3.4 How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?

What makes a work a classic, how canons are made and challenged, and how to evaluate the idea of the classic through Equiano’s Narrative and the quarrel over Heart of Darkness.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts
  • SL and HL

29 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 3.4 How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?

A classic is a work that readers keep returning to, and that keeps answering new questions when they do. Whether a work becomes one depends partly on its qualities and partly on people and institutions: publishers, critics, teachers, prize juries and translators decide which books stay in print and in classrooms. The idea of the classic is therefore valid as a description of a continuing argument, and invalid as a verdict handed down once and for all.

Olaudah Equiano’s The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavus Vassa, the African (London, 1789) shows how such an argument changes over time. It was a bestseller in the years of the campaign against the slave trade, was then little read for more than a century, and is now taught as a founding work of Black writing in English. In this extract from chapter II, Equiano describes being brought, as a child, aboard a slave ship on the West African coast.

The Slave Ship (chapter II)The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavus Vassa, the African, 1789Olaudah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavus Vassa, the African, vol. 1, chapter II (London: printed for the author, 1789)
The first object which saluted my eyes when I arrived on the coast was the sea, and a slave ship, which was then riding at anchor, and waiting for its cargo. These filled me with astonishment, which was soon converted into terror when I was carried on board. I was immediately handled and tossed up to see if I were sound by some of the crew; and I was now persuaded that I had gotten into a world of bad spirits, and that they were going to kill me. Their complexions too differing so much from ours, their long hair, and the language they spoke, (which was very different from any I had ever heard) united to confirm me in this belief. Indeed such were the horrors of my views and fears at the moment, that, if ten thousand worlds had been my own, I would have freely parted with them all to have exchanged my condition with that of the meanest slave in my own country. When I looked round the ship too and saw a large furnace or copper boiling, and a multitude of black people of every description chained together, every one of their countenances expressing dejection and sorrow, I no longer doubted of my fate; and, quite overpowered with horror and anguish, I fell motionless on the deck and fainted. When I recovered a little I found some black people about me, who I believed were some of those who brought me on board, and had been receiving their pay; they talked to me in order to cheer me, but all in vain. I asked them if we were not to be eaten by those white men with horrible looks, red faces, and loose hair. They told me I was not; and one of the crew brought me a small portion of spirituous liquor in a wine glass; but, being afraid of him, I would not take it out of his hand. One of the blacks therefore took it from him and gave it to me, and I took a little down my palate, which, instead of reviving me, as they thought it would, threw me into the greatest consternation at the strange feeling it produced, having never tasted any such liquor before. Soon after this the blacks who brought me on board went off, and left me abandoned to despair. I now saw myself deprived of all chance of returning to my native country, or even the least glimpse of hope of gaining the shore, which I now considered as friendly; and I even wished for my former slavery in preference to my present situation, which was filled with horrors of every kind, still heightened by my ignorance of what I was to undergo. I was not long suffered to indulge my grief; I was soon put down under the decks, and there I received such a salutation in my nostrils as I had never experienced in my life: so that, with the loathsomeness of the stench, and crying together, I became so sick and low that I was not able to eat, nor had I the least desire to taste any thing. I now wished for the last friend, death, to relieve me; but soon, to my grief, two of the white men offered me eatables; and, on my refusing to eat, one of them held me fast by the hands, and laid me across I think the windlass, and tied my feet, while the other flogged me severely.

What keeps a work in circulation

The extract is told by two people at once. One is the child who cannot name what he sees. To him the ship is “a world of bad spirits” (sentence 3) and the crew are “white men with horrible looks” (sentence 8), while the liquor he is given produces only “the greatest consternation” (sentence 10). The other is the adult writer in London, who knows exactly what the ship was and chooses his words with control. When the sea and the ship are “the first object which saluted my eyes” (sentence 1), the verb is a courteous one, used of a greeting between equals. The same courtesy returns grimly when the hold gives him “such a salutation in my nostrils as I had never experienced” (sentence 13).

The adult narrator’s words for the ship are the words of trade. The ship is “waiting for its cargo” (sentence 1), and the boy is at once “handled and tossed up to see if I were sound” (sentence 3), as a buyer tests goods. Nothing in these phrases says outright that the child has become the cargo, but the diction makes him one. The extract holds the child’s terror and the adult’s cold knowledge in the same sentences, so it can be reread for either, and each return brings more of the second into view.

