- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- Paper 1 at SL
Paper 1 at SL
Paper 1 at standard level: choosing between two unseen non-literary texts, reading and annotating, building a thesis and analytical paragraphs, how each criterion is earned, and a full response.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Exam skills
- SL and HL
At standard level, Paper 1 is a guided textual analysis of non-literary texts. You receive two unseen texts of different text types, each printed with one guiding question. You choose one of them and write one analytical essay on it in 1 hour 15 minutes. The essay is marked out of 20, on four assessment criteria of 5 marks each.
The guiding question is an offer, not an order. You can answer it or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text, and either essay is marked in the same way. The four criteria are A, Understanding and interpretation; B, Analysis and evaluation; C, Focus and organization; and D, Language. A strong essay therefore does four things at once. It reads the text accurately and beneath its surface, explains how the text’s choices make that meaning, argues in an order of its own, and says all of this in clear, precise English.
Nothing can be revised for Paper 1 in the way a set work can be learned. What can be prepared is a way of reading and a way of writing, practiced until it runs under time pressure. Both are easiest to learn on a real pair of texts, followed from the first minute of reading to a complete essay.
Two texts and one choice
The paper opens with a decision. The two texts are always of different types, and one of them may be visual: an advertisement, an infographic, a web page. A typical pair is a speech and a poster. The first is an address by the secretary of a residents’ trust in Chennai to the trust’s annual general meeting, printed afterwards for members. Its guiding question asks: How does the speaker use the occasion of the annual meeting to keep her audience’s trust?
The second text is a poster for a live music night held on the roof of an online music magazine’s office in Accra. It is built from a headline, a flat illustration of two musicians on a rooftop, a line-up and the practical details of the night.

Description of the poster
A tall navy poster. A yellow band at the top holds the magazine’s name and the number of the night. The headline fills the width in large bold type, its second line in yellow, with two smaller lines beneath it.
The middle is an illustration of a city skyline at night under a string of yellow lights. On a brick-colored rooftop, an older man with white hair sits on a red plastic chair playing guitar, the neck of the guitar pointing to the right. Facing him stands a young man in a red top and a dark cap, one arm raised with a microphone. A dotted yellow arc joins the space between them, and a short caption sits under each figure.
Below the picture come the line-up in bold capitals, a line in yellow italics, a thin rule, the date, place and price, a bold yellow line and a last line in small gray italics.
LORRY PARK / ROOF SESSIONS · No. 14
Bring your grandfather.
Old hands, new beats: highlife guitar meets Kumasi drill on our roof.
since 1974 / since last Tuesday
THE SALT ROAD BAND × SLY GIDI
Is drill the new highlife? Come and settle it.
Saturday 6 June 2026 · from 7pm
The Lorry Park roof, Osu (upstairs from the phone repair shop)
Free before 9pm · GH₵50 after
Chale, only 150 fit on the roof. Come early.
Grandfathers get in free all night. Grandmothers too, obviously.The words of the poster, in reading order
Choosing in five minutes
The choice is worth five minutes, not fifteen, and it should rest on one question: on which text can you say the most, with evidence, about how it works? Familiarity with the topic is a poor guide. A student who loves music may reach for the poster and then find that 75 words of copy give little to quote, while the speech, on a subject that seems remote, offers a dozen choices worth analyzing.
The decision is final once made. Switching texts after twenty minutes of annotation almost always costs more than it gains, because the second essay is written in the time left over from the first reading.
Reading an unseen text
An unseen non-literary text is read in three passes, each with its own question. The first pass asks what kind of text this is: its text type, its audience, its purpose and its context. The second asks what the whole text does from beginning to end, and where it changes. Only the third pass looks closely at details, because a detail means something only once the purpose it serves is clear.
First pass: type, audience, purpose, context
In the speech, the first pass takes two minutes. The italic headnote (paragraph 1) gives the type and the occasion: an address to the annual general meeting of members, printed afterwards. The greeting names the audience in layers: “members and neighbours”, then the children of the Junior Tank Keepers (paragraph 2), and later the two families “in the third row” (paragraph 6). The purposes follow from the occasion. An annual meeting reports on a year, so the speech must give the year’s results; this year it must also explain a failure and keep the members’ support.
Context here means what the text itself shows about its situation, not outside research, which is impossible in the exam room. The speech supplies enough: a volunteer trust that cares for a lake, an embankment (the bund) that it failed to repair, houses flooded below it, and a membership that gives money and Sunday mornings. Your essay may use all of this, because it is in the words in front of you.
