Structuring the HL essay

How to build an HL essay of 1,500 words: an introduction with a thesis, sections that each deepen the last, integrated quotation, counter-readings, a conclusion, consistent citation, and redrafting to the word limit.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

19 min readLast reviewed

An HL essay is organized around its answer, not around the order of the work. Its sections climb: each answers a smaller question that the last one raised, so that the essay knows more at the end than at the beginning. The four topic sentences that follow open the four sections of an essay on James Joyce’s Dubliners. Its line of inquiry is How does Joyce use windows in Dubliners to present characters who watch a life they cannot enter, and how far does “The Dead” change that pattern?

The boys of the first stories watch from behind glass by choice: the window lets them look at a life they are not ready to enter.note 1

Eveline’s window turns that safety into a trap, because for the first time the watcher is offered a way out and must decide.note 2

Little Chandler moves the pattern from life to art, since he believes that a man who watches might turn what he sees into poetry.note 3

“The Dead” at last puts someone on the other side of the glass, and that changes what Gabriel’s final window can show.note 4

  1. The first step. The section sets up the pattern in its simplest form, and the word choice gives the next section something to change.

  2. A step up. “Turns that safety into a trap” names how this section changes the last one. The section could not come first.

  3. A new question. The pattern is tested in a new area, art, which raises the stakes: watching might be useful after all.

  4. The turn. The last section brings in the evidence that resists the pattern, and prepares the essay’s answer to “how far”.

Read in order, the topic sentences are already an argument. Each one refers back to the last (“that safety”, “the pattern”) and forward to a new question. The diagram sets the same essay out as a staircase: the introduction at the bottom, four sections each a step higher, and the conclusion at the top, where the essay can see the whole collection at once.

Diagram: a staircase of six blocks rising from left to right: Introduction (line, thesis and route); 1, watching unseen (The Sisters, Araby); 2, choosing the glass (Eveline); 3, the poet’s view (A Little Cloud); 4, crossing over (The Dead); Conclusion.Diagram: a staircase of six blocks rising from left to right: Introduction (line, thesis and route); 1, watching unseen (The Sisters, Araby); 2, choosing the glass (Eveline); 3, the poet’s view (A Little Cloud); 4, crossing over (The Dead); Conclusion.
The plan of the Dubliners essay as a staircase. Each section answers a question the one below it raised; none could be moved without breaking the climb.

An introduction that states the line and the answer

The introduction of an HL essay has three jobs, and it should do them in about 150 words. It states the line of inquiry, often as the essay’s title and again in a sentence. It gives the essay’s answer, the thesis, before any evidence arrives. And it sets out the route: which parts of the work, or which items of the body of work, the sections will take in order. A sentence of context is welcome if the line needs it; a paragraph of biography or plot is not.

The thesis is the sentence the whole essay serves. In an HL essay it answers the line directly, including any “how far”, so an examiner knows from the first paragraph what the essay will prove. The two theses that follow are written for the same line.

Weaker: In this essay I will look at windows in Dublinersnote 1 and show how they are used to show paralysis in different stories.note 2

Stronger: Joyce makes the window the collection’s image of watching instead of living: it shelters the children of the early stories, traps Eveline and flatters Little Chandler’s idea of himself as a poet.note 3 Only “The Dead” lets anyone through, and then only in memory, so the last window widens Gabriel’s view without moving him.note 4

  1. A promise, not a claim. “I will look at” tells the examiner what the essay will do, not what it will find. Nothing in the sentence could be argued with.

  2. No answer. “Used to show paralysis” repeats the topic; it gives no reason to read on and no plan for the sections.

  3. A claim with a route. The first sentence makes the argument and names, in order, the stories the first three sections will take. Each verb (shelters, traps, flatters) marks a different step.

  4. The answer to “how far”. The second sentence says exactly how far “The Dead” changes the pattern, which is the claim the last section must prove.

The stronger thesis is longer, but it saves words later, because each section can open by referring back to it. It also commits the essay to something an examiner could disagree with, which is what makes it a thesis. If you cannot imagine a reader who might argue with your thesis, it is probably a description.

Sections that develop rather than list

The commonest structure for an essay on a literary work follows the work’s own order, a section per chapter or per story. It is easy to plan and usually produces a list: the same point found in one place after another. Criterion C asks for development, so the sections must climb instead. The way to make them climb is to give each section its own sub-question, smaller than the line of inquiry and raised by the section before.

For the Dubliners essay the sub-questions might be these. Why do the first watchers stay behind the glass? What happens when a watcher is offered a way out? Can watching become something useful, such as art? Does anyone ever cross, and what does that do to the pattern? Each question needs the answer to the last one before it can be asked, so the order of the sections is fixed by the argument. It happens to follow the order of the book here; in many essays it will not.

