Paper 1 at HL

What changes in Spanish B Paper 1 at HL: abstract tasks, 450 to 600 words used to weigh positions, structures that serve the argument, an eight-minute plan, and a middle and a high response compared.

  • IB Spanish B
  • Exam skills
  • HL only

21 min readLast reviewed

Paper 1 at HL is the same paper as at SL in its shape and its marking. You choose one task from three, each offering three text types, and your text is marked on the same three criteria with the same maxima: A Language (12), B Message (12) and C Conceptual understanding (6). What changes is the size of the job. At HL you write 450 to 600 words in 1 hour 30 minutes, the tasks are usually more abstract, and the language a marker expects to find is wider in range.

The extra 200 words and 15 minutes are not a longer version of the SL text. They exist so that an argument can be developed: a position stated, supported, tested against the strongest objection and then judged. The task that follows, on a theme of Sharing the planet, is worked through the HL method, and two responses to it are compared at the end.

Prueba 1: una tarea de práctica (NS)A Paper 1 practice task at HL, written for Augment EducationWritten for Augment Education
En muchas ciudades turísticas, los vecinos protestan porque los alquileres de corta duración para turistas encarecen la vivienda. Las autoridades de su ciudad estudian limitar este tipo de alquiler. Escriba un texto para los lectores de una revista juvenil en el que analice las ventajas y los inconvenientes de esta medida y dé su opinión. Elija uno de estos tipos de texto: artículo de opinión, discurso o entrada de blog.

Reading an abstract task

An SL task often puts you in a concrete situation: a drought, a visit, a job advertisement. An HL task more often names an issue on which reasonable people disagree, and asks you to analyze it. The verbs show this. The task asks you to “analice las ventajas y los inconvenientes” (analyze the advantages and disadvantages) and to “dé su opinión” (give your opinion), so the text must weigh both sides before it judges. A response that only argues for the measure does half the task, however well it argues.

En muchas ciudades turísticas, los vecinos protestan porque los alquileres de corta duración para turistas encarecen la viviendanote 1. Las autoridades de su ciudad estudian limitar este tipo de alquiler.note 2 Escriba un texto para los lectores de una revista juvenilnote 3 en el que analice las ventajas y los inconvenientes de esta medidanote 4 y dé su opiniónnote 5.

  1. The issue. Tourist rentals make housing more expensive. Behind it lies a larger question: who a city is for, its residents or its visitors.

  2. The situation. A measure under study, not yet decided, so the text can still influence it.

  3. The audience. Young readers, who will soon look for housing themselves. A magazine for them allows a lively, personal register, held consistently.

  4. First part: analyze. Both sides, each developed. The plural (las ventajas y los inconvenientes) expects more than one point on each.

  5. Second part: judge. A clear opinion that follows from the analysis, not one announced in the first line and repeated in the last.

Before you plan, name the positions the issue involves and who holds them. An abstract task becomes concrete through people, and each group gives you an argument and an example. For this task the positions are easy to list in Spanish, and the list already contains most of a plan.

Who

Their position

A Spanish phrase for it

Residents and young people

for the limit: rents fall and neighbors stay

recuperar la vivienda para quienes viven en la ciudad

Small owners

against: the rental is their income

viven de lo que les paga el turismo

Shops, bars and workers

against, or worried: fewer visitors, fewer jobs

el turismo da trabajo a miles de personas

Nearby neighborhoods

worried: the problem moves to them

el problema se traslada a otros barrios

The city as a whole

needs both housing and visitors

encontrar un equilibrio entre vecinos y visitantes

A response does not need every row. It needs at least one strong position on each side, set against each other, so that the opinion at the end is a judgment between them. The table also shows the vocabulary an abstract task demands: nouns such as la vivienda, el alquiler and el equilibrio, which an SL task on the same theme might never require.

A balanced argument is what most separates the HL message from the SL one. An SL letter can argue one side well and earn the top band, because the task asks for one side. An HL task that asks for advantages and disadvantages is judged on how fairly and how fully the other side is treated.

Using the extra length

The commonest weakness of HL responses in the middle band is length used for repetition. The writer states a view in the first paragraph, gives two reasons, and then spends the extra 200 words saying the same things again. Often the conclusion lists every point a second time. The word count is reached, but the argument has not grown.

