Paper 1 at HL

How Paper 1 works at higher level: an essay on each of two unseen passages, how to split the 135 minutes, how to switch between literary forms, and how to stop the second essay from turning thin or linear.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Exam skills
  • HL only

27 min readLast reviewed

Paper 1 at higher level asks for the same kind of essay as at standard level, twice, with no choice of passage. The skill tested is the same; what changes is the time, the stamina, and the need to read two different forms well in one sitting. Two passages are used throughout as one HL paper: the opening of Mary Seacole’s autobiography, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs. Seacole in Many Lands (1857), and a sonnet by the Canadian poet Archibald Lampman. Seacole, a Jamaican healer and businesswoman, published her book in London after nursing British soldiers in the Crimean War.

My Birth and Parentage (chapter I)Wonderful Adventures of Mrs. Seacole in Many Lands, 1857Mary Seacole, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs. Seacole in Many Lands, chapter I (London: James Blackwood, 1857)
I was born in the town of Kingston, in the island of Jamaica, some time in the present century. As a female, and a widow, I may be well excused giving the precise date of this important event. But I do not mind confessing that the century and myself were both young together, and that we have grown side by side into age and consequence. I am a Creole, and have good Scotch blood coursing in my veins. My father was a soldier, of an old Scotch family; and to him I often trace my affection for a camp-life, and my sympathy with what I have heard my friends call “the pomp, pride, and circumstance of glorious war.” Many people have also traced to my Scotch blood that energy and activity which are not always found in the Creole race, and which have carried me to so many varied scenes: and perhaps they are right. I have often heard the term “lazy Creole” applied to my country people; but I am sure I do not know what it is to be indolent. All my life long I have followed the impulse which led me to be up and doing; and so far from resting idle anywhere, I have never wanted inclination to rove, nor will powerful enough to find a way to carry out my wishes. That these qualities have led me into many countries, and brought me into some strange and amusing adventures, the reader, if he or she has the patience to get through this book, will see. Some people, indeed, have called me quite a female Ulysses. I believe that they intended it as a compliment; but from my experience of the Greeks, I do not consider it a very flattering one.
It is not my intention to dwell at any length upon the recollections of my childhood. My mother kept a boarding-house in Kingston, and was, like very many of the Creole women, an admirable doctress; in high repute with the officers of both services, and their wives, who were from time to time stationed at Kingston. It was very natural that I should inherit her tastes; and so I had from early youth a yearning for medical knowledge and practice which has never deserted me. When I was a very young child I was taken by an old lady, who brought me up in her household among her own grandchildren, and who could scarcely have shown me more kindness had I been one of them; indeed, I was so spoiled by my kind patroness that, but for being frequently with my mother, I might very likely have grown up idle and useless. But I saw so much of her, and of her patients, that the ambition to become a doctress early took firm root in my mind; and I was very young when I began to make use of the little knowledge I had acquired from watching my mother, upon a great sufferer—my doll. I have noticed always what actors children are. If you leave one alone in a room, how soon it clears a little stage; and, making an audience out of a few chairs and stools, proceeds to act its childish griefs and blandishments upon its doll. So I also made good use of my dumb companion and confidante; and whatever disease was most prevalent in Kingston, be sure my poor doll soon contracted it. I have had many medical triumphs in later days, and saved some valuable lives; but I really think that few have given me more real gratification than the rewarding glow of health which my fancy used to picture stealing over my patient’s waxen face after long and precarious illness.
Before long it was very natural that I should seek to extend my practice; and so I found other patients in the dogs and cats around me. Many luckless brutes were made to simulate diseases which were raging among their owners, and had forced down their reluctant throats the remedies which I deemed most likely to suit their supposed complaints. And after a time I rose still higher in my ambition; and despairing of finding another human patient, I proceeded to try my simples and essences upon—myself.
When I was about twelve years old I was more frequently at my mother’s house, and used to assist her in her duties; very often sharing with her the task of attending upon invalid officers or their wives, who came to her house from the adjacent camp at Up-Park, or the military station at Newcastle.
As I grew into womanhood, I began to indulge that longing to travel which will never leave me while I have health and vigour. I was never weary of tracing upon an old map the route to England; and never followed with my gaze the stately ships homeward bound without longing to be in them, and see the blue hills of Jamaica fade into the distance. At that time it seemed most improbable that these girlish wishes should be gratified; but circumstances, which I need not explain, enabled me to accompany some relatives to England while I was yet a very young woman.
I shall never forget my first impressions of London. Of course, I am not going to bore the reader with them; but they are as vivid now as though the year 18— (I had very nearly let my age slip then) had not been long ago numbered with the past. Strangely enough, some of the most vivid of my recollections are the efforts of the London street-boys to poke fun at my and my companion’s complexion. I am only a little brown—a few shades duskier than the brunettes whom you all admire so much; but my companion was very dark, and a fair (if I can apply the term to her) subject for their rude wit. She was hot-tempered, poor thing! and as there were no policemen to awe the boys and turn our servants’ heads in those days, our progress through the London streets was sometimes a rather chequered one.

