- Subjects
- English A Lit
- 5 Literary forms
- 5.1 Prose: fiction
5.1 Prose: fiction
How prose fiction works: the narrator, character, plot and time, place and speech, beginnings and endings, and how to read an unseen passage of fiction.
- IB English A: Literature
- Part of 5 Literary forms
- SL and HL
Notes on 5.1 Prose: fiction
Prose fiction is invented narrative told in sentences by a narrator, and its power comes from three things that narrator can do: enter minds, move freely in time and take an attitude toward what it tells. Kate Chopin’s “Regret”, a short story first published in 1895 and set on a farm in Creole Louisiana, shows all three in its first nine paragraphs.
What only fiction can do
The story opens with a description that a portrait painter could give: Mamzelle Aurélie has “a good strong figure, ruddy cheeks” and hair “changing from brown to gray” (paragraph 1). The second paragraph does something no portrait can. “Mamzelle Aurélie had never thought of marrying. She had never been in love” (paragraph 2). These sentences report what has never happened inside a mind, across a whole adult life, in a voice that knows it all and needs no evidence. That voice is the narrator, the teller every work of fiction has, and it is the first thing to identify in any passage of the form.
Access to minds
A narrator can say what a character thinks, feels and fails to notice. In paragraph 9, during “those few contemplative moments”, Aurélie is collecting herself and “determining upon a line of action which should be identical with a line of duty”. A play could show an actor standing still and frowning at four children. Only a narrator can tell the reader what the stillness contains, and add a judgment in the telling: a woman who needs her action to be “identical with” her duty is someone who trusts rules more than impulse.
This access is a choice, and narrators use it unevenly. The narrator of “Regret” enters Aurélie’s mind and Odile’s (Odile feels her husband is “a million miles away”, paragraph 6), but never the children’s. They remain small figures seen from the gallery, “staggering” and “mingling her silent tears” (paragraph 9), so the reader watches them as Aurélie does. Whose mind a story enters, and whose it keeps closed, is one of the first signs of where its interest lies.
Control of time
The second power is the freedom to compress or expand time. One sentence crosses thirty years: “At the age of twenty she had received a proposal, which she had promptly declined, and at the age of fifty she had not yet lived to regret it” (paragraph 2). The story then slows sharply. Odile “had appeared but five minutes before” (paragraph 5), and the last paragraph spends its length on a few moments of looking. A poem can leap across time, but it rarely carries a reader through decades and then stops to watch a chicken step across a porch, as paragraph 8 does.
Where a narrative slows down is where it places its weight. Thirty years of Aurélie’s life take one clause because nothing in them changed her. The arrival of four children takes six paragraphs because something is about to.
A narrator with an attitude
The third power is a voice with a point of view of its own. The phrase “had not yet lived to regret it” belongs to the narrator, not to Aurélie, who regrets nothing. The words not yet are foreshadowing: they suggest that regret may still come, and the story’s title confirms that it will. A narrator can know the end of a story while telling its beginning, and a single adverb can let the reader feel that knowledge.
The narrator’s attitude is often gently comic. The children arrive as if they “might have fallen from the clouds, so unexpected and bewildering was their coming, and so unwelcome” (paragraph 4), and Aurélie surveys them “with arms akimbo” like a farmer judging livestock. The comedy is affectionate. It also sets up the story’s turn, since a woman who meets children as a problem of management has the most to learn from them.
The same narrator speaks from inside a particular society. Paragraph 3 explains how Aurélie is “quite alone in the world” by listing her companions in one sentence: her dog, the Black laborers who live in her cabins, her fowls, cows and mules, her gun and her religion. It names the workers with the word of its time and place, and it sets them among her animals and possessions. The sentence takes the order of a Louisiana farm after slavery for granted, from the owner’s side. The story does not question that order, and noticing what a narrator assumes is part of reading it closely.
Short story, novella and novel
Fiction comes in three main lengths, and length is more than a word count: it decides what a work can hold. “Regret” runs to about 1,500 words. Anton Chekhov’s “The Lady with the Dog” runs to about 6,500 in English, Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness to nearly 40,000, and George Eliot’s Middlemarch to more than 300,000. A reader of each kind expects different things, and each kind trains a different way of reading.
The short story
A short story can be read at one sitting, and its writers have long argued that this is its strength. In 1842 Edgar Allan Poe, reviewing Nathaniel Hawthorne’s tales, described how a skilled writer begins from the effect a story should have and builds every incident toward it:
If wise, he has not fashioned his thoughts to accommodate his incidents; but having conceived, with deliberate care, a certain unique or single effect to be wrought out, he then invents such incidents — he then combines such events as may best aid him in establishing this preconceived effect.
Edgar Allan Poe, review of Hawthorne’s Twice-Told Tales, Graham’s Magazine, May 1842
Poe’s “single effect” explains why short stories are compressed. With room for one situation and a few characters, each detail has to work for the whole. In “Regret” the man’s hat and army overcoat of paragraph 1, the gun of paragraph 3 and the arms “akimbo” of paragraph 4 build one figure. She is a woman who has made herself independent by adopting the habits of a man. The story’s last paragraph, in which Aurélie cries “like a man, with sobs that seemed to tear her very soul”, turns those details against her. The independence was real, and it was also a loss.
Poe’s rule fits his own tales of terror better than it fits every story since. Chekhov’s stories often end on an unresolved question, and Katherine Mansfield’s turn on a small shift of feeling rather than a planned blow. What survives from Poe is the idea of compression: a short story is short by design, and an unseen passage from one is usually close to whole.
