The HL essay

What the HL essay asks, how it differs from a Paper 2 essay, what each of its four criteria rewards, and the rules on length, sources and citation that every HL essay must meet.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

21 min readLast reviewed

The HL essay is a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words in which you follow a question of your own about one literary work or one non-literary body of work studied in class. You write it over several months, with time to read, research and redraft, and the IB marks it. Its worth comes from the question it pursues: an essay that asks something precise about how a work makes meaning can be answered in depth in 1,500 words. The opening of a strong essay on James Joyce’s Dubliners (1914), a collection of fifteen stories set in Dublin, shows the whole task in miniature.

How does Joyce use windows in Dubliners to present characters who watch a life they cannot enter, and how far does “The Dead” change that pattern?note 1

Again and again in Dubliners, a character stands at a window. The boy of “The Sisters” studies “the lighted square of window” (Joyce 9) where a priest is dying; Eveline sits “at the window watching the evening invade the avenue” (42); Little Chandler turns from his desk “to gaze out of the office window” (85).note 2 The window lets each of them see the life outside while keeping them out of it, and most of the stories leave them behind the glass. This essay argues that Joyce makes the window the collection’s image of watching instead of living, and that “The Dead” changes the pattern only partly: Gabriel’s gaze at last travels out over the whole country, but he himself stays in the room.note 3

  1. The line as the title. The question names the work, a feature of the writing (windows) and a concern (watching instead of living). Its second half can be answered “partly”, which leaves room to argue.

  2. Evidence from across the work. Three stories in one sentence show at once that the feature recurs. Each quotation is short, worked into the sentence and cited by page.

  3. An answer, not a promise. The thesis gives the essay’s answer before the evidence arrives, including the limit the last section will test.

The extract is short, but it already does what the whole essay must do. It asks one question about one work, answers it, and shows from the work’s own words why the question is worth asking. The rest of the essay develops that answer story by story, and the pages on finding a line of inquiry and on structuring the essay build this same essay from first idea to finished plan.

What the HL essay asks

The facts are few and fixed. The HL essay is 1,200 to 1,500 words long. It develops a line of inquiry into one work: either one literary work or one non-literary body of work that you have studied in class. It is coursework, so you write it over weeks or months rather than in an exam room, and you have the work beside you while you write. It is marked externally by the IB, not by your teacher, out of 20 marks on four criteria of 5 marks each. It makes up 20% of your final HL grade.

The four criteria are A, Knowledge, understanding and interpretation; B, Analysis and evaluation; C, Focus, organization and development; and D, Language. These are the names the IB has used for the HL essay until now. Check the current wording with your teacher, since the descriptions of each criterion are what an examiner reads your essay against.

Nothing in the essay is set for you. There is no prompt to answer and no list of questions to choose from. You choose the work, the question and the evidence, and the examiner judges how well the essay you build answers the question you set. That freedom is the essay’s main difficulty, because a poorly chosen question limits every criterion before a sentence is written.

The diagram traces the stages from a work to the plan of an essay, using the Dubliners essay as the example. A work suggests a topic; the topic is narrowed into a line of inquiry; the line is answered by a thesis; the thesis is developed across sections. Most weak HL essays stop at the second stage and write about a topic.

Diagram in five stages from top to bottom: Work (Dubliners), Topic (paralysis in Dubliners), Line of inquiry (how Joyce uses windows to present characters who watch a life they cannot enter), Thesis (the glass holds most of them in; The Dead lets the gaze go out but not the man), Sections (four…Diagram in five stages from top to bottom: Work (Dubliners), Topic (paralysis in Dubliners), Line of inquiry (how Joyce uses windows to present characters who watch a life they cannot enter), Thesis (the glass holds most of them in; The Dead lets the gaze go out but not the man), Sections (four…
From a work to an essay plan: each stage narrows the one before. The essay is written from the last three.

A topic against a line of inquiry

A topic names a subject, such as gender in A Doll’s House or paralysis in Dubliners. A line of inquiry asks how the work makes meaning, in a question small enough to answer fully in 1,500 words and still open to argument. The difference is easiest to see on a moment of a work. In Act II of Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House (1879), Nora rehearses the tarantella, a dance she will perform at a party, while her husband Helmer watches. William Archer’s translation gives the stage direction:

Rank sits down to the piano and plays; Nora dances more and more wildly. Helmer stands by the stove and addresses frequent corrections to her; she seems not to hear. Her hair breaks loose, and falls over her shoulders.

