5.6 Ethics

How Spain, Argentina, Colombia and Puerto Rico answer questions of right and wrong about organ donation, the end of life and animals, with the Spanish to judge, concede and weigh a dilemma.

  • IB Spanish B
  • Part of 5 Sharing the planet
  • SL and HL

23 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 5.6 Ethics

Ethics deals with questions of right and wrong that facts alone cannot settle: whether a person may choose how to die, who decides what happens to a body after death, whether a tradition that harms an animal should continue. Some of these questions belong to each person’s conscience, and some are decided by parliaments and courts, which then have to persuade people who disagree. In a public secondary school in Madrid, the student magazine asked two students whether everyone should be an organ donor.

¿Debería ser donante todo el mundo?El Altavoz, the student magazine of a public secondary school in Madrid (Retiro), debate pageWritten for Augment Education
Cara a cara. En España, la ley considera donante de órganos a toda persona que muere, salvo que haya dicho lo contrario en vida. Aun así, en la práctica los médicos siempre hablan antes con la familia. ¿Es justo este sistema? Se lo hemos preguntado a dos compañeros de 1.º de Bachillerato.
Omar Benali, 16 años: «Sí, y deberíamos estar orgullosos». España es el país del mundo con más donantes por habitante desde hace más de treinta años, y eso no es casualidad. En cada hospital hay un equipo que se dedica a la donación y que sabe hablar con las familias en el peor momento de su vida. Gracias a ese sistema, cada año miles de personas reciben un riñón, un hígado o un corazón. Cuando alguien muere, sus órganos ya no le sirven, pero pueden salvar varias vidas. Si todos somos donantes, nadie tiene que tomar esa decisión en un pasillo, llorando. En el mercado, a mi padre le preguntan a veces si su religión lo permite, y él siempre contesta que salvar una vida es lo más importante. ¿De verdad preferiríais un sistema en el que la gente espera años un trasplante?
Lucía Ferrer, 17 años: «Donar sí, pero porque quieres». No creo que el silencio de una persona sea lo mismo que un «sí». Mucha gente ni siquiera sabe que la ley la considera donante, así que su consentimiento no es real. Además, cada familia tiene sus creencias, y está bien que los médicos las respeten. Yo voy a ser donante, y ya se lo he dicho a mis padres, pero porque lo he decidido yo. A mi juicio, sería mejor que cada persona tuviera que responder «sí» o «no» al sacarse el DNI: así nadie decidiría por nosotros. ¿No os parece que una donación vale más cuando es un regalo?
Y vosotros, ¿qué pensáis? Dejad vuestra opinión en la web de El Altavoz antes del viernes. Las mejores respuestas saldrán en el próximo número.

Two answers to the same question

The debate page sets two opinions side by side, each with a title in quotation marks that gives the writer’s answer at once. The introduction states the legal fact the debate starts from: Spanish law treats everyone as a donor “salvo que haya dicho lo contrario en vida” (unless they have said otherwise while alive), paragraph 1. It then adds the practice that softens it: doctors “siempre hablan antes con la familia” (always speak to the family first).

Omar argues from results. His evidence is a national record: Spain is “el país del mundo con más donantes por habitante” (the country with the most donors per person in the world). He adds a picture of what the system prevents, since nobody has to decide “en un pasillo, llorando” (in a corridor, in tears), paragraph 2. He ends with a rhetorical question to the readers in the vosotros form, ¿De verdad preferiríais…? (would they prefer, in all honesty…?). Vosotros is the usual plural form of address among friends in Spain.

Lucía argues from principle, and her first sentence states it: “No creo que el silencio de una persona sea lo mismo que un «sí»” (I don’t believe a person’s silence is the same as a yes), paragraph 3. She does not reject donation; she is going to be a donor herself. Her disagreement is about how the decision is made, which is why her proposal is practical: every person would answer yes or no when collecting their identity card. Both writers want more donors, and they differ only on what counts as agreement.

