4.4 Communication

How texts reach their audiences and where the exchange fails: purpose and audience, channel and noise, phatic talk, a speaker with two audiences, and a poem that refuses to tell.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 4 Central concepts
  • SL and HL

26 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 4.4 Communication

Communication asks how a text reaches its audience, what it asks of that audience, and where the exchange can break down. Every text is a message sent to someone, but most never find out whether it arrived. A public health leaflet cannot take that risk. The readers who need it most may be old, ill or busy, or reading in a second language, and on the hottest day of the year a misread instruction can cost a life. “Keeping cool in a heat wave”, a leaflet from Kelverton Health, a community health service in Melbourne, is built around that risk.

Keeping cool in a heat waveKelverton Health, public health leaflet KH-PH-012, a community health service in Melbourne, 2024Written for Augment Education
Keeping cool in a heat wave
Very hot weather can make anyone sick, and it can make health problems worse. Most heat illness can be prevented.
Get ready before the heat arrives
Watch the forecast and heat health warnings. Before a hot spell:
buy food, water and medicines for a few days, so you can stay home
ask your doctor or pharmacist about your medicines in hot weather
check that your fan or air-conditioner works
decide where you will go if home gets too hot.
Drink water
Drink water regularly, even if you don’t feel thirsty. Carry a bottle when you go out. (If your doctor has told you to drink less, ask how much to drink when it is hot.)
Keep yourself and your home cool
At home:
close blinds and curtains early in the morning
use air-conditioning or a fan if you have one
take cool showers, or wet your skin with a damp cloth
wear light, loose clothing
use the stove and oven as little as you can.
If your home is too hot, spend the hottest hours somewhere cool, such as Kelverton Library or a shopping centre.
Stay out of the heat
Move outings and exercise to the coolest part of the day. If you go out, stay in the shade and wear a hat and sunscreen.
Never leave children, older people or pets alone in a car. Parked cars get dangerously hot very quickly.
Who is most at risk?
Heat can affect anyone, but some people get sick more easily:
people over 65, especially if they live alone
babies and young children
pregnant women
people with a long-term illness, such as heart or kidney disease, diabetes or a mental illness
people who take certain medicines (ask your doctor or pharmacist)
people who work or exercise outdoors
people with no way to keep cool at home, including people who are homeless.
Look out for each other
If you know someone on this list, call them at least once on every very hot day. Offer to do their shopping, or take them somewhere cool.
Know the signs of heat illness
Heat exhaustion can cause heavy sweating, pale skin, dizziness, headache, cramps, feeling sick and fainting. Help the person lie down somewhere cool, give sips of cool water and wet their skin. If they do not get better, get medical help.
Heatstroke is a medical emergency. Call Triple Zero (000). Signs include confusion, muddled speech, very hot skin, collapse or a seizure. Cool the person while you wait.
Need advice?
Call the Kelverton Health heat and health line on 1800 000 000, 8 am to 8 pm daily from 1 December to 31 March. You can ask for an interpreter.
This leaflet is also in Arabic, Greek, Italian, Punjabi, Simplified Chinese and Vietnamese.
KH-PH-012. Revised November 2024.
Kelverton Health acknowledges the Wurundjeri Woi-wurrung people of the Kulin Nation, the Traditional Owners of the land where we work, and pays respect to their Elders past and present.

A message that cannot afford to fail

The leaflet states its task in its first two sentences: “Very hot weather can make anyone sick, and it can make health problems worse. Most heat illness can be prevented” (paragraph 2). The first sentence names a danger, and the second promises that something can be done about it. Everything after is that something, set out in the order in which a heat wave arrives: before it (paragraphs 3–8), during it (9–21) and when someone falls ill (33–35). The leaflet has one main job, to change what people do in hot weather.