Henrik Ibsen, A Doll’s House, Act II, trans. William Archer (1890)

An essay on the topic of gender in A Doll’s House could use this direction as one example among many: Nora is controlled by her husband, and here he corrects even her dancing. The point is true, and it could be made from almost any scene. A line of inquiry starts from the direction itself. How does Ibsen use stage directions for Nora’s body (the dance, the loosened hair, the change of dress) to show a performance of the obedient wife breaking down before she says so? asks about a feature of the writing and gives the essay something to test in every act.

The topic tells an examiner what the essay is about. The line of inquiry tells them what it will find out, and which evidence it needs. A line of inquiry usually has three parts: the work, a feature or method of the writing, and the concern the feature serves. The page on finding a line of inquiry teaches how to build one and how to test it before you commit.

How it differs from a Paper 2 essay

The HL essay and a Paper 2 essay are both formal essays about literature, and the habits of one help the other. The conditions are different, though, and so is what each rewards. The table compares them.

Paper 2

HL essay

Works

Two literary works, compared

One literary work or one non-literary body of work

Question

One of four general questions, set by the IB

Your own line of inquiry

Conditions

1 hour 45 minutes, from memory, no texts

Written over time, with the work open, research and redrafting

Length

Whatever you write in the time

1,200 to 1,500 words, a firm limit

Marking

25 marks, five criteria (A, B1, B2, C, D)

20 marks, four criteria (A, B, C, D)

Weight at HL

25%

20%

Three differences matter most for how you write. The first is depth. A Paper 2 essay ranges across two works and compares them; an HL essay stays inside one and can follow a single feature through it. A brief comparison with another work can sharpen a point, but the essay is marked on the one work.

The second is precision. In Paper 2 you quote from memory and an examiner accepts a phrase that is nearly right. In the HL essay you have the work in front of you, so every quotation must be exact and cited to its page, act or line. The third is the conventions of academic writing: a title that states the line, citations, a list of works cited, and secondary sources credited if you use them. These conventions are part of criterion D.

A literary work or a body of work

The choice of a literary work or a body of work shapes the essay. A literary work offers depth: a novel, a play or a collection of poems or stories holds patterns that only a whole reading finds, such as the windows that recur across the fifteen stories of Dubliners. A line of inquiry into a literary work usually follows one feature through the whole work and asks what it adds up to.

A body of work is a set of non-literary texts from one source, such as a photographer’s series, an advertising campaign or one columnist’s writing over a year. It offers patterns across items: a visual strategy that a campaign repeats, a persona a columnist builds week by week. A line of inquiry for a body of work often asks how its texts make meaning together. One example is How do the WPA’s public health posters use typography to make the state’s advice feel like the viewer’s own decision? The question names the body of work, a feature to follow across many posters, and the effect it will test.

How the criteria are earned

Each criterion is marked out of 5, and each looks at the essay from a different side. A reads what you understand about the work and what you make of it; B reads how closely you analyze the writer’s choices; C reads how the essay is built and whether its ideas grow; D reads the writing itself. The paired extracts that follow all come from essays on the same line of inquiry into Dubliners, so the difference between each pair lies in the writing, not the material.

A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation

Criterion A rewards knowledge of the work used to build an interpretation that answers your line of inquiry. Knowing what happens is the floor of the criterion, not its middle. An interpretation reads beneath the surface of the work, notices patterns and tensions, and anchors each claim in the exact words that support it. Both extracts are about the end of “Eveline”, where the young woman of the title refuses at the last moment to board the boat that would take her away with her lover, Frank.

Weaker: Eveline is a young woman who lives with her father in Dublin. She has promised to run away to Buenos Ayres with a sailor called Frank, but at the end she does not get on the boat.note 1 This shows that she is trapped by paralysis.note 2

Stronger: Eveline’s refusal at the quay is prepared by the window where her story begins. She spends the evening watching “the evening invade the avenue” (Joyce 42), and even her posture is passive: “Her head was leaned against the window curtains” (42), as if someone else had placed it there.note 3 At the barrier she becomes the one who is watched, setting her face to Frank “passive, like a helpless animal” (48). By the last sentence the window has moved inside her.note 4

  1. Retelling. Every sentence is accurate, and none needs the reader to have thought about the story. Summary proves the work has been read, which is where criterion A begins.

