Paper 1 at HL

Paper 1 at higher level: two unseen texts and no choice, dividing 135 minutes, adapting your method to very different text types, keeping the second essay strong, and a full response.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Exam skills
  • HL only

26 min readLast reviewed

At higher level, Paper 1 gives you the same two unseen non-literary texts as at standard level, each with its guiding question, but no choice. You write two analytical essays, one on each text, in 2 hours 15 minutes. Each essay is marked separately out of 20 on the same four criteria, so the paper is marked out of 40 in all.

Everything that earns marks at SL earns them at HL: an accurate reading beneath the surface (A), analysis and evaluation of the writer’s choices (B), a line of argument (C) and clear, precise English (D). What changes is the shape of the task. You must manage two texts, one of which may be visual, in a fixed time, and the second essay must be as good as the first, because a marker reading it gives it no credit for the essay before it.

That last point removes a common worry. You do not compare the two texts, connect them or mention one in the essay on the other. Each essay stands alone, with its own introduction, thesis and conclusion, as if it were the only essay you wrote that day. Paper 2 is the paper that compares.

Two texts and no choice

Because there is no choice, the first minutes are spent differently. At SL they decide which text to write on; at HL they decide the order and the time. A typical pair is sharply different in kind: for example, a behind-the-scenes article from the website of a television drama series filmed in the mountains of north Wales, and a heritage panel at a lookout in New Zealand. The article’s guiding question asks: In what ways does the article shape its readers’ view of the mountains where the series was filmed?

Filming in the cloudTawel, a six-part television drama series set in Eryri: a behind-the-scenes article on the series’ official website, 2026Written for Augment Education
Filming in the cloud
Tawel was filmed on the kind of mountain it is set on, in the season it is set in. Here is what that meant for the people who made it — and what it should mean for you.
Behind the series · Tawel · 5 minute read
The first day of filming on the ridge lasted eleven minutes. The crew had carried cameras, lights, a stretcher and two very cold actors up the path in the dark. At a quarter past eight the cloud came down, the series’ safety adviser looked at the sky once, and everybody walked back down again. “The mountain doesn’t read the schedule,” says the producer. “We learned that on day one, and we kept learning it until the last day.”
A cast that learned to wait
Before a single scene was shot, the cast spent a week with volunteers from mountain rescue teams across Eryri. They learned to read a map in the rain, to carry a stretcher across scree without dropping it, and to keep a casualty talking when they are too cold to want to. The actor who plays Gwen, the team leader, says the hardest lesson was patience. “On a callout you wait for the weather, you wait for the helicopter, you wait for a phone to ring. I learned to tie a knot in the dark with gloves on. Most of the job, it turns out, is waiting well.”
Cloud as a character
Viewers sometimes ask why the series is so grey. The director is happy to explain. “We could have waited for blue sky and made the mountains look like a postcard. But on a real callout the weather takes the view away. You see three metres of rock, a head torch, a hand. We wanted the cloud to do to the audience what it does to the team.” No sunshine was added after filming. Some days the cloud did the job better than any script, rolling over the ridge in the middle of a take and leaving the actors, quite literally, lost.
The village behind the camera
Cwm Tawel is invented, but it is built from real places: the slate villages of north-west Wales, whose landscape has been a World Heritage Site since 2021. Local people appear in every episode, in the chapel, in the shop and at the kitchen tables, and much of the Welsh you hear was suggested on set by people who speak it every day. “They corrected our Welsh and they corrected our weather,” says the producer. “When a farmer tells you the cloud will be down by two, believe the farmer.”
Before you go up
Tawel is a drama. Its ridge is invented. The cloud is not.
Every winter, real volunteer teams in Eryri are called out to walkers who set off late, in trainers, with a phone at half charge and no idea what the forecast said. Most of those callouts begin exactly the way our first episode does: with somebody who thought the path would be obvious.
Nobody in this series is a superhero, and nobody on a real team wants you to need them. If the series has made you want to see these mountains for yourself — and we hope it has — go well prepared. Check the mountain forecast, not just the weather app. Tell someone your route and when you will be back. Carry a head torch, warm layers and a charged phone. Turn back early, while turning back is still easy.
The mountain will still be there next weekend. Read the mountain safety advice before you go. #Tawel

The second text is a printed panel, one of the signs a heritage trust places along a walking trail through the ruins of a gold-mining settlement. It stands at the trail’s last stop, a lookout over the gully and the river below.

