5.3 Poetry

How poems use the line, compression and pattern, how the set forms from the sonnet to the ghazal work as choices, and how to read an unseen poem closely, from a first reading to an argued thesis.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 5 Literary forms
  • SL and HL

39 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 5.3 Poetry

Poetry is writing in lines. The line is the one thing every poem has and no other form needs. It lets a poet decide where a reader pauses, which word waits at the edge of silence, and how much meaning a few syllables must carry. Shakespeare’s Sonnet 64, first printed in 1609, uses fourteen lines to think about time, ruin and love.

Sonnet 64 (“When I have seen by Time’s fell hand defaced”)Shakespeare’s Sonnets, 1609William Shakespeare, Sonnet 64, The Sonnets of Shakespeare, ed. H. C. Beeching (Boston and London: Ginn & Company, 1904)
When I have seen by Time’s fell hand defaced
The rich proud cost of outworn buried age;
When sometime lofty towers I see down-razed
And brass eternal slave to mortal rage;
When I have seen the hungry ocean gain
Advantage on the kingdom of the shore,
And the firm soil win of the watery main,
Increasing store with loss and loss with store;
When I have seen such interchange of state,
Or state itself confounded to decay;
Ruin hath taught me thus to ruminate,
That Time will come and take my love away.
This thought is as a death, which cannot choose
But weep to have that which it fears to lose.

What a poem can do that prose cannot

Sonnet 64 is one long sentence that does not reach its main clause until line 11. Lines 1 to 10 are a chain of clauses that begin “When I have seen” (lines 1, 5 and 9) or “When sometime lofty towers I see” (line 3), and each one holds back the point. The delay is the experience of the poem: a mind collects evidence of ruin, case after case, before it lets itself draw the conclusion that “Time will come and take my love away” (line 12).

Prose can make the same argument, but it cannot make the same pauses. Each line of the sonnet is a unit of attention, and most of them end on a word that carries weight: “defaced”, “age”, “down-razed”, “rage”. The line ending gives each word a moment of silence after it, so the poem lands on images of damage four times before line 4 is over. A prose sentence would hurry past them.

Compression

Compression is the second power: a poem says more in fewer words than prose usually does. Line 8, “Increasing store with loss and loss with store”, describes the sea and the land trading ground for centuries, and it does it in eight words that turn back on themselves. The second half reverses the first, a pattern called chiasmus, so the line enacts the endless exchange it describes. A paraphrase needs a whole sentence: the sea gains land in one place and loses it in another, so neither side ever wins for long. Even then it loses the sense that the exchange goes round and round.

Compression is why poems reward slow reading. Line 4 calls bronze monuments “brass eternal slave to mortal rage”, and the phrase holds a paradox: what was made to last forever becomes the servant of what dies. Eternal and mortal sit at either end of the line, with slave between them, so the line’s word order acts out the defeat of permanence.

Pattern

Finally, a poem is patterned in sound and shape, and the pattern can be seen and heard at once. Sonnet 64 rhymes in alternate lines and, like almost all of Shakespeare’s 154 sonnets, ends with an indented pair of lines that rhyme with each other. The indent marks those two lines as different before a word of them is read. The poem’s argument does change there: after twelve lines of watching the world decay, the poem turns from what has been seen to what it feels like to have seen it.

Sonnet 64 is a lyric poem: a short poem in which one voice thinks or feels its way through a moment. Most poems studied closely are lyrics, but poetry also includes narrative poems, which tell stories in verse, and dramatic poems, in which a character speaks. All three kinds share the line.

The line, compression and pattern are the building blocks of every poem. Each of the set forms of poetry combines them in its own way, so choosing a form is choosing how a poem will think.

The speaker and the person addressed

The voice of a lyric poem is its speaker, and the speaker is not simply the poet. In Sonnet 64 the “I” has watched towers fall and seas take land, but nothing in the poem asks the reader to check those claims against Shakespeare’s life. The poem builds a voice for the length of fourteen lines, and that voice is what a reader analyzes. When biography matters, it matters as context, never as a substitute for the words.

Walt Whitman made this distinction visible in the first edition of Leaves of Grass (1855). The book printed no author’s name on its title page. Instead it opened with an engraving of a bearded man in shirtsleeves, hat tilted, one hand on his hip. The long first poem then began by announcing an “I” who celebrates himself. The portrait introduced the speaker as a type (a workman, an ordinary American) as much as it showed the poet.

A steel engraving of a bearded man in a wide-brimmed hat and an open-necked work shirt, one hand on his hip, the other in his pocket, standing at ease.
The frontispiece of the first edition of Leaves of Grass (1855), where a portrait stood in for the author’s name. Walt Whitman, steel engraving by Samuel Hollyer after a daguerreotype by Gabriel Harrison, July 1854. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The engraving shows how a book can present a speaker before a word is read. Readers who met the casual figure in the open shirt expected a voice of the street rather than of the study, and the poems supplied one. The man in the picture and the “I” of the poems were made to match.

The addressee and apostrophe

A lyric is spoken to someone, even when no listener is named. Sonnet 64 seems to speak to no one in particular, but many of Shakespeare’s sonnets address a “thou”, a beloved who never answers. The person or thing a poem speaks to is its addressee, and the choice of addressee shapes its tone: a poem spoken to a lover is intimate, a poem spoken to the public is ceremonial.

When a speaker addresses someone or something that cannot reply, the poem uses apostrophe. John Donne’s Holy Sonnet on death, first printed in 1633, opens by talking down to death itself:

Death be not proud, though some have called thee
Mighty and dreadfull, for, thou art not soe,

John Donne, Holy Sonnet X, Poems (1633), lines 1–2, in The Poems of John Donne, ed. H. J. C. Grierson (1912)

By speaking to death as thee, the speaker makes it a person who can be argued with, and an argument can be won. The poem goes on to list what death depends on (“Fate, Chance, kings, and desperate men”, line 9) and ends by declaring that “death, thou shalt die” (line 14). Apostrophe gives the speaker a power over death that a statement about death could not give: he can scold it to its face.

