Comparing two works

Criterion B2 in depth: comparing methods as well as content, what a comparison shows, the comparative thesis and paragraph, connectives that carry logic, works of different forms, the faults that keep B2 low, and a middle-band essay.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Exam skills
  • SL and HL

21 min readLast reviewed

In Paper 2, comparison is marked on its own: criterion B2, comparative analysis, is worth 5 of the 25 marks, as much as knowledge or analysis. Its marks go to an essay in which the two works are set against each other throughout, on how they are written as well as what they are about. Two plays often studied in Language and Literature classes, Susan Glaspell’s Trifles (1916) and Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House (1879), are the running pair here, for a question written for this page in the style of the paper:

Many works confine their characters to a single place. Compare how two works you have studied use a confined setting, and to what effect. Refer closely to both works in your answer.

A question in the style of Paper 2

What criterion B2 rewards

Criterion B1 asks how well you analyze each work’s choices. Criterion B2 asks what you do with the two analyses together. A comparison in this sense is an argument about both works at once, in which each work makes something visible in the other. An essay can analyze each play brilliantly and still score low on B2 if the two analyses never meet.

Essays tend to sit at three levels on this criterion. At the bottom are two separate accounts joined by a word such as “similarly”. In the middle are essays that compare what happens, such as both women being trapped at home, without comparing how each work makes that visible. At the top are essays that compare method, show what the contrast means, and keep doing so in every paragraph. The table puts one sentence from each level side by side, all on the running question.

Level

A sentence on the running question

What it does

Low

“Trifles is set in a kitchen. Similarly, A Doll’s House is set in a living room.”

Two facts placed next to each other; nothing is compared

Middle

“Both women are trapped in their homes by their husbands.”

Compares content: true, but it could be said by someone who had read summaries

High

“Glaspell confines the audience to a kitchen whose objects must be read as evidence, while Ibsen confines it to a parlor where a marriage is argued out in words.”

Compares method: how each play uses its one room, which leads to a difference of effect

The high sentence uses no harder words than the others. It is stronger because it names what each playwright does with the confined space, and that names a real difference between the plays.

Content and method

Setting against setting is content: both plays are set in one room of one house. How each playwright builds that room, and what each lets the room do, is method. Glaspell’s opening stage direction lists what is wrong with the kitchen before anyone speaks:

unwashed pans under the sink, a loaf of bread outside the bread-box, a dish-towel on the table—other signs of incompleted work

Trifles, line 1

The room is made of objects, and each is a small sign that work was interrupted. When the sheriff later dismisses the room as “Nothing here but kitchen things” (line 26), the audience has already been taught to read it more carefully than he does. Ibsen’s first stage direction does something else. His room is “comfortably and tastefully, but not expensively, furnished”, a description of taste and income rather than of disorder. The room tells the audience who the Helmers wish to seem, and the play then argues out, in dialogue, what lies behind that comfort.

The diagram sets out the comparison this opens. The two plays share their ground, a woman confined to a home, and the difference lies in method: one play gives its room to objects and to the women who read them, and the other gives it to speech. The effects follow from the methods. Glaspell’s confinement is shared by women as a group and judged in silence, while Ibsen’s is the confinement of one marriage, ended in public.

Diagram: shared ground at the top, a woman confined to one home, with arrows down to Trifles and A Doll’s House. Under each, its method (a kitchen read through objects, the wife offstage; one room, the wife on stage, dialogue) and its effect, then a box at the foot saying what the contrast shows.Diagram: shared ground at the top, a woman confined to one home, with arrows down to Trifles and A Doll’s House. Under each, its method (a kitchen read through objects, the wife offstage; one room, the wife on stage, dialogue) and its effect, then a box at the foot saying what the contrast shows.
Where a comparison of two plays lies. The shared ground starts it; the difference lies in method, and the effect of each method is what the comparison is about.

Why method is the stronger ground

A comparison of method is stronger for two reasons. It can be proved with evidence, because a method is made of stage directions, words and structure that can be remembered and quoted. It also explains a difference instead of only noticing it. To say that one play turns on a murder and the other ends in a departure records a difference of content. To say that one play keeps its wife offstage and the other keeps her in view explains why the endings feel so different.

The test matters because the two kinds of point lead to different essays. Points of content produce an essay of likenesses, in which the two plays are mostly the same. Points of method produce an essay of differences that can be explained, which is what the question’s “to what effect” asks for.

