Paper 1 at SL

How Paper 1 works at standard level: choosing a passage, reading and annotating an unseen text, turning the guiding question into a thesis, writing paragraphs that analyze, and what each criterion rewards.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

34 min readLast reviewed

Paper 1 tests one skill: reading a literary text you have never seen and explaining, in an argued essay, how it makes its meaning. Nothing can be memorized for it, but everything practiced in close reading prepares for it. The method that follows is worked through on one short poem, Edward Thomas’s “Rain”, written in 1916 while Thomas was training as a soldier.

RainPoems, 1917Edward Thomas, “Rain”, Poems (London: Selwyn & Blount, 1917)
Rain, midnight rain, nothing but the wild rain
On this bleak hut, and solitude, and me
Remembering again that I shall die
And neither hear the rain nor give it thanks
For washing me cleaner than I have been
Since I was born into this solitude.
Blessed are the dead that the rain rains upon:
But here I pray that none whom once I loved
Is dying to-night or lying still awake
Solitary, listening to the rain,
Either in pain or thus in sympathy
Helpless among the living and the dead,
Like a cold water among broken reeds,
Myriads of broken reeds all still and stiff,
Like me who have no love which this wild rain
Has not dissolved except the love of death,
If love it be towards what is perfect and
Cannot, the tempest tells me, disappoint.

What the paper asks

The paper gives you two unseen passages: literary texts you meet for the first time in the room. They are always of two different literary forms, for example a poem and an extract from a novel, or a scene from a play and a passage of memoir. Each passage is followed by one guiding question. At standard level you choose one passage and write one essay on it in 1 hour and 15 minutes. The essay is marked out of 20 and counts for 35% of the final grade.

No books, notes or annotated copies go into the room. Everything in the essay comes from two sources: the passage in front of you, and the habits of reading you bring with you. A response that talks about the writer’s life, the period or the subject in general, instead of the words on the paper, has nothing to stand on.

The task is a guided literary analysis. It is an essay in the full sense: it argues one reading of the passage and shows, with evidence, how the writer’s choices of language, structure and form make that reading. The guiding question is an offer, not an order. You can answer it or set a focus of your own on a technical or formal aspect of the passage, and the two approaches are marked in the same way. How to use the question, and when to leave it, has its own page on working with the guiding question.

Older study guides call the same task a “commentary”, and the word still leads students into the wrong shape of essay. A commentary in the old sense walks through the text from top to bottom. An analysis is organized by its argument, so its first paragraph might open on the last line of the poem, and its third set line 2 beside line 16.

Choosing between the two passages

Suppose the paper pairs “Rain” with the opening of “Hands”, the first story in Sherwood Anderson’s Winesburg, Ohio (1919). The two passages arrive with these tasks:

Passage 1. Write a guided literary analysis of the poem “Rain”. Guiding question: How does the speaker’s attention move from himself to others, and with what effect on the poem’s presentation of love?

Passage 2. Write a guided literary analysis of the extract from the story “Hands”. Guiding question: How does the narrator use Wing Biddlebaum’s hands to present his relationship with the town?