Each paragraph beyond the SL length should add something the reader does not yet have. There are four kinds of addition: a new reason, an example that makes a reason concrete, the position of the other side, and a consequence (what follows if the measure is or is not taken). The argument map sets out an opinion column for the HL task built from these additions, with a word budget for each block. The orange bracket marks the turn, where the column states the other side and answers it.

Argument map of an HL opinion column in six blocks with word budgets: thesis with a concrete opening, about 80; reason 1 with example, 100; reason 2 with example, 80; counter-position, 110; answer, 100; qualified conclusion, 70. The counter-position and answer are bracketed as the turn.Argument map of an HL opinion column in six blocks with word budgets: thesis with a concrete opening, about 80; reason 1 with example, 100; reason 2 with example, 80; counter-position, 110; answer, 100; qualified conclusion, 70. The counter-position and answer are bracketed as the turn.
An HL argument in six blocks. The turn, where the other side is stated and answered, takes about two fifths of the words.

The budget gives the turn about 210 of 540 words, almost two fifths of the text. That share is deliberate. At SL a short concession is enough; at HL the counter-position is developed as seriously as the writer’s own case, with its own reasons and examples, because the task asks for advantages and disadvantages. The answer to it then carries the opinion, and the conclusion can be short because the judgment has already been made.

Repetition is easy to see in two versions of the same closing paragraph. The first sums up; the second adds a consequence and a condition.

Repeating: En conclusión, la medida tiene ventajas y desventajas. Las ventajas son que las rentas van a bajar y los barrios van a tener más vecinos.note 1 Las desventajas son que algunos negocios van a cerrar.

Adding: Limitar los pisos turísticos no resolverá por sí solo la falta de vivienda, pero sin esa limitación ninguna otra medida funcionará.note 2 Una ciudad que expulsa a sus jóvenes para recibir a sus visitantes acabará sin unos ni otros.note 3

  1. B, repetition. The paragraph lists the points of the body again. A reader who has read the text learns nothing new.

  2. B, development. A qualified judgment: the measure is necessary but not sufficient. The opinion has a limit, which makes it more convincing.

  3. B, development. A consequence that raises the stakes: the city risks losing both groups.

Weighing positions

Weighing positions is a matter of moves, and Spanish has set phrases for each. A concession grants that the other side is partly right (si bien es cierto que…, es verdad que…). A counterargument states the strongest objection to your view. A reply answers it (aun así, no obstante), and a qualified conclusion judges with a condition or a limit (siempre que, por sí solo). The table groups the phrases by move, with the verb form each needs.

Move

Spanish

Verb form after it

Concede

Si bien es cierto que…, Es verdad que…

indicative: the point is accepted as fact

Concede (a point not yet granted)

Aunque + subjunctive: aunque sea cierto que…

subjunctive: even if it may be true

Report the other side

Hay quien teme que…, Quienes se oponen sostienen que…

temer que takes the subjunctive; sostener que, the indicative

Reply

Aun así,…, No obstante,…, Sin embargo,…

indicative

Draw a consequence

De ahí que…

subjunctive: de ahí que los alquileres hayan subido

Qualify

siempre que + subjunctive, no… por sí solo

siempre que se proteja a…

Judge

En definitiva,…, A mi juicio,…

indicative, or the conditional for a proposal

The phrases matter less than the order they create. A strong HL paragraph on the other side does not open with sin embargo and dismiss it in one sentence. It reports the position, gives its best reason and example, and only then replies. The high-band column does this in its third paragraph. “Si bien es cierto que muchos pisos turísticos pertenecen a empresas, también hay familias que alquilan el piso heredado de un abuelo” (while many tourist flats belong to companies, some families rent out an inherited flat), it begins. The sentence grants a point that favors the measure, then states the strongest case against it: families who depend on a single flat.

Aunque deserves care, because its mood changes the meaning. Aunque los alquileres han subido states a fact the writer accepts. Aunque los alquileres bajen imagines a possibility, even if rents fall. An HL writer chooses the mood for the meaning, and a marker notices when the choice is right.

Structures that show range

Criterion A at HL expects a wider range than at SL, and the range a marker looks for is the range the argument needs. An abstract task gives natural places for the structures HL students learn: conditions about the past and the future, consequences, relations between ideas, and ideas turned into nouns. Each structure in the sentences that follow is answering a need of the argument about tourist rentals.

