Paper 2: the comparative essay

How Paper 2 works: the kinds of general question, choosing a question and two works, the comparative thesis, point-by-point structure, what each of the five criteria rewards, and a full response.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

33 min readLast reviewed

Paper 2 tests whether you know two works well enough to set them against each other, from memory, in answer to a question you have not seen. The skill it rewards is comparison: an argument in which each work makes the other clearer. The method that follows is worked through on one pair, Kate Chopin’s novel The Awakening (1899) and Tennessee Williams’s play A Streetcar Named Desire (1947). Both are set in New Orleans, half a century apart, and both end with a woman leaving the life around her.

She thought of Léonce and the children. They were a part of her life. But they need not have thought that they could possess her, body and soul.

Kate Chopin, The Awakening (1899), chapter XXXIX

These sentences come from the last page of The Awakening, as Edna Pontellier swims out into the Gulf of Mexico. A Paper 2 essay cannot quote at this length, since no books are allowed in the room. It can do something harder: remember that the novel’s last thoughts are Edna’s own, given in the narrator’s voice, and compare that with a play whose heroine is led off the stage while other people watch. That contrast between a mind given from inside and a body seen from outside is what a strong Paper 2 essay is built on.

What the paper asks

The paper gives you four general questions about literature. None of them names a work, an author or a period, and no texts are printed. You choose one question and answer it in a comparative essay on two works you have studied in class, of the same form or of different forms. You write from memory, in 1 hour and 45 minutes. The essay is marked out of 25, on five criteria worth 5 marks each.

Standard and higher level sit exactly the same paper: the same four questions, the same time, the same criteria. Only the weight differs. Paper 2 is 35% of the final grade at SL and 25% at HL, where the HL essay adds a fourth component. The questions are written so that almost any pair of works can answer one of them, which means the paper rewards knowing your works in depth, not guessing the topics.

A comparative essay is not two short essays printed one after the other. Its argument depends on both works at once. A claim about Edna’s swim becomes interesting only when it is set beside Blanche DuBois’s exit, and the reverse is just as true. The method below builds that kind of essay, step by step.

Which works you may use

You may use any two works studied in class. Schools usually keep the works for Paper 2, the individual oral and the HL essay apart. The exact rule on reusing a work across components is not one to assume, so check with your teacher which works you may use where, early in the second year. Most students then prepare three works for Paper 2, so that a poor match between one work and the questions does not leave them without a pair.

Four general questions, seven kinds

A general question asks how writers do something, or what works do, rather than what you think about a social problem. Some questions open with a short statement and then ask about it; others ask directly. Across many papers, the questions fall into a small number of kinds, and recognizing the kind tells you what the essay must do. The table sets out seven kinds, each with an invented example written for this book in the style of the paper.

Kind of question

What it asks you to compare

An invented example

Method

How writers use one technique or element: setting, an object, time, an opening or ending, a minor character

In what ways do two works you have studied use food, meals or hunger, and to what effect?

Character and relationship

How works present a kind of person or bond, always with the methods that present it

Compare how two works you have studied present a friendship that one of the friends betrays.

Reader and audience

How works shape sympathy, judgment or expectation

How do two works you have studied make the reader or audience share in a character’s wrongdoing?

Concept-led

An idea close to identity, perspective, transformation or representation

“A person is what others agree to believe about them.” Discuss how two works you have studied present a character whose identity is decided by other people.

Evaluative

A claim about literature, to be tested and qualified

“Endings punish those who break the rules.” To what extent is this true of two works you have studied?

Form-aware

How the form of each work shapes what it can show

Compare how the form of two works you have studied shapes the way a secret is kept and then revealed.

Context

How works present a time, place or society

In what ways do two works you have studied show a community deciding who belongs to it?

Every kind asks how as well as what, even when the wording hides it. A character question about betrayed friendship is not answered by describing two betrayals; it asks how each work presents one, through its narrator, its structure, its staging or its images. An evaluative question is answered by testing the statement on both works, so the strongest answers usually agree with it in part and show where it fails.

The kinds overlap, and one question can belong to two. The question on endings is evaluative, but it is also a method question, because an ending is a structural choice. Reading the kind is a way of reading the task.

Seeing the difference matters most when a question uses a word you have studied as a topic. Many classes spend weeks on power, family or identity, and a question that contains one of those words looks like an invitation to write what was learned. It is an invitation to use that knowledge, but only after the question has turned it into a claim about how the works are written.