Hands (opening)Winesburg, Ohio: A Group of Tales of Ohio Small Town Life, 1919Sherwood Anderson, “Hands”, Winesburg, Ohio (New York: B. W. Huebsch, 1919)
Upon the half decayed veranda of a small frame house that stood near the edge of a ravine near the town of Winesburg, Ohio, a fat little old man walked nervously up and down. Across a long field that has been seeded for clover but that had produced only a dense crop of yellow mustard weeds, he could see the public highway along which went a wagon filled with berry pickers returning from the fields. The berry pickers, youths and maidens, laughed and shouted boisterously. A boy clad in a blue shirt leaped from the wagon and attempted to drag after him one of the maidens who screamed and protested shrilly. The feet of the boy in the road kicked up a cloud of dust that floated across the face of the departing sun. Over the long field came a thin girlish voice. “Oh, you Wing Biddlebaum, comb your hair, it’s falling into your eyes,” commanded the voice to the man, who was bald and whose nervous little hands fiddled about the bare white forehead as though arranging a mass of tangled locks.
Wing Biddlebaum, forever frightened and beset by a ghostly band of doubts, did not think of himself as in any way a part of the life of the town where he had lived for twenty years. Among all the people of Winesburg but one had come close to him. With George Willard, son of Tom Willard, the proprietor of the new Willard House, he had formed something like a friendship. George Willard was the reporter on the Winesburg Eagle and sometimes in the evenings he walked out along the highway to Wing Biddlebaum’s house. Now as the old man walked up and down on the veranda, his hands moving nervously about, he was hoping that George Willard would come and spend the evening with him. After the wagon containing the berry pickers had passed, he went across the field through the tall mustard weeds and climbing a rail fence peered anxiously along the road to the town. For a moment he stood thus, rubbing his hands together and looking up and down the road, and then, fear overcoming him, ran back to walk again upon the porch on his own house.
In the presence of George Willard, Wing Biddlebaum, who for twenty years had been the town mystery, lost something of his timidity, and his shadowy personality, submerged in a sea of doubts, came forth to look at the world. With the young reporter at his side, he ventured in the light of day into Main Street or strode up and down on the rickety front porch of his own house, talking excitedly. The voice that had been low and trembling became shrill and loud. The bent figure straightened. With a kind of wriggle, like a fish returned to the brook by the fisherman, Biddlebaum the silent began to talk, striving to put into words the ideas that had been accumulated by his mind during long years of silence.
Wing Biddlebaum talked much with his hands. The slender expressive fingers, forever active, forever striving to conceal themselves in his pockets or behind his back, came forth and became the piston rods of his machinery of expression.
The story of Wing Biddlebaum is a story of hands. Their restless activity, like unto the beating of the wings of an imprisoned bird, had given him his name. Some obscure poet of the town had thought of it. The hands alarmed their owner. He wanted to keep them hidden away and looked with amazement at the quiet inexpressive hands of other men who worked beside him in the fields, or passed, driving sleepy teams on country roads.
When he talked to George Willard, Wing Biddlebaum closed his fists and beat with them upon a table or on the walls of his house. The action made him more comfortable. If the desire to talk came to him when the two were walking in the fields, he sought out a stump or the top board of a fence and with his hands pounding busily talked with renewed ease.

The choice takes about five minutes, and it is worth taking seriously, because no later skill can rescue an essay on the wrong passage. Read both passages through once, at normal speed, and read both guiding questions. Then, for each passage, try to write three short claims in the margin: not features (“simile”, “repetition”) but statements someone could disagree with.

For “Hands” the claims come quickly. The narrator announces that “The story of Wing Biddlebaum is a story of hands” (paragraph 5), so the hands are the man. The town mocks him: a girl’s voice tells a bald man to “comb your hair” (paragraph 1), a joke he answers with his fingers. And only George Willard frees him, “like a fish returned to the brook by the fisherman” (paragraph 3). For “Rain” the claims take longer but are there. The rain both washes the speaker and isolates him (lines 1–6). The poem turns outward at “But here I pray” (line 8) to imagine others lying awake. And the last lines admit that the only love the rain has not dissolved is “the love of death” (line 16).

Both passages give three claims, so the decision moves to two further questions. Which form have you practiced most, and read best? And which guiding question opens onto a reading you can already half see? A student who has written often about narrators and point of view may find “Hands” the stronger choice; one who has learned to follow a poem’s syntax and its turns may find that “Rain” gives more.

The trap of the easier passage

“Hands” looks easier. It tells a story in plain sentences about a man you can picture, and its central image is named for you. That ease is a risk. A passage that is easy to follow pulls the essay toward retelling it, and retelling earns few marks. A short, dense poem can be the better choice for the opposite reason. Its 18 lines hold patterns that give every paragraph its evidence: the word rain seven times and rains once, solitude twice and Solitary once, two similes opening with “Like”.

A second wrong reason is the subject. A student who likes war poetry may take “Rain” because of its date, and then write about the war, which the poem never mentions. Choose by what you can show about the writing, never by the topic you would enjoy discussing.