Passage 1. Write a guided literary analysis of the extract from Wonderful Adventures of Mrs. Seacole in Many Lands. Guiding question: How does the writer use her narrating voice to present herself and the ways others see her?

Passage 2. Write a guided literary analysis of the poem “The Railway Station” (1888). Guiding question: How does the poem’s movement from what the speaker sees to what the speaker imagines shape its presentation of the crowd?

The Railway StationAmong the Millet and Other Poems, 1888Archibald Lampman, “The Railway Station”, Among the Millet and Other Poems (Ottawa: J. Durie & Son, 1888)
The darkness brings no quiet here, the light
No waking: ever on my blinded brain
The flare of lights, the rush, and cry, and strain,
The engines’ scream, the hiss and thunder smite:
I see the hurrying crowds, the clasp, the flight,
Faces that touch, eyes that are dim with pain:
I see the hoarse wheels turn, and the great train
Move labouring out into the bourneless night.
So many souls within its dim recesses,
So many bright, so many mournful eyes:
Mine eyes that watch grow fixed with dreams and guesses;
What threads of life, what hidden histories,
What sweet or passionate dreams and dark distresses,
What unknown thoughts, what various agonies!

What the paper asks

The paper gives you two unseen passages of different literary forms, each followed by a guiding question. At higher level you write a guided literary analysis of each, in 2 hours and 15 minutes. Each essay is marked out of 20 on the same four criteria as at standard level, for a total of 40, and the paper counts for 35% of the HL grade. There is no choice: both passages must be answered.

The two essays are marked separately. A marker reads the essay on Seacole and gives it marks on A, B, C and D; then reads the essay on Lampman and does the same. Nothing carries over between them. A brilliant first essay does not lift a thin second one, and the second cannot lean on an idea explained in the first.

This independence makes the arithmetic plain. A student who writes one essay at 17 and one at 9 scores 26 of 40. A student who writes two essays at 14 scores 28. The second student wrote no single essay as good as the first student’s best, and still scores higher, because Paper 1 at HL rewards two complete, controlled essays more than one excellent essay and one rushed one.

No choice: ready for every form

At standard level a student who dislikes drama can choose the other passage. At higher level that escape does not exist. The two passages are always of different forms, so an HL student goes into the room ready to analyze any of the four: poetry, prose fiction, prose non-fiction and drama. A passage of memoir or a scene from a play is as possible as a poem.

The Seacole passage is the kind that many students would not have chosen. It is long (six paragraphs, over a thousand words), it is prose non-fiction rather than fiction, and its voice belongs to 1857. A student who has prepared only poems and stories may read it as a story about a girl who wanted to be a doctor and retell it. The form asks different questions: who the “I” is, what she wants her readers to believe, and how the voice persuades them.

