An HL essay at each band

Three complete HL essays, one at each band, on Douglass’s Narrative, Thomas Nast’s Tweed Ring cartoons and Wilfred Owen’s Poems, with marks, reasons and margin comments, and what separates them on each criterion.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Internal assessment
  • HL only

33 min readLast reviewed

The HL essay is marked out of 20, on four criteria of 5 marks: A, Knowledge, understanding and interpretation; B, Analysis and evaluation; C, Focus, organization and development; D, Language. A description of a band is easier to apply once you have seen an essay that sits in it. The three essays that follow are complete, one at each band, and each is written on a single work with a works cited list. Each is marked on all four criteria with a reason and annotated in the margin.

The essays are written as students write, with the strengths and faults that students’ essays commonly have. The high essay is not perfect, and the low essay is not careless in every sentence. What separates them is mostly decided before the first paragraph, by the line of inquiry each student chose, and the teaching around each essay traces how that choice runs through everything after it.

Three essays and their lines

Two essays are on literary works and one on a non-literary body of work, so that both kinds of HL essay in Language and Literature are represented. All three works are in the public domain, so every quotation can be checked against the edition named in the works cited list.

  1. High band (18 out of 20). Frederick Douglass, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845), an autobiography read as a literary work. The line asks how the book teaches its Northern readers to distrust the evidence slavery shows them: songs, contented answers and holidays. It also asks how the book gets them to trust the facts Douglass withholds about his escape.

  2. Middle band (11 out of 20). Thomas Nast’s cartoons of the Tweed Ring in Harper’s Weekly (1871), a non-literary body of work by one cartoonist on one campaign. The line asks how Nast uses animals and labels to turn a group of corrupt city politicians into a danger to the public.

  3. Low band (6 out of 20). Wilfred Owen, Poems (1920), the collection published after his death. The essay has a topic, war in Owen’s poetry, rather than a line, and its other faults follow from that.

Each essay’s margin comments are numbered and labeled with a criterion and one verdict: strength, partly, missed or error. A comment speaks only about the words it marks, and the reason given for each mark cites the comments it rests on. Reading the reasons first and then finding the comments they cite is a quick way to see how an examiner moves from a whole essay to a single mark.

What the high-band essay does

The high essay is built on a line with two halves that pull against each other. The first half asks how Douglass corrects his readers’ misreadings of slavery; the second asks how he gets them to accept a gap in his own story. A line like this cannot be answered by listing examples, because the second half only makes sense once the first has been answered. The structure of the essay follows from that dependence.

A thesis that answers the line

The introduction states the answer in two sentences: the book argues that each sign of contentment was produced under force, and it uses that lesson to justify its own silence about the escape. A reader of the first paragraph already knows where the essay ends. Criterion C rewards this, because every later section can be measured against a claim that has been made, rather than against a topic that has been announced.

Sections that each deepen the last

The essay moves through four chapters, but not as a list. The second section begins by saying why the first was not enough. Songs can be misheard, so asking enslaved people directly looks like a better test, until the chapter on the man sold for an honest answer shows why that fails. The third section adds a further step, evidence that slaveholders produce on purpose. The fourth turns all three into the reason a reader should trust Douglass when he refuses to explain his escape.

This is what development means in criterion C: each section answers a question the previous one raised. A useful test is to try reading the sections in a different order. In a listing essay the order hardly matters. In this one, moving the chapter on silence to the start would make no sense, because the reader would not yet have learned why silence can be honest.

Analysis aimed at an audience

The essay’s analysis is precise because it always asks what a choice does to a particular reader, the Northern reader of 1845. The paradox “Slaves sing most when they are most unhappy” is not only named; the essay explains why it works on readers who believed the opposite, and why the comparison with a castaway persuades without accusing. Two words, “in silence”, are read as an instruction to readers who had been doing the talking. Criterion B rises from explaining an effect to judging it, and the judgment here comes from knowing who the text was written for.

A counter-reading from inside the work

Near the end the essay tests its own thesis. The 1845 printing opens with a preface and a letter by white abolitionists who vouch for Douglass, so the trust he asks for still depended partly on outside judges. The essay does not need a critic to raise this objection, because the evidence is in the book. Criterion A rewards an interpretation that knows its limits, and a counter-reading drawn from the primary source is stronger than one borrowed from a secondary source.