En España, la ley considera donante de órganos a toda persona que muere, salvo que haya dicho lo contrario en vida.note 1 […] Cuando alguien muere, sus órganos ya no le sirven, pero pueden salvar varias vidas.note 2 […] No creo que el silencio de una persona sea lo mismo que un «sí».note 3 […] está bien que los médicos las respetennote 4. […] A mi juicio, sería mejor que cada persona tuviera que respondernote 5 «sí» o «no» al sacarse el DNI.

  1. Exception with subjunctive. Salvo que (unless) always takes the subjunctive; here the perfect subjunctive haya dicho (has said) refers to an earlier moment in the person’s life.

  2. A concession inside the argument. Ya no le sirven (are no longer any use to him) accepts the loss before turning to the gain with pero.

  3. Denying a belief. No creo que + subjunctive (sea). The affirmative creo que takes the indicative: creo que es lo mismo.

  4. A moral judgment. Está bien que + subjunctive (respeten) judges an action as right. Las stands for las creencias of each family.

  5. A polite proposal. A mi juicio (in my judgment) frames the opinion; sería mejor que + imperfect subjunctive (tuviera) proposes a change without demanding it. Sacarse el DNI is to get one’s national identity card in Spain.

Two words in the text carry the whole debate. El consentimiento is the legal word for consent, and la voluntad is a person’s will or wish (respetar la voluntad del fallecido, to respect the wishes of the dead person). El DNI (documento nacional de identidad) is Spain’s identity card; in most of Latin America the equivalent is la cédula, and in Argentina also el DNI.

The system Omar praises has a long history. Spain’s transplant law of 1979 made every adult a potential donor unless they had refused, and in 1989 the country created a national transplant organization, the Organización Nacional de Trasplantes (ONT). Spain has had the highest rate of deceased donors in the world for more than three decades, with more than 50 donors per million people in 2024. Doctors and researchers who study the Spanish model usually credit its organization more than the law itself: trained coordinators in every hospital, and careful conversations with families, the “equipo” Omar describes in paragraph 2.

Lucía’s objection names the idea at the center of the system. When the law assumes that silence means yes, it uses presumed consent. The opposite model, explicit consent, counts as donors only the people who have signed up. A third model, the one Lucía proposes, makes everyone answer the question at some moment, such as when collecting an identity document.

No creo que el silencio de una persona sea lo mismo que un «sí». Mucha gente ni siquiera sabe que la ley la considera donante, así que su consentimiento no es real.

“¿Debería ser donante todo el mundo?”, paragraph 3

Lucía’s argument rests on knowledge: consent is real only if people know what they are agreeing to. Supporters of presumed consent answer that most people say they would donate, so the law simply matches what they want, and that anyone can register a refusal. Both sides agree that the family’s view matters in practice, which is why Spanish doctors speak to relatives before any donation.

Argentina adopted presumed consent in 2005, but families were still asked to say whether the person had objected, and some refused. In 2018 the Ley Justina went further. It is named after Justina Lo Cane, a twelve-year-old girl who died in Buenos Aires in November 2017 while waiting for a heart transplant. Her family campaigned for the change, and Congress passed it unanimously. Under the law, every person over 18 is a donor unless they have stated otherwise, and the family no longer decides.

End-of-life choices

Organ donation asks what happens after death. A harder question is whether a person may ask for help to die. Euthanasia (la eutanasia) is the act of a doctor ending the life of a patient, at the patient’s own request, to end suffering that cannot be relieved. In Spanish public debate, supporters often speak of una muerte digna (a dignified death), while opponents speak of protecting la vida and the most vulnerable.

Spain’s law of 2021

Spain’s Ley Orgánica 3/2021, dated 24 March 2021, came into force three months after its publication, in June 2021. It made Spain one of the few countries in the world where euthanasia is a legal right within the public health system. The law calls it la prestación de ayuda para morir, a service that helps a person to die. It applies to adults with a serious and incurable illness, or a serious, chronic and disabling condition, that causes suffering they find unbearable.

The law surrounds the request with steps, which the diagram sets out. The patient must ask twice, in writing and at least fifteen days apart. The patient’s own doctor must confirm the conditions, and a second doctor from outside the team must agree. A commission in each region then reviews the case before anything happens. The patient may stop the process at any point.

