- Subjects
- Mandarin B
- The conversation
The conversation
The follow-up discussion and general conversation in the SL oral: developing an answer with claim, reason, example and link, keeping the exchange going, asking for clarification and describing a missing word in Chinese.
- IB Mandarin B
- Internal assessment
- SL and HL
After the presentation, the oral becomes a conversation, and the marks for it depend on two things: how far each answer is developed, and how well you keep the exchange going with your teacher. The follow-up discussion stays with the image and its theme. The general conversation then moves to at least one other theme. Together they usually last nine to eleven minutes, most of the oral, and they are where criteria B2 and C are earned. This follow-up discussion comes after the presentation on a photograph of shared bicycles piled against a wall in Beijing.
The follow-up discussion
The teacher’s first question starts from the end of the presentation: “你在陈述的最后问……你自己怎么看?” (paragraph 1: at the end of your presentation you asked… what do you think yourself?). The follow-up discussion usually works like this. The teacher picks up a point you made and asks you to go further with it: to explain, to compare, to judge, or to say what you would do. The questions are open, so a one-word answer is never the whole answer.
The student answers each question in the first sentence and then develops it. “我觉得两个都有,但是主要看管理” (paragraph 2: I think it is both, but it mainly depends on management) gives a position at once. The next sentences set two cases side by side with 如果……那…… and end by applying them to the photograph. When the teacher asks who should be responsible, the student names one side, gives a reason, “车是他们放的,钱也是他们赚的” (paragraph 4: they put the bikes there and they made the money), and then adds the other side with 不过. The facts from the presentation come back as evidence instead of being repeated.
The last answer is personal, and it is the most natural of the three. The student has ridden shared bikes on a trip to Shanghai, liked them, and has also seen one parked on a tactile path for blind people, “停在盲道上” (paragraph 6: parked on the tactile paving). A specific memory like this one is worth more than a general opinion, because it is true, it is the student’s own, and it gives the teacher something to ask about next.
Teachers ask a few kinds of question again and again, and each kind asks for a different shape of answer. Knowing the kinds makes the questions less surprising.
The teacher asks | In Chinese, for example | Your answer needs |
|---|---|---|
Why | 为什么会这样? | A reason, then an example |
Your view | 你自己怎么看?/你同意吗? | A clear position in the first sentence |
Compare | 跟你的国家比起来呢? | Two things, with 比 or 跟……不一样 |
Judge | 你觉得这是好事还是坏事? | A position, the other side with 不过, a conclusion |
Imagine | 如果你是市长,你会怎么做? | 会 or 要 with a plan, and why it would work |
Your experience | 你自己有没有……的经历? | One specific memory, with when and where |
Developing an answer: claim, reason, example, link
A developed answer has four parts, and each has a Chinese frame that starts it. The claim answers the question directly, often after 我觉得. The reason says why, after 因为. The example makes it concrete, after 比如. The link draws the conclusion with 所以 and connects it back to the question or forward to something new. The four parts take about thirty seconds to say, which is the length a good answer usually has.

The chain is a habit, not a formula. Not every answer needs all four parts in this order, and repeating 我觉得……因为……比如……所以…… in every answer would sound mechanical. Its use is as a check: if an answer has no reason and no example, it has not been developed. Varying the frames keeps the check from showing, as the table shows.
Part | Frames | Use it when |
|---|---|---|
Claim | 我觉得…… / 对我来说…… / 我同意/不太同意…… | Any question that asks for a view |
Claim | 这要看情况。如果……,就……;如果……,就…… | The honest answer depends on the case |
Reason | 因为…… / 主要的原因是…… / 这是因为…… | Every claim |
Example | 比如…… / 拿……来说 / 我记得有一次…… | A claim needs a person, a place or a moment |
Link | 所以…… / 总的来说…… / 这就是为什么我觉得…… | Ending an answer |
Link | 不过,我也觉得…… | Adding the other side before you finish |
The frames become useful only when they come without thinking. Practicing the chain aloud on questions from every theme, with a timer set to thirty seconds, builds that habit over a few weeks and leaves your attention free for the ideas.
Improving an answer
The weak answer and the stronger one respond to the same question in a general conversation on technology: 你觉得网上上课好不好?
不好。我不喜欢网上上课。很无聊。note 1
我觉得网上上课有好处,也有问题。note 2好处是方便,因为不用花时间坐车;可是在家里很难集中注意力。note 3比如疫情的时候,我们上了三个月网课,我常常一边上课一边看手机。note 4所以我觉得,网课适合当面上课的补充,但不能完全代替它。note 5
Weak: claim only. Three short sentences that say the same thing three times. There is no reason the teacher can discuss and no example.
Stronger: a claim with two sides. It answers the question and promises a balanced view.
Stronger: reasons for each side. 因为 for the good point, 可是 for the problem. Each reason is specific.
Stronger: an example from experience. A real period, a length of time and an honest detail about the student.
Stronger: the link. 所以 draws a conclusion that answers the original question, and 适合……但不能完全代替 gives it a precise limit.
