7.5 Science, technology and the environment

How to turn the field of science, technology and the environment into a specific global issue that a literary work and a body of work both present, from who bears the cost of a heat wave to a bus lane argued on air.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 7 Global issues
  • SL and HL

21 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 7.5 Science, technology and the environment

The field of science, technology and the environment asks how people live with the natural world, how their tools change their lives, and who gains and who pays when science changes what is possible. A global issue from this field joins a literary work and a non-literary body of work through one such question, asked about a real place and real people. A leaflet from Kelverton Health, a community health service in Melbourne, asks one of them in the plainest way, under a heading of its own:

Who is most at risk?
Heat can affect anyone, but some people get sick more easily:
people over 65, especially if they live alone
babies and young children
pregnant women
people with a long-term illness, such as heart or kidney disease, diabetes or a mental illness
people who take certain medicines (ask your doctor or pharmacist)
people who work or exercise outdoors
people with no way to keep cool at home, including people who are homeless.

“Keeping cool in a heat wave”, Kelverton Health, paragraphs 22–30

What the field covers

The heat leaflet’s list sorts people in two ways. Some are at risk because of their bodies: “babies and young children” (paragraph 25), “pregnant women” (paragraph 26). Others are at risk because of how they live: “especially if they live alone” (paragraph 24), “people who work or exercise outdoors” (paragraph 29), “people with no way to keep cool at home” (paragraph 30). For the second group, a hot day is a different event from the one their neighbors live through. Weather falls on a whole city, but its harm follows age, work, housing and money.

The leaflet never says why the heat waves come. The word climate does not appear in its 40 paragraphs; heat arrives like a visitor, to be prepared for and waited out. That silence suits a public health text, whose job is to get people through a dangerous day and not to argue about causes. It also marks where this field begins. The relation between people and the natural world includes the weather they suffer, the causes of that weather, and the question of who is left most exposed when it changes.

The field has two more strands. One is technology and media: how tools from the railway to the phone change the ways people work, travel, talk and are watched. The other is the consequences of science in medicine, industry and energy, including who decides what is safe and whose knowledge is trusted. A text from the field seldom names its strand. It shows a tool, a place or a body, and the issue lies in who is helped, who is harmed and who decides.

An image that changed a view

Some texts in the field change how people see the natural world itself. On 24 December 1968 the astronaut William Anders photographed the Earth rising over the Moon from Apollo 8, the first crewed mission to orbit it. The picture shows a small, half-lit planet above a gray, lifeless surface, with no people, borders or cities in view. Earthrise is often credited with helping to build the environmental movement; the first Earth Day followed in April 1970.

Photograph: the Earth, half in shadow and blue with white clouds, rising above the gray, cratered horizon of the Moon against a black sky.
*Earthrise*: the Earth seen from lunar orbit, the planet as one place with no borders in view. William Anders, *Earthrise*, Apollo 8, 24 December 1968. NASA, public domain.

The photograph’s force comes from its choices as well as its subject. The Moon fills the foreground, so the viewer stands on the dead world and looks back at the living one. NASA’s original frame set the lunar horizon vertical, and the version printed most often turns it so that the Earth rises like a sun. Such choices raise a question about whether seeing the planet as one place makes its people readier to share the cost of protecting it.

An older strand: science and who profits

The third strand is older than the word technology. In 1717 Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, the wife of the British ambassador at Constantinople, wrote home from Adrianople about a practice that protected people from smallpox:

The small-pox, so fatal, and so general amongst us, is here entirely harmless, by the invention of ingrafting, which is the term they give it.
…
I should not fail to write to some of our doctors very particularly about it, if I knew any one of them that I thought had virtue enough to destroy such a considerable branch of their revenue, for the good of mankind.

Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, letter from Adrianople, 1 April 1717 (published 1763), paragraph 1

The letter presents a medical practice as knowledge that crosses a border, carried by a “set of old women” (paragraph 1) whom no English physician would have consulted. Its sharpest sentence is about money. Montagu expects resistance because smallpox is a “considerable branch” of the doctors’ income, so a cure threatens the people best placed to judge it. The irony of “virtue enough” lies in its doubt that such virtue exists. The letter thus turns a scientific change into the question this field keeps asking: who stands to lose when knowledge improves, and how far does that loss shape what is believed?