The novella and the novel
A novella sits between the two: long enough for a character to develop, short enough to follow one main line of action. Heart of Darkness (1899) follows a single journey up a river, which its narrator Marlow compares to a voyage back to “the earliest beginnings of the world”. Franz Kafka’s The Metamorphosis (1915) follows a single family after one impossible morning. Gabriel García Márquez’s Chronicle of a Death Foretold (1981), often called a novella, circles one murder from many witnesses’ angles in a short book. The form keeps the short story’s intensity and adds the space for consequences.
A novel has room for what the shorter forms must leave out: many characters, several lines of action, and change over years or generations. Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart (1958) takes its title from W. B. Yeats’s line “Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold”, and it needs its length to earn that title. Part One shows Okonkwo’s village as a working society, with its harvests, courts and festivals, before colonial rule arrives in Part Two. A short story could show the arrival; only a novel can make the reader feel what is being lost. The table sets the three kinds side by side.
Short story | Novella | Novel | |
|---|---|---|---|
Typical length (a rough guide) | up to about 10,000 words | about 15,000 to 40,000 words | more than about 40,000 words |
What it holds | one situation, a few characters | one main line of action | many characters and plots |
What it allows | compression; a turn or epiphany | development within one arc | change over time; subplots; a whole society |
Example | “Regret” (Chopin, 1895) | The Metamorphosis (Kafka, 1915) | Things Fall Apart (Achebe, 1958) |
Where fiction came from
Long prose narratives are much older than the word novel. Murasaki Shikibu’s The Tale of Genji, written at the Japanese court in the early eleventh century, follows a prince’s loves and losses across decades and is sometimes called the first novel. In Europe, Miguel de Cervantes’s Don Quixote (1605 and 1615) is the usual starting point. Its hero is a country gentleman who reads tales of knights day and night:
In short, he became so absorbed in his books that he spent his nights from sunset to sunrise, and his days from dawn to dark, poring over them; and what with little sleep and much reading his brains got so dry that he lost his wits.
Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote, Part I (1605), chapter 1, tr. John Ormsby (1885)
He then sets out to live the stories he has read, and the comedy of the novel lies in the collision between those stories and the dusty roads of Spain. The first great European novel is about what reading fiction does to a reader, and it shows the novel’s habit, from the start, of testing invented worlds against real ones.
Early English novels often pretended to be true. Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe (1719) appeared as the life of a castaway “Written by Himself”, with no mention of Defoe. Within a century the novel no longer needed the disguise.

By 1813 Jane Austen’s publisher could print “A Novel” on a title page without apology, as the first edition of Pride and Prejudice shows. The page also records how novels reached readers: in three expensive volumes, often borrowed from circulating libraries, and by an author who did not need to be named. The nineteenth century then made the novel the dominant literary form of Europe. Austen, Honoré de Balzac, Gustave Flaubert, George Eliot and Leo Tolstoy wrote in the tradition later called realism, which set ordinary lives in a recognizable social world.
The short story rose in the same century, with the magazines that paid for it. Poe in the United States, Guy de Maupassant in France and Chekhov in Russia made it an art of its own, and “Regret” itself first appeared in a monthly magazine. In the early twentieth century modernist writers such as James Joyce, Virginia Woolf and Kafka turned fiction inward, toward consciousness and broken time. Since the 1950s the novel has become a global form, written from Lagos, Bogotá, Delhi and Seoul, often in answer to the European novels that once described those places from outside.
The timeline places twelve works of fiction by date and place. Six of them reach English readers in translation, which is how most of the world’s fiction is read in this course.


The narrator at work in fiction
Every passage of fiction raises two questions before any other: who tells the story, and through whose eyes it is seen. The toolkit’s account of narrative voice teaches the terms in full. Fiction puts them to work in a few recurring ways, and each changes what a reader can know, feel and doubt.
Who tells, and from how close
“Regret” is told in the third person by a narrator outside the story, who can enter Aurélie’s mind but keeps a slight, amused distance from it. That combination of person, access and distance is the passage’s point of view. The narrator never says I, never appears, and knows more than Aurélie does, including the meaning of the title.
A novel told in the first person works differently, because its narrator is a character with a stake in the story. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby (1925) opens with its narrator, Nick Carraway, remembering a lesson:
In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I’ve been turning over in my mind ever since.
F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (1925), chapter 1
First-person narration gives the novel memory, confession and judgment from its first sentence: “younger and more vulnerable” already implies an older, wiser teller. It also limits the novel to what Nick saw and chose to tell. Nick claims a few lines later that he is “inclined to reserve all judgements”, and later still that he is “one of the few honest people that I have ever known”. The novel then shows him judging everyone and helping to arrange an affair. The gap between what a narrator claims and what the story shows is the main signal of an unreliable narrator, and fiction is the form that can build a whole work on that gap.
Thought on the page
Fiction’s deepest power is the presentation of thought, and third-person narration can move close enough to borrow a character’s words. In Chekhov’s “The Lady with the Dog”, after Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna first sleep together, the narrator says that she “was touching; there was about her the purity of a good, simple woman who had seen little of life”. No tag says Gurov thought, yet the judgment is his, and so is its slightly patronizing note. This is free indirect discourse: the narrator’s sentence speaking in the character’s idiom. It lets the reader share Gurov’s view and stand a little outside it at once.
Stream of consciousness and interior monologue
Early twentieth-century writers pushed narration further inside the mind. Virginia Woolf’s Mrs Dalloway (1925) follows Clarissa Dalloway through one June day in London as she prepares a party. On the first page she steps out to buy flowers, and the morning air sends her back more than thirty years:
What a lark! What a plunge! For so it had always seemed to her, when, with a little squeak of the hinges, which she could hear now, she had burst open the French windows and plunged at Bourton into the open air.
