- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- Choosing a global issue and extracts
Choosing a global issue and extracts
How to turn a field of inquiry into a specific global issue, choose a literary work and a body of work that answer it differently, and choose extracts that show the issue at work.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
An individual oral is mostly decided before it is planned. The issue, the two works and the two extracts set the limits of what the talk can say, and a weak choice at this stage cannot be rescued by fluent speaking. A first planning page in a learner portfolio, for an oral on Lorraine Hansberry’s play A Raisin in the Sun and a set of maps made by a United States government agency in the 1930s, shows a common starting point:
From a field to an issue
Every line of the draft names something real, and the pairing behind it is a strong one. The trouble is that the draft has not yet asked a question. Paragraph 1 names a field of inquiry and then a subject in a place: “racism in America” tells the listener what the talk will be about, not what it will ask. Paragraph 4 goes further and states a verdict, that both works “show that racism was wrong”. A talk built on that sentence can only collect evidence for an opinion that nobody in the room disputes.
A global issue is a question of wide significance that a society argues about. It has three qualities. It matters on a wide scale, affecting large numbers of people. It crosses national borders, so it can be found in more than one society. And it is felt in everyday local life, in a particular street, house or family. The five fields of inquiry are where an issue starts: culture, identity and community; beliefs, values and education; politics, power and justice; art, creativity and the imagination; and science, technology and the environment. A field of inquiry is a starting point, too wide to be an issue on its own.
The five pages on the fields of inquiry each narrow a field in steps and test a draft issue against two texts. The same method repairs the draft. It begins with what the two works actually share, which is not racism in general but one kind of decision: who may live where.
The narrowing did not abandon the draft’s concern. Racism is still at the heart of the issue, but it now appears as a decision with a decision-maker, which is something a talk can analyze in the writing of a play and in the design of a map. The new question also sits between two fields. It belongs to politics, power and justice, because it asks who holds power over a home, and to culture, identity and community, because it asks who is allowed to belong to a neighborhood. Issues often sit on the border of two fields, and nothing is lost by saying so.
Writing the issue as a question
An issue is easiest to use when it is written as a question, because a question can be answered differently by each work. A statement tends to become a thesis that both works are made to prove. The draft’s fourth paragraph shows the problem in one line: “both show that racism was wrong” (paragraph 4) leaves the talk with nothing to discover, since the conclusion is already in the plan.
Four faults account for most weak issues. A field word or topic (“racism”, “power”, “identity”) asks nothing. A slogan or position (“racism was wrong”) asks nothing either, and turns analysis into agreement. An issue that is too narrow (how the Younger family spends its insurance money) fits one work and no other. An issue that fits only one of the two works, even if it is well phrased, leaves half the talk without a question. The repair in each case is the same: a question that names a decision or a tension, which both works answer and answer differently.
The improvement is easiest to see in the sentence that will open the outline. The two versions that follow are about the same pairing.
Weak: My global issue is racism in America.note 1 Both works show that racism was wrong and that Black families were treated unfairly in housing.note 2
Strong: My global issue is who decides where a family may live.note 3 The maps hand the decision to lenders and appraisers who never meet the families they grade, while Hansberry stages it in a family’s own living roomnote 4 and lets the family answer.note 5
A topic in a place. It names a subject and a country, but asks nothing the works could answer differently.
A verdict. The sentence agrees with both works instead of reading them, and the talk has nowhere to go after it.
A decision with a decision-maker. The question can be put to any work about housing, and its answer is open.
Two answers. Each work is given its own answer in a few words, through its own kind of evidence: who grades in the maps, where the scene is set in the play.
A contrast that drives the talk. The family’s reply is the difference that the second half of the oral will explore.
The strong version is longer by only a few words, but every part of it can be developed. Its question gives each section of the talk a job, and its two answers tell the listener why these two works belong together. It also avoids a verdict without avoiding a view: the student clearly thinks the family’s answer matters, but lets the works make the case.
More issues from each field
The five pages on the fields of inquiry each give several issues, with a pairing for each. The table adds two more for each field, all different from those, with one literary work and one body of work that present the issue. The pairings show the kind of match that works. They are not a list to choose from: your works must be ones you have studied in class, and the same issue can be found in many other works.