The habit that prevents this is slow reading of the question itself. Mark its command term or question words first (compare, discuss, in what ways, to what extent), then the feature or concern it names, then any word that limits the evidence, such as final, minor or a moment of. Each marked word becomes something the plan must answer.

Choosing a question in the first minutes

You have about fifteen minutes to read the four questions, choose one and plan the essay. The choice comes first, and it decides more of the final mark than any sentence you write later. Read all four questions before you settle on one, even if the first looks perfect. The question that seems written for your favorite work is often the one that tempts you into a prepared essay.

Suppose the four questions on the paper include this one:

In what ways and to what effect do two works you have studied use a character’s final departure to judge the world that character leaves?

An invented Paper 2 question

A student who has prepared The Awakening, A Streetcar Named Desire and a third work tests each question with one fast check. For each question, can they name two works and say in a sentence how the works answer it differently? For this question the sentence comes at once. Edna Pontellier leaves by her own choice, walking into the sea; Blanche DuBois is taken away to an asylum by a doctor and a matron while the men play cards. One departure is chosen and one is imposed, and each says something different about the world left behind.

Reading the question’s key words

Before planning, the student marks the words that set the task. In what ways asks for several methods, not one, so the essay needs three or four distinct points. To what effect asks what those methods achieve, so every point must end in a meaning. Final departure fixes the evidence: the endings, and the moments that prepare them. Judge the world is the hardest phrase and the most useful. It asks what the departure says about the society, the family or the men the character leaves, so an essay that only describes two sad endings has answered half the question.

Reading the question this way also shows what to leave out. Chopin’s life and the novel’s hostile reception in 1899 are interesting, but the question does not ask about them, and a paragraph on either would cost focus. One sentence of context is useful only where it sharpens a point about the works, for example that Edna’s refusal of motherhood would have shocked a reader of 1899.

Choosing the two works

The best pair for a question is the one that gives the sharpest difference on the same point, not the one with the most in common. The Awakening and Streetcar share a city, a period of decline in Southern society and a heroine at odds with it. What makes them a strong pair for this question is that they answer it in opposite ways and through different forms. A novel can follow Edna’s thoughts into the water; a play can only show Blanche being led out, and let the audience judge the people who watch her go.

Two works of different forms are often a good pair, because the difference of form is itself a point of comparison. Two works of the same form can be just as strong if they handle the question differently, for example two novels whose narrators judge their heroines in opposite ways. A weak pair shares a subject and nothing else. Two novels “about war” leave the essay with little to compare once both plots have been told.

The third prepared work is insurance. If the question had asked about a character who keeps a secret, the student might have paired Streetcar with the third work instead, since Blanche’s past is the play’s secret and The Awakening has none of the same kind. Preparing three works means that at least two of them will fit almost any question well.

The comparative thesis

A comparative thesis is the claim that the whole essay argues, stated in terms of both works. It answers the question, it says how the two works differ or agree, and it names the methods that make the difference. Like the thesis of a Paper 1 essay, it ends the introduction and gives each paragraph its purpose. Unlike it, it has to hold two works in one sentence without letting either become a footnote to the other.

Three attempts on the departure question show what a comparative thesis must do. The first states a likeness that any reader of the two works could see: Both Edna and Blanche leave at the end of their works, which proves that society treats women badly. It compares only subjects, and its conclusion is about society in general rather than the works. The second describes each work in turn: In The Awakening Edna swims into the sea, and in Streetcar Blanche is sent to an asylum. It is accurate, but it says nothing about how or to what effect. The third argues:

Both works end by removing a woman from a world that has no place for her,note 1 but Chopin lets Edna choose her departure and gives it from inside her mind, while Williams stages Blanche’s removal as something done to her in front of witnesses.note 2 The novel therefore judges Edna’s world by what she refuses, and the play judges Blanche’s by what it allows.note 3

  1. The shared ground. A likeness stated precisely enough to compare on: both endings remove a woman, and both ask why.

  2. The difference, with methods. Choice against force, and a narrator’s access to a mind against a stage that shows a body. The essay now knows its points.

  3. The effect, for both works. The thesis answers “judge the world” for each work, and the parallel phrasing makes the contrast a claim that can be argued.

A thesis of this kind does three jobs at once. It names the point on which the works will be compared, it states the difference that matters, and it says what that difference shows about each work. It is also arguable. A student could reply that Edna’s swim is not a free choice at all, since the novel suggests her world left her no other. The thesis can absorb that objection in a later paragraph, and the essay is stronger for it.

