An oral at each band

Three complete SL individual orals on one visual stimulus, a hawker center in Singapore’s Chinatown, at the high, middle and low bands, each annotated and marked on criteria A, B1, B2 and C.

  • IB Mandarin B
  • Internal assessment
  • SL and HL

37 min readLast reviewed

A complete oral shows what a short extract cannot: how the presentation sets up the questions that follow, how a student recovers when a word is missing, and how four criteria add up to one mark out of 30. The three orals that follow begin from the same photograph. One is a high-band response, one a middle-band response and one a low-band response, and every mark comes with a reason. The transcripts are written texts, composed so that each band is easy to see; they are not recordings of real students.

The visual stimulus is a photograph of a hawker center in Singapore’s Chinatown, which Chinese speakers in Singapore call 牛(niú)车(chē)水(shuǐ). In the preparation room it would be one of two images, each tied to a course theme, and the student chooses one. This one carries the title 牛(niú)车(chē)水(shuǐ)的(de)小贩(xiǎofàn)中心(zhōngxīn).

A large indoor hawker center with rows of light wooden tables and fixed round stools, many empty. Food stalls with lit signboards line the back wall; roast ducks hang in two stall windows. A few middle-aged and older diners eat or walk between tables. Fans and pipes hang from the ceiling.
The stimulus for the three orals: People’s Park Food Centre, a hawker center in Chinatown, Singapore. Theme: Experiences (customs and traditions). Photograph: Kbseah, 2025. Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The stimulus, in words. A long, plain hall under a low concrete ceiling, with fans, pipes and strip lights hanging from it. The floor is filled with rows of light wooden tables, each ringed by round stools fixed to the floor, and most seats are empty. Along the back wall runs a line of food stalls. Their signboards are in Chinese and English and covered in photographs of dishes. One reads 鲜(xiān)果汁(guǒzhī) (fresh fruit juice) and another shows the figure 2.90; in two stall windows, roast ducks and chickens hang in rows. One stall on the left has its metal shutter pulled down.

The people are few, which suggests an afternoon between mealtimes. Most are middle-aged or older men, and a young woman eats at a table on the left. Some eat alone, one man talks on his phone, and a man in a blue shirt stands by a table with two red buckets. On a pillar, a sign shows the center’s rules in pictures: no smoking, no bicycles, no dogs. Cardboard boxes are stacked at the far left.

The image belongs to the theme Experiences, under customs and traditions, and it touches identity and migration too. Singapore’s hawker culture was added to UNESCO’s list of the intangible cultural heritage of humanity in December 2020, and UNESCO described hawker centers as “community dining rooms”. Several details in the photograph speak to that idea: tables shared by strangers, food from the south of China, signs in two languages, and the question the closed stall raises about who will run these stalls in future. A presentation that reads these details as meaning has already done most of the work criterion B1 rewards.

How to read the three orals

Each oral is printed as an exemplar: a complete response, marked on the four criteria and annotated. First come the student’s preparation notes, the short points written in the 15 minutes before the oral. Then comes the transcript, from the first sentence of the presentation to the last of the general conversation, with the teacher’s turns marked 老师(lǎoshī) and the student’s 学生(xuéshēng). Last come the comments in English, numbered to match the highlighted words. Each comment opens with the criterion it concerns and a verdict: strength, partly, missed or error.

Every mark sits inside a mark band. For criterion A, out of 12, the bands are 1–3, 4–6, 7–9 and 10–12; for B1, B2 and C, each out of 6, they are 1–2, 3–4 and 5–6. Your teacher first decides which band’s description fits the oral, then where in the band it sits. The reason printed beside each mark follows that order: what places the oral in its band, and what keeps it from the band above.

Teachers mark by best fit. An oral rarely matches every phrase of one description, so the teacher chooses the band whose description matches the performance most closely as a whole. A student whose language is varied and mostly accurate but who hesitates often can still sit in the third band of criterion A; how often the student hesitates decides where in that band the mark falls. An oral can also sit in the high band with one criterion in the middle band.

