Working with the guiding question

Working with Paper 1’s guiding question: what it points to, its command terms, turning it into a thesis, answering without being trapped, setting your own focus, and three questions on one interview.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

25 min readLast reviewed

Every Paper 1 text comes with one guiding question. It points to two things at once: a feature of the text, an area of its writer’s choices, and a meaning or effect those choices serve. A question that asks how an interview presents a relationship between two musicians points first at the interview’s way of presenting: its questions, its stories, its order. It also points at a concern of the text, here old and new music and the people who make it.

The question is an offer, not a requirement. You may answer it, or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text, and both essays are marked in the same way. Used well, the question is the quickest way into an unseen text, because someone who has read the text closely has chosen it to open the text up. Used badly, it becomes a cage: the essay answers one half of it, repeats its words and never reaches the rest of the text.

A good example is an interview from an online music magazine in Accra, published a month before a live night on which an older highlife guitarist shares a stage with a young drill artist. Its guiding question asks: How does the interview present the relationship between an older musician and the young artists who borrow from his music?

On the Mic: Uncle KwameLorry Park, an online magazine of young music and art in Accra (On the Mic, its interview series), 2026Written for Augment Education
On the Mic: Uncle Kwame
He has played lead guitar for The Salt Road Band since 1974, at hotels, weddings and outdoorings from the Accra coast to Kumasi. Next month he shares our roof with Sly Gidi, who says drill is the new highlife. We asked Uncle Kwame what he thinks of that — and he asked us what we think highlife is.
Interview: Lorry Park · Photos: Kojo M. · 20 May 2026
Lorry Park: Uncle, you are seventy-six and you are about to play a drill night. Are you nervous?
Uncle Kwame: Nervous of what? A young man with a microphone? I have played a wedding in Kumasi where the bride’s father pulled out the plug because he did not like our second song. Then he paid us double to put it back in. After that night, nothing frightens me. [laughs]
Lorry Park: Sly Gidi says drill is the new highlife. Is he right?
Uncle Kwame: He is half right, and the half he is right about is the important half. When we started, the older bands said we were spoiling highlife. Too fast, too loud, electric guitars, long hair. My own teacher would not come to hear us for two years. So when I hear a young man say his music is the new thing, I am not angry. I am hearing myself. But he says “new highlife” as if highlife is old. Highlife was never old. It was always the music of whoever was dancing that year.
Lorry Park: So what makes it highlife, if it is not the sound?
Uncle Kwame: The dancers. You play for the people in front of you, not for the people who will hear the record. In a hotel in 1978 you could see in five minutes who was a teacher, who was a trader, who came from the village that week. You change the song for them. You make the line longer for the old men. You speed up when the young ones come in. A guitar line is a road, and you have to see who is walking on it.
Lorry Park: Can you see the dancers when everybody is filming you on their phones?
Uncle Kwame: [long pause] That is a good question. Small small, I am learning to look over the phones. Behind every phone there is a person. Sometimes the person is dancing with one hand.
Lorry Park: Ei. Okay. You played on NaaK’s “Last Trotro” last year. What did the young people teach you?
Uncle Kwame: That a machine can be patient. I thought the drum machine would be like a man who talks all the time and never listens. But NaaK made it listen. She took things out. That is the hardest thing in music, to take things out, and she is twenty-two.
Lorry Park: The band has three members now. How has that changed it?
Uncle Kwame: There were seven of us in 1974. Seven young men from Jamestown with one amplifier between us, carrying it on our heads to the bus. Four have gone. When we play now, I still leave the space where the trumpet used to answer me. Nii Lartey says I should fill it. Yaw says leave it. I leave it. People who knew the old band hear the trumpet anyway. People who did not, they hear a space and wonder what should be there. Both are listening.
Lorry Park: So what should people expect on the roof next month?
Uncle Kwame: Expect an argument. A good one. Sly Gidi will play his drums and I will answer with my guitar, and the dancers will decide who is right. They always do. Tell the young people to bring their grandfathers. And tell the grandfathers to bring their dancing shoes, not their complaints.
Lorry Park: Last one. What is the salt road?
Uncle Kwame: When I was a boy, the women from Jamestown carried salt from the coast to the markets inland, and they sang on the road to make the load lighter. Every town on the way added a line to the song. By the time the salt reached Kumasi, the song was longer than the road. That is the band’s name. That is also highlife. Write that down.

