3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?

How texts follow and depart from the conventions of their forms and genres, and how to analyze the meaning made when a convention is kept, turned or broken.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts
  • SL and HL

27 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?

Every literary form and genre carries a set of shared expectations, and a text is read against them whether its writer follows them or not. A text can keep a convention and use it straight, keep it and turn it to a new purpose, or break it outright. Much of what a text means lies in which of these it does, and a departure only shows against an expectation that is already familiar.

Christina Rossetti wrote “In an Artist’s Studio” in 1856, and it was published after her death, in 1896. It is a sonnet about a painter who paints one woman again and again.

In an Artist’s StudioNew Poems, Hitherto Unpublished or Uncollected, 1896Christina G. Rossetti, “In an Artist’s Studio”, New Poems, ed. William Michael Rossetti (London and New York: Macmillan, 1896)
One face looks out from all his canvases,
One selfsame figure sits or walks or leans:
We found her hidden just behind those screens,
That mirror gave back all her loveliness.
A queen in opal or in ruby dress,
A nameless girl in freshest summer-greens,
A saint, an angel—every canvas means
The same one meaning, neither more nor less.
He feeds upon her face by day and night,
And she with true kind eyes looks back on him,
Fair as the moon and joyful as the light:
Not wan with waiting, not with sorrow dim;
Not as she is, but was when hope shone bright;
Not as she is, but as she fills his dream.

What a sonnet leads a reader to expect

A reader who knows sonnets knows several things about this poem before reading a word of it closely. It has fourteen lines. Its first eight lines rhyme abbaabba (“canvases”, “leans”, “screens”, “loveliness”), and its last six rhyme cdcdcd. That pattern marks it as a Petrarchan sonnet, which leads one to expect a problem or situation in the eight-line octave and a response in the six-line sestet, with a turn between them.

The poem meets that expectation exactly. Lines 1 to 8 describe the paintings: “One face looks out from all his canvases” (line 1), in role after role. Line 9 then turns from the canvases to the man who paints them: “He feeds upon her face by day and night”. The pronoun He appears for the first time as the subject of a sentence, and the poem moves from what is seen in the studio to what happens between painter and model. The volta falls exactly where the convention places it.

An established feature of a form or genre that writers repeat and readers expect is a convention. The fourteen lines, the rhyme scheme and the turn at line 9 are conventions of the Petrarchan sonnet. So is something that has nothing to do with lines or rhymes. From Petrarch’s poems to Laura in the fourteenth century onward, the sonnet was the form in which a male lover praised a beautiful, distant and usually silent woman. Rossetti’s poem keeps every formal convention and takes up this one too, which is why it can turn it.

Why conventions exist

Conventions do three kinds of work. First, they give writer and audience shared expectations about how to read: anyone who sees fourteen rhymed lines starts listening for an argument and a turn. Second, they save words. An Elizabethan audience that saw a ghost demand revenge in a play’s first act knew at once what kind of play it was watching and roughly how it would end, so the playwright did not need to explain. Third, they give a fixed ground against which variation can be seen. A sonnet that turns at line 9 is unremarkable; one that turns in the middle of line 8, as Milton’s sonnet on his blindness does, has made a choice that only the convention makes visible.

The third kind of work matters most for analysis. A departure from a convention is only meaningful because the convention exists. Without knowing that sonnets usually turn at line 9, a student cannot see a delayed or early turn as a choice at all. Knowing conventions is therefore the first step of reading, not an extra.

Using a convention against its tradition

Rossetti’s octave gives the painted woman all the roles of the old love sonnet. The lines run as a list, each item beginning with the same word:

“A queen in opal or in ruby dress, / A nameless girl in freshest summer-greens, / A saint, an angel” (lines 5–7). Queen, saint and angel are exactly what the Petrarchan lover made of his lady. The anaphora of A turns them into a catalog, and line 8 sums up the catalog flatly: “every canvas means / The same one meaning, neither more nor less”. What the old sonnet offered as worship, this sonnet offers as repetition. The woman can be a queen or a girl or an angel, but she always means the same thing, because the painter decides what she means.

