- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- Structuring the ten minutes
Structuring the ten minutes
How to plan and speak the ten minutes of the individual oral: a controlling idea, fair time for both works, the move from extract to work, signposts, and an ending on the issue.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
Ten minutes is a short time for two works. A talk that simply begins with one work and continues until the time runs out will usually give that work most of the minutes and the other the leftovers. A planned talk divides the time in advance, moves from each extract to its work, and turns from one work to the other at a moment chosen for its argument. Three minutes from the middle of a strong oral on A Raisin in the Sun and the maps show the plan at work:
A controlling idea
The six turns move through the end of the play section, the line to the whole play, the turn to the maps and the start of the reading of the item. They hang together because each one serves a single claim, stated in turn 2 and again in turn 6. The play “gives the family the last word”, and the maps leave “nobody who could answer back the way Walter does”. That claim is the talk’s controlling idea.
The controlling idea is different from the issue. The issue is the question both works present: who decides where a family may live? The controlling idea is your answer to it, for these two works: what each work suggests and how the two answers differ. In the transcript, the issue gives the talk its subject and the controlling idea gives it a direction. Every turn either builds part of the answer or moves the listener toward the next part.
A good controlling idea is short enough to say in one breath and specific enough to be wrong. Both works are about housing could not be wrong, so it cannot organize anything. The play gives the decision back to the family, while the maps take it away without the family knowing can be tested against every line of both extracts. When a section of the talk does not help to test it, the section is in the wrong talk.
The shape of ten minutes
The timeline divides ten minutes for this pairing. About a minute introduces the issue, the works, the extracts and the controlling idea. Each work then has about three and a half minutes, most of it on the extract and the rest on the work around it. A short turn joins the two halves, and the last minute and a half brings the works together and ends on the issue. The transcript covers the minutes from the end of the play section into the reading of the item, turns 1 to 6.


The proportions matter more than the exact minutes. Spoken English runs at roughly 130 to 150 words a minute, so the whole talk is about 1,300 to 1,500 words, and a section of three and a half minutes is about 500. Any plan that leaves one work with less than three minutes, or the extracts with less than half of each section, is out of balance. The criteria reward fair time for both works and attention to each extract and its work, not a stopwatch.
Two shapes suit most pairings. The first, used in the timeline, takes the works one after the other and then brings them together: work by work with a connecting section. The second alternates by aspect, taking one feature or idea at a time across both works, for example the voice that makes the decision, then the language that hides it, then who is left out. The next section compares them.
Two shapes for the body of the talk
The shape of a talk is a choice about how the listener meets the comparison. Work by work lets each extract be read as a whole before the two are compared, which suits extracts that build to a moment, such as Lindner’s visit and the family’s reply. Alternating by aspect makes the comparison constant, which suits works that share several features, such as two campaigns that both use testimony and both use images of children. The table sets the two side by side.
Feature | Work by work, then connect | Alternating by aspect |
|---|---|---|
Order | Introduction; the first work (extract, then the work); a turn; the second work (item, then the body of work); connection and ending. | Introduction; two or three aspects, each taken across both works; ending. |
Strength | Each extract is read closely and in order, and the turn between works can carry the argument. | The comparison runs through every section, so the works never drift apart. |
Risk | The first work takes too long, and the connection is squeezed into the last minute. | The extracts are cut into pieces, and neither is read as a whole. |
Suits | Two works that answer the issue in sharply different ways, through different kinds of text. | Two works that use similar methods for different ends, or the same end by different methods. |
The Hansberry pairing suits the first shape, because a play scene and a map are such different texts that each needs to be read on its own terms first. The contrast in the controlling idea, a decision made to a family’s face against one made out of its sight, then becomes the subject of the turn and of the last section. Neither shape is safer for marks. The criteria ask for balance, focus and organization, and either shape can give them or lose them.
The first minute
The introduction has four jobs: to state the issue, to name both works and both extracts, to give the controlling idea, and to say how the talk will run. It should take about a minute. A longer introduction usually means background has crept in: the writer’s life, the plot, the history of an agency. Each of those may earn a sentence later, where it explains a choice in an extract. The two openings that follow are for the same oral.