Virginia Woolf, Mrs Dalloway (1925), opening pages
The sentence begins in a London street and ends at Bourton, the country house of Clarissa’s youth, without announcing the move. The link is an association, not a logic: the hinges of the doors being taken down for the party call up the hinges of the windows at Bourton, and the word plunge joins the two mornings. The phrase “which she could hear now” puts a sound from the past into the present moment, which is how memory feels from inside. Writing that follows a mind in this way, by association rather than by argument, is called stream of consciousness.
Woolf’s sentences still belong to a narrator. They are in the third person and the past tense (“it had always seemed to her”), so the stream reaches the reader through free indirect discourse. James Joyce’s Ulysses (1922) ends with a different method. Its last episode gives the thoughts of Molly Bloom, lying awake in bed, in her own first-person words, with almost no punctuation, for page after page. Its final lines run:
and his heart was going like mad and yes I said yes I will Yes.
James Joyce, Ulysses (1922), last episode
No narrator stands between Molly and the reader, and nothing orders her memories except her own mind. This direct, first-person presentation of thought is interior monologue. The repeated yes works like a breath, and the capital on the last word turns a memory of consent into the novel’s final affirmation.
The distinction matters because the two methods produce different effects. Woolf’s narrator can still move between minds, and in Mrs Dalloway the strokes of Big Ben carry the narration from Clarissa to other Londoners in the same hour (“The leaden circles dissolved in the air”). Joyce’s interior monologue gives no such freedom: it is Molly’s mind or nothing. The short TED-Ed lesson on Woolf shows how her method grew from her view of time and consciousness.
YouTubeTry it
Paragraph 6 of “Regret” says that Odile’s husband “was away in Texas—it seemed to her a million miles away”. Whose words are a million miles away, and how does the narration present them?
The exaggeration is Odile’s, the way a frightened young woman would put it, but it comes inside the narrator’s third-person sentence. The phrase “it seemed to her” marks it as her feeling, so this is reported thought close to free indirect discourse. The effect is sympathy: for one clause the narrator sees the distance as Odile does, before stepping back to call her departure “hasty and convulsive” (paragraph 7).
How character is built
A character in fiction is made of nothing but words, and each word is evidence. The first paragraph of “Regret” gives Aurélie “a good strong figure, ruddy cheeks” and “a determined eye”, then dresses her in “a man’s hat”, “an old blue army overcoat” and “top-boots” (paragraph 1). The first details are told: the narrator names a quality, determination. The clothes are shown, and the reader draws the conclusion that Aurélie has chosen a man’s independence and a man’s working life. Together these are the story’s characterization.
The two methods do different work. Direct characterization, such as “a determined eye”, is quick and carries the narrator’s authority, but it asks the reader to take a judgment on trust. Indirect characterization is slower and makes the reader do the inferring, which is why it persuades. Most fiction uses both, and the balance between them is a choice worth analyzing.
Indirect characterization draws on several kinds of evidence, and the diagram sets out six of them for Aurélie, each with its place in the passage. Two absences are as telling as the evidence. Aurélie speaks no line in the whole opening, while Odile pours out a paragraph of urgent speech, and Aurélie’s companions in paragraph 3 are animals, workers and objects rather than friends.


Speech is often the most revealing evidence, because characters show what they do not intend to. In “The Lady with the Dog” Gurov, a Moscow banker, calls women “the lower race” (part I), a phrase that tells the reader more about his fear of intimacy than about women. His wife characterizes him in one line of her own: “The part of a lady-killer does not suit you at all, Dimitri” (part III). Each character is built partly out of what the others say.
Round and flat characters
The novelist E. M. Forster gave readers a lasting pair of terms in his lectures Aspects of the Novel (1927). Flat characters, he wrote, are “constructed round a single idea or quality”, so that one sentence can sum them up. His example is Mrs Micawber in Charles Dickens’s David Copperfield, who exists to say that she will never desert her husband. Round characters cannot be summed up so neatly, and Forster offered a test for them:
The test of a round character is whether it is capable of surprising in a convincing way. If it never surprises, it is flat.
E. M. Forster, Aspects of the Novel (1927), chapter 4
Aurélie passes this test in the last paragraph of “Regret”. A woman who met the children “with arms akimbo” (paragraph 4) sits alone after they leave and cries “like a man”. The surprise is convincing because the opening prepared it: someone who has never once let herself want anything has the most to lose when she finally does. Gurov is round for the same reason. He expects Anna Sergeyevna to be “shrouded in a mist in his memory” within a month (part III), and is surprised, as the reader is, to find himself in love for the first time.
Forster insisted that flat characters are useful, and that a complex novel often needs them. Valsin, who waits “with the mule-cart” in paragraph 6 of “Regret”, has no inner life at all, and does not need one: he is part of the machinery that takes Odile away. Gurov’s wife, summed up by her eyebrows and her “phonetic spelling”, works as a flat figure of the life Gurov wants to leave. The useful question is why the work makes a character round or flat.
Protagonist and antagonist
The protagonist is the central character whose situation and choices hold the story together: Aurélie in “Regret”, Gurov in “The Lady with the Dog”. The antagonist is whatever opposes the protagonist, and in much modern fiction it is not a villain. “Regret” has no enemy at all. What opposes Aurélie is her own settled way of life, the habit of thirty years that the children briefly break.
In Chekhov’s story the opposing force is a whole society. When the lovers meet in a Moscow hotel in the last part, Anna Sergeyevna weeps at what that society forces on them:
they could only meet in secret, hiding themselves from people, like thieves! Was not their life shattered?
Anton Chekhov, “The Lady with the Dog”, tr. Constance Garnett (1917), part IV
No person stands in the lovers’ way. Their antagonist is the respectable world of marriage, the bank and the club, with its “card-playing” and “gluttony” (part III), which they cannot defeat because they also belong to it. An antagonist of this kind turns a love story into a study of a society.
