Working with the guiding question

What a Paper 1 guiding question points to, how to answer it without being trapped by it, when to set your own focus instead, and how to read command terms precisely.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

23 min readLast reviewed

Every Paper 1 passage arrives with one question beneath it, and how a student uses that question shapes the whole essay. A guiding question points to two things at once: a feature of the passage and a meaning that feature helps to make. Used well, it starts a thesis; used badly, it either confines the essay to one feature or is quoted back and then forgotten. One short scene, read through three different guiding questions, shows how much the question decides and how much it leaves to the student.

The scene is from Shakuntala, the Sanskrit play by Kalidasa, usually placed in the fourth or fifth century CE, in Arthur W. Ryder’s English translation of 1912. A king, out hunting, enters the grove of a hermitage and watches three young women watering its trees. One of them, Shakuntala, is the foster-daughter of the sage Kanva.

Shakuntala (Act I, the hermitage grove)Shakuntala, 1912Kalidasa, Shakuntala, Act I, translated by Arthur W. Ryder, Kalidasa: Translations of Shakuntala and Other Works (London: J. M. Dent; New York: E. P. Dutton, 1912)
KING(walking and looking about). The hermitage! Well, I will enter. (As he does so, he feels a throbbing in his arm.)
KINGA tranquil spot! Why should I thrill?
KINGLove cannot enter there—
KINGYet to inevitable things
KINGDoors open everywhere.
A VOICE BEHIND THE SCENESThis way, girls!
KING(listening). I think I hear some one to the right of the grove. I must find out. (He walks and looks about.) Ah, here are hermit-girls, with watering-pots just big enough for them to handle. They are coming in this direction to water the young trees. They are charming!
KINGThe city maids, for all their pains,
KINGSeem not so sweet and good;
KINGOur garden blossoms yield to these
KINGFlower-children of the wood.
KINGI will draw back into the shade and wait for them. (He stands, gazing toward them. Enter SHAKUNTALA, as described, and her two friends.)
FIRST FRIENDIt seems to me, dear, that Father Kanva cares more for the hermitage trees than he does for you. You are delicate as a jasmine blossom, yet he tells you to fill the trenches about the trees.
SHAKUNTALAOh, it isn’t Father’s bidding so much. I feel like a real sister to them. (She waters the trees.)
PRIYAMVADAShakuntala, we have watered the trees that blossom in the summer-time. Now let’s sprinkle those whose flowering-time is past. That will be a better deed, because we shall not be working for a reward.
SHAKUNTALAWhat a pretty idea! (She does so.)
KING(to himself). And this is Kanva’s daughter, Shakuntala. (In surprise.) The good Father does wrong to make her wear the hermit’s dress of bark.
KINGThe sage who yokes her artless charm
KINGWith pious pain and grief,
KINGWould try to cut the toughest vine
KINGWith a soft, blue lotus-leaf.
KINGWell, I will step behind a tree and see how she acts with her friends. (He conceals himself.)
SHAKUNTALAOh, Anusuya! Priyamvada has fastened this bark dress so tight that it hurts. Please loosen it. (ANUSUYA does so.)
PRIYAMVADA(laughing). You had better blame your own budding charms for that.
KINGShe is quite right.
KINGBeneath the barken dress
KINGUpon the shoulder tied,
KINGIn maiden loveliness
KINGHer young breast seems to hide,
KINGAs when a flower amid
KINGThe leaves by autumn tossed—
KINGPale, withered leaves—lies hid,
KINGAnd half its grace is lost.
KINGYet in truth the bark dress is not an enemy to her beauty. It serves as an added ornament. For
KINGThe meanest vesture glows
KINGOn beauty that enchants:
KINGThe lotus lovelier shows
KINGAmid dull water-plants;
KINGThe moon in added splendour
KINGShines for its spot of dark;
KINGYet more the maiden slender
KINGCharms in her dress of bark.

What a guiding question is

In Paper 1, each passage is followed by one guiding question. It points to a technical or formal aspect of the passage (its imagery, its narrator, its staging, the shape of its lines) and to a meaning or effect that aspect helps to produce. A question on the scene from Shakuntala might ask: How does the King’s hidden position in the grove shape the audience’s view of Shakuntala? The feature is the staging; the meaning is how Shakuntala is seen.

