- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- 7 Global issues
- 7.1 Culture, identity and community
7.1 Culture, identity and community
How to narrow the field of culture, identity and community to a specific global issue, test it against two texts, and see it at work in a memoir, a poem, a blog post and a chart.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 7 Global issues
- SL and HL
Notes on 7.1 Culture, identity and community
The field of culture, identity and community gathers the questions societies ask about belonging. Who is inside a group, what does it cost to join one, and what does a group keep or lose as it changes? A global issue from this field is one such question, narrow enough to be argued and wide enough to matter in many places. Mary Antin came to Boston from the Russian Empire as a girl in 1894. Her memoir The Promised Land (1912) describes the public library she found in her new city:
What the field covers
Antin’s paragraph never uses the word migrant, yet the whole field is present in it. The library is “so unlike anything on Arlington Street” (paragraph 1), the poor street where her family lived, so class and neighborhood frame the scene. The reading room offers “order and quiet” to a child from a crowded home, and she waits on its steps “for the door of paradise to open”. A public institution of her new country becomes the place where she feels most at home.
The field takes in everything that shapes people and their groups: family, class, ethnicity, nationality, religion, language, gender and sexuality. It also takes in the movements that test those groups, such as migration, exile, the growth of cities and the passing of traditions from one generation to the next. The concept pages on identity and culture describe how texts build a self and a shared way of life. This field turns those concepts into questions that real communities argue about. Identity asks who a person is in a text, and culture asks what a group shares; the field asks what happens when the two pull against each other.
Antin’s memoir shows one of those pulls. Her new country offers her its books, its schools and its language, and she accepts them with open joy. The process by which newcomers take on the language, customs and values of the society they join is assimilation. Antin presents it as a gift, and the first pages of her book say that she has been “made over”. Other texts from the same decades present the same process as a loss, which is why assimilation belongs to a global issue and not to a single answer.
A text from this field rarely states its issue. Antin’s paragraph is about summer holidays, closed schools and a rule of one book at a time. The issue sits in what those details imply: that belonging, for this child, arrives through a public building rather than through a neighbor or a church. Reading for an issue means asking what the ordinary details of a text assume about who belongs and on what terms.
What makes an issue global
A global issue has three qualities. It matters on a wide scale, affecting large numbers of people. It crosses national borders, so that it can be found in more than one society. And it is felt in everyday local life, in a street, a school or a kitchen. All three are needed: an issue that is wide but never local becomes a statistic, and one that is local but never wide becomes an anecdote.
Antin’s library passes all three tests. Millions of people crossed the Atlantic to the United States in the decades around 1900. What they should keep or give up was argued in newspapers, schools and governments on several continents. Yet the passage is as local as a text can be, built from one reading room, one opening hour and one girl with “a book under my arm” (paragraph 1). The large movement becomes visible in a small routine. That is the scale at which literature usually presents a global issue.
The library did not open till one o’clock in the afternoon, and each reader was allowed to take out only one book at a time.
The Promised Land, paragraph 1
The sentence measures a public good in hours and single books. A rule written for every reader in a city becomes, for one child, the shape of a whole summer’s day. Through it the reader sees a society’s offer to newcomers at the size of one person’s routine.
Non-literary texts often work at the other end of the scale. A government campaign, a census form or a museum exhibit speaks to a whole population at once, and its local life lies in how each person meets it. The oral pairs the two kinds of text partly for this reason. A literary work shows an issue from inside one life. A non-literary body of work shows how a society names and shapes it in public.
From field to issue, step by step
A field is too wide to argue and a topic is only a subject. An issue becomes usable when it is a question that two works can answer differently. The surest way to reach one is to narrow in steps and test each step against the texts. The diagram sets out the steps for one issue from this field. The draft issue in the middle looks specific. The two tests beneath it find that it fits one text well and the other only loosely, so it is revised before it is used.