Reading an unseen passage

About 15 minutes of the 75 go on reading and annotating the passage you chose. That is longer than most students give it, and it is the best-spent time in the paper. A reading that is clear after 15 minutes writes itself in 40. A reading still forming during the writing produces paragraphs that change their minds halfway.

The method is the one taught in the chapter on why and how literature is studied: three readings, each with its own job. The first asks what happens. The second asks what stands out, and marks patterns, shifts and anything odd. The third asks why it matters, and turns the marks into claims. Under time, each reading is a little faster and a little more deliberate than in class, and the annotation is written to be used, since it becomes the plan.

Three readings of “Rain”

On a first reading, “Rain” is simple to follow. A speaker alone in a hut at midnight listens to the rain and remembers that he will die. He prays that nobody he once loved is lying awake as he is, and ends by admitting that the rain has dissolved every love in him except the love of death.

The second reading slows down and marks. Annotated by a strong student, the first ten lines might look like this:

Rain, midnight rain, nothing but the wild rainnote 1
On this bleak hut, and solitude, and menote 2
Remembering againnote 3 that I shall die
And neither hear the rain nor give it thanks
For washing me cleanernote 4 than I have been
Since I was born into this solitude.
Blessed are the dead that the rain rains upon:note 5
But here I praynote 6 that none whom once I lovednote 7
Is dying to-night or lying still awake
Solitary, listening to the rain,note 8

“Rain”, lines 1–10

  1. What is here. Rain three times, and no verb. The whole world is one sound.

  2. Pattern. Solitude stands between the hut and me like another object in the room. It returns in line 6, and as Solitary in line 10.

  3. Question. Again: he thinks about death often. A habit, not a shock?

  4. Pattern. Washing, as in a baptism. But the cleaning is tied to dying. Check the end: “dissolved” (line 16).

  5. Shift. Sounds like a blessing from the Bible (“Blessed are …”). The register rises from thought to prayer.

  6. Turn. The first main verb the speaker gives himself is pray. The attention moves outward here.

  7. Question. Once: does he still love them?

  8. Claim. He imagines the others in his own posture. Turning outward brings them into his solitude instead of taking him out of it.

The notes are of three kinds, and each kind matters. Some name a pattern (notes 2 and 4), some ask a question that the rest of the poem may answer (notes 3 and 7), and one already states a claim (note 8). By the end of the second reading the student has also noticed the grammar of the first sentence. Lines 1 to 6 have no main verb at all, so the scene is a state the speaker is held in, not something he does.

The third reading is short and pointed. It goes back over the marks with the guiding question in mind and asks how they connect. Two connections do most of the work in “Rain”. The washing of line 5 and the dissolving of line 16 are the same rain doing two things, so cleansing and loss are one action. And the prayer that turns toward others ends by finding them “Solitary” like the speaker, so the movement outward bends back. Those two connections are the beginning of a thesis.

From the guiding question to a thesis

A thesis is the claim the whole essay argues. It answers the guiding question in a form that someone could dispute, and it names both the how (the choices that matter) and the what (the meaning they make). It sits at the end of the introduction, in one or two sentences, and every paragraph after it develops one part of it.

Three attempts at a thesis on “Rain” show the difference. The first restates the question: The speaker’s attention moves from himself to others, which has an effect on how love is presented. It says nothing that the question did not already say. The second names a topic: The poem is about love and death in wartime. It is a subject, not a claim, and it brings in the war, which the poem never names. The third argues:

“Rain” turns outward only once, at the prayer of line 8,note 1 and the turn is an act of love: the speaker imagines those he once loved lying awake as he is. But the poem’s long final sentence carries that sympathy back to the speaker himself,note 2 so that thinking of others ends in the admission that the only love the rain has left him is “the love of death”.note 3

  1. The how. A precise location (the prayer, line 8) and a precise movement. The essay now knows where its evidence lies.

  2. The second choice. Syntax joins structure. The thesis promises to analyze the sentence, not only its content.

  3. The meaning, arguable. A reader could dispute it: some read the ending as peace rather than loss. A claim someone can argue with is one worth proving.

