7.2 Beliefs, values and education

How to narrow the field of beliefs, values and education to a specific global issue, and see it at work in a school reader, a wartime poster, a novel extract and a prayer.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 7 Global issues
  • SL and HL

19 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 7.2 Beliefs, values and education

The field of beliefs, values and education gathers the questions societies ask about what they hold to be true and good, and about how they pass it on. Its issues ask who teaches the young, what they are taught without being told, and what happens when two sets of values meet. The McGuffey readers were schoolbooks used in American classrooms for generations. A lesson in McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader (revised edition, 1879) teaches reading through a dialogue about knowledge:

Lesson LVI. Knowledge Is PowerMcGuffey's Fourth Eclectic Reader, revised edition, 1879“Knowledge Is Power”, lesson LVI, McGuffey's Fourth Eclectic Reader, revised edition (New York: American Book Company; copyright 1879), pages 151–153
1. “What an excellent thing is knowledge,” said a sharp-looking, bustling little man, to one who was much older than himself. “Knowledge is an excellent thing,” repeated he. “My boys know more at six and seven years old than I did at twelve. They can read all sorts of books, and talk on all sorts of subjects. The world is a great deal wiser than it used to be. Every body knows something of every thing now. Do you not think, sir, that knowledge is an excellent thing?”
2. “Why, sir,” replied the old man, looking grave, “that depends entirely upon the use to which it is applied. It may be a blessing or a curse. Knowledge is only an increase of power, and power may be a bad, as well as a good thing.” “That is what I can not understand,” said the bustling little man. “How can power be a bad thing?”
3. “I will tell you,” meekly replied the old man; and thus he went on: “When the power of a horse is under restraint, the animal is useful in bearing burdens, drawing loads, and carrying his master; but when that power is unrestrained, the horse breaks his bridle, dashes to pieces the carriage that he draws, or throws his rider.” “I see!” said the little man.
4. “When the water of a large pond is properly conducted by trenches, it renders the fields around fertile; but when it bursts through its banks, it sweeps every thing before it and destroys the produce of the fields.” “I see!” said the little man, “I see!”
5. “When the ship is steered aright, the sail that she hoists enables her sooner to get into port; but if steered wrong, the more sail she carries the further will she go out of her course.” “I see!” said the little man, “I see clearly!”
6. “Well, then,” continued the old man, “if you see these things so clearly, I hope you can see, too, that knowledge, to be a good thing, must be rightly applied. God’s grace in the heart will render the knowledge of the head a blessing; but without this, it may prove to us no better than a curse.” “I see! I see!” said the little man, “I see!”
Exercises.—What is the subject of this lesson? Is knowledge always a power? Is it always a blessing? Relate the several examples of power wrongly used. If we use the powers that God has given us for bad purposes, what will our knowledge prove to be?

What the field covers

The lesson is a reading exercise, yet almost every line of it teaches a value. Knowledge, the old man says, “may be a blessing or a curse” (paragraph 2), and his three comparisons, the first of which speaks of power “under restraint” (paragraph 3), all praise power kept under control. The pupil who reads it aloud practices fluency and absorbs a view of the world at the same time. That double work is what the field studies.

The field covers the beliefs and values a society holds, religious and secular, and the channels that carry them to each new generation: families, schools, faiths and the media. It also covers what happens when those channels disagree, as when a school teaches what a family rejects, and the ethical questions that follow. The concept pages on culture and perspective describe how shared practices and positions shape what a text sees; this field asks how those practices and positions are taught.

The diagram sets out the four main channels, each with a text that shows one at work. The texts differ in kind: a novel extract, a schoolbook, a prayer and a government poster. That spread is deliberate, because an issue from this field usually appears in a literary work as one person’s experience of being taught and in a non-literary body of work as the teaching itself.

Diagram: four channels of values, family, school, faith, and media and the state, each with an example text, all pointing to a box labeled a young person’s values. Examples: “The Ledger”, a McGuffey lesson, Tagore’s Gitanjali 27 and a 1940s war poster.Diagram: four channels of values, family, school, faith, and media and the state, each with an example text, all pointing to a box labeled a young person’s values. Examples: “The Ledger”, a McGuffey lesson, Tagore’s Gitanjali 27 and a 1940s war poster.
Four channels through which values reach the young, each shown in a text read on this page.