Si el ayuntamiento hubiera actuado hace diez años, el portal de mi abuela no se habría vaciado.note 1

Si se limitaran los pisos turísticos solo en el centro, el problema se trasladaría a los barrios de alrededor.note 2

Cada piso que se dedica al turismo es una vivienda menosnote 3 para quienes trabajan en la ciudad.

Mi hermana, cuyo sueldo de enfermera no es precisamente bajonote 4, comparte piso a los veintinueve años.

Lo que defienden quienes se oponen a la medidanote 5 es una ciudad organizada para quien la visita.

La falta de viviendanote 6 no se resolverá con una sola limitaciónnote 7.

  1. Pluperfect subjunctive. A condition about the past that did not happen, with the conditional perfect in the result. It turns a regret into an argument: the damage could have been avoided.

  2. Imperfect subjunctive. A hypothetical condition about the future, used to test a version of the measure and show its weakness.

  3. Impersonal se. Se dedica keeps the focus on the flats, not on who rents them, which suits a general claim.

  4. Relative cuyo. One clause gives the sister’s job and pay, the evidence that even a decent salary is not enough.

  5. Neuter lo que. It gathers the opponents’ whole position into one subject, so the sentence can judge it.

  6. Nominalization. La falta de vivienda (the lack of housing) names the problem as a thing, which an argument can then discuss.

  7. Nominalization. Una limitación in place of limitar: the measure becomes an object the sentence can weigh.

None of these sentences uses a structure for its own sake. The past condition carries the writer’s strongest point, that delay has a cost. The future condition carries the other side’s worry. Cuyo compresses evidence into the middle of a sentence, and lo que lets the writer sum up an opposing view fairly before answering it. A marker reading them sees range and purpose at once, which is what the top band of criterion A describes.

Nominalization deserves a word because it is the feature that most changes the sound of a text. Abstract tasks are about measures, problems and effects, and Spanish names these with nouns (la subida de los alquileres, la llegada de turistas, la expulsión de los vecinos). A text that can say la subida de los alquileres expulsa a los vecinos moves faster than one that says los alquileres suben y por eso los vecinos se tienen que ir. Both are correct; the first sounds like an argument and the second like a description.

Try it

Join these two sentences into one with cuyo: Mi tío tiene un bar en el centro. Los clientes del bar son casi todos turistas.

Mi tío tiene un bar en el centro cuyos clientes son casi todos turistas. Cuyo agrees with the noun that follows it (cuyos clientes), not with the owner. Another correct version is Mi tío, cuyo bar está en el centro, atiende sobre todo a turistas.

Holding one register for 600 words

A longer text gives the register more chances to slip. The task asks for a text for the readers of a youth magazine, so the register is lively and personal but not chatty. An opinion column may address readers with vosotros in Spain or ustedes in Latin America, and may use a rhetorical question or an image. What it may not do is change its mind about its reader halfway through, sounding like a friend’s message in one paragraph and like an official report in the next.

The opposite risk is common at HL. Students who want to sound advanced pile up long, abstract words until the meaning blurs. A marker rewards precise vocabulary, not inflated vocabulary, and a sentence the reader must read twice weakens both criterion A and criterion B. The pair that follows makes the same point twice.

Inflated: La problemática habitacional derivada de la proliferación de las viviendas de uso turístico constituye una realidad multidimensional cuya resolución implica la implementación de medidas integrales.note 1

Precise: Cuantos más pisos se alquilan a turistas, menos quedan para los vecinos, y eso no se arregla con una sola medida.note 2

  1. A and C, inflated. Six abstract nouns in one sentence, and the reader still does not know what happens to whom. The register is that of an official report, not a column for young readers.

  2. A and C, precise. A cuantos más… menos structure states the cause and the effect in plain words, and the second clause still makes the abstract point.

The precise version is shorter and shows more control: the comparative structure cuantos más… menos is harder than any word in the inflated version. Range at HL lives mainly in structures and in exact words for the topic (encarecer, el inquilino, el propietario, desplazarse), not in long nouns. Use one abstract noun where it names something the argument needs, and keep the rest of the sentence concrete.

Planning in eight to ten minutes

An HL plan takes longer than an SL plan because it must settle the argument, not only the content. At SL five minutes can be enough to list three points; at HL you need eight to ten to decide your position, the strongest case against it, your answer and the limit of your conclusion. The extra minutes are repaid in writing time, because an argument planned to its end does not drift or repeat itself.

The word GIRO (turn) in the plan matters. It marks the paragraph where the text stops building its own case and gives the other side its due. Writers who plan the turn give it a full paragraph; writers who do not plan it tend to add sin embargo and one sentence near the end, when the time is short.