Apostrophe can just as easily expose weakness. In John Keats’s “Ode to a Nightingale” (1819) the speaker calls to the bird, “Thou wast not born for death, immortal Bird!” (line 61), but the bird keeps singing without hearing him. At the end of the poem the music fades and he is left asking “Do I wake or sleep?” (line 80). Donne’s address subdues death; Keats’s shows how far the speaker is from what he loves.

The line and the line break

Because a poem is made of lines, every line ends somewhere, and where it ends is a choice. In Sonnet 64 almost every line is end-stopped: it closes with a comma or semicolon where the voice would pause anyway. The effect is measured and formal, the sound of a mind laying out its cases one by one. A poem in a different mood can break its lines against the grain of its sentences, and the break then does a different job.

Isaac Rosenberg wrote “Break of Day in the Trenches” in France in 1916, two years before he was killed in action; it was printed in his Poems in 1922. Near its end the speaker thinks about the poppies that grow on the battlefield:

Poppies whose roots are in man’s veins
Drop, and are ever dropping;
But mine in my ear is safe,
Just a little white with the dust.

Isaac Rosenberg, “Break of Day in the Trenches”, lines 24–27

The first line runs on into the second without a pause: the sentence is unfinished when the line ends. This is enjambment, and here it holds the verb back. The line about roots in men’s veins hangs for a moment with no action, and then “Drop” arrives alone at the start of the next line, followed by a comma. The break makes the falling happen at the edge of the line, and the comma after “Drop” is a caesura, a pause inside the line that lets the word sink before “ever dropping” repeats it.

The last two lines turn from the many poppies to one. “But mine in my ear is safe” is short, plain and end-stopped, and its calm sounds almost false after the image of flowers rooted in the dead. The final line adds a small qualification that undoes the calm: even the safe poppy is “a little white with the dust”. Line by line, the poem moves from the general slaughter to the speaker’s own body, and the dust places him inside it.

Prose has sentences and paragraphs; only verse has this third unit, the line, which can agree with the sentence or work against it. Enjambment, end-stopping and the caesura are taught in full in the toolkit chapter on structure. In a poem they matter because they control pace and emphasis. A line break can stress the word before it or delay the word after it. It can also make a phrase mean two things for a moment, until the next line settles it.

The stanza and the shapes of verse

Lines group into stanzas, the paragraphs of verse, separated on the page by white space. A stanza can be any length, but a few lengths recur so often that they have names, and each tends to do certain things. The shortest named unit is the couplet. Alexander Pope’s An Essay on Criticism (1711) is written entirely in couplets, and most of them close their sense within the pair:

True ease in writing comes from art, not chance,
As those move easiest who have learned to dance

Alexander Pope, An Essay on Criticism (1711), lines 362–363

Each line is a pentameter, and the pair rhymes and completes a thought, which makes this a heroic couplet. The form suits argument and wit: the first line makes a claim, the second gives an example, and the rhyme snaps them together. Chance and dance even sum up the claim, since the poet’s ease, like the dancer’s, only looks like chance. Pope and his contemporaries used the heroic couplet for satire and philosophy because it makes every point sound settled.

Quatrains, tercets and longer stanzas

The four-line quatrain is the most common stanza in English. It is long enough to state and develop a thought and short enough to keep a song’s pace, which is why songs and hymns use it. Three-line stanzas, or tercets, feel less settled, since an odd number of lines leaves one unpaired; Dante’s Divine Comedy (early fourteenth century) links its tercets by rhyme into a chain that pulls the reader forward. Longer stanzas let a poet build a paragraph of thought, as the ten-line stanzas of Keats’s odes do.

Unit

Lines

What it tends to do

Example

Couplet

2

Closes a thought; makes a point sound final or witty

Pope’s heroic couplets; the end of a Shakespearean sonnet

Tercet

3

Feels open and moving; links forward

Dante’s terza rima

Quatrain

4

States and develops a thought at a song’s pace

The ballad stanza; the Shakespearean sonnet’s first twelve lines

Sestet

6

Responds to or resolves what came before

The end of a Petrarchan sonnet

Octave

8

Sets out a situation, problem or question

The opening of a Petrarchan sonnet

The table gives tendencies, not rules. A couplet in a poem of quatrains stands out because it breaks the pattern, and a stanza break can come in the middle of a sentence to create suspense. What a stanza does always depends on the stanzas around it.

The turn

Many poems change direction once, and the place where they change is the key to their structure. In Sonnet 64 the change comes at line 11: “Ruin hath taught me thus to ruminate”. After ten lines of things seen in the world, the speaker turns inward and applies the lesson to his own love. The turn is marked by a change of grammar (the main clause finally arrives), a change of subject (from towers and oceans to “my love”) and a change of tone, from observation to dread.

This change of direction is the volta, Italian for “turn”. It is most famous in the sonnet, but almost every lyric has one. John Milton’s sonnet on his blindness, written in the 1650s and printed in 1673, places its turn unusually early, in the middle of line 8:

Doth God exact day-labour, light deny’d,
I fondly ask; But patience to prevent
That murmur, soon replies, God doth not need

John Milton, “When I consider how my light is spent”, Poems (1673), lines 7–9

The speaker’s complaint runs for seven and a half lines, and then “But patience” interrupts it before the octave has finished. The early turn acts out its meaning: patience cuts off the “murmur” before it can grow into a full grievance. The sestet then belongs to patience, which answers calmly and ends on the line “They also serve who only stand and waite” (line 14).

Turns are signaled in a few recurring ways. Words such as but, yet, now and then often mark them, as do a change of tense, a change of addressee, a question that is finally answered, or a shift from description to reflection. A reader who finds the turn has found the poem’s structure in two parts, and can ask what changes across it and why.