Five numbered steps under Spain’s 2021 law: first written request; second request at least 15 days later; the responsible doctor informs and confirms; a consulting doctor from outside the team agrees; a regional commission checks the case.Five numbered steps under Spain’s 2021 law: first written request; second request at least 15 days later; the responsible doctor informs and confirms; a consulting doctor from outside the team agrees; a regional commission checks the case.
The steps of a request under Spain’s Ley Orgánica 3/2021, with the law’s own names for each in Spanish.

The law also protects doctors who disagree. Article 16 gives them a right that comes from the language of conscience:

Los profesionales sanitarios directamente implicados en la prestación de ayuda para morir podrán ejercer su derecho a la objeción de conciencia.

Ley Orgánica 3/2021, de regulación de la eutanasia, artículo 16.1

La objeción de conciencia (conscientious objection) is the right to refuse to take part in an act a person considers morally wrong. The future podrán (will be able to) grants a permission rather than an obligation. Each region keeps a register of objecting professionals, so that a patient’s request still reaches a doctor who will carry it out. In this way the law leaves the moral question open and lets each professional act on their own answer.

Who supports it, and who does not

Supporters, including Spain’s association Derecho a Morir Dignamente, argue from autonomy and dignity: a competent adult should decide how their own life ends. Opponents include the Catholic bishops’ conference, many palliative care doctors and some disability organizations. The bishops argue that life is not something a person may dispose of. Palliative care groups argue that good care, available to everyone, removes most requests. Disability groups fear that people with serious conditions may feel they are a burden. Both sides appeal to la dignidad: supporters mean the right to choose, opponents the equal value of every life.

Colombia was the first country in Latin America to allow euthanasia. In 1997 its Constitutional Court ruled, in judgment C-239, that a doctor who ends the life of a terminally ill patient who has asked for it commits no crime, because the right to life includes living with dignity. Congress never passed a law, so later court rulings and health ministry rules set the procedure. In February 2024, Ecuador’s Constitutional Court followed a similar path. Both countries show courts moving ahead of parliaments, which supporters see as a defense of rights and critics as judges making law.

Animals and tradition

Some ethical debates set a tradition against the welfare of animals. In Puerto Rico, the question is cockfighting, held for centuries in arenas called galleras. A public radio program in San Juan opened its phone lines on the subject, and three callers answered.

Llamadas abiertas: ¿tradición o maltrato?Isla al Día, a public radio magazine programme in San Juan, Puerto Rico (call-in)Written for Augment Education
GABRIELBuenas tardes, Puerto Rico. Esto es «Isla al Día», y hoy abrimos los teléfonos para hablar de un tema que divide familias: las peleas de gallos. Desde diciembre de 2019, una ley federal las prohíbe en la isla, igual que en los estados. Los galleros reclamaron ante la justicia, pero los tribunales federales dijeron que manda la ley federal. ¿Qué opinan ustedes? Primera llamada. Adelante, estás en el aire.
WILFREDOSaludos, Gabriel. Me llamo Wilfredo y crío gallos en Cidra desde hace veinte años. Para mí, esto es cultura. Mi abuelo tenía gallos, mi papá tenía gallos. Y no soy solo yo: de la gallera vive el que vende el alimento, el que cuida los animales, el que vende comida afuera. No hay derecho a que decidan por nosotros desde Washington, donde nadie ha visto una gallera en su vida.
GABRIELGracias, Wilfredo. Segunda llamada. Adelante.
KEILAHola, Gabriel. Soy Keila, tengo veinte años y estudio biología en Mayagüez. Yo respeto a los galleros, pero un gallo no escoge pelear. Lo entrenan, le ponen espuelas y muchas veces termina herido o muerto. No hay derecho a que un animal sufra para que otros apuesten y se diviertan. Hay tradiciones que cambiaron y no pasó nada.
GABRIELWilfredo diría que eso lo deberíamos decidir aquí, ¿no?
KEILAPuede ser. Pero aunque lo decidiéramos aquí, yo votaría igual.
GABRIELTenemos una llamada más. ¡Doña Carmen, qué gusto escucharla otra vez! ¿Cómo está usted?
CARMENBien, mijo, gracias a Dios. Mire, yo no voy a decir quién tiene razón. Yo no iba a la gallera, porque eso era cosa de hombres, pero mi papá volvía los domingos con todas las noticias del barrio. Allí se hablaba de política y de la cosecha, y se arreglaban negocios. Era el sitio donde se juntaba la gente. Lo que me da pena es que los muchachos de hoy no tengan un sitio así, con gallos o sin gallos.
GABRIEL«Con gallos o sin gallos». Ahí lo dejamos por hoy. Gracias a todos por llamar.