The thesis also fixes the order of the essay’s two works. Whichever work it names first is usually discussed first in each paragraph, which gives the reader a steady rhythm to follow. Some students reverse the order in their strongest paragraph, so that the second work opens it. Done once and on purpose, the change signals an essay led by its points, not by the habit of always starting with the same book.

Try it

Write a comparative thesis for the context question in the table of question kinds: In what ways do two works you have studied show a community deciding who belongs to it? Use any two works you know, or use Streetcar and one other.

One possible thesis, on Streetcar and The Awakening: Both works show a community closing ranks against a woman who does not fit. Williams makes the decision collective and visible, as the poker players and Stella accept Blanche’s removal, whereas Chopin makes it quiet and inward, a set of expectations Edna feels most when no one is there to enforce them. A good answer names the shared ground (a community deciding), the difference (how the decision is made and shown) and the methods (staging against narration).

The shape of a comparative essay

There are two ways to organize a comparison, and the choice between them decides how much comparison the essay contains. In block structure, the essay discusses one work in full and then the other, and compares them in a linking paragraph and the conclusion. In point-by-point structure, each body paragraph takes one point of comparison and discusses both works on it. The diagram sets the two skeletons side by side and marks where comparison happens in each.

Two essay skeletons. Block structure: introduction, work A in two blocks, a link beginning Similarly, work B, conclusion; comparison happens only at the link and the conclusion.Two essay skeletons. Block structure: introduction, work A in two blocks, a link beginning Similarly, work B, conclusion; comparison happens only at the link and the conclusion.
Block structure compares in two places; point-by-point structure compares in every paragraph.

In the block essay, the reader meets The Awakening for half the essay and Streetcar for the other half. By the time Blanche’s exit is discussed, Edna’s swim is two pages back, and the comparison depends on the reader’s memory. In the point-by-point essay, the two endings sit in the same paragraph and are measured against the same question. Comparison is not added at the joins; it is how each paragraph is built.

Point-by-point structure is what criterion B2 most clearly rewards, because the comparison is visible in every paragraph. It is also harder to write, since each paragraph must be planned around a point that genuinely applies to both works. That is the reason to plan points, not works, in the first fifteen minutes.

When a modified block can work

A pure block essay rarely reaches the top of B2. A modified block can, if each half is built for the comparison from the start. In this shape, the paragraphs on the second work refer back to the first at every step (where Edna’s thoughts are given from inside, Blanche’s are never heard directly) and the conclusion argues rather than lists. Some students use it for a question that asks how one work changes the reading of another. For most questions, point-by-point structure is safer, because it makes forgetting the first work impossible.

A plan built on points

The plan for the departure question takes the comparative thesis and divides it into four points. Each point is a place where both works can be compared on method, and the order builds from the endings themselves toward what they say about each world.

1. The endings.note 1 Edna walks into the sea alone, her thoughts given by the narrator to the last sentence; Blanche is led out by a doctor, and her last line, “I have always depended on the kindness of strangers”, is spoken to the man taking her away. Choice against force.

2. Confinement and space.note 2 The summer cottage on Grand Isle, the family house on Esplanade Street and the small “pigeon house” Edna moves into; the two cramped rooms of the Kowalski flat, divided by a curtain, where Blanche has nowhere to be alone. One heroine leaves a house; the other is never given one.

3. The body and desire.note 3 The sea’s “soft, close embrace”, Edna swimming and, at the end, naked under the sky; Blanche’s hot baths, her fear of bright light, Stanley’s violence. A body that is freed against a body that is hidden and then attacked.

4. How the reader is placed.note 4 Chopin’s narrator, close to Edna, corrects her husband’s view of her; Williams leaves the audience to watch Stella choose Stanley and the card game go on. The novel lets the reader inside the departure; the play makes the audience a witness to it.

  1. The question’s own ground first. Each point is a claim, and the first answers the question most directly.

  2. Setting as method. The point compares how each work uses space, as well as where it is set.

  3. One quotation from each work. Short and remembered; enough to anchor the point.

  4. The strongest point last. Narration against staging, the difference of form, which the conclusion can turn into a judgment of each world.

Each line of the plan already compares. None says “Edna” or “Blanche” alone, and each ends on a contrast that the paragraph will explain. The plan also shows where the two halves of the question sit. Points 1 and 3 answer in what ways, and every point leads toward to what effect: what each departure says about the world it leaves.