Weak: Hi, today I’m going to talk about A Raisin in the Sun and the HOLC maps.note 1 A Raisin in the Sun was written by Lorraine Hansberry in 1959. It’s about the Younger family, who live in a small apartment in Chicago and are waiting for an insurance check after the father died. Walter wants to use the money for a liquor store, but Mama wants to buy a house.note 2 My global issue is racism.note 3
Strong: My global issue is who decides where a family may live.note 4 I’ll look at it in Lorraine Hansberry’s play A Raisin in the Sun, from 1959, through the scene in Act Two where Karl Lindner visits the Younger family. And I’ll look at it in the maps the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation made of American cities between 1935 and 1940, through one district on Chicago’s South Side and its description sheet.note 5 My argument is that in both works a decision about a home is made by people outside it, but the play gives the family the last word, and the maps never let the family speak.note 6 I’ll take the play first, then the maps, and then put the two decisions side by side.note 7
No issue, no direction. The listener hears two titles and learns nothing about why they belong together.
Plot in place of a plan. Three sentences of summary that the teacher already knows; none of them points toward an issue.
The issue last, and as a topic. A field word arrives after the time has been spent, so it cannot frame what came before.
The issue first, as a question. Every later sentence can be heard as an answer to it.
Works and extracts located. Both extracts are named precisely enough for the teacher to find them in the clean copies.
The controlling idea. One claim, with a difference between the works, that the rest of the talk will test.
The route. One sentence of signposting tells the listener the shape of the next nine minutes.
The strong opening is about 120 words, under a minute at a natural pace, and contains no plot at all. It does not tell the teacher what happens in the play, which the teacher knows, but what the talk will show about it, which the teacher does not. Its last sentence is a promise that the talk must keep: if the listener has been told the play comes first, the play must come first.
Moving from extract to whole work
Each section starts in the extract and then widens to the work. The move needs a sentence that says why the extract stands for more than itself. In the transcript, the student makes it at the start of turn 2:
That moment is typical of the whole play, because the question of who decides keeps coming back to this room. Later, in Act Three, Walter calls Lindner back, and he means to take the money.
Transcript of the talk, turn 2
The first sentence makes a claim about the whole play and gives a reason for it, so the listener knows why the talk is leaving the extract. The second sentence goes to one other moment, not to a summary of three acts. Walter’s refusal is chosen because it answers the issue: the decision Lindner tried to make is finally made by the family. The section ends by stating that answer as Hansberry’s, which returns the talk to its controlling idea.
For a body of work the move is from the item to the other items. In turn 5 the student notes that the sheet is “a printed form, the same for every district in every city”. That phrase does in eight words what a minute of history could not: it tells the listener that the choices in this one sheet were repeated across the whole body of work. A sentence that widens the item to the body of work is worth more than a list of facts about the agency that made it.
Try it
In turn 4 the student analyzes the legend of the map. Write one sentence the student could add to move from this district’s colors to the body of work as a whole.
One possibility: The same four colors, in the same order, were used for more than 200 cities, so the verdict on this district was a method applied across the country, not one appraiser’s opinion. The sentence widens the item to the body of work, gives a precise fact about it, and states what that fact adds to the issue: the decision about where families could live was made systematically.
Signposts and references while speaking
A reader can look back over a page, but a listener cannot rewind a talk, so spoken analysis needs more signposting than written analysis: short statements of where the talk is and where it is going. Turn 3 is a signpost that also argues: “Now I want to turn to the maps, because they answer the same question from the other side.” The first half tells the listener the subject is changing, and the second half says why the change continues the argument. A signpost that only announces (“now the maps”) does the first job and not the second.
References to the extracts have to be just as clear. For a printed extract, give a line number from the clean copy, or quote a few words and say where they come from. In turn 1 the student quotes one sentence of Lindner’s and then reduces it to a single word, “happier”, so the listener holds onto one word while hearing what it does. For a visual item, point to a part: “If you look at the legend first” (turn 4) sends the teacher’s eyes to one place on the copy before the analysis begins. Long quotations read aloud waste time and lose the listener; a few words, precisely placed, do more.
The same minutes done badly
The faults of structure are easiest to hear in a talk that has none. The four turns that follow come from a weaker oral on the same pairing, at the point where the play section ends and the maps begin. The student knows both works and has the same extracts.
Turn 1 leaves the Lindner scene without a sentence on why it matters and tours the last act instead: the lost money, Mama’s anger, Beneatha’s doubts, the move, the plant. Each event is accurate, and none is connected to the issue. The same act gave the strong speaker one moment, Walter’s refusal, chosen because it answers the question of who decides. Plot fills the minutes that analysis needed, and criterion A rewards knowledge used for an interpretation, not knowledge displayed.
Turn 2 is the turn between works, and it carries no argument: “OK, now the maps” announces a change of subject and nothing more. The history that follows is accurate, but it is about the agency, not about the item, and it uses up the time in which the map should be read. Turn 3 reaches the map at last and gives it two short sentences, one describing the colors and one labeling them. “So it’s racist” is a verdict where an analysis should be: it names no choice in the map and says nothing about how the map presents the decision.