That capacity to be reread is the oldest test of a classic. In his Preface to his edition of Shakespeare (1765), Samuel Johnson argued that works of imagination cannot be proved excellent the way a theorem can. They can only be compared with other works over a long time:

To works, however, of which the excellence is not absolute and definite, but gradual and comparative; to works not raised upon principles demonstrative and scientifick, but appealing wholly to observation and experience, no other test can be applied than length of duration and continuance of esteem.

Samuel Johnson, Preface to Shakespeare (1765)

Johnson’s test concerns a work’s history as much as the work itself: a classic is what generations have “examined and compared” and still value. Two later writers put the same idea in different ways. In “What Is a Classic?”, an address of 1944, T. S. Eliot tied the word to maturity, by which he meant a work written when a language and a literature had reached their fullest development; his model was Virgil. The Italian novelist Italo Calvino, in “Why Read the Classics?” (1981), offered fourteen definitions. The best known, in Patrick Creagh’s English translation, describes a classic as a book that “has never finished saying what it has to say”.

Three definitions compared

The three definitions measure different things. Johnson measures how long a work has been esteemed. Eliot measures the state of the culture that produced it, which makes the classic rare and tied to a tradition. Calvino measures what happens in the act of reading, so a work can be a classic for one person and not yet for another. Equiano’s narrative passes Calvino’s test easily, since a double voice that holds both “terror” (sentence 2) and the language of “cargo” keeps opening on rereading. It fails Johnson’s test for most of the nineteenth century, when it was hardly read at all.

The difference matters because the two can come apart. A canon is made by choices about many works at once: what goes in an anthology, what a school sets for study, what a publisher keeps in print. A work may be loved by a community for centuries without entering the canon of the schools. Another may sit on a reading list for decades while few people open it outside class.

How a canon is made

Every canon has a history of decisions, and the decisions can be traced. In 1623, seven years after Shakespeare’s death, two actors from his company, John Heminges and Henry Condell, collected 36 of his plays in a single large volume, now called the First Folio. About half of those plays, among them Macbeth, Twelfth Night and The Tempest, had never been printed before. Without the volume they might have been lost. Its prefatory pages also tell the purchaser how to treat the book: “Reade him, therefore; and againe, and againe”.

He was not of an age, but for all time!

Ben Jonson, “To the memorie of my beloued, The AVTHOR MR. WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE: AND what he hath left vs”, First Folio (1623)

Ben Jonson’s commendatory poem in the same volume makes a claim that no one could yet prove. In 1623 Shakespeare was one popular playwright among several, and Jonson himself was at least as respected. The line announces a classic before the rereading that would justify the word, and the volume was built to bring that rereading about: a costly, authorized collection, printed in the large format usually kept for works of history and theology. This is canon formation at its most visible, with named people choosing to preserve, present and praise a body of work.

The title page of the 1623 First Folio: the heading Mr. William Shakespeares Comedies, Histories, & Tragedies, an engraved portrait of Shakespeare with a high forehead and a stiff white collar, and the London imprint and date below.
The title page of the First Folio (1623), with Martin Droeshout’s engraved portrait. The book’s format and its prefatory poems present the plays as works to keep. Title page, Shakespeare First Folio (1623), British Library. Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

The title page groups the plays into “Comedies, Histories, & Tragedies”, the categories by which they are still taught, and places the author’s portrait at the center. Both choices shape how later readers meet the plays: as the works of one great individual, sorted by kind. A different editor might have arranged them by date or by theater, and the canon of Shakespeare’s plays would look slightly different today.

Gates and gatekeepers

Since 1623 the decisions have multiplied. The diagram sets out the main stages through which a work enters a canon and the people who decide at each. A work that passes through publication, reviews, prizes, anthologies and translation is more likely to be reread by new generations, and rereading is what keeps it in. At every stage a work can also drop out of print and off reading lists, and the green route marks the way a forgotten work can come back.

Diagram: six stages of canon formation in two rows (publication, reviews and criticism, prizes; anthologies and lists, translation, rereading), each with the people who decide; dashed arrows lead to a box marked out of print, off the lists, and a green arrow marked recovery returns to publication.Diagram: six stages of canon formation in two rows (publication, reviews and criticism, prizes; anthologies and lists, translation, rereading), each with the people who decide; dashed arrows lead to a box marked out of print, off the lists, and a green arrow marked recovery returns to publication.
How a work enters a canon, who decides at each stage, and how it can leave and return.

