- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- 4 Central concepts
- 4.5 Perspective
4.5 Perspective
Whose eyes, whose knowledge and whose silences shape a text: perspective, point of view and worldview, objectivity and bias, positionality, and how writers limit or multiply the views they give.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 4 Central concepts
- SL and HL
Notes on 4.5 Perspective
Perspective asks from where a text sees its subject: whose eyes, whose knowledge and whose silences shape what is shown. Every position lets some things be seen and hides others, and much of a text’s meaning lies in the gap between the two. The opening of Katherine Mansfield’s short story “Miss Brill” (1920) shows a woman on a bench in the public gardens of a French resort, watching everyone except herself.
A view from a special seat
Miss Brill sees a great deal. Within three paragraphs she takes in the light, the band, the crowd of people “far more than last Sunday” (paragraph 2), the conductor’s coat and the two strangers on her bench. Her position is literal before it is anything else. She sits on her “special” seat (paragraph 3), facing the band and the crowd, in gardens laid out for sitting and watching. What she can see from there is everyone else.
What she judges, she judges in others. The man on her bench is “a fine old man” and the woman “a big old woman” (paragraph 3), and the word old is given to both within one sentence. Nothing in these paragraphs applies it to her. Her fur has spent the off-season in a box with “moth-powder” and needs “a little dab of black sealing-wax” (paragraph 1), yet she treats its wear as a small repair. Even the conductor’s coat interests her because she is “sure it was new” (paragraph 2), a word that matters to someone whose own finery is old. Her attention follows her situation without her knowing it.
The chapter on narrative voice names the method that makes this possible: the story is told in the third person but focalized through Miss Brill, so the gardens arrive in her words. Perspective asks a wider question of that method. It asks what her position lets her see, what it keeps from her, and where a reader must stand to see both. The story shares her view of the gardens and also shows her from outside, as one more figure on a bench whom a passer-by might describe as she describes her neighbors, with the word “old”.
The diagram sets out the two positions. Miss Brill’s view takes in the band, the crowd and the old couple; the reader’s view holds all of that and Miss Brill as well, together with what she cannot see about herself. Later in the story the wider view is spoken aloud. A young couple sit down on her bench. The boy calls her “that stupid old thing” and asks “who wants her?”, and the story turns on the moment when Miss Brill is forced to see herself from the position she has spent the afternoon occupying.


Point of view, perspective and worldview
Three terms describe a text’s position, and they work at different scales. The narrowest is point of view, the narrative position from which a story is told: in “Miss Brill”, a narrator who says “she”, focalized through the character. Perspective is wider. It is the whole stance from which a subject is seen, including what the viewer knows, values and cannot see. Widest of all is a worldview, the set of beliefs about how the world is and ought to be that lies behind a perspective. A worldview usually goes unstated, because those who hold it treat it as plain fact.
She had become really quite expert, she thought, at listening as though she didn’t listen, at sitting in other people’s lives just for a minute while they talked round her.
“Miss Brill”, paragraph 3
The sentence shows all three at once. Its point of view is the narrator’s third person, marked by “she thought”. Its perspective is Miss Brill’s: a spectator who takes pride in watching unseen. Its worldview is the belief beneath that pride, that public life is open to anyone who listens, and that “sitting in other people’s lives” is a way of having one. The story tests that belief and finds it false. Its last scenes show that watching others gives Miss Brill no place among them.
Term | What it describes | In “Miss Brill” |
|---|---|---|
Point of view | The narrative position from which a story is told: who tells it, in which person, with what knowledge | Third person, focalized through Miss Brill |
Perspective | The whole stance from which a subject is seen: what the viewer notices, values and cannot see | A spectator on her “special” seat who sees age in others and not in herself |
Worldview | The beliefs about how the world is and ought to be that lie behind a perspective | Public life as a place anyone can join by watching and listening |
The table sets the three terms side by side for the same story. Only the first belongs to narrative alone. A council report, an encyclopedia entry and a radio host have no narrator, but each has a perspective and rests on a worldview. Their positions can be read as closely as a narrator’s, although they are usually harder to see.
Claiming to see from nowhere
Some texts present themselves as having no perspective at all. An encyclopedia entry speaks in no one’s voice, gives dates and sources, and seems to report the world as it is. The entry “Umbrella” in the eleventh edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica (1911) begins:
UMBRELLA, a portable folding protector from rain (Fr. parapluie), the name parasol being given to the smaller and more fanciful article carried by ladies as a sunshade, and the en-tout-cas being available for both purposes.