  2. A label in place of a reading. Paralysis is the collection’s own word, but attaching it here explains nothing about this story.

  3. A pattern found. The extract links the ending to the opening through the window and reads the passive verb as evidence. That is interpretation, built from exact words.

  4. An answer to the line. The last sentence states what the ending adds to the essay’s question: the barrier is now in Eveline, not in the glass.

The stronger extract knows the story no better than the weaker one. What it adds is a reading of what the story means for the line of inquiry, and every step of that reading can be checked against the page. The weaker extract could sit in any essay on “Eveline”, and the stronger one answers this essay’s question.

B: Analysis and evaluation

Criterion B rewards analysis of the writer’s choices as they bear on your line of inquiry: language, imagery, structure, narrative voice, form, and in a body of work layout, image and typography. Naming a feature earns little. Explaining what it does in this work earns the marks, and evaluating it (judging how well it works, or weighing one effect against another) earns the top band. Both extracts are about “Araby”, in which a boy watches the house of a girl he has barely spoken to.

Weaker: Joyce uses a lot of imagery of windows in “Araby”. Windows are a symbol of being trapped.note 1 This shows the theme of paralysis and makes the reader feel sad for the boy.note 2

Stronger: In “Araby” the window is a hiding place as much as a barrier. The boy watches from behind a blind “pulled down to within an inch of the sash so that I could not be seen” (Joyce 34): the inch lets him see, and the rest of the blind keeps him from being seen.note 3 Later, leaning “my forehead against the cool glass” (38), he hears his friends’ cries arrive “weakened and indistinct”. The two words soften the life of the street before it reaches him, so the glass filters as well as separates.note 4 Joyce makes the boy prefer the filtered version, which makes his paralysis partly a choice and the story’s ending less a misfortune than a judgment.note 5

  1. A feature named, not analyzed. “Imagery of windows” and “a symbol of being trapped” could be said of any window in any book. No word of the story is quoted.

  2. A general effect. “Makes the reader feel sad” is an effect any sad story has; it is not tied to a choice in this one.

  3. Detail read closely. The extract notices the inch the blind leaves open and explains what it lets the boy do. The analysis lives in a precise detail.

  4. Two choices, one effect. The words weakened and indistinct are read together, and their effect is named precisely: the glass filters.

  5. Evaluation. The extract judges what the choices add up to, and how that changes the meaning of the story’s ending. This is the step that reaches the top band.

The stronger extract quotes less than a full sentence each time, but it does more with each quotation. It works through the words it quotes, then steps back to judge what they show. That movement from detail to judgment is what criterion B reads for in every paragraph.

C: Focus, organization and development

Criterion C is where the HL essay differs most from the exam essays. Besides focus (staying on the line of inquiry) and organization (a clear order), it asks for development: each section should deepen the one before, so that the essay knows more at the end than at the start. An essay that lists five examples of the same point is organized but not developed. Both extracts open the third section of an essay, on Little Chandler in “A Little Cloud”, a clerk who dreams of becoming a poet.

Weaker: Another story with a window is “A Little Cloud”.note 1 Little Chandler looks out of the office window and sees people in the gardens. He feels sad, which shows paralysis again, like Eveline and the boy in “Araby”.note 2

Stronger: Little Chandler’s window takes the pattern a step further, because he is not a child or a dutiful daughter but a man who believes he could write about what he sees.note 3 When he “watched the scene and thought of life” (Joyce 85), the sentence separates watching from living in its own grammar, and the thinking makes him “sad”.note 4 Where the boy of “Araby” wanted to enter the life beyond the glass, Chandler wants to describe it, and the essay’s question changes: is writing a way through the window, or only a finer kind of glass?note 5

  1. Adding, not developing. “Another” announces one more example of a point already made. The section could be moved anywhere in the essay without loss.

  2. The same conclusion again. The extract ends where the last two sections ended. The essay has grown longer, not deeper.

  3. A step up. The topic sentence says how this story changes the pattern, so the section cannot be moved without breaking the argument.

  4. Analysis that serves the step. The quotation is read for its grammar and tied directly to the new idea.

  5. A sharper question. The section ends by refining the line of inquiry, which the next section, on “The Dead”, can answer. This is development in practice.

A useful test for development is to ask what each section knows that the previous one did not. If the answer is “another example”, the section adds; if the answer is a new step in the argument, it develops. The page on structuring the HL essay builds a whole plan on this test.