The sestet then makes the convention’s hidden cost visible. In the Petrarchan tradition the lover is nourished by his lady’s beauty; here he “feeds upon her face” (line 9), and the metaphor of eating suggests that the painter consumes her. The conventional praise survives in line 11, “Fair as the moon and joyful as the light”, but by now it describes the image on the canvas. The real woman appears only in the last three lines, and only as what the paintings leave out: “Not wan with waiting, not with sorrow dim; / Not as she is” (lines 12–13).

Rossetti does not abandon the sonnet’s praise of an ideal woman; she keeps it and shows it from outside. The speaker is not the lover but a visitor to the studio (“We found her hidden just behind those screens”, line 3), so the poem watches the praising instead of performing it. This use of a convention against its usual meaning is subversion. It differs from simply ignoring a convention, because the convention has to stay recognizable for the turn to be felt. A free-verse poem about the same painter might criticize him; it has no way to make the sonnet’s own tradition the evidence against him.

Rossetti returned to the question in 1881, in a sequence of fourteen sonnets called “Monna Innominata” (“the unnamed lady”). Its prose preface names the two most famous ladies of Italian love poetry:

Beatrice, immortalized by “altissimo poeta … cotanto amante;” Laura, celebrated by a great though an inferior bard,—have alike paid the exceptional penalty of exceptional honor, and have come down to us resplendent with charms, but (at least, to my apprehension) scant of attractiveness.

Christina Rossetti, preface to “Monna Innominata”, A Pageant and Other Poems (1881), as printed in her Poems (Project Gutenberg #19188)

The sentence is polite, but its argument is sharp. Beatrice, praised by Dante, and Laura, praised by Petrarch, are “resplendent with charms” yet “scant of attractiveness”: the convention that made them famous also made them lifeless. The preface goes on to imagine such a lady speaking for herself. “In an Artist’s Studio” makes the same complaint twenty-five years earlier, through the sonnet rather than about it. Rossetti’s brother William Michael, who edited the poem in 1896, noted that it seemed to refer to their brother Dante Gabriel Rossetti’s many paintings of Elizabeth Siddal, whom he later married. That context is worth knowing, but the poem’s subversion works without it.

Subversion in other forms

Subversion can work on a whole genre as well as on a verse form. Margaret Atwood’s novel The Handmaid’s Tale (1985) follows the conventions of the dystopian novel, set in an imagined state worse than the writer’s own, for almost its whole length, and then adds a final section, “Historical Notes”. It is a transcript of an academic conference held in 2195, long after the regime of Gilead has fallen. A professor jokes about the narrator’s story, doubts whether the tapes it was recorded on are genuine, and treats her suffering as a puzzle for scholars. The ending refuses the reassurance the genre seems to promise. Gilead is gone, but the habits of mind that ignored women’s voices have outlived it.

Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber (1979) subverts the fairy tale. Its stories retell “Bluebeard”, “Beauty and the Beast” and “Little Red Riding Hood”, keeping the familiar plots, settings and objects, the forbidden room, the castle, the wolf. What changes is who acts. In “The Company of Wolves” the girl who meets the wolf is not eaten or rescued; she meets his threat with laughter and ends the story asleep beside him, on her own terms. The tale’s old warning to girls becomes a story about a girl who refuses to be afraid.

Tragedy for a salesman

The conventions of tragedy are among the oldest in literature, and Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman (1949) shows what happens when a writer keeps most of them and changes the one that seemed essential. Aristotle’s account of tragedy, and the Greek and Shakespearean plays that fit it, lead an audience to expect a tragic hero of high standing: a king, a prince, a general. That hero makes an error of judgment, his fortune turns, he recognizes the truth about himself too late, and he falls, while a chorus or a survivor states what the fall means. Miller gives that shape to Willy Loman, a salesman in his sixties who can no longer sell.

Miller defended the choice in an essay published in the New York Times in the same year as the play:

I believe that the common man is as apt a subject for tragedy in its highest sense as kings were.