A thesis of this kind does three things the weaker attempts do not. It is specific to this poem, so it could not be pasted onto another. It joins a feature to a meaning in every clause. And it leaves the essay something to prove, because a reader could reasonably hold a different view.

Planning: lines of argument, not lines of text

About ten minutes go on the plan. Its job is to turn the thesis into three or four lines of argument, each with its evidence, in the order that builds the case. The plan for “Rain” in the diagram does not follow the poem from line 1 to line 18. Each branch draws on lines from different parts of the poem: the first sets line 5 beside line 16, the second line 8 beside lines 10 and 15.

Diagram: a plan as a tree. The guiding question on Rain at the top leads to a thesis, which branches into three lines of argument: one rain that washes and dissolves (lines 5, 16); a turn outward that finds the speaker again (lines 8, 10, 15); syntax that narrows love (lines 15 to 17).Diagram: a plan as a tree. The guiding question on Rain at the top leads to a thesis, which branches into three lines of argument: one rain that washes and dissolves (lines 5, 16); a turn outward that finds the speaker again (lines 8, 10, 15); syntax that narrows love (lines 15 to 17).
A plan for an essay on “Rain”. Each branch is a claim with its evidence, and each gathers lines from different parts of the poem.

A plan organized this way protects the essay from its commonest weakness. An essay that follows the passage in order has no reason to stop at one line rather than another, so it describes each in turn. An essay that follows its argument chooses its lines because they prove something, and it can set distant parts of the passage side by side, which is where much of the analysis happens.

The order of the three branches matters too. The plan moves from the image (one rain, two actions) to the structure (the turn) to the syntax (how the sentence narrows love). Each paragraph deepens the last, and the strongest point comes third, closest to the conclusion.

Try it

Write a thesis for the guiding question on “Hands”: How does the narrator use Wing Biddlebaum’s hands to present his relationship with the town?

One possible thesis: Anderson’s narrator treats Wing Biddlebaum’s hands as the whole man, so the town knows him only as a nervous gesture to mock. Freed in George Willard’s company, the same hands become “the piston rods of his machinery of expression” (paragraph 4), and the extract presents isolation as speech with nowhere to go. This thesis names the feature (the hands as a motif, the narrator’s announcements), the two settings in which they behave differently, and a meaning someone could dispute.

Paragraphs that analyze

Each branch of the plan becomes one body paragraph, and each analytical paragraph does four things in order. It opens with a topic sentence, a claim that states the paragraph’s part of the thesis. It brings in evidence as an integrated quotation, a few words worked into the grammar of the student’s own sentence. It explains the effect of the quoted choice, in at least two sentences. And it ends by linking the point back to the thesis, so the reader sees what the paragraph has added to the argument.

The paragraph that follows is built from the first branch of the plan for “Rain”. The notes say what each part is doing.

The rain in Thomas’s poem does two things that turn out to be one.note 1 At first it seems to offer comfort, since the speaker imagines it “washing me cleaner than I have been / Since I was born into this solitude”note 2 (lines 5–6). The comparative “cleaner” suggests a fresh start, almost a baptism, and the line break after “been” lets that hope hang for a moment before “solitude” closes it.note 3 Yet when the rain acts on him again near the end, it has not cleaned his loves but “dissolved” them (line 16). Washing and dissolving are the same action seen from two sides: whatever makes him clean also takes away everything he could hold. The image therefore prepares the poem’s final admission, since a speaker washed of every attachment has only death left to love.note 4

  1. Topic sentence. A claim, not a description, and one that the rest of the paragraph has to prove. It also announces the paragraph’s method: two moments of the poem read together.

  2. Integrated quotation. The quoted words run on from the student’s own clause, and the slash marks the line break. Nothing is quoted that the paragraph does not use.

  3. Effect. Two features (a comparative and a line break) are each tied to what they do in this poem. The next sentences then set line 5 beside line 16, the move a linear essay never makes.

  4. Link to the thesis. The paragraph’s point is connected to the essay’s claim about love and death, so the argument moves forward.