From field to issue, step by step

A field is a place to start looking, and an issue is a question found there. A global issue matters on a wide scale, crosses national borders and is felt in everyday local life. One student narrowed this field with two texts in mind. The body of work was Kelverton Health’s heat materials: the leaflet, its infographic of who is most at risk and its advice line. The literary work was Kim Stanley Robinson’s novel The Ministry for the Future (2020).

The test on the leaflet turns on one instruction, the only place where the list of people at risk becomes a task for its reader:

If you know someone on this list, call them at least once on every very hot day. Offer to do their shopping, or take them somewhere cool.

“Keeping cool in a heat wave”, paragraph 32

Three imperatives, “call”, “Offer” and “take”, turn the reader from a person at risk into a helper. The leaflet’s answer to the issue is care between neighbors, measured in phone calls and errands. A public place appears once, when a home is too hot and the reader is sent to “Kelverton Library or a shopping centre” (paragraph 18). The cost of the heat is shared by people who know each other, and the text is silent on housing, air-conditioning bills or the hours of outdoor work. That silence is a position too, the one a health service can take without arguing about money.

Robinson’s novel takes the opposite scale. Its first chapter follows Frank May, an American aid worker in a town in Uttar Pradesh, northern India, through a heat wave in which heat and humidity pass the point at which the human body can cool itself. The power fails, and those with no way to escape the heat die in vast numbers while Frank survives. Where the leaflet asks one neighbor to call another, the novel asks whether whole nations will act for people they will never meet.

Naming the issue’s field of argument

Both texts present heat as a harm that falls unequally, and the question of whether that sharing is fair has its own name: environmental justice. The phrase began in campaigns in the United States in the 1980s against waste sites placed near poor and Black neighborhoods, and it now covers heat, floods, polluted air and the effects of climate change worldwide. An issue framed as environmental justice is always about people first and places second.

Literature’s ability to present such an issue is itself argued over. In The Great Derangement (2016), first given as lectures at the University of Chicago in 2015, the novelist Amitav Ghosh argued that the serious modern novel has struggled to deal with climate change. Novels prefer the probable and the single life, he suggested, while a changing climate brings events too improbable and too large for realism. The study of how literature represents the natural world, and what it assumes about land, weather and resources, is ecocriticism, and Ghosh’s book is one of its best-known recent arguments.

Testing whether it is global

The issue passes all three marks. Its scale is wide: in five days of July 1995 the heat in Chicago caused 739 deaths above the usual number, and in the summer of 2003 Europe recorded more than 70,000 additional deaths. It crosses borders, from Melbourne to Uttar Pradesh to Chicago. And it is felt locally, in exactly the way the leaflet imagines. The sociologist Eric Klinenberg’s study Heat Wave (2002) found that death rates differed sharply between neighborhoods, and that many of the dead were old people living alone. The leaflet’s phrase “especially if they live alone” (paragraph 24) carries that knowledge in five words.

Try it

The heat leaflet never uses the word climate. Does that make it a weak text for an issue about who bears the cost of heat waves?

No. The silence is a choice that can be analyzed. A public health leaflet keeps to what its reader can do today, so it presents heat as weather to be survived and shares the cost among neighbors. Set beside Robinson’s novel, which names causes and asks what nations owe each other, the leaflet’s silence becomes evidence of one position in the argument: the cost handled locally, by care, without asking who caused it. A comparison can treat what each text leaves out as part of how it presents the issue.

Five more issues from the field

Each issue that follows is a question, set out with one literary work and one non-literary body of work that present it. A novel or play usually shows people living with a change over time; a body of work shows it through many public items, each aimed at an audience. With the cost of heat, they make six.

When does green advertising mislead?

Communication that makes an organization, product or policy appear better for the environment than it is has been called greenwashing since the 1980s. Ian McEwan’s comic novel Solar (2010) presents the gap between a cause and its champion through Michael Beard, a Nobel-winning physicist who takes up solar energy for money, fame and a dead colleague’s ideas, until cause and career are hard to tell apart. A body of work can present it from the advertiser’s side. Volkswagen marketed its diesel cars in the United States as “clean diesel”; in September 2015 the Environmental Protection Agency announced that the cars carried software that cut their emissions only during testing. Read after that announcement, the campaign’s promise of a clean car became evidence in the issue it had been made to avoid.

Do connected devices bring people closer or keep them apart?

