- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- The five minutes of questions
The five minutes of questions
What the teacher’s questions in the individual oral are for, the kinds of question and how to answer each, how to hold a challenge and repair a gap, and how to prepare without a script.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
The individual oral does not end when the talk ends. For about five more minutes your teacher asks questions about what you have said, and your answers are marked on the same four criteria as the talk. The questions are a chance to show more than ten minutes allowed about your global issue and your two works: a closer reading, a connection you had no time for, a view you can defend. The five minutes that follow come after the strong talk on A Raisin in the Sun and the maps, whose ending called the play “a reply to the maps”.
What the questions are for
The teacher’s questions do three jobs. They let you extend a point, by going further into a line or an item than the talk did. They let you clarify a point, by saying more exactly what you meant. And they test a point, by asking whether a reading holds up against an objection. All three are opportunities. A question is not a sign that the talk went wrong; a teacher who asks nothing gives you no chance to add marks.
The four questions in the transcript do all three jobs. The first, in turn 1, tests the talk’s last claim by asking “Can a play really answer a policy?” The second, in turn 3, asks for a closer look at one word of the legend, which extends the analysis. The third, in turn 5, asks how typical the item is, which clarifies the place of one district in the body of work. Turn 7 is a follow-up that tests the answer just given, and turn 9 asks for a view on the issue at the end of the play. Each question starts from something the student said, which is how teachers usually build them.
The questions are part of the assessment, not a conversation after it. Everything said in the five minutes counts toward the same criteria as the talk, and a strong answer can raise a mark that the talk left at the lower end of its band. The reverse is true too. A student who repeats the talk, wanders from the issue or falls silent can lose some of what the talk earned. Most schools stop the oral at fifteen minutes, so an answer that runs on also costs the questions that would have followed it.
An answer that returns to the texts
Every strong answer in the transcript goes back to the extracts within its first two sentences. Asked who the hazard is to (turn 3), the student starts from the word on the legend and its job: “The grade says whether a loan in that district is a safe investment” (turn 4). Asked how typical the district is (turn 5), the student starts from the form: “The same printed form and the same four grades were used for more than 200 cities” (turn 6). The evidence comes first, and the claim is built on it.
That habit matters because a question can easily pull a talk away from its texts. A question about whether a play can answer a policy invites a speech about theater and politics in general. The student in turn 2 accepts part of the objection in one sentence and then returns at once to the sheet, its “detrimental” influences and the family on stage. The answer stays an answer about two texts, which is what every criterion rewards.
Five kinds of question
Teachers’ questions take many forms, but most belong to five kinds. Each asks for something different, and each has a best first move. Knowing the kind helps you hear what a question is asking before you start to answer it. The diagram sets the five around the talk’s issue and claim, which every answer should return to, with the move that starts a good answer to each.


A closer look
A closer look asks you to go back to a line of the literary extract or a part of the item and say more about it: “Can you look again at the legend?” (turn 3). It usually points at something the talk named but did not analyze fully. The best first move is to go straight to the words or the part of the image and describe them exactly, then analyze. In turn 4 the student does not repeat what the talk said about “Hazardous”; the answer adds who the hazard was to, which the talk had left out.
A connection
A connection question asks how the two works relate on a particular point: how a choice in one extract compares with a choice in the other, or whether the works answer the issue in the same way. Sometimes the teacher asks it directly. Sometimes, as in turn 4, the student makes the connection inside an answer to another question, setting “Hazardous” beside Lindner’s “happier”. The best first move is to name what the two choices share, then the difference between them. A connection made in the questions is worth as much as one made in the talk.
The wider work
A question about the wider work asks how the extract fits the whole: another moment in the play, or how typical the item is of the body of work. Turn 5 asks exactly this. The best first move is to place the extract in the whole with one precise fact (one form, four grades, more than 200 cities) and then say what that fact adds to the issue. A summary of the whole work is the wrong answer to this question, because it answers what happens when the question asks how does this fit.