What a guiding question points to

A guiding question has three working parts. Its opening words are its command term, the words that say what kind of thinking the answer must do: how, in what ways, to what extent. Its feature is the area of choices it names, here the way the interview presents its subject. Its concern is the meaning or relationship it asks about, here the older musician and the young artists. The diagram splits the interview’s question into these three parts and shows each feeding the thesis.

The guiding question on the interview at the top, with arrows to three boxes: command (How: explain the means), feature (how the interview presents) and concern (old and young musicians).The guiding question on the interview at the top, with arrows to three boxes: command (How: explain the means), feature (how the interview presents) and concern (old and young musicians).
A guiding question split into its command, its feature and its concern. A thesis answers all three at once: it names the means and the claim they make.

The three parts are not equal. The concern tells you what the essay is about, and the command term tells you the shape of its argument, but the feature is where the marks under criterion B are earned. A thesis that answers the concern without the feature (the interview shows that Uncle Kwame respects young musicians) has a reading but no analysis. A thesis that names features without the concern (the interview uses questions, anecdotes and metaphors) has analysis with nothing to prove.

Four ways a question can open

Guiding questions in Language and Literature can open in several ways, four of them common, and each asks something slightly different of the argument. The table sets out each opening with a question of that kind on the interview.

Opening

What it asks of your argument

A question of this kind on the interview

How …

Explain the means: which choices make the meaning, and how they work together.

How does the interview present the relationship between an older musician and the young artists who borrow from his music?

In what ways …

Several distinct means, each developed, often from different parts of the text.

In what ways do the magazine’s questions shape the portrait of Uncle Kwame?

To what extent …

A judgment of degree: how far the claim holds, where it holds less, and why.

To what extent does the interview persuade its readers that highlife is not old music?

What is the effect of …

The effect of one named choice on the reader, traced across the whole text.

What is the effect of the interview’s closing story about the salt road?

How and in what ways are close, and an essay that answers one well usually answers the other. To what extent is different. It asks for a verdict, so an essay that only lists ways in which the interview persuades has answered half of it. The strongest answers to a to what extent question say where the claim holds, where it weakens, and how far it holds on balance.

To what extentnote 1 does the interview persuade its readersnote 2 that highlife is not old musicnote 3?

  1. Command term. A judgment of degree. The essay must end with a verdict (largely, only for some readers), not only a list of ways.

  2. Feature. Persuasion of readers: the interview’s choices as argument, aimed at the magazine’s young readers.

  3. Concern. A claim the text itself makes (“Highlife was never old”, paragraph 7). The essay tests it against the whole interview.

Reading the key words this closely takes a minute and saves the essay from answering a question that was not asked. The command term decides the shape of the conclusion. The feature decides which choices to analyze. The concern decides what the analysis is for.

Answering without being trapped

A guiding question organizes an essay; it does not fence it in. The trap is to read the question as a list of things to find, so that the essay finds them and stops. A question about the relationship between an older musician and young artists can be answered from three paragraphs of the interview, the ones that mention Sly Gidi and NaaK. An essay built only on those paragraphs misses most of the text, including the story of the four band members who have gone and the closing story of the salt road.

People who knew the old band hear the trumpet anyway. People who did not, they hear a space and wonder what should be there. Both are listening.

“On the Mic: Uncle Kwame”, paragraph 15

These lines never mention a young artist, yet they may be the interview’s fullest answer to the question. Old listeners and new ones hear the same gap in the music differently, and Uncle Kwame refuses to say that either is wrong. A reader who uses the question as a lens rather than a checklist sees that the relationship between old and young runs through the whole interview, even where neither is named. That is what answering through the question means: every part of the text is read in its light.

The second trap is the question’s own wording. A guiding question is written to open the text, but its words are not the text’s words. An essay that repeats the phrase the relationship between an older musician and the young artists in every paragraph sounds focused, but it is circling the question instead of answering it. Use the question’s idea and your own words, and quote the text rather than the question.

From question to thesis in three steps

A thesis answers the guiding question in a sentence or two, and it can be built in three steps: answer the concern, name the means, and add a judgment. The worked example takes the interview’s guiding question through all three.

The thesis answers the concern (inheritance, not rivalry), names the means (questions against stories) and contains a judgment (the stories do the persuading). It also suggests a plan, since each story can become evidence in a paragraph. A thesis that does these three things can be written in two or three minutes once the text has been read twice.

Setting your own focus

Instead of answering the guiding question, you may set a self-chosen focus: a focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text that organizes your reading of it. It is marked in exactly the same way as an answer to the guiding question. It is not an escape from analysis, because a focus on a theme alone (“music and memory”) is not technical or formal.