Some novels do give the antagonist a face. In Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus (2003) the narrator’s father, a devout and violent man admired in public, is the force his daughter must grow beyond, and also the person she loves most.
Plot and story
Every narrative involves two orders: the order in which events happened and the order in which the text tells them. Forster drew the distinction in Aspects of the Novel with two sentences about a royal couple:
“The king died and then the queen died,” is a story. “The king died, and then the queen died of grief” is a plot.
E. M. Forster, Aspects of the Novel (1927), chapter 5
A story, in Forster’s sense, answers the question “and then?”. A plot answers “why?”, because it connects events by cause and arranges them for effect. Two words, of grief, turn a list into a meaning. The same events can be plotted in many ways, and the way a writer chooses is one of the most important decisions in fiction.
“Regret” shows plotting on a small scale. In time order, Odile’s mother falls ill, Odile brings her children to the farm, and Aurélie stands looking at them. The text reverses the order. Paragraph 4 shows Aurélie on her gallery facing children who “might have fallen from the clouds”, and only paragraphs 5 and 6 explain how they came there. The reader meets the children as Aurélie does, as a puzzle, before the cause arrives.
Longer fictions often run a second line of action beside the first. A subplot parallels or contrasts the main plot so that each comments on the other. Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina (1878) opens with a claim about families: “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way” (in Constance Garnett’s translation). Anna’s passion outside her marriage then runs beside Levin’s slow courtship and marriage in the country, and the two plots test the claim against each other. Shakespeare does the same in King Lear, where Gloucester’s blindness to his sons mirrors Lear’s to his daughters.
Order and pace
A plot decides which events to connect, when to tell them and how fast. Two choices shape every narrative: the order of telling, and the speed at which each stretch of story time passes.
Flashback and flash-forward
Paragraph 5 of “Regret” takes a small step back: “The young woman had appeared but five minutes before”. The verb form had appeared marks the move, and paragraph 6 continues it with Odile’s summons to “a neighboring parish” and her husband’s absence in Texas. A move back in time to events before the narrative present is a flashback. Here it is only a few minutes long, but whole novels are built from them, as memory interrupts the present.
A flash-forward moves the other way, telling the reader something the characters do not yet know. García Márquez’s Chronicle of a Death Foretold announces in its title, and again in its first sentence, that its central character will be murdered. The suspense of the book then lies in how and why a whole town let the killing happen. A smaller hint does similar work in “Regret”: Aurélie “had not yet lived to regret it” (paragraph 2), a phrase that points toward an ending the opening does not show.
Scene, summary, pause and ellipsis
The literary theorist Gérard Genette, in Narrative Discourse (1972), described how narratives vary their speed by comparing the time events take with the space the text gives them. That relation is a text’s narrative pace. Four speeds matter most. A scene gives events at roughly the speed they happen, often through dialogue. A summary covers a long time in a few words, as “Regret” does when it crosses from “the age of twenty” to “the age of fifty” in one sentence. A pause stops story time for description or reflection, and an ellipsis skips time altogether.
Chekhov uses all four in “The Lady with the Dog”. Part II opens with an ellipsis, “A week had passed since they had made acquaintance”, skipping the days in which the affair might have been decided. A little later comes one of fiction’s most famous moments of pace:
There was a water-melon on the table. Gurov cut himself a slice and began eating it without haste. There followed at least half an hour of silence.
Anton Chekhov, “The Lady with the Dog”, tr. Constance Garnett (1917), part II
The first two sentences are a scene, told almost at the speed of Gurov’s knife. The third compresses half an hour into nine words. The effect is to put Anna Sergeyevna’s shame and Gurov’s calm side by side without comment: she treats what has happened “as though it were her fall”, and he eats fruit. The understatement in the pace carries the judgment that the narrator never states.
The diagram compares the time the story covers with the text that tells it. Weeks in Yalta and two months in Moscow are told mostly as summary, while one day in Anna Sergeyevna’s provincial town, where Gurov finds her at the theater, receives a large share of part III. The months and years of secret meetings at the end receive almost nothing, and the story stops before any of them is resolved.


Exposition and frames
Most narratives must give the reader some background before the action starts. The first three paragraphs of “Regret” are exposition: Aurélie’s appearance, her refusal of marriage, her solitary household. The fourth begins the action with a phrase that marks the change:
One morning Mamzelle Aurélie stood upon her gallery, contemplating, with arms akimbo, a small band of very small children
Kate Chopin, “Regret”, paragraph 4
“One morning” moves the story from the habitual (what Aurélie always wore, always was) to the single event that will change her. Exposition in a short story must be quick, and Chopin’s takes three short paragraphs. Many modern stories cut it shorter still, beginning in medias res, in the middle of the action, and letting the background arrive in pieces.
Some fictions put a whole story inside another. In Heart of Darkness an unnamed narrator on a boat in the Thames listens to Marlow tell of his voyage up the Congo. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) reaches the reader through an explorer’s letters to his sister, which begin by reassuring her that “no disaster has accompanied the commencement of an enterprise” she feared. This is a frame narrative. The frame decides who hears the story and how far to trust it, and frames that hold several tellers belong to the wider question of multiple perspectives in a single work.
Setting: place that does work
The setting of a narrative is where and when it happens: its places, period, season and social world. In strong fiction it is more than a backdrop and does work of its own, shaping characters, holding meanings and changing the reader’s sense of what is at stake. Thomas Hardy’s The Return of the Native (1878) opens with a whole chapter in which no person appears, only a stretch of heath in southern England at dusk:
A Saturday afternoon in November was approaching the time of twilight, and the vast tract of unenclosed wild known as Egdon Heath embrowned itself moment by moment.
