Finding a line of inquiry

How to turn a first idea about a work or body of work into a line of inquiry for the HL essay, test it before committing, open it through the concepts, and use secondary sources without letting them take over.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

20 min readLast reviewed

A line of inquiry is a question about how one work or body of work makes meaning. Good lines are rarely chosen in advance; they are found in the work, in a feature that keeps returning and a question about what it does. The nine passages that follow are the notes one student gathered while rereading James Joyce’s Dubliners (1914): moments from five of its fifteen stories where a character stands at a window.

Dubliners, passages on windows from “The Sisters”, “Araby”, “Eveline”, “A Little Cloud” and “The Dead”Dubliners, 1914James Joyce, Dubliners (London: Grant Richards, 1914), pages 9, 34, 38, 42, 48, 85, 237, 275 and 277–278
There was no hope for him this time: it was the third stroke. Night after night I had passed the house (it was vacation time) and studied the lighted square of window: and night after night I had found it lighted in the same way, faintly and evenly. If he was dead, I thought, I would see the reflection of candles on the darkened blind for I knew that two candles must be set at the head of a corpse. He had often said to me: ‘I am not long for this world,’ and I had thought his words idle. Now I knew they were true. Every night as I gazed up at the window I said softly to myself the word paralysis.
Every morning I lay on the floor in the front parlour watching her door. The blind was pulled down to within an inch of the sash so that I could not be seen.
From the front window I saw my companions playing below in the street. Their cries reached me weakened and indistinct and, leaning my forehead against the cool glass, I looked over at the dark house where she lived.
She sat at the window watching the evening invade the avenue. Her head was leaned against the window curtains and in her nostrils was the odour of dusty cretonne. She was tired.
He rushed beyond the barrier and called to her to follow. He was shouted at to go on but he still called to her. She set her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal. Her eyes gave him no sign of love or farewell or recognition.
He turned often from his tiresome writing to gaze out of the office window. The glow of a late autumn sunset covered the grass plots and walks. It cast a shower of kindly golden dust on the untidy nurses and decrepit old men who drowsed on the benches; it flickered upon all the moving figures—on the children who ran screaming along the gravel paths and on everyone who passed through the gardens. He watched the scene and thought of life; and (as always happened when he thought of life) he became sad.
Gabriel’s warm trembling fingers tapped the cold pane of the window. How cool it must be outside! How pleasant it would be to walk out alone, first along by the river and then through the park!
‘Then the night before I left I was in my grandmother’s house in Nuns’ Island, packing up, and I heard gravel thrown up against the window. The window was so wet I couldn’t see so I ran downstairs as I was and slipped out the back into the garden and there was the poor fellow at the end of the garden, shivering.’
A few light taps upon the pane made him turn to the window. It had begun to snow again. He watched sleepily the flakes, silver and dark, falling obliquely against the lamplight. The time had come for him to set out on his journey westward. Yes, the newspapers were right: snow was general all over Ireland.

Read together, the passages already suggest a question. In the first four a character watches through glass, from a priest’s “lighted square of window” (paragraph 1) to Eveline sitting “at the window watching the evening invade the avenue” (paragraph 4). In the last three, from “The Dead”, the pattern bends: Gretta once heard “gravel thrown up against the window” and ran outside to the boy who threw it (paragraph 8). Turning that pattern into a question an essay can answer takes several steps.

The three parts of a line of inquiry

A strong line of inquiry has three parts. It names the work. It names a feature or method of the writing that the essay will follow, such as an image, a narrator’s vocabulary, a staging choice or a layout. And it names a concern: what the feature is doing, the meaning or tension the essay will test. The Dubliners line has all three: the collection, its windows, and characters who watch a life they cannot enter.

The diagram shows the three parts combining into a line, once for a literary work and once for a non-literary body of work, Sebastião Salgado’s Workers (1993), a book of black-and-white photographs of manual labor around the world. In each case the feature is something an essay can quote or describe precisely, and the concern is a question rather than a fact.

Diagram in two rows. Each row has three boxes on the left (work, feature or method, concern) with arrows into a line of inquiry on the right. Top: Dubliners, windows, watching not living. Bottom: Salgado’s Workers, crowded heroic frames, dignity or spectacle.Diagram in two rows. Each row has three boxes on the left (work, feature or method, concern) with arrows into a line of inquiry on the right. Top: Dubliners, windows, watching not living. Bottom: Salgado’s Workers, crowded heroic frames, dignity or spectacle.
A line of inquiry combines three parts. The feature tells the essay what to analyze; the concern tells it what to find out.