When to set your own focus

There are two good reasons. The first is that the guiding question points at something you cannot develop for a whole essay: a feature the text uses less than the question suggests, or one you do not feel able to analyze. The second is that you have seen something else that organizes the text better. In the interview, a student may notice that most answers are stories, and that the stories carry the argument. That pattern explains the whole text, so it makes a strong focus.

There is also a poor reason, which is not having read the question carefully. A self-chosen focus takes the same thinking as an answer to the question, and often more, since you must also show that your focus is worth following. If the guiding question opens the text well for you, answer it.

How to state it

State the focus in the introduction, in one plain sentence, and make it technical. Then write a thesis about it, exactly as you would for the guiding question. Both sentences together tell the marker what the essay will do and why.

Unclear: I will not answer the guiding question. I will write about other interesting things in the interview, such as music, age and the city of Accra.note 1

Clear: Rather than following the guiding question, this essay focuses on one technical aspect of the interview: the way Uncle Kwame answers most questions with a story instead of a definition.note 2 These stories are his argument, and they let him win a debate about old and new music without ever arguing against the young drill artist he is about to play with.note 3

  1. A topic, not a focus. Music, age and Accra are subjects of the interview, not aspects of how it is made. The essay has nothing technical to analyze and no thesis.

  2. A formal focus. The pattern of answers as stories is a choice of form that runs through the text.

  3. A thesis on the focus. The second sentence makes a claim about what the pattern does, so the essay has something to prove.

Three guiding questions on one interview

The same text can carry several good guiding questions, and each sends an essay down a different path. Working three of them through on the interview shows how much the question shapes the argument, and why the same evidence can serve different theses.

First question: the old and the young

How does the interview present the relationship between an older musician and the young artists who borrow from his music?

Thesis. The magazine’s questions set up a contest between old and new, but Uncle Kwame’s answers, told mostly as stories, turn it into an inheritance in which the young are the latest travelers on his road.

Plan. A first paragraph reads the provoking questions (“you are seventy-six and you are about to play a drill night”, paragraph 4) as the frame of a contest. A second analyzes how his own history answers them: “I am hearing myself” (paragraph 7). A third takes the NaaK answer, where the young artist teaches him “That a machine can be patient” (paragraph 13), so that learning runs both ways. A fourth reads the trumpet’s space (paragraph 15) and the salt road (paragraph 19) as images of a music that every generation adds to. The conclusion judges that the stories persuade more than any statement could.

Second question: the magazine’s questions

In what ways do the magazine’s questions shape the portrait of Uncle Kwame?

Thesis. The magazine’s short, bold questions cast Uncle Kwame first as an old man to be tested and then as an elder to be consulted, and the portrait comes from the gap between what they expect and what he answers.

Plan. One paragraph on the questions that test him: his age, his nerves, Sly Gidi’s claim. One on the moment a question defeats his first answer, the phones, where the editor keeps the “[long pause]” (paragraph 11) and he admits “That is a good question.” One on the magazine’s own voice, “Ei. Okay.” (paragraph 12), which shows a young interviewer surprised by him. One on the last question, “What is the salt road?”, which hands him the final word, and his command “Write that down.” (paragraph 19). This plan analyzes the interview’s form and editing more than its subject, and it would suit a student who reads interviews closely.

Third question: a judgment of degree

To what extent does the interview persuade its readers that highlife is not old music?

Thesis. The interview largely persuades its young readers, because Uncle Kwame redefines highlife by its dancers rather than its sound. The persuasion depends, though, on trusting one elder’s stories, and the young musicians’ side is heard only through him.

Plan. One paragraph on the redefinition: “Highlife was never old. It was always the music of whoever was dancing that year.” (paragraph 7). One on the hotel scene, where the guitarist changes the song for the people in front of him (paragraph 9), as evidence for that definition. One on the salt road as a definition disguised as a memory. A last paragraph weighs the limits: Sly Gidi is heard only through the magazine’s one-line report of his claim, and the magazine has chosen what to print. The conclusion gives a verdict of degree, which is what to what extent asks for.

A guitar line is a road, and you have to see who is walking on it.

“On the Mic: Uncle Kwame”, paragraph 9

This one line serves all three essays in different ways. For the first question, it shows the older musician watching and serving the young. For the second, it shows how a question about definitions gets an image for an answer. For the third, it is evidence that highlife is defined by its listeners. The evidence stays the same; the question decides what it proves.

Try it

Write a thesis for a fourth guiding question on the interview: What is the effect of the interview’s closing story about the salt road?