A heritage panel, What the water cost: a cross-section of a hill cut into a 30 m sluice face by a jet from a pipe fed by a water race; a boxed account-book entry; bars for 1,200 people in 1866 and about 40 in 1910; a timeline; a box headed What the numbers leave out.
Text 2: an interpretation panel at the lookout at the end of a heritage trail through the ruins of a gold-mining settlement in Central Otago, New Zealand. Its guiding question: How does the panel use image, numbers and words to present the cost of the gold rush to visitors?
Description of the panel

A cream panel with a dark-brown band at the top holding the title and a subtitle. At the upper left is a cross-section of a sand-colored hill with a blue line along its top, labeled as the water race. A gray pipe runs from the end of the race out over the gully on two posts and down to the gully floor. There a nozzle shoots a curved blue jet, ending in an arrow, at the hill’s steep side. A double-headed arrow measures that side as a sluice face of about 30 m, and a dashed line continues the hill’s old outline. A tiny black figure stands at the foot of the face.

At the upper right, a white box holds two sentences, a dashed card with an italic quotation from an account book, and a line ending in bold gold-brown type beside a tiny gold dot. In the middle, one long bar, one short bar and a thin line give three population figures. Below them a timeline of seven dots runs from before 1863 to 1937. A sand-colored box holds four lines of prose, and a bold sentence closes the panel.

What the water cost
Sluicehead, 1866–1902: a gully that was sold by the sluice head
Kerr Water Race: 6 km of bought water (1866) / the hill in 1866 / sluice face, about 30 m / pipe and nozzle / a person, to scale
The hill went down the creek, and the creek went to the Clutha.
The price of water: A sluice head was the flow of water one claim bought from the race. The settlement took its name from the bill.
‘Ah Kew. Water, one week, 12s. Rice, one bag. Letter home, written.’ Account book of Wong Sai Fook, storekeeper, 4 June 1874
Gold found at Sluicehead, 1863–1902: no total survives.
The people: 1,200 in 1866 / about 40 in 1910 / none after 1937, when the last resident left
In 1875 about 160 people lived at the Chinese Camp, most of them from Guangdong.
The years: before 1863, Kāi Tahu travel the valley / 1863, gold found / 1866, the race opens / 1881, poll tax on Chinese arrivals / 1891, flood breaks the dam; two die / 1902, battery closes / 1937, last one leaves
What the numbers leave out: Water was billed and gold was weighed, so both were written down. Debt, cold and homesickness were not. Long before the rush, Kāi Tahu travelled this valley between the coast and the inland lakes; that history is theirs to tell, not ours. The record on this panel is the record of the people who paid for water.
Look down. The gravel flats below this lookout are the hill.
Sluicehead Heritage Trust · Panel at Stop 12, the lookout over the Clutha

The words of the panel, in reading order

The panel’s guiding question asks: How does the panel use image, numbers and words to present the cost of the gold rush to visitors? The two texts share almost nothing. One is continuous prose with headings, quoted voices and a call to the reader at its end. The other is read by the eye in blocks, and much of its meaning sits in the relation between a drawing, a few figures and some short lines of type. Each will need its own way of reading.

Dividing 135 minutes

There are two sensible ways to start. You can read both texts and both guiding questions before writing anything, or you can read one, write on it, and only then turn to the other. Reading both first costs about ten minutes, and it is usually worth it. It lets you choose the order with knowledge, and it lets the second text sit at the back of your mind while you write the first essay, so that when you return to it you are not starting cold.

After those ten minutes, the time divides almost evenly: about 60 minutes for each essay, each with its own reading, planning and writing, and five minutes at the end to check both. Within each hour the proportions are those of the SL paper, squeezed slightly: about 20 minutes to reread, annotate and plan, and about 40 to write. The diagram sets the SL paper above the HL paper on the same scale, so the second hour can be seen as a full copy of the first, not a remainder.

Two bars on one time scale. SL, 75 minutes: choose, read and plan, write, check. HL, 135 minutes: read both texts (0 to 10), read and plan essay 1, write essay 1 (to 70), read and plan essay 2, write essay 2 (to 130), check (to 135).Two bars on one time scale. SL, 75 minutes: choose, read and plan, write, check. HL, 135 minutes: read both texts (0 to 10), read and plan essay 1, write essay 1 (to 70), read and plan essay 2, write essay 2 (to 130), check (to 135).
SL and HL Paper 1 drawn to the same scale; “plan” includes rereading and annotating. At HL each essay gets a full hour of its own, after ten minutes spent reading both texts.