A view on the issue
A question about the issue asks what you think, or where the issue stands at the end of a work: “Where does your issue stand at the end of the play?” (turn 9). It is the question most likely to pull an answer away from the texts, because it seems to invite an opinion. The best first move is to answer through the works. In turn 10 the student gives a view (the issue is “Unsettled”) and supports it with the play’s ending, where the family leaves the apartment and is never seen arriving. The view comes from the play, not from outside it.
A challenge
A challenge questions a claim the talk made: “Can a play really answer a policy?” (turn 1), or “are they really deciding where a family may live?” (turn 7). It tests whether a reading holds up. The best first move is to say what is fair in the challenge, briefly, and then hold the rest of the claim with evidence. A challenge is often the most valuable question of the five minutes, because a well-handled challenge shows the judgment that criteria A and B reward at their top bands.
Extending, not repeating
The commonest weak answer repeats the talk. It sounds safe, because the student knows those sentences well, but it adds nothing for the teacher to credit, and the criteria have already rewarded those points once. A strong answer adds something new: a second feature of the same line, a connection the talk did not make, a limit of the reading or a piece of the work the talk had no time for. The two answers that follow reply to the same question, the closer look at the legend in turn 3.
Weak: Like I said in my talk, the legend goes from green for “Best” to red for “Hazardous”, so the color gives a verdict on everyone who lives there before you read a word.note 1 So the maps are really unfair, and they affected a lot of people.note 2
Strong: To the lender, really. The grade says whether a loan in that district is a safe investment, so “Hazardous” describes a risk to the bank’s money.note 3 But the word is printed over the place where people live, so it reads as if the neighborhood itself is dangerous.note 4 I think that’s the same move Lindner makes with “happier”.note 5
A repeat. The sentence is accurate, but the talk already said it, almost word for word, so it earns nothing new.
A verdict in place of a reading. The question asked who the hazard is to; the answer leaves the legend for an opinion about the maps.
The question answered first. The answer begins with a direct reply and grounds it at once in what the grade measured.
A new analysis. The placement of the word on the map is read for its effect, which the talk had not done.
A connection. One word in each extract is set side by side, extending the comparison the talk made in general terms.
The strong answer is about 60 words, roughly 25 seconds of speech, and the fuller answers in the transcript run to about a minute. That is a good length for most answers: long enough to add a point and support it, short enough to leave time for several more questions. An answer of one sentence gives the teacher nothing to credit and forces another question on the same point. An answer of two minutes becomes a second talk, and usually drifts from the question that started it. When the point is made and supported, stop; the teacher will ask for more if more is wanted.
Holding a challenge
A challenge is a question that disagrees, or seems to. Students often hear it as a sign that their reading was wrong, and either abandon the reading or defend it without listening. Neither earns marks. The strongest answer does two things in order: it says what is fair in the challenge, and then it holds the rest of the claim with evidence from the texts. Turn 1 asks “Can a play really answer a policy?”, and turn 2 begins by conceding:
That’s fair, and I’d accept part of it. A play can’t change who gets a loan, and the maps affected far more families than any audience.
Transcript of the questions, turn 2
The concession takes two sentences and costs nothing, because it is true. It also earns the student the right to hold the rest. The answer then narrows the claim (the play answers the maps’ “way of seeing”, not their effect) and supports the narrower claim with the sheet’s “detrimental” influences and the family on stage. A teacher hears a student who can weigh an objection, which is the judgment the top bands of criteria A and B describe. The two answers that follow reply to the same challenge.
Weak: No, I think it can, because the play is really powerful and it makes people think about racism.note 1 Lots of people have seen it, and it was made into a film.note 2
Strong: That’s fair, and I’d accept part of it. A play can’t change who gets a loan.note 3 But I meant that Hansberry answers the maps’ way of seeing. The sheet turns a district into a grade, and the play takes one family that a sheet like that would sum up in a line and gives them a living room and a decision.note 4 So it answers the form of the maps, even if it can’t answer their effect.note 5
A flat denial. The objection is refused without being weighed, and “really powerful” is a feeling, not evidence.
Evidence from outside the texts. Popularity is not an answer to whether the play answers the maps; the extracts have disappeared.