E. M. Forster’s story “The Machine Stops” (1909) imagines people living alone in underground rooms, speaking to each other only through a worldwide machine and dreading direct experience. More than a century later, its question about technology and isolation is asked of the phone. In Eric Pickersgill’s photograph series Removed, published in 2015, people sit at tables, lie in bed and stand together in the poses of using their phones, but the phones were taken from their hands before each picture. Their eyes rest on empty palms. The series presents the issue without a word of argument, through one absence repeated across many frames.

Whom is a city’s transport built for?

New transport changes who can reach what, and whose streets are cut through to make way. Charles Dickens watched the railways reach London and put them into Dombey and Son (1848), where the building of a line tears through Staggs’s Gardens, a poor district in Camden Town:

The first shock of a great earthquake had, just at that period, rent the whole neighbourhood to its centre.
…
In short, the yet unfinished and unopened Railroad was in progress; and, from the very core of all this dire disorder, trailed smoothly away, upon its mighty course of civilisation and improvement.

Charles Dickens, Dombey and Son (1848), chapter 6

The extended metaphor of an earthquake turns a building project into a natural disaster, something that happens to the neighborhood rather than something done to it by people. Then “In short” deflates the whole description into a railroad “in progress”, and the last clause lets the railroad glide away from the wreckage “smoothly”. The words “civilisation and improvement” carry the railway companies’ own language, and the ruins just described make them ironic. Dickens presents the issue as a question of who is improved: the travelers who will ride the line, or the residents whose homes lie under it. A body of work such as a radio station’s call-in segments on a city’s transport presents the same question in living voices, as the Nairobi call-in does.

Who pays for what is taken from the ground?

Oil, coal and metal make the places they come from rich for some and dangerous for others. Helon Habila’s novel Oil on Water (2010) follows two journalists through the creeks of the Niger Delta in search of a kidnapped woman, through a landscape of oil spills and violence. Edward Burtynsky’s photographs in Oil (2009) present the same issue from a great height: refineries, highways and fields of pumps, beautiful in color and pattern, in which people are often too small to see. Side by side, the novel’s close view and the photographs’ distant one raise a further question: whether distance helps a viewer see the system or lets the viewer forget the people inside it.

Whom should the public believe about harm?

When a scientist warns of a harm that others profit from, the public has to decide whom to trust. Henrik Ibsen’s play An Enemy of the People (1882) presents the issue through Dr. Stockmann, who finds that his town’s new medicinal baths are polluted. The baths are the town’s income, so the newspaper, the property owners and his brother, the mayor, turn against him, and a public meeting declares him an enemy of the people. In Eleanor Marx-Aveling’s 1888 translation he tells that meeting “The majority is never right” (Act IV), and his contempt for his neighbors leaves the audience judging him as well as his finding.

Rachel Carson’s writing on pesticides presents the same issue as a body of work: three installments in The New Yorker in June 1962, the book Silent Spring that September, and her testimony to a Senate committee in 1963. Before the book appeared, a chemical company threatened its publisher with legal action, and in 1972 the United States banned DDT for most agricultural use.

A bus lane argued on air

An issue from this field can be heard at work in a single radio segment. The Nairobi call-in is the listeners’ segment of a community station’s morning program. A week after the county painted a bus-only lane on Kamili Road, its host asks: is the red lane “a gift to the people who ride the mathree, or a punishment for everybody else?” (turn 3). Five callers answer, and their answers sort themselves by who gains and who pays.

The diagram places each caller on one side of the lane, with the words and turn that put them there. Mama Wanjiku gains more than an hour each morning, though the fare has risen with the speed. Kevo, a motorcycle-taxi rider, says the lane “has taken our road” (turn 18), and Brian, who drives his children to school, now sits in traffic beside an empty lane. Faith, a student who walks the last kilometer to college, gives the answer no one else had considered:

Diagram: the red lane on Kamili Road in the center. Who gains, in green: Mama Wanjiku, Wycliffe by text, matatu owners. Who pays, in orange: Kevo the boda rider, Brian the driver, Faith on foot. Below, dashed: Kawangware, with no lane, heard only by text.Diagram: the red lane on Kamili Road in the center. Who gains, in green: Mama Wanjiku, Wycliffe by text, matatu owners. Who pays, in orange: Kevo the boda rider, Brian the driver, Faith on foot. Below, dashed: Kawangware, with no lane, heard only by text.
The Nairobi call-in mapped as gains and costs. Each caller is placed by their own words, with the turn number; the district with no lane reaches the program only as a text message.

