- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- An oral at each band
An oral at each band
Three complete individual orals, at the high, middle and low bands, each on a different pairing and global issue, with outlines, transcripts, margin comments and marks, and what separates the bands on each criterion.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
A mark in the individual oral is easier to understand when you can hear the talk that earned it. Three orals make the bands concrete. Each is a written transcript of a complete talk, with the outline the student brought into the room, part of the teacher’s questions, numbered margin comments and a mark out of 10 on each criterion. One sits in the high band, one in the middle and one in the low. Each uses its own literary work, body of work and global issue, so the faults and strengths can be seen apart from any one pairing.
How the three orals are marked
Each oral is marked on the four criteria described on the first oral page: A, knowledge, understanding and interpretation; B, analysis and evaluation; C, focus and organization; and D, language. Each criterion is out of 10, and its band descriptions cover two marks at a time, so a talk that just reaches a description takes the lower mark and a talk that meets it throughout takes the higher. The marks here follow that rule. The three orals are labeled by their totals: high for 32 to 40, middle for 18 to 28 and low for 6 to 16. These labels are a way of reading the exemplars, not IB grade boundaries, which are set for each examination session.
Read each oral in the order the teacher meets it. Start with the outline, which shows whether the student had an argument before speaking or only a list of topics. Read the talk next, then the questions, and only then the margin comments and the marks. Each comment names a criterion and gives one verdict (strength, partly, missed or error), and each reason beside a mark points back to the comments that support it. A student who reads the marks first tends to read the talk to confirm them, and learns less.
The extracts come before each oral, as the teacher would have them: a clean copy of each, with line or paragraph numbers that the student uses when speaking. The three pairings are a one-act play with a set of documentary photographs, a novel with a series of radio addresses, and a novel with a run of advertisements. Every literary work and every item is in the public domain, so each extract can be printed in full. Your own works will be different. What carries over is the way each talk uses its extracts, its issue and its time.
A play and a photograph: what a community owes
The first oral pairs Susan Glaspell’s one-act play Trifles (1916) with Dorothea Lange’s photographs for the Farm Security Administration, a federal agency whose photographers recorded rural poverty in the United States in the late 1930s. Its global issue is what a community owes to people who suffer in isolation, a question in the field of culture, identity and community. The extract from the play comes from its second half, after the two women are left alone in the farm kitchen. It runs from Mrs. Peters’s remark that it would be lonesome to sit there alone to Mrs. Hale’s speech about the bottle of fruit, and it holds the discovery of the bird. The text is the play’s first printing.
The extract is long for 41 lines because each speech is printed as one line. It moves in three steps: the women’s talk about Mrs. Wright’s lonely life, the discovery of the dead bird and the men’s brief return, and the women’s talk after the men go back upstairs. The issue is spoken aloud twice, in Mrs. Hale’s confession in line 4 and her outburst in line 39, which gives a student two fixed points to build a talk on.
The item from the body of work is one photograph that Lange made in June 1938 near Childress, Texas. A woman stands against a wide sky with the horizon low behind her and a strip of crops along the foot of the frame. Her right hand is pressed to her forehead and her left arm crosses her body. There is no house, road or other person in the picture. The caption card the agency filed with it names her last, after her husband’s work and the place.

Lange often wrote down what the people she photographed told her, and the words recorded with this photograph belong to the item as much as its caption does. Both are short enough to give in full:
Wife of a migratory laborer with three children. Near Childress, Texas. Nettie Featherston.
“We’ve had no work since March. The worst thing we did was when we sold the car, but we had to sell it to eat, and now we can’t get away from here. . . . This county’s a hard county. They won’t help bury you here. If you die, you’re dead, that’s all.”The caption card (Library of Congress) and Nettie Featherston’s words as Lange recorded them (as given with the photograph in the Wikimedia Commons record of the item)
The pairing works because both works present a woman left alone, but from different distances. In the play the people who failed her are her neighbors, speaking in her own kitchen while she is held in town. In the photograph the woman speaks for herself in the notes, and the community she accuses is her county; the viewer the agency wanted to reach was a whole nation. A talk on this pair can be built on that difference.
What earns marks at the top
A high-band oral on this pairing does not know more facts than a middle-band one. It does more with the same facts. The difference is audible in the first minute, where a strong talk states a claim about how the two works differ, and then in every section, where each reading of a line is turned back toward that claim.