Each part limits the essay usefully. The work keeps it on one text. The feature gives criterion B something precise to analyze in every paragraph. The concern gives criterion A an interpretation to build and gives the essay a direction, since it can be answered more or less fully. A question missing any of the three tends to fail in a predictable way: without a feature it summarizes, and without a concern it lists.

From a topic to a question

Most lines of inquiry begin as topics. A topic is where reading starts, and the trouble comes only if the essay stops there. The word that first caught the student’s attention in Dubliners is the one the boy of “The Sisters” repeats to himself at the priest’s window: “the word paralysis” (paragraph 1). Paralysis is the collection’s best-known theme, and an essay on it would have plenty to say and nothing to argue. The worked example follows the student from that word to a line.

Two moves in the example matter more than the others. The fourth step makes clear that a feature on its own is not enough: a question about windows with no concern produces a catalog. The sixth shows the value of evidence that does not fit. The passages from “The Dead” could have been left out as exceptions; written into the line, they give the essay its last and most interesting section.

Questions that can be answered partly

A line of inquiry is a question, but not every question makes an essay. A question that can be answered with a plain “yes” is settled in the first paragraph, and the rest of the essay can only repeat the answer with more examples. A strong line can be answered “partly”, or in some ways more than others, so the essay has somewhere to go. The two versions of the Dubliners line that follow use the same feature and the same evidence.

Weaker: Does Joyce use windows to show paralysis in Dubliners?note 1

Stronger: How does Joyce use windows in Dubliners to present characters who watch a life they cannot enter,note 2 and how far does “The Dead” change that pattern?note 3

  1. Answered in a word. The honest answer is “yes”, and an essay that begins with its answer settled can only add examples. Paralysis is also a theme word, so the question says nothing the collection does not already say of itself.

  2. How, not whether. “How does Joyce use” asks for analysis of a method. “Watch a life they cannot enter” states the concern in words that can be tested against each story.

  3. A question of degree. “How far” invites an answer between yes and no. It points to the evidence that resists the pattern (Gretta running out, Gabriel’s widening view) and gives the essay a final step.

The phrase how far is useful but not essential. To what extent, in what ways and with what effect do the same work, because each asks for a judgment rather than a fact. What matters is that the question leaves room for evidence on both sides, so that the essay weighs it.

A question of degree also protects the essay from a common weakness: the essay that proves its point too easily. If every window in the collection fitted the pattern, an examiner would wonder whether the pattern had been imposed. The windows of “The Dead”, where Gretta once crossed the boundary the others only look through, make the reading more convincing because the essay has to account for them.

Testing a line before you commit

A line of inquiry should be tested before a single paragraph is drafted, because a weak line costs most when it is discovered late. Five questions make the test. They can be answered in an afternoon with the work open and a page of notes.

  • Is there enough evidence? Find at least six to eight moments across the work or body of work where the feature appears. Fewer than that, and the essay will stretch two examples over 1,500 words.

  • Does it need analysis, or only plot? If the question could be answered by retelling what happens, it asks about events, not about how the work is written.

  • Is there room to argue? Look for evidence against your first answer. A line with no counter-evidence is usually too obvious to be worth an essay.

  • Does it fit 1,500 words? A line that would need every chapter, every character or every poem to answer is too broad. Narrow the feature or the part of the work.

  • Can it be answered from the work? A question that needs the writer’s private life, or facts no reader could find in the text, will take the essay away from analysis.

Applied to the Dubliners line, the test is passed. Nine passages from five stories give the evidence, and each needs close reading rather than retelling: the inch of the blind, the passive “was leaned”, the exclamations Gabriel never speaks. The windows of “The Dead” supply the counter-evidence. The line is narrow enough, because it follows one image rather than the whole of Dublin, and every claim can be checked against the page.

Try it

A student proposes this line: How does Glaspell show that Minnie Wright killed her husband in Trifles? Run it through the five tests. What fails, and how could it be repaired?

It fails the second test: the answer is a matter of plot (the broken birdcage and the dead canary the women find), so the essay would retell the play’s discovery scene. It also fails the third, since the play leaves little doubt about who killed John Wright. A repair keeps the feature the student noticed, the evidence. It turns that feature into a question about method: How does Glaspell make the kitchen’s objects into a kind of testimony that only the women can read, and what does the audience’s knowledge do to the play’s last line?