The order of the four parts is a starting point rather than a rule. A strong paragraph may analyze two quotations before it explains their effect together, as this one does with “cleaner” and “dissolved”. What stays fixed is the proportion: most of a good paragraph is explanation, and the quoted words are short enough to leave room for it.

Integrated quotation matters for two reasons. It keeps the evidence brief, so the marker sees exactly which words carry the point. And it keeps the student’s voice in control: the quoted words serve a sentence that is already making an argument, instead of standing alone and waiting for one.

The introduction

An introduction in Paper 1 has one job: to bring the reader to the thesis as quickly as the thesis can be understood. Three or four sentences are enough. The first places the passage (its form and situation, in a sentence), the next one or two say what the passage does, and the last states the thesis.

Two introductions to the same essay on “Rain” show what helps and what costs time:

Weak: Edward Thomas was a British poet who died in the First World War.note 1 In this essay I will analyze how the speaker’s attention moves from himself to others and the effect on the presentation of love.note 2 The poem uses many techniques such as repetition, simile and enjambment.note 3

Strong: In “Rain”, a speaker alone in a hut at night listens to the rain and thinks about his own death. The poem seems at first entirely turned inward, but at line 8 it opens into a prayer for others.note 4 That turn is an act of love; yet the long sentence that carries it brings the speaker’s sympathy back to himself, and ends in the admission that the only love the rain has left him is “the love of death”.note 5

  1. Outside the passage. A biographical fact the passage does not give. Even when true, it points the essay toward the war and away from the poem.

  2. The task restated. The guiding question copied back as a promise. It tells the marker nothing about what the student thinks.

  3. A list of devices. Three names with no claim attached; any poem could be described this way.

  4. The shape of the poem. One sentence locates the turn, so the essay’s structure is visible before the body begins.

  5. The thesis. It answers the guiding question with a claim about how and with what effect.

The strong version says less about the poet and more about the poem, and it reaches its claim in three sentences. Context belongs in an introduction only when the passage itself makes it matter. The date of “Rain” may support a reading of the “broken reeds” (lines 13–14) later in the essay. It is not the poem’s subject, and it does not open the essay.

The conclusion that judges

A conclusion that repeats the three topic sentences in a row adds nothing the marker has not read. A strong conclusion does something new: it judges. It says which of the choices analyzed matters most, what the passage achieves through them, and, where the passage allows more than one reading, which it finds stronger and why.

“Rain” never says that the speaker is lonely or that he despairs; its syntax does.note 1 The one movement outward, the prayer of line 8, is the poem’s only act of love for the living, and it is swallowed by a sentence that will not end until it has reached death. Whether that ending is despair or a kind of peace is left open: “perfect” and “Cannot … disappoint” (lines 17–18) sound like rest, but “If love it be” admits that the speaker is not sure.note 2 The poem’s achievement is to hold both at once, in a single breath that runs from prayer to confession.note 3

  1. A judgment of method. The conclusion decides which choice carries the most weight (the syntax) instead of listing all three paragraphs again.

  2. Two readings weighed. The student sets the peaceful reading beside the bleak one and grounds each in the words, without pretending the poem settles it.

  3. Evaluation. A last sentence on what the poem achieves, which is the judgment criterion B rewards at its top.

The conclusion is short, but every sentence in it is a claim. It also returns, in its last words, to the guiding question’s two parts: the movement of attention (“from prayer to confession”) and what that movement does to love.

How the four criteria are earned

A Paper 1 essay is marked on four assessment criteria, each out of 5, for 20 marks in all. Each criterion judges one quality of the essay, and each mark on it has a short description of the work that earns it. The marker reads the whole essay and, for each criterion, chooses the markband whose description fits it best. A strong essay therefore earns marks everywhere at once, but each criterion can still be practiced on its own.

Each pair of extracts that follows comes from two responses to “Rain” and its guiding question. One earns the marks the criterion offers; the other shows the kind of writing that stays low on it.