Try it

Find the turn in Rosenberg’s lines 24–27. What marks it, and what changes across it?

The turn comes at “But mine in my ear is safe” (line 26). It is marked by But, by a change from the plural poppies to the speaker’s single poppy, and by a change from long, run-on lines to short, end-stopped ones. Across it the poem moves from the dead in general to the speaker himself, and the calm of “safe” is then qualified by the dust of line 27.

The sonnet

A sonnet is a poem of fourteen lines built around a turn. The form came into English from Italian, where Francesco Petrarch had made it the vehicle of love poetry in the fourteenth century; Thomas Wyatt and the Earl of Surrey adapted it in the 1530s and 1540s. In English it has two main shapes, and each shape leads the thought in its own direction.

The Petrarchan sonnet divides into an octave rhyming abbaabba and a sestet, usually cdecde or cdcdcd. Its first eight lines set out a situation or problem and its last six respond, so its natural movement is question and answer, or tension and release. Milton’s sonnet on his blindness follows this shape, though it moves the turn half a line early. English has fewer rhymes than Italian, so a poet who keeps four a rhymes and four b rhymes is showing skill and sometimes strain.

The Shakespearean sonnet uses three quatrains and a couplet, rhyming abab cdcd efef gg. Its argument usually advances in three steps and then turns, sums up or undercuts itself in the last two lines. Sonnet 64 follows this pattern, although its turn comes at line 11, before the couplet. The diagram sets the two shapes side by side, with the rhyme of each line and the place where each usually turns.

Two columns of fourteen boxes. Left, the Petrarchan sonnet: eight lines rhyming abbaabba labeled octave, a problem or question, then a turn at line 9 and six lines rhyming cdecde labeled sestet, the answer.Two columns of fourteen boxes. Left, the Petrarchan sonnet: eight lines rhyming abbaabba labeled octave, a problem or question, then a turn at line 9 and six lines rhyming cdecde labeled sestet, the answer.
The two main sonnet shapes. The Petrarchan sonnet turns between its octave and sestet; the Shakespearean sonnet builds through three quatrains and turns in its couplet.

Three quatrains and a couplet

Shakespeare’s Sonnet 73 shows how the three quatrains can work as three attempts at one idea. The speaker compares himself first to a tree in late autumn, then to twilight, then to a fire burning down:

That time of year thou mayst in me behold
When yellow leaves, or none, or few, do hang
Upon those boughs which shake against the cold,
Bare ruin’d choirs, where late the sweet birds sang.
…
This thou perceiv’st, which makes thy love more strong,
To love that well, which thou must leave ere long.

William Shakespeare, Sonnet 73 (1609), lines 1–4 and 13–14

Each quatrain shortens the time left. A season lasts weeks, a twilight an hour, a dying fire minutes, so the three images close in on the speaker as the poem goes on. The hesitation of “yellow leaves, or none, or few” (line 2) acts out an old man counting what remains. Then the couplet turns from the speaker to the listener, “thou”, and from decay to love: knowing the speaker will soon be gone makes the listener’s love stronger. The quatrains build the case and the couplet draws its human consequence.

A couplet can undercut what came before instead. Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130 spends twelve lines denying that the speaker’s mistress looks like anything in conventional love poetry (“My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun”, line 1). The couplet then declares his love “as rare / As any she belied with false compare” (lines 13–14). The joke is aimed at other sonnets: the form that taught poets to compare women to suns and roses is used to mock the comparisons.

YouTube
Sonnet 130 spoken by the actor Miles Jupp: the dry tone of the first twelve lines and the shift in the couplet can be heard in performance. Royal Shakespeare Company.

Heard aloud, the sonnet’s joke depends on timing. The flat denials of the quatrains build an expectation of insult, and the pause before “And yet” at the start of the couplet is where the tone changes from mockery to tenderness.

Variations

Poets have bent the sonnet in many ways, and each variation is a choice that can be analyzed. Edmund Spenser’s sonnets in Amoretti (1595) link their quatrains by rhyme (abab bcbc cdcd ee), so the argument flows rather than steps. Milton used the sonnet for public and political subjects and let his sentences run across the octave and sestet. Gerard Manley Hopkins invented the “curtal” (shortened) sonnet, ten and a half lines that keep the Petrarchan proportions in miniature. Many modern poets write unrhymed sonnets or keep only the fourteen lines and a turn, so that the form survives as a frame for an argument.

Sound, rhythm and image working together

The sonnet’s parts make its structure, but its texture comes from sound, rhythm and image working at the same time. The second quatrain of Sonnet 64 shows all three in four lines:

When I have seen the hungry oceannote 1 gain
Advantage on the kingdom of the shorenote 2,
And the firm soil win of the watery main,
Increasing store with loss and loss with storenote 3;

Sonnet 64, lines 5–8

  1. Personification. The ocean is “hungry”, an animal or a person with appetite. The image makes erosion a kind of greed, which prepares for Time as a destroyer in line 12.

  2. Extended metaphor. The shore is a “kingdom” and the sea gains “advantage” on it, the language of war and politics. Geography becomes a story of conquest that never ends.

  3. Sound and balance. The line is built of two mirrored halves, so its rhythm swings back and forth like the exchange it describes. The repeated s and l sounds slow it down.

The imagery turns a slow geological process into a war, and the war has no winner. The meter supports this. The base rhythm of the sonnet is iambic pentameter, ten syllables alternating unstressed and stressed, and line 8 fits it exactly; its regularity makes the exchange sound endless and mechanical. Line 3, by contrast, ends on three heavy syllables, “I see down-razed”, so the voice slows as the towers fall.

No feature works alone in a poem. A reading that names the metaphor in line 6 without the balance of line 8, or the rhythm without the image, misses how the parts reinforce each other. The toolkit chapters on imagery and on sound teach these features one at a time; in a whole poem the question is always how they combine to make the meaning.