What a text sets out to do for or to its audience is its purpose. Purposes are usually plural. This leaflet informs (who is at risk), instructs (“Drink water regularly, even if you don’t feel thirsty”, paragraph 10) and reassures, all in the service of prevention. Naming the governing purpose matters because it explains the other choices. A leaflet written mainly to alarm would open with the number of deaths heat causes; this one opens by saying heat can make “anyone” sick and ends its first paragraph on a remedy.

The person or group a text addresses is its audience. The leaflet speaks to “you” throughout, and its “you” is whoever picks it up: the instructions assume a home with blinds, a doctor to ask and somewhere cooler to go. Paragraph 32 then turns to a different reader: “If you know someone on this list, call them at least once on every very hot day.” The list in paragraphs 24–30 includes people least able to read a leaflet at all, such as babies, people with a long-term illness and people who are homeless. The text reaches them through someone else.

The heat leaflet’s primary audience is every resident of the city, and its secondary audience is the neighbor, relative or friend who will pass its advice to someone who cannot read it. This double address, announced by the heading “Look out for each other” (paragraph 31), is the leaflet’s main defense against failure. It shows what communication means as a way of reading: following a message from the people who send it to the people it must reach, and asking what it requires of each. A reading of this kind asks who must receive a text for it to succeed, what they are meant to do with it, and what might stop it getting through.

Sender, channel, receiver and noise

The leaflet’s design makes most sense against a simple model of how any message travels. A sender (Kelverton Health) puts a message (how to stay safe in the heat) into a form that can travel. It sends that form along a channel, here a printed leaflet and a web page, and a receiver takes the message out at the other end. The model comes from engineering. Claude Shannon set it out in “A Mathematical Theory of Communication” (1948), a paper about sending signals along telephone lines and radio links.

Shannon’s model has one more element, and it is the most useful one for reading. Anything that distorts or blocks the signal on its way he called noise. On a telephone line, noise is crackle. In a text, it is anything that stops the message getting through: a word the receiver does not know, a language the receiver does not read, a page so crowded that the urgent line is lost. Even “Call Triple Zero (000)” (paragraph 35) is noise to a visitor who knows only another country’s emergency number. A reading through communication looks for the places where noise could enter, and then for what the text does about each.

The heat leaflet answers each kind of noise with a choice. Medical terms give way to plain ones: the signs of heat exhaustion include “feeling sick and fainting” (paragraph 34), and heatstroke brings “confusion, muddled speech, very hot skin” (paragraph 35). The leaflet is “also in Arabic, Greek, Italian, Punjabi, Simplified Chinese and Vietnamese” (paragraph 38), and the advice line offers an interpreter (paragraph 37). Against a crowded page it uses short headings and saves bold type for two lines only, the warning about cars (paragraph 21) and the call for an ambulance (paragraph 35).

The diagram sets out the model with the leaflet inside it: the chain from sender to receiver along the top, four kinds of noise in the middle, and the leaflet’s answer to each along the bottom. Read this way, features that look merely plain become decisions. The leaflet’s simple vocabulary, which a quick reading might dismiss as unremarkable, is its main protection against the noise its audience is most likely to meet. Even the second reader of paragraph 32 is an answer to noise, the kind that comes from a receiver too unwell to act.

Diagram: sender (Kelverton Health), message, channel (leaflet and web page) and receiver (residents) in a row. Below, four kinds of noise: medical words, another first language, a crowded page, a reader too ill to read. Below each, the leaflet’s answer, with paragraph numbers.Diagram: sender (Kelverton Health), message, channel (leaflet and web page) and receiver (residents) in a row. Below, four kinds of noise: medical words, another first language, a crowded page, a reader too ill to read. Below each, the leaflet’s answer, with paragraph numbers.
The transmission model with the heat leaflet in it. Each kind of noise that could block the message is met by a choice in the text.

Messages for receivers nobody knows

The model of sender and receiver assumes that both share a code: the same language, the same symbols, the same sense of what a heading or a bold line means. The assumption is easy to miss when a text and its readers live in one city. It becomes visible in the most extreme message ever sent. In 1977 the two Voyager spacecraft left Earth, each carrying a gold-plated record of sounds and images, in a cover engraved with instructions for whoever might one day find it.