Arthur Miller, “Tragedy and the Common Man”, New York Times (1949)

The sentence argues with a convention by name. If kings were tragic because their fall shook a kingdom, Miller replies that a family is a kingdom to the man who heads it. The essay goes on to say that tragic feeling comes from a character ready to give his life to defend his “sense of personal dignity”. Willy’s house, his job and his sons’ success are the whole of his world, so their collapse is a fall from the only height he has.

Where the play keeps the shape

Much of the play follows the tragic sequence closely. Willy’s error is a belief he has built his life on: that being admired and “well liked” is the road to success, and that his son Biff, a high-school football star, is destined for greatness. The reversal comes in Act 2, when he goes to ask for a job in New York and is fired by Howard, the son of the man who hired him. The catastrophe is his death. He drives off at night and is killed, believing that his life insurance will give Biff the start his own life never had.

The play keeps tragedy’s sense of inevitability too. Scenes from the past break into the present on the same stage, so the audience watches the causes of the fall while the fall is happening. Willy’s memories of his rich brother Ben and of Biff’s high-school glory are not explanations offered afterward. They are the error itself, still at work in his mind.

Where it changes the shape

Two conventions are changed, and each change makes meaning. The first is recognition, the anagnorisis in which the hero finally sees the truth. In this play the recognition belongs to the son. Biff comes to see that he and his father are ordinary men and that the family has lived on illusions. He tries to make Willy see it too. Willy hears only that Biff loves him, and he dies still holding the dream. The convention is moved to another character so that the audience can measure what Willy refuses to know.

The second change is the ending. The play’s last scene is called the “Requiem”, and it stands where a Greek chorus would comment on the hero’s fall. Willy’s wife Linda, his sons, his neighbor Charley and Charley’s son Bernard stand at the grave, but they cannot agree on what his life meant. Biff says, “He had the wrong dreams.” His brother Happy insists that the dream was a good one and that he will carry it on. Charley defends Willy as a salesman who had to live on a dream. Linda, who has just made the last payment on the house, says “We’re free” and cannot understand why he is gone. A Greek chorus speaks for a community that shares its values; this chorus shows a community that has none to share.

The diagram sets the six stages a tragedy leads an audience to expect in a row over what Death of a Salesman does at each stage. Green marks a convention kept, orange one changed. The pattern explains the play’s effect: the outline of tragedy is complete, so the audience expects tragic meaning, and the changes in the hero, the recognition and the chorus are where that meaning is withheld.

Two rows of six boxes. Top, what tragedy leads an audience to expect: a noble hero, an error, a reversal, recognition, catastrophe, a chorus.Two rows of six boxes. Top, what tragedy leads an audience to expect: a noble hero, an error, a reversal, recognition, catastrophe, a chorus.
Expectation against deviation in Death of a Salesman. The play keeps tragedy’s error, reversal and catastrophe, and changes its hero, its recognition and its chorus.

Tragedy or pathos

Whether Willy is a tragic hero at all is a question Miller’s own essay helps to frame. The essay separates tragedy from pathos, the feeling of pity for a victim who never had a chance:

Where pathos rules, where pathos is finally derived, a character has fought a battle he could not possibly have won.

Arthur Miller, “Tragedy and the Common Man” (1949)

Against Miller’s play, a reader can use Miller’s definition. A salesman crushed by an economy that discards old workers seems to fight a battle he could not have won, and his refusal to see the truth makes him pitiable rather than great. For the play, the answer lies in Willy’s choices. He turns down Charley’s offer of a steady job more than once, because accepting it would mean admitting the dream was false. That refusal is a choice made to protect his dignity, exactly the quality Miller’s essay names, so the fall is partly his own. The stronger position is that the play deliberately sits on the border between tragedy and pathos, and that its power comes from keeping the audience unsure which it is watching.

The same convention looks different again in Sophocles. The table sets the tragic hero of Oedipus the King beside Willy Loman, stage by stage.

Oedipus the King (Sophocles, about 429 BCE)

Death of a Salesman (Miller, 1949)

The hero’s standing

King of Thebes; his fall brings a city down with him

A salesman; his fall touches only his family

The error

Acting on incomplete knowledge of who he is

Living by a false idea of who he is

Recognition

Complete: he sees everything and blinds himself

Refused: the son sees, the father does not

The chorus

The elders of Thebes, who share one judgment

The Requiem’s mourners, who share none

What the convention says

No one, however great, controls fate

An ordinary life can carry tragic weight, or only pathos

Set side by side, the two heroes show that the convention is not one thing. Oedipus is destroyed by knowing too much and Willy by refusing to know, so recognition, the moment both plays turn on, carries opposite meanings. A comparison of this kind does more than observe that both works are tragedies: it shows what each does with tragedy.