The people who decide at each stage are the canon’s gatekeepers. Publishers choose what to print and keep in print, and series such as Penguin Classics, launched in 1946 with E. V. Rieu’s translation of the Odyssey, turn a choice into a label. Anthologies such as The Norton Anthology of English Literature (first edition 1962) decide which few poems by a poet most students will ever read. Prizes, from the Nobel Prize in Literature (first awarded in 1901) to the Booker Prize (first awarded in 1969), direct the attention of readers, translators and schools.

Gatekeeping can open a canon as well as close it. In 1962 the London publisher Heinemann began its African Writers Series, with Chinua Achebe as its first editorial adviser, and the series’ first title was a paperback of his Things Fall Apart. Over the following decades it put cheap editions of African writers into schools across the continent. One of its early titles was an abridged edition of Equiano’s narrative, Equiano’s Travels (1967), edited by Paul Edwards.

Equiano’s road into the canon

Equiano published his narrative himself, by subscription, in 1789, two years after the founding in London of the Society for Effecting the Abolition of the Slave Trade. It was written for British readers at the moment when Parliament first debated the trade, and it went through nine editions in his lifetime. Its sentences are built for that audience. In sentence 5 the child’s terror is measured against a comparison designed to unsettle a British reader’s assumptions:

Indeed such were the horrors of my views and fears at the moment, that, if ten thousand worlds had been my own, I would have freely parted with them all to have exchanged my condition with that of the meanest slave in my own country.

Olaudah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative (1789), chapter II, sentence 5

The hyperbole of “ten thousand worlds” belongs to the child’s fear, but the end of the sentence carries an argument. Defenders of the trade claimed that Africans taken to the Americas were rescued from worse treatment at home. Equiano’s comparison turns that claim around: even “the meanest slave” in his own country was better placed than a free child on a European ship. The sentence works as testimony and as a reply in a public debate at once, which is one reason the book sold.

Its reception history then follows the history of its cause. After Britain abolished the slave trade in 1807 and slavery in most of its colonies in 1834, the book’s argument seemed to many readers to have been won, and it was reprinted only occasionally. For more than a century it was read mainly as a historical document, when it was read at all. Its return began in the 1960s, the decade in which many African states became independent. Paul Edwards’s abridged Equiano’s Travels appeared in 1967, and Henry Louis Gates Jr. placed the full text first in his collection The Classic Slave Narratives (1987). The Penguin Classics edition followed in 1995.

Recovered, and argued over again

Recovery did not end the argument about the book; it began a new one. In 2005 the scholar Vincent Carretta published a biography, Equiano, the African. It reports two documents that give Equiano’s birthplace as Carolina: the parish register of his baptism in London in 1759 and the muster roll of a naval expedition of 1773. If those records are right, the chapters on the African childhood and the crossing may be built from other people’s accounts rather than from memory. Other historians, among them Paul Lovejoy, have replied that the details of the early chapters fit what is known of the Igbo region in the 1750s too closely to be invented.

The dispute matters for this question because it tests what a classic is valued for. If the book is valued as an eyewitness record, Carretta’s documents threaten its standing. If it is valued as a slave narrative that speaks for the many who left no record, and as a work whose double voice was crafted for a purpose, it remains a classic whichever account of the birth is true. The quarrel has also kept the book in seminar rooms and journals, and continued argument is exactly what Calvino’s definition describes.

Who was left out

Equiano’s case is one of many. When the canon taught in British and American universities took shape between about 1880 and 1950, its gatekeepers were mostly white men from a few countries, and the canon they made reflected their reading. Women writers are the clearest case of a group left out. Virginia Woolf’s A Room of One’s Own (1929) argued that money, privacy and education, more than talent, had decided who could write. Since the 1970s, critics have recovered writers such as Kate Chopin and Phillis Wheatley, whose return is traced in the account of how a work’s meaning changes over time.

Writers in other languages raise a different question: how a work crosses into a canon at all. The German poet Johann Wolfgang von Goethe gave the problem a name in 1827. His secretary Johann Peter Eckermann recorded a conversation in which Goethe, who had been reading a Chinese novel in translation, argued that the age of national literatures was ending:

National literature is now rather an unmeaning term; the epoch of World literature is at hand, and every one must strive to hasten its approach.