Thomas Hardy, The Return of the Native (1878), book 1, chapter 1
The verb carries the sentence. Egdon Heath “embrowned itself”, as if darkening were something it did on purpose, and “moment by moment” slows the reader to the heath’s own pace. A place given an action and a will of its own becomes a presence. Hardy’s characters later struggle to escape the heath or to love it, and the opening has already made it older and stronger than any of them.
A setting can also hold a novel’s central mystery. In E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India (1924) an English visitor enters one of the Marabar Caves, which return every sound as the same dull echo, and comes out claiming to have been attacked. The novel never says what happened inside. The caves become the place where the English and Indian characters’ understanding of each other breaks down, and the setting holds the question the plot refuses to answer.
Setting and mood
On a smaller scale, setting builds the mood of a scene, its atmosphere. When Odile leaves in paragraph 8 of “Regret”, the narrator turns from the people to the place: the “white sunlight was beating in on the white old boards”, there is “a pleasant odor of pinks in the air”, and one chicken walks across the gallery “heavily, solemnly, and aimlessly”. The heat and brightness press on the crowded porch, and the chicken’s solemn aimlessness mirrors the human scene with gentle comedy. Aurélie is about to be just as solemn and just as lost.
The story’s last paragraph changes the light. After the children leave, “the red sunset and the blue-gray twilight had together flung a purple mist across the fields”, and the shadows are “creeping and deepening” around Aurélie’s “solitary figure”. The same gallery, in a different light, now holds loss. Placing the two moments side by side shows how far a setting can carry a change of feeling that the narrator never names.
Chekhov uses setting to set two worlds against each other. Yalta has a sea “of a soft warm lilac hue” with “a golden streak from the moon” (part I). In Anna Sergeyevna’s provincial town Gurov finds her house faced by “a long grey fence adorned with nails” and thinks, “One would run away from a fence like that” (part III). The fence is real, but it also works as an image of her marriage, and gray returns in the hotel room, the blanket and finally Gurov’s own hair.
Dialogue: what speech shows and hides
Dialogue lets characters speak in their own voices, and a narrator can set those voices against its own. In paragraph 7 of “Regret” Odile speaks in the Creole English of rural Louisiana, mixed with French. “Dieu sait, I would n’ botha you with ’em if it was any otha way to do!” Her sentences pile clause on clause, joined by “an’”, until her fear about her mother bursts out at the end. The narrator then sums up the same fear in its own formal diction: “a harrowing possibility which drove Odile to take a final hasty and convulsive leave”. The distance between the two voices is comic, and it also shows how far the narrator stands from the frightened young mother.
Dialogue is often most revealing where it fails. In part III of “The Lady with the Dog” Gurov, back in Moscow and unable to forget Anna Sergeyevna, at last tells an acquaintance about her as they leave a club late at night:
“If only you knew what a fascinating woman I made the acquaintance of in Yalta!”
The official got into his sledge and was driving away, but turned suddenly and shouted:
“Dmitri Dmitritch!”
“What?”
“You were right this evening: the sturgeon was a bit too strong!”Anton Chekhov, “The Lady with the Dog”, tr. Constance Garnett (1917), part III
Gurov offers the most important feeling of his life, and the answer is about fish. The official is not cruel; he simply did not hear. The exchange shows, without any comment from the narrator, the world in which Gurov has no one to talk to, and it sends him to find Anna Sergeyevna. The narrator adds only that the words “for some reason” moved Gurov to indignation, leaving the reader to supply the reason.
Tags and silences
How dialogue is presented is also a choice. A tag such as “she said, and blushed” lets the narrator add a gesture or a judgment to the words. Untagged dialogue, line after line, removes the narrator and leaves the reader to work out who speaks and what they mean. Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” (1927) builds a whole story from a couple’s untagged talk around an operation that neither of them names.
Silence counts too. Aurélie speaks no line of dialogue in the opening of “Regret”, while Odile, the children and the narrator fill the space around her. When she finally speaks to her cook a few pages later, it is to complain that she would rather manage “a dozen plantation’” than four children. A character who does not speak is still characterized, by the speech of others around her.
Try it
Reread the sturgeon exchange. Why does Chekhov make the official drive off and then turn back to shout, instead of answering at once?
The delay builds a moment of expectation. Gurov, and the reader, assume the official has been thinking about what Gurov said and will answer it. The answer then lands on the sturgeon, and the gap between the expectation and the remark makes the indifference sharper. The structure of the exchange does the work that a narrator’s comment would otherwise do.
Openings and endings
The first sentence of a work of fiction sets up a voice and a question. Woolf’s Mrs Dalloway begins: “Mrs. Dalloway said she would buy the flowers herself.” The reader learns at once that there is a party, that there are servants, and that Clarissa has chosen to do something herself, which raises the question of why it matters. Chekhov’s story begins with gossip: “It was said that a new person had appeared on the sea-front: a lady with a little dog.” The passive “It was said” places the reader among the idle crowd of a resort, and the woman arrives without a name, only as the label the crowd gives her. The story will be about what lies behind that label.
Endings close what openings start, or deliberately leave it open. Many stories end on a change in a character’s understanding rather than a change in events. Joyce’s Dubliners (1914) gathers fifteen stories of this kind. In “Araby” a boy goes to a bazaar at night to buy a present for a girl he worships, arrives as the stalls are closing, and hears a shop girl flirting with two young men. The story ends:
Gazing up into the darkness I saw myself as a creature driven and derided by vanity; and my eyes burned with anguish and anger.
James Joyce, “Araby”, Dubliners (1914), last sentence
Nothing happens in the outward story: the only person who speaks to the boy does so out of duty, and he buys nothing. The event is entirely inside him. He sees his romantic quest as the vanity it was, and the diction of the sentence, “driven and derided”, belongs to the older narrator looking back on his younger self. A sudden moment of insight of this kind, set off by something small, is an epiphany. Joyce took the word from the Christian feast that celebrates a revelation and gave it its literary sense.