Second pass: the whole text and its turn
The second pass reads for shape. Most texts worth setting in Paper 1 move: they change tone, reverse an expectation or say something different from what they first seem to say. The speech turns in one sentence at the end of paragraph 5, where the speaker thanks the volunteers and promises to “say something harder”. Before that sentence comes pride and good news; after it comes the breach of the bund, the apology and the changes. A student who marks this turn on the first reading already has the outline of an argument, since the essay can ask why the good news comes first and how the apology is made to fit the meeting.
Third pass: the details that carry the effect
Only now do individual choices matter, and the question for each is what it does for the purpose found in the first pass. The details that reward attention cluster around the turn. Paragraph 7 is a good example of how much a few words can hold.
That section of the bund was marked weak in August. It was marked weak by us — by me —note 1 on our inspection walk, and written in our minutes, and then it waitednote 2. We decided that the repair could wait until January, after the monsoon. It could not.note 3 For ten years we have asked this lake to hold more water. It did exactly what we asked.note 4
The secretary’s address, paragraph 7, as a student annotated it
Pronoun shift. “Us” corrected to “me”: she takes the blame herself. Why in front of the members?
Personified delay. The section of bund “waited”, as if no one chose the delay.
Short sentence. Three words after a long one: the verdict, no excuse.
Irony. Success (more water) caused the failure. Link to the accounts in paragraph 3?
These annotations are short, specific and already analytical. Each marks exact words, names what they do in a few words, and some end with a question that the essay will answer. An annotation that only names a device (“repetition”, “short sentence”) without a word about its effect saves no time later, because the thinking still has to be done in the essay.
Annotating a visual text
A visual text is annotated in a different order, because the eye does not read it from top left to bottom right. Start with what is seen first, its point of greatest salience: on the poster, the two-line headline “Bring your grandfather.”, the second line in yellow. Then follow the reading path the layout sets: headline, the two figures and their captions, the line-up, the question, the details, the small print. Mark the visual hierarchy too, since what is largest is what the designer most wants remembered.
Next, set words and image against each other, because a visual text makes much of its meaning in the gap between them. The headline addresses a young reader with an imperative, yet the picture gives equal space to the old guitarist, so the invitation becomes a promise that both generations belong. The captions “since 1974” and “since last Tuesday” turn the age gap into a joke the young reader is in on. The small print (“Grandmothers too, obviously.”) corrects the headline’s one-sided invitation with a wink, a sign that the poster knows its audience. Reading images and layout has its own chapter in the toolkit; Paper 1 asks you to use that vocabulary at speed.
From guiding question to thesis
A thesis is the answer your essay argues, stated in one or two sentences in the introduction. In Paper 1 it grows out of the guiding question, but it is never the question with its words turned around. The question names a feature and a meaning, and the thesis says how that feature makes that meaning in this text. The page on working with the guiding question takes this further, including when to set your own focus instead.
Weak: The speaker uses the occasion of the annual meeting in many ways to keep her audience’s trust, such as rhetorical devices, pathos and repetition.note 1
Strong: The secretary keeps her members’ trust by folding her apology into the meeting’s own rituals: she reports the bund’s failure as one more entry in the “lake’s accounts”, takes the blame personally, and turns the members present into witnesses of the changes she promises.note 2
Question turned around. The sentence repeats the guiding question and adds a list of devices. It promises nothing an essay could prove or disprove.
A claim with three steps. The thesis answers “how” with three moves, each tied to a part of the speech, and each move can become a paragraph.
The strong thesis also gives the essay its line of argument: the reasoning that decides what each paragraph claims and in what order. Its three moves suggest three body paragraphs, from the accounts to the apology to the witnesses, which is a progression of ideas rather than a walk through the speech in the order it was given. A thesis does not have to be long to do this, but it has to commit to a reading.
You may set your own focus when the guiding question points somewhere you cannot go far. A student who has seen that the speech’s pronouns carry its argument could state in the introduction that the essay will examine how the speaker’s movement between we and I shapes her relationship with her audience. That focus is technical, it is about the text’s choices, and it is marked in exactly the same way as an answer to the guiding question.
Paragraphs that analyze
Each body paragraph proves one part of the thesis. It opens with a topic sentence that states a claim, gives the evidence for it, explains what that evidence does, and ends by linking the claim back to the argument. The third step is where the marks are, and it is the one most often cut short under time pressure.


The diagram sets out the four parts as stacked boxes, with the analysis drawn largest because it should take the most words. The order is a habit for practice, not a template to fill. In a strong essay, evidence and analysis often alternate two or three times inside one paragraph, and the claim may become sharper as the paragraph goes. What stays fixed is the proportion: one sentence of claim, short quotations, and several sentences on what the quoted words do.
