 2 so the reader meets the true James Gatz while the party guests still trade rumors, and shares the view of a narrator who has already chosen to protect him.note 3

  1. True of every first-person novel. The sentence names a point of view and adds nothing about this novel; it would fit almost any book told in the first person.

  2. Position and choice. The strong version names where Nick’s knowledge comes from and the decision he makes about its order.

  3. Effect on the reader. It states what the arrangement does: it gives the reader Nick’s protective view of Gatsby before the reader has any reason to share it.

The strong sentence treats perspective as something the text does, not as a fixed fact about the narration. The same habit works for poetry. A student writing about “Clancy of the Overflow” might produce the following paragraph, built on the gap between the speaker’s view and the poem’s.

“Clancy of the Overflow” lets its speaker dream and quietly shows the reader what the dream rests on.note 1 The clerk’s Clancy rides “behind them singing” (line 11) under “everlasting stars” (line 16), but the only evidence he has is a letter “written with a thumb-nail dipped in tar” (line 6) saying “we don’t know where he are” (line 8).note 2 The poem therefore presents the bush as a city man imagines it, and its last line, “But I doubt he’d suit the office” (line 32), turns that perspective back on the speaker, who suddenly sees his own world through Clancy’s eyes.note 3

  1. A claim about perspective. The topic sentence separates the speaker’s view from the poem’s angle on it.

  2. Evidence on both sides. Quotations from the vision and from the letter set the dream beside its thin basis.

  3. The turn. The paragraph ends on the line where the perspective reverses, and says what the reversal shows.

Applying it in Paper 2

Paper 2 questions often turn on perspective without using the word. A question may ask how two works use a character who sees more, or less, than those around them, how they shape the reader’s trust in a teller, or how they present an event from more than one side. A question of this kind directs attention to method: the position a work gives its narrator or speaker, the gaps in that position, and what the work does with the gaps. Nick Carraway and Kambili Achike make a strong pair, because both narrate the harm done by people they love or admire, and they fail to judge it for opposite reasons.

I shook hands with him; it seemed silly not to, for I felt suddenly as though I were talking to a child.

F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (1925), chapter 9

A comparative sentence on the pair might read: “Both narrators stay close to the people who cause harm, but Nick chooses to shake Tom’s hand while calling him careless, whereas Kambili cannot yet see her father’s violence as a fault at all, so Fitzgerald exposes a failure of nerve where Adichie shows a failure of knowledge that the novel slowly repairs.” The sentence names the shared method, separates the two works by the cause of each narrator’s limit, and states what the difference shows about each.

The commonest way to lose marks is to reduce perspective to grammar. An essay that says “both novels are told in the first person” has found a likeness that fits thousands of books and explains nothing about these two. The second common loss is to discuss each narrator’s character as if the narrator were a real person, rather than a position the writer has built to control what the reader sees.

The HL essay asks for the same analysis on one work, followed further. A single narrator’s perspective, traced through a sequence of chosen moments, can carry a whole essay if each moment adds something the last did not.

The same axis serves the individual oral. A global issue such as how families hide violence from outsiders could be explored through an extract from Purple Hibiscus and one from Persepolis, read in translation, asking in each what the child sees and what the work lets its audience see past her.

Perspective leads to communication, which asks what a teller passes on and to whom, and to representation, which asks how a position shapes the way people and places are shown. Works built from several narrators or witnesses take the question one step further, by setting perspectives against each other inside one book.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain the narrow and wide senses of perspective with an example of each from one text.

  • To do:

    I can show how a narrator’s sources, order of telling and silences control what the reader knows, using The Great Gatsby or another work.

  • To do:

    I can distinguish worldview, standpoint, subjectivity and objectivity, with an example of each.

  • To do:

    I can explain how a naive narrator produces irony, and how it differs from an unreliable narrator.

  • To do:

    I can identify whose perspective a work never uses and argue what the absence means.