The even split matters because the marks are even. Each essay is worth 20, so ten extra minutes on the first essay usually buy less than ten minutes taken from the second cost. A conclusion that is never written, or a third body paragraph abandoned halfway, is the most expensive mistake at HL. Decide in advance the minute at which you stop the first essay, and keep to it even if a good idea arrives late.

Which text to write on first

Most students write first on the text they feel more confident about, and there is a good reason to. A strong first essay settles the nerves, and the method warms up on familiar ground. A student who has practiced reading images might start with the panel, and one who reads prose more easily with the article.

The choice has a risk. The confident essay tends to grow. Ideas come easily, the hour passes and the second essay, on the harder text, starts late and tired. Some students therefore reverse the order and write the harder essay first, while they are fresh, saving the easier text for the hour when concentration drops. Either order works if the time is kept. The useful question in the first ten minutes is which text will need more of your best attention, not which you like more.

Tawel is a drama. Its ridge is invented. The cloud is not.

“Filming in the cloud”, paragraph 12

A quick test helps. In these three short sentences the article turns from a story about filming into a warning to its readers. If you can already see where a text turns like this, you have the beginning of a thesis and can write on that text even when tired. The text whose turn you cannot yet find is the one that needs your fresh first hour.

Two sharply different kinds of text

The two texts of an HL paper are always of different types, and often of sharply different kinds, so the method of reading must change between them. The three passes taught for SL still apply: type, audience, purpose and context first; then the shape of the whole; then the details. What changes is where each pass looks.

Reading the article in its own order

A prose text with headings is read in order, because its writer controls the sequence. The article on filming opens with a small story of failure, the first day “lasted eleven minutes” (paragraph 4), and builds its headed sections on quoted voices: the producer, the actor who plays Gwen, the director. Its audience is viewers who enjoyed the series and may want to visit the mountains. Its purposes are double: to deepen their pleasure in the series, and, from the heading “Before you go up” (paragraph 11), to keep them safe.

“The mountain doesn’t read the schedule,”note 1 says the producer. … We wanted the cloud to do to the audience what it does to the team.note 2 … If the series has made you want to see these mountains for yourself — and we hope it has — go well prepared.note 3

“Filming in the cloud”, paragraphs 4, 8 and 14

  1. Mountain as actor. Personified from the first paragraph: it has its own will. Sells the drama, prepares the warning?

  2. Cloud as a tool. The director makes weather into a technique: viewers feel the team’s blindness.

  3. Turn to “you”. Promotion and warning in one sentence; the dash admits the series wants visitors.

These three annotations already hold an argument: the article personifies the mountain to make the drama exciting, and then uses the same idea of a mountain with its own will to make its safety advice convincing. On a prose text, annotation follows the line of the writer’s argument and marks where it turns.

Reading the panel by its layout

A visual text is read by its layout, not its order of composition. On the panel, the eye goes first to the title, “What the water cost”, then to the drawing, with its blue jet aimed at the hill, then to the boxes and bars. The reading path ends on the bold imperative at the foot, “Look down.”, which sends the visitor’s eyes off the panel to the real gully below. Annotating the panel means marking these relations: the long blue race against the tiny gold dot, the long bar for 1,200 people against the thin line for none, the account book’s single name against the lists of figures.

The biggest risk with two different texts is to use one method on both. An essay that reads the panel from top to bottom, box by box, retells it in the order of its layout and misses the relations that carry its meaning. An essay that treats the article as a set of separate quotations misses the turn from story to warning that organizes it. Adapting the method is part of understanding the text.

The four criteria across two essays

Each essay is marked on the same four criteria as at SL, and each criterion asks the same thing of it. Two essays raise particular demands under each, because the second text calls for a fresh reading and a fresh argument rather than a repeat of the first.

A: Understanding and interpretation. The second essay needs its own reading of its own text, and for a visual text that reading rests on precise description as well as quotation. A reading of the panel that says only that the gold rush was hard does not reach beneath the surface; one that sees the panel turning the settlement’s name into a debt does.