Topic sentences as steps

Each section opens with a topic sentence that states its step in the argument. A topic sentence in an HL essay does two things. It answers the section’s sub-question in brief, and it links that answer to the section before, so that the examiner can follow the climb. The four topic sentences of the Dubliners essay show the form: “turns that safety into a trap” could only follow a section about safety.

A quick test of a plan is to read the topic sentences alone, without the paragraphs under them. If they make an argument, the essay develops. If they could be shuffled without loss (Another story with a window is…, Windows also appear in…), it lists, however good the analysis inside each section.

Planning in topic sentences also saves words. A section whose step is clear needs no announcement of what it will do, and no summary at its end of what it has done.

Integrating quotation

An HL essay is written with the work open, so its quotations can be exact, short and placed precisely. The ending of “Eveline” gives the second section of the Dubliners essay its key evidence: the moment at the barrier when Frank calls to her and she does not move.

She set her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal. Her eyes gave him no sign of love or farewell or recognition.

James Joyce, “Eveline”, Dubliners (1914), page 48

The two sentences could be copied into the essay whole, followed by a comment. A stronger essay works them into its own sentences. An integrated quotation is a short quotation that becomes part of the grammar of the writer’s sentence, so that the evidence and the analysis of it are read together. The two versions that follow use the same lines.

Weaker: Eveline does not go with Frank. “She set her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal. Her eyes gave him no sign of love or farewell or recognition.”note 1 This shows that she is paralyzed.note 2

Stronger: At the barrier Eveline sets “her white face to him, passive, like a helpless animal” (Joyce 48).note 3 The simile makes her a creature penned in, and the list that follows, “no sign of love or farewell or recognition” (48), removes each bond with Frank in turn until he is a stranger.note 4 The watcher at the window has become the one watched, and she gives nothing back.note 5

  1. A dropped quotation. Two whole sentences stand alone, introduced by nothing and cited nowhere. The examiner must work out why they are there.

  2. A comment that could follow anything. “This shows” attaches a label without saying which words show it, or how.

  3. Integrated. The quotation is cut to the words that matter and the sentence’s grammar runs through it. The verb is changed to the present outside the quotation marks, where the essay’s own tense rules.

  4. Each part analyzed. The simile and the list are read separately, and the analysis is as long as the quotation.

  5. Back to the line. The last sentence ties the detail to the essay’s question about watching.

Three conventions keep integrated quotation honest. Words inside quotation marks are exactly as the edition prints them, spelling included: an essay quoting the 1914 Dubliners keeps its “parlour” and “odour”. A word left out is marked with an ellipsis (…), and a word changed or added to fit the sentence goes in square brackets. A quotation of more than about four lines is set as a block, indented and without quotation marks, but an HL essay rarely needs one: its word limit is better spent on analysis than on long stretches of the work.

Visual items in a body of work

An essay on a non-literary body of work often analyzes images that it cannot quote. A photograph, a poster or an advertisement’s layout must be described precisely enough for an examiner to see what the analysis sees, and cited so that they could find it. The photographs Lewis Hine took for the National Child Labor Committee from 1908 are a body of work often studied; one of them, A Little Spinner in the Mollahan Mills, Newberry, S.C. (1908), shows a young girl standing in the aisle between two long spinning frames. The paragraph that follows is from an essay on how Hine’s photographs and captions work together as evidence.

In A Little Spinner in the Mollahan Mills (Hine, 3 Dec. 1908), the two spinning frames run from the edges of the picture and meet near its center, where she stands, so that the lines of the machinery lead the eye to her small figure.note 1 She looks straight into the camera without smiling, and the frames, lined with hundreds of bobbins, dwarf her.note 2 The composition makes the argument before the caption speaks: a child placed at the center of the machine is part of it.note 3 Hine’s caption then quotes the overseer’s excuse that she “just happened in”, and the photograph, by showing her at work among the frames, answers him.note 4

  1. Described and cited. The item is named and dated, and its composition is described in terms an examiner can check: where the lines run and where they meet.

  2. Precise visual detail. Gaze and scale are described exactly, which gives the analysis something to work on.

  3. Analysis of the image. The paragraph says what the composition does, as it would say what a metaphor does.

  4. Image and words together. The caption is quoted briefly and read against the photograph, which is what a line on a body of work like this one asks for.

The paragraph treats the photograph as a text with its own choices: framing, the placing of the figure, the direction of gaze, the scale of the machines. Those choices are analyzed with the same care as words in a story. Visual analysis has its own vocabulary, taught with the images of the toolkit, and an HL essay on a body of work uses it in the same way.