What a lesson teaches without saying

The McGuffey lesson states its subject openly. The first question of its Exercises asks “What is the subject of this lesson?”, and the answer is in the title. Other lessons sit under the stated one. The characters are a “sharp-looking, bustling little man” and an old man who “meekly replied” (paragraphs 1 and 3), and the story always takes the old man’s side. A child reading it learns that quickness is vanity and that age and humility deserve the last word.

Exercises.—What is the subject of this lesson? Is knowledge always a power? Is it always a blessing? Relate the several examples of power wrongly used. If we use the powers that God has given us for bad purposes, what will our knowledge prove to be?

“Knowledge Is Power”, Exercises

The questions look like comprehension, but each one has a single answer fixed by the lesson. The last question builds its answer into its own wording: it assumes that powers are “given us” by God before it asks the pupil anything. What a pupil practices here, besides reading, is the habit of returning the answer the book expects. The values and habits that a school teaches through its methods and routines, without stating them as lessons, are its hidden curriculum.

The term was coined by the American educationist Philip W. Jackson in Life in Classrooms (1968), but the thing it names is far older. It is visible in the McGuffey lesson because the book is more than a century old and its values are no longer those of most schools. The hidden curriculum of a present-day school is harder to see from inside. Reading an older textbook is therefore a useful first step toward seeing one’s own.

A school reader that warns against schooling

The lesson also holds a tension. The bustling man is proud that his boys “know more at six and seven years old than I did at twelve” (paragraph 1), and the lesson sets out to correct that pride. A reader used in schools thus warns its pupils not to trust too much in what schooling gives them. The lesson can be read as a caution against arrogance, or as a way of keeping educated children deferent to their elders, and both readings use the same lines.

Education or indoctrination

The hardest arguments in this field concern the point at which teaching becomes something else. During the Second World War the United States Office of War Information issued a poster against the burning of books. A huge upright book stands like a wall against a red sky. At its foot, men in uniform with swastika armbands throw volumes into a fire, a scene that recalls the Nazi book burnings of 1933. The book’s page carries words signed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt:

Books cannot be killed by fire. People die, but books never die. No man and no force can put thought in a concentration camp forever. No man and no force can take from the world the books that embody man’s eternal fight against tyranny. In this war, we know, books are weapons.

Books Are Weapons in the War of Ideas, poster, 1941–45

Poster: a giant open book stands like a wall against a red sky; at its foot uniformed men with swastika armbands burn books. The page carries a signed quotation beginning “Books cannot be killed by fire”; the title below reads Books Are Weapons in the War of Ideas.
A wartime poster that defends free reading in the language of war. Poster: US Office of War Information, *Books Are Weapons in the War of Ideas*, 1941–45. National Archives, public domain.

The poster defends free thought, and it does so by recruiting books into a war. Its first sentences speak of books as living things that outlast people, but its last sentence and its title turn them into “weapons”. The burning men are small, faceless and dark, while the book towers over them in white, so the image settles the argument before the words begin. A government is telling its citizens what reading is for.

Teaching a belief in a way that closes off question, so that it is accepted rather than tested, is indoctrination. The poster sits on a disputed line. It argues for a value most of its viewers already held, the freedom to read, yet it uses the methods of a state message: an enemy, a slogan, a leader’s signature. Seen one way it is civic education in wartime; seen another, it is propaganda that happens to defend books.

Where education ends and indoctrination begins is argued in many countries, most often over school history. From 1965 the Japanese historian Ienaga Saburō brought lawsuits against the state’s screening of school textbooks, after the education ministry required changes to his account of Japan’s part in the war. Ienaga argued that the screening was censorship; the ministry argued that it kept textbooks accurate and balanced. The cases ran for more than three decades and ended in 1997 with a partial ruling in his favor. Neither side claimed to oppose education, which is why the dispute is an issue and not a slogan.

From field to issue, step by step

A good issue from this field begins with a question that a school, a family or a faith would actually face. The worked example narrows the field to one such question and tests it against two texts. One is “The Ledger”, Isobel Laird’s first week in the weighing house of a Dundee jute mill in 1958; the other is a body of photographs made for a school. The draft issue fits one text at once and the other only after it is restated. In “The Ledger” the narrator, looking back, remembers what her schooling made of her:

I knew my figures were the neatest in the hut; I had been told since I was nine that I had a good hand, and I believed that a good hand and a right figure were the same thing.