Where it lost marks

Two marks were lost. The holiday chapter’s metaphor of “safety-valves” is explained as a machine image but not weighed for what it implies about how slaveholders saw enslaved people, so criterion B stops at 4. One sentence in the counter-reading is wordy and empty, and criterion D stops at 4 for that kind of lapse in otherwise exact writing. Neither fault changes the argument, which is why the essay still sits near the top of the high band.

Exemplar · High band18 of 20 marks

HL essay: a high-band response (about 1,340 words)

On Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

With a high essay in view, the middle-band essay is easier to diagnose. Its faults are not ignorance or carelessness, and most of its sentences are accurate. They come from what the student did with a sound line once it was chosen.

What holds the middle-band essay in the middle

The middle essay is on a non-literary body of work: the cartoons Thomas Nast drew against the Tweed Ring, the group of politicians who controlled New York City’s government and stole from its treasury, for Harper’s Weekly in 1871. Its line asks how Nast uses animals and labels to show the Ring as a danger to the public. That line names the body of work, a method and a concern, and it could have carried a high essay. The essay scores 11 because it treats the line as a reason to visit four cartoons, not as a question to answer.

A route instead of an answer

The introduction spends most of its length on history and ends by announcing that it will look at four cartoons. A reader learns the route but not the destination. Compare the essay’s own last sentence of the introduction with a version that answers the line.

Weak: In this essay I will look at four of these cartoons and how Nast uses animals and labels in them to show the Ring as a danger to the public.note 1

Strong: Across 1871 Nast’s animals grow more dangerous, from vultures waiting over a city that is already a carcass to a tiger killing the Republic in front of its citizens. At the same time his labels move the Ring’s crime from stolen money to stolen law and votes.note 2 By November the cartoons no longer invite readers to laugh at the Ring; they dare them to vote it out.note 3

  1. A route. The sentence repeats the line of inquiry and promises a tour. It makes no claim that a reader could agree or disagree with, so nothing in the essay can be measured against it.

  2. A claim with a direction. The animals and the labels each change across the year, which gives the essay an order (by escalation) and a reason for that order.

  3. An answer to “danger”. The second sentence says what the danger finally is and what the cartoons ask readers to do about it, which is where the essay’s best paragraph, on the tiger, was already heading.

The strong version is not longer because it is fancier. It is longer because it contains an argument, and an argument needs the essay’s evidence arranged in a particular order. That is why the thesis matters so much to criterion C: it decides whether the sections that follow can develop.

Items in the order they were published

The essay takes the cartoons in order of publication, a paragraph each. Within each paragraph it describes the cartoon, reads one or two features, and moves on. The essay’s best idea, that a tiger kills while vultures only wait, appears in the last body paragraph, where it can no longer organize anything. In a body-of-work essay, development usually comes from a pattern across the items: a symbol that changes, a phrase that returns, a strategy that sharpens. The middle essay even notices one such pattern, Nast returning after the election to the vultures’ “storm” that would “blow over”, but it records the return without asking what it means.

Context in place of analysis

One paragraph tells the rest of Tweed’s story: his arrest, his escape to Spain, his death in prison. None of it is about how a cartoon works, and the story of his capture is offered as proof of the cartoons’ power although the essay itself says only that he was “supposedly” recognized. Context earns its place in an HL essay only when it changes how a feature is read. The election of November 1871 does that for the tiger cartoon, because it turns Tweed’s taunt into a question the readers could answer at the ballot box, and the essay uses it well there.

Analysis that stops at the obvious

The essay’s analysis is uneven. Its reading of the labels on the vultures’ bones (“Law”, “Justice”, “Liberty”, “Suffrage”) is a real interpretation: the Ring has consumed more than money. Its reading of the vultures themselves stops at calling them disgusting, and its reading of the money bag in “The ‘Brains’” stops at greed. In both places one more question would have lifted the analysis: what does it mean that the city is already dead when the vultures arrive, and why does the caption put “Brains” in quotation marks?

Try it

The middle essay says: “Vultures are animals that eat dead things, and this shows that the Ring are disgusting.” Rewrite the sentence so that it analyzes the choice of animal in relation to the line of inquiry.