Kinds of story and the promises they make

A genre is a kind of work recognized by shared conventions of subject, structure and tone, and each genre makes promises to its readers. A novel about growing up promises that the young person at its center will become someone. A Gothic novel promises fear, secrets and an old building that holds them. Writers keep these promises, delay them or break them, and in each case the genre is part of what the work means.

The novel of growing up

Charles Dickens’s Great Expectations (1861) opens with a child naming himself:

My father’s family name being Pirrip, and my Christian name Philip, my infant tongue could make of both names nothing longer or more explicit than Pip. So, I called myself Pip, and came to be called Pip.

Charles Dickens, Great Expectations (1861), chapter 1

The sentence is comic, but it sets up the central question of the genre: who this person will become, and who decides. Pip makes his own name out of the names his family gives him. The rest of the novel follows him from a blacksmith’s forge to London and back, as he learns what his “expectations” of wealth have cost him and others. A novel that follows a young person’s growth into maturity, through education, conflict and choices about who to be, is a Bildungsroman, a German word meaning “novel of formation”. Its conventions include a sensitive protagonist, a departure from home, mentors and false friends, a crisis, and an ending that settles the grown self in the world.

Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre (1847) follows the same arc from a mistreated orphan to an independent woman who chooses her own marriage. Tsitsi Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions (1988), set in Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe) in the 1960s and 1970s, uses the form to question its central promise. Its narrator, Tambudzai, opens with the line “I was not sorry when my brother died.” His death gives her his place at the mission school, and with it the education the genre treats as growth. The novel shows what that education costs: her cousin Nyasha, schooled in England and caught between two cultures, breaks down in body and mind. The Bildungsroman’s path from home into the wider world becomes, in a colonial setting, a path away from one’s family and language.

The haunted house and the forbidden experiment

The Gothic novel began in the late eighteenth century with stories of ruined castles, imprisoned heroines and ghosts. Its conventions are confinement, darkness, secrets, the supernatural or the suggestion of it, and a past that returns to threaten the present. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) moves the Gothic from the castle to the laboratory:

It was on a dreary night of November, that I beheld the accomplishment of my toils.

Mary Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818), volume I, chapter 4

The night, the solitude and the dread are all Gothic conventions, but the terror they announce is new. No ghost or tyrant threatens Victor Frankenstein. The monster is one he has made himself with the science of his own age. Shelley keeps the genre’s furniture and changes the source of fear, so the Gothic becomes a way of asking what modern knowledge might unleash. In the twentieth century, writers of the American South used the same conventions, the decaying mansion and the family secret, to show a society haunted by slavery and its own past. William Faulkner’s story “A Rose for Emily” (1930) is an early example of this Southern Gothic.

Futures, omens and ghosts

Some genres are defined by the world they imagine. In a dystopia, the imagined state is worse than the writer’s own, and its conventions are surveillance, controlled language, a rebel whose private life becomes a crime, and usually defeat. George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949) follows them closely: Winston Smith’s secret diary and his love affair with Julia are acts of rebellion, and the novel ends with his mind broken by the state. Atwood’s use of the same genre in The Handmaid’s Tale, closed by a calm academic lecture instead of a final defeat, shows how far a writer can vary a dystopia’s ending and still be read within it.

Magical realism presents impossible events in the calm, matter-of-fact manner of realist fiction, and its characters accept them as part of ordinary life. Gabriel García Márquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude (1967) was translated into English by Gregory Rabassa in 1970. In it a young woman rises into the sky while helping to fold sheets in the garden, and one of her relatives goes on praying for the sheets to be sent back. The convention does not ask the reader to believe in miracles. It questions whose idea of the real a story should follow, the European novel’s or that of a community whose history already seems impossible.