A routine for each form

Readiness for every form means having, for each, the first questions to ask in the reading time. These questions come from the pages on the four literary forms and the analysis toolkit, which teach each form in depth; what Paper 1 at HL adds is the need to switch between them within minutes. For a passage of memoir such as Seacole’s, the first three questions are about the narrator as a real person, the gap between her younger and older selves, and the purpose of the telling. For a sonnet such as Lampman’s, they are about the speaker, the movement of the lines and sentences, and what the form itself contributes.

Dividing 135 minutes

The simplest division gives each essay the same time. Five minutes go on reading both passages and both guiding questions. Each essay then gets about 63 minutes, used as at standard level: roughly 21 to prepare (13 to read and annotate, 8 to plan) and 42 to write. Four minutes at the end go on checking both essays. The diagram sets the plan out as two rows on one clock.

Diagram: two rows on a 135-minute axis. Both rows start with 5 minutes reading both passages and end with 4 minutes checking. Essay 1 runs from minute 5 to 68 (prepare, then write); essay 2 from 68 to 131. A dashed line at minute 75 marks the latest start for essay 2.Diagram: two rows on a 135-minute axis. Both rows start with 5 minutes reading both passages and end with 4 minutes checking. Essay 1 runs from minute 5 to 68 (prepare, then write); essay 2 from 68 to 131. A dashed line at minute 75 marks the latest start for essay 2.
An even division of Paper 1 at HL. The dashed line marks the point after which essay 1 must stop, whatever state it is in.

Narrated on the two passages, the plan runs like this. In the first five minutes the student reads Seacole at normal speed, then Lampman, then both guiding questions, and decides the order. At minute 5 the reading of Seacole begins in earnest: three readings, annotation of the voice and its jokes, a thesis on how her humor manages the ways others see her. Writing starts around minute 26 and ends by minute 68 with a conclusion. Then the sonnet gets the same treatment, ending by minute 131, and the last minutes go on reading both theses and checking quotations.

The same plan as a list:

  1. Minutes 0–5: read both passages and both guiding questions; decide the order.

  2. Minutes 5–68: the first essay (about 13 minutes reading and annotating, 8 planning, 42 writing).

  3. Minutes 68–131: the second essay, divided the same way.

  4. Minutes 131–135: check both essays.

Reading both passages first, or one at a time

Some students read only the first passage at the start and meet the second at minute 68. That saves a few minutes, but it has a cost. A passage read once at the start keeps working in the mind during the first essay. A phrase from Lampman’s sonnet, such as “hidden histories” (line 12), may already have suggested a thesis by the time the student turns to it. Reading both first also makes the decision about order an informed one. For most students the five minutes are worth spending.

A second option goes further and plans both essays before writing either. The student reads and annotates both passages and writes both plans (about 35 minutes in all), then writes the two essays one after the other. The advantage is that the second essay never starts from nothing when the student is tired, since its plan was made while fresh. The disadvantage is that the first plan has to wait 30 minutes to be used, and a student who works best by reading and writing in one flow may lose the thread. Either method works if it has been practiced; neither works if tried for the first time in the exam.

Which passage first

There are two reasonable ways to decide. Starting with the passage you feel stronger on builds confidence and banks a good essay early. Starting with the harder passage gives it your freshest attention, and leaves the more familiar task for the time when fatigue sets in. What matters is that the decision is made for a reason, in the first five minutes, rather than by the order in which the passages are printed.

With this pair, many students would take Seacole first, and the reasons show how to think about it. Her passage is long, so its reading costs more time, and reading is what tiredness damages most. Its humor and irony also need a clear head. A tired reader is more likely to take “I may be well excused giving the precise date of this important event” (paragraph 1) at face value and miss the joke about a woman’s age. The sonnet, at 14 lines, can still be read closely in 13 minutes at minute 68. A student who finds poetry difficult might reverse the order, to write the sonnet essay while fresh; that is also a reasoned choice.