“Umbrella”, The Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th edition (1911), paragraph 1
The entry is built to signal objectivity, the aim of presenting a subject independent of any one observer. Nobody says “I”. The definition comes first, followed by the word’s origins in brackets. Every later claim is pinned to a date, a place or a named source: the king of Burma “In 1855” (paragraph 1), “allusions by Montaigne” (paragraph 2), a letter from Paris “in 1752” (paragraph 5). Even its uncertainty is measured. “Probably in these southern climes it never went out of use” (paragraph 2) hedges a claim that the evidence cannot settle, which is what a careful reference work should do.
Read for perspective, the same entry stands somewhere. The parasol is “smaller and more fanciful” and belongs to “ladies”, a judgment about women’s things presented as part of a definition. The compass words give the writer a location. The umbrella’s first home is “Eastern countries”, and Greece and Rome are “these southern climes”, east and south of a writer who is plainly in northern Europe. The entry’s history moves toward its reader and ends in England, with “the first Englishman who habitually carried an umbrella” (paragraph 5). Its opposite quality, subjectivity, does not show in any single word, yet the selection and the directions belong to a British reference work of 1911 and to its readers.
Whether any text can be objective is an old argument. The philosopher Thomas Nagel, in The View from Nowhere (1986), treated objectivity as a direction rather than a place. On his account a view becomes more objective as it steps back from the features of one observer, though no view can step back completely. The philosopher of science Donna Haraway, in “Situated Knowledges” (1988), called the claim to see from nowhere a “god trick”. On her account knowledge always comes from somewhere, and the honest form of objectivity is to make that position visible and answer for it.
For reading texts, the two positions are most useful together. Haraway’s explains why it matters where the encyclopedia stands, and why its compass words matter. Nagel’s explains why its dates, sources and careful “Probably” are still real virtues, which a polemic would lack. The entry is far less one-sided than a pamphlet for or against umbrellas would be, and it still has a position. A reading that sees both is more exact than one that calls the entry either neutral or prejudiced.
An open “I” against a neutral report
A non-literary text that admits its position can be more honest than one that hides it. “Keep the Saturday ferry”, an opinion column in The Port Ellery Tide, a weekly newspaper in Nova Scotia, argues against a council report that would cut an island ferry’s Saturday sailings from six to two. The report is never printed, but the column quotes its key phrase:
The report has a phrase for those trips. It suggests that islanders “shift discretionary travel to weekdays.” I went down to the slip last Saturday to see what discretionary looks like.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 6
The report’s phrase sounds like a neutral category. Discretionary is a word from budgets, and it sorts trips into those that must happen and those that can be moved, without saying who decided which is which. The report’s other evidence works the same way: an “average of 58 passengers” per sailing, judged “under-used” (paragraph 4). Its perspective is the view from the council chamber, where a ferry appears as a cost per sailing and travelers as an average. The impersonal wording makes that position look like no position at all.
The column, by contrast, announces where it stands in its first sentence: “I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters” (paragraph 1). Its evidence comes from the slip rather than the spreadsheet, and it counts people instead of averages: the teenagers who work at the Co-op, the food-bank volunteers and “Marjorie Langille, who is 91” (paragraph 7). The writer even grants the other side its due: “$212,000 is real money in a district our size” (paragraph 3). Its audience always knows whose view it is getting, and so can weigh it.
Openness does not make the column free of bias, a systematic leaning in what a text selects, how it words it and what it leaves out. The column’s list of Saturday travelers in paragraph 7 names workers, volunteers, a dog on its way to the vet and a woman of 91 with a standing appointment, all people whose trips are hard to move. Nobody in it is crossing just to shop, although such passengers must exist among the 58. That pattern of selection is bias in the strict sense. The column’s purpose is to persuade, and its bias is declared and expected, while the report’s is hidden in vocabulary that claims to be neutral.
Where the writer stands
A writer’s position in the world is part of the perspective of any text. In 1906 Kakuzo Okakura, a Japanese art scholar, published The Book of Tea in New York, in English, for American readers. Explaining the tea ceremony to people who might find it strange, he turns the outsider’s gaze back on itself:
The average Westerner, in his sleek complacency, will see in the tea ceremony but another instance of the thousand and one oddities which constitute the quaintness and childishness of the East to him. He was wont to regard Japan as barbarous while she indulged in the gentle arts of peace: he calls her civilised since she began to commit wholesale slaughter on Manchurian battlefields.