Revenge and delay

Some conventions belong to one period and one stage. Revenge tragedy was popular in London theaters around 1600. Its pattern was set by Thomas Kyd’s The Spanish Tragedy (about 1587). A wrong is done, a ghost demands vengeance, the avenger delays, madness is feigned or real, a play is staged within the play, and the final scene is a slaughter. Shakespeare’s Hamlet (about 1600) has every one of these, beginning with the ghost of Hamlet’s father in Act 1:

Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder.

William Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act 1, scene 5

The command sets the genre’s machine running, and an audience of 1600 knew how it would end. What Hamlet changes is the delay. In earlier revenge plays delay was a practical necessity, since a revenge carried out in Act 1 would end the play. Shakespeare makes the delay the subject of the play: Hamlet doubts the ghost, tests the king with a play, reproaches himself for his slowness and thinks aloud about whether action has any meaning. A convention that was only structure becomes the hero’s inner life.

Try it

Revenge tragedy needs its avenger to delay. Name one other genre whose plot depends on something being held back, and explain what that convention allows a writer to do.

The detective story depends on the solution being withheld until the end: the reader is shown clues but not their meaning. This convention lets the writer make the reader an active partner, reading every detail as possible evidence, and it lets the final revelation reorganize everything that came before. Writers who break it, by naming the culprit early, shift attention from who did it to why, or to what the investigation does to the investigator.

Imitation that mocks, honors or inflates

Some texts take conventions as their subject. Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey, written in the late 1790s and published in 1817, begins by refusing its heroine the qualities a heroine is supposed to have:

No one who had ever seen Catherine Morland in her infancy would have supposed her born to be an heroine.

Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey (1817), volume I, chapter 1

The first chapter lists the conventions of the popular Gothic novel, the orphaned or persecuted heroine, the tragic mother, the accomplishments, and shows Catherine lacking every one of them. Later, staying at the Abbey, she reads its rooms as if she were in a novel by Ann Radcliffe: a locked black cabinet at night yields a roll of papers that turns out, by daylight, to be a laundry list. This is parody, an imitation that exaggerates the features of a work, style or genre for comic or critical effect. Austen’s target is less the Gothic than a way of reading that mistakes fiction’s conventions for life.

Pastiche and the mock-heroic

An imitation made as tribute or play rather than mockery is pastiche. A. S. Byatt’s novel Possession (1990) follows two modern scholars researching two invented Victorian poets, and Byatt writes those poets’ poems and letters herself, in styles close to Robert Browning’s and Christina Rossetti’s. The pastiche is not a joke at the Victorians’ expense. It lets the reader experience the poets’ voices directly, so the scholars’ hunt becomes the reader’s.

The mock-heroic imitates a grand style in order to make a small subject look smaller. Alexander Pope’s The Rape of the Lock (1712, enlarged in 1714) began with a real quarrel between two Catholic families after a young lord cut a lock of hair from a young woman’s head. Pope tells the story with all the conventions of epic: an opening statement of the subject, an invocation, supernatural guardians, a card game fought like a battle and a descent into an underworld. The opening lines set the scale:

What dire offence from am’rous causes springs,
What mighty contests rise from trivial things,

Alexander Pope, The Rape of the Lock (1714), canto I, lines 1–2

The epic manner is flawless, which is what makes the subject look small. The lines echo the opening of Homer’s Iliad, which asks what anger caused a war, and the words dire, mighty and contests belong to that world. The rhyme pairs “springs” with “things”, and the second line sets “mighty contests” against “trivial things” in one breath, so the grand style itself announces how little is at stake. When the lock is cut, Belinda’s screams are compared to those heard “When husbands, or when lapdogs breathe their last” (canto III, line 158). Placing husbands and lapdogs in one line mocks a society that grieves for both alike.

The diagram places these kinds of imitation on two scales: how closely the model is imitated, and whether it is mocked or honored. Parody and pastiche both stay close to their models and differ only in attitude. The mock-heroic copies epic closely but turns the mockery on its subject. Subversion borrows less of the surface and turns a convention’s meaning instead, and a homage, a passing tribute to an admired work, borrows least of all.