One possible thesis: the closing story works as a definition of highlife disguised as a memory, since a song to which “Every town on the way added a line” describes the music Uncle Kwame has defended throughout. Ending on it lets him, rather than the magazine, decide what the interview has been about, and his command “Write that down” makes the point explicit. The effect is to send the young reader to the roof session expecting not a contest but another verse.

Where marks are lost

Most faults that come from the guiding question are faults of the introduction, and they spread from there through the whole essay. The table shows three common ones on the interview, each with a correction.

Fault

A sentence that loses marks

The same point, corrected

Quoting the question back

In this essay I will discuss how the interview presents the relationship between an older musician and the young artists who borrow from his music.

The interview frames old and new as rivals, but Uncle Kwame’s stories recast the young as his heirs.

Answering half the question

The interview presents Uncle Kwame as a funny and confident man who has played for fifty years.

Uncle Kwame’s confidence matters because it lets him greet the young drill artist as his younger self, not as a threat.

Features with no meaning

The interview uses questions, anecdotes, humor and metaphors.

The interview answers each provoking question with a story, so the past becomes the argument for the present.

The corrected sentences share one quality: each makes a claim that could be wrong. A thesis that cannot be disagreed with (the interview uses many features) cannot organize an essay, because no paragraph is needed to prove it.

The guiding question and the four criteria

The guiding question touches every criterion, but most directly C. The pairs in the table come from essays on the interview, one sentence that earns the marks and one that does not, with the difference named.

Criterion

Earns it

Does not

The difference

A: Understanding and interpretation

The magazine sets up a fight that Uncle Kwame refuses, so the interview becomes a portrait of an elder recognizing himself in the young.

Uncle Kwame plays guitar and is going to play with Sly Gidi on the roof.

A reading of what the text does, against a summary of what it says.

B: Analysis and evaluation

The bare “Four have gone” follows a detailed picture of seven young men, and the missing detail makes the loss felt.

The writer uses a short sentence for effect.

One choice explained in this text, against a device named with a general effect.

C: Focus and organization

If the stories answer the questions about rivalry, the trumpet’s space shows what that inheritance costs.

Another thing in the interview is when he talks about the trumpet.

A transition that carries the thesis forward, against a list joined by “another”.

D: Language

The redefinition moves the debate from sound to dancers.

He basically says highlife is about dancing and not really about the sound.

Precise and formal, against loose and conversational.

Under criterion C, the guiding question or your own focus is the thread the marker follows. An essay can be relevant in every paragraph and still score low on C if its paragraphs follow the interview from question to question. The highest marks go to an essay whose paragraphs each answer part of the question and whose order is its own.

A response in full

A complete essay shows a self-chosen focus at work. This one was written on the interview in 75 minutes and sets its own focus instead of answering the guiding question. Like most strong essays written under time it has flaws, and the margin comments name its strengths and faults by criterion.

Exemplar · High band17 of 20 marks

Paper 1: “On the Mic: Uncle Kwame”, a high-band response with its own focus

On On the Mic: Uncle Kwame

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The focus does the work a guiding question would have done. It tells the marker in the first paragraph what the essay will analyze, it gives every paragraph a question to ask of its part of the interview, and it leads to a conclusion that judges. It also reaches much of what the guiding question asked for. An essay about stories as argument ends up explaining the relationship between the old musician and the young, which shows how close a good focus usually stays to the text’s central concern.

Practice in choosing between the question and a focus of your own is most useful on texts you have not seen. The question bank holds Paper 1 texts, each with its guiding question and three marked responses.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can split a guiding question into its command term, its feature and its concern.

  • To do:

    I can explain what how, in what ways, to what extent and what is the effect of ask of an argument.

  • To do:

    I can turn a guiding question into a thesis by answering the concern, naming the means and adding a judgment.

  • To do:

    I can use a guiding question as a lens on the whole text, not a list of things to find.

  • To do:

    I can decide when a self-chosen focus serves better, and state it as a technical or formal aspect.

  • To do:

    I can recognize a thesis that quotes the question back, answers half of it or names features with no meaning.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Command term

A word or phrase in an exam question that names the kind of thinking the answer must do. It shapes the argument an answer builds as much as the question's subject does.

Guiding question

The question printed with each Paper 1 text, which points to a feature of the text and a meaning or effect it serves. It is offered as a way into the text, and an essay may answer it or set a focus of its own.

Self-chosen focus

A focus on a technical or formal aspect of a Paper 1 text that a student sets instead of answering the guiding question. It is stated in the introduction and is marked in the same way as an answer to the guiding question.

Exam skills for English A Lang & Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding questionThis page

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.