Keeping the second essay as strong as the first

The second essay is where most HL marks are lost, and the cause is almost always time. The first essay feels important and runs over; at minute 80 the student is still writing it; the second essay gets 50 minutes, then 45, then whatever is left. The plan above has one rule that prevents this: by minute 75 at the latest, the second essay starts. The last 60 minutes belong to it.

Keeping that rule means being willing to end the first essay before it feels finished. A first essay with three body paragraphs and a short conclusion that judges is complete; a fourth paragraph that eats into the second essay’s time is a bad exchange. In the same way, a second essay of 750 to 900 words with a thesis, three paragraphs and a conclusion scores far more than a longer one that stops in its third paragraph with no conclusion.

Try it

It is minute 70. Your first essay has a thesis, two body paragraphs and half of a third. What do you do?

Finish the sentence you are writing and close the third paragraph in a sentence that links it to the thesis. Then write a short conclusion that judges: which choice matters most, and what the passage achieves through it. Then move to the second passage by minute 72 or 73. The conclusion protects criterion C on the first essay; the time protects all four criteria on the second.

Fatigue also changes the writing itself. Sentences grow longer, quotations grow longer, and paragraphs begin to follow the passage instead of the argument. A student who knows this can watch for it: in the second essay, keep quotations to a few words, start every paragraph with a claim, and stop to reread the thesis once in the middle.

Switching forms

The second essay begins with a change of mind as well as a change of passage. Each literary form asks its own first questions, and the questions that opened the first passage may close the second. The diagram sets out the first three questions for each of the four forms: not everything to look for, but where the reading time should start.

Diagram: four columns. Poetry: who speaks; lines and sentences; what form adds. Prose fiction: who narrates; how time moves; what setting holds. Prose non-fiction: who the I is; its purpose; how trust is won. Drama: what is on stage; what is unsaid; where the tension is.Diagram: four columns. Poetry: who speaks; lines and sentences; what form adds. Prose fiction: who narrates; how time moves; what setting holds. Prose non-fiction: who the I is; its purpose; how trust is won. Drama: what is on stage; what is unsaid; where the tension is.
A switchboard for HL Paper 1: the first three questions to ask of each literary form in the reading time.

The questions at work on Seacole

For the memoir, the first question is who the “I” is, and here there are two. The older Seacole, writing in 1857, looks back on a girl in Kingston, and the gap between them is where much of the humor lives. She says that “the century and myself were both young together, and that we have grown side by side into age and consequence” (paragraph 1). The sentence gives her own birth the grandeur of history and laughs at it at the same time.

The second question is purpose. She is presenting herself to British readers, and much of the passage manages what they might think of her. She quotes the label “lazy Creole” in order to reject it: “I am sure I do not know what it is to be indolent” (paragraph 1). She also reports that people have called her “a female Ulysses” only to undercut the compliment with a joke about her “experience of the Greeks”.

The third question, how the voice wins trust, leads to her habit of addressing the reader directly and mocking herself. The doll she nursed is “a great sufferer” (paragraph 2), and when every other patient fails her she tries her remedies “upon—myself” (paragraph 3), the dash timing the joke. A student who asks these three questions has the material for a thesis on the guiding question within the reading time.

The questions at work on Lampman

The sonnet asks different first questions. The speaker is a watcher whose own state is part of the subject: the station gives “no quiet” and “No waking”, and works “on my blinded brain” (lines 1–2). The second question, about lines and sentences, finds an octave of noun lists whose verb comes late: “The flare of lights, the rush, and cry, and strain, / The engines’ scream, the hiss and thunder smite” (lines 3–4). The third, about form, finds the turn of a Petrarchan sonnet at line 9, where seeing gives way to imagining. These are questions the Seacole essay never asked, and an essay on the sonnet that only discussed the speaker’s attitude would miss most of what the poem does.