A chart with two axes: imitates closely at the top, loosely at the bottom; mocks on the left, honors on the right. Parody (Northanger Abbey) top left; pastiche (the poems in Possession) top right; mock-heroic (The Rape of the Lock) left of center; subversion lower left; homage lower right.A chart with two axes: imitates closely at the top, loosely at the bottom; mocks on the left, honors on the right. Parody (Northanger Abbey) top left; pastiche (the poems in Possession) top right; mock-heroic (The Rape of the Lock) left of center; subversion lower left; homage lower right.
Kinds of imitation by closeness to the model and attitude toward it. The positions are approximate: a single work can move between them.

Memoir and the promise of truth

Non-fiction has conventions too, and the deepest is a promise. A memoir tells the reader that the person on the cover, the narrator and the main character are the same real person, and that the events happened. Philippe Lejeune called this the autobiographical pact. Its conventions follow from it: a narrator who looks back on a younger self, a chronology the reader can trust, and real names and places.

Maxine Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior (1976) announces both its promise and its departure in its subtitle:

Memoirs of a Girlhood Among Ghosts

Maxine Hong Kingston, The Woman Warrior (1976), subtitle

Memoirs claims the pact; Ghosts warns that it will be bent. The book is about growing up Chinese American in California, but it mixes the narrator’s memories with her mother’s “talk-story”, family secrets told as warnings, and legends. One chapter retells the legend of the woman warrior Fa Mu Lan in the first person, as if the narrator had lived it. The departure is the meaning. For a daughter whose identity is made from her mother’s stories as much as from events, a memoir confined to verifiable facts would leave out most of her childhood.

Whether great works transcend genre

Critics disagree about how much genre matters to a work’s value. In his Aesthetic (1902) the Italian philosopher Benedetto Croce argued that every true work of art is a unique expression, and that genres are only labels for sorting books, useless for judging any one of them. On this view, Hamlet is great despite being a revenge tragedy, not because of it. The French philosopher Jacques Derrida answered from the other side in “The Law of Genre” (1980):

Every text participates in one or several genres, there is no genreless text

Jacques Derrida, “The Law of Genre” (1980), translated by Avital Ronell

Derrida’s word is participates, not belongs. A text takes part in genres without being contained by any of them, so it is always both inside and outside its kind. Rossetti’s sonnet and Miller’s play support his position more than Croce’s. “In an Artist’s Studio” could not make its argument without the Petrarchan sonnet, and Death of a Salesman draws its force from the tragic shape it half fills. Neither transcends its genre; each is great partly because of how it stands in relation to one. Croce’s point keeps one warning in view: to call a work “a tragedy” or “a sonnet” is to begin a reading, never to complete one.

Writing about convention

Writing about convention goes wrong when it stops at classification. A strong sentence names the specific convention, says whether the text keeps, turns or breaks it, and states the effect. The pair that follows is about the turn in Rossetti’s sonnet.

Weak: “In an Artist’s Studio” is a Petrarchan sonnet with fourteen lines and a volta at line 9.note 1 This shows that Rossetti follows the conventions of the sonnet form.note 2

Strong: Rossetti keeps the Petrarchan turn at line 9 and uses it to move from the paintings to the painter, who “feeds upon her face”.note 3 The form that once carried a lover’s praise now carries a judgment of that praise,note 4 so the convention itself becomes the evidence that idealizing a woman can consume her.note 5

  1. Classification only. Every fact is correct, and none is analysis: the sentence would fit any Petrarchan sonnet.

  2. An empty conclusion. “Follows the conventions” is true of thousands of poems and explains nothing about this one.

  3. The convention and its use. The sentence names the convention, says it is kept, and quotes the line where it does its work.

  4. Kept, then turned. The second clause says what the convention used to mean and what it means here.

  5. The effect. The sentence ends on what the choice adds to the poem’s argument.

The strong version is longer by only a few words, but every word does work. It moves in three steps that suit any writing about convention: identify the convention precisely, say what the text does with it, and state what that choice means. A sentence that stops after the first step has described the text’s genre, not the text.