A gold disc engraved with line diagrams: a record and stylus at top left, waveforms and picture frames at top right, a starburst of lines at lower left and two small circles at lower right. There are no words.
The cover of the Voyager Golden Record: instructions for an unknown receiver in diagrams, binary numbers and a unit of time taken from the hydrogen atom. Photograph: NASA/JPL, 1977. NASA, public domain.

The cover carries no words. At top left it shows the record and the stylus that plays it, with the time of one turn written in binary numbers. At top right, waveforms and frames show how to turn the signal into pictures. At lower left, a starburst of lines maps the position of the Sun against fourteen pulsars. At lower right, two small circles stand for the hydrogen atom, whose behavior supplies the unit of time for every number on the cover. The designers chose physics as their shared code because it was the one thing they thought any receiver might know.

Every choice still assumes something about the receiver: eyes, an interest in sound, a habit of reading lines on a surface as objects. The record itself holds spoken greetings in 55 languages, and each spacecraft carried a statement from President Jimmy Carter:

This is a present from a small, distant world, a token of our sounds, our science, our images, our music, our thoughts and our feelings. … We are attempting to survive our time so we may live into yours.

Jimmy Carter, statement carried on the Voyager spacecraft, 1977

The statement addresses its receiver as “yours”, a civilization with a future of its own, while writing in English to a being who could not know the language. Earlier probes, Pioneer 10 and 11 (1972 and 1973), had carried plaques that marked the spacecraft’s path with an arrow, and the art historian E. H. Gombrich objected that an arrow is a sign only to cultures that hunted with arrows. A message with no known audience shows what every text does without noticing. It builds a picture of its receiver into its form.

The likeliest receivers of the record were never in space. Its contents were announced, published and argued about on Earth, where the greetings and a “present from a small, distant world” could be understood. A message nominally sent to strangers worked mainly as a message to the people who sent it, about how they wished to be seen. The heat leaflet has the opposite problem: it knows its receivers well, and its difficulty is reaching every one of them.

Where the model stops

Shannon was clear about what his model left out. Messages, he granted, often have meaning, but “These semantic aspects of communication are irrelevant to the engineering problem.” A telephone engineer needs the words to arrive; whether the listener understands, believes or acts on them is someone else’s concern. For the study of texts it is the main concern. The heat leaflet can arrive whole, in the right language, and still fail if the person holding it decides that heat is dangerous only for other people.

The cultural theorist Stuart Hall built a different model around that gap. In “Encoding and Decoding in the Television Discourse” (1973) he argued that a message is encoded by its makers within one set of meanings and decoded by each audience within its own. A viewer may take the meaning its makers intended (a preferred reading), accept it with exceptions (a negotiated reading) or understand it and reject it (an oppositional reading). On Hall’s account the receiver makes meaning rather than collecting it. The two models do different jobs. Shannon’s shows where a message can be lost; Hall’s makes clear that a message can arrive intact and still be read in ways its sender never planned. The chapter on how meaning is constructed and negotiated teaches the three readings in full, on a radio call-in.

Keeping the line open

Some language carries almost no information at all. A morning call-in program on Mtaa Moja FM, a community radio station in Nairobi, puts its first caller on air with this exchange:

MAMA WANJIKU: Hallo? Hallo, Njeri?
NJERI: We can hear you, mama. Karibu. Who is this?

“Sema Mtaa: the red lane on Kamili Road”, turns 5–6

Neither line says anything about the bus lane the program is discussing. The caller checks that the channel is open, and the host confirms it, welcomes her (karibu is Swahili for “welcome”) and asks her name. Language whose job is to open, keep up or close contact rather than to inform is phatic communication. The anthropologist Bronisław Malinowski named it “phatic communion” in 1923, after observing how much everyday talk exists to create a bond between speakers. The linguist Roman Jakobson later counted the phatic function among the functions of language, as the one concerned with the channel itself.