Field | Issue | A literary work | A body of work |
|---|---|---|---|
Culture, identity and community | Who decides what beauty looks like, and who is left out? | Toni Morrison, The Bluest Eye (1970): a Black girl in Ohio prays for blue eyes. | Dove’s Campaign for Real Beauty (from 2004): advertisements built on women who are not professional models. |
Culture, identity and community | Who has the right to name a place? | Brian Friel, Translations (1980): British soldiers mapping Donegal in 1833 turn Irish place names into English ones. | The Ordnance Survey’s name books for Ireland (1830s): surveyors’ records of each place name and the spelling chosen for the map. |
Beliefs, values and education | What does a society teach young men they must prove? | Chinua Achebe, Things Fall Apart (1958): Okonkwo’s fear of being thought weak like his father. | British recruitment posters of 1914 and 1915, which asked men to prove their courage by enlisting. |
Beliefs, values and education | What does a society owe the victims of a past regime: truth, justice or peace? | Ariel Dorfman, Death and the Maiden (1990): a woman believes a guest is the man who tortured her. | The South African Broadcasting Corporation’s weekly TRC Special Report (1996–1998) on the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. |
Politics, power and justice | Who decides where a family may live? | Lorraine Hansberry, A Raisin in the Sun (1959): a family buys a house in a neighborhood that does not want them. | The Home Owners’ Loan Corporation’s residential security maps (1935–1940): city districts graded for lending. |
Politics, power and justice | Whose account of a war does the public believe? | Tim O’Brien, The Things They Carried (1990): linked stories that question what a true war story is. | Larry Burrows’s photographs of the Vietnam War for Life magazine (1962–1971). |
Art, creativity and the imagination | Should art about real suffering be beautiful? | Art Spiegelman, Maus (1986–1991): the Holocaust drawn with Jews as mice and Germans as cats. | Sebastião Salgado’s photographs of people on the move, published as Migrations (2000). |
Art, creativity and the imagination | Why do people turn to stories and performance in a crisis? | Emily St. John Mandel, Station Eleven (2014): a traveling company performs Shakespeare after a pandemic. | StoryCorps’s recorded conversations between ordinary people (from 2003), kept at the Library of Congress. |
Science, technology and the environment | What may medicine take from a body, and who gives consent? | Kazuo Ishiguro, Never Let Me Go (2005): students raised to give their organs. | NHS Blood and Transplant’s advertisements for England’s move to an opt-out system of organ donation (2020). |
Science, technology and the environment | Whose freedom gives way in an epidemic, and who decides? | Albert Camus, The Plague (1947, in translation): an Algerian town sealed off during an outbreak. | The UK government’s “Stay home” campaign of 2020: posters, broadcasts and press briefings. |
The pairs differ in how the two works meet. Some meet only through the issue: Dorfman’s play is set in an unnamed country, and the South African broadcasts belong to a different place and a different decade. Others are joined by history as well. The Ordnance Survey’s name books are part of the record that Translations dramatizes, and historians of the survey have pointed out where the play departs from that record. A pairing of that kind gives criterion A a debate to weigh: how far a play may reshape the history it draws on.
Other pairs meet through a choice of method, which suits criterion B. Maus draws people as animals, which keeps its images plain, while Salgado’s photographs of refugees have been praised and criticized for being beautiful. The issue of whether suffering should be made beautiful can then be argued from the form of each work, the drawing in one and the composition and printing in the other, rather than from their subjects alone.
Choosing two works that answer differently
The task fixes the kinds of work: one literary work and one non-literary body of work, both studied in class. Within that rule the best pairings are works that present the issue from different positions, so that the talk has a contrast to explain. A Raisin in the Sun and the maps differ in almost every way that matters. One is a play written for a theater audience in 1959, the other a set of working documents made for lenders between 1935 and 1940. One speaks from inside a family; the other speaks about thousands of families it never names.
Those differences of form, purpose and position are what the oral analyzes. The play gives the issue a voice, a room and a moment of choice. The maps give it a color and a grade. A talk on two works that agree, such as two novels that both condemn segregation through a family’s story, would have less to explain, because the works would answer the question in the same way and by the same means.
Context can strengthen a pairing without taking it over. Hansberry’s own family bought a house in a white neighborhood of Chicago in the late 1930s and had to defend the purchase in court, a case that reached the United States Supreme Court in 1940. The Chicago map was drawn in the same city at about the same time. One sentence of that history in the talk shows the listener why the two works speak to each other; three minutes of it would leave the texts behind.