Forms of praise and mourning: the ode and the elegy

Some forms are defined less by their shape than by what they do. The ode is a long, serious lyric that addresses a person, a thing or an idea, and praises it or thinks about it at length. Its ancestors are Greek and Latin. Pindar’s odes, in the fifth century BCE, were public songs for victorious athletes, sung by a chorus in elaborate stanzas; Horace’s odes, in the first century BCE, were quieter and more personal, in regular stanzas. English poets borrowed both, and the Romantic poets of the early nineteenth century made the ode a form for private meditation.

John Keats wrote most of his great odes in the spring and autumn of 1819. In “Ode to a Nightingale” the bird’s song draws the speaker into thoughts he did not plan to have:

Darkling I listen; and, for many a time
I have been half in love with easeful Death,
Call’d him soft names in many a mused rhyme,
To take into the air my quiet breath;

John Keats, “Ode to a Nightingale” (1819), lines 51–54, in Keats: Poems Published in 1820, ed. M. Robertson (1909)

The ode moves by association, not by argument. Listening in the dark leads to death, death to the wish to die while the bird sings, and that wish, a few lines later, to the bird’s own immortality. The ten-line stanza gives each turn of thought room to unfold, and the phrase “half in love” keeps the speaker honest: he confesses the attraction of death and holds it at a distance in the same breath. This is what an ode in the Romantic sense does. It follows a mind meditating in the presence of its subject, and the meditation, more than the praise, is the poem.

The elegy

An elegy is a poem of mourning. Its traditional movement has three stages: grief at the death, praise of the dead, and a consolation that makes the loss bearable, often through religion, nature or the survival of the person’s memory. John Milton’s “Lycidas” (1638), for a college friend who drowned, follows this pattern and ends by telling the mourners to weep no more, because the dead man lives in heaven. Alfred Tennyson’s In Memoriam A. H. H. (1850) stretches the same journey over seventeen years of writing and 131 sections, with doubt and faith fighting all the way.

Walt Whitman’s elegy for Abraham Lincoln, published in 1865, months after the assassination, never names the president. It opens with three images that will run through the whole poem:

When lilacs last in the dooryard bloom’d,
And the great star early droop’d in the western sky in the night,
I mourn’d, and yet shall mourn with ever-returning spring.

Walt Whitman, “When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom’d” (1865), section 1, lines 1–3, Leaves of Grass (1891–2)

The lilac, the falling star and, from section 4, a thrush singing in a swamp become the poem’s three symbols: the living spring, the dead leader and the voice of mourning. Grief is tied to the season itself, so it will return “with ever-returning spring”, every year. The long lines, unrhymed and without regular meter, let the speaker’s feeling expand and repeat like breath. When consolation comes, it comes through the thrush’s song, which welcomes death as “lovely and soothing” (section 14) rather than defeating it.

Many modern elegies refuse that comfort. In Poetry of Mourning (1994) the critic Jahan Ramazani argues that twentieth-century elegists tend to resist consolation and keep grief open, unresolved and sometimes angry, against the tradition’s movement toward peace. A reader can test the claim on any modern elegy by asking where, or whether, the poem comforts. The question is useful even when the answer is yes, because a consolation that a poem has to struggle for reads differently from one it takes for granted.

Story and song: the ballad

The ballad is the oldest storytelling form in English verse. Folk ballads were sung and passed on by memory for centuries before collectors printed them. They share a recognizable manner: short stanzas, plain language, dialogue without speech tags, sudden jumps between scenes, and a story told without the narrator’s comment. The usual ballad stanza is a quatrain whose lines alternate four and three stresses and rhyme on the second and fourth lines. Its practice as performance and memory belongs to the study of literature as a cultural practice.

In the Romantic period poets wrote literary ballads in imitation of the old songs. Keats’s “La Belle Dame sans Merci”, written in 1819 and first printed in 1820, opens with a question to a stranger:

Oh what can ail thee Knight at arms
Alone and palely loitering?
The sedge has withered from the Lake
And no birds sing.

John Keats, “La Belle Dame sans Merci” (1819), lines 1–4, in Keats: Poems Published in 1820, ed. M. Robertson (1909)

The poem keeps the ballad’s dialogue and its mystery: an unnamed questioner asks, and the knight answers with a story of a fairy woman who loved him and left him on a cold hill. Keats shortens the last line of every stanza from four stresses to two. Each stanza ends on a short line that stops abruptly, and the first stanza’s “And no birds sing” sounds as if the song itself had died. In the final stanza the knight repeats the opening lines almost word for word, so the poem ends where it began, with the knight still loitering and the lake still bare.

Repetition of this kind is a refrain in a looser sense; in many folk ballads a true refrain, a line or chorus repeated after every stanza, kept the listeners singing along. Each return of a refrain sounds different because the story has moved on, so the same words gather new meaning. The knight’s “alone and palely loitering” means one thing as a stranger’s question and another after the reader has heard what happened to him.

Forms that repeat: the villanelle and the ghazal

Some forms are built on return. The villanelle has nineteen lines: five three-line stanzas and a final four-line stanza, on only two rhymes. Its first and third lines come back in turn as the last line of each stanza, and both return together to close the poem. The form demands that two lines be repeated four times each, so a poet who chooses it chooses obsession. Dylan Thomas’s villanelle to his dying father, published in 1951, is built on these two refrains:

Do not go gentle into that good night,
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.

Dylan Thomas, “Do not go gentle into that good night” (1951), lines 1 and 3

Each refrain is a command the speaker cannot stop giving. Between them the stanzas run through wise men, good men, wild men and grave men, all of whom resist death, and the refrains return after each case as if the list might persuade. In the final stanza the speaker addresses his father directly and both refrains arrive together. The repetition that sounded like conviction now sounds like pleading, because nothing in nineteen lines has changed the fact the poem cannot accept.