Linear commentary

The fault that time pressure produces most often is linear commentary: an essay that works through the passage in its own order, commenting on each part in turn. It tempts for a simple reason. The passage already has an order, and following it needs no plan, so a tired student at minute 90 falls into it almost without choosing to. The cost is high. With no thesis to organize it, the essay describes rather than argues, which keeps criterion C low. Because it meets each line only once, it also cannot set distant parts of the passage side by side, which keeps B low as well.

The two paragraphs that follow are about the same eight lines of Lampman’s sonnet. The first is linear; the second is argued.

Linear: In the first line the poet says the darkness brings no quiet. Then in line 3 there is a list, “the flare of lights, the rush, and cry, and strain”, which shows how busy the station is.note 1 In line 4 “the engines’ scream” is personification.note 2 In lines 5 and 6 the speaker sees people saying goodbye. Finally in line 8 the train leaves into the night.note 3

Argued: The octave presents the station as an attack on the senses that the speaker cannot put in order.note 4 Its nouns arrive in lists, “the flare of lights, the rush, and cry, and strain” (line 3). The verb that should organize them is held back to the end of the next line, where the “hiss and thunder smite”. The people are caught in the same lists, as “Faces that touch, eyes that are dim with pain” (line 6): parts of bodies, not persons.note 5 The sestet will try to turn these fragments back into lives, and the octave makes that effort necessary.note 6

  1. Following the poem. Each sentence starts with a place in the text (“In the first line”, “Then in line 3”). The paragraph has no claim, so it has no reason to choose one detail over another.

  2. A label without an effect. Personification is named and left. In a linear essay there is rarely time to explain, because the next line is waiting.

  3. Retelling. The paragraph ends where the octave ends, on an event rather than a meaning.

  4. A claim first. The topic sentence states what the whole octave does, so every quotation that follows is evidence for it.

  5. The same technique, read twice. The student notices that people and noises are listed in the same way, and draws a conclusion from it.

  6. A link forward. The paragraph prepares the next one, which a linear essay cannot do because it has no argument to continue.

The argued paragraph uses almost the same quotations as the linear one. The difference is the first sentence. Once the student has decided what the octave does, the details become evidence for a claim, and the paragraph can move from noises to faces because both prove the same point.

A student who notices partway through an essay that it has become linear can repair it without starting again. Stop at the end of the paragraph, and ask what the observations so far have in common. Write that as the topic sentence of the next paragraph, and draw its evidence from anywhere in the passage. The essay will not be perfectly shaped, but from that point on it argues.

When the two passages are very different

Some papers pair passages that seem to come from different worlds: a modern free-verse poem and a nineteenth-century prose extract, or a comic memoir and an anguished sonnet. The pair used here is of the second kind. Both passages are from the nineteenth century, but Seacole is chatty, funny and full of asides, while Lampman is compressed, high in register and close to despair. The second essay has to adjust to the passage’s register, not carry over the first’s.

Adjusting means changing what counts as evidence. In Seacole, the jokes and asides are the analysis: “I had very nearly let my age slip then” (paragraph 6) is a choice to be read, not a digression to skip. In Lampman, the archaic forms (“Mine eyes”, line 11; “bourneless”, line 8) are part of the poem’s high, almost biblical register, and the student reads them as such rather than as old-fashioned decoration.

Reading a text in its period

An older passage may also use language about race, class or gender that a modern reader finds uncomfortable, and the essay should neither ignore it nor simply condemn the writer for it. Seacole describes herself as a Creole with “good Scotch blood coursing in my veins” (paragraph 1), accepting her period’s belief that blood carries character, and in the same paragraph refuses its stereotype of Creoles as lazy. In paragraph 6 she reports that London street-boys mocked her and her companion’s skin:

I am only a little brown—a few shades duskier than the brunettes whom you all admire so much; but my companion was very dark, and a fair (if I can apply the term to her) subject for their rude wit.