The question is an offer. You can answer it or set a focus of your own on a technical or formal aspect of the passage, and the two approaches are marked in exactly the same way. Most strong essays answer the guiding question, because it has been written to open the passage’s central tension. The best of them use it as a starting point and argue something the question did not say.

Two kinds of guiding question

The same name is used for something quite different elsewhere in the study of literature. The three areas of exploration each have six guiding questions, such as How do literary texts offer insights and challenges? Those eighteen questions are prompts for discussion and for the learner portfolio. They organize what is studied, and none of them is ever set as an examination question.

The difference matters because the two kinds invite different writing. An essay that answers a Paper 1 question with the broad reflection suited to an area question (literature offers insights into love) has left the passage behind. In the paper, every sentence answers a question about these words.

The anatomy of a guiding question

A guiding question has two parts, and an answer needs both. The feature is the how: a choice of language, structure or form, such as the staging, the shifts of tone, the narrator’s perspective or the movement between prose and verse. The meaning is the what: the effect or idea the feature serves, such as the audience’s view of a character, a speaker’s attitude to a place, or the tension in a scene. The question word that opens it (“How”, “In what ways”, “To what extent”) says how the two are to be connected.

The diagram splits three guiding questions on the scene from Shakuntala into these parts. The first two name their feature precisely. The third leaves the feature open: it asks how the extract “presents” a relationship, which means the student chooses which choices to analyze.

Diagram: three guiding questions split into parts. How: the King’s hidden position (staging) → the audience’s view of Shakuntala. How: shifts from prose into verse (form) → the King’s response. How … present: any choices, left open → the young women and the natural world.Diagram: three guiding questions split into parts. How: the King’s hidden position (staging) → the audience’s view of Shakuntala. How: shifts from prose into verse (form) → the King’s response. How … present: any choices, left open → the young women and the natural world.
Three guiding questions on the scene from *Shakuntala*, each split into its question word, its feature and its meaning.

Reading a question this way takes a minute and saves the essay from the two commonest misreadings. A student who sees only the feature writes a survey of the staging, or of the verse, and never says what it does. A student who sees only the meaning writes about Shakuntala’s character or about nature, and never analyzes a choice. The thesis has to join the two: it says how the feature makes the meaning.

Before planning, it helps to rewrite the guiding question in two lines, one beginning Feature and one beginning Meaning. If either line is hard to fill in, the question needs another reading. If the feature line says “left open”, the student decides which two or three choices to analyze before starting.

Try it

Split this guiding question into its parts: In what ways does the extract use comparisons with plants and flowers to shape the King’s view of Shakuntala? What does “In what ways” add?

Feature: comparisons with plants and flowers, the imagery of the King’s verse and of the women’s speech (“jasmine blossom”, line 13; “Flower-children of the wood”, line 11; the lotus, lines 21 and 37). Meaning: the King’s view of Shakuntala. “In what ways” asks for several distinct ways, not one. Flowers praise her as natural; a lotus-leaf makes her too delicate for the hermitage; and a hidden flower among withered leaves turns the praise toward her body.

Command terms and question words

The words that tell an answer what to do are command terms. Paper 1 guiding questions use few of the formal ones: most are open questions that begin “How”, “In what ways” or “To what extent”, sometimes with “present” or What is the effect of. Paper 2 questions more often ask students to “compare” or “discuss”. Each word asks for a different kind of thinking, and an essay that does a different kind from the one asked can be excellent and still miss the task.

Term

What it asks the answer to do

Analyze

Take a text or feature apart and show how its parts work together to make meaning.

Compare

Set two works side by side and show likenesses and differences, with the comparison doing the work of the argument.

Contrast

Show the differences between two works or features, and what the differences show.

Discuss

Weigh more than one reading or factor and reach a supported conclusion.

Evaluate

Judge the strengths, limits or success of a choice, reading or claim against the evidence.

Examine

Look closely at something to bring out its assumptions and connections.

Explain

Give the reasons: how and why a choice produces its effect.

Interpret

Draw out a meaning that is not on the surface, and support it from the text.

Justify

Give reasons and evidence for a claim or for choosing one reading over another.

How

Analyze method: the choices that produce an effect.

In what ways

Find and analyze several distinct ways something is done, not one.