“The Ledger”, paragraph 6

Her school gave her a hand fine enough for a clerk’s job, and the job places her above her father in the mill’s order. He carts the bales; she writes his initials in the ledger. The extract never says that her schooling divided her from her parents. It shows the division in a single misreading. When her father brings in his bales without looking at her, she reads it as shame and learns only later that “it was manners” (paragraph 5). The knowledge she lacked was his.

The two texts now answer one question from different positions, and the difference is itself something to analyze. A painful history such as Carlisle’s needs to be presented through what its texts show and how they show it, never with invented detail or for shock. The photographs are evidence of an intention: they show what the school wanted its audience to see.

Four more issues from the field

Each issue that follows is phrased as a question that societies argue about, with a literary work and a non-literary body of work that present it. The pairs show the kind of match that works. An oral uses works studied in class, and an issue found here can usually be traced in other works too.

Belief spoken in public

Religious belief is held privately and expressed in public, and the issue asks what place it should have in a life shared with people who do not hold it. Rabindranath Tagore’s Gitanjali (1912), his own English prose versions of Bengali devotional songs, offered a prayer of this kind to readers in London who did not share its faith. Its poem 27, a night prayer for light in a storm, gives suffering a place in a belief:

Misery knocks at thy door, and her message is that thy lord is wakeful, and he calls thee to the love-tryst through the darkness of night.

Tagore, Gitanjali 27, paragraph 3

Misery arrives as a messenger, and its message is an invitation. In the value system the prayer speaks from, suffering is not a sign of abandonment but a call from a god imagined as a lover waiting for a meeting at night. The belief changes what the hardship means without removing it: the night stays dark and the storm continues through the next paragraphs. A reader who does not share the faith meets here a way of valuing suffering, and can respect it, question it or reject it, which is exactly the range of response the issue concerns.

A non-literary body of work can present the same question in the setting of public broadcasting. Since 1970 BBC Radio 4’s morning news program has carried Thought for the Day, a short reflection given almost always by speakers from religious traditions. Whether a public broadcaster should keep such a slot, and whether non-religious speakers should be invited into it, has been argued for decades. Tagore’s prayer and the broadcast slot both raise one question: on what terms does belief speak to people who do not share it?

Try it

The prayer ends with the request “Kindle the lamp of love with thy life” (paragraph 6). What does this ask of the believer, and what value does it express?

The lamp that was unlit in paragraph 2 is to be lit with the speaker’s own life as its fuel, so devotion is imagined as giving oneself up entirely. The value expressed is self-offering: love for the divine measured by what the believer is willing to spend. A public that does not share the faith may admire that value as generosity or question it as self-erasure, and the line holds both possibilities.

Who is allowed to learn

In many places girls still receive less schooling than boys, and the issue asks what a family or a state owes a daughter’s education. Tsitsi Dangarembga’s novel Nervous Conditions (1988), set in colonial Rhodesia, presents it through its narrator, Tambu, whose brother is the one sent to the mission school until his death opens a place for her. The novel shows schooling as escape and as estrangement at once. A body of work presents the same question as a public campaign. Malala Yousafzai was attacked in 2012 for speaking out for girls’ schooling in Pakistan, and addressed the United Nations in 2013. Her speeches, interviews and fund’s publications form a body of work on one issue.

What a schoolroom counts as knowledge

Schools decide what counts as knowledge, and the issue asks what is lost when a curriculum values only what can be measured. Charles Dickens’s Hard Times (1854) opens in a schoolroom where a man demands nothing but “Facts” and a circus child cannot define a horse she has known all her life. The McGuffey readers present the opposite emphasis, a curriculum of morals and faith, and the McGuffey series is itself a body of work that taught American children for generations. Set together, the two show how differently a society can define what a child must know.

Values sold with goods

Advertising sells values as well as products, and the issue asks whether a company can teach values while it sells to its audience. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby (1925) presents a man who believes that wealth can remake a self, and it lets the reader weigh that belief against what it costs. The campaigns that the clothing company Benetton ran in the 1980s and 1990s showed images of racial harmony, war and illness rather than clothes. They form a body of work in which a brand takes positions on social questions, and they were both praised and attacked for it.

How an issue goes wrong

Issues from this field fail in the four usual ways, and one of them is more tempting here than anywhere else. A field word is too broad: education or religion fits every text about schools or faith. An issue tied to one text is too narrow, such as why Mr Gourlay corrects Isobel’s figure, which no body of work can present. A topic without tension, such as schools in the 1950s, names a subject that nobody disputes. The McGuffey lesson’s own claim that knowledge “may be a blessing or a curse” (paragraph 2) marks the difference. The claim is a position; the question behind it asks when knowledge becomes harmful and who decides.