B: Analysis and evaluation. The choices worth analyzing differ by type. In the article they are mostly verbal: personification, quoted voices, the shift into the second person. In the panel they are as much visual as verbal: scale, color, the size of a bar, the placing of a box. A second essay that reaches only for verbal features on a visual text loses B even when its language is good.

C: Focus and organization. A tired second essay drifts. It loses its thesis by the third paragraph and starts to list. Keeping a line of argument to the end is what most separates a strong second essay from a weak one.

D: Language. Fatigue shows first in language: sentences grow longer and vaguer, and analytical terms are replaced by general ones. Short, exact sentences are easier to write when tired, and they are clearer to read.

Keeping the second essay strong

The second essay is written in the second hour of a long exam, when concentration is lowest. Fatigue lowers its quality in predictable ways: shorter plans, longer quotations, more description, a conclusion that repeats. None of these is inevitable. The plan for the second essay can be shorter than the first, but it must still be complete: a thesis in full and a topic sentence for each paragraph, even if each is only a phrase.

Two second essays on the panel, both written in the last hour of the paper, show the difference. Each begins its third body paragraph at the same place on the panel.

Loses focus: The timeline at the bottom shows many important dates. In 1863 gold was found and in 1866 the race opened. In 1881 there was a poll tax on Chinese arrivals and in 1891 there was a flood that broke the dam and two people died. In 1902 the battery closed. This is very sad and shows that life was hard for the miners.note 1

Keeps focus: The timeline extends the panel’s argument about cost into time. Its first entry is not gold but “Kāi Tahu travel the valley”, so the rush becomes one short episode in a longer history rather than the start of the place. The entries that follow are flat phrases (“flood breaks the dam; two die”), and that restraint makes the cost sound recorded rather than dramatized, as an account would.note 2

  1. Drift into retelling. The paragraph copies the timeline in order, adds a general feeling and never returns to the guiding question’s “cost” or to how the panel presents it.

  2. The thesis carried through. The topic sentence links the timeline to the essay’s argument, and two choices (where the timeline starts, how its entries are worded) are explained as part of it.

The second paragraph is no longer than the first. It is better because its writer still had a thesis in mind, and asked of the timeline the same question asked of the drawing and the bars: how does this part present the cost? A plan of one line per paragraph is enough to keep that question alive.

A method for 135 minutes

The method is clearest on this pair, minute by minute. In the first ten minutes you read both guiding questions and both texts once. The article turns visibly at “Tawel is a drama. Its ridge is invented. The cloud is not.”, so a thesis is already in sight. The panel is quick to read but slower to understand, since its meaning lies in the relations between its parts. You decide to write on the article first, while it is fresh, and write the stopping times on the booklet.

From minute 10 to minute 30, you reread the article with a pen: the eleven-minute first day, the quoted voices and what each adds, the claim that “No sunshine was added after filming” (paragraph 8), the turn and the advice. You write a thesis and four topic sentences. From minute 30 to 70 you write. At minute 70 the essay ends, finished, even though one more paragraph could have been added.

The second hour repeats the first on the panel. You spend the first few minutes looking before annotating: the reading path from title to drawing to bars to box to the last line, the sizes of things, the colors. Then you annotate the relations that carry meaning, write a shorter plan and write from about minute 90 to minute 130. The last five minutes go to a quick check of both essays, starting with the second, where errors are more likely.

Look down. The gravel flats below this lookout are the hill.

The panel, its last line

On a visual text the planning minutes are well spent on lines like this one, because a single line can reorganize the whole text. The imperative sends the visitor from the panel to the real gully, and an essay that notices it can end by arguing that the landscape completes the infographic.

The timed plan, as a list to practice with:

  • Minutes 0–10: read both guiding questions and both texts; choose the order; write down two stopping times.

  • Minutes 10–30: reread and annotate the first text; write a thesis and topic sentences.

  • Minutes 30–70: write the first essay, including its conclusion.

  • Minutes 70–90: reread and annotate the second text; write a shorter but complete plan.

  • Minutes 90–130: write the second essay, including its conclusion.

  • Minutes 130–135: check both essays, the second one first.

Try it

You reach minute 70 in the middle of your third body paragraph on the article, and you have not written a conclusion. What do you do?