The first test uses Claude McKay’s “The Tropics in New York” (1922), the poem of a shop window full of island fruit that brings its speaker to tears. Its last stanza is the speaker’s response to the window:
My eyes grew dim, and I could no more gaze;
A wave of longing through my body swept,
And, hungry for the old, familiar ways,
I turned aside and bowed my head and wept.“The Tropics in New York”, lines 9–12
Nothing in these lines concerns language. The speaker speaks the English he shares with the city. What he longs for is “the old, familiar ways” (line 11): food, landscape, the rhythm of a rural life. A draft issue about giving up a home language would force the poem to say something it does not say. The poem does present a loss that belonging in a new place has cost, so the issue needs widening, not abandoning.
The revision did not make the issue vaguer. It made it fit the two works as they are, and it turned a statement into a question that each work answers in its own way. A campaign that presents the giving up as a duty and a poem that presents it as a wound give two answers to one question. That is what an oral needs. An issue that only one of the two works can carry is not yet finished.
Four more issues from the field
The field holds many issues besides the cost of belonging. Each one that follows is phrased as a question that societies argue about, with one literary work and one non-literary body of work that present it. The pairs are examples of the kind of match that works, not a list to choose from. An oral needs works studied in class, and the same issue can be found in many others.
Whose words shape how refugees are seen
When people arrive as refugees, the host society meets them first through other people’s words: news reports, official statements, photographs with captions. The issue is a question about voice: whose account of a refugee’s life reaches the public, and who edits it? Mohsin Hamid’s novel Exit West (2017) answers it by refusing the expected story. Its two lovers leave their unnamed city through doors that open onto other countries. The dangerous journey that news coverage dwells on is largely skipped, and the novel spends its pages on arrival and on how hosts behave.
A non-literary body of work can present the same question from the opposite direction. In 2015 the photographer behind Humans of New York posted a series of portraits of refugees on the Greek islands and on the routes through Croatia, Hungary and Austria. Each came with a caption in the person’s own words. The captions seem to give refugees their own voice, yet each is chosen, cut and ordered by someone else. The novel invents its people and the photo series records real ones, and both raise the question of who frames the story.
Who keeps a living heritage
A tradition that lives in people’s hands, such as a recipe, a song or a craft, is passed on by practice rather than by record. The Penang night-market blog post, “Same umbrella, new hands”, written as a family’s oyster-omelette stall reopens after the grandmother retires, shows such a handover in one paragraph:
Ah Ma does not write recipes down. She says the recipe is in the wrist. So Papa and I stood beside her every night in July and wrote down what her wrist does: how much starch (less than you think), how hot the kuali (hotter than you think), when the oysters go in (last, and for less time than you think).
“Same umbrella, new hands”, paragraph 7
The paragraph turns a skill of the body into a written list, and the turn is the issue in small. “The recipe is in the wrist” claims that the knowledge cannot be written at all. The bracketed measures (“less than you think”) try to write it anyway. The bracket repeats three times and never gives a number, so the record admits what it cannot hold. A family, a street of stalls and a city’s food culture all depend on knowledge of this kind. The term cultural heritage covers it when it includes practices as well as buildings.
Alice Walker’s story “Everyday Use” (1973) presents the same issue as a quarrel inside one family. Two sisters are at odds over their family’s hand-stitched quilts. The elder, educated away from home, wants to hang them as art; the younger, who stayed and learned to quilt, would use them on a bed. A non-literary body of work shows the public side of the quarrel. Singapore campaigned to have its hawker culture recognized on UNESCO’s list of intangible heritage, which it was in 2020. The campaign’s materials present street food as a national treasure. The question both raise is the same: who decides how a living tradition is kept, the people who practice it or those who display and protect it?
Mixed identities and the demand to choose
Many people belong to more than one culture by birth, and many forms, schools and families still ask them to name one. Jhumpa Lahiri’s novel The Namesake (2003) follows a son of Bengali parents in the United States. He is named Gogol, after the Russian writer, and renames himself Nikhil before college. The name he refuses and the name he chooses both come from his parents. The novel presents a mixed identity as something a single choice cannot settle. A non-literary body of work can show the same demand made by a state. The forms of the United States census changed their race and origin categories many times over two centuries. Only in 2000 did they first allow a person to mark more than one race.