A claim the whole talk can test
The issue of this pairing, what a community owes to people who suffer in isolation, is a question. A strong talk answers it differently for each work before the analysis begins: the play places the debt in a neighbor who could have visited, and the photograph places it in a distant nation asked to look. That answer is the talk’s controlling idea, and it decides what is analyzed. Mrs. Hale’s confession earns minutes because it names the debt; the quilt pattern earns none, however interesting, because it does not bear on the claim.
Criterion A at its top band asks for an interpretation of how each work presents the issue, not for knowledge of everything in it. A talk makes that interpretation clearest when it reads one line as the work’s own statement on the issue. Mrs. Hale’s speech in line 41 offers such a line:
We live close together and we live far apart. We all go through the same things—it’s all just a different kind of the same thing—
Trifles, line 41
The first sentence balances two halves that contradict each other, and the contradiction is the play’s whole view of a farming community: near enough to know a neighbor’s life, too far apart to share it. A talk that reads the balance this way has interpreted the play through its form. It can then move to the work around the extract, where the women hide the dead bird from the men, and ask whether that act repays the debt or only conceals it.
Analysis that stays with one choice
Criterion B rewards analysis of choices in both extracts, weighed for how well they present the issue. In a play the choices are small and exact: a dash, a repeated word, a stage direction. Mrs. Peters’s “we just don’t see how it is with other folks until—something comes up” (line 5) can be analyzed through two choices. Its pronoun makes neglect a habit of the whole community, and its dash stops just before the word murder. Two choices explained fully earn more than six named.
The photograph needs the same care, with precise description standing in for quotation. Its choices are those of composition (a low horizon, an empty field, no house or road), of gesture (a hand pressed to the forehead, an arm across the body) and of camera angle. The caption card is a choice too: it names the woman’s husband’s work and the place before her name. A high-band talk weighs these choices against each other. A low camera can make a person look strong and dignified, which may help a viewer respect her, but it leaves out the hunger and the sold car that her own recorded words describe.
A balance the listener can hear
Criterion C asks for a talk that is planned, stays on the issue and gives both works fair time. Fair time is the criterion most often lost by strong students, because the literary work usually feels richer and the body of work feels thinner. A plan that gives the play five sections and the photograph three can still score well on criterion C, but not at the top, because the imbalance is audible. The repair is planning, not cutting quality: a body of work offers as much to analyze as a play when the item’s words, image and place in the series are all used.
Criterion D rewards fluent, precise speech. At the top band, terms such as dramatic irony or composition arrive with their explanation in the same breath, and the occasional slip of live speech does not lower the mark. What lowers it is a figure of speech that the listener has to decode, or a vague word where a precise one exists.
A novel and a series of radio addresses: who carries the cost
The second oral pairs Upton Sinclair’s novel The Jungle (1906), which follows a family of Lithuanian immigrants through the stockyards of Chicago, with Franklin D. Roosevelt’s fireside chats, the radio addresses the president gave to the nation between 1933 and 1944. A speaker’s series of speeches is a body of work in the same way as a photographer’s series: one source, one purpose, many items. The global issue, in the field of politics, power and justice, is who should carry the cost when a worker can no longer earn: the worker’s family, the employer or the state. The extract from the novel comes from chapter XI, where Jurgis is injured at work, printed as the first edition gives it.
The extract moves from the accident to its cost. Paragraph 1 ends on the company doctor’s view, given in the narrator’s words, and paragraph 3 turns to the family’s budget at the kitchen fire. The second extract is part of the fireside chat of 28 April 1935, broadcast while the Social Security Act was still before Congress; the act was signed into law that August. It is printed from the text the American Presidency Project publishes.
The two extracts answer the issue from opposite ends. Sinclair’s family carries the whole cost of the injury, and no one from outside the family appears except the boss and the doctor who sends Jurgis home. Roosevelt’s address proposes that the state, with employers, should carry part of the cost of old age and unemployment, and it speaks of “a feeling of security” (paragraph 2) to listeners in their own homes. A talk on this pair has a sharp contrast available, if it looks for it.
What holds a talk in the middle
A middle-band oral usually knows its works well. Its problem is what it does with that knowledge. It describes where it should analyze, it follows one work for most of the time, and it reaches the other work late, with background where an argument should be. Each of these faults costs marks on a different criterion, so a talk can lose ten marks without a single wrong fact.
Restating a sentence in place of analyzing it
The most useful sentence in the extract from The Jungle is the last one of its first paragraph:
The injury was not one that Durham and Company could be held responsible for, and so that was all there was to it, so far as the doctor was concerned.