To what extent

Weigh a claim and reach a judgment of degree (largely, partly, in one sense but not another) with evidence.

Present (“how … present”)

Analyze how a writer constructs something (a character, a place, an issue) through choices, not the thing itself.

Three of these shape most Paper 1 essays. “How” asks for method, so an answer that describes Shakuntala’s character without analyzing a single choice has not begun. “In what ways” asks for range: three or four distinct means, each analyzed, rather than one means explored at length. “To what extent” asks for a degree, so the thesis has to commit to one and the essay has to weigh what supports it against what limits it.

A question on the scene could ask: To what extent does the bark dress change the King’s view of Shakuntala? The King’s verse changes its mind about the dress. First it hides her, “As when a flower amid / The leaves by autumn tossed” (lines 30–31); then it adorns her, as the moon “Shines for its spot of dark” (line 40). A good answer of degree sees that the dress changes his view of her beauty only in direction, from hidden to heightened, while his view of her as an object of beauty does not change at all.

One passage, three guiding questions

The guiding question decides where an essay looks first, and so it decides much of what the essay finds. Three questions on the same scene from Shakuntala show this, each with a thesis, the evidence it leads to, and what it leaves out.

The staging: the King’s hidden position

Guiding question: How does the King’s hidden position in the grove shape the audience’s view of Shakuntala?

The King hides twice. He draws “back into the shade” to wait (line 12), and later steps “behind a tree” to see how Shakuntala “acts with her friends” (line 22). From then on the audience watches the women from beside him, and knows what they do not: that every word they say is overheard. The scene uses this dramatic irony for comedy when Priyamvada teases Shakuntala about her “budding charms” and the hidden King agrees aloud, “She is quite right” (lines 24–25), joining a conversation he is not part of.

The strongest thesis notices that the hiding gives the audience two views of Shakuntala at once. In her own words she is practical and affectionate: she feels “like a real sister” to the trees (line 14), and she complains that the bark dress is fastened “so tight that it hurts” (line 23). In the King’s verse, the same dress becomes a frame for her body. The diagram ranks three theses on this question, from one that restates it to one that argues.

Diagram: a guiding question on the King’s hidden position, with three theses beneath it ranked by strength. Restates: the hidden position shapes the view in many ways. Describes: the audience sees how beautiful and innocent she is. Argues: she is seen twice, in her own words and in his verse.Diagram: a guiding question on the King’s hidden position, with three theses beneath it ranked by strength. Restates: the hidden position shapes the view in many ways. Describes: the audience sees how beautiful and innocent she is. Argues: she is seen twice, in her own words and in his verse.
Three theses on one guiding question, from restating to arguing. Only the last says how the staging works and what it does.

What this question leaves out is the detail of the verse itself, its form and its images. A strong answer uses the verse as evidence for what the King sees, but it does not have time to analyze why he moves into verse, which is a second question.

The form: prose and verse

Guiding question: How do the King’s shifts from prose into verse present his response to Shakuntala?

The King speaks prose when he acts and verse when he is moved. His prose plans and moves: “I will draw back into the shade”, “I will step behind a tree”. His verse begins at the first omen, a throbbing in his arm, with a paradox:

Love cannot enter there—
Yet to inevitable things
Doors open everywhere.

Shakuntala, Act I, lines 3–5

The verses also grow. The first three are four lines each (lines 2–5, 8–11, 18–21); the last two, on Shakuntala’s body and on the dress as ornament, are eight (lines 26–33, 35–42). A thesis on this question might argue that the King’s verse grows as his watching continues, so the form records a feeling that outruns his sense of place. He is, after all, in a hermitage he had just said love “cannot enter”. The evidence comes from the length, the placing and the similes of the five verses.

This question leaves out the women almost entirely. Their prose is part of the contrast, but an essay on the King’s verse risks forgetting that Shakuntala speaks at all, which is exactly what the first question brought into view.

The relationship: the women and the natural world

Guiding question: How does the extract present the relationship between the young women and the natural world of the hermitage?