  • To do:

    I can show how a poem’s angle differs from its speaker’s, and how staging builds perspective in drama.

  • To do:

    I can plan a comparison of two works with perspective as its axis.

Key terms

Each is also in the Central concepts glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Naive narrator

A narrator who understands less of the events than the reader does, often because the narrator is a child or new to a place. The gap between what the narrator reports and what the reader grasps produces irony and often strong sympathy.

Objectivity

The quality, or the effect, of a view that seems free of personal feeling and judgment, reporting events without comment. In literature it is always a constructed effect, which leaves the work of judging to the reader.

Perspective

The position from which a text's events, people and world are seen, both in the narrow sense of whose eyes and voice a reader shares and in the wide sense of the work's own angle on its subject. Reading for perspective asks what that position shows, what it hides and whose view is missing.

Standpoint

The social position, shaped by things such as gender, class, race and power, from which a person knows and speaks. Thinking about standpoint asks what a position makes visible and what it makes hard to see.

Subjectivity

The quality of a view or a style that is shaped openly by one person's feelings, memories and position. In a text it shows in judgments, emotional language and a voice that colors everything it reports.

Worldview

The set of beliefs and assumptions through which a person, character, speaker or culture makes sense of the world. A text can show a worldview from inside, so that it feels natural, or set it beside others so that it can be judged.

Practice questions on 4.5 Perspective

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGAL-0000120 marks
Near EnoughThe Weighing House, a novel of Dundee, 1958Written for Augment Education
The lorry came through the gate on the second Monday in October, at twenty past ten by our clock, which made it sixteen minutes past by everyone else’s. I know the time because I wrote it down. Mr Gourlay had me enter it in the In ledger like any other delivery, although it was not jute and the platform scale would not have taken one of its wheels. There was no column for what it was, so I wrote it across three: One motor lorry, green, with tarpaulin. Under weight I put nothing. Mr Gourlay looked at the line for some time and then initialled it, which he did not usually do.
My father had driven the mill’s cart for eleven years, behind a grey horse called Major who knew the road to the docks better than he did and stopped of his own accord at the foot of the Wellgate. From the weighing-house window I watched the manager walk round the lorry with its driver, kicking a tyre, and I did not see my father anywhere in the yard. I saw Major. Somebody had left him in the shafts by the stable door, and he stood with his head down, the way horses stand in rain, though it was not raining.
My father came home at seven, an hour after the hooter, which was the first thing. My mother was at the range with her back to the door and her good ear to the room. He set his tin on the table and she opened it, as she did every night, to see what had come back. It was empty. ‘You’ve eaten your pieces, then,’ she said, louder than she needed to, and he said, ‘Aye.’ He ate them whatever happened; I have thought since that he must have given them to the horse.
Nobody said anything about the lorry. Davie talked about a ship he had seen in the Earl Grey Dock with a funnel striped like a barber’s pole, and my father asked him the right questions about her: where she was from, what she carried, how low she sat in the water. My mother put the plates down hard, one after another, as she always did. She had not heard Davie, or she had heard enough.

In this extract from a novel, the narrator, Isobel, is a clerk in the weighing house of a jute mill, where her father drives the mill’s cart.

Write a guided literary analysis of the extract from the novel The Weighing House.