Handling counter-readings

A strong HL essay uses the evidence that resists its thesis. In the Dubliners essay that evidence comes in “The Dead”, when Gretta tells her husband about a boy who loved her when she was young. On the night before she left Galway he came to her grandmother’s house in the rain:

‘Then the night before I left I was in my grandmother’s house in Nuns’ Island, packing up, and I heard gravel thrown up against the window. The window was so wet I couldn’t see so I ran downstairs as I was and slipped out the back into the garden and there was the poor fellow at the end of the garden, shivering.’

James Joyce, “The Dead”, Dubliners (1914), page 275

Here, for once, a character does not stay behind the glass. Gretta cannot see through the wet window, so she runs out to the boy, Michael Furey, who soon afterward dies. An essay that ignored the passage would be weaker for it, because an examiner who knows the story would notice the gap. The fourth section of the essay takes the passage on directly, as a counterargument it must answer.

Gretta’s story is the one moment in Dubliners when someone leaves the window: she “ran downstairs as I was” (Joyce 275) to Michael Furey in the garden.note 1 The crossing seems to break the pattern, but it is told as a memory, years later, about a boy who died soon after.note 2 The one character who went through the glass did so in the past, and the cost was a death.note 3 Gabriel, hearing it, walks back “quietly to the window” (275), so the pattern returns, changed: the man who listens is still a watcher, but he now knows what lies on the other side.note 4

  1. The counter-evidence stated fairly. The paragraph quotes the passage that most resists the thesis, without weakening it.

  2. Concession, then a limit. “Seems to break the pattern, but” admits the force of the evidence, then finds what limits it in the text itself (the memory, the death).

  3. The point turned to use. The counter-reading becomes part of the argument: crossing is possible, but only once, and at a price.

  4. The thesis refined. The essay’s answer to “how far” is sharper for having met the strongest objection.

Handling a counter-reading in this way takes one paragraph, not a section. The concession is honest, the limit is found in the work rather than asserted, and the essay ends the paragraph with its thesis stronger than before. That movement is part of what criterion C calls development.

The conclusion

A conclusion answers the line of inquiry in its final form and says what the answer adds up to. It does not summarize each section again, since the examiner has just read them. A good conclusion of 120 to 150 words does three things. It states the answer, now earned by the evidence; it judges what the answer shows about the work; and it names a limit or an open question the essay could not settle. The last window of Dubliners gives the essay its ending:

A few light taps upon the pane made him turn to the window. It had begun to snow again.

James Joyce, “The Dead”, Dubliners (1914), page 277

The windows of Dubliners hold its characters in three ways: they shelter the boys, trap Eveline and flatter Little Chandler, and in each case the glass lets a character see a life without entering it.note 1 “The Dead” changes the pattern, but less than its ending first suggests. Gretta once crossed, yet her crossing survives only as a memory of a boy who died, and Gabriel’s last window shows him snow “general all over Ireland” (Joyce 278) while he stays at the glass.note 2 Joyce lets the gaze escape, not the watcher.note 3 What the line cannot settle is whether that wider view is a beginning for Gabriel or only a more generous way of standing still.note 4

  1. The answer in one sentence. The first sentence gathers the three sections into one claim, without retelling them.

  2. The answer to “how far”. The final section’s finding is stated with its evidence, briefly.

  3. A judgment. A short sentence states what the whole essay has shown. It is earned by what comes before it.

  4. A limit named. The essay ends on the question its evidence cannot answer, which shows judgment rather than uncertainty.

Try it

Read the conclusion again. Which sentence would you cut first if the essay were 40 words over the limit, and why?

Probably the first: it recaps the three sections, which the examiner has just read, and its claim is repeated in the third sentence. Cutting it to The windows of Dubliners let characters see a life without entering it saves about 25 words and loses nothing the argument needs. The last two sentences should stay, because they hold the essay’s judgment and its limit.

Citing the work and your sources

A citation tells the examiner exactly where a quotation or a borrowed idea comes from. In an HL essay it usually sits in brackets after the quotation, and it points to a full entry in the list of works cited at the end. The style matters less than consistency: choose one recognized style, such as MLA, use it for every citation, and check with your teacher whether your school prefers one.

In MLA style, a quotation from a prose work is followed by the author and page the first time, and by the page alone after that, as long as the source is clear: (Joyce 42), then (48). A play in an edition with act divisions can be cited by act and page; poems are cited by line. A work in translation is cited like any other in the text, but its entry in the list of works cited names the translator, since the words quoted are the translator’s. A secondary source is cited by its author and page, or by its date for a letter.