Kakuzo Okakura, The Book of Tea (1906), chapter I, paragraph 2
The words “to him” do the essay’s main work. Quaintness and childishness are described as qualities the Westerner sees, not qualities the East has, so the Western view becomes a perspective among others rather than a view from nowhere. The second sentence exposes the worldview behind that perspective. A nation that “indulged in the gentle arts of peace” was called “barbarous”, and the same nation is called “civilised” once it wins battles in Manchuria, in the war with Russia of 1904–1905. The standard of civilization turns out to be military power.
The force of the passage comes from Okakura’s positionality, his social position as a Japanese writer addressing Western readers in their own language, at the moment his country’s victory had changed how it was seen. He writes as an insider explaining his culture to outsiders, and he speaks for a “we”: “our soldiers”, “our Art of Life” (paragraph 2). His position has limits of its own. “The average Westerner” is a type, a single figure standing for millions, which is the kind of generalization the essay accuses Western readers of making about “the East”. Audiences bring positions too: an American of 1906 is the essay’s target, while someone in Tokyo would meet the same sentences as a defense.
Maps and the place of the viewer
Maps are among the most trusted non-literary texts, and among the clearest examples of perspective. The Hereford Mappa Mundi, drawn on a single sheet of vellum in about 1300 and kept in Hereford Cathedral in England, puts east at the top and Jerusalem at the center. Paradise sits at the top edge, and Britain is squeezed into the lower left corner. The map is accurate to its purpose, which is to show the world arranged around the places of Christian history. Its center is chosen by belief rather than by measurement.

Modern maps have a perspective too, and the argument about one shows how hard it is to remove. Gerardus Mercator designed his projection in 1569 for sailors, because it shows a course of constant compass bearing as a straight line. The price is distortion near the poles, so that Greenland appears about as large as Africa, which is roughly fourteen times bigger. In 1973 the German historian Arno Peters presented an equal-area world map and argued that Mercator’s made Europe and North America look larger and more important than the countries of the south. Cartographers replied that Peters’s map was far from new (James Gall had described the same projection in 1855) and that it badly distorted shapes in its turn.
Both sides were partly right. Mercator’s projection was made for navigation, not to flatter Europe, but its use as a classroom wall map did shape how many people pictured the size of continents. Peters exposed that effect while overstating the novelty of his own solution. In 1989 seven North American geographic organizations urged publishers to stop using rectangular world maps of either kind. No projection shows the round Earth on a flat page without choosing what to distort, so the useful question for a map, as for any text, is whose purpose its choices serve.
Limiting and multiplying perspectives
Writers control perspective by narrowing it as well as by widening it. Mark Haddon’s novel The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time (2003) is told by Christopher Boone, a fifteen-year-old who sets out to discover who killed a neighbor’s dog. Christopher records events with great precision, takes words literally and finds other people’s faces hard to read. The novel lets its readers see with him, sharing the order and logic of his account, and through him, understanding what he reports without grasping. When he finds letters from the mother his father had told him was dead, the adults’ grief and deceit are plain on the page before Christopher can make sense of them.
A limited narrator of this kind turns perspective into work for the audience. Miss Brill’s story keeps a narrator who can quietly show what she misses; Christopher’s first-person account has no such voice, so the wider view has to be assembled from his own careful facts. The novel’s perspective also raises a question about positionality. Some editions described Christopher on their covers with a diagnosis the novel itself never names, and many readers took the book as an account of autism. Haddon wrote on his website in 2009 that the book is about difference rather than a particular condition, and that he had not researched one. A narrator’s perspective is always also a writer’s, and readers judge both.
Other texts multiply perspectives instead of limiting them. A morning call-in program on a Nairobi community radio station asks whether a new bus-only lane is “a gift” or “a punishment” (turn 3). Five callers answer from five positions: a market trader, a motorcycle-taxi rider, a retired teacher, a driver and a student who walks. At the end the host draws the calls together:
NJERI: So, gift or punishment? From this morning, I would say it depends on where you are standing. And some of us are standing at a roundabout with no footpath.
“Sema Mtaa: the red lane on Kamili Road”, turn 59
The host’s summary states the concept almost word for word: the meaning of the lane “depends on where you are standing”. Her second sentence makes clear that even a summary has a position. “Some of us” places the host beside Faith, the student who said the lane had moved the danger onto people who walk, so the last word goes to the perspective the other callers had overlooked. Setting the callers’ views side by side, in juxtaposition, lets the program show a disagreement without settling it, although the host’s final sentence leans one way.