So the lane is good for the time. But it has moved the danger. It has moved it onto us.

The Nairobi call-in, turn 54

Faith’s three short sentences move from a concession to an accusation. “Good for the time” grants the lane its purpose; “moved the danger” names a cost the plan did not count; “onto us” gives the cost an address. Her next turn adds that walkers “don’t have a phone line to the county” (turn 56). The cost falls on the people with the least voice in the decision, which is environmental justice in the small space of one road. The program repeats the pattern, since Kawangware, the district with no lane at all, reaches the air only as a text message.

Does the lane decide, or do people?

The callers disagree about something deeper than the lane: whether a new technology changes a city by itself. The view that technologies shape a society’s way of life largely by their own nature, so that people adapt to them, is technological determinism. Marshall McLuhan’s Understanding Media (1964), with its phrase “the medium is the message”, is often read as its classic statement. Raymond Williams answered it in Television: Technology and Cultural Form (1974), arguing that technologies are developed and used for human purposes and within institutions, so their effects depend on who controls them.

Mr Ochieng, the former geography teacher, takes Williams’s side without knowing it:

The lane is correct, but if the county does not put officers on it who cannot be bought, in six months it will be a car lane with red paint.

The Nairobi call-in, turn 37

For Ochieng the paint decides nothing; enforcement, and the honesty of the officers, decides everything. The host’s summary, “So the paint is the easy part” (turn 38), agrees. Faith’s grammar takes the other side, since in “it has moved the danger” the lane is the subject of the verb and the county disappears. The segment as a whole suggests that both are partly right: the paint changed every road user’s morning at once, but whether the change lasts is a human choice. That balance is a fair reading of most technologies a text presents, from a railway to a phone.

Grammar is often the quickest guide to which view a text takes. When the machine, the lane or the screen is the subject of the main verbs, the text leans toward determinism; when officials, owners and users are, it presents technology as a human choice.

How an issue goes wrong

This field invites slogans more than any other, because many of its questions carry real urgency. The four drafts that follow were each proposed for an oral with real works in mind, and each fails in a different way.

Climate change is bad.note 1

Technology and society.note 2

The red lane on Kamili Road.note 3

Pollution in Oil on Water.note 4

  1. A slogan. It states a position nobody in the two works disputes, so there is nothing to compare. A text that agrees with it and a text that agrees with it more give the argument no movement.

  2. Too broad. It names the field’s middle strand and nothing else. Any two texts fit it, which is why it says nothing about these two.

  3. Too narrow. One road in one city. No literary work presents it, and the second half of the comparison has nothing to stand on.

  4. A topic, not an issue. It names a subject and a work, but no question and no human stake. Pollution is something the novel shows; the issue is who suffers it, who profits and who decides.

Each draft can be repaired by asking who acts and who pays. The slogan becomes a question with sides: who should bear the cost of a changing climate, the places that caused it or the places that suffer it? The broad pair becomes one relation: whether new technologies bring people closer or leave them more alone. The narrow road widens to the kind of change it is: whom a city’s new transport is built for, and who pays for the speed of others. The topic gains its stake: who pays for the oil taken from a place, and who is paid. Each repaired issue could be answered “partly”, and each would fit a novel as well as a body of work.

Writing about it

The pair that follows comes from two students planning orals on Dickens’s Dombey and Son and a radio station’s call-in segments on the city’s transport, under the issue whom a city’s new transport is built for. The first sets out what each text is about; the second shows how each text’s choices answer the question.

Weak: Both of my texts are about technology and the environment.note 1 In Dombey and Son the railway destroys a neighborhood, and in the call-in people complain about a bus lane, which shows that new transport is not always good for everyone.note 2

Strong: Both texts ask whom a city’s new transport is built for, and both find the answer in who is left out of the plan.note 3 Dickens makes the railway an “earthquake” and then lets it glide away “smoothly” toward “civilisation and improvement”, so the people of Staggs’s Gardens vanish from the sentence that ruins them.note 4 The call-in gives such people a voice, but only some of them: Faith can say the lane “has moved the danger” onto walkers (turn 54), while Kawangware, with no lane at all, is heard only as a text message.note 5

  1. A field, not an issue. “Technology and the environment” could join any two texts in the field, so the talk has no direction.

  2. Summary with a moral attached. Each text is reduced to its plot, and the conclusion is true of every road ever built.

  3. The issue as a question, with a shared answer. The first sentence names what both texts are asked and what they have in common.