Finish the sentence you are writing in a line, skip the rest of the paragraph and write a two- or three-sentence conclusion that judges, for example that the article’s personified mountain sells the series and then makes its warning credible. Then turn to the panel. A short conclusion completes the argument for criterion C; ten more minutes on the first essay would cost far more in the second.

Where marks are lost at HL

Every fault that costs marks at SL costs them at HL, twice over if it appears in both essays. Three faults belong to HL alone, because they come from managing two texts in one sitting. The table shows each on a sentence or a plan, with its correction.

Fault

What it looks like

The correction

An unfinished second essay

A second essay that stops in the middle of its third paragraph: “The bars also show that the population went down, and the timeline’”

At the stopping time, finish the sentence and write two sentences of conclusion: “The panel presents the rush as a bill the landscape still pays, and its box of what the numbers leave out is its most honest choice.”

The first essay’s method on a different text

An essay on the panel that opens: “The writer uses many persuasive techniques, such as rhetorical questions and emotive language.”

An opening that reads the panel as a visual text: “The panel is laid out like a bill, from the price of water at the top to what the numbers leave out at the bottom.”

Unequal time

A plan with four detailed paragraphs for the article and, for the panel, only “image, numbers, timeline”.

Two plans of the same shape: a thesis and a topic sentence for each paragraph, the second plan shorter in words but just as complete.

All three corrections come from the same habit: treating the two essays as two complete pieces of work, each with its own thesis, plan and conclusion. The marker of each essay sees nothing else.

Nobody in this series is a superhero, and nobody on a real team wants you to need them.

“Filming in the cloud”, paragraph 14

A second essay that runs out of time is often one whose first essay spent too long on lines like this one, which are rich enough for a whole paragraph. The sentence balances two denials and then turns the series’ drama into a request. The useful habit is to note such a line in the plan, give it the paragraph it deserves, and move on at the stopping time.

A response in full

A complete HL essay shows what a second essay can still achieve. This one was written on the panel in the second hour of the paper and answers its guiding question. Its partner essay, on the article, is summarized after it. Like most strong essays written under time, it has flaws, and the margin comments name them by criterion beside its strengths.

Exemplar · High band18 of 20 marks

Paper 1: “What the water cost”, a high-band response

On What the water cost

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

This essay reaches the high band in the second hour because its writer adapted the method to the text. Every body paragraph analyzes a visual relation (a label against an image, color against words, bar against bar) as well as words. The two marks it loses come from a layout-driven order and from a lapse into vague praise, the two faults most typical of a tired second essay.

The partner essay, on the article, reached a similar mark by a different route. Its thesis argued that the article personifies the mountain twice. The first time sells the series as a struggle with a living landscape; the second makes its safety advice credible, since a mountain that “doesn’t read the schedule” will not read a walker’s plans either. Its body paragraphs moved from the quoted voices of the producer, actor and director, to the decision that “No sunshine was added after filming”, to the turn into the second person under “Before you go up”. Its conclusion judged that the dash in “and we hope it has” is the article’s most honest moment, since it admits that the series wants the visitors it warns. The two essays never mention each other, and each was marked on its own.

Timed HL practice is the only way to learn how long your own hour is. Mock papers in the question bank pair Paper 1 texts of different types into full HL papers, each text with its guiding question, marking notes and three marked responses.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what changes in Paper 1 at HL and why each essay is marked on its own.

  • To do:

    I can divide 135 minutes into two equal hours after reading both texts, and keep to two stopping times.

  • To do:

    I can decide which text to write on first by asking which needs my freshest attention.

  • To do:

    I can read a prose text in its own order and a visual text by its layout and reading path.

  • To do:

    I can keep a line of argument through the second essay by planning it completely, if briefly.

  • To do:

    I can recognize an unfinished essay, a borrowed method and unequal time, and correct each.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.

Higher level HL only

The longer and more demanding of the two levels at which an IB Diploma course is studied. In Language and Literature it adds a second Paper 1 essay, the HL essay and a wider reading list.

Standard level HL only

The shorter of the two levels at which an IB Diploma course is studied. In Language and Literature it shares the course's frame and criteria with higher level, with fewer works to study and one Paper 1 essay instead of two.

Exam skills for English A Lang & Lit

Paper 1

  1. 1Paper 1 at SL
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLThis page
  3. 3Working with the guiding question

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: the comparative essay
  2. 5Comparing two works
  3. 6Preparing your works for Paper 2

Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.