The fourth point is the one only a comparison of different forms can make. A narrator can enter Edna’s mind on the last page; a play cannot enter Blanche’s at all, except through what the stage lets the audience hear. Williams uses that limit, since in scene 11 the polka Blanche hears after her husband’s death returns, a sound only she and the audience can hear. That detail lets the paragraph show that each writer turns the limits of a form into a judgment.

The voice of the sea is seductive; never ceasing, whispering, clamoring, murmuring, inviting the soul to wander for a spell in abysses of solitude …

Kate Chopin, The Awakening, chapter VI (repeated, with small changes, in chapter XXXIX)

A student who remembers that this sentence appears twice, early in the novel and again on its last page, has a piece of evidence for point 4 that no plot summary provides. The narrator repeats a sentence about the sea’s invitation, so the ending reads as an answer to a call the novel set up long before. A stage has no equivalent of a narrator’s repeated sentence, but Williams repeats a tune instead, and the comparison of the two repetitions is exactly the kind of method comparison the plan was built to reach.

How the five criteria are earned

The marker reads the whole essay and gives a mark out of 5 on each of the five criteria. Each criterion judges one quality, so a strong essay earns marks on all five at once, but each can be practiced on its own. The pairs of extracts come from two responses to the departure question on The Awakening and Streetcar. In each pair, one extract earns the marks the criterion offers and one stays low on it.

A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation

Criterion A asks whether you know both works in detail and use that knowledge to build an interpretation that answers this question. Accurate plot is where it starts. Above that, marks go to a reading that sees what the works are doing beneath their events, supported by precise references to particular moments.

Low: At the end of The Awakening, Edna goes to Grand Isle and drowns herself in the sea. She has had an affair with Arobin and Robert has left her. In Streetcar, Blanche is raped by Stanley and taken to a mental hospital.note 1

High: Edna’s thoughts in the water turn to a childhood “blue-grass meadow” that seemed to have “no beginning and no end”, and the novel closes on sounds from that childhood, so it presents her departure less as despair over a lover than as a return to the only freedom she has known.note 2

  1. Plot, and the wrong emphasis. Accurate and in order, but every sentence reports an event, and the question about judging a world is never touched.

  2. Knowledge used to interpret. A precise, remembered detail from the last page supports a reading that someone could argue with.

The second extract knows less of the plot and more of the work. It has chosen one moment because it changes how the ending can be read, and it says what that moment means. Interpretation, under A, is a claim about meaning that the work supports but does not state.

B1: Analysis of textual features and authorial choices

Criterion B1 is the skill of Paper 1 applied from memory to two whole works. It asks how each writer’s choices make the meanings found under A: narrative voice, structure, characterization, setting, imagery, staging, form. Because the texts are not in the room, analysis often works through precise reference to a moment or a pattern rather than through a long quotation.

Low: Williams uses a lot of symbolism in Streetcar, for example the lantern and the music, which helps the audience understand Blanche.note 1

High: Williams makes Blanche’s paper lantern the play’s image of her need for concealment: the bare bulb is covered in scene 3, and when Mitch tears the lantern off in scene 9 to see her clearly, exposure becomes an act of cruelty.note 2

  1. Features named, effect vague. Two choices are identified and given one effect that would suit any symbol in any play.

  2. A choice explained across the work. The lantern is followed from its first appearance to its destruction, and its meaning is tied to the play’s structure.

The step up from the first extract to the second is the step from naming to tracing. A symbol in a whole work is not a single moment but a pattern, and remembering where it appears, and how it changes, is what lets an essay analyze it without the book.

B2: Comparative analysis

Criterion B2 asks whether comparison drives the essay. It rewards essays that set the works against each other point by point, on how they work as well as what they say, and that say what the contrast shows about each. Two separate essays joined by “similarly” sit at the bottom of B2. A comparison of events, characters and themes only sits in the middle.

Low: Edna dies at the end of the novel. Similarly, Blanche’s life is also ruined at the end of the play. Both women are victims of society.note 1

High: Chopin gives Edna’s last minutes from inside her mind, so the reader shares her refusal of the people who “need not have thought that they could possess her”;note 2 Williams can give Blanche no such inner voice, and instead makes the audience watch Stella let her sister be taken, so the play judges its world through the people who stay.note 3

  1. Comparison by link word. “Similarly” joins two events; the shared conclusion about society needs neither work.

  2. Method in the first work. Narration from inside a mind, with a remembered phrase.

  3. Method in the second, set against the first. The difference of form is turned into a difference of judgment. This is what B2 rewards at the top.