An epiphany closes a story even when nothing is settled, because the character’s understanding is complete. An open ending works the other way: the change may be complete, but the situation is not. Chekhov’s story has one of the best-known open endings in fiction, and it shows how much a short story can hold.
Case study: “The Lady with the Dog”
Chekhov published “The Lady with the Dog” in 1899, and Constance Garnett’s English translation appeared in 1917. Dmitri Gurov, a Moscow banker under forty, unhappily married and habitually unfaithful, meets Anna Sergeyevna, a young wife from a provincial town, at the Black Sea resort of Yalta. They have an affair; she returns home; he goes back to Moscow expecting to forget her within a month. He cannot. He travels to her town, finds her at the theater, and from then on she visits him secretly in Moscow. The story follows one man from cynicism to love in four short parts.
An arc told through images
Gurov begins as a man who calls women “the lower race” (part I) and treats the affair as a holiday diversion. His change is never announced by the narrator in a single statement. It arrives through images and small scenes: the memories that “glowed more and more vividly” in the Moscow winter, the sturgeon that disgusts him, the gray fence he would run away from. In the last part, as he comforts Anna Sergeyevna in a hotel room, he catches sight of himself:
He went up to her and took her by the shoulders to say something affectionate and cheering, and at that moment he saw himself in the looking-glass. His hair was already beginning to turn grey.
Anton Chekhov, “The Lady with the Dog”, tr. Constance Garnett (1917), part IV
The mirror shows Gurov an aging man at the moment he feels most alive, and the narrator’s next sentences follow his thought: he has known many women and “never once loved”. Only now, “when his head was grey”, has he fallen in love. The arc of a whole life is completed in the time it takes to glance into a mirror, and the image of graying hair carries both the late arrival of love and the shortness of the time left for it.
Understatement and the narrator’s restraint
Chekhov’s narrator judges little. The watermelon scene in part II sets Gurov’s calm beside Anna Sergeyevna’s shame and leaves the comparison to the reader. At Oreanda, at dawn, the lovers sit looking at the sea, and “A man walked up to them—probably a keeper—looked at them and walked away”; the narrator adds only that “this detail seemed mysterious and beautiful, too”. The story says much less than its situations warrant, and this understatement is the source of its power. A reader who is told nothing about what to feel must notice the details that carry the feeling.
The restraint extends to morality. The story never condemns the adultery and never excuses it. Gurov reflects that he has “two lives”, one open and false, the other secret and true (part IV), and the story lets that paradox stand. A reader may judge the lovers harshly; the narrator declines to do it for them.
The open ending
The final scene leaves the lovers trying to plan a future that their society forbids. Its last sentence is famous for what it refuses:
And it seemed as though in a little while the solution would be found, and then a new and splendid life would begin; and it was clear to both of them that they had still a long, long road before them, and that the most complicated and difficult part of it was only just beginning.
Anton Chekhov, “The Lady with the Dog”, tr. Constance Garnett (1917), last sentence
The sentence turns on its semicolon. Before it, the lovers’ hope, softened by “it seemed as though”; after it, the clear knowledge that nothing is solved. A conventional love story would end with a marriage, a death or a parting. This one ends where such a story would reach its crisis, with “the most complicated and difficult part” still ahead. The question of what the lovers will do is left open, but Gurov’s transformation is complete: the cynic of part I could not have felt the difficulty at all.
Reading a story in translation
Every quotation from the story is Garnett’s English, not Chekhov’s Russian. Her title, “The Lady with the Dog”, is one choice among several: the Russian title uses a diminutive for the dog, and some later translators call the story “The Lady with the Little Dog”. Analysis of a translated work rests most safely on what survives translation: structure, pace, image, the arc of a character and the shape of an ending. Claims about a single word are claims about the translator’s word, and they are stronger when a second translation agrees.
The extract and its whole
Most passages of fiction read closely are extracts: a few hundred words cut from a story or a novel. An extract is chosen because it can stand alone for a while, so it usually begins and ends at a natural break, such as the start of a chapter, a change of scene or a decision. The opening of “Regret” ends on such a break:
During those few contemplative moments she was collecting herself, determining upon a line of action which should be identical with a line of duty. She began by feeding them.
Kate Chopin, “Regret”, paragraph 9
The last sentence, “She began by feeding them”, is short and practical after a long, Latinate one, and the contrast is comic: all that contemplation produces the most obvious first step. It is also a turn. The exposition and the arrival are over, and the story of what the children do to Aurélie is about to begin. The extract stops at the moment when the question it has raised (how will this woman cope?) is fully posed and not yet answered.
Reading an extract means asking what it shows of three things in the whole work. It shows a voice, which will usually stay the same: Chopin’s amused, knowing narrator. It shows a character at one point of an arc: Aurélie before any change. And it shows a piece of a structure: here the opening of a story whose title promises a later reversal. A reader who has not seen the rest can still read the signs of it, and the phrase “not yet lived to regret it” is the strongest of them. What the extract does not show, a reading of it should not claim.
Reading an unseen passage of fiction
An unseen passage arrives without its title’s promise explained, without the rest of the story and without notes. The reading that follows takes the opening of “Regret” from a first impression to an argued interpretation, in the order an experienced reader usually asks the questions.
First impressions
A first reading of the passage leaves a clear impression of a comic situation. A tough, solitary farmer is suddenly put in charge of four small children who “might have fallen from the clouds” (paragraph 4), and she is out of her depth. The tone is light, the narrator is amused, and the passage ends on a sensible decision. A first impression is worth writing down in a sentence, because the analysis that follows will either support it or show where it was too simple.