What a comparison shows

A comparison earns its place when the difference it finds tells you something about each work that you would not have seen in it alone. In Trifles the confined woman never appears. Minnie Wright is in jail throughout the play, and the audience knows her only through her kitchen and through the memories of a neighbor. Mrs. Hale recalls her as a girl who “used to wear pretty clothes and be lively, when she was Minnie Foster, one of the town girls singing in the choir”. In A Doll’s House the confined woman is on stage almost all the time, and the audience watches her think, lie, plan and finally speak.

Set together, the two plays change each other. Read beside Trifles, Nora’s exit looks like a privilege: she has words, a listener and a door, all of which Minnie lacked. Read beside A Doll’s House, Minnie’s act looks like what happens when a confined woman has none of these. The two women who read her kitchen understand this, and Mrs. Hale’s words could stand over both plays:

We live close together and we live far apart.

Trifles, Mrs. Hale, near the end of the play

The line describes the farm women, isolated on their separate farms, but it also describes the Helmers, who have shared a house for eight years without, in Nora’s words, ever talking “seriously” together. A comparison of the two settings has turned into a comparison of two kinds of isolation, one between neighbors and one inside a marriage. That is what a comparison shows at its best: a likeness that makes each work’s difference sharper.

Try it

Mrs. Peters says “I know what stillness is” after the dead canary is found. Which moment in A Doll’s House could you set against this line, and what would the comparison show?

One possibility is the stripped Christmas tree at the start of Act II, “with the candles burnt out”: an object left on stage that shows the household after its celebration, as the empty cage shows the house after its song. The comparison shows two ways of making silence visible. Glaspell puts it into a woman’s memory, spoken aloud for the first time; Ibsen puts it into a prop that no one comments on, so the audience must read it alone.

The comparative thesis and topic sentence

Because B2 rewards comparison that runs through the essay, the comparison has to begin in the first paragraph. A comparative thesis states how both works answer the question and where they differ, so that every later paragraph can test it. For the running question, a thesis might read: both plays confine their audience to one room in which a marriage has failed. Glaspell makes the room a set of clues that only the women can read, while Ibsen makes it a stage on which the wife finally speaks. One play therefore ends in a shared silence, and the other in a public exit.

Each body paragraph then opens with a comparative topic sentence: a sentence that names both works and the point on which they are compared. The topic sentence is where most essays first lose the comparison, because it is natural to begin a paragraph with the work you know better. The two topic sentences that follow open the same paragraph of an essay on the running question.

Weak: In Trifles, the kitchen is full of objects that show Mrs. Wright’s unhappy life.note 1

Strong: Both plays let one object in the room hold the truth about a marriage, but Glaspell gives that object to the women to read, while Ibsen gives it to the audience to dread.note 2

  1. One work only. The paragraph will discuss Trifles first and A Doll’s House later, if at all; the comparison has already been postponed.

  2. Both works, one point, a difference. The sentence names the shared method (an object as evidence) and the difference of effect (reading against dread) that the paragraph will prove.

The strong topic sentence also gives the paragraph its order. It will move from the likeness to the difference, and end on what the difference shows. The next section builds that paragraph in full.

The comparative paragraph

A comparative paragraph holds both works and sets them against each other on one point. Its evidence alternates, so that each quotation is read against the other. It ends on what only the comparison could show. The paragraph that follows continues the strong topic sentence on Trifles and A Doll’s House.

Both plays let one object in the room hold the truth about a marriage, but Glaspell gives that object to the women to read, while Ibsen gives it to the audience to dread.note 1 In Trifles the women find a bird-cage, and Mrs. Peters notices that its door is “broke” and “One hinge is pulled apart”.note 2 From that hinge the two women work out, step by step, what John Wright did to the bird and what his wife did to him, while the men search the barn for a motive. Ibsen’s object is the letter-box, which Nora shows Mrs. Linden “through the glass”, so that the audience knows Krogstad’s letter is waiting there from the second act until Helmer reads it in the third.note 3 Where Glaspell’s object explains a violent act that has already happened, Ibsen’s threatens one that has not, and the tarantella is danced to delay it.note 4 Set together, the two objects show two places a confined wife can stand. In Trifles she can only be known after her life has broken, through what she left behind, while in A Doll’s House she is still present, and the suspense is whether she can act before the object speaks for her.note 5

  1. A comparative topic sentence. Both works, one point (an object as evidence), and the difference the paragraph will prove.