A: Understanding and interpretation

Criterion A asks whether the essay understands what the passage is doing beneath its surface, and supports each claim with the exact words. Retelling the passage accurately is where this criterion starts, not where it rewards. Above that, marks go to readings that see tension, change or ambiguity across the whole passage.

Low: The poem is about a man in a hut while it is raining. He thinks about dying and about the people he used to love. At the end he says that he loves death.note 1

High: The speaker’s prayer that nobody he loved is “lying still awake / Solitary, listening to the rain” (lines 9–10) imagines them in exactly his own position, so even his care for others is shaped by his solitude.note 2

  1. Retelling. Accurate, and every sentence is true, but none of it says why anything matters. It describes the surface and stops.

  2. Beneath the surface. A claim about what the prayer shows, anchored in the precise words (“Solitary” picks up the speaker’s “solitude”). This is the kind of reading criterion A rewards.

The difference is one of direction. The first extract reports what happens; the second notices a pattern in how it happens (the others are imagined in the speaker’s own posture) and draws a conclusion from it. Interpretation is a claim about meaning that the words support but do not state.

B: Analysis and evaluation

Criterion B asks how the writer’s choices make the meaning found under A, and how well they work. Choices include diction, imagery, syntax, structure, sound and form. Naming a choice earns almost nothing. Explaining what it does here earns the middle of the scale, and weighing one effect against another earns the top.

Low: Thomas uses repetition of the word “rain” and a simile in line 13, which create a sad atmosphere.note 1

High: The first line, “Rain, midnight rain, nothing but the wild rain”, gives the sentence no verb to carry it forward, so the speaker is held inside the sound as he is held inside the hut: the poem begins not with an action but with a condition.note 2

  1. Features named, effect general. Two features are identified and given one effect that would suit almost any sad poem.

  2. A choice explained. The repetition and the missing verb are tied to the speaker’s situation and to how the poem opens. The analysis is specific to these words.

The step from naming to explaining is the one most students need to take, and the step from explaining to weighing is what the top of B rewards. The table sets out the levels as a sequence of sentences about the same two lines of the poem. Each level keeps what the one before it does and adds something.

What the sentence does

A sentence on lines 13–14 of “Rain”

Names a feature

Line 13 contains a simile.

Describes it, with a general effect

The simile in line 13 creates a cold and sad image.

Explains its effect in this passage

Comparing the sleepless to “a cold water among broken reeds” sets them, still and chilled, among countless broken things, so the living lie among images of the dead.

Explains several choices together

The simile and the alliteration of “still and stiff” (line 14) make the reeds sound like bodies, so the prayer for the living slides toward the dead the speaker blessed in line 7.

Weighs the effect and judges it

The second simile, “Like me” (line 15), matters more than the first: having set the sleepless among the broken reeds, the speaker compares the reeds to himself, and the sentence that looked outward folds back on him. Sympathy and self-absorption are made by the same word.

The last row does what the others do not. It compares two choices and decides which carries more of the poem’s meaning, and it says why. That decision is evaluation, and it is rarer in Paper 1 essays than analysis, which is why it earns the top of the criterion.

C: Focus and organization

Criterion C asks whether the essay argues. It rewards a clear line of argument tied to the guiding question or the student’s own focus, paragraphs that build on one another, and quotations placed where they do work. The fastest way to see the difference is in the first sentences of paragraphs.

Low: In the next lines, lines 8 to 12, the speaker prays for the people he loved. He hopes they are not dying or lying awake.note 1

High: The prayer that opens line 8 is the poem’s one movement outward, and the rest of the sentence slowly draws it back.note 2

  1. Organized by the passage. The paragraph begins where the last one stopped in the poem. It announces a place, not a point, and goes on to retell.

  2. Organized by the argument. The topic sentence states a claim that develops the thesis and tells the reader what the paragraph will prove.

An essay whose paragraphs begin In the first stanza, In the next lines and At the end is following the passage, and its organization belongs to the poet, not to the student. An essay whose paragraphs begin with claims has an organization of its own, which is what criterion C marks.