The full account of B2 and of the comparative paragraph that earns it is part of the skill of comparing two works. What matters here is that B2 is earned in sentences like the second extract, where both works appear and each makes the other clearer.

C: Focus and organization

Criterion C asks whether the essay argues one line in answer to the question, in an order that builds, with paragraphs that connect. In Paper 2 it also asks whether the two works are kept in balance from beginning to end. An essay whose second work fades in its last two paragraphs loses on C as well as on B2.

Low: Another way the works are similar is the setting. Both works take place in New Orleans, which was a very lively city.note 1

High: If the endings show one departure chosen and one imposed, the settings show why: Chopin gives Edna a house of her own to leave, while Williams never gives Blanche a room with a door.note 2

  1. A new topic added with “another”. The point is not connected to the thesis or to the question, and the comment on the city is off the task.

  2. A paragraph that builds. The topic sentence links back to the previous point and forward to the question of judging each world.

D: Language

Criterion D asks whether the writing is clear, accurate and varied, in an academic register, with literary terms used precisely. For a comparative essay, precision includes naming the form correctly. Streetcar is a play with an audience, scenes and stage directions; calling it a “book” or its audience “the reader” is a small error that a marker notices.

Low: In the book Streetcar, the reader feels very sad for Blanche because of all the bad things that happen to her and it is very tragic.note 1

High: By ending the play on the card game, with the line “This game is seven-card stud”, Williams leaves the audience in the same room as the men who have already forgotten her.note 2

  1. Wrong form, vague register. “Book” and “reader” misname the play; “very sad” and “very tragic” say nothing precise.

  2. Precise terms, controlled sentence. The form is named correctly, the remembered line is integrated, and the effect is stated exactly.

The five criteria are not separate tasks to be done in turn. A single good sentence can earn on all five at once. It shows knowledge of a moment (A) and explains a choice (B1). It sets that choice against the other work (B2) and moves the argument forward (C), in clear and precise English (D). The high extracts in each pair are sentences of that kind.

The cure is to plan each paragraph around a comparison of methods, then to make sure the knowledge serves it. Knowledge chosen for a point earns on A; knowledge recited because it was learned does not.

A method for the time

One hour and 45 minutes feels long until the essay is half written. The time is best divided before the paper starts, so that no decision about it has to be made under pressure. The student answering the departure question spends it like this.

In the first five minutes they read all four questions slowly, marking the key words of each, and test each with the one-sentence check: two works, and a difference. By minute 15 they have chosen the question, chosen The Awakening and Streetcar, written the comparative thesis in full, and listed four points with one or two remembered details from each work beside each point. The plan takes ten minutes, and it is the most valuable ten minutes of the paper. An essay that is planned point by point writes itself; an essay that is not drifts back into one work at a time.

The writing takes about 80 minutes. The introduction is short: one sentence that reframes the question, one that introduces the two works by title, writer and form, and the thesis. Each of the four points gets about 15 to 18 minutes, and the student glances at the clock at the end of each. At minute 55 they should be in the middle of the second or third point; if they are still on the first, the remaining points must be shorter, not dropped. The conclusion takes five minutes and judges: it says what reading the two departures together shows about each work.

The last ten minutes go on checking. The student rereads the thesis and each topic sentence first, to make sure the argument holds, then checks titles, names and the spelling of characters, and corrects any sentence where “the reader” should be “the audience”. Ten minutes is not enough to rewrite a paragraph, but it is enough to add a missing comparative sentence at the end of one.

The plan as a list, for practice under time:

  1. Minutes 0 to 5: read all four questions; mark the key words in each.

  2. Minutes 5 to 15: choose the question and the pair; write the comparative thesis; plan four points, each with evidence from both works.

  3. Minutes 15 to 95: write the introduction, four comparative paragraphs and a conclusion that judges, checking the time after each point.

  4. Minutes 95 to 105: check the thesis and topic sentences, the names and titles, and the terms for each form.

The diagram shows the same plan as a single bar, with the checkpoint at minute 55. The proportions matter more than the exact minutes. Planning takes about a seventh of the time, writing about three quarters, and checking the rest.

A bar of 105 minutes divided into three parts: choose and plan (15 minutes), write the introduction, four points and conclusion (80 minutes), and check (10 minutes). A dashed line at minute 55 marks the halfway point of the writing.A bar of 105 minutes divided into three parts: choose and plan (15 minutes), write the introduction, four points and conclusion (80 minutes), and check (10 minutes). A dashed line at minute 55 marks the halfway point of the writing.
The 105 minutes of Paper 2, with a checkpoint at minute 55.