D: Language

Criterion D rewards writing that is clear, accurate and varied, in a register that suits a formal essay, with terms used precisely. In the HL essay it also covers academic conventions: quotations exact and correctly integrated, citations consistent, a list of works cited. Errors or vagueness that blur the meaning cost marks under this criterion. Both extracts are about Gabriel in “The Dead”, who stands at a window during his aunts’ annual dance.

Weaker: Joyce really shows us that Gabriel is stuck,note 1 he says “how nice it would be to walk outside”note 2 and it is obvious that he wants to escape from the party.note 3

Stronger: Gabriel’s wish to leave is framed as an exclamation he never speaks aloud: “How pleasant it would be to walk out alone, first along by the river and then through the park!” (Joyce 237).note 4 The conditional would be keeps the walk imaginary, and the fingers that tap “the cold pane” (237) touch the barrier rather than the snow.note 5

  1. Register and run-on. “Really shows us” is conversational, and the comma splice joins three claims that need separate sentences.

  2. A misquotation, uncited. The words in quotation marks are not Joyce’s, and there is no page reference. With the book open, this is a fault in conventions as well as accuracy.

  3. An empty intensifier. “It is obvious” asserts what the extract has not shown.

  4. Exact and integrated. The quotation is copied exactly, introduced by a sentence that analyzes it, and cited by page.

  5. Precise terms. Conditional names the grammar accurately, and the sentence is balanced so its two halves can be compared.

Criterion D is the one most improved by redrafting. A first draft should be written for the argument; a later draft can check every quotation against the book, every citation against the list of works cited, and every sentence for the word that says exactly what you mean.

The word limit

The essay must be 1,200 to 1,500 words. The upper limit is firm: an examiner stops reading at 1,500 words, and anything after that point is not marked. An essay that runs to 1,700 words therefore loses its last 200, which is usually where the conclusion sits. Criterion C then reads an essay with no ending, and criteria A and B lose whatever the final section argued.

The lower figure matters too. An essay well short of 1,200 words rarely has room to develop a line of inquiry through more than two steps, so it tends to lose marks on criterion C even when every sentence is good. Aim for a draft between 1,400 and 1,500 words, which leaves a margin for a late sentence or two.

Whether the title, the citations and the list of works cited count toward the limit is a detail schools describe differently. Check the current rule with your teacher, and count your words the way they tell you before you submit. Footnotes are a poor way to hold extra argument in any case: an examiner reads the essay, not its margins.

Your own work: academic integrity

Because the HL essay is written over time, with books and the internet within reach, it is held to the rules of academic integrity. The argument must be yours. Any idea, phrase or fact you take from another writer must be credited where you use it, and every source you use must appear in your list of works cited. Paraphrasing a critic without credit counts as copying, even when every word has been changed.

Your teacher reads and comments on your work as it develops, but the help a teacher can give on a draft is limited, and the details vary. Your teacher will explain how much feedback they can give and at which stage. Friends, tutors and online services cannot write or rewrite any part of the essay for you. You will usually be asked to confirm that the essay is your own work when you submit it.

The two sentences that follow use the same source: a letter of 5 May 1906 in which Joyce told his publisher why he had set his stories in Dublin. The first borrows the letter’s phrase without saying so. The second credits it and puts it to work.

Weaker: Dublin is the centre of paralysis, and the windows in the stories show this.note 1

Stronger: Joyce wrote in 1906 that he had chosen Dublin because the city seemed to him the “centre of paralysis” (letter to Grant Richards, 5 May 1906).note 2 The windows give that claim a shape, but “The Dead” tests it: its last window opens a view far wider than Dublin.note 3

  1. An uncredited borrowing. The phrase is Joyce’s, taken from his letter, but the sentence presents it as the student’s own idea. This breaks academic integrity even though it is only four words.

  2. Credited and cited. The sentence names the source and its date, and the letter appears in the list of works cited.

  3. The source used, not obeyed. The essay uses Joyce’s words as a claim to test against the stories, not as proof. A source that settles the argument for you leaves criterion A with less to reward.

Secondary sources are optional. An essay that uses none can reach the top band, because the criteria reward your analysis of the work. If you do use criticism, history or a writer’s letters, use them sparingly and cite each one. The page on finding a line of inquiry explains when such sources help and when they take the essay over.