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, in Johann Peter Eckermann, Conversations with Goethe, 31 January 1827 (tr. John Oxenford, 1850)

Goethe’s world literature (Weltliteratur) is literature that travels beyond its place of origin and is read alongside other nations’ works. The phrase “every one must strive” makes it a project, something readers and translators build, rather than a list that already exists. Translation is the means. Murasaki Shikibu’s The Tale of Genji, written in Japan in the early eleventh century, became a classic of world literature in English largely through Arthur Waley’s translation (1925–1933), and many readers first met it in that version.

The idea has limits that later critics have pointed out. A work joins world literature mainly by being translated into a few dominant languages, especially English and French, so the field can repeat the hierarchy it was meant to overcome. In The World Republic of Letters (1999), the French critic Pascale Casanova argued that writers from smaller literatures have had to win recognition in centers such as Paris before their own countries treated them as classics. A work in translation also arrives with the translator’s choices built in, as Waley’s elegant, freely cut Genji does.

A classic on trial: Heart of Darkness

Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness has been taught for decades as a classic of English fiction, and since 1975 it has been one of the most argued-over books in the canon. Conrad, born in 1857 to Polish parents in the Russian Empire, became a British merchant seaman and, in 1890, captained a river steamer in the Congo Free State, then the private colony of King Leopold II of Belgium. The novella appeared in Blackwood’s Magazine in 1899 and as a book in 1902. Its form is a story inside a story, and the quarrel over it turns on that form.

A tale inside a frame

An unnamed narrator sits with four friends on a yacht, the Nellie, in the mouth of the Thames at dusk. He praises the river for the ships and men it has sent out to “the uttermost ends of the earth”, and then one of the company speaks:

“And this also,” said Marlow suddenly, “has been one of the dark places of the earth.”

Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness (1899), part I

Marlow’s first words turn the narrator’s pride inside out. London, the capital of the largest empire in the world, was once a wild edge of the Roman Empire, and Marlow imagines a young Roman sent there among “savages” and swamps. Africa is not yet named, but the comparison has already made “darkness” a matter of where one stands. The rest of the novella is Marlow’s account of his journey up the Congo to find Kurtz, a brilliant ivory agent who has set himself up as a god among the people of the Inner Station.

This is a frame narrative, and the diagram sets out its three levels and whose voices each one lets through. Everything the reader learns about Kurtz comes through Marlow, and everything about Marlow comes through the unnamed narrator. The Europeans speak at length. The Africans of the story speak in only two brief moments, and otherwise appear as bodies, shapes and sounds.

Diagram: three nested boxes for the levels of Heart of Darkness: the unnamed narrator on the Nellie, Marlow’s tale of the Congo, and Kurtz, known only through Marlow. Beside them, a green box lists the voices heard and an orange box notes that African characters speak in only two brief moments.Diagram: three nested boxes for the levels of Heart of Darkness: the unnamed narrator on the Nellie, Marlow’s tale of the Congo, and Kurtz, known only through Marlow. Beside them, a green box lists the voices heard and an orange box notes that African characters speak in only two brief moments.
The frame of *Heart of Darkness*: three levels of telling, and the voices each lets through.

Achebe’s charge

In February 1975 the Nigerian novelist Chinua Achebe gave a lecture at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, published in 1977 and revised in 1988 as “An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness”. Achebe argued that the novella presents Africa as “the other world”, “the antithesis of Europe and therefore of civilization”, a place against which a European mind can be tested. In the revised version he called Conrad “a thoroughgoing racist”. One of the passages he examined describes the steamer passing a village on the riverbank:

But suddenly, as we struggled round a bend, there would be a glimpse of rush walls, of peaked grass-roofs, a burst of yells, a whirl of black limbs, a mass of hands clapping, of feet stamping, of bodies swaying, of eyes rolling, under the droop of heavy and motionless foliage.

Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness (1899), part II

The sentence breaks people into parts. “Black limbs”, “hands”, “feet”, “bodies” and “eyes” are listed in a run of plural nouns, so no single person appears, and the yells are sound without words. A few lines later Marlow admits his “remote kinship with this wild and passionate uproar”, but the kinship is “remote”, and it is claimed with an “uproar”, not with any person in the crowd. For Achebe this was the core of the problem: Africa serves as a backdrop for a European’s crisis, and its people are denied the speech that would make them characters.