Upton Sinclair, The Jungle, chapter XI, paragraph 1
A middle-band reading quotes it and says that the company takes no responsibility, which is true and is already what the sentence says. An analysis asks how the sentence says it. The narrator reports the doctor’s view in flat terms close to the doctor’s own, “so that was all there was to it”, without comment, and the calm of the phrasing is what makes it damning. Then paragraph 4 changes voice completely. The narrator speaks out: “It was dreadful that an accident of this sort, that no man can help, should have meant such suffering.” Two voices in one extract, one indifferent and one outraged, is a choice that a top-band talk would build its section on.
The improvement is easiest to see side by side. Both versions are about the same sentence.
Weak: This shows that the company does not take responsibility, which links to my global issue.note 1
Strong: Sinclair gives the company’s answer in flat words close to the doctor’s own, “so that was all there was to it”, and lets it stand without comment.note 2 Three paragraphs later the narrator breaks in with “It was dreadful”, so the extract sets indifference against outrage, and the family’s cost falls in the space between them.note 3
A restatement. The sentence repeats the quotation’s meaning and names the issue, but says nothing about how the writing works.
The choice named. The voice of the sentence is identified and its effect explained: the calm phrasing condemns the company better than an attack would.
A contrast inside one extract. A second choice is set against the first, and the pair is tied back to the issue of who carries the cost.
Plot, background and the second work
A middle-band talk often spends a minute telling what happens later in the novel. Knowledge of the whole work belongs in criterion A, but only when it is chosen for the issue. The later chapters of The Jungle hold many events, and one would serve this issue precisely: whether anyone outside the family ever takes on its costs. A list of every misfortune proves that the student has read the book and leaves the listener to find the connection.
The body of work then suffers twice. It arrives late, and it arrives with background (how many fireside chats there were, when the act was signed) instead of a reading of the item. A radio address offers as much to analyze as a novel: its pronouns, its metaphors, the way it addresses a listener at home, and the people it does not mention. The extract speaks of “old-age pensions” and “unemployment insurance” and says nothing of a worker hurt on the job, which is exactly the case of Jurgis. A talk that noticed that silence would have its comparison ready.
A novel and an advertising campaign: who decides what is wrong
The third oral pairs Kate Chopin’s novel The Awakening (1899), in which a married woman in New Orleans begins to refuse the life expected of her, with the advertisements for Lydia E. Pinkham’s Vegetable Compound, a patent medicine sold to women from the 1870s. The Pinkham advertisements ran for decades in newspapers and magazines, under the founder’s portrait, and they form one of the best-known campaigns of their period. The pair could carry a sharp global issue in the field of science, technology and the environment: who decides what is wrong with a woman who is unhappy, her husband, her doctor, a seller of remedies or the woman herself? The extract from the novel is from chapter XXII, in which Mr. Pontellier visits the family doctor to talk about his wife.
Edna herself never appears in the extract. Her husband describes her, the doctor diagnoses her, and both speak about “women” as a class. The item from the body of work is a full-page magazine advertisement from April 1882. A portrait of Lydia E. Pinkham fills its top half, with her handwritten “Yours for Health” and signature beneath it, and two slogans run up its sides. Below, a column of small type lists what the compound is said to cure.

The words of the advertisement matter more than its picture, and the lines a talk would use are these:
Woman can Sympathize with Woman.
Health of Woman is the Hope of the Race.
LYDIA E. PINKHAM’S VEGETABLE COMPOUND. Is a Positive Cure for all those Painful Complaints and Weaknesses so common to our best female population.
… It cures Bloating, Headaches, Nervous Prostration, General Debility, Sleeplessness, Depression and Indigestion. …
Mrs. Pinkham freely answers all letters of inquiry.Advertisement for Lydia E. Pinkham’s Vegetable Compound, 1882: the side slogans, the heading and lines from the column of type
The contrast between the two items is ready to hand. In the novel two men decide, between themselves, what is wrong with a woman who is absent, and the doctor’s answer is to wait. In the advertisement a woman speaks to women, offers to answer their letters herself, and turns their unhappiness into a list of complaints that one bottle will cure. Both claim to understand women, and each speaks from a position of authority over them. The low-band oral on this pair never reaches this contrast, because its issue is only a topic word.
Why a low-band talk stays low
A low-band oral is rarely short of effort. Its faults usually follow from one early misunderstanding, and the commonest is an issue that is only a topic. When the issue is “women”, every text about women fits it, so nothing in the talk has to be chosen or connected. The novel is retold because retelling is all a topic asks for. The advertisement is judged true or false because the talk has no question to put to it. And the ending reaches for a modern fact because the two works have not been made to answer anything.