Phatic talk is easy to dismiss as filler, but the program depends on it. The host greets her listeners in Swahili and Sheng, “Habari za asubuhi, wasee wa mtaa” (turn 2), roughly “Good morning, people of the neighborhood”, before any topic is raised. She ends the segment with “Stay with us” (turn 60), a line whose only content is a request to keep listening. These lines tell listeners that the station belongs to their neighborhood and that the conversation will go on tomorrow. For a station whose purpose is to give a neighborhood a voice, keeping the line open is part of the message.

Writing has phatic moments too, and the heat leaflet prescribes one. Its request to “call them at least once on every very hot day” (paragraph 32) asks for a call whose main business is contact: checking that a neighbor is well and still answering. In such a call, the fact that someone picks up the phone is the information that matters.

Try it

At the end of her call, the host says to Faith, a student who walks to college: “Asante sana, Faith. Pole pole on that road” (turn 57). Which parts of the line are phatic, and what do they add to the program?

Both parts are phatic. Asante sana (many thanks) closes the call politely, and pole pole (slowly, take care) wishes Faith a safe walk on a road she has just described as dangerous. Neither gives information, but together they turn a caller into a person the host cares about. In a program built on listeners calling in, such lines show future callers how they will be treated, which keeps the line open for the next morning.

One speech, two audiences

A speech seems to have the simplest audience of all: the people in the room. Frederick Douglass’s Fourth of July oration shows how misleading that can be. On 5 July 1852 Douglass, who had escaped slavery in Maryland, spoke to the Rochester Ladies’ Anti-Slavery Society in Corinthian Hall, Rochester, New York. His listeners already opposed slavery. Yet in the speech’s best-known passage he addresses them as if they were the nation that defended it:

What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July? I answer; a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim.

Frederick Douglass, Oration, Delivered in Corinthian Hall, Rochester, July 5th, 1852, paragraph 5

The pronouns divide the hall. Your belongs to the listeners as Americans, so the holiday they celebrate becomes theirs to answer for, whatever their own views. Him is the enslaved man, who is spoken about and cannot hear. Douglass, standing between them, is the one person present who has been both. The audience in front of him stands in for a larger one, and the speech says so: “could I reach the nation’s ear, I would, to day, pour out a fiery stream of biting ridicule” (paragraph 4).

The phrase “the nation’s ear” names the speech’s real difficulty as one of reach. The listeners in the hall can be persuaded, but they are persuaded already; the nation, which needs persuading, is not in the room. The oration was printed as a pamphlet in Rochester the same year, so its words could travel far beyond the hall. A secondary audience in print was part of its design from the start, and the listeners became a channel to them.

Douglass’s handling of his own method is about communication as well. Paragraphs 1–3 refuse to argue that slavery is wrong, since the audience has “already declared it” (paragraph 1). The chapter on rhetoric reads these refusals as praeteritio; read through communication, they show a speaker diagnosing noise. Information is not what his listeners lack. The noise that blocks his message is their comfort, a holiday mood in which familiar arguments are heard and nothing changes. His answer is to change the kind of message he sends: “At a time like this, scorching irony, not convincing argument, is needed” (paragraph 4).

Communication withheld

Literary texts often make their meaning from communication that does not happen. Characters misunderstand each other, letters go unsent, and speakers decline to say what they mean. Christina Rossetti’s “My Secret”, first printed in Goblin Market and Other Poems (1862), is a poem made almost entirely of a refusal to tell.