The host sets out the facts in his first turn: a federal law has banned cockfighting on the island since December 2019, and the cockfighters’ challenges failed in federal courts. Each caller then answers from a different place. Wilfredo, a breeder in Cidra, argues from culture and work: “Mi abuelo tenía gallos, mi papá tenía gallos” (my grandfather had roosters, my father had roosters), and many people live from the gallera. His strongest complaint is about who decides: “No hay derecho a que decidan por nosotros desde Washington” (they have no right to decide for us from Washington).

Keila, a biology student, uses the same structure for the opposite view. In her words, “No hay derecho a que un animal sufra para que otros apuesten y se diviertan” (it is not right that an animal should suffer so that others can bet and have fun). When the host repeats Wilfredo’s point, she makes a concession and keeps her position with aunque + imperfect subjunctive: “aunque lo decidiéramos aquí, yo votaría igual” (even if we decided it here, I would vote the same way). Doña Carmen, whom the host addresses as usted out of respect for her age, refuses to judge. Her memory moves the question from the animals to what the gallera gave the neighborhood.

GABRIEL: ¿Qué opinan ustedes?note 1 Primera llamada. Adelante, estás en el airenote 2. […] WILFREDO: No hay derecho a que decidan por nosotros desde Washingtonnote 3. […] KEILA: Hay tradiciones que cambiaron y no pasó nadanote 4. […] CARMEN: Lo que me da pena es que los muchachos de hoy no tengan un sitio asínote 5, con gallos o sin gallos.

  1. Inviting views. ¿Qué opinan ustedes? addresses all the listeners. In Puerto Rico, as in all of Latin America, ustedes is the only plural form of address.

  2. Radio register. Estás en el aire (the caller is on the air) uses tú, the informal address the host uses with callers of his own age or younger.

  3. No hay derecho a que + subjunctive (decidan) protests that something is unfair. Both Wilfredo and Keila use it, for opposite causes.

  4. An argument from history. The preterite cambiaron and no pasó nada point to changes that are complete, as evidence that this one would also be survivable.

  5. Me da pena que + subjunctive (tengan) expresses regret. The subjunctive follows a feeling about a fact, not doubt about it.

The argument map sets the call-in out as a debate: a question, the reasons on each side, and an objection to each with its reply. Doña Carmen’s turn sits outside the map, because she answers a different question from the other two callers.

An argument map. Question: ¿Prohibir una tradición con animales? Yes: the animal suffers and does not choose; other traditions changed. No: it is culture and work; his grandfather and father kept roosters. Objections: who decides, the island or Washington; do the jobs justify the harm.An argument map. Question: ¿Prohibir una tradición con animales? Yes: the animal suffers and does not choose; other traditions changed. No: it is culture and work; his grandfather and father kept roosters. Objections: who decides, the island or Washington; do the jobs justify the harm.
The call-in as an argument map, with Keila’s and Wilfredo’s reasons summed up in Spanish.

Bulls, roosters and the law

The same conflict runs through the debate on bullfighting (las corridas de toros) in Spain and Latin America. Catalonia banned bullfights in 2010, and the last one in Barcelona was held in September 2011. In 2016 Spain’s Constitutional Court annulled the ban. It did not rule on animal suffering: it found that a region could not ban a practice that a national law of 2013 had declared part of Spain’s cultural heritage. No bullfights have returned to Barcelona since. In Colombia, Congress passed a law in 2024, known as No más olé, that bans bullfighting from 2027. In September 2025 the Constitutional Court upheld it and struck out the law’s exemption for cockfighting and the corralejas, a bull festival of the Caribbean coast, giving those practices three years to end.