The 90 minutes divide much as the 75 do at SL, with the extra time going to planning and writing:

  • reading the three tasks: about 5 minutes

  • choosing a task and a type: about 3 minutes

  • planning the argument: 8 to 10 minutes

  • writing: 60 to 65 minutes, about 100 words every 11 minutes

  • checking: about 10 minutes

A pace of about 100 words every 11 minutes reaches 550 words with time to spare. If you are behind at the hour, shorten the second reason rather than the turn. The turn carries the weighing that the task asks for, and a column that loses it loses more under criterion B than one with a thinner second reason.

Two responses compared

Two students answered the HL task with an opinion column. The first lives in Mexico and writes departamentos, rentar and la alcaldía; the second lives in Spain and writes pisos, alquilar and el ayuntamiento. Both are consistent in their variety, and neither gains or loses marks for it. The difference between them lies in what they do with the length.

A middle-band response

Exemplar · Middle band17 of 30 marks

Paper 1 (HL): an opinion column on tourist rentals, middle band

On ¿Turistas o vecinos?

The response and its mark on each of 3 criteriaRead it with a free account

The middle-band column scores 17 out of 30. It has the material of a good answer: two family examples, a sense that both sides have a point, and a clear opinion. Its weakness is the structure the length allows. Advantages fill one paragraph, disadvantages the next, and the opinion arrives afterward without having been tested against either. The extra words at HL go into repetition, most visibly in a conclusion that lists the body again.

A high-band response

Exemplar · High band28 of 30 marks

Paper 1 (HL): an opinion column on tourist rentals, high band

On Mi barrio no es un hotel

The response and its mark on each of 3 criteriaRead it with a free account

The high-band column scores 28 out of 30, and the margin notes show why. It is about the same length as the middle one, so the difference does not come from more words. It comes from what each paragraph adds. The opening scene is a reason as well as a hook, the turn gives the other side its best case, and the reply judges that case instead of ignoring it. The conclusion adds a limit and a consequence where the middle column repeated a list.

What the high response does with the length

Set side by side, the two columns differ at almost every comment. The middle column opens by announcing a plan (comment 1); the high one opens on a scene its readers can see. The middle column gives the other side a paragraph of facts; the high one gives it a paragraph of reasons, introduced by si bien es cierto que, and then answers them with aun así. The middle column’s best idea, that both sides are partly right, is the high column’s whole structure.

Under criterion A, the two writers use the same tenses for most of their sentences. The difference lies in what the harder structures do. The middle column’s errors fall in basic structures (gender, ser and estar, the subjunctive after common triggers), so they suggest those structures are not yet secure. The high column’s one slip falls in a sentence that is otherwise ambitious, and its subjunctives elsewhere are right. A middle-band writer aiming higher should first secure the basics, then make each paragraph add a reason, an example, an objection or a consequence.

Paper 1 at HL builds on the method of the SL paper, taught on the page on Paper 1 writing, and on the choice of type, which has a page of its own. The opinion column, the speech and the blog post each have a text type page with a model. The grammar pages on connectors, relative pronouns and si clauses teach the structures that carry an HL argument. The page on globalization gives the vocabulary and the real examples for tasks like this one.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what is the same and what changes in Paper 1 at HL.

  • To do:

    I can name the issue behind an abstract task and the positions people take on it.

  • To do:

    I can plan an argument with a marked turn and a word budget for each block.

  • To do:

    I can concede, report the other side, reply and qualify my conclusion with si bien, aun así, de ahí que and siempre que.

  • To do:

    I can use the imperfect and pluperfect subjunctive, cuyo, lo que and nominalization where my argument needs them.

  • To do:

    I can hold one register for 600 words without inflated vocabulary.

  • To do:

    I can explain why one response scores in the middle band and another in the high band.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB Spanish B glossary.

Balanced argument HL only

An argument that sets out the main positions on an issue fairly, each with its reasons, before reaching a judgment. Its conclusion is an opinion that has been tested against the strongest case on the other side.

Exam skills for Spanish B

Paper 1

  1. 1Choosing a text type
  2. 2Paper 1 at HLThis page
  3. 3Paper 1: writing

Paper 2

  1. 4Paper 2: reading
  2. 5Paper 2 at HL
  3. 6Paper 2: listening

Carry on with Spanish B in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.