Opening lines through the concepts

The seven concepts of English A (identity, culture, creativity, communication, perspective, transformation and representation) are useful for finding lines, because each one asks a different kind of question of the same work. The pages on each concept explain them fully. Here each works as a door: choose a concept, ask what it would notice in the work, and see whether a feature answers.

Applied to Dubliners, three of the concepts open different lines. Perspective asks who is watching and from where, which is the windows line itself. Transformation asks what changes, and points to Gabriel in “The Dead”, whose view of his wife and of himself changes in one night. Identity asks how characters see themselves, and might follow Little Chandler’s idea of himself as a poet against the life he leads. Each concept would produce a different essay on the same book.

The same doors open on other works. Trifles, Susan Glaspell’s one-act play of 1916, is set in the kitchen of a farmhouse where a man has been killed. The men search the house for a motive while two women, left in the kitchen, find it. The sheriff dismisses the room in five words:

Nothing here but kitchen things.

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916)

Representation asks how the play represents the absent wife through objects: the preserves, the quilt, the birdcage. Communication asks how the women speak in front of the men without being understood. At the end, when the county attorney asks whether Minnie meant to quilt the quilt or knot it, Mrs. Hale answers with a phrase that is also a secret: “We call it—knot it, Mr. Henderson.” A line that follows the double meanings of the women’s speech opens through communication; a line that follows the objects opens through representation.

The areas of exploration as starting points

The three areas of exploration open lines too. Readers, writers and texts asks how a text positions its reader, which suits lines about sympathy, irony or a narrator’s reliability. Time and space asks how context shapes a text, and suits lines that use history as evidence for a feature rather than as a subject. Intertextuality asks how texts answer other texts, and suits a line on a work that rewrites an earlier one, though the essay must stay on the one work it is written on.

Lines for a literary work

A literary work offers depth: a feature can be followed from the first page to the last and read differently each time it returns. Lines for a literary work tend to follow one of a few kinds of feature. A recurring image, like the windows of Dubliners. A narrator’s voice and how far it can be trusted. A staging choice in a play, such as the objects of the kitchen in Trifles. Or, in a graphic work, a drawing style. The table turns three topics into lines on works often studied.

Topic

Line of inquiry

Why it works

War in Persepolis

How does Marjane Satrapi’s plain black-and-white drawing present violence that a realistic style would make either unbearable or unreal?

The feature (the drawing style) is visible on every page, and the question weighs a gain against a loss.

Cloning in Never Let Me Go

How does the calm vocabulary of Kathy’s narration (carer, donations, complete) make the students’ fate seem ordinary, and where does that vocabulary fail her?

It follows a narrator’s words across the novel, and the second half looks for the moments that break the pattern.

Creation in Frankenstein

How does Mary Shelley’s frame of letters and retold stories shape how far the creature’s own voice can be heard?

It asks about structure, a feature many essays ignore, and the creature’s chapters supply evidence on both sides.

Each of these lines names a feature of the writing that an essay can quote or describe in every paragraph. The Persepolis line asks about Satrapi’s drawing, not about the Iranian revolution; the history matters only as what the drawings show. The Never Let Me Go line asks about three ordinary words that Kazuo Ishiguro’s narrator uses for terrible things, so the essay’s evidence is her vocabulary. The Frankenstein line asks about the novel’s structure: the creature’s story reaches the reader only through Victor Frankenstein’s telling, written down in the letters of the explorer Robert Walton.

Works still in copyright, such as Persepolis and Never Let Me Go, are quoted in an HL essay in the same way as any other: briefly, exactly and with a citation. Public-domain works such as Frankenstein, Dubliners and Trifles are no different in the essay. The difference is only that they can be read and checked freely in old printings.

Lines for a non-literary body of work

A non-literary body of work offers what a single text cannot: a pattern across items. A line for a body of work usually asks how its texts make meaning together, through a strategy a campaign repeats, a style a photographer keeps, or a persona a columnist builds week by week. Which bodies of work your class studies, and what counts as one, is your teacher’s decision.

Topic

Line of inquiry

Why it works

Labor in Salgado’s Workers

How do the crowded, heroic frames of Sebastião Salgado’s Workers (1993) give manual laborers dignity, and do they also turn their suffering into spectacle?

One visual strategy recurs across the book, and the second question opens a real debate about beauty and suffering.

Beauty in a soap brand’s advertising

How do the print advertisements of the Campaign for Real Beauty, launched in 2004, borrow the conventions of beauty advertising to argue against them, and how far does selling soap limit that argument?

It reads a campaign’s method across many advertisements and asks the essay to judge the campaign’s own contradiction.