The same pairing, with a real issue, would score far higher. Asked who decides what is wrong with an unhappy woman, the extract from The Awakening answers at once: two men, in a study, with the woman absent. The advertisement answers differently: a woman’s face and signature, an offer to answer letters, a promise that a bottle will cure “Depression”. Every quotation the low-band student used would then do work.
The three orals compared
Set side by side, the three orals differ most on criteria A, B and C, where the high-band talk interprets, analyzes and plans and the others describe and drift. The table gives each oral’s mark on each criterion with the main reason for it.
Criterion | High (34) | Middle (21) | Low (13) |
|---|---|---|---|
A Knowledge, understanding and interpretation | 9: both works read through a claim about the issue; the play’s key line and the photograph’s later title interpreted. | 6: sound knowledge, but an issue that joins two problems and a comparison that takes promises as facts. | 3: knowledge given as retelling; a topic word in place of an issue. |
B Analysis and evaluation | 8: a sentence’s turn, a dash and a caption’s word order analyzed; the camera angle weighed only in the questions. | 5: several choices in the novel explained; the radio address described in general terms. | 3: quotations labeled (“sexist”, “lying”) rather than analyzed. |
C Focus and organization | 8: planned from a controlling idea and ended on the issue; the play has more time than the photograph. | 4: a list of topics; the novel takes more than half the time; the second work arrives with background. | 3: mostly plot; the works joined only by a topic; an ending on a new subject. |
D Language | 9: fluent and precise, terms explained as they are used. | 6: clear and accurate, with “this shows” doing much of the work. | 4: the meaning is clear, but the wording is loose and informal, and one term is used loosely. |
The chart sets the same marks as bars. The gap between the high and middle orals is widest on criterion C, where planning decides the mark. The low oral’s best criterion is D, which is common: a student can speak clearly about texts without saying much about them.


What the questions added
The five minutes of questions changed each oral in a different way. The high-band student used them to weigh a choice the talk had only named, and to hold a reading against a challenge with line numbers. The middle-band student found a real gap in the radio address when asked about it, then let it go. The low-band student repeated the topic and guessed. A strong answer to a question goes back to the extract, adds something the talk did not say, and stops.
Try it
The middle-band oral claims that Sinclair “shows the problem and Roosevelt gives the solution”. Using the two extracts, write two sentences that a stronger student could say in its place.
One possibility: The novel shows the cost of an injury landing on a family because no one outside it accepts any share, while the address offers the state and employers a share of two costs, old age and unemployment. But it never mentions a worker hurt on the job, so Jurgis’s case would still fall to his family. The sentences compare how each work answers the issue, quote nothing the extracts do not hold, and turn the contrast into a judgment of the address instead of accepting its promise.
Taking the three orals into your own
The habits that separate the bands can be practiced before the oral, with your own works. Five of them make most of the difference.
Write the issue as a question and answer it for each work before you plan anything else. If the two answers are the same, choose a different issue or a different extract.
Choose two or three choices per extract and explain them fully, each tied to the issue, rather than naming every feature you can find.
Plan the minutes so that each work has about the same time, and practice with a timer until the second work is never squeezed.
Read the body of work as a text with a purpose: its words, its images and what it leaves out, not only its history or its claims.
End on the issue, with each work’s answer, and keep one thing in reserve that a question could let you add.
Self-check
- To do:
I can read a marked oral in order, from the outline to the marks, and say which comments support each mark.
- To do:
I can explain what separates a high-band, a middle-band and a low-band oral on each of the four criteria.
- To do:
I can tell analysis of a choice from a restatement or a label, and turn one into the other.
- To do:
I can judge whether a talk keeps its issue central and gives both works fair time.
- To do:
I can use a question in the five minutes to extend or repair a point from the talk.
- To do:
I can apply the habits that separate the bands to the plan of my own oral.
Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit
Individual oral
HL essay
- 4The HL essayHL only
Individual oral
- 5The five minutes of questions
- 6An oral at each bandThis page
HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
- The five minutes of questionsThe page before this.
- Finding a line of inquiryThe next page. HL only.
- English A Lang & Lit exam formatEach English A Lang & Lit paper, how long it is and its share of the grade.
- IB English A Lang & LitThe English A Lang & Lit syllabus, how it is assessed and every notes page.
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.