The fourth fault, the slogan, is the one this field invites. Beliefs and values are things people hold strongly, so an issue easily becomes a position to defend: education is the key to freedom, religion divides people. An oral built on such a statement turns its two works into supporting evidence and judges them by whether they agree. A question keeps the works in charge, because each can answer it in its own way and the talk can analyze how.

The same care applies to the painful subjects the field includes, such as schools that set out to separate children from their families. These are presented through what the texts show and how they show it: the paired portraits, the captions, the audiences they were sent to. Detail that a text does not contain is not added for effect, and the people in the texts are described with the respect a historian would give them.

Writing about it

The two statements that follow open an oral on “The Ledger” and the Carlisle portraits. The first preaches and generalizes; the second states the issue as a question and shows how each text presents it.

Weak: Education is very important and both of my texts show that it can change people.note 1 The photographs are very sad and show how badly the children were treated.note 2

Strong: Both texts present schooling that lifts a child out of a family’s world, but they place the loss differently.note 3 Isobel’s neat hand puts her above her father in the ledger, and she learns only later that his not looking at her “was manners”note 4; the Carlisle portraits set a child on arrival beside the same child in uniform, so that the loss is shown to donors as progress.note 5

  1. A position, not an issue. “Education is very important” is a slogan that both texts would have to prove, and it says nothing about either.

  2. Feeling instead of analysis. The sentence responds to the subject, not to the photographs as texts: it names no choice the photographer or the school made.

  3. The issue as a shared question. Both texts are joined by what they present, and the clause after “but” promises a comparison.

  4. How the literary work presents it. A detail of the plot and a short quotation show the loss as a late understanding inside one life.

  5. How the body of work presents it. The pairing of portraits is named as a choice, and its audience explains its purpose.

The strong version never says whether schooling of this kind was right or wrong. It does not need to: the contrast between a loss understood too late and a loss displayed as success says more about the issue than any judgment the student could add.

Applying it in the individual oral

In the individual oral the student speaks for about ten minutes on how one literary work and one non-literary body of work present a global issue, through an extract from each. The teacher’s questions follow for about five minutes. For a body of work such as the Carlisle portraits, the extract is usually one item or a short set; check with your teacher how much is allowed. The field of beliefs, values and education gives the oral its axis when the issue names something a society teaches and asks what that teaching does.

A strong plan for the pair opens with the issue as a question. It reads Isobel’s hand and her father’s manners in paragraphs 5 and 6, then how the whole novel extends the loss. It turns to one pair of portraits, its composition and its audience, and to how other pairs in the series repeat the method. It closes by returning to the question. The commonest way to lose marks in this field is to drift from the texts into an opinion on the issue, which leaves both extracts unanalyzed for minutes at a time.

The concept pages on culture and perspective take these questions back to single texts, and the text type page on the textbook reads a schoolbook closely. The Internal assessment pages on choosing a global issue and extracts turn a tested issue into a plan for the oral.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can describe what the field of beliefs, values and education covers and name the channels through which values are passed on.

  • To do:

    I can explain the hidden curriculum and find it in a text that teaches.

  • To do:

    I can define indoctrination and explain why its line with education is argued over.

  • To do:

    I can narrow the field step by step to a specific issue and revise it after testing it against two texts.

  • To do:

    I can state four or five issues from the field as questions, each with a literary work and a body of work.

  • To do:

    I can keep an issue from this field a question rather than a position to defend.

  • To do:

    I can present a painful subject through what a text shows and how it shows it.

Key terms

Each is also in the Global issues glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Hidden curriculum

What a school teaches without stating it: values, habits and expectations carried by its routines, methods and the examples in its books, alongside the subjects it teaches openly.

Indoctrination

Teaching that aims to fix a belief so firmly that it is accepted without question, often by presenting only one view and discouraging doubt. It differs from education in method more than in content, since the same belief can be taught openly with its evidence and alternatives.

Practice questions on 7.2 Beliefs, values and education

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0002220 marks

The following extract is taken from a memoir by a Norwegian secondary-school teacher, written in English and published in 2022, about the year after she had a heart attack at the age of forty-nine.