This question leaves its feature open, so the student chooses the choices. The women’s relationship with the plants is one of care and kinship. Shakuntala waters the trees as their “sister” (line 14), and Priyamvada suggests watering those whose flowering is past, because then “we shall not be working for a reward” (line 15). The King’s relationship with the same plants is comparison. He calls the women “Flower-children of the wood” (line 11), sets Shakuntala beside a “soft, blue lotus-leaf” (line 21), and makes the lotus and the moon into images of her beauty (lines 37–40).

A thesis might argue that the extract sets two relationships with nature side by side. The women care for the plants as family, without reward; the King uses plants only as comparisons for their beauty, so the grove that is a home to them is a frame for desire to him. What this question leaves out is the theater: the hiding and the overhearing, which make the King’s comparisons into a private performance the women cannot answer.

Set side by side, the three questions produce three different essays on one scene, and each strong thesis reaches toward what the other questions foreground. The staging thesis needs the verse as evidence; the nature thesis needs the King’s hidden position to explain why his comparisons go unanswered.

Answering it without being trapped

A guiding question is the spine of the essay, not its walls. The thesis answers it, every topic sentence develops the answer, and the conclusion judges it. But the evidence the essay uses, and the claims it reaches, are not limited to the feature the question names. A question about the King’s verse can be answered with his prose, the women’s speech and the stage directions, as long as each is used to explain the verse.

The trap is an essay that does only what the question names. On the question about prose and verse, a trapped thesis reads: The King uses verse five times in the extract to express his feelings about Shakuntala. It is accurate, and it promises five paragraphs that each describe one verse. A thesis that answers the question and goes further sees what the verses do in sequence. The last of them follows a prose line that calls her dress “not an enemy to her beauty” (line 34), and then proves the claim in verse:

The meanest vesture glows
On beauty that enchants:
The lotus lovelier shows
Amid dull water-plants;

Shakuntala, Act I, lines 35–38

The King’s verse has turned even the thing he objected to, the hermit’s dress, into one more reason to admire her. A thesis that sees this might argue that the King’s verse grows from praise to argument, and its last turn makes every detail of the hermitage, even the bark dress, into a reason to go on looking. It still answers the question about prose and verse. It has simply followed the question to the point where the passage’s tension lies.

Setting your own focus

Instead of answering the guiding question, you may set a self-chosen focus: a focus of your own on a technical or formal aspect of the passage. It is marked in exactly the same way as an answer to the guiding question, so it is neither a risk in itself nor a way to earn extra credit. It is a choice to make when the reading points elsewhere.

Two situations justify it. In the first, the guiding question points to a feature the student cannot do much with: a student who has never studied drama might find a question about staging hard to sustain for 40 minutes. In the second, the student’s own reading, after the annotation, is clearly stronger on another aspect. A student who has noticed how the women’s teasing prose sets up each of the King’s verses has found something the three questions above only touch.

How to state it

A self-chosen focus is stated in the introduction, in one sentence that names both parts, just as a guiding question does: the feature and the meaning. For the scene from Shakuntala, it might read: This essay focuses on the dialogue between the three women, and argues that their practical, teasing speech offers a view of Shakuntala that the hidden King’s verse cannot hear. The thesis then follows, and the essay is held to that focus as firmly as it would be held to a guiding question.

The risk of a self-chosen focus is drift. Without a printed question to return to, an essay can begin on dialogue and end on imagery, and its paragraphs no longer form one argument. A student who sets a focus should write it at the top of the plan and test each topic sentence against it before writing the paragraph.

Weak and strong uses of the guiding question

The guiding question goes wrong in three common ways. Each is shown with a strong version, all on the question about the King’s hidden position.

Weak: The guiding question asks how the King’s hidden position in the grove shapes the audience’s view of Shakuntala. In this essay I will analyze how it does this.note 1

Strong: Hidden first in the shade and then behind a tree, the King turns the audience into fellow watchers, and the scene shows Shakuntala twice: as she speaks for herself and as his verse remakes her.note 2

Weak: In lines 13 to 16 the friends talk about watering the trees, and Shakuntala says she feels like a sister to them.note 3

Strong: The women’s own speech, overheard by the hidden King, gives the audience a Shakuntala his verse never describes: a girl who waters trees “like a real sister” (line 14) and complains that her dress “hurts” (line 23).note 4

Weak: The King is wrong to spy on the girls, which shows that he is not a respectful person.note 5

Strong: Because the women cannot see him, the King’s praise is never tested against what Shakuntala might say back, and the staging lets his view run unchecked.note 6

  1. Quoting the question back. The introduction copies the question and promises to answer it. Nothing in it is a claim.

  2. An answer at the start. The question is answered in the thesis itself, with the feature located (shade, tree) and the meaning stated (two views).