Works cited and citing editions

Every HL essay ends with a list of works cited: every text the essay quotes or refers to, set out so that a reader could find the same edition. The edition matters because page numbers differ from one printing to another, and because a work in translation exists in several versions. A Doll’s House in William Archer’s translation (the 1890 edition quoted earlier) is worded differently from later translations, so an essay that quotes Archer must say so.

Use one recognized citation style, such as MLA or Chicago, and use it consistently. Your school may prefer one. In MLA style, the most common in English essays, a quotation is followed by the author and page in brackets the first time and by the page alone after that: (Joyce 42), then (48). The list of works cited for the Dubliners essay, with a body of work item added to show the form, might read:

  • Joyce, James. Dubliners. Grant Richards, 1914.

  • Joyce, James. Letter to Grant Richards. 5 May 1906.

  • Hine, Lewis W. A Little Spinner in the Mollahan Mills, Newberry, S.C. 3 Dec. 1908. National Child Labor Committee Collection, Library of Congress.

The first entry is the work itself. The second is a secondary source; in a real essay it would also name the book in which the letter is printed, since a student reads a published edition of the letters. The third shows how a single photograph from a body of work is cited: maker, title as the record gives it, date and the collection that holds it. The page on structuring the HL essay shows how citations work inside paragraphs.

Where HL essays lose marks

The commonest faults are few, and most begin before the first sentence. The first is a topic instead of a line of inquiry: an essay on gender in A Doll’s House or paralysis in Dubliners has no question to answer, so it gathers examples. The second is biography and context replacing analysis: paragraphs on Joyce’s life or on Dublin in 1904 that never reach the words of the stories. The third is summary, the retelling that sits at the floor of criterion A. The fourth is length: an essay over 1,500 words loses its last section unread.

The first and last are matters of planning, solved by a sharper question and a word budget. The middle two are matters of writing, and they can be repaired paragraph by paragraph. The worked example repairs one paragraph that has drifted into context.

The repaired paragraph keeps its context as one sentence that makes the analysis matter. That is the balance the criteria reward in every HL essay, on a literary work or on a body of work.

Try it

Your first idea for an HL essay is money in A Doll’s House. Is it a topic or a line of inquiry, and how could you begin to turn it into the other?

It is a topic: it names a subject but no feature of the writing and no question. A first step is to find where money appears in the writing itself, for example in what Nora says about her secret loan, or in the macaroons she hides in Act I. A line could then ask how Ibsen uses Nora’s small deceptions about money to show a marriage built on performance, and how far her final speech explains them.

The next step is the question itself. The Dubliners essay began with finding a line of inquiry, from a first idea about the work to a question tested against it. Structuring the essay then turns the line into a plan, and complete essays at three bands show the results side by side.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can state the HL essay’s length, subject, marking and weighting, and what happens past 1,500 words.

  • To do:

    I can tell a topic from a line of inquiry and name the three parts of a line.

  • To do:

    I can explain how the HL essay differs from a Paper 2 essay, and what a literary work and a body of work each offer it.

  • To do:

    I can say what each of the four criteria rewards and recognize a stronger and a weaker answer on each.

  • To do:

    I can credit every source I use and set out a list of works cited in one consistent style.

  • To do:

    I can repair a paragraph that summarizes or drifts into context so that it serves my line of inquiry.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Academic integrity HL only

The principle that work submitted for assessment is the student’s own, with every idea, phrase or fact taken from another person credited to its source. Copying, paraphrasing without credit and handing in writing someone else has shaped all break it.

HL essay HL only

The higher level coursework essay of English A: a formal essay of 1,200 to 1,500 words that develops a student’s own line of inquiry into one literary work or one non-literary body of work. It is marked externally by the IB on four criteria.

Line of inquiry HL only

The question an HL essay sets out to answer: a question about how one work or body of work makes meaning, narrow enough to answer in the essay’s length and open enough to argue. It names the work, a feature or method of the writing, and the concern the feature serves.

Works cited HL only

The list at the end of an essay of every text the essay quotes or refers to, each with enough detail (author, title, translator, publisher, year) for a reader to find the same edition. It works with the citations in the essay, which point to entries in the list.

Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes

HL essay

  1. 4The HL essayThis page

Individual oral

  1. 5The five minutes of questions
  2. 6An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 7Finding a line of inquiry
  2. 8Structuring the HL essay
  3. 9An HL essay at each band

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.