Who presents a community to the world
A community is often described by outsiders before it can describe itself, and the issue asks who has the right to present it. For the Paris Exposition of 1900, the sociologist W. E. B. Du Bois and his students at Atlanta University drew two series of charts about Black Americans. One covered the state of Georgia and one the nation, in an exhibit seen by visitors from many countries. The chart on occupations, reproduced here, uses the period’s own term for the people it counts.

The chart ranks the jobs of Black men in Georgia in 1890 as red bars on a pale sheet. The bar for 98,400 agricultural laborers is too long for the page, so it folds back on itself, and the eye reads the fold before it reads the number. Beneath it, fifteen smaller trades, from sawmill hands and blacksmiths to clergymen, teachers and engineers, are bracketed together and summed into one more bar. The chart presents a community at work in more than twenty trades, against the narrow picture of Black American life common in the period. It makes its case in the language of measurement that its audience trusted. Ralph Ellison’s novel Invisible Man (1952) presents the same question from inside one life: its narrator is unseen because others see only their idea of him.
A diaspora in a shop window
McKay’s poem returns here from a different angle, because its middle stanza shows how a scattered community remembers the place it left. The fruit of the first stanza is only now placed in the city:
Set in the window, bringing memories
Of fruit-trees laden by low-singing rills,
And dewy dawns, and mystical blue skies
In benediction over nun-like hills.“The Tropics in New York”, lines 5–8
The fruit has made the same journey as the speaker, from a Caribbean island to a northern city, but it travels as goods. A shop in New York stocks “alligator pears” (line 2) and mangoes because people in the city will buy them. The window implies a whole community of islanders that the poem never shows. That community is a diaspora: a population living away from its homeland and keeping ties to it through memory, food, language or faith. McKay himself was one of many Caribbean-born writers in New York in the 1920s.
The memory the window brings is not an ordinary one. Its words are religious: the skies are “mystical”, they hang “In benediction”, and the hills are “nun-like” (lines 7–8). Home becomes holier at a distance than any working landscape could be, and the stanza presents this as the way a diaspora remembers. The issue the stanza carries is a question about that memory: does keeping an idealized home alive help people belong where they are, or keep them from it? The poem leaves the question open, and the speaker’s tears in the last stanza do not settle it.
Try it
The poem ends with a speaker who “turned aside and bowed my head and wept” (line 12), away from the window. Why might it matter that he turns away from the window and the street to weep?
The turn may hide his grief from anyone passing, so the longing that the window caused stays private in a public place. The gesture can be read as suggesting that belonging in the new city asks for composure: the feeling for home has no place in public and must be turned aside. Read through the issue, the line shows a cost of belonging that no one else sees, which is why a public text such as a campaign poster could never record it.
How an issue goes wrong
Most weak issues fail in one of four ways, and each can be seen by trying it against the texts already read. The first is the issue that is too broad. Identity or migration names a field or a topic, so it fits every work ever written and says nothing about any one. Antin’s “door of paradise” (paragraph 1) and McKay’s window (line 5) are both about identity, and the label does not tell an audience what to look for in either.
The second is the issue that is too narrow to fit two works. How McKay’s speaker remembers Jamaican fruit is a question about one poem, and no body of work can present it. The third is a topic dressed as an issue: immigrants and public libraries has a subject but no tension, nothing a society disagrees about. The fourth is a slogan in place of a question. Immigrants should keep their culture is a position. An oral built on it turns both works into evidence for a speech, and the analysis of their choices shrinks.
Each fault has the same repair: a question that names who is affected and what is at stake, and that both works answer differently. Antin waits on the steps “for the door of paradise to open” (paragraph 1), and McKay’s speaker “turned aside” at a window (line 12). Each gives an answer to the question of what belonging costs. Antin counts what the new country gives her, and McKay counts what living in it has taken. The two answers differ, which is exactly what makes the question worth an oral.
Writing about it
A statement of an issue is only as good as the sentence that connects it to the texts. The two openings that follow were planned for an oral on Antin’s memoir and on the Speak Mandarin Campaign’s posters. The first names a field and describes; the second states an issue and how each text presents it.