  4. A choice analyzed. The quotations show how the metaphor and the grammar of the sentence hide the residents.

  5. A contrast that deepens the issue. The call-in gives the excluded a voice, yet still decides whose voice reaches the air, so the comparison ends on a finding.

Applying it in the individual oral

The individual oral asks how a global issue is presented in one literary work and one non-literary body of work, through one extract from each and the works they come from. The talk lasts about ten minutes and the teacher’s questions about five. In this field the issue becomes the axis of the talk only when it is stated as a human question, about who is exposed, who decides or who pays, and when each section of the talk returns to it. Extracts are usually about 40 lines of print, or one item from a body of work; the exact limits are worth checking with a teacher.

An opening sentence names the issue and the angle each work takes:

My global issue is who bears the cost when heat waves hit a city. A health leaflet from Melbourne presents that cost as something neighbors can share in a phone call, while Robinson’s The Ministry for the Future presents it at the scale of a region where the poorest cannot escape the heat.

A model opening for an oral on Kelverton Health’s heat materials and The Ministry for the Future

The extracts might be the leaflet’s page on who is most at risk, with its infographic, and a passage from Robinson’s first chapter. Two concepts suit this field most often. Communication asks how a text reaches the people it needs, which is the leaflet’s whole design problem. Perspective asks where each voice stands, as the Nairobi host admits when she says the answer “depends on where you are standing” (turn 59).

The commonest way to lose marks in this field is to explain the science, the physics of heat or the history of the bus lane, instead of analyzing the texts. A sentence of context is enough; the minutes belong to the extracts.

The concept pages on communication and perspective take those two concepts back to single texts, and the text type pages on the leaflet, the infographic and the radio broadcast read the heat materials and the call-in as whole types. The Internal assessment pages on choosing a global issue and extracts turn a tested issue into a plan for the oral.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can say what the field of science, technology and the environment covers, across its three strands.

  • To do:

    I can explain the three marks of a global issue and test a draft issue against them.

  • To do:

    I can narrow the field step by step to a specific issue, and test it against a literary work and a body of work.

  • To do:

    I can describe several issues in the field and how a literary work and a body of work might each present them.

  • To do:

    I can use environmental justice, greenwashing and ecocriticism accurately in discussing a text.

  • To do:

    I can weigh technological determinism against human choice, using a text’s grammar as evidence.

  • To do:

    I can recognize an issue that is a slogan, too broad, too narrow or a topic, and repair it.

Key terms

Each is also in the Global issues glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Ecocriticism

Ecocriticism is the study of how literature and other texts represent the natural world and the relation between people and their environment. It asks what a text assumes about land, animals, weather and resources, and whose place in nature it takes for granted.

Environmental justice

Environmental justice is the fair sharing of environmental harms and benefits, such as pollution, heat, flooding, clean air and green space, among the people of a place or the world. The term is used to name and challenge cases where the poorest people, or those with least say, bear most of the harm from changes they did least to cause.

Greenwashing

Greenwashing is communication that makes an organization, product or policy appear better for the environment than it is. It works through selective claims, vague words such as natural or clean, and images of nature that stand in for evidence.

Technological determinism

Technological determinism is the view that new technologies shape a society's way of life largely by their own nature, so that people adapt to them rather than choose how to use them. Its critics argue that technologies are developed, used and limited by human decisions, interests and institutions.

Practice questions on 7.5 Science, technology and the environment

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0004620 marks

The following double-page spread is taken from Our Changing Lands, a geography textbook for students aged 13 to 15, published in Casablanca, Morocco, for English-medium secondary schools across North Africa.

A geography textbook double-page spread headed 7.3 Water from under the desert: three paragraphs and a green case study box with a farmer’s quotation on the left; a cross-section of a khettara, two panels of a falling water table, key terms and four questions on the right.
Description of the textbook spread

Two cream pages, each topped by a terracotta band with the unit title in white capitals. Page numbers sit at the foot.

The left page opens with a large heading, the section number in terracotta, then three paragraphs in a serif type, with “aquifer” and “khettara” in bold terracotta. Below them is a pale green box with a dark green bar down its left edge, labeled “CASE STUDY · A farmer’s view”. It holds a quotation in italic, the speaker’s name and region, and a small dark green silhouette of a man beside a palm tree.