Elizabeth Bishop’s “One Art” (1976) uses the same form against itself. Its refrain insists that the art of losing is easy to master, and the stanzas test the claim on larger and larger losses: keys, an hour, a mother’s watch, houses, cities, a continent and at last a loved person. The refrain changes slightly each time it returns. In the last line the speaker has to interrupt herself with a bracketed command to keep writing, so the calm of the form breaks at the moment the loss becomes personal.

The ghazal

The ghazal comes from Arabic poetry and was developed over centuries by Persian and Urdu poets such as Hafez and Ghalib. It is a sequence of couplets, each complete in itself, linked by a repeated word or phrase at the end of every couplet, with a rhyme just before it. In the first couplet both lines end with the repeated word, and in the last the poet traditionally names himself or herself. Its traditional subject is longing, for a beloved, for God or for both at once.

Agha Shahid Ali, a Kashmiri poet who wrote in English and died in 2001, argued that English ghazals should keep these strict rules rather than borrow only the name. His own ghazals, collected in Call Me Ishmael Tonight (2003), end every couplet on the same word and close by addressing the poet by name. In a ghazal each couplet may jump to a new image or thought, and the repeated word holds the poem together the way a refrain holds a ballad. Repeating forms suit grief and longing because those feelings return, unchanged, however the mind tries to move on.

A character speaking: the dramatic monologue

In a dramatic monologue the speaker is clearly not the poet but a character, speaking to a silent listener at a particular moment. Robert Browning’s “My Last Duchess” (1842) is the classic case. A Renaissance duke shows a visitor a portrait of his dead wife:

Oh, sir, she smiled, no doubt,
Whene’er I passed her; but who passed without
Much the same smile? This grew; I gave commands;
Then all smiles stopped together. There she stands
As if alive.

Robert Browning, “My Last Duchess” (1842), lines 43–47, in Browning’s Shorter Poems, ed. Franklin T. Baker (1899)

The Duke means to show his good taste and his grievance. Instead he lets slip that he had his wife killed, or at least silenced, because she smiled at everyone as warmly as at him. “I gave commands” is the whole crime in three words, and the full stop after “together” falls in the middle of a line, a caesura that marks the end of a life. The Duke then returns to the painting at once, as if nothing had been said.

The listener is the key to the form. Near the end the reader learns that the visitor represents a count whose daughter the Duke now plans to marry (line 49). The monologue is therefore a warning delivered to the next wife’s family, whether the Duke intends it or not. The poem is written in rhyming couplets, yet the sentences run across the line ends so freely that the rhymes are barely heard, and the Duke sounds like a man talking, not a poet performing.

The form has been used to give voices to those whom history kept silent as well as to expose those who held power. Alfred Tennyson’s “Ulysses” (1842) lets the aging hero speak for himself; Carol Ann Duffy’s The World’s Wife (1999) gives monologues to the wives of famous men from myth and history, who answer the stories told about them. The form is close to drama, and it shares drama’s central pleasure: the audience knows more than the speaker.

From blank verse to free verse

Most English poetry before the twentieth century was written in meter, and much of it in iambic pentameter. When that line is left unrhymed it is blank verse, the line of Shakespeare’s plays and of Milton’s Paradise Lost (1667). It is close enough to the rhythm of speech to sound natural and regular enough to carry weight. Translators have often used it to give foreign poems a dignified English voice. L. Cranmer-Byng’s A Lute of Jade (1909) turns a poem by the Tang dynasty poet Du Fu (712–770) about a recruiting officer into blank verse:

At sunset in the village of Che-Kao
I sought for shelter; on my heels there trod
A grim recruiting sergeant, of the kind
That seize their prey by night.

Tu Fu (Du Fu), “The Recruiting Sergeant”, translated by L. Cranmer-Byng, A Lute of Jade (1909), lines 1–4

The English lines run on into each other, and the third line ends on “of the kind”, holding back what kind of man this is until the next line names him a predator. Du Fu’s original is written in short lines of five characters each, a form with no equivalent in English. The translator keeps the images (sunset, the village, the sergeant hunting at night) and the story, but the shape, the rhyme and the sound are remade from English materials. Translation keeps a poem’s images and arguments more easily than its forms, and a reader of a poem in translation analyzes the translator’s line as well as the poet’s choices.

Free verse

Free verse gives up regular meter and rhyme but keeps the line. Walt Whitman made it a major form in English with Leaves of Grass (1855), whose long lines are shaped by breath, by lists and by repeated grammar rather than by counted syllables. In “Sparkles from the Wheel” (1871) a knife-grinder sharpens a blade on a city street:

The low hoarse purr of the whirling stone, the light-press’d blade,
Diffusing, dropping, sideways-darting, in tiny showers of gold,
Sparkles from the wheel.

Walt Whitman, “Sparkles from the Wheel” (1871), lines 14–16

The long lines pile up participles (“Diffusing, dropping, sideways-darting”) as the sparks pile up in the air, and the short last line falls like the sparks themselves. That last line repeats the title and the end of the first stanza, so the poem has a refrain even without meter. Free verse is not prose cut into lengths: its line ends, its repetitions and its use of white space are choices, and they can be analyzed as precisely as rhyme. In Whitman the long line is also an argument, since it gives room to everyone and everything in the crowd.

The timeline places the major forms of English poetry in their history, with one poet at each point. It shows how forms arrive, borrowed from other languages (the sonnet from Italian, the ghazal from Persian and Urdu), and how later poets keep, bend or abandon them. Free verse does not replace the older forms: poets have written sonnets, ballads and villanelles in every decade since Whitman.