Achebe’s lecture is the best-known example of postcolonial criticism: reading for how empire shapes a text, who is allowed to speak in it, and what it takes for granted about colonizer and colonized. He did not only criticize. His own Things Fall Apart (1958) had already given the Igbo village its speech, its law and its arguments, and it is now often taught beside the novella as a reply to it.

The replies

Achebe’s lecture provoked replies that are now part of the novella’s history. In 1983 the critic Cedric Watts, in an essay whose title quoted the charge back at its author, argued that Heart of Darkness is one of the sharpest attacks on imperialism written in its time. The evidence he and others point to is in Marlow’s own words, spoken before the voyage begins:

The conquest of the earth, which mostly means the taking it away from those who have a different complexion or slightly flatter noses than ourselves, is not a pretty thing when you look into it too much.

Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness (1899), part I

Read alone, the sentence condemns conquest in plain terms, and its dry understatement (“not a pretty thing”) makes the condemnation sharper. Read in context, it is less simple. Marlow goes straight on to say that what redeems conquest “is the idea only”, and the novella tests that idea in Kurtz and finds it hollow. Defenders also stress the frame: the racism, they argue, belongs to Marlow and his listeners, and the novella exposes it through a narrator it does not fully trust. That reading treats Marlow as at least partly an unreliable narrator.

Achebe’s answer was that a frame that never lets an African speak cannot criticize the silence it creates. Edward Said, in Culture and Imperialism (1993), took a position between the two. Conrad, he argued, saw that imperialism was robbery but could not imagine Africans outside it, governing themselves, because no European of his time could. The debate is still open, and an essay that claims to settle it in a sentence has not understood it.

What the quarrel shows about classics

The argument has not removed Heart of Darkness from the canon. It has changed why the novella is read. Students who once met it as a study of a European soul in crisis now meet it as a test case for how literature represents other people, and often read it beside Things Fall Apart. In Calvino’s terms the novella has not finished saying what it has to say, partly because Achebe made it say something new. A classic, on this evidence, is a work worth arguing with, and the argument is part of what keeps it alive.

Merit, popularity and the middlebrow

Behind every canon lies a judgment of literary merit: the qualities for which a work is thought worth keeping. Johnson’s Preface names the oldest test, which is survival:

He has long outlived his century, the term commonly fixed as the test of literary merit.

Samuel Johnson, Preface to Shakespeare (1765)

A hundred years was Johnson’s working measure, and it has the advantage of being hard to fake: fashion fades long before a century is out. Later critics added other qualities, such as complexity, originality, mastery of form, truth to experience and influence on later writers. Each quality has its champions and its problems. Complexity favors works made for trained readers, and influence favors writers whose followers were allowed to publish.

The line between merit and popularity has moved more than once. Charles Dickens published his novels in monthly or weekly parts that sold to a mass public, and some critics of his day treated him as an entertainer rather than an artist. He is now at the center of the English canon. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) reached most people in the nineteenth century through stage versions, beginning in 1823, and entered university reading lists mainly from the 1970s. Both are cases of popular fiction, fiction written for a wide market, later read as literature.

Highbrow, lowbrow and between

Detective fiction shows the same movement within a genre. T. S. Eliot praised Wilkie Collins’s The Moonstone (1868) as the first and best of modern English detective novels, and it is now widely taught. Yet the genre as a whole has often been placed below “literary” fiction. The word middlebrow, which appeared in the 1920s, named the space between: books for readers who wanted seriousness without difficulty. Virginia Woolf mocked middlebrow taste in a letter written in 1932, and the label has since been used to dismiss writers, many of them women, whose books sold well to educated readers.

The labels describe the standing of readers as much as the qualities of books. A novel read on trains by commuters and the same novel read in a seminar are the same words; what differs is who reads them and how. Some critics now defend middlebrow fiction as a tradition with its own skills, such as clarity, moral seriousness and reliable craft. Others reply that a canon without any judgment of quality would be only a list of what sold.

Where readers disagree: inheritance or exclusion

The strongest case for a canon is that it is a shared inheritance. Johnson’s Preface makes the argument in its simplest form, as a claim about knowledge:

… what has been longest known has been most considered, and what is most considered is best understood.