Red PenNotes on the Patient, a memoir of the year after a heart attack, written in English by a Norwegian teacher, 2022Written for Augment Education
The hospital let me go home on a Thursday, with a bag of tablets, a leaflet about stairs and a password. The password was for the patient portal, where, the nurse said, I could read everything that had been written about me. She said it the way you might mention that there is a lift at the end of the corridor. I thanked her. I did not yet understand that she had handed me the most unsettling text I would read that year.
I teach Norwegian and English at an upper secondary school in Tromsø. For twenty-two years I have read what other people have written, usually at the kitchen table, usually after ten at night, usually with a red pen. So on the Sunday, when my husband had gone to bed and the new tablets were making the room feel slightly too large, I opened the portal, found the notes from my four days on the cardiology ward, printed them, and reached, without thinking, for the pen.
The admission note began: “49-year-old woman, teacher, previously healthy. Presents with chest pain radiating to left arm. Patient is pleasant and cooperative.” I underlined pleasant. In the margin I wrote: relevance? I had not been pleasant. I had been terrified, and I had apologised, twice, to the ambulance crew for the state of my hall. If that is pleasant, I thought, then pleasant is the word for a woman who apologises while she is having a heart attack.
I went on like that for an hour. “Patient reports some anxiety.” Some? “Denies shortness of breath.” I had not denied anything; I had answered a question. The verb made me sound like a suspect. “Husband present, supportive.” Show, don’t tell, I wrote, which is what I write forty times a term. A cardiologist had summarised my angiogram¹ in a sentence of fifty-three words with no main verb, and I gave it the small wavy line I keep for sentences that have lost their way. I was enjoying myself. I can see now that it was the first time since the ambulance that I had felt in charge of anything.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How does the writer use the language of teaching and marking to explore being a patient?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0002820 marks

The following interview is taken from “Your Shilling”, the personal finance page of The Weekend Courier, a Saturday newspaper published in Nairobi, Kenya.

“We don’t borrow from a bank. We borrow from each other.”Your Shilling, the Saturday personal finance page of The Weekend Courier, a Nairobi newspaper, 2011Written for Augment Education
YOUR SHILLING · In partnership with Mlima Bank
“We don’t borrow from a bank. We borrow from each other.”
Every Saturday afternoon, twenty-two women meet behind a vegetable stall in Kawangware market to save, to lend and to argue. Their chairlady, Rose Achieng Otieno, 47, has never taken a bank loan. She told our personal finance desk why.
Mrs Otieno, thank you for your time. How would you describe your business?

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect is the question-and-answer form used in this interview about saving and borrowing?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0004320 marks

The following extract is taken from Two Alphabets, a memoir published in London in 2011 by a writer who grew up in Tartu, Estonia, which was part of the Soviet Union until 1991.

From Both EndsTwo Alphabets, a memoir of a childhood in Tartu, Estonia, published in London, 2011Written for Augment Education
My brother and I cleared our father’s flat in the March after he died. It took four days, most of them spent on the books, and on the last afternoon Toomas found the exercise book under the newspapers in the bottom drawer of the desk. It was the ordinary kind, blue card covers, squared paper, the price still printed on the back in kopecks¹. On the front, in my father’s upright capitals, it said AJALUGU 9 – history, ninth class – and below that, smaller, 1986.
Inside were his lesson notes. My father taught history at the same school in Tartu for thirty-one years, and he prepared every lesson as if he were going to be examined on it himself: the date in the margin, the main points numbered, the questions he would ask underlined twice. Lesson 14, 3 February 1987, was the year 1940. Point one read: The Estonian people, led by the working class, voluntarily joined the fraternal family of Soviet nations. Underneath, underlined twice: Why was this a historic step forward?
Toomas read it aloud in the voice we used as children for the radio. Then he turned the book over to look at the price again, and stopped.
My father had started a second set of notes from the back. He had turned the book upside down, so that the last page became the first, and begun again, in the same blue ink, in the same capitals. The first date was September 1990. Lesson 14 was the year 1940. Point one read: Occupation. One word, and a full stop. The question underneath, underlined twice: What did your family lose?

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect is the image of the exercise book used in this memoir?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 17 questions on 7.2 Beliefs, values and education

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

7.2 Beliefs, values and education questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 7 Global issues

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 7.1Culture, identity and community
  2. 7.2Beliefs, values and educationThis page
  3. 7.3Politics, power and justice
  4. 7.4Art, creativity and the imagination
  5. 7.5Science, technology and the environment

Carry on with 7.2 Beliefs, values and education in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.