The speaker protects her members even as she apologizes to them.note 1 When she reports who marked the bund as weak, she corrects herself mid-sentence: “by us — by me —”note 2 (paragraph 7). The dashes make the correction audible, as if she decides on the spot to take the blame herself. Until this point “we” has meant the whole trust, volunteers included; the switch to “me” lifts the failure off the people who gave their Sunday mornings and places it on the officer who should have acted.note 3 The apology therefore keeps the membership’s trust by sparing the membership, which prepares for the public promises that follow in paragraph 8.note 4
Claim. One point, stated as an interpretation that answers the guiding question.
Evidence. Four words, exactly quoted, with the paragraph number.
Analysis. Two sentences on what the choice does: how it sounds, and what it changes in the speaker’s relationship with this audience.
Link. Back to trust, the guiding question’s concern, and forward to the next part of the speech.
The paragraph quotes four words and spends two sentences on them. It also names the audience precisely: not “the reader” but the volunteers who gave their Sundays. That precision is the difference between analysis that could describe any speech and analysis of this one.
Try it
Write the claim and the analysis for a paragraph on paragraph 3 of the speech, where the speaker distinguishes the treasurer’s accounts from “the lake’s accounts”.
A possible claim: the speaker sets up a metaphor of bookkeeping early so that bad news can later be entered in the same book. Analysis: “the lake’s accounts: what it held, how long it held it, and who came back to it” turns water, time and birds into figures that can be added up, like the audited money on the notice boards. Because the members already trust the treasurer’s accounts, the metaphor lends the lake’s record the same reliability. When the breach is reported in paragraph 6, it reads as an honest entry in a set of books the audience has already learned to believe.
A conclusion that judges
The conclusion is where criterion B’s word evaluation is most visible. A weak conclusion repeats the thesis and lists the features discussed. A strong one judges: which choice did most to achieve the purpose, how well the text works for its audience, and what limit or cost its method has. It may add one new thought, as long as the essay has earned it.
Some of you have asked me whether we should say less about all this. A trust that asks for money, you say, should talk about lilies and birds, not about a wall that fell down.
The secretary’s address, paragraph 9
A judging conclusion can grow from these lines. The speaker answers her critics by arguing that honesty is the trust’s only asset, and the essay can weigh whether the speech persuades on that point. One strong conclusion might decide that the pronoun shift in paragraph 7 does more than any figure in the speech. It might add that the light jokes about the treasurer’s tea risk sounding casual in front of two flooded families, yet they also remind the audience that this is a meeting of neighbors. A judgment of that kind uses evidence from the whole text and leaves the marker with a reading, not a summary.
How the four criteria are earned
Each criterion is marked from 0 to 5, and each mark has a markband: a short description of the work that earns it. A marker reads the whole essay, finds the description that fits it best on each criterion, and adds the four marks. The criteria overlap in practice, since a misreading under A usually weakens the analysis under B, but each rewards something different. The pairs that follow come from two essays on the same speech, one that earns the marks and one that does not.
A: Understanding and interpretation
Criterion A asks whether you have understood what the text is doing beneath its surface, and whether every claim rests on words from the text that prove it. Retelling the text accurately is the floor of this criterion. The higher marks go to essays that see tension, change and ambiguity across the whole text, and that say what the text means for its audience.
Does not earn it: The speaker says the lake had a good year, with water until June and 61 kinds of bird. Then she says that the bund broke in November and flooded two houses, and she says sorry.note 1
Earns it: The good news comes first for a reason: the speaker needs the members to feel the year was theirs before she tells them what the trust failed to do. By the time the bund “gave way” (paragraph 6), the audience has been reminded of its own 4,120 hours, so the failure lands on people who are invested enough to forgive it.note 2
Retelling. Every fact is accurate, but the extract only reports the order of events. It never says why the speech is arranged this way.
Reading the structure. The same facts become evidence for an interpretation of purpose: the order of the speech prepares its audience. The quotation is short and exact.
The difference is the word because. The first extract knows what happens; the second knows why it happens in this order and what it does to these listeners.
B: Analysis and evaluation
Criterion B asks how the writer’s choices make the meaning found under A, and how well they work. In a non-literary text the choices include words, sentence structure and the order of ideas, and in a visual text also image, layout, color and typography. Naming a feature earns almost nothing. Explaining its effect in this text earns the middle marks, and weighing one effect against another, or judging how well a choice serves its purpose, reaches the top.