These cases show two ways of arguing. One asks about animal welfare: whether an animal suffers, and whether human enjoyment can justify that suffering. The other asks who has the right to decide about a custom: a region, a nation, or the people who practice it. The Catalan case was decided on the second question, and the Colombian case on the first.

Try it

Read doña Carmen’s turn again. Does she defend cockfighting? Explain with words from the transcript.

No. She says “yo no voy a decir quién tiene razón”. What she regrets is the loss of a meeting place: “Lo que me da pena es que los muchachos de hoy no tengan un sitio así, con gallos o sin gallos.” The phrase con gallos o sin gallos separates the social value of the gallera from the fights themselves.

Everyday ethics: food, clothes and honesty

Most ethical choices are smaller than a law on euthanasia. They are made in shops, kitchens and classrooms, often without anyone noticing. Spain turned one of them into law in 2025. Its law on food loss and waste, Ley 1/2025, requires bars and restaurants to let customers take their leftovers home in a free container. It also asks shops and food companies to donate food that is still safe to eat before throwing it away. The law treats waste as a shared responsibility of farms, shops, restaurants and households.

Clothing raises similar questions. The page on globalization follows fast fashion from the shop to the factories that sew it and the deserts where unsold clothes end up. From an ethical angle, the question is what a buyer owes to the people and places in that chain. At school, the commonest ethical question is honesty: copying homework, sharing answers in a group chat, or presenting someone else’s words as one’s own. Many students who would never steal an object feel differently about copying a paragraph.

Technology adds questions about personal data and the body. Phone apps, online shops and genetic tests collect information about who a person is, where they go and which illnesses may run in the family. Rules such as the European data protection regulation, in force in Spain since 2018, say that companies need a person’s consent and must say what they do with the data. The ethical question is who else should see a genetic result, such as an employer, an insurer or relatives, and whether a person has a right not to know. Genetic data have also served justice: Argentina’s national genetic data bank, set up in 1987, helps grandchildren taken during the dictatorship recover their identity, as the page on human rights describes.

Choices like these are often taught as moral dilemmas: situations in which every option has a cost, so that a person must decide which value matters more. Spanish poses them with si + imperfect subjunctive and a question in the conditional, as in these three from a class debate:

¿Qué harías si encontraras una carteranote 1 con 200 euros y la dirección del dueño? Si tu mejor amigo copiara en un examennote 2, ¿se lo dirías al profesor? ¿Comprarías una camiseta de dos euros aunque supierasnote 3 cómo la han fabricado?

  1. The dilemma frame. ¿Qué harías si…? + imperfect subjunctive (encontraras) asks about an imagined situation. The conditional harías and the past subjunctive always go together in this structure.

  2. Loyalty against honesty. Copiara (copied) and dirías (would tell, addressed as tú) set up the conflict between two values, which is what makes a dilemma.

  3. Knowledge against price. Aunque supieras (even knowing) uses aunque with the imperfect subjunctive for a hypothetical concession.

In each question the conditional asks what a person would do, not what is right in general. That distinction is useful in discussion: a speaker can say Lo correcto sería devolverla, pero no sé si yo lo haría (the right thing would be to return it, but I don’t know whether I would). Honest answers of this kind sound more convincing than claims to be perfect, and they keep a discussion going.

Ideas to discuss

Should everyone be an organ donor unless they say no?

Omar and Lucía in El Altavoz agree that donation saves lives and disagree about consent. Lucía’s last question, “¿No os parece que una donación vale más cuando es un regalo?” (isn’t a donation worth more when it is a gift?), paragraph 3, sums up the case for asking. Spain and Argentina presume consent; other countries ask people to register, and some, as Lucía proposes, make everyone answer the question at some point. The argument turns on whether silence can count as a decision, and on how much weight a family’s wishes should carry after a death.

Who should decide about a tradition?