My SecretGoblin Market and Other Poems, 1862Christina Rossetti, “My Secret”, Goblin Market and Other Poems (London and Cambridge: Macmillan, 1862), pages 82–84
I tell my secret? No indeed, not I:
Perhaps some day, who knows?
But not to-day; it froze, and blows, and snows,
And you’re too curious: fie!
You want to hear it? well:
Only, my secret’s mine, and I won’t tell.
Or, after all, perhaps there’s none:
Suppose there is no secret after all,
But only just my fun.
To-day’s a nipping day, a biting day;
In which one wants a shawl,
A veil, a cloak, and other wraps:
I cannot ope to every one who taps,
And let the draughts come whistling through my hall;
Come bounding and surrounding me,
Come buffeting, astounding me,
Nipping and clipping through my wraps and all.
I wear my mask for warmth: who ever shows
His nose to Russian snows
To be pecked at by every wind that blows?
You would not peck? I thank you for good will,
Believe, but leave that truth untested still.
Spring’s an expansive time: yet I don’t trust
March with its peck of dust,
Nor April with its rainbow-crowned brief showers,
Nor even May, whose flowers
One frost may wither through the sunless hours.
Perhaps some languid summer day,
When drowsy birds sing less and less,
And golden fruit is ripening to excess,
If there’s not too much sun nor too much cloud,
And the warm wind is neither still nor loud,
Perhaps my secret I may say,
Or you may guess.

The speaker answers a request the poem never prints. The first line, “I tell my secret? No indeed, not I” (line 1), repeats the question back as if it were absurd, and the questioner is scolded as “too curious: fie!” (line 4). This questioner is the poem’s addressee, a “you” who wants to hear, and every stanza is built from excuses offered to that person. The excuses follow the seasons: winter is too cold for opening up, spring too changeable, and only on “some languid summer day” (line 28), when nothing is too much, might the speaker tell.

Seen through the transmission model, the poem is a message about a message that is never sent. The speaker even invents noise to justify the silence. In winter one “cannot ope to every one who taps, / And let the draughts come whistling through my hall” (lines 13–14), so telling a secret is pictured as opening a door to bad weather. The “mask” is worn “for warmth” (line 18). Withholding becomes a kind of shelter, and the poem raises the question of whether anyone is owed the truth about another person’s inner life.

Then the poem turns against its own premise: “Or, after all, perhaps there’s none: / Suppose there is no secret after all, / But only just my fun” (lines 7–9). If there may be no secret, the subject moves from information to relationship. What passes between speaker and listener is a game of power, in which the one who withholds sets the rules. The last lines hand the problem back: “Perhaps my secret I may say, / Or you may guess” (lines 33–34).

Anyone reading the poem stands where the addressee stands, and this is its most precise effect. An interpretation that tries to name the secret, whether a love affair, a crisis of faith or a calling to write, casts its maker as the “too curious” listener the poem has already rebuked. The poem keeps that curiosity unanswered by design. Read through communication, its meaning lies in the act of withholding rather than in anything withheld.

A greeting that fails

Drama shows failed communication in exchanges an audience can hear. In Susan Glaspell’s one-act play Trifles (1916), a farmer named Hale describes finding Mrs. Wright in her kitchen on the morning her husband is found dead. He greeted her in the usual way: “How do, Mrs. Wright, it’s cold, ain’t it?” And she said “Is it?” (line 20). His remark about the weather is phatic, an opening that asks for an equally empty reply. Her question treats it as a request for information, and the ordinary contact between neighbors breaks. Hale reports the moment as merely odd, but the audience hears a woman for whom the small talk that holds a community together has stopped working. The page on drama follows how the play’s women later communicate in subtext that the men never catch.

Communication across the three areas

Communication connects the three areas of exploration rather than belonging to one of them. Each area asks a different question of the transaction between a text and its audience, and the student caller on the Nairobi program puts the widest of those questions in two sentences:

FAITH: Yes. And most people in this city walk for some part of the morning, isn’t it? We just don’t have a phone line to the county.
NJERI: Well, today you had one to us.

“Sema Mtaa: the red lane on Kamili Road”, turns 56–57

Faith’s complaint is about access to a channel. People who walk have no way to send their experience to the county, so the radio program becomes the channel they lack. Who is able to communicate at all, and through which channels, is the question that links communication to power in each of the three areas.