Mary Seacole, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs. Seacole in Many Lands, paragraph 6

A strong essay analyzes what she does with the mockery. By comparing herself to “the brunettes whom you all admire so much”, she makes her English readers’ own taste the measure of her appearance. The pun on “fair”, and her apology for it, lets her report the insult without repeating it. The writing manages prejudice through wit and a show of good humor, and an essay can discuss both the skill of that strategy and what it concedes.

Where marks are lost at HL

The faults that cost marks at standard level cost them at higher level too, twice over. Four more belong to HL itself, because they come from writing two essays in one sitting. The table shows each with what it looks like and how to correct it.

Fault

What it looks like

The correction

An unfinished second essay

A third paragraph that stops mid-sentence, and no conclusion.

Start the second essay by minute 75. If time is short, write two paragraphs and a conclusion rather than three paragraphs and none.

The first essay’s method, repeated

An essay on Lampman that discusses only “tone” and “attitude”, like the essay on Seacole.

Switch to the form’s own questions: line, sound and the turn at line 9.

Planning only one essay

A second essay that walks through the sonnet from line 1 to line 14.

Give each essay its eight minutes of planning, or plan both before writing either.

A thinner second thesis

The poem shows how busy a railway station is.

The sonnet turns from seeing to imagining, but its imagining stops at guesses, so the crowd grows more human and more distant at once.

All four come from treating the second essay as less important than the first. It is not: it is half of the paper, marked exactly as the first is.

A second essay in full

The response that follows is the second essay of an HL script, written on “The Railway Station” after an essay on Seacole, in the last hour of the paper. Its guiding question was: How does the poem’s movement from what the speaker sees to what the speaker imagines shape its presentation of the crowd? It is shorter than the student’s first essay and less polished, but it is complete, and it changes its questions to suit a poem.

Exemplar · High band16 of 20 marks

Paper 1 at HL: “The Railway Station”, a high-band second essay

On The Railway Station

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The essay scores 16 of 20, a high-band mark for a second essay written in the last hour. It is about 800 words, shorter than a first essay usually is, and it has the flaws of tiredness: one hedged phrase, a point about rhyme left unproved, a conclusion that begins by restating. What it does not lack is any of the things that keep marks safe. It has a thesis that answers the guiding question, a turn in its argument, a conclusion, and analysis shaped by the form: the octave and sestet, the delayed verb, the lists and the rhyme.

Set beside the plan for the 135 minutes, the essay shows the rule about the last 60 minutes at work. The student stopped the Seacole essay on time, gave the sonnet its own reading and plan, and wrote less rather than leaving the essay unfinished.

Where to practice

In the question bank, Paper 1 practice passages of all four forms can be paired into a timed HL sitting of 2 hours and 15 minutes, two passages of different forms with no choice. Sitting a full HL paper at least three times before the exam, and comparing both essays with the marked responses, is the surest way to learn your own pace.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what Paper 1 at HL asks: an essay on each of two unseen passages of different forms, in 135 minutes, each marked out of 20.

  • To do:

    I can divide the 135 minutes so that the second essay starts by minute 75 at the latest.

  • To do:

    I can decide which passage to write on first, for a reason.

  • To do:

    I can switch between the first questions of the four literary forms within minutes.

  • To do:

    I can recognize linear commentary in my own writing and turn it into an argued paragraph.

  • To do:

    I can write a complete, argued second essay even when it is shorter than the first.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Linear commentary HL only

An essay that works through a passage in the passage’s own order, commenting on each part in turn instead of arguing a thesis. It tends to describe rather than analyze and loses the links between distant parts of the text.

Markband HL only

A level on an assessment criterion: a mark or range of marks together with a description of the work that earns it. A marker reads the whole response and chooses the description that fits it best.

Exam skills for English A Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLThis page
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.