Does not earn it: The speaker uses a lot of rhetorical devices such as short sentences, repetition and a metaphor of accounts. This creates a sense of honesty and makes the audience trust her.note 1
Earns it: After the long sentence that explains the delay, the verdict “It could not.” (paragraph 7) is three words long. Its shortness refuses any excuse, which suits an apology; yet it also has the clipped tone of the accounts, as if the speaker is recording a loss rather than asking for sympathy, and that restraint makes the apology more credible.note 2
A list with a general effect. Three features are named and joined to an effect that could describe any honest speech.
One choice, two effects, a judgment. The extract explains what the short sentence does, weighs a second effect against the first, and judges why the combination works.
The second extract treats one sentence fully rather than three features briefly. Depth on a few choices nearly always outscores coverage of many.
C: Focus and organization
Criterion C asks whether the essay argues. A clear line of argument, tied to the guiding question or to your own stated focus, should decide the order of the paragraphs. Each paragraph should follow from the last, and quotations should sit where they do work. An essay that walks through the text paragraph by paragraph can still be relevant, but its order is the text’s, not its own.
Does not earn it: In paragraph 4 the speaker gives some statistics about the lake. Next, in paragraph 5, she thanks the volunteers. Then in paragraph 6 she talks about the bund.note 1
Earns it: If the accounts metaphor prepares the members to accept bad news, the pronoun shift in paragraph 7 decides who will carry it.note 2
The text’s order. The links are “next” and “then”: each paragraph of the essay follows a paragraph of the speech, and the guiding question disappears.
The argument’s order. A topic sentence that joins the last paragraph’s claim to this one’s, so the essay moves from one idea to the next.
A transition like the second one shows a marker, in a single sentence, that the essay has a direction. It cannot be written without a plan, which is the strongest reason to spend ten minutes planning.
D: Language
Criterion D asks whether the writing is clear, accurate and varied, in an academic register, with analytical terms used precisely. Many Paper 1 candidates write in a second or third language, and an accent on the page is not penalized. Marks are lost when errors or vague words blur the meaning, or when the register slips into chat. Precision matters more than difficult vocabulary.
Does not earn it: The speaker is very emotional and she really uses the families to make people feel bad, which is kind of a smart move to get them on her side.note 1
Earns it: By pointing out the two families “in the third row” and noting that they agreed to be spoken about (paragraph 6), the speaker turns them from a problem in a report into witnesses who have agreed to hear it.note 2
Vague and informal. “Very emotional”, “really”, “kind of a smart move”: the register is conversational, and the claim is too loose to test.
Exact and formal. Plain academic words (“witnesses”, “accepted”) say precisely what the choice achieves, in one sentence with one subject.
The stronger sentence uses no rare words at all. It is precise because each word does a job: the verb says what the speaker does, the noun says what the families become, and the paragraph reference shows where.
A method for 75 minutes
The method is easiest to see on the speech, minute by minute. In the first five minutes you read both guiding questions, skim both texts and choose, as in the worked choice between the speech and the poster. You then read the speech once straight through, without a pen, to find its shape. The turn at the end of paragraph 5 is visible on that first reading, and so is the return to the treasurer’s tea at the end, which frames the whole speech as part of an ordinary meeting.
The second reading is slower and done with a pen. You mark the layers of the audience (paragraphs 2 and 6), the accounts metaphor (paragraph 3), the numbers set in pairs (paragraph 4), the turn, the correction “by us — by me” (paragraph 7) and the Promise line (paragraph 10). By minute 20 the margin holds perhaps fifteen annotations, several of them questions. One of those questions, why the good news comes first, is already a possible thesis.
Planning takes ten minutes and saves more than ten. You write the thesis in full, then three or four topic sentences, each with the two or three quotations it will use. For the speech, the plan might move from the accounts metaphor, to the pronoun shift, to the members as witnesses, and end with a judgment of the jokes that frame the evening. The order follows the argument, so the essay does not need to follow the speech.
Writing takes forty minutes: about five for the introduction, eight to ten for each body paragraph and four for the conclusion. The last five minutes are for reading the essay through, correcting slips that blur the meaning and checking that each paragraph returns to the thesis. The diagram sets out the same plan as a bar, so the proportions are visible at a glance.


The timed plan, as a list to practice with:
Minutes 0–5: read both guiding questions, skim both texts, choose one.
Minutes 5–20: read the chosen text twice; annotate type, audience, purpose, the turn and the key choices.
Minutes 20–30: write the thesis in full and a topic sentence for each paragraph, with its quotations.
Minutes 30–70: write the introduction, three or four body paragraphs and the conclusion.
Minutes 70–75: reread; fix errors that blur meaning; check every paragraph links to the thesis.
The numbers are a guide, not a rule. A student who reads slowly in English may need twenty minutes for reading and annotating and should take them from the writing time, since an essay built on a misreading cannot be rescued by its length. What matters is that some planning happens, and that the essay is finished.