A concession. The fair part of the objection is granted in two sentences.
The claim narrowed and supported. The student says what was meant and grounds it in one feature of each work.
The judgment stated. The answer ends with a sentence that holds the reading in its new, defensible form.
The follow-up in turn 7 pushes further: if the maps only recorded what lenders already did, are they deciding anything? Here the student concedes more, “Not on their own, no” (turn 8), and rephrases the controlling idea. A student who rephrases a claim under a good challenge has not lost the argument. Rephrasing a claim so that it fits the evidence better is exactly what a careful reader does, and saying so aloud shows the teacher the reading at work.
The question you did not expect
Some questions will surprise you. A teacher may ask about a moment in the work you did not mention, or about a feature of the item you had not noticed, or may put the issue in words you had not used. The real danger is silence. A few seconds of thought are normal and cost nothing, and three moves turn a surprise into an answer.
First, take a moment, and say so if it helps: Let me think about that for a second is a sentence teachers hear often. Second, rephrase the question in your own words, which checks that you have understood it and gives you time: So you’re asking whether the maps decide anything at all. Third, connect it to something you know well, usually a line of the extract or the controlling idea. An answer that begins from firm ground and moves toward the new question is better than a guess, and a teacher can always narrow the question if you have heard it wrongly.
Turn 9 of the transcript asks a question the talk had not prepared for: where the issue stands at the end of the play. The student had ended the talk on the play as a reply to the maps, which is a claim about the two works, not about the play’s last scene. The answer moves from what the student knows (the family leaves; Lindner’s association has not changed its mind) to a view the talk had not stated:
So the play doesn’t promise that the family will be safe. It says the decision was theirs to make, which is exactly what the maps never allowed.
Transcript of the questions, turn 10
The last sentence returns to the controlling idea, so even an unexpected question ends by strengthening the argument of the talk. If you cannot answer a question at all, say what you can say. I haven’t thought about that scene in relation to my issue, but in my extract… is honest. It moves the discussion back to ground where you can earn marks.
Try it
Suppose the teacher points out that you chose a red district, and asks whether a green district’s sheet would have told you anything about your issue. Using what you know of the maps from the pages on choosing an issue and structuring the talk, plan an answer in three or four sentences.
A good answer concedes, then turns the question into evidence: A green sheet wouldn’t show the families who were graded down, so it couldn’t carry my issue on its own. But it would show the same form praising the residents of a district, and that matters, because it means the form judged people everywhere, not only in red districts. The decision about who belonged was being made in every district; in the green ones it was simply a compliment. The answer takes the question seriously, uses a precise feature of the body of work (one form for every district) and ends on the issue.
Using the questions to repair the talk
No ten-minute talk says everything it planned. Points are cut for time, a choice is named without being explained, or the balance tips toward one work. The questions are your chance to repair some of this, but only when a question opens the door. Turn 6 is the clearest case. Asked how typical the district is, the student answers the question in three sentences and then adds:
But there’s something I had to cut from the talk for time, which is that historians disagree about what the maps did.
Transcript of the questions, turn 6
The debate over whether the maps caused unequal lending or recorded it was in the timed plan, under the body of work, and it was the first thing to go when time ran short. The question about the body of work makes it relevant, so the student brings it in and, importantly, says what it does to the issue: if the maps recorded decisions already made, the decision began “by people like Lindner’s association”. That sentence is a new connection between the two works, which is the kind of point that criterion A rewards.
A repair has to answer the question first. A student who hears any question as a chance to deliver a prepared paragraph sounds as if they are not listening, and the paragraph rarely fits. The test is simple. If the missing point answers the question asked, add it after the direct answer; if it does not, wait for a question that it does answer. A short list of two or three points you could not fit in, kept in mind rather than on paper, is enough.
How the five minutes count toward each criterion
Each criterion looks at the whole oral, so each can be helped or harmed by the questions. The table sets out what an answer can show on each criterion and how marks are most often lost there.