The ferry column multiplies voices in a different way. It brings in the ferry’s captain, Lise Thibodeau, and quotes Wendell Corkum, who “has been on the water for 40 years”: “Cut a sailing and you don’t get it back” (paragraph 11). Each quoted voice widens the column beyond one islander’s experience, but every voice is chosen to agree with the writer. Multiplying perspectives can open a text to disagreement, as the call-in does, or it can add witnesses to one side, as the column does. Texts built from many voices are read further in the question of how texts offer multiple perspectives on a subject.
Try it
The ferry column reports “a habit in the council chamber” of calling the boat “the island’s ferry”, “as if it were a private yacht we had asked the town to pay for” (paragraph 9). Whose perspective does the phrase “the island’s ferry” belong to, and how does the column answer it?
The phrase belongs to the council chamber, where the ferry is seen from the town as a service for someone else: the island’s marks it as the islanders’ property and so their cost. The column exposes that perspective by naming it as a “habit” and by pushing it to an absurd extreme (“a private yacht”). It then offers its own view in the next sentences, “It is the island’s road” (paragraph 9), which places the ferry among the public things a town maintains for everyone. The two names are two perspectives on one boat.
Perspective across the three areas
Perspective runs through every area of exploration, because every text is written from somewhere and read from somewhere else. Frederick Douglass’s Fourth of July oration of 1852 makes the concept its argument, setting the same national holiday in front of two viewers:
To him, your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national greatness, swelling vanity; your sounds of rejoicing are empty and heartless
Frederick Douglass, Oration, Delivered in Corinthian Hall, Rochester, July 5th, 1852, paragraph 5
The words “To him” fix the point from which the celebration is seen, the position of the enslaved, and every your names what the listeners see from theirs. The holiday has not changed between the two views; the viewer has. Douglass asks his listeners to stand, for the length of a sentence, where they have never stood.
In Readers, writers and texts, perspective is about the position a text offers its reader. “Miss Brill” gives its readers a double view, inside her pleasure and outside her loneliness, and the ferry column invites readers in town to see the boat as theirs: “this is your boat too” (paragraph 10). In Time and space, it is about the positions of a period and a place. The 1911 encyclopedia’s “Eastern countries” and Okakura’s “average Westerner” are both perspectives of their moment, and anyone reading them today does so from a position that will in turn look dated.
In Intertextuality: connecting texts, perspective is how texts answer each other. The column answers the council report from the slip instead of the chamber. Okakura answers Western accounts of Japan from inside the culture they describe, and Douglass answers his nation’s founding claims about liberty from the position of those excluded from them. Each reply works by showing that the earlier text had a position it did not admit.
Perspective and the other concepts
Perspective pairs most often with representation, since how a person or place is shown depends on where it is seen from. The council report represents the ferry’s users as “an average of 58 passengers” (paragraph 4); the column represents them as named people. It pairs with identity when a character’s view of the world is also a view of the self, as Miss Brill’s is. With communication, it explains why one message means different things to different receivers. Two concepts used together usually give a sharper reading than either alone: “Miss Brill” read through perspective and identity shows a woman whose view of others is the only self-portrait she allows herself.
Writing about perspective
A paragraph about perspective locates a position before it judges one. It says where the text stands, quotes the words that show it, names what that position shows and hides, and, where two positions meet, weighs them against each other. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, reads the ferry column this way.
“Keep the Saturday ferry” wins its argument by showing that the council’s neutral-sounding report has a perspective of its own.note 1 The report’s phrase “discretionary travel” (paragraph 6) sorts trips by a budget’s logic, and its “average of 58 passengers” (paragraph 4) is what a ferry looks like from the council chamber.note 2 The column moves the point of view to the slip, where an average becomes “Marjorie Langille, who is 91” (paragraph 7), so the same Saturday sailing is seen from the position of the people on it.note 3 Because the writer declares that position in the first line, “I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters” (paragraph 1), the column’s own bias is open to inspection, which makes its charge against the report’s hidden one harder to dismiss.note 4
A claim about perspective. The topic sentence is about where the two texts stand, not about the ferry.
The other position located. Two quoted phrases place the report in the council chamber and show its perspective in its vocabulary.
The shift shown. One quotation proves the change of position, from an average to a named person.
Two perspectives weighed. The paragraph ends by judging declared bias against hidden bias, which is the point only a reading through perspective could reach.