Samuel Johnson, Preface to Shakespeare (1765)

On this view a canon is the record of a long conversation, and a reader who knows its works can follow the many later books that answer them. The American critic Harold Bloom made the modern defense in The Western Canon (1994). He argued that works enter the canon through aesthetic strength alone, by overpowering earlier writers and later readers, and he called the critics who judged works mainly by their politics a “School of Resentment”. For Bloom, opening the canon to works chosen for whom they represent would empty it of the reasons for reading at all.

The opposing case holds that every canon is a record of exclusion as well as of value. Achebe’s lecture is one version of it: a work can be beautifully made and still teach its readers to see a continent as a void. Another comes from the American critic John Guillory, whose Cultural Capital (1993) argued that the canon debate was about access. The question, for Guillory, is who goes to the schools where canonical works are taught, and who gains the prestige of knowing them. On this view a canon is an institution, and its contents follow its gatekeepers.

Adding, abolishing or arguing

Between the two positions lie two practical answers. One is to add to the canon, as the recoveries of Equiano, Chopin and Wheatley have done, while keeping the idea of a shared list. The other is to abolish the idea and let every reader choose freely. The first risks token additions that leave the gates unchanged; the second gives up the common ground that lets readers compare works and argue about them.

The most defensible judgment combines the strengths of both. A canon is best understood as an argument that a culture keeps having about which works repay rereading. The case of Heart of Darkness suggests that the argument, more than any settled list, is what keeps classics alive. Johnson’s test of “continuance of esteem” survives in this view, but esteem now includes the esteem of readers whom the first canon-makers never imagined.

A reading list as a canon in miniature

A literature course’s reading list is a small canon, built by the same kind of choices. A class reads a handful of works from a very large field, among them works originally written in English and works read in translation, from different periods, places and forms. Each choice brings one author in and leaves hundreds out, and the person who chooses, whether a teacher or a student, acts as a gatekeeper. The list therefore shapes which classics a class meets and which it never hears of.

Try it

Take the works on your own course reading list. Which of them would Johnson, Eliot and Calvino each count as classics, and which of them would not have been taught 50 years ago?

Johnson’s test favors works that have been read for a century or more, such as a Shakespeare play or a nineteenth-century novel. Eliot’s favors works from a mature literary tradition. Calvino’s can include a recent novel if it keeps opening on rereading. Works by women, by writers outside Europe and North America, and works in translation from smaller languages are the ones most likely to be recent additions. Recording this in the learner portfolio gives a ready example of canon formation for discussion.

Writing about a classic

A weak paragraph about a classic treats its status as a fact and stops there. A strong one treats the status as a claim, sets out the strongest objection, and tests both on the text. The two paragraphs that follow answer the same question about Heart of Darkness.

Weak: Heart of Darkness is a classic because it is famous and is still studied in schools today.note 1 Chinua Achebe said that Conrad was racist, but other critics disagree, so it is still a great book.note 2

Strong: Heart of Darkness has stayed in the canon less because its standing is secure than because it keeps provoking argument.note 3 Achebe’s charge rests on passages such as the “whirl of black limbs”, where Africans appear as parts of bodies and sounds without words.note 4 Marlow’s attack on conquest as “taking it away from those who have a different complexion” complicates the charge, but it is spoken by one European to others, inside a frame that never lets an African reply.note 5 The novella can therefore be read as exposing imperial thinking and as repeating it, and that double possibility is what makes it worth rereading.note 6

  1. Status as evidence. “Famous” and “still studied” describe the work’s situation, not its qualities or its arguments.

  2. Debate named, not weighed. The critic appears, but nothing in the novel is tested against the charge.

  3. A claim about the classic. The topic sentence explains why the novella remains a classic, which is an argument rather than a label.

  4. Charge tested on words. The critic’s case is tied to a quoted phrase and to what the phrase does.

  5. The reply, weighed. The opposing passage is quoted too, and the frame is used as evidence against it.

  6. A judgment. The last sentence states what reading the two sides together shows about the novella.

The strong paragraph quotes both the passage that supports Achebe and the passage that supports his opponents. Its conclusion is a judgment about how the novella works, which neither critic’s view alone would produce, and it would fit an essay on representation as well as one on the canon.

Applying it in the HL essay

The HL essay is a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words on a line of inquiry into one literary work. A debate over a classic can give an essay its starting point, but the line of inquiry must be the student’s own question about how the text works. An essay that summarizes Achebe and Watts has written about the critics; an essay that asks how the frame narrative shapes what a reader can know of Africa has written about Conrad.