Items of a body of work are cited by what identifies them: maker, title as the record gives it, and date. An essay on Hine’s photographs might cite A Little Spinner in the Mollahan Mills (Hine, 3 Dec. 1908) in the paragraph and give the full record, with the collection that holds it, in the list of works cited. An essay on a campaign cites each advertisement by its headline or description, publication and date. Whether images of the items may be included in the essay, and how, is a question for your teacher.

Yes, the newspapers were right: snow was general all over Ireland.

James Joyce, “The Dead”, Dubliners (1914), page 278

A citation also records which printing the essay used. The sentence above is quoted from the first edition of 1914, whose pages run differently from a modern paperback’s. If your class uses a modern edition, cite its pages and list it, and never mix page numbers from two editions in one essay.

Quotations from secondary sources need the same care as quotations from the work. Quote a critic briefly, name them in the sentence, and cite the page. A borrowed idea needs a citation even when none of its words are quoted, because the idea, not only the wording, belongs to its author.

Drafting and redrafting

The HL essay is written over time so that it can be redrafted, and the best essays are usually rewritten more than once. Each draft has a different job. A first draft is written for the argument: get every section down, in order, without polishing. A second draft checks the structure: read the topic sentences alone, test whether each section develops the last, and move or cut what lists. A last draft checks the details: every quotation against the book, every citation against the list, every sentence for the exact word.

Your teacher reads your work as it develops and gives feedback, but how much feedback they can give, and on how many drafts, is limited, and the details vary from school to school. Your teacher will explain what they can comment on and when. Use the feedback you are given on the largest problems first, since a clearer line or a better order improves every paragraph at once. Keep your earlier drafts and your notes; they record how the essay became yours.

Managing the word limit

Most first drafts are too long, and the question is what to cut. Cut what the argument does not need before cutting analysis. In roughly this order:

  • Plot summary that the examiner, who knows the work, does not need.

  • Context beyond the one sentence the analysis depends on.

  • A second quotation that makes the same point as the first.

  • Announcements of what a section will do or has done.

  • The thesis restated at the end of every section.

  • Intensifiers and filler: very, really, it is clear that.

Cutting in this order often removes 150 words or more from a long draft without touching a single piece of analysis. If the essay is still long after that, the line may be too broad for 1,500 words, and the right cut is a whole section, with the thesis narrowed to match. A shorter essay that develops three steps fully is stronger than one that crowds in five.

Some words should never be cut. The linking phrases at the start of sections and paragraphs (this safety, the pattern, for once) are what make the essay develop rather than list, and they cost only a few words each. A draft cut to the limit by removing them reads as a set of separate observations, which criterion C rewards least.

A model plan for one line

A plan for an HL essay is short: the line, the thesis, and for each section its sub-question, its topic sentence, its evidence and its share of the words. The worked example builds the full plan for the Dubliners essay from the line developed on the page about finding a line of inquiry.

The plan does more than list what each section contains. Each section has a question it must answer, and the questions climb; the evidence for each is chosen in advance and cited; and the counter-reading has a place before the drafting starts.

Planning is the last step before writing. Three complete HL essays, at a high, a middle and a low band and set side by side with their marks, show the difference a line of inquiry, a structure and integrated quotation make across a whole essay.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can write an introduction that states the line, gives a thesis that answers it and sets out the route.

  • To do:

    I can plan sections that each answer a sub-question raised by the last, and test the plan by reading the topic sentences alone.

  • To do:

    I can integrate short quotations into my own sentences and analyze them, using ellipses and square brackets correctly.

  • To do:

    I can describe and cite the items of a non-literary body of work precisely.

  • To do:

    I can answer a counter-reading inside the essay and use it to sharpen my thesis.

  • To do:

    I can write a conclusion that judges and names a limit instead of summarizing.

  • To do:

    I can cite consistently in one style, redraft with a clear purpose for each draft, and cut to the word limit in a sensible order.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Citation HL only

A short note in an essay, usually in brackets after a quotation or borrowed idea, that names its source and its exact place, such as a page number. Each citation points to a full entry in the list of works cited.

Integrated quotation HL only

A short quotation worked into the grammar of the writer’s own sentence, so that the quoted words and the analysis of them read as one statement. It keeps evidence brief and places it exactly where the argument needs it.

Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes

HL essay

  1. 4The HL essay

Individual oral

  1. 5The five minutes of questions
  2. 6An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 7Finding a line of inquiry
  2. 8Structuring the HL essayThis page
  3. 9An HL essay at each band

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.