- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- Paper 2: the comparative essay
Paper 2: the comparative essay
What Paper 2 asks, how its five criteria are earned, choosing a question and two works, a thesis that compares, point-by-point structure, a plan for the time, and a high-band essay on A Doll’s House and The Awakening.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Exam skills
- SL and HL
Paper 2 asks for one essay that compares two literary works you have studied in class, written from memory in 1 hour 45 minutes. The paper prints four general questions and no texts, and you answer one. Because the questions name no work, the paper tests whether you can turn what you know about two works into an argument on a question you have not seen. The question used as the running example in the sections that follow is written in the style of the paper:
Some characters must perform a role at home that others have chosen for them. In what ways and to what effect do two works you have studied present such a character? Refer closely to both works in your answer.
A question in the style of Paper 2
What the paper asks
The task has three fixed parts. You write one essay, not answers to several questions. The essay must use two literary works studied in your course, and in Language and Literature non-literary texts cannot be used. The two works must be compared, and the comparison is marked on its own. The essay is the same task at SL and HL: 1 hour 45 minutes and 25 marks at both levels, though it counts for a larger share of the final grade at SL.
The 25 marks are divided equally among five criteria of 5 marks each. Criterion A is knowledge, understanding and interpretation: how well you know both works and whether your reading answers this question. B1 is analysis of textual features and authorial choices, the same skill as close analysis in Paper 1, applied from memory. B2 is comparative analysis, the criterion that exists only in this paper. C is focus and organization, and D is language. Analysis (B1) and comparison (B2) carry ten of the 25 marks between them, so an essay that knows both works well but never sets them against each other cannot reach the top marks.
A comparative essay is therefore different from two good essays on two works. Every main point needs both works to be made. The question about performing a role is a useful example. It can be answered about almost any two works with a central character, and it is pointed enough that an essay prepared on “women in literature” will not fit it without change.
Four questions, and choosing one
The four questions are general by design, so that every class can answer them whatever works it has read. They can fall into three kinds. Some ask about a feature or element of literature: a setting, an ending, a narrator, a minor character, a title, the handling of time. Some ask about a concern: power, belonging, work, memory, justice. Some ask about the reader or audience: how a work makes us judge, trust or sympathize with someone. The table sets out one question of each kind, written for this page, with what it points you toward.
Kind of question | Example | What it points you toward |
|---|---|---|
A feature or element | In what ways and to what effect do two works you have studied end on a question rather than an answer? | Endings as authorial choices: the last scene, line or image, and what it leaves unresolved |
A concern | Compare how two works you have studied present the cost of keeping a secret. | Characters, situations and choices, read through the methods that present them |
The reader’s response | To what extent do two works you have studied make the reader complicit in what they show? | Narrative voice, dramatic irony, staging: how each work positions its audience |
The kinds overlap, and every question, whatever its kind, still rewards analysis of how the works are written. A question about a concern is not an invitation to discuss the concern itself. The running question about performing a role is a concern question, but its first half, “In what ways”, asks for methods, and its second half, “to what effect”, asks what those methods achieve.
Reading a question closely
Read each question twice and mark three things: the command words, the key terms and any condition. In the running question the command words are “In what ways and to what effect”, which divide the answer into two halves, the methods and their effects. The key terms are “perform” and “a role”, which suggest theater, costume and an audience. The condition is “that others have chosen for them”, which rules out a character who chooses a role freely. An essay that ignores the condition, and writes about any character who pretends, answers a nearby question instead of this one.
Try it
Mark the command words, key terms and any condition in this question: To what extent do two works you have studied make the reader complicit in what they show?
The command words are “To what extent”, which ask for a judgment of degree: an essay that only shows complicity has answered half the question. The key term is “complicit”, which means more than sympathetic: the reader is drawn into sharing in something wrong. The condition is “what they show”, which points to the works’ methods of showing, such as narrative voice, dramatic irony or staging, rather than to their subjects.