The paragraph never calls either text biased as a verdict. It shows each position in the text’s own words and then judges how openly each holds it. The pair that follows shows the most common fault in writing about perspective, and a repair of the same point about the same text.
Weak: The writer is biased because they live on the island and only give their own opinion, so the article cannot be trusted.note 1
Strong: The column’s perspective is an islander’s and says so (“I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters”, paragraph 1), and its bias shows in a pattern of selection: the travelers named in paragraph 7 are all making trips that are hard to move.note 2
Bias as a verdict. Living on the island is a position, not a fault, and “cannot be trusted” ends the analysis where it should begin.
Position, then pattern. The rewrite names the position in the text’s own words and shows bias as a pattern across a paragraph, which anyone can check.
Applying it in Paper 2
Paper 2 asks for a comparison of two literary works studied, written from memory in answer to one of four general questions. Questions about narrators, about how a work presents a character the reader is meant to judge, or about what a work leaves unsaid all invite perspective as the axis of comparison. The concept works well because every work has a perspective, and works differ sharply in how they build one: through a narrator, a speaker or the staging of a play.
A comparison of Mansfield’s The Garden Party and Other Stories, which contains “Miss Brill”, with Haddon’s novel might open on this claim. Both works confine their telling to one limited view, but Mansfield’s third-person narration quietly shows what Miss Brill misses, while Christopher’s first-person account leaves readers to build the wider view from his own facts. Each later paragraph can test the claim on a pair of moments, such as Miss Brill’s “fine old man” set against one of Christopher’s literal reports, or the young couple’s cruelty set against the discovery of the letters.
Marks are most often lost by discussing what characters think instead of how the works build a view. An essay that says Miss Brill thinks she belongs and Christopher thinks logically is comparing opinions, which earns little for analysis. The comparison becomes analytical when it names the method each work uses and what that method lets a reader know.
In the individual oral
In the individual oral, perspective can connect a literary work with a non-literary body of work through a global issue about who is seen, and from where. A student might pair a novel with a limited narrator and a body of work such as a newspaper’s columns on a local dispute, asking how each presents a community from inside or outside it. The analysis of each extract then locates its position before judging what that position shows.
Perspective leads to the opinion column, where the ferry column is read whole as a type built on a declared position, and to the report, where an institution speaks in an impersonal voice. Representation takes the concept’s question about silence further, asking who is shown, by whom, and with what consequences.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain perspective as the position from which a text sees, and say what a given position shows and hides.
- To do:
I can distinguish point of view, perspective and worldview, and use each term precisely.
- To do:
I can identify the signals of objectivity in a non-literary text and locate the perspective behind them.
- To do:
I can demonstrate bias as a pattern of selection and wording, with evidence, rather than assert it.
- To do:
I can explain how a writer’s and a reader’s positionality shape what a text means.
- To do:
I can analyze how a text limits or multiplies perspectives, and use perspective as the axis of a comparison or an oral.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph that locates two positions in a text and weighs them against each other.
Key terms
Each is also in the Central concepts glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Bias
Bias is a systematic leaning in a text toward one side, group or view, shown in what it selects, how it words it and what it leaves out. It is demonstrated by a pattern of evidence across a text rather than by a single choice.
- Objectivity
Objectivity is the aim of presenting a subject as it is, independent of any one observer's feelings or interests. Texts signal it through an impersonal voice, figures, sources and measured wording, but these signals do not remove the perspective behind what is selected.
- Perspective
Perspective is the position from which a text sees its subject: whose eyes, knowledge and values shape what is shown and what is left out. It includes a narrator's point of view but also the wider stance of a writer, an institution or a reader.
- Positionality
Positionality is the social position of a writer or reader, shaped by such factors as nationality, class, gender, age and culture, and the way that position affects what they notice, know and value. It treats where someone stands as part of what they see.
- Subjectivity
Subjectivity is the quality of a text or judgment that is shaped by a particular person's feelings, experience and position. In writing it shows in first-person claims, evaluative words and choices of detail that a different observer would make differently.
- Worldview
A worldview is the set of beliefs and assumptions about how the world is and ought to be that lies behind a perspective. Those who hold it usually take it for granted, so a text shows it most clearly in what it treats as normal.
Practice questions on 4.5 Perspective
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 22 questions on 4.5 Perspective
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 4 Central concepts
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 4.1Identity
- 4.2Culture
- 4.3Creativity
- 4.4Communication
- 4.5PerspectiveThis page
- 4.6Transformation
- 4.7Representation
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with 4.5 Perspective in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.