Pairings often cross the areas of exploration, the three ways of studying texts around which English A is organized. A class may meet the maps while studying Time and space, as documents shaped by the moment that produced them, and the play while studying Readers, writers and texts, as a work whose choices shape an audience’s sympathy. The oral brings the two together, and the questions each area asks become ways of comparing them. The concepts help in the same way: perspective asks whose position each work speaks from, and representation asks how each shows the families it is about.
Choosing extracts that show the issue in the writing
The draft chose its extract from the play “because it introduces the whole Younger family” (paragraph 2). That is a reason to read the scene first, not a reason to analyze it. An extract earns its place when the issue can be seen at work in its choices: in the dialogue, the stage directions, the structure of the scene or the arrangement of an image. The opening of the play sets up the insurance check, but the question of who decides where the family may live has not yet been asked.
The scene that asks it is the visit of Karl Lindner in Act Two, Scene Three. The family is packing to move when Lindner arrives from the Clybourne Park Improvement Association. He speaks politely of “special community problems” and offers to buy the house back from them. The center of his speech is one sentence:
…for the happiness of all concerned that our Negro families are happier when they live in their own communities.
Lorraine Hansberry, A Raisin in the Sun, Act Two, Scene Three
The line is a decision about where the family may live, made by people they have never met and delivered in the language of kindness. The possessive “our Negro families” claims to speak for Black families while excluding them, and “happiness” turns exclusion into a favor. Lindner also insists that “race prejudice simply doesn’t enter into” the association’s wishes, which makes his politeness the scene’s main euphemism. An extract of about 40 lines, from Lindner’s entrance to his exit, holds every feature the issue needs: his register, the family’s replies, the stage directions around their replies, and the offer of money.
The scene also connects outward to the whole play, which criterion A asks for. Later, when the family has lost much of its money, Walter calls Lindner back intending to take the offer, and then, with his son watching, refuses it. The decision Lindner tried to make for the family is finally made by the family. An extract that points forward to that ending gives the talk its line from the extract to the work.
Choosing an item from a body of work
The draft’s choice of item, “the map of Chicago” (paragraph 3), is too large to analyze closely in four minutes and too general to show the issue in detail. Choosing an item from a body of work means choosing between two kinds of value. A representative item shows the method that the whole body of work shares: any graded city map shows how the four colors divided a city. A revealing item presents that method at its most telling, where the choices are visible and the issue is plain.
For the maps, the revealing item is one red-graded district on Chicago’s South Side, shown on its section of the map together with the area description sheet that went with it. The map’s legend ranks districts from green for the “Best” to red for “Hazardous”, so a color carries a judgment. The sheet records that judgment in words, on a printed form that asked appraisers about “favorable” and “detrimental” influences and about the “infiltration” of groups they considered a risk. The sheet’s flat, official register is itself a choice that the talk can analyze.
The pair of map section and sheet is a short sequence that shows the issue in both image and words. It still lets the student speak about the body of work as a whole, since the same form, the same colors and the same vocabulary were used for more than 200 cities. Teachers differ on how much may count as one item, so check whether a map section and its sheet can be brought together. A limit of the body of work belongs in the talk too. Historians disagree about how far the maps caused unequal lending and how far they recorded lending practices that already existed, a debate that bears directly on who decided.
Testing the choice
The draft’s last line asks the right question: “can I really talk for four minutes about a map?” (paragraph 5). A useful test of any choice is whether you could speak for about four minutes on each extract, with the work around it, and for about two minutes on what the two together show about the issue. The figures are a guide to proportion, not a rule. If one extract runs dry after a minute, it is the wrong extract, or the issue is not one that the extract presents.
Applied to the revised choice, the test passes. The Lindner scene gives four minutes easily: his register, the possessive pronoun, the offer of money, the family’s replies and the line forward to Walter’s refusal. The map section and its sheet give four minutes too: the legend’s colors and labels, the headings of the form, the official register, what the sheet never mentions, and the place of one district in a graded city. The two minutes of connection have a clear subject: a decision made to a family’s face against a decision made where the family could never see it.
Try it
The draft chose the opening of Act One, Scene One as its extract. Apply the four-minute test to it. Would the scene carry the issue of who decides where a family may live?
Only weakly. The scene shows the crowded apartment and the family’s hopes for the insurance check, so a student could speak about the need for a better home. But no one in the scene decides where the family may live, and no one outside the family decides it for them. Most of four minutes would become description of the characters and the situation, which is plot rather than the issue at work in the writing. The Lindner scene puts the decision on stage.