Choose the question before you choose the works. Students who arrive with a favorite pair and look for a question to fit it often write the essay they prepared rather than the one set. The better order is to find the question you can answer most precisely, and only then ask which two of your works give it the most to work with. A prepared pair can still be the right one, but it has to earn its place against the question.
Choosing two works for the question
A good pair gives the question two different answers. Two works that answer it in the same way leave you nothing to compare except quantity, and the essay slides into listing likenesses. Two works with nothing in common leave you nothing to compare at all. The pair to look for shares enough to be set side by side on the question, and differs in a way you can explain, ideally in how each work is written.
Works of different forms often make the strongest pairs, because each form has methods the other lacks. For the running question, a student who has studied Henrik Ibsen’s play A Doll’s House (1879), in William Archer’s translation, and Kate Chopin’s novel The Awakening (1899) has a pair that fits closely. Both present a wife whose household depends on her playing a part her husband has written. The play presents that part mainly from the outside, in what Nora says and does on stage. The novel has a narrator who can describe what Edna is becoming behind the part. The question about performance can then be answered through a real difference of method.
Archer’s Helmer calls to his wife from his study in the play’s first minutes:
Is that my lark twittering there?
Henrik Ibsen, A Doll’s House, Act I, trans. William Archer (1890)
The line gives the essay its first piece of evidence. Helmer names his wife as a small caged bird, and Nora answers in the same playful key, so the role is set up before the audience knows there is anything to hide. Chopin opens differently: her narrator says that Léonce looks at his sunburned wife “as one looks at a valuable piece of personal property which has suffered some damage” (chapter I). One work shows the role being assigned in dialogue; the other has a narrator name it for the reader. That contrast is a comparison of method, and it comes from choosing the pair for the question.
The worked example shows the order of thinking: the question’s condition first, then a likeness, then a difference of method, then a check that the pair can answer the whole question. The same order works for any question and any set of works. If two pairs both seem to fit, choose the one whose difference you can explain with the most precise evidence.
A thesis that compares
The thesis of a comparative essay is one or two sentences in the introduction that say how both works answer the question and how they differ. It is the claim every paragraph will test. A thesis that only states a likeness gives the essay nothing to argue, because a likeness can only be repeated. A thesis that names a likeness and the difference it leads to gives each paragraph a job: to show the difference at work on one point. The two theses that follow answer the running question with the same two works.
Weak: Both A Doll’s House and The Awakening present women who perform roles for their husbands and eventually rebel against them.note 1 This essay will compare how the two works present this.note 2
Strong: Both works present a wife whose performance keeps a household running, but Ibsen makes the performance visible on stage,note 3 in pet names, a dance and a change of dress, so that Nora ends it in full view of the audience,note 4 while Chopin’s narrator shows the self growing behind Edna’s role, so that her release can only be private.note 5
A likeness only. True of both works and of many others; there is nothing here to prove or disprove.
A promise, not a claim. The sentence says what the essay will do instead of what it will argue.
Likeness, then the turn. The shared point is precise (performance keeps a household running), and “but” opens the difference.
Method and evidence. The thesis names how the play shows the role, which tells the reader what the paragraphs will analyze.
What the difference does. The last clause links each method to its effect, so the second half of the question is answered too.
The strong thesis is longer, but every clause in it will become a paragraph. It also commits to a judgment about form: that a play can make a performance public and a novel can make it private. A thesis of this kind, which states how the works differ and why, is a comparative thesis, and the page on comparing two works takes it further.
The shape of a comparative essay
A comparative essay can be organized in two ways. In block structure, the first half discusses one work and the second half the other, and the comparison is made in linking sentences and the conclusion. In point-by-point structure, each body paragraph takes one point of comparison and discusses both works on it. The diagram sets the two plans side by side for the running question and marks where the two works meet in each.