Weak: Both of my texts are about the global issue of identity.note 1 Antin is happy in the library and the posters tell people to speak Mandarin, which shows that language is important to identity.note 2
Strong: My issue is what belonging to a new place or nation costs people in language and ways of life.note 3 Antin presents the cost as a gain, waiting on the library steps “for the door of paradise to open”, while the campaign presents it as a dutynote 4, asking a whole population to give up the languages its grandparents brought.note 5
A field, not an issue. “Identity” could join any two works, so it gives the talk no direction.
Summary and a truism. Each text is reduced to one sentence of content, and the conclusion is true of every text about language.
The issue as a question of cost. The issue names what is at stake, so every later point can return to it.
How each text presents it. A quotation from the literary work and a precise description of the body of work show two different answers.
Context used for the issue. The detail about grandparents explains why the request is a cost, which keeps the context in service of the issue.
The strong version is longer, but every word in it points the talk somewhere. It states the issue once, in the form of a question about cost, and then shows that the two texts answer it from opposite sides. That opposition gives the oral a reason to move from one text to the other.
Applying it in the individual oral
In the individual oral the global issue is the axis of the whole talk. The student speaks for about ten minutes on how a literary work and a non-literary body of work present one issue, through one extract from each. The teacher’s questions follow for about five minutes. Extracts are usually around 40 lines, or one item or a short sequence from a body of work; check the exact limits with your teacher. The field gives an oral its axis when the issue is stated as a question at the start and each section of the talk answers it from one text.
A strong opening sentence states the issue and promises the comparison: I will look at what belonging costs people, and at how McKay presents that cost as private grief while the Speak Mandarin posters present it as a public duty. The commonest way to lose marks is to state such an issue in the first minute and then leave it, so that the rest of the talk becomes a commentary on two extracts with no thread. Returning to the issue at the end of each section, in a sentence that names what the extract has just shown, keeps it in view.
The concept pages on identity and culture take these questions back to single texts. The Internal assessment pages on choosing a global issue and extracts turn a tested issue into a plan for the oral.
Self-check
- To do:
I can describe what the field of culture, identity and community covers and name the movements, such as migration, that test communities.
- To do:
I can explain the three qualities of a global issue and show them in a text such as Antin’s library paragraph.
- To do:
I can narrow the field step by step to a specific issue and revise it after testing it against a literary work and a body of work.
- To do:
I can state four or five issues from the field as questions, each with a literary work and a non-literary body of work that present it.
- To do:
I can define assimilation, diaspora and cultural heritage and use each in a reading of a text.
- To do:
I can recognize an issue that is too broad, too narrow, a topic or a slogan, and repair it.
- To do:
I can open an oral with an issue stated as a question and keep it in view through the talk.
Key terms
Each is also in the Global issues glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Assimilation
The process by which a person or group takes on the language, customs and values of a dominant society, often giving up those they brought with them. It is usually distinguished from integration, in which newcomers take full part in a society while keeping much of their own culture.
- Cultural heritage
What a community inherits from earlier generations and chooses to keep. It includes places, objects and buildings (tangible heritage) and living practices such as languages, crafts, rituals and recipes (intangible heritage).
- Diaspora
A population living away from its homeland that keeps ties to it through memory, food, language, faith or family. Texts from a diaspora often look in two directions, toward the place left and the place lived in.
Practice questions on 7.1 Culture, identity and community
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 17 questions on 7.1 Culture, identity and community
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
7.1 Culture, identity and community questions by paper, with 6 in full
More in 7 Global issues
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 7.1Culture, identity and communityThis page
- 7.2Beliefs, values and education
- 7.3Politics, power and justice
- 7.4Art, creativity and the imagination
- 7.5Science, technology and the environment
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
- 7 Global issuesBefore this in the syllabus.
- 7.2 Beliefs, values and educationNext in the syllabus.
- English A Lang & Lit exam formatEach English A Lang & Lit paper, how long it is and its share of the grade.
- IB English A Lang & LitThe English A Lang & Lit syllabus, how it is assessed and every notes page.
Carry on with 7.1 Culture, identity and community in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.