Applying it in Paper 2

Paper 2 often sets questions about how writers use familiar patterns: a kind of character, a kind of ending, a genre’s expectations. Such a question invites a comparison of how two works handle one convention, and the comparison is strongest when the works handle it differently. A question might ask how two works use a familiar story pattern and to what effect. A student who has studied Death of a Salesman and Nervous Conditions could compare how each takes a convention, the tragic recognition and the Bildungsroman’s education, and withholds what it promises.

Both Death of a Salesman and Nervous Conditions borrow a form that promises understanding and then deny their central character the reward it promises.note 1 Miller gives tragedy’s recognition to Biff and leaves Willy to die believing in the dream, while Dangarembga lets Tambudzai gain the education the Bildungsroman treats as growth and shows it carrying her away from her family.note 2 The difference is where the blame falls: Miller’s changed convention exposes a man’s refusal to see, Dangarembga’s a colonial system that makes seeing costly.note 3

  1. A comparative claim about convention. The thesis names what both works do with a form, not what they are about.

  2. Each work’s convention, precisely. The middle sentence names the specific convention each work changes and how.

  3. The difference that matters. The last sentence uses the shared method to bring out a difference in meaning.

The model works because its likeness is one of method and its difference is one of meaning. Each work gets one precise convention, and the final sentence says what setting them side by side shows.

Marks are most often lost when a comparison stops at the label, as in “both works are tragedies” or “both are coming-of-age novels”. A shared genre is a starting point for comparison, and the essay begins where the two works use it differently.

Conventions change: the sonnet, the tragic hero and the novel in letters have all changed across centuries, as have the stories and references writers expect readers to share. The concept of creativity takes the question further, asking how a writer makes something new inside a tradition, and comparison of whole works asks what two texts that handle a convention differently show about each other.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can define a convention and explain why conventions exist, using the Petrarchan sonnet as an example.

  • To do:

    I can show how “In an Artist’s Studio” keeps the sonnet’s conventions and turns its tradition of praise against itself.

  • To do:

    I can explain which tragic conventions Death of a Salesman keeps and which it changes, and what each change means.

  • To do:

    I can name the main conventions of the Bildungsroman, the Gothic, dystopia, magical realism and revenge tragedy, and show one work changing each.

  • To do:

    I can distinguish subversion, parody, pastiche and the mock-heroic with an example of each.

  • To do:

    I can explain the autobiographical pact and how a memoir can bend it for a purpose.

  • To do:

    I can write a sentence that names a convention, says what a text does with it and states the effect.

  • To do:

    I can compare how two works handle the same convention and say what the difference shows.

Key terms

Each is also in the Intertextuality: connecting texts glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Bildungsroman

A novel that follows a young person's growth from childhood or youth into maturity, through education, conflict and choices about who to become. Its conventions include a sensitive protagonist, a departure from home and an ending that settles the self in the world.

Convention

An established feature of a form or genre that writers repeat and readers expect, such as a fixed number of lines, a kind of character or a pattern of events. Because readers know the convention, a text can meet the expectation it creates or make meaning by departing from it.

Dystopia

An imagined society far worse than the writer's own, usually controlled by a state or system that claims to serve its people, used to criticize tendencies in the present. A utopia is its opposite, an imagined society better than ours.

Gothic

A genre of fiction built on fear: confinement in old buildings, secrets, the supernatural or its suggestion, and a past that returns to threaten the present. Its settings and terrors usually stand for anxieties the society of the time could not state directly.

Magical realism

Fiction that presents impossible events in the calm, matter-of-fact manner of realism, so that the characters accept them as part of ordinary life. The method questions whose idea of what is real a story should follow.

Mock-heroic

Writing that treats a trivial subject in the grand style and conventions of epic, so that the gap between style and subject makes the subject look small. It is usually satirical, mocking the people who take small things too seriously rather than epic itself.

Parody

An imitation of a work, style or genre that exaggerates its features for comic or critical effect. Parody depends on the reader recognizing what is imitated, and it usually judges it.

Pastiche

An imitation of the style of a writer, period or genre, or a combination of several styles, made as tribute or play rather than mockery. Where parody judges its model, pastiche reproduces it.