Who tells, and from how close
The second question is about the narrator. This one is outside the story, in the third person, and knows Aurélie’s past and her mind. It is close enough to report her calculations (“determining upon a line of action”) but never shares her feelings from inside. Its diction is formal and slightly elevated (“contemplating, with arms akimbo”, “irresolute steps”, “disconsolate family”), and that formality applied to a crowd of crying children is the source of much of the comedy. The narrator’s distance, then, is part of the passage’s meaning: it lets the reader smile at Aurélie as the narrator does.
What changes across the passage
The third question is what moves. The passage begins with Aurélie as a settled figure, described in habitual verbs (“She wore a man’s hat about the farm”, paragraph 1). It ends with her “collecting herself” and choosing “a line of action” (paragraph 9). In between, her world is invaded: four children, a weeping mother, a mule-cart, a crowd on the porch. The change is small but real. For the first time in the passage Aurélie must decide something, and her habit of duty is what she decides with.
The detail that holds it
The fourth question looks for the word or detail that carries the most. In this passage the strongest candidate is the phrase in paragraph 2:
At the age of twenty she had received a proposal, which she had promptly declined, and at the age of fifty she had not yet lived to regret it.
Kate Chopin, “Regret”, paragraph 2
Everything in the sentence is brisk and confident (“promptly declined”) until the last clause, where not yet opens the possibility that regret is coming. Read with the title, it turns the comedy of the passage into the first stage of a reckoning. The detail also changes how the reader sees paragraph 3, where Aurélie’s companions are listed. A woman “quite alone in the world” except for a dog, her workers, her animals, a gun and her religion has built a self-sufficient life, and has also left something out of it.
From observations to a thesis
The last step is to turn these observations into a claim that explains the passage as a whole. Each observation so far points the same way: the comedy is real, but it rests on a woman whose independence has a cost she has not yet counted. A thesis of two sentences can say exactly that and name the choices that carry it. In the opening of “Regret”, Chopin’s amused narrator presents Aurélie’s self-sufficiency as both admirable and incomplete. The phrase “not yet lived to regret it” turns a comic scene of a farmer facing four children into the first step toward a loss. Every paragraph of an essay on the passage would then test one part of that sentence against the text.
The order of the questions matters more than any list of features. Who tells, what changes, which detail holds it, and what claim explains it: asked in that order, the questions keep a reading on the passage’s meaning and stop it from becoming a tour of features.
Where fiction’s edges blur
The boundaries of prose fiction have never been firm. Robinson Crusoe claimed to be true, and its preface presented an “Editor” who vouched for it:
The Editor believes the thing to be a just History of Fact; neither is there any Appearance of Fiction in it
Daniel Defoe, Robinson Crusoe (London, 1719), Preface
The claim was itself a fiction, since Crusoe never existed. Novels have borrowed the authority of fact ever since, and writers of fact have borrowed the methods of the novel. Truman Capote called In Cold Blood (1966), his account of a real murder in Kansas, a “nonfiction novel”: every event is documented, but the book is built from scenes, dialogue and shifting points of view like a novel. Readers who meet such a work have to decide which contract they are reading under, the novel’s or the reporter’s.
Other edges blur in other directions. The French writer Serge Doubrovsky coined the term autofiction in 1977 for a novel so close to its writer’s own life that the line between memoir and novel disappears. Karl Ove Knausgaard’s six-volume My Struggle (2009–2011) is a well-known example. The prose poem keeps the compression of poetry without its lines. The graphic novel tells its story in panels of image and word, and schools classify graphic works as fiction or non-fiction case by case. In each case the useful question is the same as for any work: what does this form let the writer do that a purer form would not?
Writing about prose fiction
A strong paragraph on a passage of fiction keeps the narrator in view. It treats every detail as something the narration chooses to show, in a particular voice and order, and it links each detail to a claim about the passage as a whole. The paragraph that follows was written by a student on the opening of “Regret”, with notes on what each sentence does.
Chopin’s narrator presents Aurélie’s independence with affectionate irony. She is first seen in “a man’s hat” and “an old blue army overcoat” (paragraph 1), clothes that announce a woman who has taken a man’s freedom for herself.note 1 The narrator’s formal diction then turns her first meeting with the children into comedy: she surveys them “with the same calculating air” she might turn on a market, and answers their tears by choosing a line of action “identical with a line of duty” (paragraph 9).note 2 The irony stays gentle because the narrator has already hinted at a cost. At fifty she has “not yet lived to regret” refusing marriage (paragraph 2), and not yet suggests that these children may show her what she has done without.note 3
Evidence from appearance. The student reads clothes as indirect characterization and says what they announce, rather than listing them.
The narrator as subject. The sentence analyzes the voice of the telling (its formal diction) and explains the comic effect of applying it to crying children.
Detail linked to the whole. The last sentences connect one adverb to the passage’s direction and to the title, which is what turns observations into an interpretation.
The commonest weakness in writing about fiction is retelling. A paragraph that follows the events in order can be accurate and still analyze nothing, because it describes what happens instead of how the telling shapes it. The two versions that follow are about the same moment in the passage.
Weak: In this passage Aurélie is a strong woman who lives alone on her farm. Then Odile arrives with her four children and leaves them with her.note 1 Chopin uses characterization and setting, which creates a sense of tension.note 2 Then she decides to feed them.
Strong: The passage measures Aurélie’s self-sufficiency against four small children, and the narrator’s formal diction makes the contest comic.note 3 A woman who meets them “with arms akimbo” (paragraph 4) answers their tears with a plan, and the short last sentence, “She began by feeding them”, shows how much contemplation it took to reach the obvious.note 4
Plot summary. Every clause reports an event in the order the story gives it. Nothing explains a choice the writer made.