Where marks are lost

The commonest faults in Paper 2 essays are few, and each has a fix that can be practiced. Each row of the table shows a fault in a sentence from a response to the departure question, and a corrected version of the same sentence.

Fault

The sentence

Corrected

Two essays stapled together

“That is everything about Edna. Now I will discuss Blanche.”

Plan points, not works: each paragraph discusses both women’s departures on one point.

Comparing content only

“Both women are unhappy in their marriages or relationships.”

“Chopin narrates Edna’s unhappiness from inside, while Williams shows Blanche’s only through what she hides from others.”

A prepared question

“Women in the nineteenth century had few rights, and both works show this.”

Begin from the question’s words: “Each departure judges the world it leaves, but in a different way.”

A memorized quotation that does not fit

“Blanche says, ‘I don’t want realism. I want magic!’, which shows her final departure.”

Use the line where it proves something: it explains why Blanche hides from light, not how she leaves.

The second work fades

A final paragraph that discusses only The Awakening.

Check the plan: every point has evidence from both works, and the conclusion judges both.

Context in place of analysis

“Chopin was criticized when the novel came out, and she stopped writing novels.”

Keep context to a clause that sharpens a point about the text, or leave it out.

The faults share a cause. Each one moves the essay away from the question and toward what the student happens to know: a plot, a line, a fact about a writer. A strong essay knows just as much and uses only what this question needs.

The second work fading deserves a further word, because it happens to good essays. A student who knows one work better often writes more about it, and by the last paragraph the weaker work has shrunk to a sentence. The fix is in the plan. If each point has its evidence from both works written beside it before the essay starts, the balance is decided before the pressure arrives.

A conclusion of this kind can be short. Three or four sentences that state the pair’s finding, weigh it against the strongest objection and end on the question’s own words are enough, and they leave time for checking.

A response in full

The response answers the departure question on The Awakening and Streetcar. It was written to show what a strong essay looks like in 1 hour and 45 minutes from memory, not a polished critical article. Its margin comments note what it does well and where it falls short, criterion by criterion.

Exemplar · High band21 of 25 marks

Paper 2: two departures, a high-band response

On The Awakening, A Streetcar Named Desire

The response and its mark on each of 5 criteriaRead it with a free account

The response scores 21 out of 25. It earns full marks on B2 because comparison is the way each paragraph is built, not something added at its end. Its four points move from what happens to how it is prepared and then to what each form allows, so the essay develops as it goes. The marks it loses come from the kind of slips speed produces: a claim without evidence, a turning point named in a clause, a conclusion written with too little time left.

Planning a response to a general question in 15 minutes, with two of your own works, is the most useful practice there is, and it can be done often. Writing a full essay under the full time once a month shows whether the plan survives the clock.

Paper 2 rests on two further skills. One is comparison itself, how a paragraph moves between two works and what makes a contrast tell the reader something about each. The other is preparation, knowing a work well enough to analyze its methods without the book.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what Paper 2 asks: one comparative essay on two works studied, from one of four general questions, in 1 hour 45 minutes without the texts.

  • To do:

    I can recognize the kind of a general question and say what it asks me to compare.

  • To do:

    I can choose a question and the two works that give the sharpest difference on it, using a one-sentence test.

  • To do:

    I can write a comparative thesis that names both works’ methods and the difference that matters.

  • To do:

    I can plan a point-by-point essay in which every paragraph compares both works.

  • To do:

    I can say what each of the five criteria rewards and correct the commonest faults in my own sentences.

  • To do:

    I can divide the 105 minutes so that the plan, the essay and the check each get their share.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lit glossary.

Block structure

A way of organizing a comparison that discusses one work in full and then the other, leaving most of the comparing to the links between the halves and to the conclusion.

Comparative essay

An essay that answers one question by setting two works against each other, so that its argument depends on what each work shows about the other. In Paper 2 it is written from memory, without the texts.

Comparative thesis

The central claim of a comparative essay: how two works answer the question, and which likeness or difference between them matters most. A strong one names the works' methods as well as their meanings.

Paper 2 question

One of the four general questions set in Paper 2. Each names no work and asks how writers handle a feature, a kind of character, a relationship or a concern, so that many pairs of works studied can answer it.

Point-by-point structure

A way of organizing a comparative essay in which each body paragraph takes one point of comparison and discusses both works on it, so the comparison runs through every paragraph.

Exam skills for English A Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essayThis page
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.