The worked example keeps the proportion that suits the HL essay: one critic, cited accurately, then several pages of analysis of the writer’s choices.

Marks are most often lost when the essay becomes a survey of what critics have said, because the argument then belongs to them. A model sentence names the critic in a clause and spends the rest of the sentence on the text: “Where Achebe hears only noise in the riverbank passage, the syntax suggests a deliberate effect, since its run of plural nouns keeps any single person from coming into focus.”

The classic is never fixed, because later readers and writers keep answering it, sometimes with new works. That leads to the question of how texts can offer several perspectives on one issue, and to the way rewriting transforms an earlier work.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what makes a work a classic, using Johnson’s, Eliot’s and Calvino’s definitions, and distinguish a classic from a canon.

  • To do:

    I can describe how a canon is formed, from the First Folio to modern publishers, anthologies and prizes, and say who the gatekeepers are.

  • To do:

    I can trace how Equiano’s Narrative left the canon and returned, and explain why the debate over its account keeps it there.

  • To do:

    I can set out Achebe’s charge against Heart of Darkness and the strongest replies, and test both on passages from the novella.

  • To do:

    I can explain world literature, literary merit, popular fiction and the middlebrow label with an example of each.

  • To do:

    I can evaluate the arguments for and against canons and reach my own judgment.

  • To do:

    I can look at my own course reading list as a canon in miniature and say whose choices shaped it.

Key terms

Each is also in the Intertextuality: connecting texts glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Canon

The body of works that a culture, a school system or a discipline treats as most important and most worth teaching. A canon is made by many choices over time and changes as works are added to it or drop out of it.

Canon formation

The processes by which works enter or leave a canon: publication and reprinting, reviews and criticism, prizes, anthologies, translation and teaching. It explains a work's standing as the result of many people's decisions rather than of its qualities alone.

Classic

A work that continues to be reread and reinterpreted across generations, so that it keeps answering new questions from new readers. Its status depends on that continued rereading and on the institutions that keep it in circulation.

Gatekeeping

The control over which writers and works reach readers, exercised by publishers, editors, critics, prize juries, translators and schools. Gatekeepers can keep writers out of a canon or open it to them.

Literary merit

The qualities for which a work is judged worth reading and keeping, such as complexity, originality, mastery of form, truthfulness and influence. Which qualities count, and who decides, has changed over time and is itself debated.

Middlebrow

A label, often used dismissively, for works and tastes placed between the demanding art of the highbrow and the mass entertainment of the lowbrow. It says as much about the cultural standing of readers as about the works themselves.

Popular fiction

Fiction written for a wide readership, often within a recognized genre such as the detective story, romance or adventure. It has often been set against literary fiction, although many works first read as popular entertainment later entered the canon.

Postcolonial criticism

A way of reading that examines how empire and colonial rule shape texts, identities and languages, both in works written by colonizers and in works written by the colonized. It asks whose perspective a text takes for granted and whose it silences.

World literature

Literature read beyond its place and language of origin, usually in translation, and the idea that the literatures of many nations form one field of reading. The term goes back to Goethe in 1827.

Practice questions on 3.4 How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGAL-0002120 marks
The Letter-WriterThe Ink Stone, a memoir of Hong Kong, 1920sWritten for Augment Education
In the summer I turned fifteen my father decided that I was becoming a foreigner. I was in my third year at the English school on Bonham Road, where we learnt the kings of England in order and read Julius Caesar aloud in voices that made the masters wince, and I had begun, without meaning to, to count in English. Father heard me one evening, adding up the price of a pair of shoes under my breath, and the next Sunday he took me down to the lane behind the Man Mo Temple and handed me over to Mr Fung.
Mr Fung wrote letters for a living. He had a folding table, a stool for himself and another for his customers, a cloth awning propped on two bamboo poles, and a wooden board that said, in his own hand, LETTERS WRITTEN AND READ, FAMILY AND BUSINESS, TEN CENTS. He had passed the county examination in the last years of the Qing, when that still meant something, and he wore the long gown of a scholar every day of the year, even in August, when the rest of the lane was in singlets. The nail of his little finger was as long as a matchstick. He used it to turn the pages of a book so that his skin need not touch the paper.
His customers were dock coolies, amahs on their day off and, once, a Sikh policeman who wanted a letter written to a Chinese widow and would not say why. They sat on the second stool with their hands on their knees and told Mr Fung what they wanted to say, and Mr Fung listened with his eyes closed, and then he wrote something else. I watched him do it many times. A man from the godowns at Sai Ying Pun, his right hand in a grey bandage, said: tell my mother the work is hard and the foreman is a dog and I have not been paid for May. Mr Fung wrote, in a running hand so beautiful that I wanted to steal the paper: The work is light, the master is just, and your son thinks of you at every meal. Then he read it back, and the man nodded and paid his ten cents and went away, as far as I could tell, satisfied.
“You have changed his letter,” I said. “He did not tell you that.”