In Readers, writers and texts, communication is the study of how a text builds its reader into its form. The heat leaflet assumes a resident and then recruits that resident as a helper, and “My Secret” makes its reader the curious listener it scolds. Both texts decide what their audiences will do before anyone picks them up.

In Time and space, the question is what happens when a message reaches receivers its sender never imagined. Douglass spoke to a hall in Rochester in 1852. The printed oration now reaches readers for whom the Fourth of July and slavery carry different weights, so its “your” (paragraph 5) lands on a different audience. The Voyager record was addressed to receivers so distant in time and space that nothing about them could be assumed.

In Intertextuality: connecting texts, communication becomes a conversation between texts. Douglass answers the founding documents of his nation with “You have already declared it” (paragraph 1). On the Nairobi program, each caller answers the host’s framing of the bus lane as “a gift” or “a punishment” (turn 3), and Kevo’s “Which people?” (turn 25) answers the name “the people’s lane” that others have given it.

Communication and the other concepts

Communication pairs most naturally with perspective, since what a message means depends on where its receiver stands: Douglass’s “your 4th of July” (paragraph 5) asks his listeners to hear their holiday from the position of the enslaved. It pairs with representation when the question is who speaks and who is spoken for. The heat leaflet speaks about “people who are homeless” (paragraph 30) but has no channel that reaches them directly. With identity and culture, it explains why phatic talk matters, since the host’s greeting in Swahili and Sheng tells listeners which community the program belongs to before any information is exchanged.

Writing about communication

A paragraph about communication follows a message along its route. It names who is addressed, quotes the words that address them, identifies the channel and explains how one or two features help the message survive the journey. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, reads the heat leaflet this way.

“Keeping cool in a heat wave” is designed to keep working even when its first reader cannot act on it.note 1 Its instructions address a “you” with a home, a doctor and a phone, but paragraph 32 turns that reader into a messenger: “If you know someone on this list, call them at least once on every very hot day.”note 2 The list ends with “people who are homeless” (paragraph 30), a group a printed leaflet can rarely reach, so the neighbor’s call becomes the channel the leaflet itself lacks.note 3 The plain register supports this second journey, because symptoms such as “feeling sick” and “muddled speech” (paragraphs 34–35) can be passed on over the phone exactly as printed.note 4

  1. A claim about communication. The topic sentence states what the text does to reach its audience, not what it is about.

  2. Two audiences. One quotation shows the shift from the reader as someone at risk to the reader as a helper.

  3. The channel named. The sentence explains why a second channel is needed, using the leaflet’s own list as evidence.

  4. A feature tied to the route. Diction is explained by the journey the message must make, which links word choice to communication rather than listing it as a separate feature.

The paragraph never claims that the leaflet “communicates effectively”. It traces the message from the health service to a reader and from that reader to someone at risk, and it judges each feature by whether it helps the message travel. The same method serves a speech or a poem: it names the audience, finds the channel and asks what could stop the message on the way. The weaker sentence in the pair that follows makes the most common fault in writing about audience, and the stronger one repairs it on the same feature.

Weak: The leaflet uses simple language and bold text so that the audience can understand the message easily, which makes it effective.note 1

Strong: The leaflet saves bold type for two lines, the warning about cars and “Heatstroke is a medical emergency. Call Triple Zero (000).” (paragraph 35), so a reader who only skims the page during a crisis still meets the one instruction that cannot wait.note 2

  1. Effect asserted, not shown. “Simple language” and “easily” could describe any leaflet, “the audience” is unnamed, and “effective” is a verdict without evidence.

  2. Feature, reader, situation. The rewrite counts the bold lines, quotes one and names the reader it serves, someone skimming in an emergency, which explains why the choice matters.

Applying it in Paper 1

Paper 1 sets an unseen non-literary text with a guiding question, and many guiding questions point toward communication without naming it. A question about how a text addresses a varied audience, engages its readers or presents information clearly asks how the text reaches its receivers and guards against failure. The concept supplies a plan for the essay. It identifies the audience, primary and secondary, the purpose and the channel, and then analyzes the choices that answer each likely kind of noise.