The stronger answer is about four times as long, but its length is not the point. Every sentence adds something the teacher can respond to: a reason to question, an experience to ask about, a conclusion to agree or disagree with. This is what criterion B2 rewards.
Keeping the exchange going
Criterion C rewards a student who takes part in the conversation, not one who only waits for the next question. Taking part means responding to what the teacher actually said, adding your own ideas, and now and then asking the teacher something. In the extract that follows, the teacher does not ask a question at all; the teacher states a view, and the student has to decide what to do with it.
The student treats the statement as an invitation. “我同意一部分,但不是全部” (paragraph 2: I agree with part of it, but not all) sets up a balanced answer in one sentence. The student then concedes the teacher’s point with 确实 (it is true that) and its own example, people looking at phones over dinner, before turning it with 不过. The second example comes from the student’s family: a grandmother in Singapore, with whom the student video-calls every weekend. The answer closes by handing the conversation back: “您觉得呢?” (paragraph 2: what do you think?).
Agreeing in part is often the most interesting answer a student can give, because it makes clear that the student has listened to the view and weighed it. A flat 我同意 ends the exchange; a flat 我不同意 without a reason sounds like a refusal. The frames for responding to a view give you more choices.
Frame | What it does |
|---|---|
我同意,而且我觉得…… | Agrees and adds a new point |
我同意一部分,但不是全部。 | Agrees in part; the reasons follow |
确实,……。不过,…… | Concedes a point, then turns it |
我不太同意,因为…… | Disagrees politely, with a reason |
这个问题很难说,要看…… | Shows that the answer depends on the case |
您觉得呢?/您是怎么看的? | Hands the question back to the teacher |
我想补充一点…… | Adds to your own earlier answer |
说到……,我想起…… | Moves on from the teacher’s point to a related example |
Handing a question back works best once or twice in an oral, at the end of a developed answer. The teacher may answer briefly and ask you something else, which is normal: the oral is assessing you, not the teacher. Asked after every answer, 您觉得呢 starts to sound like a way of avoiding the question.
Asking for clarification in Chinese
Every student meets a question they do not fully understand, and the oral expects it. What matters is what happens next. Asking for clarification in Chinese, quickly and clearly, keeps the conversation going and shows exactly the control that criterion C rewards. Guessing at the meaning and answering a different question loses marks under B2 as well.
This student asks for help twice, in two different ways. The first time, the problem is one word, so the student asks about it and offers a guess: “是说政府怎么设计一个城市吗?” (paragraph 2: does it mean how the government designs a city?). A guess tells the teacher that the student has understood most of the question, and the teacher only needs to confirm it. The second time, the student did not catch the end of a long question, and says so precisely: “我没听清楚最后一部分” (paragraph 6: I didn’t hear the last part clearly). The teacher then rephrases the question in simpler words.
Frame | Use it when |
|---|---|
不好意思,您能再说一遍吗? | You did not hear or catch the question |
我没听清楚最后一部分。 | You missed only part of it |
对不起,“……”是什么意思? | One word is unknown |
您的意思是……吗?/是说……吗? | You think you understand and want to check |
您能说得慢一点儿吗? | The question was too fast |
您是问……还是……? | The question could mean two things |
One request for clarification costs nothing; it is part of normal conversation in any language. What lowers criterion C is needing every question repeated, or long silences while you try to work a question out alone. If a question is hard, a short phrase to hold the turn while you think also helps: 这个问题很有意思,让我想一想 (that is an interesting question, let me think).
When a word is missing
Even a strong student forgets a word in the middle of a sentence. The way through is to describe the thing in the Chinese you have, rather than stopping or switching to English. This is called circumlocution, and it is one of the most useful skills in any spoken exam. In the next extract, a student talking about food-delivery riders cannot remember the word for helmet.
The student holds the turn with “嗯,怎么说呢” (paragraph 1: um, how should I put it), then describes the object by what it does and where it goes: “骑车的时候戴在头上、保护头的那个东西” (paragraph 1: that thing you wear on your head when riding, to protect it). The teacher offers 头盔, and the student takes the word at once, repeats it and uses it in the next sentence: “不戴头盔非常危险” (paragraph 3: riding without a helmet is dangerous). The gap has become a small exchange between two speakers, which is what criterion C values.
Frame | How it describes |
|---|---|
就是那种……的东西 | By what kind of thing it is |
用来……的 | By what it is used for: 用来开瓶子的 |
跟……差不多,可是…… | By comparison with a word you know |
……的反义词 | By its opposite |
……的时候需要的那个…… | By the situation it belongs to |
我想不起来那个词了,意思是…… | Says openly that a word is missing, then explains |
Circumlocution also helps with words you know but are unsure how to say. If 环境保护 will not come out right, 保护地球、让空气和水更干净 says the same thing in words you are sure of. Simplifying a sentence is a choice a skilled speaker makes, and it costs far less under criterion A than a long sentence that breaks down.
Thinking time and correcting yourself
Pauses are part of every conversation, and a short one before a hard question costs nothing. What criterion C notices is a long silence, or a pause filled with sounds from another language. Chinese has its own ways of holding the turn while you think, and using them keeps the conversation in Chinese even while you are looking for an idea.