  2. Evidence from the first work. Short remembered quotations, with the object’s discovery placed in the plot.

  3. Evidence set against it. The second work’s object is chosen because it answers the first: visible, unopened, waiting.

  4. A connective that carries logic. “Where … , …” states a contrast of time: one object looks back, the other forward.

  5. What only comparison shows. The last sentence draws a conclusion about both plays that neither play states alone.

The paragraph never stays with one play for more than two sentences, and its last sentence could not have been written about either play alone. It also uses only three short quotations, which is realistic for an essay written from memory: precise moments, such as the cage’s hinge and the letter-box, do as much work as quoted words.

Connectives that carry logic

A comparative connective states the relation between two points: likeness (both, in the same way, likewise), contrast (whereas, while, unlike, by contrast), or concession (although, even though). The word only works when the sentences on either side stand in that relation. “Mrs. Hale hides the box. Similarly, Nora hides the macaroons” joins two acts of hiding that have little in common: one conceals evidence of a killing to protect a woman, and the other conceals a small pleasure. The connective claims a likeness that the sentence never shows.

The fix is to let the connective sit inside a sentence that names the relation exactly. “Both women hide something from a man in authority, but where Nora hides a pleasure to keep up a role, Mrs. Hale hides evidence to protect another woman” uses both, but and where to state a likeness, a difference and its nature. Each connective there is doing work.

Integrated comparison across the essay

One comparative paragraph is a skill; a comparative essay is a structure. Integrated comparison means that the comparison is carried inside every paragraph rather than saved for links and the conclusion. It works at three scales. Within a sentence, a connective sets two pieces of evidence against each other. Within a paragraph, the evidence alternates and the last sentence draws a conclusion from both. Across the essay, each paragraph’s conclusion leads into the next point, so the comparison builds.

The third scale is the one most essays miss. Three comparative paragraphs that each end on a separate insight are better than two stapled halves, but they still read as a list. An essay builds when the second point grows out of what the first showed. In the worked plan that follows, the first paragraph’s finding, that Minnie Wright is absent and Nora present, becomes the question the second paragraph asks about how each woman is heard.

Each point in the plan carries both works, and each one opens from the last. A reader of the topic sentences alone would follow the argument from absence and presence, through voice and objects, to two ways of leaving a room. That chain is what integrated comparison looks like at the scale of the essay.

Comparing works of different forms

When the two works are of different forms, the forms themselves become a point of comparison. A play can show several things at once: a speaker, a listener, an object and a silence, all in view together. It has no narrator to explain them, so the audience must interpret. A novel can enter a mind, move through years in a sentence, and comment on what it shows. A poem can compress a feeling into an image and control the pace of reading through the line. The question in each comparison is what each form lets its writer do with the shared concern.

Trifles set against a novel of confinement, such as Kate Chopin’s The Awakening (1899), shows the difference clearly. Glaspell cannot tell the audience what Minnie Wright felt; she can only let two women piece it together from a quilt and a cage. Chopin can tell the reader what Edna feels, and does, in a narrator’s sentences about the self Edna is becoming. The comparison is then about knowledge: in the play, a woman’s inner life has to be inferred by others, and in the novel it is given to the reader directly. A strong essay turns this difference of form into an argument about the works, never into a lecture on the forms in general.

When the forms are the same

Two works in the same form need a finer point of method. Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus (2003) and Tsitsi Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions (1988) are both novels narrated by a girl growing up in a household ruled by a man with authority over everyone in it. Compared by content, they are similar: an authoritarian father or uncle, education as escape, a brother’s fate. Compared by narrative voice, they differ sharply. Their first sentences show it:

Things started to fall apart at home …
I was not sorry when my brother died.

Adichie, Purple Hibiscus, first sentence (opening words); Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions, first sentence

Kambili, Adichie’s narrator, opens with a phrase that echoes the title of Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart, and tells her story in a restrained, hesitant voice that stays close to what she saw and felt. Tambu, Dangarembga’s narrator, opens with a shock, told by an adult looking back who has judged what happened to her. A comparison of the two voices shows two ways of narrating an oppressive household: from inside the fear, or from beyond it. That is a comparison of method, and it explains why the two novels feel so different although their situations are close.

The faults that keep B2 low

Most low B2 marks come from four faults: halves stapled together, a “similarly” joint, a comparison of content only, and unequal treatment of the two works. Each is easy to recognize in a single sentence, and each has a direct correction. The sentences that follow are from essays on the running question, each followed by a corrected version.