The three orals are most useful read side by side. Read the high oral in full first, to hear what the whole exchange can sound like. Then compare the three at four moments: the first minute of the presentation; the point where the student mentions the closed stall; the answer to the first question about young people; and the first answer of the general conversation. Those four moments hold most of the difference between the bands.

The general conversation is on a different theme in each oral, as it would be with three different students. The high oral moves to education (whether exams measure ability), the middle oral to the environment (what one person can do), and the low oral to lifestyles (weekends, sleep and food). These parts show criteria B2 and C on ordinary questions, where no preparation helps and only the habit of developing an answer does.

A high-band oral

The first student chose the hawker center because she had eaten in one with a cousin who lives in Singapore. Her preparation notes hold eight short points. Only two describe the image; the rest are ideas, a fact she knows and a view of her own. The arrow in point 4 shows the thinking that matters most: a closed stall turned into a question about the future.

Exemplar · High band27 of 30 marks

Individual oral (SL): a high-band response

On 牛车水的小贩中心

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The oral scores 27 out of 30. What lifts it is the preparation more than the Chinese. Her notes decided, before she spoke, what the image means: a place where strangers share tables, where the food tells a story of migration, and where a closed stall raises a question. Every part of her presentation serves one of those three ideas, so it never becomes a list.

Her Chinese is strong but not perfect. She puts 了(le) on a daily habit, her general conversation is simpler than her presentation, and she stops once to find a word. None of this costs much, because each slip is brief and she never loses the thread. A listener follows her without effort, which is what the top band of criterion A asks.

Her conversation shows the habit of a developed answer: a claim, a reason, an example and a link back to the question. Asked why young people avoid the work, she gives two reasons, an example from her cousin and a qualification about new young hawkers. Only one answer, on fairness in education, stays general, and that is the one that keeps B2 from full marks.

A middle-band oral

The second student chose the same image because he had visited a hawker center while staying with his uncle in Singapore. His preparation notes are honest and organized. Five of the eight points describe what is in the image, one is a memory and one a short list of good and bad points. Only point 6 names the theme, and it holds no idea about what the image means.

Exemplar · Middle band17 of 30 marks

Individual oral (SL): a middle-band response

On 牛车水的小贩中心

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The oral scores 17 out of 30. His presentation is careful, accurate and almost all description: tables, stools, fans, the fruit-juice sign, the man in blue, the rules on the pillar. Each detail is right, and each is something the teacher can see. When he reaches the theme, he lists three true points (tradition, UNESCO, night markets) and adds a general sentence about Chinese people and food.

The discussion makes clear that he has more to say than his presentation suggests. Asked about older diners, he gives the best answer of his oral: his uncle meets old friends there every morning, so the hawker center is 一个(yígè)见面(jiànmiàn)的(de)地方(dìfang). That idea belongs in the presentation. Had he asked himself in the preparation room why most diners in the photograph are older, it would have been there, and it would have counted under B1.

His Chinese is clear and his errors are typical of the middle band. The place-after-verb order, the missing 把(bǎ) and 不(bù) for 没(méi) all come from English, and the first two recur. None blocks the meaning, which is why criterion A sits at 6; the narrow range is what keeps it out of the third band. A few structures he half knows already, such as a 是(shì)……的(de) sentence or 虽然(suīrán)……但是(dànshì)…… with a real contrast, would widen his range, and range is what the third band asks for.

A low-band oral

The third student chose the hawker center because it looked easier than the other image. Her seven preparation points are single words or short lists. Four describe what is in the photograph, two hold her opinion of Singapore and a friend’s memory, and the last names the theme with nothing beside it, which is how her presentation ends too.