Applied to a text like the heat leaflet, the opening of such an essay might argue that the leaflet’s purpose is to change behavior in a crisis. Its choices are then made to survive the conditions in which it will be read, by people who are unwell, hurried or reading in a second language. Every later paragraph can then take one condition and the features that meet it. Marks are most often lost by treating audience as a label. An essay that says in its introduction that the text targets the general public and never returns to the audience has not analyzed communication at all.

Audience and purpose are also where the image and layout of a visual text belong. A leaflet’s headings, an advertisement’s picture or an infographic’s colors are choices about how a message lands in a few seconds, and an analysis that leaves them out has ignored part of the channel.

In Paper 2 and the individual oral

Communication also gives a Paper 2 essay a strong axis, because every literary work has its own channels, gaps and failed messages. Trifles and Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House (1879) can be compared on how a marriage stops communicating. In Glaspell’s play the wife is absent, and her silence is read by two women through the objects in her kitchen. In Ibsen’s, the final scene is the first serious conversation of an eight-year marriage, and it ends with Nora asking for a “communion between us” that “shall be a marriage” (Act III) before she leaves. The comparison has a clear question: what each play suggests must change before two people can speak to each other.

In the individual oral, communication often frames a global issue about who gets heard. A student might link a literary work about a silenced character to a non-literary body of work from a public campaign, asking how each reaches, or fails to reach, the people it concerns. The global issue then sits in the field of politics, power and justice, and both extracts are analyzed for their channels and audiences as well as their content.

Communication leads to the page on the brochure or leaflet, which reads the heat leaflet whole as a text type, and to the page on the speech, where Douglass’s oration is read for its structure. Perspective takes the concept’s last question further, because where a receiver stands decides what a message can mean.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain communication as a transaction between a text and its audience, and identify a text’s purpose and its primary and secondary audiences.

  • To do:

    I can use the terms sender, message, channel, receiver and noise to show how a text anticipates failure.

  • To do:

    I can explain where the transmission model stops, using Shannon’s own limit and Hall’s idea of decoding.

  • To do:

    I can recognize phatic communication in speech and writing and explain what it maintains.

  • To do:

    I can analyze how a literary text makes meaning from communication that is withheld or fails.

  • To do:

    I can use communication as the axis of a comparison between two works or of an individual oral.

  • To do:

    I can write a paragraph that follows a message along its route and judges features by whether they help it travel.

Key terms

Each is also in the Central concepts glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Audience

The audience of a text is the person or group it addresses or reaches: its readers, listeners or viewers. The primary audience is the one a text is mainly designed for; a secondary audience also receives it, or is meant to be reached through the first.

Channel

A channel is the means by which a message travels from sender to receiver, such as a printed page, a voice in a hall, a radio signal or a screen. Each channel shapes what a message can carry and who is able to receive it.

Communication

Communication is the passing of meaning from a sender to a receiver through a text, a voice or a sign. In the study of texts it covers whom a text addresses, what it asks of them, the means by which it reaches them and the ways the exchange can fail.

Noise

Noise is anything that interferes with a message between sender and receiver, from a bad line or a cluttered page to unfamiliar words or a language the receiver does not read. The term comes from the engineering model of communication and is used in the study of texts for any barrier to understanding.

Phatic communication

Phatic communication is language used to open, keep up or close contact rather than to pass on information, such as greetings, small talk and checks that a listener is still there. Its meaning lies in the relationship it maintains.

Purpose

A text's purpose is what it sets out to do to or for its audience, such as to inform, instruct, persuade, entertain or move. A text often has several purposes at once, and one of them usually governs its main choices.

Practice questions on 4.4 Communication

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0001220 marks

The following advertisement appeared in 2023 in Stoep & Spoon, a monthly South African food and travel magazine read mainly in Johannesburg and Cape Town.