Turn 4 shows where the plan failed. With two minutes left the student has spent most of the talk on the play, and the ending falls back on a slogan that the issue was meant to replace. Every fault in the four turns comes from one missing thing, a controlling idea that would have told the student what to keep and what to cut. The strong transcript was planned around such an idea from the start.
A timed plan
A timed plan turns the shape into minutes. It is written in the learner portfolio, practiced aloud, and then cut down to the brief points of the outline. For the Hansberry pairing, worked out from the record on the page on choosing an issue and extracts, it runs as follows.
0:00–1:00. Introduction. Issue as a question; both works and both extracts; the controlling idea; the route.
1:00–3:30. The Lindner scene. His polite register; “our Negro families”; “happier”; the money offered; the family’s replies.
3:30–4:30. The whole play. Walter calls Lindner back and refuses; the family makes the decision itself.
4:30–5:00. The turn. A decision made to the family’s face; now one made out of its sight.
5:00–7:30. The district and its sheet. The legend’s colors and labels; the form’s headings; the flat official register; no names.
7:30–8:30. The body of work. The same form and colors for more than 200 cities; the debate over what the maps caused.
8:30–9:30. The two decisions side by side. Who speaks and who is spoken about, in each work.
9:30–10:00. Ending on the issue.
The plan gives each work about three and a half minutes and gives the extracts most of each. It also places the comparison twice: briefly at the turn, where it explains why the talk is moving, and fully near the end, where it becomes the talk’s conclusion. If time runs short on the day, the plan shows what to cut first, which is the body-of-work section, not the comparison.
Ending on the issue
The last half-minute should answer the issue, not summarize the talk. A summary repeats what the listener has just heard; an answer tells the listener what the two works, together, suggest about the question. The weak transcript ends on a summary and a slogan, “both works show that racism in housing was wrong” (turn 4), which could have been said before the talk began.
A strong ending for the same oral runs like this: So who decides where a family may live? The maps say the answer was settled far away, in a color on a sheet the family would never see. Hansberry’s play brings the decision back into the family’s living room and lets them refuse it, and in that sense the play is a reply to the maps. The ending returns to the question in its first words, gives each work its answer, and closes on what the comparison adds. It also hands the teacher an obvious first question, about whether a play can answer a policy, which is a good place for the questions to start.
Speaking from an outline, practicing for time
The timed plan becomes the outline by losing words. Lindner: our, happier, money is enough to start two and a half minutes of speech for a student who has practiced it; a full sentence is a temptation to read. Outlines are usually limited to about ten brief points; check with your teacher what yours may hold, and keep line numbers and a few key words, not prepared sentences.
Practice aloud with a timer, at least three times, and say the same points in different words each time. The first run is usually too long; the second shows which section to cut; the third should land near ten minutes. Record one practice and listen for the turns: if a listener could not tell when the talk moved from one work to the other, the signpost needs work. A practice talk on a different pairing builds the same habits without rehearsing the real one.
Where structure goes wrong
Four faults account for most lost marks on criterion C. A long introduction spends two or three minutes on background and plot, so the analysis starts late and the second work is rushed. One work dominates, usually the one the student finds easier to talk about, which is often the literary work. The second work is cut short when the time runs out, as in turn 4 of the weaker transcript. And the talk drifts into plot, tour by tour, until the issue has not been named for several minutes.
Each fault has a plan-level repair: an introduction written to the minute, sections with times, a turn that restates the issue, and a controlling idea to test every section against. The page on the five minutes of questions shows how the teacher’s questions extend the talk once it ends. The page of full orals at three bands shows whole talks with these plans, and these faults, marked against the criteria.
Self-check
- To do:
I can write a controlling idea that answers the global issue for both works and say how it differs from the issue itself.
- To do:
I can divide the ten minutes so that each work, and each extract and its work, receives fair time.
- To do:
I can choose between a work-by-work shape and an alternating shape for a pairing, and explain why.
- To do:
I can open an oral in about a minute with the issue, the works, the extracts, the controlling idea and the route.
- To do:
I can move from an extract to the whole work, and from one work to the other, with a signpost that also argues.
- To do:
I can refer to lines and to parts of an image precisely while speaking.
- To do:
I can end on the issue rather than a summary, and practice the talk from an outline rather than a script.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.
- Controlling idea
The single claim that holds a talk or an essay together. In the individual oral it says how the two works present the global issue and how their answers differ, and each section of the talk develops part of it.
Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
- 3Structuring the ten minutesThis page
HL essay
- 4The HL essayHL only
Individual oral
HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.