One possible rewrite: Vultures do not kill; they feed on what is already dead. Nast’s choice suggests that the city’s law and treasury were destroyed before the Ring sat down to eat, and that its danger lies in waiting patiently for public anger to pass. The rewrite keeps the student’s point about feeding but connects it to the caption’s storm and to the line’s idea of danger.

Citation that does not let a reader check

One cartoon is dated to the day, two only to the month and one only to the year, two are missing from the works cited list, and the biography is cited without a page. An essay on a body of work needs each item identified as precisely as a quotation from a novel: title, publication, date and, where possible, page. Loose citation costs marks under criterion D, and it also weakens criterion A, because a reader cannot check the knowledge the essay claims.

Exemplar · Middle band11 of 20 marks

HL essay: a middle-band response (about 1,220 words)

On Thomas Nast’s Tweed Ring cartoons (Harper’s Weekly, 1871)

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The middle essay lost most of its marks after a sound start. The low essay’s problems begin with the title, and almost every later fault can be traced back to it.

How one weak choice makes a low-band essay

The low essay is on Wilfred Owen’s Poems, the collection of his war poetry published in 1920, two years after his death. Its title is “War in the poetry of Wilfred Owen”, and its introduction promises to show “how he shows that war is terrible”. That is a topic with a conclusion attached, not a line of inquiry. It names the work but no feature or method, and its answer is one that no reader of Owen would dispute, so there is nothing to argue.

From a topic to a tour

With no question to answer, the essay can only visit poems in turn: “Anthem for Doomed Youth”, then “The Send-off”, “Disabled”, “Exposure” and “Futility”, a paragraph each, each ending on the same message. This is why criterion C sits at 1. The poems are not arranged to build anything, and the conclusion can only repeat the opening. A line on the same work would have given the essay a direction. One student might ask how Owen turns the sounds of a church funeral into the noise of battle in “Anthem for Doomed Youth”, and what that says about the comfort the poems refuse to offer. Another might ask how “Disabled” uses the contrast between the young man’s past and present to judge the people who enlisted him.

Filling the space with context

A topic gives a writer little to say about the poems, so the space fills with what is easier to find. The low essay opens with a paragraph of biography and continues with a paragraph of general history about the First World War, and later adds how the poems came to be published. Most of it is accurate, and none of it is about how a poem means what it means. Knowledge of the author’s life counts under criterion A only when it changes the reading of a line.

Naming features without reading them

The essay knows its terms: simile, personification, alliteration, oxymoron, repetition, rhetorical question. Each appears with an effect that could be attached to almost any war poem (“creates a sense of the noise of war”, “makes the reader think about the meaning of life”). This is the pattern of criterion B at 1: features named, little said about how they create meaning. The repetition of “But nothing happens” in “Exposure” is read as boredom, which misses the dread of soldiers waiting for an attack that the silence promises.

Quoting and citing carelessly

The essay misquotes the most famous sentence of Owen’s Preface, which in the 1920 edition reads “The subject of it is War, and the pity of War.” One quotation is cited by page, one by the poem’s title and the rest not at all, and the works cited list names a website with no author, date or address. Criterion D sits at 2: the meaning usually comes through, but errors and loose conventions get in the way. At about 1,000 words the essay is also well short of the 1,200 words the HL essay asks for. Your teacher can tell you how a short essay is treated; either way, the shortfall shows how little a topic gave the writer to develop.

Exemplar · Low band6 of 20 marks

HL essay: a low-band response (about 1,010 words)

On Poems (Wilfred Owen)

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The three essays compared

Set side by side, the three essays show that the bands differ most on criterion C. The high and low essays are four marks apart on development and three apart on knowledge. The chart sets out each essay’s mark on each criterion, and the gaps between the bars show where the distance between the bands lies.

Bar chart of marks out of 5 on each criterion for three HL essays. High (Douglass): A 5, B 4, C 5, D 4. Middle (Nast): A 3, B 3, C 2, D 3. Low (Owen): A 2, B 1, C 1, D 2.Bar chart of marks out of 5 on each criterion for three HL essays. High (Douglass): A 5, B 4, C 5, D 4. Middle (Nast): A 3, B 3, C 2, D 3. Low (Owen): A 2, B 1, C 1, D 2.
Marks on each criterion for the three essays. The widest gap between the bands is on criterion C, development; language varies least.