A timeline from 1350 to 2050 with thirteen points: Chaucer 1390 couplet tales, Wyatt 1540 sonnet arrives, Shakespeare 1609, Donne 1633, Milton 1667 blank-verse epic, Pope 1711 heroic couplet, Percy 1765 folk ballads printed, Keats 1819 ode, Browning 1842, Whitman 1855 free verse, Eliot 1922,…A timeline from 1350 to 2050 with thirteen points: Chaucer 1390 couplet tales, Wyatt 1540 sonnet arrives, Shakespeare 1609, Donne 1633, Milton 1667 blank-verse epic, Pope 1711 heroic couplet, Percy 1765 folk ballads printed, Keats 1819 ode, Browning 1842, Whitman 1855 free verse, Eliot 1922,…
Forms of poetry in English, with one poet at each point. Dates are of first publication, except Wyatt’s, which marks the decade the sonnet arrived from Italian.

Reading an unseen poem

All of these building blocks come together when a student meets a poem for the first time. The process is easiest to see on a short, rich example. E. Pauline Johnson (1861–1913), whose Mohawk name was Tekahionwake, was born on the Six Nations reserve in Ontario to a Mohawk father and an English mother. “The Corn Husker” appeared in Harper’s Weekly in 1896 and was collected in Canadian Born (1903). Its language for Indigenous people (“Indian lodges”, “her race”) is the vocabulary of its time and of the largely white audiences she wrote and performed for; part of the poem’s force lies in how it uses that vocabulary.

The Corn HuskerCanadian Born, 1903E. Pauline Johnson (Tekahionwake), “The Corn Husker”, Canadian Born (Toronto: George N. Morang, 1903)
Hard by the Indian lodges, where the bush
Breaks in a clearing, through ill-fashioned fields,
She comes to labor, when the first still hush
Of autumn follows large and recent yields.
Age in her fingers, hunger in her face,
Her shoulders stooped with weight of work and years,
But rich in tawny coloring of her race,
She comes a-field to strip the purple ears.
And all her thoughts are with the days gone by,
Ere might’s injustice banished from their lands
Her people, that to-day unheeded lie,
Like the dead husks that rustle through her hands.

First impressions

A first reading gathers the obvious facts before any interpretation. The title names a person by her work, not her name. The poem has three quatrains of iambic pentameter, rhymed abab, with the second and fourth lines indented: a neat, traditional shape. There is no “I”; an observer describes a woman who “comes to labor” (line 3) at the autumn harvest near the “Indian lodges”, and the last stanza moves into her thoughts. On a first reading the poem looks like a quiet sketch of rural work.

Patterns

A second reading looks for patterns, and the first is a contrast between plenty and want. Line 4 speaks of “large and recent yields”, but line 5 gives the woman “hunger in her face”. The harvest is large, and none of it seems to be hers. Line 5 is built of two balanced halves, “Age in her fingers, hunger in her face”, so the line itself sets age beside hunger like two burdens carried at once.

Line 7 begins with “But” and turns from poverty to wealth: she is “rich in tawny coloring of her race”. The word rich takes the language of value away from the harvest and gives it to her, so the stanza moves from what she lacks to what she possesses in herself. The colors of the poem gather around her too: the “purple ears” of corn (line 8) and her own coloring are the only vivid colors in the poem.

The turn and the last image

The third stanza is the turn. “And all her thoughts are with the days gone by” (line 9) moves from her body to her mind and from the present to the past. Then the poem names what happened in its plainest words: “might’s injustice banished from their lands / Her people” (lines 10–11). The line break separates the verb from its object, so “Her people” arrives on the next line, pushed out of its place in the sentence as the people were pushed from their lands. The poem’s grammar acts out the history it records.

The final line is a simile: her people lie “Like the dead husks that rustle through her hands” (line 12). Husks are what is left after the valuable corn is taken, so the image places the people among the waste of someone else’s harvest. Yet the husks still “rustle”: they make a faint sound, and they pass through the hands of the one person in the poem who remembers. The sound of husks also echoes the “hush” of line 3, so the silence of autumn and the rustle of the dead frame the whole poem.

Three boxes in a row for the three stanzas of The Corn Husker: the place and season, her body moving from want to worth, and her thoughts of the lost lands, marked as the turn. A curved arrow links hush in line 3 to husks in line 12.Three boxes in a row for the three stanzas of The Corn Husker: the place and season, her body moving from want to worth, and her thoughts of the lost lands, marked as the turn. A curved arrow links hush in line 3 to husks in line 12.
A structure map of “The Corn Husker”: the poem moves from the field to the woman to her memory, and a sound link ties its first stanza to its last line.

The map sets out the movement that the second reading found. The poem narrows its focus stanza by stanza, from the landscape to the woman and then into her mind, and each step brings the reader closer to the injustice it finally names. The first two stanzas could belong to a picturesque painting of rural life; the third shows what the painting leaves out.

From reading to thesis

A thesis states what the poem does and how, in one or two sentences. For “The Corn Husker” it might be: Johnson uses the orderly form and harvest imagery of a rural sketch to bring her readers close to the woman. She then turns the harvest into an image of her people’s dispossession, so that a picturesque scene becomes an accusation. Every part of that thesis can be supported from the lines read so far, and it names a change, which gives an essay a direction.

The last step is judgment. A reader may ask whether the final simile, by comparing the people to “dead husks”, accepts their disappearance as complete. One answer is that the word “unheeded” (line 11) places the fault with those who do not listen, so the image mourns and accuses at once. Another is that the poem, written for an audience that wanted picturesque Indigenous figures, could only accuse quietly. Weighing such readings, with evidence, is what turns a description of a poem into an interpretation.

Try it

The poem has three quatrains in iambic pentameter, rhymed alternately. In what way does its shape resemble a Shakespearean sonnet, and what might the resemblance add?

It has exactly the first twelve lines of a Shakespearean sonnet (three quatrains rhymed abab cdcd efef) and stops without the closing couplet. A reader who hears that shape may expect a summing-up or consolation, and none comes: the poem ends on the image of dead husks instead. The missing couplet can be read as part of its meaning, a resolution withheld. The reading is an inference, so it should be offered as one possibility, supported by the poem’s refusal to comfort.