D: Language

Criterion D asks whether the writing is clear, accurate and varied, in a register that suits an essay, with literary terms used precisely. It does not reward long words or ornate sentences. A student writing in a second language is not marked down for sounding like one; marks are lost when errors or vague wording blur the meaning.

Low: The speaker feels sad and the rain is used to show his feelings and it makes the reader feel the sadness of the speaker too because of the words.note 1

High: The speaker’s grief is never named; it is carried by the rain, which the first line repeats until the sentence has no room for anything else.note 2

  1. Vague and repetitive. “Feels sad”, “feelings”, “sadness” and “the words” circle one idea without making it precise. The sentence is grammatical, but it says little.

  2. Precise and controlled. One idea per clause, an exact verb (“carried”), and a claim about the syntax made in plain words.

The second sentence is not more difficult than the first. It is more exact: it chooses one word for each idea and puts the claim in the subject and verb. Clear, plain sentences with the right terms score well on D, and they make A, B and C easier to see.

A method for the 75 minutes

A student who chooses “Rain” might spend the time like this. The first five minutes go on reading both passages and both guiding questions and making the choice. The next fifteen go on three readings of the poem, pencil in hand, ending with the two connections (washing and dissolving; the prayer that finds the others in the speaker’s posture) that become the thesis. Ten minutes go on writing the thesis in full and building the three-branch plan.

That leaves 40 minutes to write, which is enough for an introduction of three or four sentences, three body paragraphs of about ten minutes each, and a conclusion. In that time most strong students write between 800 and 1,100 words: enough to analyze closely, not so many that the argument thins. The last five minutes go on checking. The student reads the thesis and the topic sentences one after another, to make sure they form one argument. Then the student checks every quotation and line number, and repairs any sentence whose meaning a marker could miss.

The diagram sets the plan out as a single bar. The striking thing about it is the first 30 minutes: two-fifths of the paper passes before the first sentence of the essay is written.

Diagram: a bar of 75 minutes divided into choose (0 to 5), read and annotate (5 to 20), plan (20 to 30), write (30 to 70: introduction, three or four paragraphs, conclusion) and check (70 to 75). The first 30 minutes come before any writing.Diagram: a bar of 75 minutes divided into choose (0 to 5), read and annotate (5 to 20), plan (20 to 30), write (30 to 70: introduction, three or four paragraphs, conclusion) and check (70 to 75). The first 30 minutes come before any writing.
One way to divide the 75 minutes of Paper 1 at SL. The proportions matter more than the exact minutes.

Set out as a list, the same plan reads:

  1. Minutes 0–5: read both passages and both guiding questions; choose.

  2. Minutes 5–20: read the chosen passage three times and annotate it.

  3. Minutes 20–30: write the thesis and plan three or four lines of argument with their evidence.

  4. Minutes 30–70: write the introduction, the body paragraphs and the conclusion.

  5. Minutes 70–75: check the argument, the quotations and the line numbers.

The minutes are a guide and can move. A student who reads quickly can plan for longer, and one whose first language is not English might take a few more minutes to read and fewer to check. What should not move is the order, and the protected 30 minutes before writing. Students who start writing after five minutes usually finish their reading in the middle of the second paragraph, and the essay shows it.

Where marks are lost

The faults that cost most marks in Paper 1 have something in common: each puts something other than the passage’s words at the center of the sentence. A list of devices puts the features there, a retelling puts the events there, a paragraph on the war puts the topic there. The table shows six of them on sentences about “Rain”, each with a correction.

Fault

Weak sentence

Corrected

Listing devices

The poem uses repetition, simile, enjambment and allusion.

The echo of a biblical blessing in line 7, “Blessed are the dead”, lifts the poem from private thought into prayer, and prepares the prayer for the living that follows.

Retelling

Then the speaker says he prays that the people he loved are not dying.

The verb “pray” (line 8) is the first main verb the speaker gives himself, and it is an action on behalf of others.

Writing about the topic

War caused terrible suffering, and many soldiers died in 1916.

The poem never names the war; it enters only as an image of countless dead, the “Myriads of broken reeds all still and stiff” (line 14).