In the Puerto Rican call-in, Wilfredo’s strongest point is about power: a law made far away ended a custom on the island. He objects to a decision taken “desde Washington, donde nadie ha visto una gallera en su vida” (from Washington, where nobody has ever seen a gallera), paragraph 2. Catalonia’s ban was annulled on a similar question of who decides, while Colombia’s was upheld on the question of suffering. Some argue that the community that practices a tradition should decide its future; others answer that a community may not decide on its own about harm to beings who cannot speak for themselves.

Can the law allow what many people think is wrong?

Spain’s euthanasia law allows something that some of the population, including many doctors, considers wrong, and it lets those doctors refuse to take part. Supporters say that a law in a plural society should protect each person’s choice, not impose one view. Opponents say that some acts change what a society values, whoever performs them, and that the most vulnerable will feel pressure to choose them.

Words and phrases

Ethical debate needs words for judging, conceding and deciding. The most useful are the expressions that take the subjunctive: no hay derecho a que, está bien que, me da pena que, salvo que. Tener razón (to be right) is a phrase students often get wrong, since Spanish uses tener, not ser: Keila tiene razón. El consentimiento (consent) and la voluntad (a person’s wishes) belong to the language of law and medicine, while me da pena and no pasó nada belong to everyday talk, which is why they appear in the radio call-in.

Spanish (as printed)

Dictionary form

Meaning in context

Where

donante de órganos

el donante

organ donor

Altavoz, ¶1

salvo que haya dicho

salvo que; decir

unless they have said

Altavoz, ¶1

en la práctica

in practice

Altavoz, ¶1

no es casualidad

la casualidad

it is no coincidence

Altavoz, ¶2

se dedica a

dedicarse a

works on, is devoted to

Altavoz, ¶2

un riñón, un hígado

a kidney, a liver

Altavoz, ¶2

salvar varias vidas

salvar

to save several lives

Altavoz, ¶2

un trasplante

a transplant

Altavoz, ¶2

el silencio

silence

Altavoz, ¶3

su consentimiento

el consentimiento

their consent

Altavoz, ¶3

sus creencias

la creencia

their beliefs

Altavoz, ¶3

a mi juicio

in my judgment

Altavoz, ¶3

sacarse el DNI

sacarse

to get one’s identity card (Spain)

Altavoz, ¶3

un regalo

a gift

Altavoz, ¶3

las peleas de gallos

la pelea

cockfights

Isla al Día, ¶1

las prohíbe

prohibir

bans them

Isla al Día, ¶1

manda la ley federal

mandar

federal law prevails

Isla al Día, ¶1

crío gallos

criar

I breed roosters

Isla al Día, ¶2

la gallera

cockfighting arena

Isla al Día, ¶2

no hay derecho a que

it is not right that

Isla al Día, ¶2

herido o muerto

herir; morir

wounded or dead

Isla al Día, ¶4

sufra

sufrir

(should) suffer

Isla al Día, ¶4

apuesten

apostar

(should) bet

Isla al Día, ¶4

aunque lo decidiéramos

decidir

even if we decided it

Isla al Día, ¶6

quién tiene razón

tener razón

who is right

Isla al Día, ¶8

me da pena

dar pena

it makes me sad

Isla al Día, ¶8

se juntaba la gente

juntarse

people used to gather

Isla al Día, ¶8

Say it yourself

These frames help you judge an action, concede a point and weigh a dilemma. They run from simple to complex; most of them need the subjunctive.

Frame

Use

A mi juicio, …

give a considered opinion

Para mí, lo correcto sería…

say what would be right

Entiendo que…, pero…

acknowledge a view, then answer it

Está bien / mal que + subjunctive

judge an action as right or wrong

Es justo / injusto que + subjunctive

judge whether something is fair

No hay derecho a que + subjunctive

protest that something is unfair

Una cosa es… y otra muy distinta…

separate two ideas that others confuse

¿Qué harías tú si…? + imperfect subjunctive

pose a dilemma

Aun cuando + subjunctive, …

concede the strongest objection, then hold your view

A student used several of the frames in a short speech for a class debate on traditions that involve animals:

Entiendo quenote 1 las peleas de gallos son parte de la historia de Puerto Rico, pero una cosa es recordar una tradición y otra muy distinta es mantenerlanote 2 cuando hace sufrir a un animal. No hay derecho a quenote 3 un ser vivo pague por nuestra diversión. Aun cuando la prohibición cueste empleosnote 4, creo que lo correcto es buscar otras formas de mantener vivo el barrio.