Exemplar · Low band10 of 30 marks

Individual oral (SL): a low-band response

On 牛车水的小贩中心

The response and its mark on each of 4 criteriaRead it with a free account

The oral scores 10 out of 30. Her presentation makes clear that she understood the image: she can name the tables, the fans, the stalls, the fruit juice and the older diners, and she notices the price. What she cannot yet do is say what any of it means. She names the theme, 习俗(xísú)和(hé)传统(chuántǒng), in her last sentence and stops there, so criterion B1 has almost nothing to reward.

Her language is limited but rarely confusing. Most of her errors, such as the missing measure words, 是(shì) before an adjective and 不(bù)听(tīng)懂(dǒng), sound wrong without hiding the meaning. One does hide it: when 卖(mài) comes out as 买(mǎi), the teacher cannot tell who is selling, and has to stop to check. Tone errors of this kind are the ones to work on first, because they change the word, not just its correctness.

She still earns marks on every criterion, and her conversation shows why. She never switches to English, she asks for help in Chinese when she is lost, and once she asks the teacher a question of her own. Those habits keep an oral going even when the language is thin, and they are the base on which a middle-band oral is built.

Comparing the three orals

The chart places each oral’s marks on one line per criterion, from zero to the criterion’s maximum, with the edges of the mark bands drawn in. The high oral is close to full marks everywhere. The middle oral sits in the middle band on every criterion, which is common: a student who describes the image also tends to answer the questions briefly. The low oral is low throughout but never at zero, because she keeps communicating.

Dot plot of the three exemplar orals by criterion. A out of 12: high 10, middle 6, low 4. B1 out of 6: 6, 3, 2. B2 out of 6: 5, 4, 2. C out of 6: 6, 4, 2. Totals: high 27, middle 17, low 10.Dot plot of the three exemplar orals by criterion. A out of 12: high 10, middle 6, low 4. B1 out of 6: 6, 3, 2. B2 out of 6: 5, 4, 2. C out of 6: 6, 4, 2. Totals: high 27, middle 17, low 10.
The marks of the three orals, each criterion on a line from zero to its maximum. These are the page’s exemplars, not data about real students.

The widest gap is on B1, the criterion most open to preparation. The high student earns 6, the middle student 3 and the low student 2, and the difference was made in the preparation room. The same image gave all three the same details; only one student decided in advance what those details mean.

Four moments, read across the three transcripts, show where the marks come from. In the first minute, the high student sets out a plan that names the theme, while the middle student starts with “在(zài)照片(zhàopiàn)里(lǐ),有(yǒu)很多(hěnduō)桌子(zhuōzi)和(hé)凳子(dèngzǐ)” (in the photograph there are many tables and stools) and the low student with single nouns. At the closed stall, the high student asks “谁(shuí)来(lái)接班(jiēbān)呢(ne)?” (who will take over?), the middle student mentions it in one sentence and moves on, and the low student finds it only when the teacher points to it.

The first question about young people brings two reasons, an example and a qualification from the high student. The middle student offers a guess, then a reason after a second question. The low student first answers “我不(wǒbù)听(tīng)懂(dǒng)” (I don’t understand), then gives a short answer once the teacher rephrases. In the first answer of the general conversation, the high student weighs what exams can and cannot measure, the middle student lists two things he does for the environment, and the low student says 我(wǒ)睡觉(shuìjiào) (I sleep). The difference in the follow-up discussion and the conversation is mostly one of development, not of vocabulary.

From one band to the next

From the middle band to the high band

The middle student knows enough Chinese to say much of what the high student says. Two habits separate them. In the preparation room, he wrote down what to describe, while she wrote down what to argue. In the discussion, he answers and waits, while she answers, explains, gives an example and links it back to the question.

His answer about the closed stall shows the second habit at work. The first version is what he said; the second is how he could have answered with Chinese he already uses elsewhere in the oral.