Labels without effect. “Characterization and setting” could describe any story, and “creates a sense of tension” names no words and no tension.
A claim first. The strong version opens with an interpretation of the scene and names the choice (the narrator’s diction) that produces it.
Quotation doing work. Each quotation is embedded and explained: the gesture shows Aurélie’s stance, and the length of the last sentence becomes evidence of the comedy.
The strong version uses fewer events and more words of the text. It quotes only what it explains, and it explains something a reader could disagree with, which is what makes it an argument rather than a report.
Applying it in Paper 1
Paper 1 sets two unseen passages of different literary forms, each with a guiding question, and prose fiction often appears among them. A guiding question on a fiction passage usually directs attention to one of the building blocks: the narrator’s perspective, the presentation of a character, the role of setting, or a change across the passage. For the opening of “Regret”, a question might ask how the narrator’s perspective shapes the presentation of Aurélie, or how the arrival of the children is presented as a turning point.
Either question can be answered with the thesis built in the worked reading, because that thesis already names the narrator, the character and the change. A body paragraph might then open: “The narrator’s formal, slightly elevated diction is the first source of the passage’s comedy, and it keeps the reader at the same amused distance from Aurélie that the narrator keeps.” The paragraph would go on to quote and explain two or three phrases, and end by connecting them to the hint of regret in paragraph 2.
Marks in a fiction essay are most often lost by retelling. An essay that walks through the passage paragraph by paragraph, reporting what happens, shows understanding of the events but analyzes no choices. The remedy is the order of the worked reading: narrator first, then change, then the key detail, then the claim.
The narrator at the center of every fiction passage is studied in full in the toolkit chapter on narrative voice and point of view. Prose non-fiction takes the same methods of telling, scene and character into texts that claim to be true, and asks what changes when the “I” is a real person.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain three things prose fiction can do that poetry and drama cannot, with an example of each from a passage.
- To do:
I can distinguish the short story, the novella and the novel, and say what each length allows.
- To do:
I can distinguish free indirect discourse, stream of consciousness and interior monologue on a quoted sentence.
- To do:
I can analyze how a character is built from direct and indirect evidence, and say whether it is round or flat and why.
- To do:
I can explain the difference between story and plot and analyze order and pace (flashback, scene, summary, pause, ellipsis) in a passage.
- To do:
I can analyze what setting and dialogue contribute to a passage, including what dialogue leaves unsaid.
- To do:
I can read an unseen extract from first impressions to a thesis, asking who tells, what changes and which detail matters most.
- To do:
I can write a paragraph on a fiction passage that analyzes the telling rather than retelling the events.
Key terms
Each is also in the Literary forms glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Antagonist
The character, group or force that opposes the protagonist. It can be a person, a society, a set of conventions or a part of the protagonist's own nature.
- Characterization
The ways a writer builds a character. Direct characterization tells the reader what a character is like; indirect characterization lets the reader infer it from speech, action, appearance, thought, other characters' reactions and surroundings.
- Epiphany
A sudden moment of insight in which a character sees the truth about a situation or about themselves, often set off by a small outward event. James Joyce gave the word its literary sense.
- Exposition
The material, usually near the start of a narrative, that sets out the situation, the characters and the background the reader needs to follow the action.
- Flash-forward
A move ahead in time to events that happen after the narrative present, telling the reader in advance something the characters do not yet know.
- Flashback
A move back in time to events that happened before the narrative present, after which the narrative usually returns to where it was.
- Frame narrative
A narrative that contains another narrative: an outer story, often of someone telling or finding a tale, encloses an inner story that makes up most of the work.
- Interior monologue
A character's thoughts given directly in the first person and usually the present tense, as if overheard, with no narrator reporting them.
- Narrative pace
The relation between how long events take in the story and how much text is given to them. Summary covers a long time in a few words, scene gives events at about the speed they happen, a pause stops time for description, and an ellipsis skips time altogether.
- Novel
A long work of prose fiction, usually of tens of thousands of words or more. Its length gives room for many characters, several lines of action and change over a long stretch of time.
- Novella
A work of prose fiction longer than a short story and shorter than a novel, usually following one main line of action through a limited group of characters.
- Open ending
An ending that leaves the central question of a narrative unresolved, so that the reader must judge what follows or what the outcome means.
- Plot
The events of a narrative as the text arranges and connects them, by cause as well as by time. The plot is distinct from the story, which is the same events in the order in which they happened.
- Prose fiction
Invented narrative written in sentences and paragraphs rather than in lines of verse, told by a narrator: the form of the novel, the novella and the short story.
- Protagonist
The central character of a narrative or play, whose situation, aims and choices drive the action and hold the reader's attention.
- Round character
A complex character who can change and can surprise the reader convincingly, as opposed to the flat character, who is built around a single idea or quality and stays the same. Forster’s lectures on the novel (1927) gave the pair of terms its use.
- Setting
Where and when a narrative takes place: its places, period, season, time of day and social world. In fiction a setting often does work of its own, shaping characters, mood and meaning.
- Short story
A brief work of prose fiction that can be read at one sitting. It usually centers on one situation and a few characters, and it relies on compression, so that each detail carries more weight than it would in a novel.
- Stream of consciousness
Writing that follows the continuous, unordered flow of a mind: perceptions, memories, feelings and half-formed thoughts as they arrive, joined by association rather than by logic.
- Subplot
A secondary line of action running beside the main plot, often with other characters. It usually parallels or contrasts the main plot, so that each throws light on the other.
Practice questions on 5.1 Prose: fiction
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 46 questions on 5.1 Prose: fiction
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
More in 5 Literary forms
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 5.1Prose: fictionThis page
- 5.2Prose: non-fiction
- 5.3Poetry
- 5.4Drama
Carry on with 5.1 Prose: fiction in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.