Language varies least of the four criteria. All three essays are written in clear English, and even the low essay’s meaning usually comes through. What separates them is what the writing is doing: arguing toward an answer, visiting examples, or describing poems. The table names the main reason for each mark.

Criterion

High (Douglass)

Middle (Nast)

Low (Owen)

A Knowledge, understanding and interpretation

5: an independent reading of silence as protection, tested by a counter-reading from the book’s prefaces

3: sound knowledge of four cartoons, one strong reading of the arena, an anecdote accepted without a source

2: biography and history in place of interpretation, one misreading of “Disabled”

B Analysis and evaluation

4: image, paradox, analogy and diction judged for their effect on Northern readers; one metaphor explained but not weighed

3: the circle and the labels read well; the vultures and the money bag read at the obvious level

1: features named with effects that would fit any war poem

C Focus, organization and development

5: a two-part line answered at once, each section deepening the last

2: cartoons in order of publication, a paragraph of history, the organizing idea arriving last

1: a topic, no argument, poems described in turn

D Language

4: precise and varied, quotations integrated and cited by page; one empty sentence

3: clear, with informal lapses and loose citation

2: tone wavers, a misquotation, an unusable works cited list

Each step down the bands begins with a weaker answer to the same question: what is this essay trying to find out? The high essay asks a question with two parts and needs all four chapters to answer it. The middle essay asks a sound question but answers it one cartoon at a time. The low essay asks no question at all, and everything else follows from that.

Using the exemplars on your own draft

The exemplars are most useful when you read your own draft the way their margin comments read them. The steps that follow turn the comparison into a check you can run on a draft before your teacher sees it.

  1. Write your line of inquiry at the top of a blank page. If it names no feature or method, or if no one could disagree with its answer, it is still a topic.

  2. Underline the sentence in your introduction that answers the line. If you cannot find one, the introduction gives a route, as the middle essay’s does.

  3. Write each section’s question in the margin. If two sections could swap places without loss, they are listing, not developing.

  4. Mark every sentence that is biography or history. Keep each one only if the next sentence uses it to read a line or an item differently.

  5. Find every effect you claim for a feature. If the same words would fit another work, rewrite the sentence until they would not.

  6. Check every quotation against your edition and every citation against your works cited list, in one consistent form.

Try it

A student writing on Douglass’s Narrative proposes this line: The theme of freedom in Douglass’s Narrative. Using the low and high essays as guides, explain what is wrong with it and rewrite it as a line of inquiry.

The proposal is a topic: it names the work and a theme but no feature or method, and it asks nothing that could be argued. An essay on it would probably tour scenes about freedom in order, as the low essay tours Owen’s poems. A line needs a feature, a concern and a question that could be answered “partly”. For example: How does Douglass use the ships on Chesapeake Bay in Chapter X to show freedom as something seen before it can be imagined? That line points to one passage and one image, and it could be answered by tracing how the sight of free movement turns into Douglass’s own decision to run.

The pages on finding a line of inquiry and on structuring the essay take the high essay’s two strengths further. One shows how a topic becomes a question worth 1,500 words; the other, how a plan turns that question into sections that each deepen the last.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can describe what an HL essay at the high, middle and low bands does on each of the four criteria.

  • To do:

    I can explain how a line of inquiry decides an essay’s structure, and why a topic produces a tour of examples.

  • To do:

    I can tell a section that develops the argument from a section that adds another example.

  • To do:

    I can say when biography or historical context helps an essay and when it replaces analysis.

  • To do:

    I can rewrite a general claim about a feature’s effect into one that only fits the text it is about.

  • To do:

    I can check my quotations against my edition and cite them consistently in the essay and the works cited list.

  • To do:

    I can judge where a draft of my own sits on each criterion, and what to change first.

Internal assessment for English A Lang & Lit

Individual oral

  1. 1The individual oral
  2. 2Choosing a global issue and extracts
  3. 3Structuring the ten minutes

HL essay

  1. 4The HL essay

Individual oral

  1. 5The five minutes of questions
  2. 6An oral at each band

HL essay

  1. 7Finding a line of inquiry
  2. 8Structuring the HL essay
  3. 9An HL essay at each bandThis page

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.