Where marks are lost
The same few faults cost marks in essay after essay, whatever the text. Each one is easiest to recognize in a single sentence, and each has a correction that needs no more words than the fault. The table pairs a faulty sentence on the speech, or on the poster, with a corrected one.
Fault | A sentence that loses marks | The same point, corrected |
|---|---|---|
Listing devices | The speaker uses anaphora, a metaphor, statistics and pathos to persuade the audience. | The paired dates “until the ninth of June” and “by the twenty-first of March” (paragraph 4) let the members measure their own work in weeks of water. |
Retelling the text | First she thanks the children, then she talks about the lake, and then she apologizes for the bund. | The speech delays its apology until the members have heard their own achievements, so the failure is received by people already invested. |
Writing about the topic | Lakes in cities are very important, and many cities have lost their lakes to buildings. | The speaker never blames the members who live “on what used to be its bed” (paragraph 4); she includes them in the lake’s story instead. |
Ignoring the image | The poster says “Bring your grandfather.”, which is a funny way to advertise a concert. | The headline speaks to the young, but the picture gives the old guitarist as much space as the young man with the microphone, so the joke becomes a real invitation to both. |
A generic “the reader” | This makes the reader feel sad and think about the situation. | For the two families in the third row, being asked for permission turns an apology about them into one made with them. |
No audience or purpose | The speech has many interesting techniques. | Speaking to members who give both money and time, the secretary must report a failure without losing either. |
The six corrections share one habit: each is about this text, its audience and its purpose, and could not be moved to an essay on any other.
Three acres is not much on a map. It is a great deal of silt carried out by hand.
The secretary’s address, paragraph 4
These two sentences show how a fault and its correction can sit on the same words. A device list would call them “short sentences” and stop. An analysis explains that the second sentence moves the number from the map to the members’ own hands, so a small figure becomes a large achievement. It can then add that this prepares the audience to hear the bad news as part of work they share.
A response in full
A complete essay shows how the parts fit. This one was written on the speech in 75 minutes and answers its guiding question. It is a high-band response, and like most strong essays written under time it has flaws: a generic phrase, one overloaded sentence, one claim that goes further than the text. The margin comments name its strengths and its faults by criterion.
Two things lift this essay into the high band. Its thesis commits to a reading of how the speech works, and almost every quotation is short and then explained for this audience. Its marks below the top come from habits that time pressure produces: a sentence that praises without explaining, a paragraph order that follows the speech, and a closing claim stated more strongly than the text allows. Each could be fixed in the five minutes of checking, which is the strongest argument for keeping those five minutes free.
Practice turns this method into habit. The question bank holds Paper 1 texts, each with a guiding question, marking notes and three marked responses to compare with your own.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain what Paper 1 at SL asks and what each of the four criteria rewards.
- To do:
I can choose between two unseen texts in about five minutes by testing what I can say about each.
- To do:
I can read an unseen text for type, audience, purpose and context, then for its turn, then for its details.
- To do:
I can annotate a print text and a visual text in a useful order.
- To do:
I can turn a guiding question into a thesis with a line of argument, or state my own focus.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph whose analysis is longer than its claim and evidence together.
- To do:
I can divide 75 minutes into choosing, reading, planning, writing and checking.
- To do:
I can recognize and correct the six faults that cost the most marks.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.
- Assessment criterion
One of the named qualities on which a piece of assessed work is marked, each with its own maximum mark. A Paper 1 essay is marked on four criteria of five marks each, and each mark rewards a different skill.
- Guided textual analysis
The task set in Paper 1 of Language and Literature: an essay that analyzes how an unseen non-literary text makes its meaning, with a guiding question offered as a way in. The essay may follow the guiding question or a focus of the student's own.
- Line of argument
The connected reasoning that runs through an essay from its thesis to its conclusion, deciding what each paragraph claims and in what order. An essay with a line of argument is organized by its ideas rather than by the order of the text it analyzes.
- Markband
The description of work that earns a given mark or range of marks on one assessment criterion. A marker reads the work against the markbands and chooses the description that fits it best.
- Paper 1
The written exam in which students analyze unseen non-literary texts, each offered with a guiding question. Standard level students write one essay on one of two texts; higher level students write an essay on each text.
- Unseen text
A text that a student meets for the first time in the exam room and analyzes without preparation. Everything an essay on it needs must come from the text itself and the words of the task.
Exam skills for English A Lang & Lit
Paper 1
- 1Paper 1 at SLThis page
- 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
- 3Working with the guiding question
Paper 2
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.