Now I will discuss the setting of A Doll’s House.note 1 → Ibsen’s parlor, unlike Glaspell’s kitchen, is tidy, and its order hides the debt that Nora’s secret has kept out of sight.note 2

Mrs. Wright was lonely. Similarly, Nora was lonely.note 3 → Both women are isolated, but Minnie’s isolation is a farm miles from neighbors, while Nora’s is inside a marriage in a busy town.note 4

Both plays are about women who are trapped by their husbands.note 5 → Both plays show a trapped wife, but Glaspell shows her through the objects she left, and Ibsen through what she finally says.note 6

A long paragraph on Trifles ending: “This is also like Nora.”note 7 → A paragraph in which each piece of evidence from Trifles is answered by one from A Doll’s House.note 8

  1. Stapled halves. The sentence announces the second half of a block essay; the works will not meet again until the conclusion.

  2. Corrected. The new work enters already set against the first, through a contrast (tidy against disordered) that says something about Nora.

  3. A “similarly” joint. Two statements of content, one per work, with a word between them that compares nothing.

  4. Corrected. The likeness is stated once, and the difference (where each isolation lies) is the point.

  5. Content only. True of both plays, but it could be written from summaries; no method is named.

  6. Corrected. The likeness of content leads straight to a difference of method: objects against speech.

  7. Unequal treatment. The second work appears only in a closing phrase, which is common when time runs short or one work is better known.

  8. Corrected. Evidence alternates through the paragraph, so both works carry the argument.

The corrections share one habit: the second work enters the sentence already set against the first, and the sentence says how they differ. A student who checks every topic sentence for that habit before writing the paragraph will rarely fall into any of the four faults.

A middle-band response

The essay that follows answers a different question, Compare the ways in which two works you have studied present a moment when a character sees their own life clearly for the first time, and whether that clarity lasts. It uses two collections of stories, Chekhov’s in Constance Garnett’s translation and Mansfield’s. It is a reasonable essay by a student who knows both works, and it shows the commonest pattern in the middle of criterion B2: accurate knowledge, some good analysis, and comparison left to a joint and a late paragraph. The comments mark where its comparison works, where it is partial and where it is missing.

Exemplar · Middle band14 of 25 marks

Paper 2: moments of clarity, a middle-band response

On The Lady with the Dog and Other Stories, The Garden Party and Other Stories

The response and its mark on each of 5 criteriaRead it with a free account

The quickest way to raise this essay is to change its structure, not its knowledge. Comments 6 and 11 point to the paragraph it needed: Gurov’s clarity set against Laura’s, on how each writer ends the moment. Chekhov closes on a narrator’s sentence about a difficult part just beginning, and Mansfield on a sentence Laura cannot finish. One is a clarity that commits to an uncertain future, and the other is a clarity that cannot survive being spoken. That single comparison of method would lift B2 and give C the argument it lacks.

The question bank holds Paper 2 questions with marking notes and three marked essays each, so the comparison can be practiced on prompts not seen before. The knowledge that makes comparison possible under time, short quotations and key passages organized by concept and feature, is the subject of the page on preparing works for Paper 2.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what criterion B2 rewards and how it differs from B1.

  • To do:

    I can turn a comparison of content into a comparison of method on two works I have studied.

  • To do:

    I can say what a contrast between two works shows about each of them.

  • To do:

    I can write a comparative thesis and a comparative topic sentence for each paragraph.

  • To do:

    I can write a comparative paragraph with alternating evidence and connectives that state real relations.

  • To do:

    I can plan an essay in which each point grows from the last.

  • To do:

    I can find and correct stapled halves, “similarly” joints, content-only comparison and unequal treatment.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Comparative connective

A word or phrase that states the logical relation between two points about two works, such as likeness, contrast or concession (whereas, while, unlike, in the same way, by contrast). It carries part of the argument only when the sentences on either side stand in that relation.

Comparative thesis

The central claim of a comparative essay, stated near its start, that says how two works answer the question and where and why they differ. It names a likeness and the difference it leads to, so that every later paragraph can test it on both works.

Integrated comparison

Comparison carried inside every paragraph and often inside single sentences, with evidence from both works set against each other as the argument moves. It contrasts with comparison saved for links between separate sections or for the conclusion.

Exam skills for English A Lang & Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLHL only
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two worksThis page
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.