因为(yīnwèi)太(tài)累了(lèile)吧(ba)。做(zuò)小贩(xiǎofàn)要(yào)很(hěn)早(zǎo)起床(qǐchuáng),工作(gōngzuò)时间(shíjiān)很(hěn)长(cháng),也(yě)很(hěn)热(rè)。note 1

我(wǒ)觉得(juéde)主要是(zhǔyàoshi)因为(yīnwèi)太(tài)辛苦(xīnkǔ)了(le),做(zuò)小贩(xiǎofàn)要(yào)很(hěn)早(zǎo)起床(qǐchuáng),厨房(chúfáng)也(yě)很(hěn)热(rè)。我(wǒ)叔叔(shūshu)家(jiā)楼下(lóuxià)有(yǒu)一个(yígè)卖(mài)咖啡(kāfēi)的(de)摊(tān)位(wèi),老板(lǎobǎn)六(liù)十多岁(shíduōsuì)了(le),可是(kěshì)他的(tāde)孩子(háizi)都(dōu)不想(bùxiǎng)接着(jiēzhe)做(zuò)。note 2所以(suǒyǐ)照片(zhàopiàn)里(lǐ)那个(nàge)关门(guānmén)的(de)摊(tān)位(wèi),可能(kěnéng)不是(búshì)老板(lǎobǎn)今天(jīntiān)休息(xiūxi),而是(érshì)已经(yǐjīng)没有(méiyǒu)人(rén)接班(jiēbān)了(le)。note 3

  1. B2, partly. A reason in three short clauses. It is relevant and accurate, and it stops where the teacher has to ask the next question.

  2. B2, strength. An example from his own visit: one stall, one owner, one family. It turns a general reason into evidence.

  3. B2, strength. The link back to the image, in the discussion. The answer now says something about the photograph that the teacher had not seen in it.

The rewrite uses no structure beyond the middle band. 不是(búshì)……而是(érshì)…… is the only new pattern, and it is one he has met. What changes is the order of thought: reason, example, link. That order can be practiced in any conversation in Chinese, on any topic.

From the low band to the middle band

The low student needs different changes, and fewer of them. First, full sentences with the commonest structures right: a measure word after every number, no 是(shì) before an adjective, 听不懂(tīngbudǒng) rather than 不(bù)听(tīng)懂(dǒng). These three alone would remove most of her errors. Second, tones on the words of the topic, above all 买(mǎi) and 卖(mài), so that the teacher never has to stop and check her meaning.

Third, one or two sentences of meaning prepared in the 15 minutes, in Chinese she can already say, such as 小贩(xiǎofàn)中心(zhōngxīn)很(hěn)便宜(piányi),所以(suǒyǐ)很多(hěnduō)人(rén)都可以(dōukěyǐ)来(lái). A low-band oral moves up by doing simple things reliably before it tries harder ones. Her habit of asking for help in Chinese is already in place. Talking around a missing word with circumlocution, as the middle student does for 环保(huánbǎo)袋(dài), is the next step, and criterion C, interactive skills, will rise as her answers grow longer.

Try it

The low student answers the question 你(nǐ)觉得(juéde)小贩(xiǎofàn)中心(zhōngxīn)为什么(wèishénme)便宜(piányi)? with 因为(yīnwèi)……没有(méiyǒu)空调(kōngtiáo)?桌子(zhuōzi)很简单(hěnjiǎndān)。我(wǒ)不知道(bùzhīdao)。 Rewrite her answer as a middle-band answer of two or three sentences, using only words she already uses in her oral.

One possible answer: 我(wǒ)觉得(juéde)小贩(xiǎofàn)中心(zhōngxīn)便宜(piányi),因为(yīnwèi)没有(méiyǒu)空调(kōngtiáo),桌子(zhuōzi)也(yě)很简单(hěnjiǎndān),所以(suǒyǐ)老板(lǎobǎn)不用(búyòng)花(huā)很多(hěnduō)钱(qián)。还有(háiyǒu),这里(zhèlǐ)每天(měitiān)有(yǒu)很多(hěnduō)客人(kèrén),老板(lǎobǎn)卖得(màide)很多(hěnduō),所以(suǒyǐ)一(yì)碗饭(wǎnfàn)不用(búyòng)很(hěn)贵(guì)。 It keeps her own reasons (no air conditioning, simple tables), adds 所以(suǒyǐ) to show the result, and adds a second reason. It drops 我(wǒ)不知道(bùzhīdao), which ends an answer before it starts.