Revenge tragedy

A kind of tragedy driven by a character's quest to avenge a wrong, popular on the English stage around 1600. Its conventions include a ghost demanding revenge, delay, feigned or real madness, a play within the play and a violent final scene.

Subversion

The use of a convention against its usual meaning, so that a form or genre ends up questioning the values it normally carries. Unlike a simple departure, subversion keeps enough of the convention for the reader to see what is being turned.

Practice questions on 3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGAL-0004220 marks
The Tin BoxThe Tin Box, a play from Kolkata, 1950sWritten for Augment Education
A front room in a rented flat in north Calcutta. Evening. A table, two stools, and a wooden armchair on which lie a folded newspaper and a pair of spectacles. Upstage, a closed door, with a line of light under it. Behind the door a radio plays, low.
TAPAN, fifteen, sits on the floor beside a tin box, sorting sheets of paper. Footsteps on the stairs. He shuts the lid.
ARATI, his mother, comes in with a string bag and an envelope.
ARATIYour Headmaster’s peon was on the stairs.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the play The Tin Box. Tapan, aged fifteen, lives with his mother, Arati, and his father in a rented flat in Calcutta in the 1950s.

Guiding question: In what ways does the unseen father shape the tension between Tapan and his mother?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-0004520 marks
Staff NotesThe Chalk Years, a memoir from Colombo, 1980sWritten for Augment Education
Mr Ratnasabapathy taught us Geography in Form Two, and he could draw the island in one line. He did it on the first morning of every term without looking round: the chalk went on at Colombo and travelled south past Galle, round the bottom, up the east coast, across the top and down the west, and came back into Colombo with a small click, and the boys at the front would let out their breath. Between the end of his line and the start of it there was a gap of perhaps a hair. Then he would turn and say, ‘That is the country. Now we will fill it in,’ and for a term we filled it in.
We called him Sabby, because nobody could say Ratnasabapathy at the speed boys need to say a master’s name. He knew this and did not mind, or did not let us see him minding, which at that age is the same thing. He wore the same brown tie every day of the three years I knew him, and carried a black umbrella in all weathers, closed, like a gentleman in a picture. He called each of us Mister and the surname. He wrote lines on the board in a careful round hand for us to copy fifty times: I shall not guess the gradient of the Hatton plateau. I shall not confuse the Mahaweli with a drain. He was the only master who taught us the Tamil names of the rivers as well as the Sinhala ones, and we wrote both down because they would be in the test, not for any other reason I can honestly claim.
My own maps were bad. I hurried the north and my coast never met itself, and in March of 1983 he gave me four out of ten and wrote under it, in red, An island, Mister Perera, is a thing that closes. I was furious for a week. I still have the map. The ink has gone brown, like his tie.
In the last week of July the schools were shut. From our roof in Bambalapitiya you could see the smoke over Wellawatte, and my father put the car in the garage and the radio on and told us to stay off the roof, which we did not. There was a curfew. The cricket match on the Saturday was cancelled, and I remember that I minded this more than anything else, which is a thing about myself I have had forty years to get used to.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from The Chalk Years, a memoir. The writer remembers a master at the boys’ school he attended in Colombo, Sri Lanka.

Guiding question: Consider how, and to what effect, the writer uses details to build a portrait of his former teacher.

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-0007020 marks
The Ayah to the New MemTanglin Road, a collection of poems from Singapore, 1890sWritten for Augment Education
Come in, Mem. Mind the step: the wood is soft
there by the door. The white ants had it last year.
Tuan will mend it. Tuan says he will mend it.
This is the front room. That is the punkah, Mem;

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following text is a poem, “The Ayah to the New Mem”. It is set in a European household in Singapore in the 1890s.

Guiding question: Consider how, and to what effect, the speaker’s courtesy presents her place in the household.

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 14 questions on 3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms? questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 3.1How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?This page
  2. 3.2How do conventions and systems of reference evolve over time?
  3. 3.3In what ways can diverse literary texts share points of similarity?
  4. 3.4How valid is the notion of a “classic” literary text?
  5. 3.5How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?
  6. 3.6In what ways can comparison and interpretation be transformative?

Carry on with 3.1 How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms? in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.