  3. Losing the question in the body. A body paragraph that begins with line numbers and plot has forgotten the question; it will be answered, if at all, only in the conclusion.

  4. The question in every topic sentence. The same lines are now evidence for the answer: the hidden King and the audience overhear a Shakuntala the verse ignores.

  5. A different question. A moral judgment of the King answers whether the King is good, which nobody asked. It moves from how the scene works to what the student thinks of a character.

  6. Back to the question. The same discomfort with the King’s watching becomes analysis: the staging is what lets his view go unanswered.

The three strong versions share one habit. Each sentence names the staging (the hiding, the overhearing) and says what it does to the view of Shakuntala. An essay whose every topic sentence does this has answered the guiding question throughout, not only at its two ends.

How criteria A and C read the guiding question

Two criteria are most affected by how the guiding question is used. Under criterion A, Understanding and interpretation, a question that points to the passage’s central tension rewards a reading of the whole passage. An essay on the King’s hidden position that never notices Shakuntala’s own words has understood only half the scene. Answering the question well usually means finding the tension it points toward, here the gap between how Shakuntala sees herself and how she is seen.

Under criterion C, Focus and organization, the question (or the student’s own focus) is the line the argument follows. The criterion rewards a line of argument that runs from the introduction to the conclusion and through every paragraph between. An essay that answers the question in its first and last paragraphs, and walks through the passage in between, has a frame but no line. That pattern is one of the commonest reasons for a middle mark on C.

A response in full

The response that follows answers the first guiding question on the scene: How does the King’s hidden position in the grove shape the audience’s view of Shakuntala? It is a middle-band essay, and it shows the commonest problem with the guiding question: the question is answered in the introduction and the conclusion, and the paragraphs between them walk through the scene in order. Its margin comments show where it understands the scene well and where its use of the question costs marks.

Exemplar · Middle band10 of 20 marks

Paper 1: *Shakuntala*, Act I, a middle-band response

On Shakuntala

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The response scores 10 of 20. Most of its marks are lost not to misreading but to the way it uses the guiding question. Its best observation, the King agreeing aloud with a conversation he is hiding from (comment 7), is a direct answer to the question, and it sits in the fourth paragraph as a joke. Suppose it were rewritten so that every topic sentence answers the question, with that moment at the center of a paragraph on how the hiding divides the audience’s view of Shakuntala. The same knowledge of the scene would then reach the top of the middle band at least, and probably beyond it.

Where to practice

Every Paper 1 practice passage in the question bank has its own guiding question. A useful habit is to work with the questions in two ways. On one passage, split the question into its feature and meaning and write a thesis that goes one step beyond it. On another, set a focus of your own and state it in one sentence before planning.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what a Paper 1 guiding question points to, and how it differs from the guiding questions of the areas of exploration.

  • To do:

    I can split a guiding question into its feature and its meaning, and say what its question word asks.

  • To do:

    I can read the common command terms and question words precisely, including “to what extent” and “in what ways”.

  • To do:

    I can write a thesis that answers a guiding question and goes one step beyond it.

  • To do:

    I can decide when to set a self-chosen focus, and state one clearly in an introduction.

  • To do:

    I can keep the guiding question in every topic sentence, not only in the introduction and conclusion.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Command term

A word or phrase in a task that sets the kind of thinking the answer must do: explaining, comparing, weighing or judging. Reading it precisely keeps an essay answering the task that was set rather than a nearby one.

Guiding question

In Paper 1, the question printed beneath each passage, pointing to a technical or formal aspect of the passage and the meaning it helps to make; a student may answer it or set a focus of their own. The same name is used for the eighteen discussion questions of the areas of exploration, which are prompts for study rather than examination questions.

Self-chosen focus

A focus on a technical or formal aspect of a Paper 1 passage that a student sets instead of answering the guiding question. It is stated in the introduction, carries the essay’s thesis, and is marked in the same way as an answer to the guiding question.

Exam skills for English A Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding questionThis page

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.