The differences between the bands, criterion by criterion

The table sets out what each oral does on each criterion. Read it across a row to see what one criterion rewards at three levels, and down a column to see that a band is usually a pattern across all four criteria rather than one weakness.

Criterion

High (27)

Middle (17)

Low (10)

A Language

10: wide range for the topic (接班(jiēbān), 非(fēi)物质(wùzhì)文化(wénhuà)遗产(yíchǎn)), passives and contrasts in control; rare slips that never block the meaning

6: everyday words in simple sentences; errors from English word order, repeated (吃饭(chīfàn)在(zài)小贩(xiǎofàn)中心(zhōngxīn), 放(fàng)垃圾(lājī)在(zài)); meaning clear

4: short sentences of a few words; frequent errors; one that changes the meaning (买(mǎi) for 卖(mài))

B1 Message: visual stimulus

6: three details interpreted (food, tables, closed stall) and linked to migration, UNESCO, Taiwan and Hong Kong; a personal view to close

3: accurate description at length; links to southern Chinese food and to UNESCO stated, not developed

2: a list of objects; the theme named in the last sentence; one link, to her own wish to visit

B2 Message: conversation

5: claim, reason, example and link in almost every answer; one answer stays general

4: relevant answers, developed when the topic is personal; others stop after a reason

2: fragments and short answers; one real contrast (night market and hawker center)

C Interactive skills: communication

6: narrows a question, checks a word, asks the teacher a question; leads the exchange

4: checks a question, talks around a missing word; some answers need a second question

2: asks for repetition in Chinese; the teacher repairs a meaning; one question to the teacher

Two points stand out from the rows. On criterion A, the bands differ less in how many errors there are than in what the errors do: the high student’s slip never stops the listener, while the low student’s 买(mǎi) for 卖(mài) does. On criteria B2 and C, the bands differ in who carries the conversation. In the high oral the student does; in the low oral the teacher does, question by question.

Each habit these orals show is taught on the other Individual oral pages. One explains what happens in the individual oral and how each criterion is earned. One moves from describing an image to interpreting it and linking it to Chinese-speaking cultures, and one builds the developed answer: claim, reason, example, link. The HL oral, on a literary extract, has three complete orals of its own.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can say what places an oral in the high, middle or low band on each of criteria A, B1, B2 and C.

  • To do:

    I can read a transcript and explain which criterion each comment concerns, and why.

  • To do:

    I can compare three orals at the same moment and name what the stronger answer adds.

  • To do:

    I can turn a detail of an image into a point about its meaning, its theme and a Chinese-speaking place.

  • To do:

    I can develop an answer with a claim, a reason, an example and a link back to the question.

  • To do:

    I can name the Mandarin errors that blur meaning in an oral, such as tones that change the word, and the ones that do not.

  • To do:

    I can name the two or three changes that would lift my own oral to the next band.

Key terms

Each is also in the IB Mandarin B glossary.

Best fit

The way IB work is marked against band descriptions: the marker chooses the band whose description matches the performance most closely as a whole, rather than requiring every point of it to be met.

Mark band

A range of marks within one criterion that shares a single description of performance. A teacher first decides which band's description fits the work, then where within the band the mark falls.

Internal assessment for Mandarin B

Individual oral

  1. 1An HL oral at each bandHL only
  2. 2The individual oral
  3. 3An oral at each bandThis page
  4. 4Presenting a visual stimulus
  5. 5The conversation
  6. 6The HL oral: a literary extractHL only

Carry on with Mandarin B in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.