Where poetry’s edges blur

The line is the test of poetry, and some poems give it up. A prose poem is written in sentences and paragraphs, without line breaks, but keeps poetry’s compression, imagery and patterning. Charles Baudelaire’s Paris Spleen, published in 1869 after his death, made the prose poem a recognized form in French. In English one of the best-known examples is Rabindranath Tagore’s Gitanjali (1912), his own English versions of songs he had written in Bengali. Poem 50 tells of a beggar who meets a king on the road and is asked, to his surprise, to give rather than receive. It ends:

But how great my surprise when at the day’s end I emptied my bag on the floor to find a least little grain of gold among the poor heap. I bitterly wept and wished that I had had the heart to give thee my all.

Rabindranath Tagore, Gitanjali (Song Offerings), poem 50, paragraph 5 (1912)

There are no lines here, but the paragraph works as a stanza does. It is built on a reversal: the one grain given away has come back as gold. Its phrasing is patterned too, since “a least little grain” repeats the words used for the grain of corn in the previous paragraph, so the reader hears the change from corn to gold in the same small phrase. The archaic thee sets the speech in the register of prayer. The whole piece is a parable told in five paragraphs, and each paragraph is a step in its turn, as each quatrain is in a sonnet.

Other forms sit on the border between poetry and something else. The verse novel tells a long story in poems, as Vikram Seth’s The Golden Gate (1986) does in hundreds of sonnet-like stanzas, so it borrows fiction’s plot and characters while keeping verse’s line. Song lyrics are written to be sung, and on the page they lose the music that shaped them; whether a songwriter’s lyrics count as poetry for a reading list is a decision each school makes. Performance poetry and spoken word are written to be heard, and their sound and timing belong to the performer as much as to the page.

These borders are useful because they make the question “what is a poem?” precise. A text that keeps the line but tells a novel’s story, or keeps compression but gives up the line, shows which of poetry’s powers it needs. Analyzing a borderline text means asking which of those powers it uses, and what it gains or loses by doing without the others.

Writing about a poem

An essay on a poem is an argument about how its choices make its meaning. The commonest weakness is a sentence that names a feature and attaches a general effect that would fit any poem. The two sentences that follow are about the same line of “The Corn Husker”.

Weak: The poet uses a simile “like the dead husks” to show that the people are sad. This creates a sense of sadness for the reader.note 1

Strong: In the closing simile Johnson places her people among the “dead husks” (line 12), the waste left after a harvest others have gathered,note 2 but the husks still “rustle” through the hands of the one woman who remembers.note 3 The image mourns the dispossessed and accuses the readers who leave them “unheeded” (line 11).note 4

  1. Label and a vague effect. The sentence names the simile and claims “sadness”, which could be said of almost any elegiac line. It does not say what husks are, or why this comparison was chosen.

  2. What the image means here. The sentence explains the vehicle (husks are what is left after a harvest) and ties it to the poem’s contrast between other people’s yields and her hunger.

  3. A second detail that complicates the first. “Rustle” gives the dead a faint voice, and the hands that hold them belong to the speaker’s subject, so the image is not only defeat.

  4. An interpretation. The last sentence states what the image does to the reader, with a second quotation as evidence.

The strong version takes longer because it does more. It explains the image, adds a detail that complicates the first reading, and ends on an interpretation that links the line to the poem’s argument. The weak version uses the phrase “creates a sense of”, which usually signals that the writer has not yet decided what the effect is.

Applying it in Paper 1

A poem is one of the two passages on most Paper 1 papers. The guiding question beside it usually directs attention to the speaker’s attitude, a change or shift in the poem, its imagery, or the way its form shapes meaning. For “The Corn Husker” a guiding question might ask how the poet presents the woman’s relationship to the land. A strong response treats the question as a starting point, answers it in a thesis, and organizes the essay around claims, not stanzas. Its opening paragraph might read:

In “The Corn Husker”, Johnson presents a woman whose relationship to the land is defined by what has been taken from her.note 1 The poem begins as a harvest scene, with “large and recent yields” (line 4). Yet the woman who “comes to labor” in these fields has “hunger in her face” (line 5): the land’s plenty is visible to her and not hers.note 2 The last stanza explains the gap, naming the “injustice” that “banished from their lands / Her people” (lines 10–11),note 3 so that the harvest she works becomes a reminder of what was lost. Johnson’s orderly quatrains hold this accusation quietly, which makes it harder to dismiss.note 4

  1. Thesis. The first sentence answers the guiding question directly and names the idea the essay will develop.

  2. Evidence in contrast. Two short quotations are set against each other, and the sentence says what the contrast means.

  3. Structure as evidence. The turn of the final stanza is used to explain the contrast, not just reported in order.

  4. Evaluation of form. The paragraph ends by judging how the form serves the meaning, which prepares the next paragraph.

The paragraph moves through the poem out of order: it quotes the first and second stanzas to set up a problem and the third to explain it. That is the difference between an argument and a walk-through. The commonest way to lose marks on a poem is to describe each stanza in turn, which produces an accurate account of the poem and no line of argument.

The building blocks of poetry return throughout the study of literature. The line and the turn reappear in the chapter on structure, the speaker in the chapter on narrative voice, and the set forms in the questions about how conventions are kept and broken over time. Drama, the next form, gives the speaking voice a body and a stage.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what the line, compression and pattern let a poem do that prose cannot, using lines from a poem.

  • To do:

    I can distinguish the speaker from the poet, and explain how apostrophe and the choice of addressee shape a poem’s tone.

  • To do:

    I can analyze what a line break, a stanza shape and a turn do in a particular poem.

  • To do:

    I can describe the Petrarchan and Shakespearean sonnets and say how each tends to organize an argument.

  • To do:

    I can recognize the ode, elegy, ballad, villanelle, ghazal, dramatic monologue, blank verse, free verse and prose poem, and explain what choosing each form brings.