Quoting the question back

The speaker’s attention moves from himself to others, and this affects the presentation of love.

The one time the speaker looks outward, at line 8, is the one time his love is directed at the living.

“The reader”, in general

This makes the reader feel sad.

The missing main verb of lines 1–6 leaves a reader waiting for an action that never comes, which matches the speaker’s helplessness.

A vague tone word

The tone is emotional.

The tone is restrained grief: the speaker names his death calmly, “that I shall die” (line 3), and keeps every exclamation out of the poem.

Each correction does the same thing. It quotes or locates the words, and it says what they do in this poem. None of the corrections is longer than the weak sentence by much; they are better because they are about the passage.

Two further faults are about time rather than sentences. An unfinished essay, with no conclusion and a last paragraph that stops mid-thought, loses marks on C however strong its first half. And an essay that runs out of evidence after two paragraphs usually began writing too early, before the third reading had found the connections that a third paragraph needs.

A response in full

The response that follows was written to the task on “Rain” used throughout, with its guiding question: How does the speaker’s attention move from himself to others, and with what effect on the poem’s presentation of love? The task gave one line of context, that the poem was written in 1916 while Thomas was training as a soldier. It is a strong response written in the time, not a polished critical essay, and its margin comments note what it does well and where it falls short.

Exemplar · High band17 of 20 marks

Paper 1: “Rain”, a high-band response

On Rain

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The response scores 17 out of 20, which is typical of an excellent essay written under time. It does not score 20, and the reasons are useful. Its analysis of the poem’s sound and line is thin, one paragraph still walks through lines 1 to 6 in order, and the conclusion begins by repeating the thesis. None of these is a serious fault; each is the kind of slip that speed produces, and each costs a mark on one criterion.

What lifts it into the top band is visible in almost every paragraph. It sets distant lines side by side (washing in line 5, dissolving in line 16), it decides which choice matters most and says why, and it treats the poem’s ending as open while still taking a position. Those three habits can be practiced on any passage.

Where to practice

The question bank’s Paper 1 practice holds unseen passages of all four literary forms, each with a guiding question, marking notes, and three marked responses to set beside your own. Working one passage a week under the full 75 minutes, then comparing your essay with the responses at each band, is the closest practice to the paper itself.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what Paper 1 at SL asks: one guided literary analysis of one of two unseen passages, in 75 minutes, out of 20.

  • To do:

    I can choose between two passages in five minutes by testing which one gives me three arguable claims.

  • To do:

    I can read an unseen passage three times and annotate it with patterns, questions and claims.

  • To do:

    I can turn a guiding question into a specific, arguable thesis and plan three lines of argument that cut across the passage.

  • To do:

    I can write a paragraph with a topic sentence, integrated quotations, an explained effect and a link to the thesis.

  • To do:

    I can write an introduction that reaches the thesis quickly and a conclusion that judges.

  • To do:

    I can say what each of the four criteria rewards and correct the commonest faults in my own sentences.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Assessment criterion

One of the separate scales on which a piece of assessed work is marked. Each criterion judges one quality of the work and sets out what the work does at each mark on the scale.

Guided literary analysis

The task of Paper 1 in English A: Literature: an argued essay on an unseen literary passage, written in answer to its guiding question or to a focus the student sets. It explains how the passage makes its meaning rather than retelling what it says.

Integrated quotation

A short quotation worked into the grammar of the writer’s own sentence, so that the quoted words and the analysis read as one sentence. It keeps evidence brief and keeps the writer’s argument in control of it.

Thesis

The central claim an essay argues, stated early and developed by every paragraph that follows. In literary analysis it says what a text means and how its choices make that meaning, in a form that a reader could dispute.

Topic sentence

The sentence, usually the first of a paragraph, that states the paragraph’s point and shows how it advances the essay’s thesis. Everything else in the paragraph supports or develops it.

Unseen passage

A literary passage that a student reads for the first time in the examination room, with no notes and no earlier study of it. Because the passage cannot be prepared, it tests a way of reading rather than knowledge of a particular work.

Exam skills for English A Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SLThis page
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.