The worked pair in full
A pairing is ready when it can be written down as a short record. The record names the issue, where each extract comes from, what each shows through its choices, what the contrast between them adds, and the order of the talk in outline. The record goes into the learner portfolio and becomes the source of the outline. The table sets it out for the Hansberry pairing.
Part of the record | The Hansberry pairing |
|---|---|
Issue | Who decides where a family may live? |
Literary work and extract | Lorraine Hansberry, A Raisin in the Sun (1959): Act Two, Scene Three, from Lindner’s entrance to his exit, about 40 lines. |
What the extract shows | Exclusion spoken as kindness (“happier when they live in their own communities”); a possessive that speaks for Black families while excluding them; money offered to settle the decision; a family in the room, able to reply. |
Body of work and item | The Home Owners’ Loan Corporation’s residential security maps (1935–1940): one red-graded district on Chicago’s South Side, its section of the map and its area description sheet. |
What the item shows | Color as a grade from “Best” to “Hazardous”; a printed form with headings for “detrimental” influences and “infiltration”; a flat official register; no names and no voices. |
What the contrast shows | The play stages the decision where the family can hear and refuse it; the maps make it where the family can never see it. Hansberry gives the family the last word that the maps deny. |
The talk in outline | Issue and works; the Lindner scene and its line to Walter’s refusal; the map section and sheet and their place in the graded city; the two decisions set side by side; the issue today, in one sentence. |
The record is short, but each row has been tested against the texts. The quotations come from the extract, the features are choices that can be analyzed, and the contrast names a difference in how each work presents the issue, not in what each is about. The diagram sets the two columns of features side by side, with the contrast between them in the middle.


The page on structuring the ten minutes builds a full timed plan from this record, and shows passages of the talk done well and badly. The page on the five minutes of questions uses the same pairing for its worked exchanges, so the record is worth keeping complete.
Where choices go wrong
Most weak choices can be found in the draft, which makes it a useful checklist. Its extract from the play was chosen for plot, because it “introduces the whole Younger family” (paragraph 2). Its item from the body of work was chosen for size and setting, “because the play is set in Chicago” (paragraph 3), not because the map shows the issue in detail. Its issue was a topic, and its reason for pairing the works was a verdict. Each fault is common, and each has a repair already shown: a scene where the issue is spoken, an item where it is visible, a question in place of a topic, and a contrast in place of agreement.
A fourth fault is harder to see in a plan: an item from a body of work that does not present the issue at all. A green-graded district’s sheet, praising a suburb’s houses and residents, shows the method of the maps but not the families it judged, so a talk on it would have to describe the issue from outside the item. Choosing the item that presents the issue in its own choices saves the talk from explaining what the extract does not show.
Self-check
- To do:
I can narrow a field of inquiry to a specific global issue in steps and test it against the three qualities of a global issue.
- To do:
I can phrase an issue as an open question and repair an issue that is a topic, a slogan, too narrow or fitted to one work.
- To do:
I can name further issues in each field, with a literary work and a body of work that present each.
- To do:
I can choose two works that present an issue from different positions, and explain the contrast between them.
- To do:
I can choose an extract in which the issue is at work in the writing, and explain why a scene chosen for plot is weaker.
- To do:
I can choose a representative or a revealing item from a body of work and justify the choice.
- To do:
I can test a choice of issue and extracts and record a pairing in full in my learner portfolio.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.
- Area of exploration
One of the three ways of studying texts into which the course is organized: Readers, writers and texts; Time and space; and Intertextuality: connecting texts. Each is led by six questions about how texts make meaning.
- Extract
A short passage from a literary work, or one item or short sequence from a body of work, chosen to stand for the work in the individual oral because it shows the global issue at work in the writing or the image.
- Field of inquiry
One of the five broad areas from which a global issue is drawn: culture, identity and community; beliefs, values and education; politics, power and justice; art, creativity and the imagination; and science, technology and the environment. A field is a starting point, too wide to be an issue itself.
- Global issue
A question of wide significance that crosses national borders and is felt in everyday local life. In the individual oral it is the question that the literary work and the body of work both present.
Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit
Individual oral
- 1The individual oral
- 2Choosing a global issue and extractsThis page
- 3Structuring the ten minutes
HL essay
- 4The HL essayHL only
Individual oral
HL essay
- 7Finding a line of inquiryHL only
- 8Structuring the HL essayHL only
- 9An HL essay at each bandHL only
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.