Criterion | What an answer can show | How marks are lost |
|---|---|---|
A Knowledge, understanding and interpretation | Knowledge of the work beyond the extract (the play’s last scene, the reach of the maps) used to deepen the interpretation. | Plot or background recited without a link to the issue; a reading abandoned under challenge. |
B Analysis and evaluation | A closer reading of a line or a part of the item, and a weighing of one choice against another. | Repeating the talk’s analysis; replying to a question about a choice with an opinion about the issue. |
C Focus and organization | Answers that stay on the issue, keep the two works in view and end on the point. | Long answers that drift; every answer about one work while the other is forgotten. |
D Language | Clear, precise speech under pressure, with terms used well and a calm way of rephrasing. | Long silences, filler and vague words when the question is unexpected. |
Preparing for the questions without a script
You cannot know the questions in advance, and you should not try to write answers to guessed ones. Written answers sound read, rarely fit the question actually asked, and tempt you to steer every question toward them. What you can prepare is the knowledge that good answers draw on, and the habit of answering from the texts. Five kinds of preparation do most of the work.
Know each extract beyond what the talk uses. Read both extracts again after planning the talk and note two or three features you did not include: a second line, a stage direction, a part of the image, a word on the form.
Know one or two moments of each whole work that bear on the issue and are not in the talk, ready for a question about the wider work.
Test your controlling idea against an objection. Write the strongest challenge you can think of in one sentence, then say aloud what you would concede and what you would hold.
Keep a short list of points you cut for time. These are your repairs, to bring in when a question opens the door to them.
Practice with a partner who asks open questions. A classmate or family member who has read the extracts can ask why that line?, how is it like the other work? or are you sure about that? Answer in under a minute each time.
Practicing with a partner matters because answering is a different skill from presenting. The talk is planned; the answers are not, and they improve only through answering. Use a different pairing from your real oral when you practice with your teacher, as schools usually require, and use your real pairing with classmates or at home. Record a practice and listen for two faults above all: answers that start with “Like I said”, and answers that never mention a line or a part of an image.
Where marks are lost in the questions
Four faults account for most marks lost in the five minutes. Going silent turns a question into a gap in the recording; even a partial answer, started from a line you know, earns more than nothing. Repeating the talk adds nothing for the criteria to reward. Abandoning the issue happens when a question about a work becomes an answer about the work alone, or when a question about the issue becomes a personal opinion. Answering with plot replaces a reading with a summary, most often after a question about the wider work.
The last fault is the easiest to hear. The two answers that follow reply to the same question about the wider work, how typical the district is.
Weak: Well, the HOLC made maps of a lot of cities, like Chicago, Detroit and New York, and they all had the four colors. Later the maps were found again, and people started calling it redlining.note 1
Strong: Very typical in its method. The same printed form and the same four grades were used for more than 200 cities, so the language on my sheet was repeated thousands of times.note 2 That’s partly why I chose it. It’s a representative item, not an unusual one.note 3
History in place of the item. True facts about the agency, but nothing about how this sheet compares with the others, and no link to the issue.
A precise fact chosen for the question. One form and four grades answer “how typical” directly, and the repetition of the language is what makes it matter.
A judgment about the choice. The student explains the choice of item as representative, which shows understanding of the body of work as a whole.
The strong answer uses fewer facts and earns more, because each fact answers the question and serves the issue. The page of orals at three bands shows whole sets of answers like these, and how they change a mark.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what the teacher’s questions are for and why they are an opportunity.
- To do:
I can recognize a closer look, a connection, a question about the wider work, a question on the issue and a challenge, and start each answer well.
- To do:
I can answer by returning to the extracts and add something the talk did not say, in under a minute.
- To do:
I can concede what is fair in a challenge and hold the rest of a reading with evidence.
- To do:
I can handle an unexpected question by pausing, rephrasing and connecting it to what I know.
- To do:
I can use a question to repair a gap in my talk, and say how the five minutes count toward each criterion.
- To do:
I can prepare for the questions without writing or memorizing answers.
Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit
Individual oral
HL essay
- 4The HL essayHL only
Individual oral
- 5The five minutes of questionsThis page
- 6An oral at each band
HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.