In the block plan the works meet twice: once in the link that opens the second half, usually a sentence beginning “Similarly”, and once in the conclusion. Everything between is description of one work at a time. In the point-by-point plan they meet in every paragraph, so comparison is the essay’s main activity rather than its last step. This is why point-by-point structure is safer for criterion B2: the criterion rewards comparison that runs through the essay, and the structure makes it hard to avoid.
For the running question, a point-by-point plan might take three points, each with evidence from both works. The first is how the role is assigned: Helmer’s “lark” and “squirrel” against the narrator’s “valuable piece of personal property”. The second is the performance itself: the tarantella Nora rehearses against the Tuesday receptions Edna stops holding. The third is how the role is put down: Nora’s change of costume, when she goes off “To take off my doll’s dress”, against Edna’s “fictitious self”, which she is “casting aside”. Each point moves the argument one stage further, from the role’s beginning to its end.
How the five criteria are earned
Each criterion rewards something different, and the same paragraph can do well on one and poorly on another. The pairs that follow are short extracts from two responses to the running question about performing a role, both on A Doll’s House and The Awakening. In each pair the first extract earns the marks and the second does not, and the sentence after it names the difference.
A: knowledge, understanding and interpretation
Criterion A rewards detailed knowledge of both works used to build a reading that answers this question. Knowing what happens is the starting point. The marks go to an essay that interprets what happens in the terms the question sets.
Earns the marks: Nora’s performance is not only for Helmer. She has kept the secret of the loan for years by playing the spendthrift he believes in, so the role has been her cover as well as her cage.note 1
Does not: A Doll’s House is about Nora, who has a secret debt. During the play Krogstad tries to use the debt against her, and she grows more and more worried until she finally walks out on her family.note 2
A, strength. The facts (the loan, the secret) are used to say something about the role that the question asks about: it protected her as well as confined her.
A, missed. Accurate plot, but no reading of it: the extract never mentions performance or a role, so it answers no question at all.
Both extracts know the plot. The first makes the knowledge serve an interpretation, and that interpretation is specific to the question.
B1: analysis of textual features and authorial choices
Criterion B1 rewards analysis of how each writer makes meaning: structure, voice, staging, imagery, characterization, form. It is the same skill as close analysis of an unseen text, applied from memory. A few precisely remembered details, explained, earn more than many named features.
Earns the marks: While Helmer calls to her from his room, a stage direction has Nora hide “the bag of macaroons in her pocket” and wipe her mouth, so Ibsen shows her performing in the play’s first minutes, before her husband has even entered.note 1
Does not: Ibsen uses a lot of symbolism in the play, such as the macaroons, the Christmas tree and the tarantella, which all symbolize Nora’s situation.note 2
B1, strength. One remembered stage direction is analyzed as a choice: the audience sees the performance prepared before Helmer sees it, which is something only staging can do.
B1, missed. Three features are named and given one vague meaning; nothing explains what any of them does.
The second extract proves the student remembers the play. The first proves the student can analyze it, because the detail is tied to an effect on the audience at a particular moment.
B2: comparative analysis
Criterion B2 rewards comparison that drives the essay: the works set against each other point by point, on how they are written as well as what they say, with a sense of what the contrast shows about each. Two separate accounts joined by “similarly” sit at the bottom of the criterion. A comparison of content alone, of what happens, sits in the middle.
Earns the marks: Ibsen has to show the role being assigned through dialogue, in Helmer’s “lark” and “squirrel”, whereas Chopin’s narrator names it directly: Léonce looks at Edna “as one looks at a valuable piece of personal property”. The audience must infer what the reader of the novel is told.note 1
Does not: Helmer treats Nora like a child. Similarly, in The Awakening Léonce treats Edna like his property.note 2
B2, strength. The comparison is of method (dialogue against narration), and the last sentence says what the difference means for each audience.
B2, missed. Two statements about content sit side by side; “similarly” joins them but compares nothing.
Both extracts see that the husbands treat their wives as possessions. The first goes on to compare how each work shows it, which is where the marks for B2 lie. The page on comparing two works treats this criterion in depth.