Guiding question: How does the older narrator’s voice shape the reader’s understanding of the family’s silence?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the extract.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-0000220 marks
First MorningNotes from Carlisle Bay, a book of travel writing from Barbados, 1890sWritten for Augment Education
The doctor in Clifton had said Barbados, and said it in the voice he used for barley water, so that I understood I was being prescribed and not consulted. My nephew, who has been everywhere once, told me that Bridgetown was a hot little town of no consequence, built on sugar and kept up by sermons. I have since learnt to divide everything my nephew says by two; but on the morning the Esk came to anchor in Carlisle Bay I had not yet learnt it, and I stood at the rail with my parasol furled, prepared to be unimpressed.
There was no time for it. Before the anchor chain had stopped complaining, the ship was surrounded by boats, and every boat had a man standing in it, and every man was shouting. They offered to carry our luggage, our persons, our letters, our sorrows. One held up a pineapple to me as a priest holds up the Host. I am sixty-three years of age and have buried a husband and two sisters, and I was lowered into the boat of the loudest of them in a sort of canvas chair on a rope, like a parcel of the better kind, with my skirts gathered in one hand and my dignity in the other. The boatman received me with great courtesy and told me I was very light for a lady from England. I have not decided whether this was a compliment.
The Careenage is a narrow arm of water that runs up into the town, and it was so packed with schooners that a person might have walked across it on their decks. Everything smelt of molasses. Great barrels, which I am told are called puncheons, were being rolled along the wharf by men who sang to keep time, and the sound they made on the stones was like slow thunder. Above them the sun was already high and white, though it was not eight o’clock, and I opened my parasol and felt at once that it was a small and foolish thing.
Broad Street might be any street in Bath, if Bath had been left out in the weather. The shops have English names over them and English hats in the windows, a season late. At the end of it stands Lord Nelson in bronze, who has been there since before I was born, and who looked, I thought, as hot as I was and a good deal more patient. A policeman in a white helmet directed me to the tram, which is drawn by two small mules who seemed to share my opinion of the climate.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from Notes from Carlisle Bay, a piece of travel writing.

Guiding question: How and to what effect does the writer’s voice present her first day in Bridgetown?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-0001820 marks
The Man-o’-War BirdNotes from the Careenage, a collection of essays from Bridgetown, Barbados, 1940sWritten for Augment Education
From my stool at the high desk in the counting-room of Da Costa and Lashley, commission merchants, Broad Street, I can see a piece of sky about the size of a ledger opened flat. It lies between the corner of the bond warehouse and the clock on the Public Buildings, and for most of the year there is nothing in it but weather. From May until about November, however, it holds a man-o’-war bird.
I say a bird, because I have never been able to prove that it is not the same one. It hangs above the Careenage on wings longer than I am tall, crooked at the elbow like an umbrella half blown inside out, and it does not move them. I have timed it by the Public Buildings clock. On the eleventh of June it held its place for nineteen minutes, in which time I entered fourteen bills of lading in the day book and Mr Lashley asked me twice whether I was paid to look out of windows. I am not. I am paid three pounds ten a month, and there is no column in any book of this firm for what the bird does.
The fishermen at the Careenage, who know it better than I do, say that it cannot settle on the sea. Its feathers take the wet like a sponge, and once down it would never rise again; so it must stay up there, or on a branch, all its life. Nor does it fish, not as the pelicans fish, folding up and dropping like a sack off a dray. It waits until a booby has fished. Then it comes down on the booby out of the sun and worries it in the air, turn for turn, until the booby lets go, and it takes the fish before the fish can reach the water. Mr Bourne, who keeps the flying-fish boat Endeavour in the inner basin, calls this collecting. He means it as a joke against the bird, I think. But he had the word from somewhere.
Collecting is a word I know. A schooner comes in from Demerara with rice and goes out with molasses, and the commission is ours. A planter in St Philip draws on his account for nails, saltfish and a new set of coppers for the boiling-house, and pays when the crop is sold, or does not pay, and the interest runs on in red ink beside his name. I have never been to St Philip. I know the estates there as balances, some of them very old. The firm lends, and waits, and is paid; I write it down.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from Notes from the Careenage, a collection of essays written in Bridgetown, Barbados, in the 1940s.

Guiding question: In what ways does the description of the man-o’-war bird shape the writer’s reflections on work?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 35 questions on 4.5 Perspective

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

4.5 Perspective questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 4 Central concepts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 4.1Identity
  2. 4.2Culture
  3. 4.3Creativity
  4. 4.4Communication
  5. 4.5PerspectiveThis page
  6. 4.6Transformation
  7. 4.7Representation

Carry on with 4.5 Perspective in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.