  • To do:

    I can read an unseen poem from first impressions through patterns and the turn to a thesis and a judgment.

  • To do:

    I can write a paragraph on a poem that is organized around a claim, not a walk through the stanzas.

Key terms

Each is also in the Literary forms glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Apostrophe

A speaker's direct address to someone or something that cannot answer: an absent or dead person, an abstraction, an animal or an object. It turns a statement about a subject into a speech to it, which can sound intimate, desperate or defiant.

Ballad

A poem or song that tells a story in short stanzas, usually quatrains alternating four-stress and three-stress lines, often with dialogue and a refrain. Folk ballads were passed on orally; literary ballads are written by poets in imitation of them.

Blank verse

Unrhymed lines of iambic pentameter. Close to the rhythm of English speech, it is the line of Shakespeare's plays and of Milton's Paradise Lost, used for drama and long poems.

Couplet

Two consecutive lines of verse, usually rhymed, that form a unit. The heroic couplet is a pair of rhymed iambic pentameter lines that usually completes its sense within the pair.

Dramatic monologue

A poem spoken by one character, clearly not the poet, to a silent listener at a particular moment. The speaker reveals more about himself or herself than he or she intends, so the reader judges what the speaker says.

Elegy

A poem of mourning for a person who has died, or more broadly a reflective poem on loss. The traditional elegy moves from grief through praise to consolation; many modern elegies refuse or question that consolation.

Free verse

Verse without a regular meter or fixed rhyme scheme, whose lines are shaped instead by breath, syntax, repetition and the placing of words on the page. It still depends on the line break, which is what separates it from prose.

Ghazal

A poem of self-contained couplets that share a repeated word or phrase at the end of each couplet, preceded by a rhyme, a form from Arabic, Persian and Urdu poetry. Traditionally its subject is longing, and the poet often names himself or herself in the last couplet.

Lyric poem

A short poem in which a single speaker voices thought or feeling at a particular moment, rather than telling a long story. Most poems read closely today, from sonnets to free verse, are lyric poems.

Octave

The first eight lines of a Petrarchan sonnet, usually rhyming abbaabba, which set out the situation or question the rest of the poem answers. The word can also mean any stanza of eight lines.

Ode

A long, serious lyric poem that addresses and praises or meditates on a person, thing or idea, often in elaborate stanzas. The Pindaric ode is public and ceremonial; the Horatian ode is calmer and more personal.

Petrarchan sonnet

A sonnet divided into an octave rhyming abbaabba and a sestet rhyming cdecde, cdcdcd or a similar pattern, with the turn at the start of line 9. The octave usually sets out a problem or situation and the sestet responds to it.

Prose poem

A poem written in sentences and paragraphs without line breaks, which keeps poetry's compression, imagery and patterning of sound. It gives up the line as a unit of attention and relies on the sentence instead.

Quatrain

A stanza or unit of four lines, usually with its own rhyme pattern. It is the most common stanza in English verse and the building block of the ballad and the Shakespearean sonnet.

Refrain

A line or group of lines repeated at intervals in a poem or song, usually at the end of a stanza. Each return can carry a changed meaning because of what has happened since it was last heard.

Sestet

The last six lines of a Petrarchan sonnet, which follow the turn and respond to the octave. The word can also mean any stanza of six lines.

Shakespearean sonnet

A sonnet of three quatrains and a closing couplet, rhyming abab cdcd efef gg. The quatrains develop an argument in three steps and the couplet sums it up, turns it or undercuts it.

Sonnet

A poem of fourteen lines, traditionally in iambic pentameter with a fixed rhyme scheme, built around a turn in its thought. Its short, closed shape suits an argument that must be stated, developed and answered in a small space.

Villanelle

A nineteen-line poem of five tercets and a closing quatrain, using two rhymes, in which the first and third lines return in turn as refrains and come together at the end. The returning lines make the form suited to obsession, grief and self-persuasion.

Volta

The turn of thought or feeling in a poem, where its argument changes direction, answers a question or reverses its attitude. In a Petrarchan sonnet it usually falls at line 9; in a Shakespearean sonnet often at the closing couplet.

Practice questions on 5.3 Poetry

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGAL-0000520 marks
RemittanceCrop Time, a collection of poems from Barbados, 1920sWritten for Augment Education
Ettie, the order is for four pound ten.
Take it to the post office yourself, not the boy,
and count it at the window in front of Mr Gill
the way my mother used to count the fish.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following text is a poem, “Remittance”. In the 1920s many workers from Barbados went to Cuba to cut sugar cane.

Guiding question: How is the poem’s form of address used to present a family divided by work?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-0000820 marks
Ninth NightLime and Candles, a collection of poems from Manila, 1900sWritten for Augment Education
The first night the whole street came. Aling Pacita
brought the tall candles from her store and would take nothing,
and we said the rosary to a table with no one on it.
The second night I told the Virgin everything in order:

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following text is a poem, “Ninth Night”. It is set in Manila in 1902, during an epidemic of cholera.

Guiding question: How does the poet use the nine nights of prayer to shape the speaker’s grief?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-0001020 marks
Piggy BedsThe Coal Quay, a collection of poems from Dublin, 1950sWritten for Augment Education
Sister Bernadette says Limbo is a grand place,
the same as Heaven only you can’t see God from it.
Like the seats behind the pillar in the Pro, I said,
and I got the leather for that, on the two hands.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following text is a poem, “Piggy Beds”. It is set in Dublin in the 1950s, when Catholic teaching held that a baby who died before baptism could not enter Heaven.

Guiding question: In what ways does the speaker’s game shape the poem’s presentation of loss?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 45 questions on 5.3 Poetry

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

5.3 Poetry questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 5 Literary forms

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 5.1Prose: fiction
  2. 5.2Prose: non-fiction
  3. 5.3PoetryThis page
  4. 5.4Drama

Carry on with 5.3 Poetry in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.