C: focus and organization
Criterion C rewards an essay that argues: a clear line from the thesis through every paragraph to the conclusion, with quotations placed where they do work. A paragraph that follows the plot of one work, scene by scene, has lost its focus even if every sentence is accurate.
Earns the marks: The clearest sign that each role has been put down is a change of clothes, and the two works give that change opposite scales: a single costume in the play, a lifelong “garment” in the novel.note 1
Does not: In Act Three of A Doll’s House, after the party, Helmer reads Krogstad’s letter and is very angry with Nora.note 2
C, strength. A topic sentence that names both works, the point and the claim, and connects to the thesis about public and private release.
C, missed. The paragraph opens on the next event in the plot; no point is stated, and the essay’s argument stops.
A reader of the first topic sentence knows what the paragraph will prove. A reader of the second knows only what happens next in one work.
D: language
Criterion D rewards clear, accurate and varied writing in an academic register, with literary terms used precisely. Second-language writers are not marked down for an accent on the page; vague words and errors that blur the meaning cost marks.
Earns the marks: Helmer’s monologue while Nora changes offstage keeps the language of the role going, “like a hunted dove”, while Nora is taking off its costume.note 1
Does not: Helmer is kind of fake when he talks to Nora at the end and the way he talks is really bad and shows he doesn’t get it.note 2
D, strength. Precise terms (“monologue”, “offstage”) and a quotation built into the grammar of the sentence.
D, missed. Informal words (“kind of fake”, “doesn’t get it”) and a vague judgment (“really bad”) blur what the student means.
The second extract may contain a real insight, that Helmer has not understood. Its language hides the insight, so the marker cannot reward it under A or B1 either.
A method for the 1 hour 45 minutes
The time allowed is long enough to plan properly and too short to plan twice. Strong essays usually spend the first 20 minutes without writing a sentence of the essay. The walk-through that follows shows those minutes on the running question.
You read all four questions first, slowly, before deciding anything. The question about performing a role stands out because two of your works, A Doll’s House and The Awakening, both have a wife at their center. You mark “In what ways and to what effect”, “perform” and “that others have chosen for them”. Then you check the condition: Nora’s role is chosen by her father and her husband, and Edna’s by her husband and her society, so both fit. You glance at the other three questions to make sure none suits your works better, then commit.
Next you test the pair. The likeness is clear, and the difference of method, a play against a novel with a narrator, gives the essay a thesis. You write the thesis in note form: both perform to keep house going; Ibsen shows it on stage, Chopin’s narrator shows the self behind it; public exit against private release. Then you list three points down the left of the page and, beside each, a quotation or a precise moment from each work. For the first point you write “lark, squirrel” and “valuable piece of personal property”. Where you cannot remember a quotation, you note the moment instead, such as Edna not being at home on a Tuesday.
Before writing, you number the points in the order that builds the argument, from how the role is assigned, through the performance, to how it ends. The plan now holds a thesis, three topic sentences and about eight pieces of evidence, roughly half from each work. The essay itself then takes about 75 minutes, which leaves time at the end to reread it. The timed plan divides the 105 minutes; adjust it to your own speed, but keep the planning and the checking.
Minutes 0–5: read all four questions; mark the command words, key terms and any condition.
Minutes 5–10: choose the question, then the two works; test the pair for likeness and a difference of method.
Minutes 10–20: write the thesis; plan three or four points, each with evidence from both works; put them in order.
Minutes 20–95: write the introduction (about 5 minutes), the body paragraphs (about 15 to 20 minutes each) and the conclusion (about 5 minutes).
Minutes 95–105: reread; check that each topic sentence names both works and serves the thesis, and correct errors.
The commonest timing fault is to skip the plan and start writing at minute 3. The essay that results usually discovers its argument in the third paragraph, by which point the introduction promises something else. Ten minutes of planning repay themselves in every criterion except D.
Where marks are lost
The faults that cost most marks in this paper are few and predictable. Most come from treating the essay as two essays, or from writing about the works instead of answering the question. The table shows each fault in a sentence from an essay on the running question, and a correction.