Frame | What it does |
|---|---|
这个嘛…… | A natural pause before a view, like “well…” |
让我想一想。 | Asks for a moment, politely |
怎么说呢…… | Signals that you are looking for the right words |
我的意思是…… | Restates a point more clearly |
不对,应该说…… | Corrects something you have just said |
刚才我说……,其实…… | Goes back to an earlier answer to change or add to it |
Correcting yourself is a sign of control, not of weakness. A student who hears an error and repairs it at once shows the teacher that the structure is known, and the slip then costs less under criterion A. The student in this short turn, answering a question about school life, corrects one grammar error and one choice of word.
我们学校每天下午四点放学,我常常去打篮球在……不对,我常常在操场打篮球note 1。我觉得运动对学习很帮助……我的意思是,很有帮助note 2,因为运动以后,我做作业的时候更容易集中注意力note 3。
A, self-correction: word order. The student starts with the place after the verb, as in English, hears it, and repairs it with 不对: place before the verb.
A, self-correction: a fixed phrase. 很帮助 is a common learner error; 我的意思是 restates it as 很有帮助 without stopping the answer.
B2: development continues. After both repairs the student still gives the reason, so the corrections do not cut the answer short.
Self-correction works only when it is quick. Stopping to rebuild a whole sentence slowly, or correcting every small slip, breaks the flow that criterion C also listens for. The aim is to repair the errors that matter to meaning or that you know you make often, and to let the rest go.
Moving to another theme
The general conversation usually takes the last five to six minutes, and it moves to at least one theme other than the one your image belonged to. The teacher signals the change, often in a single sentence such as 我们换一个话题 (now for another topic). You cannot know the questions in advance, but the themes are the five your class has studied, so the topics will not be new.
The teacher moves from the city to Education with one sentence, and the student answers the new question as fully as any in the discussion. The first answer opens with 对我来说 and a contrast, “最难的不是写汉字,而是声调” (paragraph 2: the hardest part is not writing characters but tones), then gives a reason and a real, slightly embarrassing story about buying and selling. The story is funny, short and specific, and it ends with what the student does now, practicing every day. The second answer weighs two places to learn, 各有好处 (each has its advantages), sets them side by side, gives a plan with 先……然后再……, and ends by asking the teacher a question.
The best preparation for the general conversation is a small store of material for every theme: two or three things you know about a Chinese-speaking place, one opinion with a reason, and one experience of your own. The table gives questions of the kind a teacher might ask on each theme; practicing a developed answer to each one aloud is a good way to build that store.
Theme | A question a teacher might ask |
|---|---|
Identities | 你觉得一个人的身份认同跟他说的语言有关系吗? |
Experiences | 你最难忘的一次旅行是什么?为什么? |
Human ingenuity | 如果没有手机,你的生活会有什么不同? |
Social organization | 你觉得学校应该减少作业吗? |
Sharing the planet | 你自己为保护环境做过什么? |
Try it
Your teacher says: 我们换一个话题。你觉得中学生应该打工吗? Give a developed answer in four parts, then hand the question back.
One good answer: 我觉得这要看情况。(claim)如果打工的时间不太长,比如周末几个小时,学生可以学会管理钱,也能认识不同的人。(reason)比如我的表哥在新加坡读高中的时候,每个星期六都在小贩中心帮忙,他说这让他更懂得父母赚钱不容易。(example)不过,如果打工影响了学习,那就不值得了。所以我觉得,最重要的是平衡。(link)老师,您上中学的时候打过工吗?(handing the question back)
Three complete orals at the high, middle and low bands, on one image, show these skills across a whole conversation, with marks and comments for each criterion. The page on presenting a visual stimulus covers the presentation that comes first, and the HL oral, which starts from a literary extract, has its own pages.
Self-check
- To do:
I can say what the follow-up discussion and the general conversation are, and how long each usually lasts.
- To do:
I can develop an answer with a claim, a reason, an example and a link, without repeating the same frames every time.
- To do:
I can agree in part, concede a point with 确实……不过……, and hand a question back to the teacher.
- To do:
I can ask for a question to be repeated or explained in Chinese, and check my guess with 您的意思是……吗?
- To do:
I can describe a missing word by what it is, what it is used for or what it is like.
- To do:
I can answer a question on a new theme with the same depth as on the theme of my image.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB Mandarin B glossary.
- Circumlocution
Describing a thing or idea in other words when the exact word is not known or cannot be remembered, for example by saying what it is used for, what it looks like or what it resembles. It keeps a conversation going in the target language.
- Follow-up discussion
The part of the individual oral that comes straight after the presentation, usually four to five minutes long, in which the teacher asks about the stimulus or extract and its theme, starting from what the student has said.
- General conversation
The last part of the individual oral, usually five to six minutes, in which the teacher talks with the student about at least one course theme other than the one of the stimulus.
Internal assessment for Mandarin B
Individual oral
- 1An HL oral at each bandHL only
- 2The individual oral
- 3An oral at each band
- 4Presenting a visual stimulus
- 5The conversationThis page
- 6The HL oral: a literary extractHL only
Carry on with Mandarin B in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.