Women in Fanny Fern’s columns

How does Fanny Fern build a sharp, comic persona across her weekly columns for the New York Ledger, and what does the persona let her say that a woman writing in the 1850s could not say plainly?

It follows one feature (the persona) across many texts by one writer, and asks what the feature makes possible.

The three lines cover the three commonest kinds of body of work. Workers is a photographer’s series: images of mining, shipbreaking, fishing and other manual labor, taken in many countries over several years, most of them crowded with bodies and shot from angles that make the workers look monumental. The Campaign for Real Beauty is an advertising campaign by the soap and skin-care brand Dove, which used women of different ages and body shapes in place of professional models. Fanny Fern was the pen name of Sara Willis, whose weekly newspaper columns, written from the mid-1850s, made her one of the best-paid newspaper writers in the United States.

Each line asks what the items do together, which no single photograph, advertisement or column could show. A body of work also asks for precise description, since an essay on photographs cannot quote them. Analyzing visual items, citing each one and describing it exactly, is covered in the account of structuring the HL essay.

Using secondary sources

The work or body of work your essay analyzes is its primary source: every claim is tested against it. Anything else you read for the essay is a secondary source: criticism, a biography, a history of the period, a review, even the writer’s own letters or interviews. Secondary sources are optional in the HL essay. An essay that uses none can reach the top band, because the criteria reward your own analysis of the work.

Used well, a secondary source sharpens a line. The boy of “The Sisters” repeats one word to himself at the priest’s window:

Every night as I gazed up at the window I said softly to myself the word paralysis.

James Joyce, “The Sisters”, Dubliners (paragraph 1)

In a letter to his publisher of May 1906, Joyce wrote that he had set his stories in Dublin because the city seemed to him the “centre of paralysis”. An essay on the windows could use the letter in one sentence, to show that the word in “The Sisters” carries weight for the whole collection. It could then test the claim against the stories, and against “The Dead” in particular, which complicates it. Here the source serves the line: it states a view the essay goes on to examine.

Used badly, a source takes the essay over. An essay on Salgado’s Workers might quote the critic Ingrid Sischy, whose article “Good Intentions” (The New Yorker, 1991) argued that the beauty of Salgado’s photographs of suffering risks turning the suffering into a matter of aesthetics. If the essay simply agrees and illustrates her view, the argument is hers. If it sets her view beside the photographs and judges where it holds and where it does not, the argument is the student’s, and the source has made it stronger.

Where lines go wrong

Most weak lines fail in one of four ways, and each can be repaired by moving the question closer to the writing. A topic names a subject with no question: Paralysis in Dubliners. The repair is to find the feature that shows the subject, as the windows show paralysis. A question that is too broad asks about a whole world: How does Joyce present Dublin? That question would need every story; the repair narrows the feature or the part of the work.

A question about the writer’s life asks for biography: How did Joyce’s exile from Ireland shape Dubliners? An essay on it would be built on facts outside the stories. The repair keeps the interest but moves it into the work, for example by asking how the stories present characters who think of leaving. A question that needs only plot asks what happens: Why does Eveline not leave with Frank? The repair asks how the story presents her choice, which leads straight back to the window where she sits.

A tested line is the start of the essay’s structure, since the line’s parts already suggest the sections. Structuring the HL essay turns the Dubliners line into a full plan, section by section, and three complete essays at different bands show what the line becomes on the page.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can name the three parts of a line of inquiry and turn a topic into a line.

  • To do:

    I can find a line in a recurring feature of a work or body of work.

  • To do:

    I can write a line that can be answered “partly”, with evidence on both sides.

  • To do:

    I can test a line against the work for evidence, analysis, room to argue, length and focus.

  • To do:

    I can use a concept or an area of exploration to find a feature and a question.

  • To do:

    I can write lines for a literary work and for a non-literary body of work.

  • To do:

    I can tell primary from secondary sources and use a secondary source without letting it replace my argument.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Primary source HL only

In an essay on a text, the work or body of work the essay analyzes, which supplies its evidence. Every claim in the essay is tested against it.

Secondary source HL only

Any text other than the work under study that an essay draws on, such as criticism, a biography, a historical study or a writer’s letters. It can sharpen or challenge an argument but cannot replace the essay’s own analysis of the work.

Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes

HL essay

  1. 4The HL essay

Individual oral

  1. 5The five minutes of questions
  2. 6An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 7Finding a line of inquiryThis page
  2. 8Structuring the HL essay
  3. 9An HL essay at each band

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.