Fault | A sentence that shows it | Corrected |
|---|---|---|
Two essays stapled together | “Now that I have discussed A Doll’s House, I will turn to The Awakening.” | “Where Nora’s role is assigned in dialogue, Edna’s is named by the narrator, which keeps the reader at a distance from Léonce from the first chapter.” |
Content compared, methods ignored | “Both women are treated as possessions by their husbands.” | “Both husbands treat their wives as possessions, but Ibsen lets Helmer’s pet names show it, while Chopin’s narrator states it in a simile of damaged property.” |
A prepared answer to a nearby question | “Both works show the oppression of women in the nineteenth century.” | “Both works show a wife performing a part her husband chose, and both end when she refuses to play it.” |
A memorized quotation that does not fit | “Nora calls herself a ‘doll-wife’, which shows how sad she is.” | “Nora’s ‘doll-wife’ describes the role exactly: a part played for others’ pleasure, with no self of its own.” |
The second work fading out | A last body paragraph on Nora’s exit with one sentence on Edna. | A last body paragraph that sets Nora’s public exit against Edna’s solitary ending, with evidence from each. |
The last fault is the hardest to see while writing, because it comes from time pressure. Students often know one work better than the other, and in the last half hour the stronger work takes over. A plan with evidence from both works for every point is the best protection.
Context earns its place in the body of the essay, attached to a moment it explains. A sentence on what a wife’s leaving her children meant to Ibsen’s first audiences belongs beside Nora’s exit, where it sharpens the analysis of the ending. The same sentence in the introduction is information without a use.
A response in full
The essay that follows answers the running question on A Doll’s House and The Awakening as a strong student might, in the time and from memory. Its margin comments say what each marked passage does and under which criterion, and the marks explain why each criterion sits where it does. The essay has real flaws, of the kind speed produces, and the comments mark them as well as its strengths.
The essay earns its marks mainly through comparison: every body paragraph holds both works, and most end by saying what the contrast shows. Its lost marks come from the last two paragraphs, where time ran short. A conclusion that judged which work makes the performance more costly, and why, would have lifted both C and A.
The question bank holds Paper 2 questions in this style, each with marking notes and three marked essays at different bands, for practice with your own works. The page on comparing two works takes further the skill this paper rewards most, setting two works against each other on how they are written. The page on preparing works for the paper covers the knowledge that skill depends on.
Self-check
- To do:
I can say what Paper 2 asks and what each of its five criteria rewards.
- To do:
I can mark the command words, key terms and conditions of a general question and choose a question before choosing works.
- To do:
I can choose two works for a question because they differ in method as well as resemble each other.
- To do:
I can write a thesis that states a likeness and the difference it leads to.
- To do:
I can plan a point-by-point essay with evidence from both works for every point.
- To do:
I can divide the 1 hour 45 minutes into reading, planning, writing and checking.
- To do:
I can recognize and correct the faults that cost marks, from stapled essays to a fading second work.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.
- Block structure
A way of organizing a comparative essay in which the first half discusses one work and the second half the other, with the comparison made in links and in the conclusion. It tends to produce two separate accounts rather than one argument about both works.
- Comparative essay
An essay that answers one question by setting two works against each other, so that each point of its argument depends on both. It differs from two separate essays placed side by side, because its claims concern the relation between the works.
- Paper 2
The written examination in English A, at both levels, in which a student answers one of four general questions with an essay comparing two literary works studied in class, from memory and without the texts. It is marked out of 25 on five criteria, one of them for comparison.
- Point-by-point structure
A way of organizing a comparative essay in which each body paragraph takes one point of comparison and discusses both works on it. It keeps the comparison running through the whole essay rather than leaving it to the end.
Exam skills for English A Lang & Lit
Paper 1
Paper 2
- 4Paper 2: the comparative essayThis page
- 5Comparing two works
- 6Preparing your works for Paper 2
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.