Full-page magazine advertisement: a dusk landscape of dry farmland, a cream guard dog lying in front of a flock of sheep and looking at the viewer, a jackal on a flat-topped hill, a headline about a hungry jackal, body copy, and a dark brand band for Nagwag Lamb.
Description of the advertisement

A portrait magazine page. The top half is an illustration at dusk: the sky darkens from orange near the horizon to deep blue at the top, with a thin crescent moon and a few stars in the upper right. The headline is set over the sky in large cream serif type, with the subhead below it in orange italics.

On the right a large, dark, flat-topped hill fills the middle distance. A small black silhouette of a jackal stands on its ridge, facing right. On the brown ground in front, a flock of nine pale sheep with dark heads grazes. In the lower left foreground, much larger than the sheep or the jackal, a cream-colored dog with dark ears and a dark muzzle lies on the ground, its head raised, looking straight out at the viewer.

The lower half is a pale cream panel holding four short paragraphs of body copy in dark serif type. A dark brown band runs across the foot of the page: the brand name in large white capitals, “LAMB” in smaller orange letters, the slogan in orange italics, two lines of small print, and on the right a round logo of a dog’s face.

The text of the advertisementStoep & Spoon, a monthly South African food and travel magazine, 2023Written for Augment Education
Somewhere on that hill, a jackal is going to bed hungry.
Nobody had to shoot him.
For a hundred years, farmers in the Karoo answered the jackal with fences, traps and a rifle by the back door. The jackals kept coming. So did the losses.
Our farmers went back to something older. Every flock now has a dog that has lived among the sheep since it was a puppy. It doesn’t herd. It doesn’t hunt. It stays out all night, and it barks.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How do text and image work together in this advertisement to promote a way of farming?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0001725 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Many works address a listener whom the work itself imagines. Discuss how this listener shapes what is said in two works you have studied.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0002120 marks

The following work of art is a painting by the French artist Jean-Léon Gérôme, commissioned by the French government. It records the ceremony of 27 June 1861 at the Palace of Fontainebleau, near Paris, at which ambassadors sent by the King of Siam (now Thailand) delivered a letter from their king to Emperor Napoleon III of France.

Wide oil painting of a palace ballroom: on the left, Siamese envoys in colored silks lie prostrate in a row on a red carpet; on the right, French officers stand before a raised throne where the emperor leans toward a kneeling envoy holding up a gold vessel; gifts lie in front.

Jean-Léon Gérôme, Reception of the Siamese Ambassadors by Emperor Napoleon III at the Palace of Fontainebleau, 27 June 1861, 1864. Oil on canvas, 128 × 260 cm. Palace of Versailles.

Description of the painting

A wide painting, about twice as long as it is high. A Renaissance ballroom of tall arches, high windows, chandeliers, paneling and painted ceilings fills the upper half.

On the left, about a dozen envoys in silk robes of many colors (orange, purple, green, pale yellow) and tall pointed gold hats crawl forward in a long row on a red carpet, heads lowered, faces mostly hidden. Behind them a crowd of French officials and soldiers stands upright in dark uniforms, many with red sashes.

On the right, under a canopy of red velvet topped by a gold eagle, Napoleon III sits on a raised platform beside the Empress, who wears a white gown and a blue mantle and a small boy in uniform. A line of women in white stands at the far right. At the foot of the platform one envoy in a gold robe kneels and lifts a gold two-tiered vessel toward the Emperor, who leans forward to take it.

In the foreground lie gifts: a gilded carrying chair, bundles of folded parasols and fans, and, on a pedestal at the lower right, a red and gold crown. The pedestal is signed “J.L. GÉRÔME MDCCCLXIV”.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How is composition used in this painting to communicate the meaning of a diplomatic ceremony?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 23 questions on 4.4 Communication

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

4.4 Communication questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 4 Central concepts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 4.1Identity
  2. 4.2Culture
  3. 4.3Creativity
  4. 4.4CommunicationThis page
  5. 4.5Perspective
  6. 4.6Transformation
  7. 4.7Representation

Carry on with 4.4 Communication in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.