  1. Acknowledge first. Entiendo que + indicative (son) accepts a fact before the answer, which makes the speaker sound fair.

  2. A distinction. Una cosa es… y otra muy distinta… separates remembering a custom from continuing it, the speech’s central idea.

  3. A protest. No hay derecho a que + subjunctive (pague). Un ser vivo (a living being) widens the point beyond roosters.

  4. The strongest objection, conceded. Aun cuando + subjunctive (cueste) admits the cost in jobs, then creo que lo correcto es gives the speaker’s judgment.

The same view can be argued weakly or strongly. The weak version is clear, but it asserts and repeats without reasons or concession.

Weak: Las corridas de toros son malas. Son muy crueles. Hay que prohibir las corridas porque son malas para los toros.note 1

Strong: Aunque las corridas formen parte de la historia de muchos pueblos, no creo que una tradición justifique el sufrimiento de un animal, y por eso me parece justo que se prohíban.note 2

  1. Circular and repetitive. Son malas appears twice and the reason repeats the claim. Nothing answers the other side.

  2. Conceded, argued, concluded. Aunque + subjunctive (formen) concedes, no creo que + subjunctive (justifique) gives the reason, and me parece justo que se prohíban draws the conclusion with a third subjunctive.

Applying it in Paper 1

Ethical topics suit tasks that ask for an argued opinion, including the more abstract tasks usually set at HL. A typical task asks for an opinion column for a local newspaper, a speech for a school debate or a letter to the editor on whether traditions that involve animals should be banned. A strong response states its position early, gives two or three reasons with real examples (Colombia’s law, Catalonia’s ban and its annulment, the call-in from San Juan), and answers the strongest objection fairly before concluding.

The structure that most often goes wrong in this kind of argument is the si clause.

Ethics leads on to the opinion column and the speech as text types, to si clauses and the imperfect subjunctive, which carry every dilemma, and to the HL writing that weighs two positions before judging.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can describe the debates on organ donation, euthanasia and traditions involving animals in Spain, Argentina, Colombia and Puerto Rico.

  • To do:

    I can explain the difference between presumed and explicit consent, using Omar’s and Lucía’s words.

  • To do:

    I can explain the steps of Spain’s 2021 euthanasia law and the right to conscientious objection.

  • To do:

    I can judge an action with está bien que, es justo que and no hay derecho a que + subjunctive.

  • To do:

    I can pose and answer a dilemma with si + imperfect subjunctive and the conditional.

  • To do:

    I can concede a point with aunque and aun cuando + subjunctive and still defend my view.

  • To do:

    I can weigh whether the law should allow something that many people consider wrong.

Key terms

Each is also in the Sharing the planet glossary for IB Spanish B, beside the other terms of its topic.

Animal welfare

Concern for the physical and mental state of animals in human care, which accepts that people use animals but requires their suffering to be kept as low as possible. It differs from animal rights, which holds that some uses of animals are wrong however they are treated.

Euthanasia

The act of a doctor ending the life of a patient, at the patient's own repeated request, to end suffering from a serious and incurable condition. Where it is legal, it is allowed only under strict conditions and checks.

Moral dilemma

A situation in which a person must choose between two or more actions, each of which breaks a value they hold, so that no option is free of cost.

Presumed consent

A rule in organ donation law that treats every person as agreeing to donate their organs after death unless they have registered a refusal while alive.

More in 5 Sharing the planet

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 5.1The environment
  2. 5.2Human rights
  3. 5.3Peace and conflict
  4. 5.4Equality
  5. 5.5Globalization
  6. 5.6EthicsThis page
  7. 5.7Urban and rural environment

Carry on with 5.6 Ethics in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.