The right page opens with Fig. 7.6, a labeled cross-section: snow-capped mountains on the left, ground sloping down to two palm trees on the right, a gray-blue aquifer under a dashed water table, a vertical mother well, four shafts and a blue tunnel running gently down to the palms. Fig. 7.7 shows two small panels side by side: in 1980 the dashed water table lies just under the palms; in 2020 it lies much deeper, reached by a solar pump’s pipe. A sand-colored key terms box and a pale blue box of four numbered questions complete the page.

The text of the textbook spreadOur Changing Lands, a geography textbook for English-medium secondary schools, published in Casablanca, Morocco, 2021Written for Augment Education
UNIT 7 · FARMING IN DRY LANDS
7.3 Water from under the desert
In the oases of south-eastern Morocco, farmers have grown dates, barley and vegetables for centuries in a climate that receives less than 100 mm of rain a year. The water they use falls as rain and snow on the Atlas Mountains and travels slowly underground into an aquifer.
For hundreds of years, farmers reached this water with a khettara: a gently sloping tunnel that carries groundwater to the surface by gravity alone. A khettara needs no fuel. It does need people. Each family that shares the water must help to clean the tunnel every year, and each receives water for a fixed number of hours, according to its share.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect does this textbook spread combine different registers to present farming in the oasis?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0007320 marks

The following appeal, printed as a postcard, was left in holiday rentals on Aspriada, a small Greek island, by Friends of the Aspriada Sterna, a volunteer association that repairs the island’s old rainwater cisterns.

A postcard shown front and back. The front: Greetings from ASPRIADA over a sunny sea, white houses on a hill, a swimming pool and a small gray ship. The back: a handwritten-style letter to the visitor, a stamp showing a cistern, a postmark and an address.
Description of the appeal

The appeal is printed as a postcard, shown with its front above its back.

The front is a flat, brightly colored illustration in the style of a holiday postcard. A yellow sun sits in a pale sky above a deep blue sea, on which a small gray ship lies on the horizon. On the right, white cube houses with blue doors climb a sandy hill. In the foreground are a turquoise swimming pool, a wooden sun lounger and a red umbrella. Across the sky, “Greetings from” is written in red italic script above the island’s name in large blue capitals.

The back is cream. “POSTCARD” is printed at the top. On the left, a message is set in a dark blue italic serif that looks like handwriting. A vertical line divides it from the right side, which holds a stamp, a round postmark and three ruled address lines. The stamp shows a white domed building under falling rain on a blue ground, with “€40” below it. A dark blue band along the bottom holds a square code to scan and three lines of white print.

The text of the postcardan appeal printed as a postcard by Friends of the Aspriada Sterna, a volunteer association on a small Greek island, 2025Written for Augment Education
[Front] Greetings from
ASPRIADA
[Back] POSTCARD
Dear visitor,

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect does this appeal use the conventions of a holiday postcard?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0007920 marks

The following is a transcript of part of Chalkboard World, a weekly program about schools around the world, broadcast in English by an international radio service. This episode was first broadcast in March 2003.

The Weather SchoolChalkboard World, a weekly radio programme about schools, broadcast in English by an international radio service, 2003Written for Augment Education
[Signature tune fades.]
PRESENTER: Welcome to Chalkboard World, the programme that takes you into classrooms around the globe. This week, a school at the end of the road. Our reporter travelled to a village in the Middle Atlas mountains of Morocco, two hours by track from the nearest town, where the pupils have taken on a job that most adults would find tedious.
[Wind. A metal door bangs. Children’s voices, counting in French.]
REPORTER: It is seven in the morning and four degrees below zero. Up here, at nearly two thousand metres, the school day begins not with a bell but with a thermometer. Twelve-year-old Fatima and two classmates crunch across the frozen yard to a white wooden box on legs, the kind of thing you might expect to see at an airport, not beside a goat pen. [The box creaks open.] Fatima reads the numbers aloud, and a boy called Youssef writes them in an exercise book, with a pencil he has to hold through his glove.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect are different voices used in this radio broadcast to present the mountain school?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 17 questions on 7.5 Science, technology and the environment

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

7.5 Science, technology and the environment questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 7 Global issues

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 7.1Culture, identity and community
  2. 7.2Beliefs, values and education
  3. 7.3Politics, power and justice
  4. 7.4Art, creativity and the imagination
  5. 7.5Science, technology and the environmentThis page

Carry on with 7.5 Science, technology and the environment in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.