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from The Ink Stone, a memoir. The writer grew up in Hong Kong in the 1920s.

Guiding question: By what means, and to what effect, does the writer create a portrait of Mr Fung?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-0016720 marks
StandardsStandards, a play from Toronto, 1990sWritten for Augment Education
The lobby bar of a hotel on Front Street, Toronto. Ten past one in the morning, January. A baby grand piano with its lid down. Small round tables, the chairs turned upside down on them, except at one table. Behind the bar, a mirror and bottles. In the window, a lit sign: PIANO BAR. Outside, snow falling past a streetlight. MARGUERITE, in a black dress and white running shoes, sits at the free table with a glass of soda water. A pair of black heels stands on the table beside the glass. DEV, in a white shirt and vest, is wiping the bar.
MARGUERITEYou can turn the sign off. Nobody’s coming in out of that.
DEVMr. Haddad says two o’clock.
MARGUERITEMr. Haddad is in Mississauga with his feet up. (DEV does not move.) Fine. Leave it on. Let it shine on the snow.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the play Standards. Marguerite is the pianist in the bar of a hotel in Toronto in the 1990s; Dev works behind the bar.

Guiding question: Consider how, and to what effect, the playwright presents the balance of power between Marguerite and Dev.

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-0017720 marks
KarkidakamThe Verandah Step, a novel from Kerala, 1900sWritten for Augment Education
I was eleven the year I learnt the Ramayana, and I learnt it the way you learn the sound of one particular cart on the road: without meaning to, and then for ever. It was in the Vakil’s house at Trichur, the big house beside the temple tank with the red-tiled gatehouse, and I had been there since the Onam before, sweeping, drawing water, carrying the old Amma’s spittoon. My mother had worked there before me. They were good people. I say that first because it is true, and because people who hear the rest always ask.
In Karkidakam the rain does not stop for a month, and in that month, in good houses, the Ramayana is read aloud each evening. At the Vakil’s house the reader was Unni, the younger son, who was twelve and had a cold every year from the first rain to the last. The tall brass lamp was lit in the front room, the one with five wicks, and the old Amma sat on her mat with her eyes shut, and Unni sat before the book on its little wooden stand and read, and the family sat where they liked. I sat on the verandah step outside the door. That was my place. The step was wet on one side and dry on the other, and I kept to the wet side, which nobody wanted.
Unni read badly. I did not know it was badly then; I thought that was how the gods talked, in a voice that stopped to blow its nose. He lost his place when a lizard dropped from the rafters. He read some verses twice and some not at all, and the old Amma, without opening her eyes, would say, ‘Again,’ and he would go back. So I heard the hard parts more often than the easy ones. By the middle of the month I could say the whole of the part where Ravana comes to the door dressed as a holy man, under my breath, a little ahead of him.
I did not think this was anything. You learn what is said in a house. I knew the Vakil’s cough and the cook’s bad words and which of the cows would kick, and I knew Ravana at the door asking for alms. It was all the same kind of knowing. When I scrubbed the brass in the mornings I said the verses to the pots, because it made the work go in lines, and the cook told me to stop moaning, she thought I had a fever.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the novel The Verandah Step. The narrator, now an old woman, remembers working as a servant in the house of a lawyer, the Vakil, in Kerala, India, in the early 1900s.

Guiding question: By what means, and to what effect, does the narrator present her place in the household?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 9 questions on 3.4 How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

The English A Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 3.1How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?
  2. 3.2How do conventions and systems of reference evolve over time?
  3. 3.3In what ways can diverse literary texts share points of similarity?
  4. 3.4How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?This page
  5. 3.5How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?
  6. 3.6In what ways can comparison and interpretation be transformative?

Carry on with 3.4 How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text? in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.